Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Organization
Edited by
Thomas N. Duening
Abstract
Positive psychology and positive organizational scholarship have begun to
have an impact on the enterprise. It is important for organizational leaders at all levels to understand this powerful new framework. This volume
brings together a wide range of organizational scholars who have derived
implications from positive research for the modern enterprise. Engaging topics from leadership, to self-esteem, and to conflict resolution, this
book provides practical tools, actions, and processes that can be used to
create positive organizations.
Keywords
positive psychology, positive organizational scholarship, leadership, psychological capital, self-esteem, conflict management, positive service organization, positive communications, organizational change, organizational
development.
Contents
Preface...................................................................................................ix
Chapter 1 The Positive Organization: Why Its Not More
of the Same........................................................................1
Thomas N. Duening
Part I
Positive Organizational Culture..................................... 25
Chapter 2 Organization-Based Self-Esteem: Making
aDifference at Work........................................................27
Donald G. Gardner, Jon L. Pierce
Chapter 3 Building Positivity inYour Organization
WithPsychological Capital..............................................49
Dustin Bluhm
Chapter 4 The Role of Positive Organizational Behavior in
Building a World-Class Service Organization...................71
Andrew J. Czaplewski, Thomas Martin Key,
James R. Van Scotter II
Part II
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Part III
Positive Organizational Transformation...................... 141
Chapter 7 Positive Transformational Leadership: Building
Positive Organizations....................................................143
D.D. Warrick
Chapter 8 Developing the Positive Organization: Preparation
for Learning and Collaborative Learning Design............163
Shawna L. Rogers
About the Authors................................................................................187
Index..................................................................................................193
Preface
Positive psychology is a relatively new field of study that represents a
significant shift in focus for the psychological, behavioral, and organizational sciences. Traditional psychology trained its attention on dysfunction and its relief; positive psychology focuses on optimal functioning and
its attainment.
Organizational scholars have embraced the positive psychology paradigm and have begun to explore its variety of applications within the
enterprise. This volume is based on work being conducted by scholars
from a variety of business disciplines. Together, they comprise the Positive
Organizational Behavior Research Group, housed within the College of
Business at the University of Colorado Colorado Springs.
The authors of the chapters contained in this volume have attempted
to convey the practical implications of their work that combines traditional organizational models with models and concepts from positive
psychology. The result, we believe, is a stimulating introduction to this
emerging field of study that should be of interest to scholars and practitioners alike.
Each chapter provides an introduction to the authors main line of research, a deep dive into how that basic research is enhanced and extended
by positive psychology, and concludes with an Action Time section with
practical suggestions for practice. We hope you enjoy this volume and
welcome any feedback you might have on the presentation of the chapters
and how our Positive Organizational Behavior Research Group can be of
further service to you and your organization.
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
Organizational theory is a term that many business practitioners loathe.
There is a prevailing notion that anything that is merely a theory cannot have substantive implications for practice. At the same time, most
business practitioners readily adopt popular organizational theories
in the hope that it will arm them with insights to transform their own
organizations.
This ambivalence about organizational theory is easy to understand.
The bookshelves in the business section of the local bookstore burst with
an ever-growing number of volumes promising to reveal the latest secrets,
insights, or rules that once and for all will ensure high performance. How
is one to choose among these various alternative approaches? What is the
evidence that backs up their lofty claims?
Business leader skepticism should be high when it comes to claims
about the latest breakthrough in creating high-performing organizations.
A review of the past 30 years of such epiphanies reveals a mostly dismal
record of lasting performance enhancements. Some of the organizational
theories have more substance than others, to be sure. For example, its
likely that most readers of this book have heard of W. Edwards D
eming
and the total quality management revolution he helped to usher in
following World War II.2 The transformations that many companies experienced as a result of adopting Demings ideas and prescriptions were
vitally important at the time. Today, Deming and total quality management dont sell well because most organizations have adopted quality
processes, practices, and controls as a routine part of their operations.
It is no longer revolutionary to say that one has adopted quality as a
centerpiece of competitive advantage; it is the entry price to nearly any
industry.
