Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Currently, atrial fibrillation (AF) is a source of consider- lines, a procedure that yields low complication rates and
able concern, and its impact is likely to be amplified as high success rates in both paroxysmal and chronic
the estimated number of patients affected by AF is ex- AF.1–10 Electrical isolation of the PV from the atrial
pected to increase nearly 2.5-fold over the next 50 years. substrate provides an electrophysiologically based end
AF is associated with an increased number of emergency point that serves to prevent propagation of arrhythmo-
department visits and hospitalizations, and frequent elec- genic impulses from the PV to the atria, eliminating this
trical cardioversions may be required despite the use of region from the substrate capable of maintaining AF.
antiarrhythmic drugs. These observations indicate how However, electrical isolation of the PV may not be re-
imperative it is to promote coordinated efforts on behalf quired, as demonstrated by circumferential PV ablation
of cardiologists, electrophysiologists, neurologists, and (CPVA): a ⬎80% reduction in the bipolar voltage am-
primary care providers to meet the increasing challenge plitude in the ablation lines of CPVA results in even
of stroke prevention and rhythm management in the
greater long-term success.
growing population with AF. Catheter ablation to cure
The AF Follow-up Investigation of Rhythm Manage-
AF has now evolved as an established method for treating
ment (AFFIRM) showed that a rhythm control strategy
this common rhythm disorder. Catheter ablation of AF is
confers no survival advantage over rate control among
now performed on a daily basis in electrophysiology
laboratories in most regions of the world. Cure of AF has patients with AF who had risk factors for stroke.11,12
had a dramatic impact on quality of life, morbidity, and However, drug inefficacy or adverse drug effects, or
mortality. The first decade of AF ablation was character- both, can easily account for the absence of a survival
ized by new observations and concepts as well as im- benefit of rhythm control. We have found that in both
provement in technology. Most current treatment ap- ablation and antiarrhythmic treatment groups, sinus
proaches for AF aim at ablation around the pulmonary rhythm (SR) maintenance is associated with significantly
veins (PVs) with or without additional ablation lesion lower mortality and adverse event rates, calling into
question the results of 3 recent AF trials (the Pharmaco-
logical Intervention in Atrial Fibrillation [PIAF]12 trial,
Department of Cardiology, Electrophysiology and Cardiac Pacing Unit, AFFIRM,11 and the Rate Control Versus Electrical Car-
San Raffaele University Hospital, Milan, Italy. dioversion for Persistent Atrial Fibrillation [RACE]12a
*Address for reprints: Carlo Pappone, MD, PhD, Department of Car- trial). Our results suggest that catheter ablation for curing
diology, San Raffaele University Hospital, Via Olgettina 60, 20132 Milan,
Italy. AF is effective in the long term and will continue to
E-mail address: carlo.pappone@hsr.it. improve with further technologic advances.13
0002-9149/05/$ – see front matter © 2005 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. www.AJConline.org
doi:10.1016/j.amjcard.2005.09.063
60L The American Journal of Cardiology (www.AJConline.org) Vol 96 (12A) December 19, 2005
Current Atrial Fibrillation Ablation Strategies: enlarged ablation design inclusive of additional lesion lines
Comparative Data is indeed crucial to cure patients with AF.
