Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Introduction
The following article is an introduction to the basic principles and philosophies behind
the Taguchi approach to quality control. It will attempt to give an overview on the
Taguchi techniques used in quality control. These include, the concept of Parameter
design, Orthogonal arrays and the process of Brainstorming.
Table of Contents
Introduction
The Taguchi Philosophy
The Fundamental Taguchi Concepts
The Total Loss Function
Total Loss Function Case Study
Taguchi Quality Strategy
Taguchi Techniques using Quality Control
Brainstorming
Orthogonal Arrays
Parameter Design
Conclusion
References
Authors
INTRODUCTION
The word quality cannot have a specific meaning when applied to the manufacturing
industry. This is basically because the word quality changes within the context it is being
used. For a long time, manufacturing industries in European and American countries have
worked from the basis of a tolerance. This tends to suggests that the manufactured item
would be passed as acceptable if its quality was within the specified tolerance range.
Taguchi's response to quality differs rather greatly from the goalpost philosophy of the
European and American countries. The Japanese implementation of Taguchi's concept
sees them working on the principle that when designing a product, it should be designed
with minimum loss, with the relative product being designed as close to the optimum
value as is feasibly possible. This would result in the product being manufactured in
regards to its life cycle and customer satisfaction from the design stages. It would also
mean that less repair work would be required in the long run.
The Authors of the article would like to thank you for showing interest in this article. The
setup has been constructed for ease of navigation. It consists of a table of contents with
links to all sections. Each section at the bottom comprises of convenient links to navigate
between and within the relevant sections. In-text referencing is also implemented
extensively throught the article. To return to the home page of the article, please click on
the Taguchi Home Page icon.
From the quadratic loss function, the total loss increases parabolically as the deviation
from the target value increases. This loss represents a continuous function. This indicates
that by making a product within the specification limits, it does not necessary mean that
the product is of good quality, since good quality is now defined as keeping the product
characteristic on target with low variation. Taguchi emphasis on optimum customer
satisfaction is by developing products which meet the target value on a consistent basis.
Thus, the most important aspect of Taguchi's quality control philosophy is the
minimisation of variation around the target value.
Fig 5.1.0
From the figure, it can be seen that for a design specification of 115V, it would be
necessary to use a transistor with a gain of 20, which would cost approxiamateley 25
cents. The cost of the electronic component depends on the tolerance and the power
handling capability. The 25 cent transistor has a tolerance of 30% which will be
assumed to be three standard deviation away from the target value. Hence one standard
deviation is equivalent to 10% in tolerance.
In figure 5.1.0, it can also be seen that the variation in the gain, is transmitted to the
variation in the voltage. If a normal distribution of the gain is assumed , then a normal
distribution of voltage will be obtained. While it is centred around the target of 115V, it is
also possible to have a voltage as low as 109 and as high as 121V. If a higher tolerance
transistor is used then the tolerance would be reduced. However, this would mean a
higher cost in the overall product. To produce the true regulated power supply could then
cost up to four times the original design cost.
However, a more cost effective approach is to use the portion of the voltage Vs gain
curve that is less steep. In this way, the large variation in gain to the output voltage is not
transmited. This part of the curve is around the 40-HFE point. Even with the 30%
tolerance range, the variation in voltage around this point is 2 Volts. Hence, it is seen
that designing in the constant region of the relationship will reduce the variation.
The distributions for transistor A and transistor B are shown in the following diagram:
The losses for the two transistors can then be calculated as follows:
For transistor A:
EL = 0.444[ ( 115 -115) + 2 ]
EL = $1.78
For transistor B:
EL = 0.444[ (124 -115) + 0.33 ]
EL = $36.01
The loss for transistor B is excessive because it is 9 volts of the target. This loss can be
minimised by using a higher current limiting resistor which would shift the entire voltage
versus gain curve as follows:
Brainstorming
Orthogonal Arrays
Parameter Design
Brainstorming
The brainstorming stage is perhaps the most important stage of the whole Taguchi
procedure. At this stage, clear statements of the problems are established, the objectives,
the desired output characteristics, the methods of measurement and the appropriate
experiments are designed. Brainstorming is an activity which promotes group
participation, encourages creative thinking and generates many ideas in a short period of
time.
