Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CHAPTER 1s
January 2016
CHAPTER 1
1.1
January 2016
Preface
The understanding of the principles and concepts for Separation Technology is essential in
the sense that will enable us to not only identify but as well as choosing the best method in
achieving Separation and Product Recovery while at the same time will also enable us to
identify the type of mixture that we are dealing with. This is because identification the type
of mixture to be separated and choosing the best method for separation is inter related and
dependable with each other. However, it is important to bear in mind that choosing the best
method for separation precede identification of product mixture.
As previously mentioned, it is very important to choose the best and suitable method
for Separation and Product Recovery. For that matter, it is worthwhile to bear in mind that
each and different methods has limitations as well as advantages. With that in mind, it is
important to choose the best and suitable methods which can produce the desired
separation and recover of wanted or desired product from the mixture as specified in the
products specification and classification.
With the product limit in terms of the products specification and classification,
sometimes, it will be troublesome and difficult to achieve the required specification and
classification by just using only one separation method. In normal cases, more than one
separation methods need to be chosen which compliment to each other in terms of their
respective limitation and enhance each others advantages. For that matter, these different
methods of separation can be combined in one big separation system or can be assemble
close to each other with separation process occurs from one step or stage to the other step
until the final step which at the final step the product analysis need to be done to check and
confirmed the product quality meets the products specification and classification.
Before we look at each method of Separation in more detail, it is important for us to
know the definition and concept of two classifications of mixture to be separated and then
followed by basic concepts in Introduction of Separation Technology. Then, we will look into
different types and General Classifications of Separation Technology.
1.2
In this particular chapter, you will be exposed to first and foremost regarding the Purpose
of Separation. In other words, the question of "Why do we need to carry out Separation?
or what is the importance of having Separation Process / Technology? will be answered
and discussed in brief. This is then followed by the definition and discussion concerning
the broad classification of mixture which can either be classified as Homogeneous or
Heterogeneous.
January 2016
Next, this chapter will continue the discussion by looking at two broad categories of
Separation which can be classified as Chemical Separation or Physical Mechanical
Separation. The definition for both categories of Separation will be given in brief. After
that, we will look into specific classifications under both Chemical Separation as well as
Physical Mechanical Separation. Among the specific classifications under Chemical
Separation are Absorption, Distillation, Liquid-Liquid Extraction, Leaching, Membrane
Processing, Crystallization, Adsorption, Evaporation and Ion Exchange. This is then
followed by specific classifications under Physical Mechanical Separation which are
Filtration, Settling and Centrifugation. In this chapter, different definitions for each specific
classification for Chemical Separation as well as Physical Mechanical Separation will be
looked into as given by different reference books which are then followed by a summarized
and simplified definition.
Now let us look at the first part of the chapter which is concerning the Introduction
and Purpose of Separation.
1.3
January 2016
Basically, the types of mixture can be divided into two parts which are known as
Homogeneous Mixture and Heterogeneous Mixture.
1.4
January 2016
Separation Process basically can be generally classified or divided into two (2) types, which
are Chemical Separation and Mechanical Separation. The respective definition of these
two methods as well as examples of methods under Chemical Separation and Mechanical
Separation will be shown respectively as given in the below paragraphs.
Distillation
Evaporation
Drying
Ion Exchange
Liquid-Liquid Extraction
Leaching
Crystallization
Now, we will look at brief description for each method of separation. The detail
principles and operation as well as application will be given in the next and coming chapters.
Let us look at brief definition for Absorption.
January 2016
Absorption
There are different descriptions of Absorption which can be given as follows which are
based on referenced materials:
1. When the two contacting phases are a gas and liquid the unit operation is called
absorption. Solute A is absorbed from the gas phase into a liquid phase. Involves
molecular or turbulent diffusion. Mass transfer of a solute A thorough a stagnant nondiffusity gas B into a stagnant liquid C.