Figure 1. In the posterior left atrial (LA) wall, rotor-driven atrial fibrillation amenable to catheter ablation using an extensive approach is shown. Emphasis
is on the crucial role of the pulmonary vein (PV)-LA junction for successful ablation of atrial fibrillation. IVC ⫽ inferior vena cava; LIPV ⫽ left inferior
PV; LOM ⫽ ligament of Marshall; LSPV ⫽ left superior PV; RA ⫽ right atrial; RIPV ⫽ right inferior PV; RSPV ⫽ right superior PV; SVC ⫽ superior
vena cava. (Adapted from Circulation,8,14,15 N Engl J Med,10 and Ann Thorac Surg.16)
Table 1
Complication rates following circumferential pulmonary vein (PV) ablation
Complication Rate (%)
Death 0.0
Pericardial effusion 0.1
Stroke 0.03
Transient ischemic attack 0.2
Tamponade 0.1
Atrioesophageal fistula 0.03
PV stenosis 0.0
Incisional left atrial tachycardia 6.0
favorable is an ostial diameter ⬍10 mm. Radiofrequency Mapping and ablation procedure: Three catheters are
(RF) applications at a small ostium carry a higher than usual usually used: (1) a standard bipolar or quadripolar catheter
risk of PV stenosis. in the right ventricular apex to provide backup pacing, (2) a
quadripolar catheter in the coronary sinus to allow pacing of
the left atrium, and (3) a deflectable ablation catheter to be
Circumferential Pulmonary Vein Ablation Technique advanced through the transseptal sheath. A pigtail catheter
Patient population and selection: Over the last 5 years, is temporarily positioned above the aortic valve to act as a
⬎6,000 patients with either paroxysmal or chronic AF, landmark at the time of transseptal puncture. A reference
many of whom had associated structural heart disease, were patch is also placed on the back of the patient. A 3-dimen-
referred to our department for circumferential PV ablation. sional reconstruction of the left atrium is created with an
In our series the presence of heart failure, coronary artery electroanatomic mapping system. Tubular models of the
disease, and mechanical prosthetic valves did not affect the PVs and the outline of the mitral valve annulus are also
outcome. depicted as anatomic landmarks for the navigation system,
62L The American Journal of Cardiology (www.AJConline.org) Vol 96 (12A) December 19, 2005
and we create the map by entering each PV in turn (Figure Ablation strategy: Our initial ablation strategy was to
2). Three locations are recorded along the mitral annulus to encircle the 4 PVs by creating circumferential lesions
tag the valve orifice. To secure PV entry, we use 3 criteria around each PV. These lines consisted of contiguous
based on (1) fluoroscopy, (2) impedance, and (3) electrical focal lesions deployed at ⬎5 mm from the PV ostia.
activity. Entry into the vein is clearly identified because the However, since 2001, additional ablation lines on the
catheter leaves the cardiac shadow on fluoroscopy, imped- posterior wall connecting both the superior and inferior
ance usually increases ⬎140 to 150 ⍀, and electrical activ- PVs and the mitral annulus to the left inferior PV (mitral
ity disappears. To better differentiate between PVs and the isthmus line) are created (Figure 2) to prevent postabla-
left atrium, we use voltage criteria (fractionation of the local tion LA flutter.8,9 RF current is usually applied with a
bipolar electrogram) and impedance (an increase of ⬎4 ⍀ target temperature of 55°C to 65°C and a maximum
above mean LA impedance) to define the PV ostium. An- power of 100 W. CPVA is performed 1 to 2 cm from the
atomic appearance clearly acts as added confirmation of PV ostia to encircle each PV. RF energy is applied in the
catheter entry into the PV ostium, and an 8-mm tip-deflect- posterior wall with a maximum power of 50 W and a
able catheter or a 4-mm tip-irrigated catheter is used for temperature target of 55°C to minimize the risk of injury.
mapping and ablation. The mapping and ablation proce- RF energy is applied continuously on the circumferential
planned ablation lines as the catheter is gradually
dures are performed by using the coronary sinus atrial signal
dragged along the line. Continuous catheter movement,
if the patient is in SR, or the right ventricular signal if the
often in a to-and-fro fashion over a point, helps keep
patient is in AF, as the synchronization trigger for the
catheter-tip temperature down by means of passive cool-
CARTO (Biosense Webster, Inc., Diamond Bar, CA) sys-
ing. The end point of ablation is voltage abatement of the
tem. Each endocardial location is recorded while a stable
local atrial electrogram by 90% or to ⬍0.05 mV. In some
catheter position is maintained, as assessed by both end-
patients, if necessary, additional ablation lines are cre-
diastolic stability (a distance of 2 mm between 2 successive ated along the LA roof, septum/anterior wall, or along the
locations) and local activation time stability. Atrial volumes posterior mitral annulus. On average, a total of 10 to 15
are calculated at the end of diastole independently of the seconds of RF is required. Circumferential ablation lines
underlying rhythm (AF or SR). The mapping catheter is are usually created by starting at the lateral mitral annu-
introduced into the left atrium under fluoroscopic guidance, lus and withdrawing posteriorly and then anteriorly to
and its location is recorded relative to the location of the left-sided PVs, passing between the LSPV and the LA
fixed reference. Usually, 100 points are required to create appendage before completing the circumferential line on
adequate maps of the left atrium and PVs, and ⱕ200 points the posterior wall of the left atrium. The “ridge” between
for accurate mapping of LA tachycardia. Anatomic recon- the LSPV and LA appendage can be identified by frag-
struction of the left atrium obtained with the CARTO sys- mented electrograms resulting from the collision of ac-
tem or Endocardial Solutions (St. Paul, MN) system is tivity from the LA appendage and LSPV/left atrium. We
reliable compared with magnetic resonance imaging. By observed termination of AF during the procedure in about
moving the catheter inside the heart, the mapping system one third of patients. If AF does not terminate during RF,
continuously analyzes its location and orientation and pre- transthoracic cardioversion is performed at the end of the
sents it to the user on the monitor of a graphic workstation, procedure. If there is immediate recurrence of AF after
thereby allowing navigation without the use of fluoroscopy. cardioversion, completeness of the lines is reassessed.
