Sei sulla pagina 1di 12

Confidential

Temperature Controllers
Cross Reference Guide

Disclaimer:
This document is intended to be used as a guide when crossing competitors products
as the crosses contained in this document are considered to be functional equals. When
selecting the proper controller for the application, please reference the Customer Needs
Analysis contained in the following pages for proper selection criteria.
Omron and Competitors part numbers are subject to change due to market conditions
and technical advances.

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Temperature Controller Needs Analysis


1. Please describe the application.

2. What size of controller is needed?


1/32 Din
1/16 Din
1/8 Din

1/4 Din

22 mm Wide

3. How do you want to mount the controller?


DIN Rail Mounted
Panel Mounted
4. What type of controller is needed?
Analog
Digital
5. What type of control mode is needed?
Heating Only Cooling Only Heating and Cooling
6. What is the ease of programming needed?
(Could include front panel, dip switches, and software)

7. What type of control type is needed?


ON/OFF PID
8. What is your load? What type of output would you prefer?
Relay
Voltage Output
Linear Current Output

Position Proportional Relay Output

Dont forget the solid state relay associated sell with the voltage output option.

9. What is the temperature range?

10. What is the number of set points?

11. What type of input is needed?


Thermocouple RTD
Analog
12. What is the number of alarms needed?
0
1
2

13. How many loops are needed?


1
2
4

5 or more

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Temperature Controller Needs Analysis


14. What is the speed of the application? (ft/sec, ft/min)

15. Are there any external devices connected?


Device for Remote Monitoring/Control
Transfer Output

Event Input

Other

16. What type of accuracy is needed?

17. Is software for programming and logging needed?

18. What is the number of ramp/soak steps needed?

19. Do you need cascade or ratio control to control your process?


Cascade
Ratio
20. Is heater burnout or heater short alarms needed?
Single Phase
Three Phase

21. Do you want to connect to an HMI?

22. Are any protection options needed such as hiding levels or individual parameters?

Note: you are only able to hide individual parameters using CX-Thermo

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Temperature Controller Selection Table


Category

Compact Digital Temperature


Controller

Analog Temperature Controller

Digital Temperature Controller

Selection
criteria
Control
mode
Features
Supply
voltage
Comms*5
Control
output
Input
type
linear
Input type
thermocouple
Input
type
RTD

E5CSV
Basic
On-panel type
Single loop
1/16 DIN

Heating & Cooling

.05%

Up to 2

IP66; NEMA 4X
Single 3.5 digit

E5GC
General purpose
On-panel type
Single loop
1/32 DIN

Heating & Cooling

0.3%

Up to 2

IP66; NEMA 4X
Dual 4 digit (color change)

110/240 VAC

24 VAC/VDC

Model
Type
Panel
Loops
Size
ON/OFF
PID
2-PID *2
Operation
Valve control *3
Accuracy
Auto-tuning
Self-tuning
Transfer output
Remote input
Number of alarms
Heater alarm
IP rating front panel
Display

RS-485
Event IP
Quick Link Port port*6
DeviceNet
Modbus
Relay
SSR
Voltage (pulse)
Linear voltage
Linear current
mA
mV
V
K
J
T
E
L
U
N
R
S
B
W
PLII
Pt100
JPt100
Themistor

4 Standard

8 Available

E5C2
Basic
In- & on-panel type
Single loop
1/16 DIN

*1

Heating

2%

IP20
SV analog dial

No/not available

*1 P only
*2 2-PID is Omrons easy to use high performance PID algorithm

*3 Valve control = relay up and down


*4 Heater alarm = heater burnout & SSR failure detection

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Temperature Controller Selection Table