Readers may also recall several other noteworthy organizational theories that have appeared and faded over the past few decades:
Of course, there are many more beyond this short list. If you find yourself
weary of organizational theory, you are not alone. In fact, some scholars
have written insightful critiques of the tendency for practitioners to become beguiled by the latest fads in organizational theory.8
We have collaborated to write this book on positive organizational
behavior (POB), because we believe this organizational theory is more
powerful than the others noted earlier, and it is based on substantial
evidence from the human sciences. In fact, a large part of its power and
potency derives from the fact that it is rooted in the ultimate causes
of human behavior. Ultimate causation links human behaviors to the
evolutionary origins of the motivations and mechanisms underlying
them. Traditional management and leadership scholarship has suffered
from a lack of integration of evolutionary insights into organizational
theory.9
POB is not a theory designed to dig us out of some contemporary organizational hole created by other, now defunct, theories. It is not a theory
Positive Psychology
I now think that the topic of positive psychology is well-being, that the
gold standard for measuring well-being is flourishing, and that the
goal of positive psychology is to increase flourishing.11
Psychologists Martin Seligman and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi originated
the discipline of PP at the 1998 annual meeting of the American Psychological Association.12 In a nutshell, PP focuses on helping people advance
from normal to optimal functioning. Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi said
PP is about identifying and nurturing [a persons] strongest qualities,
what they own and are best at, and helping them find niches in which
they can best live out these strengths.13 This is in stark contrast to traditional psychology and its focus on human dysfunction and psychological
maladaptations. Figure 1.1 highlights the difference between traditional
and PP.
As this figure shows, clinical psychology is concerned with mental illness, mental disorders, and other dysfunctions. Organizational leaders, taking their cues from decades of psychological research into human capital
and its relationship to organizational performance, also were prone to focusing on helping people who were situated to the left in this figure. This has
been referred to as the four Ds approach to leading (damage, disease, disorder, and dysfunction). The four Ds approach tends to focus on preventing
poor performance, low motivation, ill-health, and disengagement.14
By way of contrast, PP focuses on the right side of Figure 1.1.
According to Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi, the purpose of PP is to
begin to catalyze a change in the focus of psychology from preoccupation
only with repairing the worst things in life to also building positive qualities. We emphasize here the difference between PP and other management fads such as positive thinking. The latter were never part of the
Mental illness Mental disorders Personality disorders Strengths Happiness Flourishing Virtues Meaning
Clinical psychology
Dysfunctional relationships Pathology Diagnosis
Positive psychology
Purpose Talent Flourishing Positive relationships
ORGANIZATIONAL
Production Deviance
Property Deviance
Leaving early
Taking excessive breaks
Intentionally walking slow
Wasting resources
Sabotaging equipment
Accepting kickbacks
Lying about hours worked
Stealing from company
MINOR
SERIOUS
Political Deviance
Prosocial Aggression
Showing favoritism
Gossiping about co-workers
Blaming co-workers
Competing nonbeneficially
Sexual harassment
Verbal abuse
Stealing from co-workers
Endangering co-workers
INTERPERSONAL
deviant behaviors reported by the study participants ranged on a twodimensional scale between minor and serious and between interpersonal
and organizational. The typology that emerged from the research is provided as Figure 1.2.
No doubt youve seen some of these deviant behaviors before. They are
common among employees who dont have opportunities to flourish at work.
By way of contrast, a focus on POB has led to the development of
a positive typology. Luthans and Youssef give us a typology of positive
workplace behavior that is encapsulated under the acronym CHOSE
(confidence/self-efficacy, hope, optimism, subjective well-being, and
emotional intelligence) (Figure 1.3).20
State:
Momentary
Feelings
Pleasure
Happiness
Positive Moods
Transient
State Like:
Self Opinions
Efficacy
Hope
Optimism
Open to Change
Trait Like:
Big five
Core Self
Evaluations
Character
Strengths
Virtues
Difficult to
Change
Traits:
Intelligence
Talents
Inherited
Characteristics
Unchanging
also are malleable, but they are more stable over time than are the ephemeral psychological states. Trait-like psychological constructs, including virtues, are relatively stable and difficult, although not impossible to change.