The mapping procedure is performed by moving the cath- Ablation is performed in the cavotricuspid isthmus in
eter to numerous sequential points within the left atrium and patients with a history of typical atrial flutter; in patients
PVs, and establishing the location in 3-dimensional space with cavotricuspid isthmus– dependent atrial flutter, it is
together with the local unipolar and bipolar voltages and the induced by atrial pacing.
local activation time relative to the chosen reference inter- PV innervation and denervation: Potential vagal target
val. The acquired information is then color coded and dis- sites are identified during the procedure in ⱖ33% of pa-
played. As each new site is acquired, reconstruction is tients.4 Vagal reflexes are considered sinus bradycardia
progressively updated in real time to create 3-dimensional (⬍40 beats per minute), asystole, atrioventricular block, or
chamber geometry color coded with activation time. Addi- hypotension that occurs within a few seconds of the onset of
tionally, collected data can be displayed as voltage maps RF application. If a reflex is elicited, RF energy is delivered
depicting the magnitude of the local peak voltage in a until such reflexes are abolished or for ⱕ30 seconds. The
3-dimensional model. The chamber geometry is recon- end point for ablation at these sites is termination of the
structed in real time by interpolation of the acquired points. reflex that is followed by sinus tachycardia or AF. Failure to
Local activation times can be used to create activation maps, reproduce the reflexes with repeat RF is considered confir-
which are important when mapping and ablating focal or mation of denervation. Complete local vagal denervation is
macroreentrant atrial tachycardia but are not used during confirmed by the abolition of all vagal reflexes. The most
ablation in patients with AF. common sites are tagged on electroanatomic maps.4
Pappone and Santinelli/ Atrial Fibrillation Ablation: State of the Art 63L
Figure 2. Preablation and postablation electroanatomic left atrial maps. Circular radiofrequency lesions are created around each pulmonary vein (PV) ostium,
constituting the standard ablation set for circumferential PV ablation. Additional linear lesions connect both the right-sided and left-sided PVs. The mitral
isthmus line connecting the mitral annulus and the left inferior PV (LIPV) to prevent left atrial incisional tachycardia is evident. LSPV ⫽ left superior PV;
MV ⫽ mitral valve; PA ⫽ pulmonary artery; RIPV ⫽ right inferior PV; RSPV ⫽ right superior PV.
Among patients in SR, postablation remapping is per- application is recommended when ablating on the LA pos-
formed using the preablation map for the acquisition of new terior wall; at present, the line is made on the posterior wall
points to permit accurate comparison of pre- and post-RF near the roof of the left atrium, where the left atrium is not
bipolar voltage maps. Among patients in AF, after restora- in direct contact with the esophagus. Success rates are
tion of SR, postablation remapping is performed with the approximately 90% among patients with paroxysmal AF
anatomic map acquired during AF to have the same land- and 80% among those with chronic AF. In patients with
marks and lesion tags for accurate lesion validation. Gaps paroxysmal AF in whom vagal reflexes are elicited and
are defined as breakthroughs in an ablated area and identi- abolished by RF application, the long-term success rate is
fied by sites with single potentials as well as by early local approximately 100%.4 A recent randomized study by our
activation. The completeness of the mitral isthmus lesion laboratory demonstrated that early recurrence of AF or
line is usually demonstrated during coronary sinus pacing iatrogenic LA tachycardia may occur within the first few
by endocardial and coronary sinus mapping to seek widely months after the procedure, particularly in patients without
spaced double potentials across the line of block. In our additional ablation lines; usually they do not require a repeat
experience, after block is achieved, the double-potential procedure because the condition resolves spontaneously
interval at the mitral isthmus during coronary sinus pacing during long-term follow-up.8 Another recent randomized
is usually approximately 150 msec, depending on the atrial study by our laboratory demonstrated that CPVA is superior
dimensions and the extent of scarring and lesion creation.8 to administration of amiodarone in maintaining long-term
If incomplete block is revealed by impulse propagation SR in patients with chronic AF.
across the line, further RF applications are made to com-
plete the line of block.