Category

Digital Temperature Controller/Process Controller


v

Selection
criteria
Control
mode
Features
Supply
voltage
Comms*5

0.3%

0.3%

3 or 4

IP66, NEMA 4X
Dual or Triple Display

IP66, NEMA 4X
Dual or Triple Display

IP20, NEMA 1
Dual Display

110/240 VAC

24 VAC/VDC

Input type
thermocouple
Input
type
RTD
4 Standard

E5CC/E5EC/E5AC
General purpose
On-panel type
Single loop
1/16 DIN

Heating/Cooling

0.3%

E5_C-T
Ramp soak
On-panel type
Single loop
1/4, 1/8, 1/16 DIN

Heating/Cooling

E5DC
General purpose
In-panel or On-panel
Single loop
22.5 mm wide

Heating/Cooling

mA

mV

RS-485
Event IP
Quick Link Port port*6
DeviceNet
Modbus
Relay
Voltage (pulse)
Linear voltage
Linear current

Input
type
linear

Control
output

E5CC-U
General purpose
In-panel or On-panel
Single loop
1/16 DIN

Heating/Cooling

0.3%

0, 1 or 2

IP66, NEMA 4X
Dual Display

Model
Type
Panel
Loops
Size
ON/OFF
PID
2-PID *2
Operation
Valve control *3
Accuracy
Auto-tuning
Self-tuning
Transfer output
Remote input
Number of alarms
Heater alarm
IP rating front panel
Display

K
J
T
E
L
U
N
R
S
B
W
PLII
Pt100
JPt100
Themistor
8 Available

No/not available

*5 PROFIBUS-DP communication option via PRT1-SCU11 for E5_N(-H), E5_R, EJ1


*6 QLP: Quick Link Port to connected TC to PC using the smart USB cable E58-CIFQ1

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Temperature Controller Selection Table


Category

Selection
criteria

Modular
In-panel type
Multi-loop
22.5 mm wide

Heating & Cooling


0.1%

Heating and cooling

0.5%

Heating and cooling

0.5%

*4

*4

IP66; NEMA 4X
Dual or Triple Display

110/240 VAC

24 VAC/VDC

0-50

8 Available

Control
mode
Features

No/not available

*1 P only
*2 2-PID is Omrons easy to use high performance PID algorithm
*3 Valve control = relay up and down

E5ZN

Modular
In-panel type
Multi-loop
31 x 96 mm

RS-232
RS-485
Event IP
Quick Link Port port*6
DeviceNet
Modbus
Relay
SSR
Voltage (pulse)
Linear voltage
Linear current
mA
mV
V
K
J
T
E
L
U
N
R
S
B
W
PLII
Pt100
JPt100
Themistor

4 Standard

EJ1

Universal
On-panel type
Single loop
1/4, 1/8, 1/16 DIN

Type
Panel
Loops
Size
ON/OFF
PID
2-PID *2
Operation
Valve control *3
Accuracy
Auto-tuning
Self-tuning
Transfer output
Remote input
Number of alarms
Heater alarm
IP rating front panel
Display

Supply
voltage
Comms*5
Control
output
Input
type
linear
Input type
thermocouple
Input
type
RTD

E5_N-H

Model

*4 Heater alarm = heater burnout & SSR failure detection

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Temperature Controller Selection Table


Category

Advanced Temperature/Digital Process Controllers

Input
type
RTD

Input type
thermocouple

Input
type
linear

Control
output

Comms*5

Supply
voltage

Features

Control
mode

Selection
criteria

4 Standard

E5_N-HT

Model
Type
Panel
Loops
Size
ON/OFF
PID
2-PID *2
Operation
Valve Control *3
Accuracy
Auto-tuning
Self-tuning
Transfer output
Remote input
Number of alarms
Heater alarm
IP rating front panel
Display