Finally, traits are largely defined as heritable and are stable and difficult to
change.
The research associated with PP is robust and diverse. Research considered central to the movement includes studies of human happiness,
well-being, positive emotions, and character strengths. Here, our primary interest in PP centers on its research associated with identifying and
explicating the virtues and character strengths associated with optimal
human functioning. This branch of PP has developed a relatively stable
understanding of virtues associated with optimal human functioning.
The stable set of virtues has been codified as the Values in Action (VIA)
Classification of Strengths (see Table 1.1).
The VIA Classification of Strengths identifies six virtues. Each virtue
has associated character strengths that are defined as the psychological ingredients of virtues.24 The originators of the VIA Classification
System recognize that the list of character strengths has some limitations. A primary limitation theyve identified is that it does not take
into account local cultural pressures and opportunities. For example, it
has been noted that the U.S. culture would likely need to include more
explicitly character traits of ambition and achievement to reflect the
positive moral evaluation such strengths generally receive in that culture. Seligman also addressed this absence and added achievement
to his list of measurable elements associated with human well-being:
Table 1.1 The VIA classification of strengths
Courage
Justice
Humanity
Temperance
Wisdom
Transcendence
Selfactualization
Esteem
Love/belonging
Safety
Physiological
10
11
This section of the chapter will not endeavor to unravel the manner
in which the neural apparatus of the brain works. Suffice it to say that
chemical and electrical forces that power the vast neural networks in the
brain are non-mysterious parts of nature that give rise to all the thinking,
emoting, and behaving that people do.29 The brain is a dynamic and in
some ways mysterious organ to be sure. Likely, the human sciences will
never be able to trace the precise causal patterns that effect an individuals personality, proclivities, and preferences. Still, the general patterns
of behavior that emerge as distinctly human preferences are lodged in
the whispers of evolutionary priorities.30 It is indisputable, for example,
that people generally prefer to view pastoral landscapes rather than fetid
garbage dumps. Why? The choice seems unforced and naturalwhich is
exactly the point. Our ancestors evolved and carved out a niche in the savannas of Africa, and they developed a distinct and innate preference for
verdant, and therefore fruitful vistas. The dung beetle, on the other hand,
with its differential adaptations and life strategies likely would prefer the
garbage dump. To the dung beetle, that choice is unforced and natural.
Evolution works via natural selection. It has over the 4 billion years of
life on earth selected life forms that have adapted to their unique habitats.
Mammalian evolution, of which humans are part, has been traced back
315 to 320 million years. The evolution of the human line has been traced
back 4 million years. Of course, at the time at which the human lineage
began it was already equipped with the evolved brain bequeathed by its
mammalian primate ancestors. Since then, the main adaptation that has
led to the uniquely human way of functioning is an extraordinarily large
neocortex (measured by body mass) compared with other mammals. The
neocortex is the seat of most of our conscious experience, including communicating, planning, and thinking.
The large neocortex in humans evolved to help us manage our complex social environment. In other words, the uniquely social habitats chosen
by our ancestors led to the inexorable development of a distinctive social
brain.31 The main driving force of human evolution today is no longer selection of instinctual behavior patterns. Rather, humans are now subject primarily to the equally selective forces of cultural evolution.32 Still, the insight
that faint echoes of our instinctual preferences gently nudge our choices and
preferences to certain cultural forms over others does offer opportunities for
12
13
14
15
16
17
Action Time
We have been on quite a journey through some of the theoretical foundations to POB that you will find reiterated and advanced throughout this
book. Its time now to get a general idea of how these theories can be put
into action within the organizational setting.
1. Prepare employees to be hired by the best in your industry, and be
prepared to help them advance their careers with other organizations if they choose.
