Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
5. According to Jan Noel, what factors contributed to making the women of New
France remarkable?
Women of New France had more advantages compared to women at other
times and places, they were educated worked in many areas of society and
worked just the way their husbands did if not more
A lot less number of women compared to men- for every 8 marriageable man
there was one woman so more advantages
Considered more intelligent, generous, pretty
Women were in short supply in N.F. they were carefully selected and sent to
colonies to become wives (daughters of the king)
The courts favored the women over men, punishing them less severely than a
man who wouldve committed the same crime
Men were absent either off to war or fur trade so the wives contributed more
to society and managed the farms
They entered heavy trades like stone working and brick laying
No private or public split everything was public
They were crucial for the survival of the colony there had to be a man and
a woman
Having children was also important for the population and families were
given incentives for birth of a child
6. The nature of society of New France has been the subject of historical debate.
Discuss the three main depictions of the society of New France.
Feudal society it was not progressing they thought that change and
capitalism was good in development
Primarily shaped by conditions of north America they were improving to
become a developed society
Geography, climate, fur trade-alternate to agriculture, availability of landindependent land ownership, contact with first nations, had warfare
Distance from France, absence of sustained immigration from Old France
Low immigration rates and lowering of seigniorial dues
New France had seigniorial system, no military but still feudal
10. What accounts for the dominance of English Canadian merchants over French
Canadian merchants in Montreal after 1763, according to Jose Igartua?
The change for the French merchants happened too fast they were not able to
adjust/adapt quick enough
European merchants were good at what they did so when they came to New
France, also there were more European merchants compared to French
merchants they created new intense commercial competition
Military officials favored the British over the French
French suffered because of their conservative thinking, the animosity
between both nations and the new political climate (lobbying, petitioning
creates opportunities and Europeans possessed this quality and got changes
that suited them)
The old system the French were familiar with disappeared and a new system
was created
Indians did not acknowledge the price increase of beaver trade which
happened because of the risky shipping
11. Did the European fur traders cheat the aboriginal peoples in fur trade? What
factors must be considered in addressing such a question?
Some Europeans did cheat the aboriginals but most likely not
Aboriginals were accustomed to trade, they knew what they were doing and
they waited for other ships to arrive to ensure they received the best deals
They threatened Europeans that they will go to other posts and trade
elsewhere if they did not received what they wanted
They knew how to bargain with the Europeans and complained if they felt
like they were being cheated with quality of the material
They traded relatively inexpensive European goods for aboriginal goods (like
greasy beaver) which was rare in North America
Europeans also traded alcohol with aboriginals which was a popular trade
item since aboriginals could consume it right away and not need to carry it
around and pay fees for it
12. With the respect to the fur trade, we discussed 3 major questions about which
there has been a good deal of controversy. What are they? What factors need to
be considered with respect to these questions?
Exploitation in fur trade
Relatively inexpensive European trade goods for furs
Used beaver for everything like kettles, hatches, swords, knives,
bread
Native people did not always trade for economically helpful items
They did not understand why Europeans were greedy
13. What advantages and disadvantages lay in marriage to a European fur trader for
Indian women?
They sought relationships
Fur traders thought women enjoyed higher status in fur trader society
It provided them with an easier life regarding European goods their
husbands provided them with, less carrying, no fetching firewood or water
Since they were Indian women married to European men they used a
position of women in between to enhance their and their familys position
and status (daughters of mixed were also seen as desirable/ beneficial since
they were more European and had links to fur traders)
Disadvantages were that they usually had poorer health because of exposure
to European diseases that they were not immune to
Child birth becomes difficult since a female that is in poor health has a
harder chance of conceiving
They had reduced control/authority over upbringing of their children
Less freedom of action in marriage
They were victims of violence in the fur trade rivalry
14. According to Susan Sleeper-Smith, how did aboriginal women in the great lakes
area use Catholicism and kin networks to enhance the positions and life chances
of themselves and their families?
Created affective kin networks through marriages and baptism which they
also would marry daughters off to men to help them gain more business for
themselves and their families
Women served as godmothers and instructors guiding people to convert to
Catholicism
Jesuits favored the women because they were devotees whereas men did not
convert and if they did they were not good catholic men