3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036

General Docket
US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Digitally signed by
Joseph H Zernik
Second Circuit Court of DN: cn=Joseph H
Appeals Zernik, o, ou,
email=jz12345@ear
thlink.net, c=US
Location: La Verne,
INDIV California
Date: 2010.03.23
21:30:44 -07'00'

CLOSED

Court of Appeals Docket #: 03-7036-cv

Nsuit : 3440 CIVIL RIGHTS-Other

Huminski v. Haverkoch, et al Filed 1/14/03

Appeal DISTRICT OF VERMONT (BRATTLEBORO)

from:

Case type information:

Civil

Private

None

Lower court information:

District: 00-cv-55

Trial Judge:

MagJudge:

Date Filed: 02/15/00

Date order/judgement: 12/2/2002

Date NOA filed: 12/30/2002

Fee status: Paid

Panel Assignment:

Panel: RJC JAC SS 40 Foley Sq.

Date of decision: 11/5/04

Prior cases: NONE

Current cases NONE

Official Caption 1/
​ INDIV

CLOSED

------------------

Docket No. [s] : 03-7036

SCOTT HUMINSKI,

Plaintiff-Appellant,

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 1/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036

v.

TOWN OF BENNINGTON, VERMONT, RICHARD GUATHIER, STUART

HURD,
BENNINGTON POLICE DEPARTMENT, VANESSA HAVERKOCH, as a

Representative, executor, administrator, or holder of

assets
of or for Henry Haverkoch or for the Estate of Henry

Haverkoch, HENRY HAVERKOCH (deceased),

Defendant-Appellees.

------------------

Authorized Abbreviated Caption 2/

------------------

Docket No. [s] : 03-7036

HUMINSKI V. HAVERKOCH

------------------

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 2

​ INDIV

CLOSED

-------------------------------------------

1/ Fed. R. App. P. Rule 12 [a] and 32 [a].

2/ For use on correspondence and motions only.

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 3

​ INDIV

CLOSED

Scott Huminski Alan Uris Esq.

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 2/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036
Plaintiff-Appellant [ LD n ]
Law Office of Alan Uris

13-29 Michael Pl.

Bayside , NY , 11360

Henry Haverkoch Gordon P. Black Esq.

Defendant-Appellee [ ret ]
Donovan & OConnor

116 So. St. P.O. Box 1033

Bennington , VT , 05201

802-442-3233

Vanessa Haverkoch Gordon P. Black Esq.(See above)

Defendant-Appellee [ ret ]

Bennington Police James F. Carroll Esq.

Defendant-Appellee [ ret ]
English Carroll & Ritter P.C.

64 Court St.
Middlebury , VT , 05753

802-388-6711

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 4

​ INDIV

CLOSED

Richard Guathier James F. Carroll Esq.(See above)

Defendant-Appellee [ ret ]

Stuart Hurd James F. Carroll Esq.(See above)

Defendant-Appellee [ ret ]

Town of Bennington James F. Carroll Esq.(See above)

Defendant-Appellee [ ret ]

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 5

​ INDIV

CLOSED

1/14/03 Copy of notice of appeal and district court

docket entries on behalf of Appellant Scott
Huminski filed. [03-7036] [Entry date Jan
22 2003 ] [DT]

1/14/03 Note: This appeal was PRO SE when filed.

[Entry date Jan 22 2003 ] [DT]

1/14/03 Copy of receipt re: payment of docketing fee

filed on behalf of Appellant Scott Huminski
receipt #: 18829. [03-7036] [Entry date
Jan 22 2003 ] [DT]

1/14/03 Copy of district court judgment dated

December 2, 2002, endorsed by Deputy Clerk,
RECEIVED. [03-7036] [Entry date Jan 22
2003 ] [DT]

1/14/03 NOTE: See: 02-6150, 02-6199, 02-6201

[Entry date Jan 22 2003 ] [DT]

1/14/03 Record on appeal filed. (Original papers of

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 3/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036
district court.) Number of volumes: 2
[Entry date Jan 22 2003 ] [DT]

1/22/03 Record on appeal received in records room

from team. (2 volumes). [Entry date Jan
22 2003 ] [DT]

4/15/03 Scheduling order #1 filed. Appellant's brief

and appendix due on 5/15/03. Appellee's
brief due on 6/16/03,, . Argument as early
as week of 7/28/03. [Entry date Apr 15
2003 ] [DT]

4/15/03 Notice to counsel/pro se re: Scheduling

order dated April 15, 2003 issued. [Entry
date Apr 15 2003 ] [DT]

5/6/03 Appellant Scott Huminski appendix/addendum

received. Problem: no briefs [Entry date
May 8 2003 ] [DT]