In patients who are in AF at the beginning of the proce- Anatomic, Electrical, and Functional Remodeling
dure, RF ablation is performed without an initial attempt at After Pulmonary Vein Ablation
cardioversion. If AF does not terminate during ablation,
cardioversion is performed at the end of the procedure. Restoration of SR after ablation (usually by 5-month fol-
low-up) results in “reverse” electrical and mechanical atrial
remodeling and improved atrial function. Enlarged atria
Safety and Efficacy may become smaller, and this is associated with both elec-
trical and mechanical changes. Among patients with mitral
Complications of circumferential LA ablation are reported regurgitation who undergo ablation, anatomic remodeling is
in Table 1. Postablation LA flutter is relatively common but more pronounced and, interestingly, is associated with re-
usually does not require a repeat procedure because it gen- duced mitral regurgitation and improved left ventricular
erally resolves spontaneously within 5 months after the function compared with patients in whom SR is maintained
index procedure. Atrioesophageal fistula is rare, but its by drugs alone. In our experience, anatomic, electrical, and
occurrence is dramatic and devastating.5 Lower RF energy functional remodeling after ablation is associated with a
64L The American Journal of Cardiology (www.AJConline.org) Vol 96 (12A) December 19, 2005
good long-term outcome in patients with either paroxysmal 2. Pappone C, Oreto G, Rosanio S, Vicedomini G, Tocchi M, Gugliotta
or chronic AF. F, Salvati A, Dicandia C, Calabro MP, Mazzone P, et al. Atrial
electroanatomic remodeling after circumferential radiofrequency PV
ablation. Efficacy of an anatomic approach in a large cohort of patients
with AF. Circulation 2001;104:2539 –2544.
Future Directions 3. Pappone C, Rosanio S, Augello G, Gallus G, Vicedomini G, Mazzone
Remote magnetic catheter navigation system for P, Gulletta S, Gugliotta F, Pappone A, Santinelli V, et al. Mortality,
mapping and ablation of AF—a new era in interven- morbidity, and quality of life after circumferential PV ablation for AF:
tional electrophysiology: A novel and promising approach outcomes from a controlled nonrandomized long-term study. J Am
Coll Cardiol 2003;42:185–197.
to transcatheter AF ablation is the robotic magnetic naviga-
4. Pappone C, Santinelli V, Manguso F, Vicedomini G, Gugliotta F,
tion system for accurate mapping and ablation. The initial Augello G, Mazzone P, Tortoriello W, Landoni G, Zangrillo A, et al.
experience with this system in our laboratory has shown that PV denervation enhances long term benefit after circumferential abla-
the remote control of a soft magnetic catheter in patients tion for paroxysmal AF. Circulation 2004;109:327–334.
with either paroxysmal or chronic AF is safe and feasible. 5. Pappone C, Oral H, Santinelli V, Vicedomini G, Lang CC, Manguso
F, Torracca L, Benussi S, Alfieri O, Hong R, et al. Atrio-esophageal
This navigation system is integrated with a newly developed
fistula as a complication of percutaneous transcatheter ablation of AF.
electroanatomic CARTO RMT (Biosense Webster, Inc.) Circulation 2004;109:2724 –2726.
mapping system. A special magnetic 4-mm tip mapping and 6. Oral H, Scharf C, Chugh A, Hall B, Cheung P, Good E, Veerareddy S,
ablation catheter with a location sensor, the NaviStar-RMT Pelosi F, Morady F. Catheter ablation for paroxysmal AF: segmental
catheter, has been developed to function with both magnetic PV ostial ablation vs. left atrial ablation. Circulation 2003;108:2355–
2360.
navigation and the CARTO system. The CARTO RMT
7. Oral H, Knight BP, Tada H, Ozaydin M, Chugh A, Hassan S, Scharf
system sends real-time catheter-tip location and orientation C, Lai SW, Greenstein R, Pelosi F Jr, et al. PV isolation for paroxys-
data to the magnetic navigation system. Magnetic field mal and persistent AF. Circulation 2002;105:1077–1081.
