Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
a r t i c l e
i n f o
Article history:
Received 8 May 2013
Accepted 23 July 2013
Available online 2 August 2013
Keywords:
Cast iron
Mechanical behavior
Simulation
Thermal cycling
a b s t r a c t
A three-dimensional nite element model (FEM) of 4.5 ton ingot casting system including ow, heat and
stress coupled calculation by ProCAST software has been developed. The temperature and stress distribution of grey cast iron mould dependence of solidication time has been revealed. The phase transformation stress has been also taken into account according to the thermal expansion coefcient measured
from 293 K to 1193 K during the heating process. Based on the simulated temperature variation of the
hot spot in the 4.5 ton mould inner face, the thermal cycling experiment scheme is made. The tensile
strength and thermal fatigue resistance of this grey cast iron at various temperatures against pretreatment cycles have been studied. The possibility and tendency of longitudinal cracks and map cracks in
ingot mould under service conditions have been discussed.
2013 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Grey cast iron is one of the most widely used materials for the
manufacture of large steel ingot moulds, beneting from its excellent castability, processability and the resulting feasibility of economical producing. However, the service life of grey iron mould
is usually poor because of its low tensile strength and weak thermal fatigue resistance especially at high temperature, which may
lead to the increase of mould consumption together with the production safety issues, as shown in Fig. 1.
A great number of studies about failure behavior, crack mechanism and high temperature tensile strength of grey cast iron have
been carried out. Sharma [1] experimentally analyzed the variation
of chemistry and microstructure of the specimens from different
moulds at Bethlehem Steel, the relationship between tensile
strength and moulds service times has been revealed. Socie et al.
[24] built up a simple model for estimating the stress/strain response of grey cast iron. Defects were found to be a detrimental effect on fatigue life in castings. Haenny and Zambelli [57] made an
interesting research to analyze the mechanism of crack in grey cast
iron. They pointed out that cracks essentially initiated and propagated inside the graphite phase inducing a permanent loss of elastic stiffness. The cracking rate appeared as strongly dependent on
the graphite morphology whereas the matrix strength seemed to
823
Fig. 1. Longitudinal crack in initial service times (a) and map cracks after many service times (b) in grey iron mould.
qc
@T
r krT
@t
where c is the effective specic heat, q is the density, k is the thermal conductivity. The enthalpy is dened as follows:
HT
cp dT L1 fs
Then
@H
dfs
cp L
@T
dT
Dv
lr 2 v r p q F
Dt
e_ e_ el e_ vp e_ th
_ el
_ vp
_ th
r_ Del : e_ el
where Del is the fourth-order isotropic elastic stiffness modulus tensor given by
2
Del 2lI kB l I I
3
Here l and kB are the shear modulus and bulk modulus, respectively. I and I are fourth and second order identity tensors.
The viscoplastic strain rate evolves via a ow rule [23],
_
e_ vp km
824
Fig. 3. 4.5 ton ingot mould (a) and its FEM mesh (b).
Fig. 4. Temperature (left) and the rst principal stress (right) of 4.5 ton ingot and mould against casting time.
U_ pk_
N
f
/f
@g
@r
10
_.
where g depends on rate-dependant effects U
For a widely used Perzyna model, the viscoplastic strain rate is
dened as
e_ vp
h/fi
eth
aTdT d
14
T0
11
with g the viscosity parameter, / the overstress function that depends on the rate-independent yield surface f(r, U). An explicit
expression for the consistency parameters is obtained:
h/f i
k_
13
12
1173
Temperature, K
973
P
N
773
573
373
173
0
100
Difference of P and M
1000
10000
60
40
20
M
P
N
0
-20
100
1000
10000
Time, s
Fig. 5. Temperature and stress histories of point M, N and P against casting time.
the inner face of the mould walls [1], located about three fth of
the total height from the bottom. During ingot solidication process, the temperature gradient varies all the time, inducing thermal
stress in the mould walls. Mould inner face stays at high temperature for a longer time, thus it is more liable to form map cracks, as
shown in Fig. 1b.
In order to make a further research on temperature and stress
history of the hot spot in this mould, three points named M, N
and P are marked in the mould wall from outer face to inner face,
as shown in Fig. 4. Their thermal history and stress variation as a
function of casting time are shown in Fig. 5. It can be seen that
at about 260 s the liquid level reaches point P, at which its temperature increases obviously due to the large heat ux with the good
contact between steel and mould. And at about 600 s its temperature reaches the highest value of 1133 K, and then it begins to decrease. This should be the result of air gap formation at the ingotmould interface, leading to the dramatic drop of heat ux. At the
same time, the temperature of point N is nearly 573 K, and that
of the point M just starts to rise. After a slight drop of the temperature of point P, it turns to rise at 1000 s. At about 3200 s, it reaches
1073 K. After about 1800 s at this value, it decreases to 973 K at the
825
Fig. 6. Grey iron plate casting (a), blocks for thermal treatment (b) and tensile specimens (c).