Ironically, you are most likely to retain employees if they feel like you are
truly interested in their career advancementwherever it may take them. It is
counter-intuitive, obviously, to build individual talent in a manner that is a fit
with top competitors. But if you are building them to be a fit for top competitors, you are also building them for success in their chosen professionwhich
translates to higher performance for you. Most professional-level employees
enjoy building their talents to achieve excellence in their chosen careers. This
pursuit in fact feels good because it is a function of an active EXPLORATION E/M system. Research has shown that EXPLORATION is most active for people who feel they are operating from a secure base. If they believe
advancing in their career means they are trapped into a particular promotion
and salary band system (yours) they are likely to feel less secure. Far better to
make it known to everyone that you are most interested in helping them become accomplished professionals who have ample internal promotion opportunities, but who also will be assisted in the event that a better opportunity
ariseseven with your closest competitor.
2. Develop a robust and effective outplacement office that will assist
employees who have failed to meet the performance expectations
of the company.
This may seem like a cost-center investment that is not reflected in either
the revenues or profits of the firm. But lets take a deeper look at the logic
of developing outplacement services designed to help those who have
been terminated find comparable employment elsewhereeven with the
firms competitors.
The GRIEF system in mammals is activated when the individual feels
as though its social attachments are threatened. The activation of this
18
system powerfully inhibits positive E/M systems such as EXPLORATION and PLAY. When employees feel threatened, either because they
are taking risks that are necessary to advance the organization or because
they are not currently meeting expectations, their ability to advance beyond the feeling is blocked by activation of the GRIEF system. Such employees are more likely to continue to underperform and eventually to
select out of the system entirely.
To prevent and/or alleviate this type of behavior, companies must be
able to communicate to their employees that they will help them, even if
they should fail and be fired. Employees who feel a sense of social belonging despite their need to engage in risky, innovative behaviors are more
likely to find the internal E/M resources to face difficult challenges and
see them through than those who face the potentially gaping maw of
termination.
3. Enable play activities within the workplace and during the workday.
You may be thinking that this chapter has gone completely off the rails
suggesting that business leaders should allow people to play at work. Our
inclination as adults, who largely have sublimated our ability for imaginative play, is to separate work and play. Naturally, we are not suggesting
that the workplace should be turned into a playground, but there are
several very important consequences of enabling some play activity in the
workplace. Below we highlight some of these consequences and suggest
techniques for bringing them about:
Play promotes creativity and innovation. Play by its very
nature is spontaneous, open ended, and creative. Among
children there is no need for elaborate toys, play structures,
or organizational rules to initiate play. Children have little
trouble inventing games with others and creatively altering
and adjusting the rules as they proceed. Play, in fact, often
is inhibited by preexisting rules. When asked about play,
children often indicate that it is best when there is no adult
supervision. While adult play, such as professional sports, is
definitively rule-governed there is also an aspect of balance
19
20
21
Endnotes
1. Anchor, S. 2014. Foreword to How to be a Positive Leader, eds. J.E.
Dutton and G.M. Spreitzer. San Francisco, CA: Barrett-Koehler.
2. Deming, W.E. 2000. Out of the Crisis. Boston, MA: MIT Press,
reprint edition.
3. Hammer, M., and J.A. Champy. 1993. Reengineering the Corporation:
A Manifesto for Business Revolution. New York, NY: Harper Collins.
4. K. Blanchard. The One Minute Manager. New York, NY: William
Morrow.
5. Peters, T.J., and R.H. Waterman. In Search of Excellence: Lessons from
Americas Best-Run Companies. New York, NY: Harper & Row.
6. Porter, M.E. 1998. Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining
Superior Performance. New York, NY: Free Press.
7. Drucker, P.J. 2006. The Practice of Management. New York, NY:
Harper Business, re-issue edition.
8. Francis, R. 2007. The Science of Management: Fighting Fads and
Fallacies with Evidence-Based Practices. Samford Valley, Australia:
Australian Academic Press.
9. Bingham, P.M., and J. Souza. 2012. Ultimate Causation in Evolved
Human Political Psychology: Implications for Public Policy. Journal
of Social, Evolutionary, and Cultural Psychology 6, no. 3, pp. 360383.