orientations corresponding to specific map points can be 8. Pappone C, Manguso F, Vicedomini G, Gugliotta F, Santinelli O,
stored on the navigation system and reapplied, if desired, to Ferro A, Gulletta S, Sala S, Sora N, Paglino G, et al. Prevention of
return to previously visited locations on the map, repeatably iatrogenic atrial tachycardia after ablation of atrial fibrillation: a pro-
spective randomized study comparing circumferential pulmonary vein
and accurately. We have now developed a remote mapping ablation with a modified approach. Circulation 2004;110:3036 –3042.
and ablation protocol for circumferential PV ablation pro- 9. Pappone C, Santinelli V. The who, what, why, and how-to guide for
cedures.9 The learning curve is not long and is limited to the circumferential pulmonary vein ablation. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol
first case. No complication has been observed. 2004;15:1226 –1230.
On the basis of our experience with this remote naviga- 10. Haissaguerre M, Jais P, Shah DC, Takahashi A, Hocini M, Quiniou G,
Garrigue S, Le Mouroux A, Le Metayer P, Clementy J. Spontaneous
tion technology in patients with node-reentrant atrioventric- initiation of atrial fibrillation by ectopic beats originating in the pul-
ular reciprocating tachycardia and/or accessory pathways, monary veins. N Engl J Med 1998;339:659 – 666.
as well as in patients with AF, we believe a new era in 11. Wyse DG, Waldo AL, DiMarco JP, Domanski MJ, Rosenberg Y,
interventional electrophysiology is beginning. Magnetic Schron EB, Kellen JC, Greene HL, Mickel MC, Dalquist JE, et al, for
catheters can now be navigated in the left atrium more the AF Follow-up Investigation of Rhythm Management (AFFIRM)
Investigators. A comparison of rate control and rhythm control in
precisely and safely than achieved manually, without risk of
patients with AF. N Engl J Med 2002;347:1825–1833.
major complications, even in less experienced centers. 12. Hohnloser SH, Kuck KH. Randomized trial of rhythm or rate control
in atrial fibrillation: the Pharmacological Intervention in Atrial Fibril-
lation Trial (PIAF). Eur Heart J 2001;22:801– 802.
Conclusion 12a.Van Gelder IC, Hagens VE, Bosker HA, Kingma JH, Kamp O,
Kingma T, Said SA, Darmanata JI, Timmermans AJ, Tijssen JG, et al,
for the Rate Control versus Electrical Cardioversion for Persistent AF
The circumferential PV approach to ablation can be safely
Study Group. A comparison of rate control and rhythm control in
performed in most patients with either paroxysmal or patients with recurrent persistent AF. N Engl J Med 2002;347:1834 –
chronic AF, with high success rates that are maintained over 1840.
the long term. With practice and new technology develop- 13. Pappone C, Santinelli V. Towards a unified strategy for atrial fibril-
ment, the procedure can be accomplished more quickly and lation ablation? Eur Heart J 2005;26:696 –704.
14. Hwang C, Wu TJ, Doshi RN, Peter CT, Chen PS. Vein of Marshall
can be safely performed even in less experienced centers,
cannulation for the analysis of electrical activity in patients with focal
thus improving patient tolerance and exposing the patient to atrial fibrillation. Circulation 2000;101:1503–1505.
less risk. 15. Mandapati R, Skanes A, Chen J, Berenfeld O, Jalife J. Stable micro-
reentrant sources as a mechanism of atrial fibrillation in the isolated
1. Pappone C, Rosanio S, Oreto G, Tocchi M, Gugliotta F, Vicedomini sheep heart. Circulation 2000;101:194 –199.
G, Salvati A, Dicandia C, Mazzone P, Santinelli V, Gulletta S, Chier- 16. Sueda T, Nagata H, Orihashi K, Morita S, Okada K, Sueshiro M, Hirai
chia S. Circumferential radiofrequency ablation of pulmonary vein S, Matsuura Y. Efficacy of a simple left atrial procedure for chronic
ostia: a new anatomic approach for curing atrial fibrillation. Circula- atrial fibrillation in mitral valve operations. Ann Thorac Surg 1997;
tion 2000;102:2619 –2628. 63:1070 –1075.