2. For gas absorption, the gas contains a desired component, say A. A liquid solvent which
has specific affinity only to A is then contacted with the gas stream, and a fraction of A
coming into the absorber is "absorbed" by the entering liquid. Ideally, the chosen solvent
should have low volatility such that almost none of the solvent escapes with the gas. The
fraction absorbed is again strongly dependent on the operating temperature and
pressure, where lower temperature and higher pressure is more desirable. The solvent
containing absorbed A is then passed to another separation unit such as a distillation
column to finally separate the two.
3. A widely used alternative to Distillation for the separation of a solute from a gas stream
is Absorption. In this separation process, the gas mixture is contacted with a liquid
solvent which preferentially absorbs one or more components from the gas stream.
Liquid flow rate, temperature and pressure are the variables that must be set in this
separation process. (Peters, Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics
For Chemical Engineers).
From the brief description, it can be said that the method of Absorption involves two
phases which are GAS or VAPOUR and LIQUID. Also, from the description above it can be
simplified that:
If the desired component of GAS or VAPOUR is to be separated or extracted from the
mixture of gases, a LIQUID will be used as a SOLVENT to ABSORP the desired gas into
the liquid. This process is called ABSORPTION.
Stripping
There are basically two brief descriptions concerning the process of Stripping which are
as given below:
1. The reverse of Absorption is called stripping or desorption, and the same theories
and basic principles hold. (Geankoplis : Transport Process And Separation
Process Principles)
2. Once a solute is dissolved in a solvent, it is often necessary to separate the solute
from the absorbent in a stripping operation to recycle the solvent back to absorber.
(Peters, Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics For Chemical
Engineers).
January 2016
From the two descriptions given in previous page, it can be said that the Stripping also
involves TWO phases which are LIQUID that consist of mixture between liquid solvent
being used for Absorption and solute which is being Absorbed into the solvent and
VAPOUR that is to Desorbed or Stripped the solute. In other words, it can be said that:
Stripping or Desorption is the REVERSE process of Absorption whereby the liquid
mixture from Absorption process is to be SEPARATED by using Vapour which is to
DESORP the solute from the Liquid mixture into the Vapour. This is done in order to
REGAIN the Liquid solvent to be recycled or reused for Absorption process.
Distillation
There are different descriptions concerning the process of Distillation which are as given
below:
1. A volatile vapor phase and a liquid phase that vaporize are involved. Distillation of an
ethanol-water solution where the vapor contains a concentration of ethanol greater than
in the liquid. In the distillation of crude petroleum, various fractions such as gasoline,
kerosene and heating oils are distilled off.
2. Distillation is similar in concept to evaporation, but allows the capture of the substance
which evaporated. Distillation is the process of heating a liquid to its boiling point,
condensing the vapors back to a liquid (by cooling), and then collecting the liquid
distillate. Since different substances have different boiling points, control of the
temperature allows a separation to occur. As an example, crude oil is refined into
various products such as naphtha, gasoline, kerosene, fuel oil, and lubricating oil
through a fractional distillation process.
3. The heavy phase is liquid while the light phase is vapor. For the binary case, say a
mixture of compounds A and B, separation depends strongly on the relative volatilities
of each component. If both have the same volatility then separation via distillation is not
effective. However, as will be shown later, the volatilities depend on the vapor pressures
at the operating temperature and the column pressure used.
4. The creation or addition of another phase in Distillation is obtained by the repeated
vaporization and condensation of the fluid. The separation process exploits the
differences in vapour pressure of the key components in the mixture to initiate the
separation. (Peters, Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics For
Chemical Engineers).
Based on the three brief descriptions of Distillation, it can be seen that the separation
of desired compound involve ONE phase only which is in LIQUID phase. Therefore, it can
be simplified or concluded that:
January 2016
Leaching
There are four brief descriptions concerning the method of Leaching from three different
referenced materials:
1. The process of Leaching occurs if a fluid is being used to extract a solute from a solid.".
2. Leaching refers to the extraction of a soluble constituent from a solid by means of a
solvent. (Coulson & Richardson Volume 2).