The experiment stage is where resulting data is examined and an interpretation of results
is conducted. The variability control factors are determined and the optimal values are
selected so that the variability of the product is minimised. The target control parameters
are also determined during this stage, and their settings are selected for a desired mean
response. Predictions are also made at this stage of the Taguchi procedure.
To confirm the predicted results, a confirmatory experiment is conducted. This is an
essential stage in order to confirm that the new parameter settings do provide optimal
performance. Confirmation removes any concerns of the incorrect choice of parameters,
experimental design or assumptions of product response. After which, corrective action
can then be followed. A study of the new system should take place and any improvements
require standardising. After successful improvements, the optimal settings will, from then
on, become a standard.
Orthogonal Arrays
A product can be designed and manufactured based on a set of specifications demanded
by the customer. Each specification has a required parameter value or values, which the
manufactured product must be able to satisfy. Thus, the manufacturing process must be
capable of producing the designed parameters, which is termed as the targeted value,
according to the customer's specifications. Unfortunately in reality, manufacturing
processes are far from ideal. Products manufactured tends to give a distribution that has a
mean value slightly different from the targeted value. Thus, one of the main technique
used in Taguchi's quality control is to reduce the variation around the targeted value.
According to Taguchi, the quality of a group of products can be improved by achieving
its end product specifications distribution as close to the target value as possible. This
concept can be realised by designing and building the quality into the product itself.
Hence, Taguchi employs design experiments using specially constructed table, known as
"Orthogonal Arrays (OA)" to treat the design process, such that the quality is build into
the product during the product design stage.
Discussions of the various aspects of Orthogonal Arrays(OA) can be found in the
following links:
The Approach of OA
Comparison to the Conventional Approach
OA Analysis
Application of OA
Advantages and Disadvantages of OA
different experimenters. Thus, two different investigators will have similar conclusion
and a standard design methodology.
The concept of standard design methodology and uniform results through OA analysis is
very important, since it allows the manufacturer to produce two products of the same
quality standards, using the same materials, but with differences in the manufacturing
process. This is possible since, through OA experimental analysis, the quality influencing
factors of a product can be identified, controlled, and hence compensated during the early
product design stage. Thus, the quality of the product itself, rather than depending on the
manufacturing process, is able to "adapt" to the manufacturing process.
Taguchi's OA is considered to be more superior than the traditional factorial design
method since :
The factorial design experiment is not efficient in handling large number of
factor variables.
Taguchi's OA experiments, on a product design yield similar and consistent
results, although the experiment can be carried out by different experimenters.
The OA table allows determination of the contribution, of each quality
influencing factor.
OA allows easy interpretation of experiments with a large number of factors.
quality influencing factor, produces the preferred result. Thus, the levels of influencing
factors , to produce the best results, can be predicted.
There are two different methodologies in carrying out the complete OA analysis. A
common approach is to analyse the average result of repetitive runs, or a single run,
through ANOVA analysis as discussed. Another approach, which is a better method for
multiple runs, is to use signal (S) to noise (N) ratio (S/N) for the same steps in the
analysis. The objective of S/N analysis, is to determine the most optimum set of the
operating conditions, from variations of the influencing factors within the results. The
signals, in this case, will be those factors which are invariant. The noise are those
influencing factors which are active. Details regarding the methods of OA results analysis
using ANOVA and signal-to-noise ratio can be referred to article [1].
Parameter Design
When a product is said to be optimum, it implies that the product has achieved most of
the target values set out by the quality measure. Taguchi tries to reduce the variation
around the target, not by eliminating the cause of variation, since totally removing the
cause of variation can be expensive in an industrial setting. The variation is reduced by
adjusting the levels of the influencing factors, and controlling the variation of other
factors, which is the approach of the parameter design technique.
To illustrate this concept, consider an example involving only one factor.