E5AR

E5ER

Universal, Ramp/Soak
On-panel type
Single loop
1/4, 1/8, 1/16 DIN

Advanced
On-panel type
Multi-loop
1/4 DIN

Advanced
On-panel type
Multi-loop
1/8 DIN

Heating & Cooling

Heating & Cooling

Heating & Cooling

0.1%

2 or 3

IP66; NEMA 4X
Dual 4 digit

0.1%

0.1%

IP66; NEMA 4X
Triple 5 digit

IP66; NEMA 4X
Triple 5 digit

110/240 VAC

24 VAC/VDC

RS-232
RS-485
Event IP
Quick Link port*6
DeviceNet
Modbus
Relay
SSR
Voltage (pulse)
Linear voltage
Linear current
mA
mV
V
K
J
T
E
L
U
N
R
S
B
W
PLII
Pt100
JPt100
Themistor
8 Available

No/not available

*2 2-PID is Omrons easy to use high performance PID algorithm


*3 Valve control = relay up and down

*5 PROFIBUS-DP communication option via PRT1-SCU11 for E5_N(-H), E5_R, EJ1


*6 QLP: Quick Link port to connected TC to PC using the smart USB cable E58-CIFQ1

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Competitor Cross Reference


Athena Series

1ZC
16C
18C
25C
32C
16
18/19
25
1810
2000
3020
4000
6075
6080
F1C
F3C
P104
P108
P116

Omron Cross

E5ZN or E5DC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5EC-T or E5EN-HT
E5AC-T or EACN-HT
E5GC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
EJ1, E5ZN or E5DC
EJ1, E5ZN or E5DC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC

Autonics

TC
TCN
TK
TM
TZ
TOS/TOM/TOL

Automation Direct

SL4824
SL4848
SL4896
SL9696

Eurotherm Series
CAL Series

3200
3300
6000
8000
9300
9400
9500
9500P
9900

TC24/PC24
TC48
TC96

E5_C Series
E5_C Series
E5_C Series
EJ1 or E5ZN
E5_C Series
E5C2

Omron Cross

E5GC
E5SCV, E5CB or E5CC
E5EC
E5AC

Omron Cross

Omron Cross

E5GC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CV or E5C2
E5CV or E5C2
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CN-H or E5CC

Cutler-Hammer

Omron Cross

Omron Cross

E5GC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC

91e
94
94C
808
818S
808P
809
847
847P
849
902P
903P
904P
900EPC
2116
2132
2204e
2208e
2216e
2404
2408
2416
2500
3204
3208
3216
35040
35080

E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5EN-HPRR
E5EN-H
E5EN-HT
E5EN-HPRR or E5EC-PR
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CC
E5GC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5ZN
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5AN-HT, E5AR or E5AC-T
E5EN-HT, E5ER or E5EC-T

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Competitor Cross Reference


Fuji Series

CC-M
PXE
PVX
PXH
PXR4
PXR5
PXR9
PXR4
PXR3
PXG9
PXG5
PXG4

E5ZE
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5AR
E5AC-PRR or E5AR-PR
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5GC
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T

Honeywell Series

DC100 Series
DCP50
DCP 100
DCP 300
UDC700
UDC900
UDC1200
UDC1700
UDC2500
UDC3200
UDC3500

Omron Cross

E5_C Series
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5AR
E5GC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AR

JUMO Series

cTRON 04
cTRON 08
cTRON16
DICON500
DICON501
dTRON 304
dTRON 308
dTRON 316
iTRON04
iTRON08
iTRON16
iTRON32
iTRON DR 100
LC100
LC200
LC300

Omron Cross

Omron Cross

E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5AR
E5AR
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5GC
E5DC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC

Love Series

16A
16L
32A
32B
32DZ
4B
8B
16B
4C
8C
16C
2500
2600
SDC
SDC8
SCZ10

Ogden Series

ETR-104
ETR-401
ETR-402
ETR-404
ETR-405
ETR-406
ETR-805
ETR-901
ETR-902
ETR-905
ETR-3000
ETR-3200
ETR-3400
ETR-4100
ETR-4300
ETR-8100
ETR-8300
ETR-9090
ETR-9100
ETR-9200
ETR-9300