5/13/03 Appellant Scott Huminski brief FILED with

proof of service. [Entry date May 14 2003
] [DT]

5/13/03 Appellant Scott Huminski appendix filed

w/pfs. Number of volumes; 10. [Entry date
May 14 2003 ] [DT]

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 6

​ INDIV

CLOSED

5/23/03 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to extend

time to file reply briefs, ten additional
days, FILED (w/pfs). [2344351-1] [Entry
date May 27 2003 ] [DT]

6/3/03 Notice to counsel/pro se re: Motion Order

dated June 2, 2003 granting an extension of
time to file reply briefs. [Entry date
Jun 3 2003 ] [DT]

6/3/03 Order FILED GRANTING motion for extended

time [2344351-1] by Appellant Scott Huminski,
endorsed on motion form dated 5/23/03.
Extended appellant's reply brief due on
6/12/03. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT the
motion is GRANTED. Endorsed For the Court by
CJM, Sup. Staff Attorney. [Entry date Jun
2 2003 ] [DT]

6/18/03 Notice of appearance form on behalf of James

F. Carroll, Esq., filed. (Orig in acco, copy
to Calendar) [Entry date Jun 19 2003 ]
[DT]

6/18/03 Appellee Town of Bennington, Appellee

Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart Hurd,
Appellee Bennington Police, Appellee Vanessa
Haverkoch, Appellee Henry Haverkoch brief
filed withproof of service. [Entry date
Jul 7 2003 ] [DT]

6/18/03 Appellee Town of Bennington, Appellee

Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart Hurd,
Appellee Bennington Police, Appellee Vanessa
Haverkoch, Appellee Henry Haverkoch appendix
or addendum filed. [Entry date Jul 7
2003 ] [DT]

6/18/03 Appellee Town of Bennington, Richard

Guathier, Stuart Hurd, Bennington Police,
Vanessa Haverkoch, Henry Haverkoch motion to

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 4/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036
file brief using 12-point type instead of
the 14-point type specified, FILED (w/pfs).
[2363499-1] [Entry date Jun 19 2003 ]
[DT]

7/2/03 Appellant Scott Huminski reply brief filed

with proof of service. Satisfy appellant's
reply brief due. [Entry date Jul 10 2003
] [DT]

7/2/03 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to allow

change of oral argument date to the same
date as companion cases 02-6150, 02-6199,
02-6201, FILED (w/pfs). [2378796-1]
[Entry date Jul 10 2003 ] [DT]

7/7/03 Notice to counsel dated 7/07/03 [Entry

date Jul 7 2003 ] [DT]

7/7/03 Appellee Town of Bennington, Richard

Guathier, Stuart Hurd, Bennington Police,
Vanessa Haverkoch, Henry Haverkoch brief

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 7

​ INDIV

CLOSED

RECEIVED. Problem: 12 point typeface,

awaiting disposition on pending motion.
[Entry date Jun 19 2003 ] [DT]

7/7/03 Appellee Town of Bennington, Richard

Guathier, Stuart Hurd, Bennington Police,
Vanessa Haverkoch, Henry Haverkoch appendix
or addendum received. Problem: 12 point
typeface onthe brief, awaiting disposition
on pending motion. [Entry date Jun 19
2003 ] [DT]

7/7/03 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to

consolidate with docket numbers: 02-6201,
02-6150, 02-6199 FILED (w/pfs). [2379032-1]
[Entry date Jul 10 2003 ] [DT]

7/7/03 Order FILED GRANTING motion to file brief

[2363499-1] by Appellee Town of Bennington,
Richard Guathier, Stuart Hurd, Bennington
Police, Vanessa Haverkoch, Henry Haverkoch,
endorsed on motion form dated 6/18/03. (CJM)
[Entry date Jul 7 2003 ] [DT]

7/17/03 Appellee Town of Bennington, Appellee

Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart Hurd,
Appellee Bennington Police, Appellee Vanessa
Haverkoch, Appellee Henry Haverkoch
affidavit filed (w/pfs). (Defendants'
memorandum in opposition to motion to
consolidate). [Entry date Jul 18 2003 ]
[DT]

7/18/03 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to withdraw

motion to consolidate FILED (w/pfs).
[2388150-1] [Entry date Jul 22 2003 ]
[DT]

8/26/03 Notice to counsel (order dated 8-22-03)

[Entry date Aug 26 2003 ] [DT]

8/26/03 Order FILED GRANTING motion to withdraw the

motion to withdraw motion to consolidate
appeals [2388150-1] MOOTING motion to
consolidate appeals [2379032-1] by Appellant
Scott Huminski, (ec) [Entry date Aug 22
2003 ] [DT]

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 5/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036

11/24/03 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to withdraw

the motion to change oral arguments
scheduling dated June 30, 2003 and that the
argument in the instant matter of 02-6201,
be held on the same day, FILED (w/pfs).
[2486730-1] [Entry date Nov 25 2003 ]
[DT]

12/5/03 Notice to counsel/pro se re: Motion order

dated December 2, 2003. [Entry date Dec
5 2003 ] [DT]

12/5/03 Letter dated December 3, 2003, from James F.