3. This is the method of removing one constituent from a solid by a means of a liquid
solvent. (McCabe, Smith & Harriott : Unit Operations).
4. In order to separate the desired solute constituent or remove an undesirable solute
January 2016
component from the solid phase, the solid is contacted with a liquid phase. The two
phases are in intimate contact and the solute or solutes can diffuse from the solid to the
liquid phase, resulting in a separation of the components originally in the solid. This
separation process is called Liquid - Solid Leaching or simply Leaching. (Peters,
Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics For Chemical Engineers).
Based on the four different and similar descriptions given in previous page, it is
important to realize that SOLVENT used is in the form of LIQUID, while the mixtures which
consist of the desired and undesired compound is in the form of SOLID. To conclude the
brief description of Leaching:
If a process of EXTRACTING solute which is the desired compound in the form of SOLID
from its SOLID MIXTURE with the usage of a solvent in the form of LIQUID, then the
process is called LEACHING or SOLID EXTRACTION."
Membrane Processing
There are three brief descriptions concerning Membrane Processing as one method of
separation under Chemical Separation which is listed below:
1. The relatively thin, solid membrane controls the rate of the movement of molecules
between 2 phases.
2. This is the method of separating gaseous or liquid mixtures by the usage of semi
permeable membranes which act like a filter. This membrane allows one or more
constituents of the mixture to pass through more readily than the others. (McCabe,
Smith & Harriott : Unit Operation).
3. This type of separation is accomplished with the use of specially prepared membranes
that selectively permit one or more components of a feed stream to pass through the
barrier while retarding the passage of other components in the feed stream. (Peters,
Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics For Chemical Engineers).
Based on the two brief descriptions given in previous page, it can be seen that the
membrane is basically in the form of SOLID while the desired compound is in the form of
either LIQUID or GAS in the mixture of LIQUID or GAS respectively. Therefore, the
description of Membrane Processing can be given as:
The method of SEPARATING the desired compound from the mixture by the usage of a
MEMBRANE FILTER which ONLY ALLOWS the DESIRED compound to pass through
and left behind the other compound in the mixture. This method is known as MEMBRANE
PROCESSING."
Crystallization
For the brief description of the method Crystallization, there are four descriptions based
January 2016
Adsorption
There are basically two descriptions concerning the method of Adsorption as given in the
referenced materials which are as follows:
1. One or more components in a gas stream are adsorbed on the surface of the pres of
a solid adsorbent and the separation is obtained.
2. Adsorption is a separation process in which certain components of a fluid phase are
transferred to the surface of a solid adsorbent.
January 2016
Evaporation
There are different descriptions of Evaporation which can be given as follows which are
based on referenced materials:
1. Evaporation refers to removal of relatively large amounts of water from material. In
Evaporation, the water is removed as vapour at its boiling point. In Evaporation, the
vapour from a boiling liquid solution is removed and a more concentrated solution
remains. In the majority of cases, the separation process called Evaporation refers to
the removal of water from an aqueous solution. (Geankoplis : Transport Process
And Separation Process Principles).
2. In Separation Technology, Evaporators may be considered as liquid dryers or
concentrators that separate solvents from a solution by Evaporation. In most cases, the
solvent is water. Evaporation, as a separation process, is distinct from Distillation in that
the solute is nonvolatile and a high degree of separation can be achieved in one stage.
(Peters, Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics For Chemical
Engineers).
Based on two brief descriptions concerning Evaporation, it can be understood that the
mixture is in Liquid form or a Homogenous type of mixture. Therefore, the concept of
Evaporation can be summarized as follows:
EVAPORATION is a method of REMOVING Water which acts as a solvent or Organic
solvent from the liquid mixture. The evaporated Water or Organic solvent is DISCARDED
or DISPERSED to the atmosphere and leaving the desired product in MORE
CONCENTRATED form.
Ion Exchange
There are different descriptions of Ion Exchange which can be given as follows which are
based on referenced materials:
January 2016
1. Ion Exchange is also similar to Adsorption in that solid particles are used in the
separation process and regeneration is necessary. However, a chemical reaction is
involved. (Peters, Timmerhaus & West : Plant Design An Economics For Chemical
Engineers).
