Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
margarIta daz-andreu *
archeologIa preIstorIca nelleuropa occIdentale: Iph, Il cIpp e Il crpu (1910-1914) - Larticolo tratta delle origini
e dello sviluppo di tre istituzioni che hanno a che fare con la preistoria dellEuropa occidentale allinizio del ventesimo
secolo. Esse sono lIstituto parigino di Paleontologia umana (IPH), la Comisin de Investigaciones Paleontolgicas y
Prehistricas (CIPP) di Madrid e il Comitato Italiano per le ricerche di Paleontologia umana (CRPu). Lanalisi va al
di l dei ristretti conini dello Stato-nazione e giunge al risultato che lo sviluppo simultaneo di queste tre istituzioni pu
essere considerato un caso di transnazionalismo. Larticolo si occupa anche di globalizzazione e glocalizzazione
e di come questi due concetti possano illuminare la storia delle istituzioni archeologiche.
SuMMARY - transnatIonalIsm and archaeology. the connectIng orIgIns of the maIn InstItutIons dealIng wIth
western europe:the Iph, the cIpp and the crpu (1910-1914) - This article examines
the origins and development of three institutions which dealt with prehistory in Western Europe at the start of the
twentieth century. These three institutions the Parisian Institut de Palontologie Humaine (IPH), the Comisin de
Investigaciones Paleontolgicas y Prehistricas (CIPP) based in Madrid and the Italian Comitato per le ricerche di
Paleontologia umana (CRPu). The analysis undertaken goes beyond the narrow nation-state perspective, for it is
argued that the almost simultaneous establishment of these three institutions can be understood as an example of
transnationalism. The article also deals with globalization and glocalization and how these concepts can illuminate the
history of archaeological institutions.
prehIstorIc archaeology In
164
m. daz-andreu
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
165
166
m. daz-andreu
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
167
168
m. daz-andreu
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
169
Tab. I. Reports published by the CIPP. x= prehistoric art as main or secondary subject. (x) prehistoric art mentioned. P= palaeontology
1
2
1915
1914
1914
1914
1914
1915
1915
1915
9
10
1916
1916
11
1916
12
13
1916
1916
14
15
16
17
1917
1917
1917
1917
18
19
20
1918
1918
1918
21
1918
22
1919
23
1919
24
1919
25
26
27
1920
1919
1921
cabr, J
hernndez
pacheco, e.
cabr, J.
cabr,
J.hernndez
pacheco, e.
conde de la
vega del sella
hernndez
pacheco, e. dantn, J.
hernndez
pacheco, e. obermaIer, h.
bosch gImpera, p
schmIdt, h.
obermaIer, h.
hernndez
pacheco, e.
cabr, J. wernert, p.
wernert, p.
conde de la
vega del sella
cabr, J.
lantIer, r.
obermaIer, h.
hernndez
pacheco, e.
frankowskI, e.
motos, f. 1918
obermaIer, h.
- conde de la
vega del sella
pan, I.del
conde de la
vega del sella
obermaIer, h. wernert, p.
hernndez
pacheco, e.
frankowskI, e
obermaIer, h.
correIa, v
(x)
oltIco
(x)
x
(x)
(x)
( x)
170
m. daz-andreu
28
1921
29
1921
30
1922
31
1923
32
1923
33
34
1923
1924
35
36
1927
1929
hernndez
la llanura manchega y sus mamferos fsIles. yacImIento de la puepacheco, e.
bla de almoradIer
conde de la
el paleoltIco de cueva morn (santander)
vega del sella
royo gmez, J. el mIoceno contInental IbrIco y su fauna malacolgIca
hernndez
pacheco, e.
conde de la
vega del sella
roman, f.
hernndez
pacheco, e.
vega del sella
gomz llueca,
f.