826
Tensile test
Table 1
Chemical composition of HT200 grey iron, wt%.
C
Si
Mn
3.58
1.59
0.89
0.087
0.076
1073K
1073
Temperature, K
873K
873
673K
673
473K
473
Table 2
Casting conditions for HT200 mould sample.
15331553 K
Teeming method
With riser
Gravity, bottom
Mould material
Yes
50
100
150
200
250
300
Time, s
Resin sands
Numerical simulation
50
1073
Temperature, K
Casting temperature
293K
873
673
473
273
0
40
80
120
160
40
80
120
160
40
80
Time, min
Fig. 7. Illustration of thermal treatments up to 50 cycles for mould specimens.
827
150
293K
473K
673K
873K
1073K
The sample was cut from the plate casting, and its size is about
/5 20 mm. The experiment was carried out based on GB/T 43392008 [29]. The thermal expansion coefcient between 293 K and
1203 K was calculated according to the liner expansion rate measured with DIL402C Dilatometer under nearly zero-load conditions, protected by argon at a heating rate of 10 K min1. The
result is shown in Fig. 9. And it has been taken into consideration
in the model of stress calculation.
3.5. Results and discussions
50
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
40
20
-20
-40
273
473
673
873
1073
1273
Temperature, K
Fig. 9. Thermal expansion coefcient variation against temperatures, at a heating
rate of 10 K min1.
Longitudinal cracks and map cracks are the most popular reasons for the failure of large grey iron mould, which mainly occur
in the initial and nal stage of every service period, respectively.
Longitudinal cracks usually initiate in the outer face of the mould,
while the inner face is under compressive conditions. The relationship between stress and temperature at the hot spot is shown in
Fig. 13, in which the simulated data are from Fig. 5 and experiment
data are from Fig. 10. It is shown that the maximum of the tensile
stress in the outer face of the mould is about 50 MPa when its temperature is about 473 K. It is much lower than the value of
120.64 MPa measured at this temperature for the specimen after
1 cycle of pretreatment. Thus cracks should not appear in initial
828
Table 3
Fitting relationship between tensile strength (TS) and pretreated cycles (Cycs).
From 1 to 20 cycles
293 K
473 K
673 K
873 K
1073 K
From 20 to 50 cycles
2
R = 0.979
R2 = 0.949
R2 = 0.999
R2 = 0.999
R2 = 0.956
R2 = 0.964
R2 = 0.994
R2 = 0.981
R2 = 0.925
R2 = 0.965
Fig. 11. Microstructure of the specimens after different cycles of thermal pretreatment near the fracture (a) 10 cycles, (b) 20 cycles, (c) 30 cycles and (d) 50 cycles.
160
Original
Thermal treated
140
120
100
80
60
40
273
373
473
573
673
773
Temperature, K
150
1 cycle
10 cycles
20 cycles
30 cycles
40 cycles
50 cycles
120
90
M
60
30
P
N
-30
473
673
873
1073
Temperature, K
may also occur there at 473 K. Because the tensile strength at this
temperature is much lower than the rst principal stress.
5. Conclusions
The possibility and tendency of longitudinal cracks and map
cracks in ingot mould under service conditions have been studied
by numerical simulation and thermal cycling experiment. Main
conclusions are summarized as follows:
(1) The mould outer face is always under tensile state and show
a max tensile stress of 50 MPa at about 473 K. The mould
inner face is initially upon compressive stress, and a peak
value of 23 MPa of tensile stress appears at about 1073 K.
Both the middle and inner parts exhibit zero stress status
at the nal solidication time.
(2) The tensile strength decreases with the cycles of thermal
pretreatment increasing. The tensile strength of the specimen after 50 cycles of thermal loads reduces by 40% at least
compared to that of the one after 1 cycle of pretreatment.
The decrease of pearlite and coarsening of grains should be
the main reasons for the weakening of tensile strength and
thermal fatigue resistance.
(3) The longitudinal crack is not closely related to mould materials. It usually initiates where serious stress concentration
appears, resulting from casting or structure defects. Map
crack forms where thermal stress exceeds the local tensile
strength at high temperature after numbers of service cycles.
They may also initiate in the out face with poor microstructure at low temperature.
References
[1] Sharma SK. Chemistry, microstructure and tensile strength of ingot mould.
Ironmaking Steelmaking 1984;11:21426.
[2] Fash J, Socie DF. Fatigue behavior and mean effects in grey cast iron. Int J
Fatigue 1982;4:13742.
[3] Downing SD, Socie DF. Stress/strain simulation model for grey cast iron. Int J
Fatigue 1982;4:1438.
[4] Weinacht DJ, Socie DF. Fatigue damage accumulation in grey cast iron. Int J
Fatigue 1987;9(2):7986.
[5] Haenny L, Zambelli G. Strain mechanisms in grey cast iron. Eng Fract Mech
1983;18(2):37787.