Carroll, Esq. informing the court of his
unavailability February 2-6, 2004, received.

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 8

​ INDIV

CLOSED

Copy sent to Calendar. [Entry date Dec 10

2003 ] [DT]

12/5/03 Order FILED GRANTING motion to withdraw oral

argument [2486730-1] by Appellant Scott
Huminski, endorsed on motion form dated
11/24/03. Endorsed For the Court by CJM, Sup.
Staff Attorney. [Entry date Dec 2 2003
] [DT]

12/9/03 Letter from appelant Scott Huminski,

informing the court of his change of addres,
received. Case Manager made the change.
[Entry date Dec 10 2003 ] [DT]

2/18/04 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to expedite

oral argument, filed with proof of service.
[Entry date Feb 19 2004 ] [DH]

3/2/04 Appellee Town of Bennington, Appellee

Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart Hurd, et
al motion to allow appeal to be decided
without oral argument, filed with proof of
service. [Entry date Mar 11 2004 ] [DH]

3/2/04 Appellees papers in opposition to motion to

expedite oral argument filed with proof
of service. [Entry date Mar 3 2004 ]
[DH]

3/3/04 Papers (Notice of attorney/prosecutorial

misconduct) from APPELLANT Scott
Huminski, filed. [Entry date Mar 5 2004
] [DH]

3/4/04 Order FILED DENYING motion to expedite

appeal by Appellant Scott Huminski,
Appellee Town of Bennington, Appellee
Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart Hurd,
Appellee Bennington Police, endorsed on
motion dated. Denied. Oral argument will
be set in the ordinary course. Endorsed For
the Court by CJM, Sup. Staff Attorney.
[Entry date Mar 5 2004 ] [DH]

3/5/04 Notice to counsel/pro se re: Motion order

dated March 4, 2004. [Entry date Mar 5
2004 ] [DH]

3/8/04 in opposition to motion to allow appeal to

be decided w/o oral argument,filed with
proof of service. [Entry date Mar 11 2004
] [DH]

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 6/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036

3/29/04 Order FILED DENYING motion to allow a

decision of appeal on briefs without oral
argument, by Appellee Town of Bennington,
Appellee Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart
Hurd, Appellee Bennington Police, endorsed
on motion dated 3/2/2004. Endorsed for the
Court by CJM, Motions Staff Attorney.
[Entry date Mar 31 2004 ] [DH]

3/31/04 Notice to counsel/pro se re: Motion order

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 9

​ INDIV

CLOSED

dated March 29, 2004. [Entry date Mar 31

2004 ] [DH]

5/5/04 Proposed for argument the week of July 12,

2004, B Panel. [Entry date May 5 2004 ]
[AG]

5/26/04 Set for argument on July 13, 2004, B Panel.

[Entry date May 26 2004 ] [AG]

6/4/04 Order FILED MOOTING motion allow Change of

oral argument schedule by endorsed on
motion dated 3/2/2004. Endorsed for the
Court by CJM, Sup. Staff Attorney. [Entry
date Jun 8 2004 ] [DH]

6/8/04 Notice to counsel/pro se re: Motion order

dated June 4, 2004. [Entry date Jun 8
2004 ] [DH]

6/16/04 Letter dated Jume 8, 2004 from appellant

stating he will no longer be pro se and has
an attorney that will be representing him in
his behalf, received. [Entry date Jun 16
2004 ] [DH]

6/16/04 Pro se motion for continuance of oral

argument sent to attorney. [Entry date Jun
18 2004 ] [AM]

6/16/04 Pro se motion for continuance of oral

argument received. [Entry date Jun 18 2004
] [AM]

6/16/04 Appellant Scott Huminski motion to allow a

continuance of oral argument filed with
proof of service. [Entry date Jun 22 2004
] [DH]

6/28/04 Order FILED GRANTING motion allow by

Appellant Scott Huminski, endorsed on
motion dated 6/16/2004 [Entry date Jun 29
2004 ] [JC]

6/29/04 Notice to counsel in re: order dated

6/28/04. [Entry date Jun 29 2004 ] [JC]

6/29/04 Appellee Town of Bennington, Appellee

Richard Guathier, Appellee Stuart Hurd et
al memorandun in opposition to motion allow
filed with proof of service. [Entry date
Jul 7 2004 ] [EA]