umana (Italy,
1913)
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
171
172
m. daz-andreu
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
173
174
m. daz-andreu
references
alexandrowIcz, s.w. 2006. The Polish initiative in creation
of the International union for Quaternary Research
(InQuA). In M. KoKoWSKI (ed.). The Global and
the Local:- The History of Science and the Cultural
Integration of Europe. Proceedings of the 2nd ICESHS
Conference, Cracow September 6-9 2006: 194-197,
on-line publication (http://www.2iceshs.cyfronet.pl/
proceedings.html)
ameghIno, f. 1911. observations au sujet des notes du
Dr.Mochi sur la paloanthropologie argentine. Anales
del Museo Nacional de Buenos Aires 22:181-230.
anon. 1954. Sucinta biografa del Profesor Eduardo
Hernndez-Pacheco. Boletn de la Real Sociedad
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
175
176
m. daz-andreu
CNRS 8:http://histoire-cnrs.revues.org/document550.
html?format=print.
. 2005. La decouverte de lhomme fossile de la Chapelleaux-Saints (1908). Practiques de Terraine, debats et
representations des neandertaliens. Organon (Institute
for the History of Science of the Polish Academy of
Sciences) 34:97-118.
. 2011. Labb Breuil. Un prhistorien dans le sicle.
Paris: CnRS ditions.
InIzan, c. 2011. Linstitut ocanographique de Paris. In Situ
17:digital.
Jae. JAE. Memorias.
kIng, d. e. 2006. Transnationalism. In H. J. BIRX (ed.).
Encyclopedia of Anthropology: 2220-1, London: Sage.
kohl, p. l., and c. fawcett. eds., 1995. Nationalism,
Politics, and the Practice of Archaeology. Cambridge:
Cambridge university Press.
lanzarote guIral, J. m. 2011. La stratigraphie dune vide
consacre la prhistoire. Hugo obermaier, sa chaire
et les fouilles du Castillo. In H. de LuMLEY and A.
HuREL (eds.), Cents ans de Prhistoire. LInstitut de
Palontologie Humaine: 65-82, Paris: CnRS ditions.
lumley, h. de 2011. Les collections scientiiques de
lInstitut de palontologie humaine. In H. de LuMLEY
and A. HuREL (eds.), Cents ans de Prhistoire.
LInstitut de Palontologie Humaine: 121-125, Paris:
CnRS ditions.
madarIaga de la campa, b. 1996. Hugo obermaier en
el contexto de la Prehistoria cntabra: una valoracin
de Altamira. In A. Moure Romanillo (ed.). El
hombre fsil 80 aos despus: 51-78, Santander:
universidad de Cantabria, Fundacin Marcelino
Botn, Institute for Prehistoric Investigations.
mantegazza, p., and e. regalIa. 1886. Studio sopra una
serie di crani di Fuegini. Archivio per lAnrropologia e
la Etnologia XVI:463-51.
mapm. 2013. un muse, une histoire [Muse
dAnthropologie prhistorique de Monaco. Fond par
le Prince Albert Ier]. http://www.monaco-sciences.com/
index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=89
&Itemid=109
mrquez ura, c. 1996. obermaier y el Conde de
la Vega del Sella. El paradigma cientico. In a.
moure romanIllo (ed.). El hombre fsil 80
aos despus: 79-98, Santander: universidad de
Cantabria, Fundacin Marcelino Botn, Institute for
Prehistoric Investigations.
. 1988. El Conde de la Vega del Sella (1870-1941) y
la Comisin de Investigaciones Paleontolgicas y
Prehistricas. In J. M. Snchez Ron (ed.). 1907-1987.
La Junta para Ampliacin de Estudios e Investigaciones
Cienticas ochenta aos despus II: 485-500, Madrid:
Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cienticas.
meskell, l. ed. 1998. Archaeology under ire. Nationalism,
politics and heritage in the Eastern Mediterranean and
Middle East. London: Routledge.
mochI, a. 1910. Appunti sulla Paleoantropologia argentina.
Archivio per lAntropologia e la Etnologia 40:203-254.
mochI, a., and l. cardInI. 1928. Atti della I Riunione
dellIstituto Italiano di Paleontologia umana, 21-24
Transnationalism and archaeology. The connecting origins of the main institutions dealing
with prehistoric archaeology in Western Europe:the IPH, the CIPP and the CRPU (1910-1914)
12
177
178
m. daz-andreu