10. Panksepp, J. 1998. Affective Neuroscience: The Foundation of Human
and Animal Emotions. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
22
23
24
Index
Accommodating approach, 123124
Adams, Douglas, 71
Adaptability, 80
Anger, 12, 15
Anxiety, 15
Apple company, 5657
Appreciative inquiry (AI) model, 154
Attachment theory, 14
AttractionSelectionAttrition (ASA)
model, 9899
Attribution, 78
optimistic versus pessimistic, 7879
Autonomy, 42
Avoidant conflict behavior, 122123
Bandura, Albert, 55, 73
Bass, Bernard, 149
Behavior, 6
patterns, 1011
Behavioral mimicry, 105
Biasperception conflict spiral, 133
Bingham, Liz, 54
Bluhm, Dustin, 49
Bonding, 12, 1314
Bradley-Geist, Jill, 93
Branson, Richard, 5759
Broaden and build approach, goal
of, 20
Buffer (social media marketing
company), 6263
BuildMeasureLearn feedback loop,
174, 175
Burns, James MacGregor, 149
CallWest company, 120121,
123124
Cameron, Kim, 100, 147
CEO and top-level leaders roles,
in building positive
organization, 144, 145
194 INDEX
Conflict
concept of, 119120
positive and negative, 121
positive conflict and
communication, 128136
framing, 128130
language choice and conflict
spirals, 130133
positive communication and
positive affect, 133134
procedural justice and voice,
134136
styles, 121127
accommodating, 123124
avoiding, 122123
collaborating, 127
competing, 124125
compromising, 125126
Contagion, 96, 101
Cooperrider, David, 154
Coproduction of services, 73
Core self-evaluations, 36
Corporate citizenship, 83
Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, 4
Culture and well-being, 82
Customer service, 7475
Czaplewski, Andrew, 71
Damasio, Antonio, 21
Decision-making process, model
of, 167
Deming, W. Edwards, 2
Depression, 10
Deviancy, in workplace, 5
Disagreement, 134
Downton, J.V., 149
Ds (four) approach, 4
Duening, Thomas, 1
Duluth Pack, 4142
Efficacy, 5456
Elliot, Jane, 75
Emotional contagion, 96, 102, 104
Emotional intelligence (EI), 6,
8081
Emotional labor, 102
Emotional/motivational (E/M)
systems, 3, 1011
INDEX
195
Management behaviors
building employee trust, 40
Managing change, 151156
classic model for, 154
principles for, 153
Maslows hierarchy of needs, 9,
165, 166
Microloan pathway, 5253
Milgram experiment, 106107
Minimal viable products (MVPs),
164, 173, 175
research conducted with
employees, 176177
revise/pivot, 177
Mirror neurons, 105
Modeling, 75
Moods, 7
Needs, Maslows hierarchy of, 9,
165, 166
Neocortex, 11
Office of Professional & Executive
Development (OPED), 178
Optimism, 6, 5759, 7879
Organization-based self-esteem
(OBSE)
adequate resources, 43
benefits of, 3335
building OBSE at work, 3844
concept of, 2930
defined, 29
developments, 3637
enriched work, 4142
importance of, 3031
leader trustworthiness, 3940
and organizational citizenship
behaviors (OCBs), 34
organizational structure, 39
organizational support and
respect, 4041
reasons for affecting performance,
3233
scale, 31
self-esteem, 2837
self-managed teams, 4243
withdrawal behaviors, 34
Organization development, 152
196 INDEX
coproduction of services, 73
role in building world-class service
organization, 7186
services marketing and
management, 7281
Positive organizational climate, 9698
Positive organizational conflict and
communication, 119138
Positive organizations
appointing high-impact team,
146147
building, 143159
Collaborative Learning Design
(CLD), 164, 171182
commitment, importance of, 144
developing, 163184
leaders in, 144, 145
managing change, 151156
organization-wide learning,
164167
positive leadership and, 147148,
151
resources on, 147
traditional learning design,
167171