2. Ion Exchange processes are basically chemical reactions between ions in solution
and ions in an insoluble solid phase. The technique used in Ion Exchange so closely
resemble those used in Adsorption that for the majority of engineering purposes Ion
Exchange can be considered as a special case of Adsorption. In Ion Exchange, certain
ions are removed by the Ion Exchange solid. Since electro neutrality must be
maintained, the solid releases replacement ions to the solution. (Geankoplis :
Transport Process And Separation Process Principles).
3. Ion Exchange is a chemical reaction wherein an ion from solution is exchanged for a
similarly charged ion attached to an immobile solid particle. (Mohd. Adi Abdul Hadi,
Mohd Azri, Mohd Helmy & Idris : Ion Exchange Separation).
Based on three brief desriptions concerning the concept of Ion Exchange, therefore, it
can be summarized as follows:
Ion Exchange is a SPECIAL case of Adsorption since it is SIMILAR with Adsorption but
with the DIFFERENCE by having CHEMICAL REACTION between IONS of solution with
ions of Solid Particle or Ion Exchange Resin. As a result of the chemical reaction, the ions
of solution exchange with ions of Solid Particle based on SIMILARLY CHARGED Ions.
Drying
There are basically two brief descriptions concerning the principle and concept of Drying
which are as shown below:
1. Drying generally means removal of relatively small amounts of water from material. In
Drying, the water is usually removed as a vapour by air. (Geankoplis : Transport
Process And Separation Process Principles).
2. The main purpose of this separation process is to remove liquid from a liquid - solid
system to produce a dry solid. Generally, the liquid removed is water, but drying can
also be used to separate organic liquids from solids. (Peters, Timmerhaus & West :
Plant Design An Economics For Chemical Engineers).
Therefore, from the two brief descriptions given above, it can be seen that the mixtures
for Drying is basically a Heterogeneous which is SOLID and LIQUID. For that matter, the
concept of Drying can be summarized as follows:
January 2016
Drying generally involves the method of REMOVING water or organic solvents from the
wet Solids at a specified MOISTURE CONTENT. The water or organic solvents being
removed to the atmosphere is in the form of VAPOUR.
Now, we have FINISHED our brief discussion concerning each method of
separation under CHEMICAL SEPARATION. In the NEXT section, we will look at some
brief description concerning the Mechanical Separation as well as the methods of
separation.
Now, let us look at briefly the concept of using these three methods of Mechanical
Separation starting with Filtration.
Filtration
There are basically two brief descriptions concerning the principle and concept of Filtration
as given by reference materials which are as shown below:
1. In Filtration, a pressure difference is set up that causes the fluid to flow through small
holes in a screen or cloth which block the passage of the large solid particles; these, in
turn, build up on the cloth as a porous cake. (Geankoplis : Transport Process And
Separation Process Principles).
January 2016
2. In this mode of separation, solid particles in a liquid or gas are removed by passing the
mixture through a porous medium that retains the particles and passes the fluid."
(Peters, Timmerhaus & West: Plant Design An Economics For Chemical
Engineers).
As a summary, the concept of Filtration as given in the reference material can be
given as follows:
Filtration is used to separate a solid from a liquid or solid from gas. In this case, the
mixture is poured through a porous medium (often filter paper), in which the size of the
pores allows liquids or gas and dissolved solutes to pass through but retains solid
particles. This is essentially like using a strainer, but with much smaller openings. The clear
liquid phase obtained is called the filtrate.
From the statement given above, it can be understood that the method of Filtration is
used to SEPARATE a mixture which contains SOLIDS and LIQUIDS for Solid Liquid
Mixture but also used to separate mixture which contains SOLIDS and GASEOUS for Solid
Gaseous Mixture. Solid is the desired product while Liquid is an unwanted product for the
case of Solid Liquid Mixture.
