Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
The Question
Solution
This is a detail question, so were
going to use our notes and any clues
in the question stem to know where
to look. The question stem gives us
one huge clue: it actually highlights a
portion of a sentence in the first
paragraph.
Next, the question says the passage
suggests,
so this is an inference
question. Finally, the question is
asking for a prediction that can be drawn from both the conventional theories
and the new computer theoryin other words, where do these two theories
agree?
Take a look at your notes. Mine are below, but everyone will have somewhat
different notes.
P1
P2
P3
Hmm. Well, the yellow highlighter already gives us a clue that well need to use
paragraph 1 and my notes reinforce that message: the model (or computer
model) of the Geminid vs. the (conventional) theory. All right, back to
paragraph 1 we go!
Paragraph 1
As a general rule, start a sentence or so before the cited text.
The reseNavigator found, as expected, that the computer-model stream
broadened with time. Conventional theories, however, predicted that the
distribution of particles would be increasingly dense toward the center of a
meteor stream. Surprisingly, the computer-model meteor stream gradually
came to resemble a thick-walled, hollow pipe.
Hmm. The first sentence says that as expected, the computer-model stream
broadened with time.
If this was expected, then both the computer model and
the conventional theories must be in agreement on this issue. The next two
actual meteor stream, the Geminid. Hmm. Thats how they made the model,
yes, but theres no indication that the conventional theories also held to this,
and were looking for something on which both things agreed.
(B) The orbits of most meteor streams should cross the orbit of the Earth at
some point and give rise to a meteor shower.
Most meteor streams? The universe is a pretty big place. It seems impossible
that there would only be meteors right around our own little planet. The
passage says only that when they do cross our path, well see a meteor shower.
(C) Over time the distribution of dust in a meteor stream will usually become
denser at the outside edges of the stream than at the center.
The passage did say something about this yep, at the end of paragraph 1. This
was the surprising result of the computer model; the conventional theories
disagreed. This ones definitely wrong.
(D) Meteor showers caused by older meteor streams should be, on average,
longer in duration than those caused by very young meteor streams.
Yes, this is pretty much what we said above: a bigger meteor stream would take
longer to pass through, so the older ones would take longer.
(E) The individual dust particles in older meteor streams should be, on
average, smaller than those that compose younger meteor streams.
The only thing I remember seeing about the individual particles was
something about velocities at the beginning. The passage never mentions
anything about their size.
The correct answer is (D).
We did have to get into the detail here, and that took some time. We didnt
read all that detail carefully on the first read-through, so heres where we
concentrate on several specific sentences and try to figure things out. On a
question like this one, if at all possible, try to formulate at least an idea of what
the answer must or might include before looking through the answer choices.
If youre not sure, then first try to eliminate answers that are never mentioned
in the passage at all. In this case, answer (E) mentions the size of dust
particles, but thats never mentioned in the passage.
Next, look for answers that dont make common sense. Answer (B) doesnt
make sense because the Universe is enormous; its very unlikely that most
meteors out there will cross our path at some point.
Finally, if you do pick up that the question is asking for agreement between
the conventional theories and the computer model, then cross off answer (C),
because the information in that choice is presented in the however
and
surprisingly
sentences of paragraph 1.
Now youre down to two choices; guess and move on.
If you cant get enough of the Meteor Stream passage, check out our ensuing
post here.
Key Takeaways for Inference Questions
(1) First, figure out where to look; the clues will be in the wording of the
question itself. In this case, they highlighted a couple of words for us, but they
also gave important direction when they asked what could be derived from
both
the theory and the model.
(2) Whenever possible, know what youre not looking for as well. In this case,
the question asks where the theory and the model agree, not where they
disagree. Because the passage does also give info about where the two
contradict, chances are a trap answer will include that info.
(3) If the text is just too hard to understand, use a couple of tactics to try to
eliminate some wrong answers. Anything that isnt actually mentioned in the
passage can be crossed off. You can also use common sense; if something
really doesnt make sense in the real world, dont guess that one.
CALL US
(800) 576-4628
E M A IL US
info@manhattanprep.com
2016 ManhattanPrep
Enable UC auto page to scroll all the way down through pages! Enable