[6] Haenny L, Zambelli G. The role of the matrix graphite interaction in the tensile
behavior of grey cast iron. Eng Fract Mech 1984;19(1):11321.
[7] Haenny L, Zambelli G. Crack growth resistance of a gray cast iron. Eng Fract
Mech 1985;21(3):52935.
[8] Sjogren T, Svensson IL. Comparison of mechanical properties in ake graphite
and compacted graphite cast irons for piston rings. Int J Cast Met Res
2004;17(2):6571.
829
[9] Sjogren T, Svensson IL. Modelling the effect of graphite morphology on the
modulus of elasticity in cast irons. Int J Cast Met Res 2004;17(5):2719.
[10] Collini L, Nicoletto G, Konecn R. Microstructure and mechanical properties of
pearlitic gray cast iron. Mater Sci Eng A 2008;488(1):52939.
[11] Guo C, Zhou W. Thermal fatigue and fracture mechanism analysis of grey cast
iron. Acta Metall Sin 1989;2(3):194200.
[12] Vadiraj A, Balachandran G, Kamaraj M. Effect of misch metal inoculation on
microstructure, mechanical and wear properties of hypoeutectic gray cast
irons. Mater Des 2009;30(10):448892.
[13] Vadiraj A, Balachandran G, Kamaraj M, et al. Studies on mechanical and wear
properties of alloyed hypereutectic gray cast irons in the as-cast pearlitic and
austempered conditions. Mater Des 2010;31(2):9515.
[14] Vadiraj A, Balachandran G, Kamaraj M, et al. Mechanical and wear behavior of
quenched and tempered alloyed hypereutectic gray cast iron. Mater Des
2011;32(4):243843.
[15] Balachandran G, Vadiraj A, Kamaraj M, et al. Mechanical and wear behavior of
alloyed gray cast iron in the quenched and tempered and austempered
conditions. Mater Des 2011;32(7):40429.
[16] Hejazi MM, Divandari M, Taghaddos E. Effect of copper insert on the
microstructure of gray iron produced via lost foam casting. Mater Des
2009;30(4):108592.
[17] Tasgin Y, Kaplan M, Yaz M. Investigation of effects of boron additives and heat
treatment on carbides and phase transition of highly alloyed duplex cast iron.
Mater Des 2009;30(8):31749.
[18] Ruiz J, Lopez V, Fernandez BJ. Effect of surface laser treatment on the
microstructure and wear behaviour of grey iron. Mater Des
1996;17(5):26773.
[19] Yao S, Zheng X, Jin J, et al. Crack analysis and optimum design of the large at
ingot mould. J Iron Steel Res Int 1996;8(2):227 [in Chinese].
[20] ProCAST 2011. ProCAST users manual. ESI Group. The Virtual Try-Out Space;
2010.
[21] Lan P, Li Y, Zhang J, et al. Effect of mould taper and wall thickness on steel
ingots soundness by 3-D solidication simulation. In: Materials processing
fundamentals, TMS 2012, Florida, 2012: 7178.
[22] Koric S, Thomas BG. Thermo-mechanical models of steel solidication based
on two elastic visco-plastic constitutive laws. J Mater Process Technol
2008;197(1):40818.
[23] Heeres OM, Suiker ASJ, de Borst R. A comparison between the Perzyna
viscoplastic model and the consistency viscoplastic model. Eur J Mech A
Solids 2002;21(1):112.
[24] Simo JC, Hughes TJR. Computational inelasticity. New York: Springer; 1998.
[25] Sheng D, Huang H, Zeng D, et al. Temperature measurement of 4.5 t ingot mold
of vermicular graphite cast iron during teeming. Iron Steel 1982;17(5):614
[in Chinses].
[26] Yu G, Han W, et al. Analysis of the failure behavior of cast iron ingot mould.
Angang Technol 1993;11:316 [in Chinese].
[27] GB/T228.1-2010.
Metallic
materialstensile
testing
at
elevated
temperature. China Zhijian Publishing House; 2007 [in Chinese].
[28] GB/T228.1-2010. Metallic materialstensile testingPart 1: method of test at
room temperature. China Zhijian Publishing House; 2011 [in Chinese].
[29] GB/T 4339-2008. Test methods for thermal expansion characteristic
parameters of metallic materials. China Zhijian Publishing House; 2009 [in
Chinese].
[30] Roehrig K. Thermal fatigue of gray and ductile irons. AFS Trans 1978;86:7588.
[31] Drapkin BM, Zhukov AA. Elastic and relaxation characteristics grey cast iron
during thermal cycling. Met Sci Heat Treat 1971;13:9535.
[32] Tkalcec I, Mari D. Internal friction in martensitic, ferritic and bainitic carbon
steel; cold work effects. Mater Sci Eng A 2004;370(1):2137.
[33] Li S, Deng L, Wu X. The mechanism investigation of deep cryogenic treatment
on high alloy martensitic steel by low frequency internal friction. Cryogenics
2010;50(8):4338.