Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
until 1938.
From 1937 on, the UCI rejected a fundamental slogan of the Fourth International: the 'defence
of the USSR'. Stinas and his comrades didn't reach this position through a debate on the social
nature of the USSR, but through a critical examination of the policies and slogans to be
adopted in the face of an imminent world war. The UCI aimed to eliminate from its
programme any aspect which could allow the infiltration of social patriotism, under the cover
of the defence of the USSR.
During the Second World War, Stinas, as an intransigent internationalist, remained loyal to the
principles of revolutionary marxism, such as Lenin and Rosa Luxemburg had formulated and
practically applied during the first world war.
Since 1934 the UCI had been the only section of the Trotskyist current in Greece. During all
the years of war and occupation, isolated from other countries, this group was convinced that
the Trotskyists were fighting along the same lines, for the same ideas, and against the stream.
The first news they got about the real positions of the Trotskyist International left Stinas and
his comrades open-mouthed. Reading the French pamphlet 'Les trotskystes dans la lutte
contre les nazis' provided proof that the Trotskyists had fought against the Nazis like all the
other good patriots. They then learned about the shameful attitude of Cannon and the Socialist
Workers Party in the USA.
In the war, i.e. in conditions which put the organisations of the working class to the test, the
Fourth International had crumbled to dust. Its sections, some openly through 'the defence of
the fatherland', others under the cover of the 'defence of the USSR', had passed to the service
of their respective bourgeoisies and had in their own way contributed to the massacre.
In autumn 1947, the UCI broke all political and organisational links with the Fourth
International. In the years that followed, the worst period of counter-revolution at the political
level, when revolutionary groups were reduced to tiny minorities and when most of those who
remained faithful to the basic principles of proletarian internationalism and the October
revolution were completely isolated, Stinas became the main representative in Greece of the
Socialisme ou Barbarie current. This current, which never managed to clarify the completely
capitalist nature of the social relations in the USSR, developed the theory of a kind of third
system of exploitation, based on a new division between 'order-givers' and 'order-takers'. It
moved further and further away from marxism and finally fell apart in the 1960s. At the end
of his life, Stinas didn't really have any organised political activity. He moved close to the
anarchists and died in 1987.