Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
c
u
n
la
-B
lt
ip
to
ll
(f
(f
(r
(f
(f
(f
(f
(f
(a
f)
(f
t)
(f
(f
,r
)(
th
rt
e
rd
ld
fo
ro
id
e
tw
s
ri
rn
n
(d
to
fi
p
h
(f
t)
(a
t)
/f
(f
(d
th
t)
(f
&
(a
in
to
re
rd
to
re
(a
(a
rd
&
to
(f
,s
t)
t)
t)
t)
(f
(f
,a
le
(a
ic
u
ro
ll
e
g
tr
ke
kh
tn
to
ke
lf
in
fo
ro
ro
rm
lp
rp
(a
ks
ra
(a
&
(a
th
IN
lp
)(
rt
1000
o
m
rd
IG
le
r-
ry
k-
te
in
ill
in
in
M
(F
ke
(Y
ile
to
tr
rp
lo
th
5000
4000
3000
2000
Current
If improved
600
400
200
0
A
B C D E F G H I J
FUNCTION, SYSTEM or EQUIPMENT
1. Individual intervention
optimisations
(cost/benefit/risk/timing)
3. Activity programme
optimisation
Acquire/create
(cost/benefit/risk/timings)
Operate
Maintain
Dispose/replace
2. Asset life cycle optimisation
(cost/performance/risk/lifespan)
a) Component/equipment level
b) System level
3500
TRUE
OPTIMUM
3000
2500
RISK
EXPOSURE
2000
1500
Balance point
but not optimal
1000
500
PREVENTIVE
ACTIONS
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Maintenance intervals
Inspection/monitoring intvls & alarm points
Safety testing & failure finding tasks
Shutdown & Outage programmes
Work opportunities & clustering
Conflicting Objectives
Problem Definition
Reliability
Efficiency
Direct costs (labour & materials)
Life Extension
Penalty costs (lost oppty, risk etc.) Compliance
Shine
COSTS
Systems-level strategies,
resourcing & What if? modeling
Periodictasks
tasks
Periodic
Periodic tasks
e.g. maintenance,
inspection, renewal
Current data
condition, performance
Customised
system/RAM
Simulation
Criticality/
size of the
decision
Quantified
cost/benefit/risk
Calculation
(appropriate
sophistication
& cost of
method)
Rules, templates
& decision trees
Simple,
structured
common sense
Yes/No
decisions
Options or
scenario
choices
Specific task
evaluation &
timing
optimisation
Multiple tasks
or systems
configuration/
optimisation
n/a
n/a
4
2
n/a
n/a
1
Levels of cost/risk
Patterns of cost/risk
The Woodhouse Partnership Ltd 2010
Premium for
compliance
Decision-support toolkit
Quantified risk
Problems
SPC, RAM
Prioritise
Filter
1. asdfasf
2. fwqerv
3. tasdf fwq
4. eadfre rwe
5. rwerwr
Known causes,
unknown solutions
What type
of solution?
Criticality
ranking
APT-PROJECT
Cost/risk evaluation
Impact ($$/yr)
Opportunities
Root Cause
Analysis e.g. PROACT
APOLLO
Cost/benefit/risk
evaluation
3500
3000
OPTIMUM
TOTAL
IMPACT
Optimal work
programming
RISK
2500
2000
1500
1000
PREVENTIVE
ACTIONS
500
1
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
APT-MAINTENANCE
APT-PROJECT
(design modifications)
APT-INSPECTION
(testing/monitoring tasks)
APT-SCHEDULE
(work/resource
bundling)
APT-LIFESPAN
(replacement timing)
The Woodhouse Partnership Ltd 2010
Education
Conflicting stakeholder expectations
Cross-functional teamwork mechanisms
Black box mentality
Short-termism & fire-fighting habits
Risk-based decision credibility
3.
4.
5.