For the case of Solid Gaseous Mixture, Solid is again the desired product while
Gaseous is an unwanted product. Therefore, in order to achieve separation, the Solid and
Liquid or Solid and Gas need to be separated by the usage of a POROUS MEDIUM such
as Filter Paper. The concept of Filtration is about the same with Membrane Processing in
the Chemical Separation. The DIFFERENCE is that Membrane Processing is used to
separate LIQUID mixture as well as GASEOUS mixture whereas Filtration is used to
separate mixture which contains SOLID and LIQUID or SOLID and GAS.
Settling
There are basically two brief descriptions given by referenced material which can be shown
as follows:
1. In Settling and Sedimentation, the particles are separated from the fluid by gravitational
forces acting on particles of various sizes and densities. (Geankoplis: Transport
Process and Separation Process Principles).
2. In Settling processes, solid particles or liquid drops are separated from a fluid by
gravitational forces acting on the particles or drops. The fluid can be a liquid or a gas.
(Peters, Timmerhaus & West: Plant Design An Economics For Chemical
Engineers).
To summarize the concept of Settling based from the statements given by two referenced
material, the description can be given as below:
Settling or also known as GRAVITATIONAL SETTLING is a method of separating SOLIDS
from the mixture of SOLIDS and LIQUID by the usage of gravitational force. Here, the Solid
January 2016
which has higher density will obviously slowly drop to the bottom of the container or tank
which is then sucked by pumps to separate the Solid by the usage of Filter.
Here, it can be seen that the method of Settling cannot stand on its own. This method
needs to come together with Filtration in order to achieve complete separation of solids from
the filtrate or the liquid remains of the mixture.
Centrifugal Settling
There are basically two brief descriptions given based on referenced materials which can
be given as follows:
1. In Centrifugal Separations, the particles are separated from the fluid by centrifugal
forces acting on particles of various sizes and densities. (Geankoplis : Transport
Process And Separation Process Principles).
2. Use of centrifugal force increases the force acting on the particle and permits more
rapid separation times. Beside solids separation from liquids, it is also sometimes used
to separate two liquids with different densities by centrifugation. ( Peters, Timmerhaus
& West : Plant Design An Economics For Chemical Engineers ).
As a summary, the concept of Centrifugation which is based on referenced material can be
given as below:
Centrifugation is the process of separating a suspended solid in a liquid by high speed
rotation which result in centrifugal force acting on the particle or more denser liquid.
Based on the statement given above, it can be seen that the mixture contains SOLIDS
and LIQUIDS or can also Liquids with DIFFERENT DENSITIES. Solid with higher density
is the desired product. If the method of Settling allows the desired product which is the solids
to drop slowly by gravitational force, Centrifugation is a method of separating the solid from
the liquid by rotating the tank or vessel in high speed. As a result, water will be removed
outward and at the top while the solid will be removed at the bottom of Centrifugal Separator.
This concept is similar to our usage of Spinning in Washing Machine.
Centrifugal Filtration
It is unfortunate at the time of writing that not much description is given for this type of
Mechanical Separation. However, there is only one brief description which can be given as
follows:
In the second type of centrifugal separation process, centrifugal filtration occurs, which is
similar to ordinary filtration, where a bed or cake of solids builds up on a screen, but
centrifugal force is used to cause the flow instead of a pressure difference." (Geankoplis :
Transport Process And Separation Process Principles).
January 2016
Based on the statement given above, it can be understood that there is not much
different as compared to Filtration as been mentioned earlier. This is because this method
also deals with either Heterogeneous mixture of Solid - Liquid or Solid - Vapour or Gas. The
only difference is concerning the causes of flow with Pressure Difference is applied for
normal Filtration but obviously Centrifugal Force is used for Centrifugal Filtration type.
By now, we have FINISHED our discussions concerning the basic concept of
CHEMICAL SEPARATION and MECHANICAL SEPARATION. In the NEXT TOPIC, we will
look at SOLID - LIQUID SEPARATION which involves DRYING and FILTRATION.