6/30/04 **ORIGIANL**Argument as early as week of

2003 [Entry date Jun 30 2004 ] [JC]

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 10

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 7/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036
​ INDIV

CLOSED

6/30/04 Notice of appearance form on behalf of Alan

Uris , Esq., filed. (Orig in acco, copy to
Calendar) [Entry date Jul 2 2004 ] [EA]

8/19/04 Proposed for argument the week of 11/01/04

[Entry date Aug 19 2004 ] [CA]

9/8/04 Set for argument on 11/2/04. [Entry date

Sep 8 2004 ] [AV]

11/2/04 Case heard before CARDAMONE, CABRANES,

SOTOMAYOR, C.JJ
CD DATE: 11/02/04 [Entry date Nov 2 2004
] [RD]

11/5/04 Judgment filed; judgment of the district

court is Affirmed by detailed order of the
court without opinion filed. (JAC)
[Entry date Nov 5 2004 ] [EA]

11/5/04 Notice to counsel in re: Summary Order filed.

[Entry date Nov 5 2004 ] [EA]

11/15/04 APPELLANT Scott Huminski, petition for

rehearing(10 copies),
petition for rehearing en banc(25 copies)
received.
Problem: Pending motions to file. [Entry
date Dec 3 2004 ] [EA]

11/29/04 Appellant Scott Huminski motion allow (the

filing of both the panel rehearing and en
banc rehearing)filed with proof of service.
[Entry date Dec 3 2004 ] [EA]

11/29/04 Appellant Scott Huminski motion supplement

record on appeal filed with proof of service.
[Entry date Dec 3 2004 ] [EA]

12/7/04 Appellant Scott Huminski Petition for

rehearing filed with proof of service.
[Entry date Dec 14 2004 ] [EA]

12/7/04 Appellant Scott Huminski petition for

rehearing en banc filed with proof of
service. [Entry date Dec 14 2004 ] [EA]

12/7/04 Order FILED GRANTING motion supplement

record on appeal by Appellant Scott
Huminski, endorsed on motion dated
11/29/2004.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that appellant`s motion
to supplement the record with an article or,
alternatively, to strike the article from
rehearing petition is GRANTED without

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 11

​ INDIV

CLOSED

intimating any view of the significance vel

non of this article. Before: RJC, JAC, SS, C.
JJ.(TWY) [Entry date Dec 14 2004 ] [EA]

12/7/04 Order FILED GRANTING motion allow by

Appellant Scott Huminski, endorsed on
motion dated 11/29/2004.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that appellant`s motion
to allow the filing of both a petition for
rehearing and a petition for rehearing en

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 8/9
3/23/2010 USCA2 Docket Sheet for 03-7036
banc be and it hereby is GRANTED. Before:
RJC, JAC, SS, C.JJ.(TWY) [Entry date Dec
14 2004 ] [EA]

12/14/04 Notice to counsel in re: Granted motion to

file two petitions, and granted motion to
supplement. [Entry date Dec 14 2004 ]
[EA]

2/28/05 Order FILED DENYING motion petition for

rehearing en banc by Appellant Scott
Huminski, endorsed on motion dated 12/7/2004.
(TWY) [Entry date Mar 1 2005 ] [EA]

2/28/05 Order FILED DENYING motion Petition for

rehearing by Appellant Scott Huminski,
endorsed on motion dated 12/7/2004.(TWY)
[Entry date Mar 1 2005 ] [EA]

3/1/05 Notice to counsel in re: Denied petition for

rehearing, and petition for rehearing in
banc. [Entry date Mar 1 2005 ] [EA]

3/8/05 Judgment MANDATE ISSUED. CLOSED [Entry

date Mar 8 2005 ] [EA]

3/28/05 Acco received in records room from team.

Number of volumes:1 [Entry date Mar 28
2005 ] [AJ]

3/29/06 Record on appeal RETURNED to lower court.

(1 vol.)
Vermont [Entry date Mar 29 2006 ] [FN]

6/9/09 Letter received from Scott Huminski

requesting CD of the oral argument. Fee
Paid, Forwarded to Calendar Team. Receipt #
199384. [Entry date Jun 9 2009 ] [SH]

7/21/09 Oral argument CD mailed to Scott Huminski.

[Entry date Jul 21 2009 ] [AG]

Docket as of July 22, 2009 1:31 am Page 12

PACER Service Center

Transaction Receipt
03/23/2010 18:49:03
PACER Login: dr2600 Client Code:
Description: dkt report Case Number: 03-7036
Billable Pages: 11 Cost: 0.88

pacer.ca2.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/dktrpt.pl… 9/9