transforming organizations,
156157
Positive psychology (PP), 4
Maslows hierarchy of needs, 9
negative versus positive
organizational behavior, 57
overview of, 49
purpose of, 45
traditional psychology and, 4
virtues and character strengths, 79
Positive thinking, 4
Positivity, 50
Poverty eradication, microloan
solution to, 5253
Power of Positive Thinking, The
(book), 50
Power statements, 130, 132
Practice mindfulness, 109
Practicing Positive Leadership
(book), 147
Prisoners Dilemma, 129130
Product, 72
Production deviance, 5
INDEX
197
Property deviance, 5
Prosocial aggression, 5
Prosocial culture, 166
Prospect theory, 107
Ps (four), of marketing, 72
Psychological and affective states, 76
Psychological capital (PsyCap)
components of, 5059
defined, 50
in leadership development, 62
questionnaire sample items, 61
synergistic PsyCap, 6064
training and development of, 6364
Psychological ingredients, of virtues, 8
Psychological states, 78
Psychological traits, 7
Real conflict, 121
Reis, Eric, 172174
Resilience, 5657
Responsiveness, 80
Ries, Eric, 164
Rights statements, 131
Rogers, Shawna, 163
Role clarity, 7778
Rometty, Ginni, 5455
Sandberg, Sheryl, 54
Schneider, Benjamin, 98
Schutz, Will, 46
Scotter II, James Van, 71
Sculley, John, 56
Self-actualization, 9, 165, 166
Self-awareness, 80
Self-belief, 30, 32, 34
Self-efficacy, 6
concept of, 7374
enhancing, 7577
power of, 7475
prophesy, 7576
Self-esteem
defined, 28
See also Organization-based
self-esteem (OBSE)
Self-evaluations, 36
Self-handicapping, 33
Self-improvement, 6263
Self-managed teams, 4243
Self-monitoring, 80
Self-protection motive, 33
Seligman, Martin, 4
Services
coproduction of, 73
defined, 72
marketing, 71
Shoestack, Lynn, 71
Skill variety, 42
Social capital, 49
Social contagion, 101
Srivastva, Suresh, 154
Stress, 129
Subject matter experts (SMEs), 176
Subjective well-being (SWB), 6,
35, 7980
Sutton, Bob, 100
Synergistic PsyCap, 6064
Task identity, 42
Task mastery, 77
Task significance, 42
Thomas, Dan, 71
Tomlin, Kathleen, 119
Total quality management, 2
Toyota Production System
(TPS), 173
Traditional learning design, 167171
case studies, 168171
Training design, 172
Traits, 78
Transactional leadership, 149
Transformational change models,
156157
Transformational leadership
four dimensions of, 150
positive leadership and, 151
understanding, 149151
Transforming organizations,
156157
Trust, 3940
Unstable attribution, 79
Values and well-being, 8283
Values in Action (VIA) classification
of strengths, 8
Verbal persuasion, 75
198 INDEX
Vicarious experience, 75
Virgin Galactic, 58
Virtues and character strengths, 79, 20
Walton, Sam, 38
Warrick, Don, 143
Well-being
culture and, 82
values and, 8283
See also Subjective well-being
(SWB)
What Went Well (WWW) reflection
journal, 110
Withdrawal behaviors, 34
Work
forms of, 13
and play, 14, 1819
Worklife integration, 80
Workplace efficacy, 54
Workplace safety, 108
Wozniak, Steve, 56
Wurtzel, Alan, 81
Yunus, Muhammad, 5253
Zero-sum mindset, 120
a one-time purchase,
that is owned forever,
allows for simultaneous readers,
has no restrictions on printing, and
can be downloaded as PDFs from within the library community.
Our digital library collections are a great solution to beat the rising cost of textbooks. E-books can
be loaded into their course management systems or onto students e-book readers.
The Business Expert Press digital libraries are very affordable, with no obligation to buy in future years.
For more information, please visit www.businessexpertpress.com/librarians. To set up a trial in the United
States, please contact sales@businessexpertpress.com.