Omron Cross

E5CN-H or E5CC

E5GC
E5GC
N/A
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
EJ1, E5AN or E5DC
EJ1, E5AN or E5DC
E5DC

Omron Cross

E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5C2 or E5CB
E5C2 or E5CB
E5CB or E5CSV
E5GC
E5GC
E5GC
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Competitor Cross Reference


Omega Series

CN1A
CN243-R1-F2
CN4000 Series
CN6201
CN63100
CN740
CN76000
CN7800
CN78000
CN77000
CN79000
CN800
CN8590
CN9000A
CN9300
CN9500
CNi16
CNi332
DPi8
DPi16
DPi32

E5CB or E5CSV
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5_N-H or E5_C Series
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CSV, E5CB or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5GC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5GC
E5CSV or E5CC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5GC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5GC
E5EN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5GC

Red lion Series

CSMSTR
DLC
PAX2C
PXU
PCU
PCU-MVP
PSC
TCU
TCU-MVP
TSC
P16
P48
T16
T48

10

Omron Cross

Omron Cross

EJ1 or E5DC
E5ZN
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5_C Series
E5EN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5CC
E5EN-HT or E5CC-T
E5EN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5CC
E5EN-HT or E5CC-T
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5CC
E5CC

RKC

CB100
CB100L
CB103
CB400
CB403
CB500
CB700
CB900
CB900L
CB903
FAREX SR mini HG
FB100
FB400
FB900
MA900
MA901
PF-900
RB100
RB400
RB500
RB700
RB900
REC-C400
REX-C100
REX-C410
REX-C700
REX-C900
REX-D100
REX-D400
REX-D900
REX--F-400
REX--F-700
REX--F-900
REX-F9000
REX-P24
REX-P48
REX-P96
SA100
SA100L
SA200
SB1
SRV
SRX
SRZ
Z-TIO-G

Omron Cross

E5CC
N/A
E5CC
E5EC
E5EC
N/A
N/A
E5AC
N/A
E5AC
EJ1
E5CN-T or E5CC-T
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AR
N/A
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5CC
E5EC
N/A
N/A
E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5CN-H or E5CC
N/A
N/A
E5AN-H or E5AC
Discontinued 11/2015
Discontinued 11/2015
Discontinued 11/2015
Discontinued 5/2015
Discontinued 11/2015
Discontinued 11/2015
E5AR
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5CC-U
N/A
E5GC
N/A
EJ1 or E5ZN
EJ1 or E5ZN
EJ1 or E5ZN
EJ1 or E5ZN

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

Competitor Cross Reference


Watlow Series

F4
EZ-Zone RM
EZ-Zone Express PM
Series CV

West

4100
6100
8100
KS Vario
MLC 9000+
PlastX6
PlastX8
Pro-16
Pro-8
Pro-4
Pro-EC44

Omron Cross

E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
EJ1 ro E5DC
E5CC or E5GC
E5EC

Omron Cross

E5AN-H or E5AC
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC
EJ1, E5ZN or E5DC
EJ1, E5ZN or E5DC
E5CSV or E5CB
E5CC
E5CN-HT or E5CC-T
E5EN-HT or E5EC-T
E5AN-HT or E5AC-T
E5AR

Yokogawa Series

UP350
UP550
UP750
UT150
UT152
UT155
UT320
UT350
UT420
UT450
UT520
UT550
UT750
YS80
YS150
YS170

Omron Cross

E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AR
ES100P
E5CN-H or E5CC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5EN-H or E5EC
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AR
E5AN-H or E5AC
E5AR
E5AR

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.

11

OMRON AUTOMATION AND SAFETY THE AMERICAS HEADQUARTERS Chicago, IL USA 847.843.7900 800.556.6766 www.omron247.com

CONFIDENTIAL - Restricted for use by Omron Sales Engineers and Distributors.


TempControl-XREF

Note: Specifications are subject to change.

2015 Omron Electronics LLC