An electronic device which controls the luminance of a light bulb, was influenced
significantly by the applied voltage. The investigator, wishing to select the right voltage,
investigate the luminance of the light bulb at several input voltages. The influence of the
voltage variation on the luminance of the light bulb can be shown in the figure .
Conclusions
This article has investigated the Taguchi philosophy in quality control. And discussed the
difference between Taguchi's new concepts, in quality control, and the traditional
goalpost philosophy. It has shown that in Taguchi's view, the measurement of the quality
of a manufactured product, is the total loss generated by that product to the society.
Taguchi defines the quality control of a given product as "achieving the targeted value
and minimising the variability around the target value", instead of "achieving
conformance to the specification".
The Taguchi quality strategies discussed are derived from several experiment techniques
used in the product design stage to implement the quality concepts into the product.
Taguchi proposed the idea of brainstorming to define the processes and factors which
create the product, followed by a series of experimental implementation, outlined by
Taguchi's quality concepts, to determine the optimum parameters to be implemented in
the parameter design stage of the product.
Taguchi suggested the use of Orthogonal Arrays(OA), in the experiment implementation
stage, to investigate and predict noise factors which might affect the quality of a given
product during the product manufacturing phase. Through OA experiment analysis, the
quality influencing factors of a product can then be identified, controlled, and hence
compensated during early product design stage.
Glossary Terms
Total Loss Function
The loss function is a function of deviation from the ideal value of a given design
parameter.
Orthogonal Arrays
An important analysis tool in designing quality into the design process.
Parameter Design
The approach whereby the influential factors are adjusted to control the variation
of other factors.
REFERENCES.
[1] Howard Gitlow, Shelly Gitlow, Alan Oppenheim and Rosa Oppenheim.1989. "Tools And Methods
For The Improvement Of Quality". Von Hoffman Press, Inc. Boston.
[2] Claire G. Meisonheime. 1992 "Improving Quality : A Guide To Effective Programs". Aspen
Publishers, Inc. Gaitherburg. .
[3] A.V. Feigenbaum.1991 "Total Quality Control". 3rd edition. Mcgraw Hill, Inc. New York.
[4] Ranjit Roy. "A Primer On The Taguchi Method". Van Nostrand Reinhold. New York. 1990.
[5] Thomas B. Barker. 1990 "Engineering Quality By Design : Interpreting The Taguchi Approach".
Marcel Dekker, Inc. New York. .Figure 5.1.0(14), 5.1.1(16), 5.1.2(13)
[6] Genichi Taguchi.1988 "Introduction To Quality Engineering : Designing Quality Into Products And
Processes". Asian Productivity Organisation. Tokyo. .
[7] R. Kacker. 1986 "Taguchi's Quality Philosophy : Analysis And Commentary". Quality Progress.
December. PP 21-29.
[8] Kwok-Leung Tsui, 1988, "Strategies for Planning Experiments using Orthogonal Arrays and
Confounding Tables", Quality and Reliability Engineering International, Vol. 4. pp 113-122.
[9] K. Dehnad, 1989 "Quality Control, Robust Design, and the Taguchi method" , Wadsworth &
Brooks/Cole, California.
[10] 1988"Introduction to Taguchi methods", Engineering, Jan.
[11] G. Taguchi,1988, "Introduction to Quality Engineering: Designing Quality into Products and
Processes", Asian Productivity Organisation, Japan.
[12]T.B. Barker, 1990 "Engineering Quality by Design", Marcel Dekker, Inc. N.Y.
[13] R. Roy, 1990"A primer on the Taguchi Method", Van Nostrand Reinhold, N.Y.
[14] C.Maynard,1995 "Quality Engineering", Curtin University Handout Notes for Computer Aided
Engineering.
Authors
The Authors of this paper are all currently studying at Curtin University Of Technology
in Western Australia. We are Final Years Students doing the Information and
Communications Engineering Degree.
Article assembled and placed on web by
Katleen.F.Ritchie.
Research for article provided by
Yeow Nam Ng
Don Black
Khanh Luu
Latest Revision done by :
Hartono Tedjokusumo (2nd yr Computer Technology)