Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
SOCIETY
FOR
PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA
SECTION EDITOR
PETER J. DAVIS
MD,
Departments of Anesthesiology and Pediatrics, Medical College of Wisconsin, Childrens Hospital of Wisconsin; National
Outcomes Center, Childrens Hospital and Health System; Jane B. Pettit Pain and Palliative Care Center, Childrens
Hospital of Wisconsin; Department of Nursing, Childrens Hospital of Wisconsin; Department of Pharmacy, Childrens
Hospital of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Critically ill children are treated with opioid medication in an attempt to decrease stress and alleviate pain
during prolonged pediatric intensive care. This treatment plan places children at risk for opioid dependency. Once dependent, children need to be weaned or
risk development of a withdrawal syndrome on abrupt
cessation of medication. We enrolled opioid-dependent
children into a prospective, randomized trial of 5- versus 10-day opioid weaning using oral methadone. Children exposed to opioids for an average of 3 wk showed
no difference in the number of agitation events requiring opioid rescue (3 consecutive neonatal abstinence
scores 8 every 2 h) in either wean group. Most of the
events requiring rescue occurred on day 5 and 6 of the
wean in both treatment groups. Patients may be able to
be weaned successfully in 5 days once converted to oral
methadone, with a follow-up period after medication
wean to observe for a delayed withdrawal syndrome.
(Anesth Analg 2006;102:104550)
cumulative dose exposure of 2.5 mg/kg or time exposure of 9 days. A variety of clinical scoring tools have
been used to follow the course of withdrawal. The
Neonatal Abstinence Score (NAS) (Table 1), described
by Finnegan et al. (3), ranks symptoms in neonates
exposed to intra-uterine opiates and has subsequently
been adopted through publication as a measure of
withdrawal in opioid-exposed infants requiring extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) (4) and in
older children (2,5).
Pediatric opioid dependence and subsequent withdrawal symptoms have been reported with a 48-h wean
(2), whereas none were reported in a 6-wk outpatient
wean (5). A 2- to 4-wk wean protocol has been favored in
a review article (6). However, a retrospective case series
showed successful weaning from opioids over 10 days in
23 of 26 pediatric patients who had an exposure of 14.5
9.2 days (7). Robertson et al. (8) used a strategy for
children designed to limit the duration of weaning based
on time of medication exposure. Patients with 714 days
of exposure were weaned over a 5-day period and patients with 14 days of exposure were weaned over a
10-day period. Eighty percent of these opioid-dependent
patients weaned successfully with minimal withdrawal
symptoms regardless of the wean duration.
Anesth Analg 2006;102:104550
1045
1046
PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA
BERENS ET AL.
OPIOID WEANING IN OPIOID-DEPENDENT CHILDREN
Score
2
3
3
2
1
2
3
1
2
3
4
2
1
1
5
ANESTH ANALG
2006;102:104550
Sign/
Symptom
Score
Sweating
Fever
37.2C38.4C
38.4C
Mottling
Nasal Stuffiness
Sneezing
Nasal flaring
Respiratory rate
60
60 (retractions)
Excessive sucking
Poor feeding
Regurgitation
Projectile vomiting
Stools
Loose
Watery
1
1
2
1
1
1
2
1
2
1
2
2
3
2
3
For all signs and symptoms, other causes must be eliminated. Score 0 7
indicates mild withdrawal, 8 11 indicates moderate withdrawal, and 1215
indicates severe withdrawal.
Methods
This study was an IRB-approved, prospective, randomized, double-blind comparison of 5-day versus
10-day enteral methadone wean in opioid-dependent
patients. The inclusion criteria were 18 yr of age and
exposed to at least 120 h of continuous IV opioid
infusion. Exclusion criteria were neonates 36 wk
gestation, lack of attending physician consent, patient
diagnosis of acute central nervous system injury (hypoxic ischemic injury, traumatic brain injury, postoperative craniotomies), the presence of an orotracheal,
nasotracheal or tracheostomy tube, or the inability to
transition to morphine or methadone based on present
or past difficulties with either drug. Medication weaning was initiated at the discretion of the attending
physician. Standard demographic data, a full psychoactive medication profile (as determined by the medication administration record), NAS (Table 1), and
modified Ramsey sedation scores (Table 2) (9) were
collected on each patient. These 2 scoring systems
were selected because they are the standard scoring
tools used at our facility. Informed consent was obtained from each patients parent or legal guardian by
one of the investigators.
Patients were enrolled into the study either while
receiving a continuous opioid infusion (preemptive
enrollment) or with an increase of NAS after cessation
Activity
Score
1
2
3
4
5
6
ANESTH ANALG
2006;102:104550
PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA
BERENS ET AL.
OPIOID WEANING IN OPIOID-DEPENDENT CHILDREN
1047
Table 3. Demographics, Pre-enrollment Variables and Severity Indices: 5- versus 10-Day Wean Groups
Variable
Age (mo)
Gender
Race
9.45 16.69
10 boys, 6 girls
10 white
2 native American
1 Hispanic
3 African-American
8 CHD
5 HLHS, 1 Fontan,
1 TAPVR, 1 VSD
4 Respiratory failure
1 ENT
3 trauma
9.80 26.17
15 boys, 6 girls
17 white
1 native American
1 African-American
1 other
7 CHD
5 HLHS, 1 critical AS
1 TGA
7 Respiratory failure
3 ENT Surgery
3 PHN
2 ECMO
1 Shock
337.83 272.76
183.31 337.86
13.05 6.52
19.14 15.11
36.95 25.75
Admitting Diagnosis
268.53 144.01
140.10 173.90
9.63 4.70
20.81 16.84
36 20.36
Values are mean sd. P not significant. CHD congenital heart disease; TAPVR total anomalous pulmonary venous return; HLHS hypoplastic left
heart syndrome; VSD ventricular septal defect; ENT ear, nose and throat; AS aortic stenosis; TGA transposition great arteries; PHN pulmonary
hypertension; ECMO extracorporeal membrane oxygenation; PRISM pediatric risk of mortality.
study drug was finished. Scoring frequency was increased to every 2 h if the NAS increased to 8 on any
occasion. If the NAS remained 8 for 3 scores, 2 h apart,
the child was assessed by one of the investigators.
In our unit, many children are treated continuously
with both opioids and lorazepam; these were allowed
to participate in the study. Lorazepam was weaned if
the child was continuously exposed for 5 days at the
time of transitioning from morphine to methadone.
Continuous exposure was defined as a dosing regimen designed to administer the medication in a
shorter interval than the elimination half-life of the
administered medication. For exposures 10 days,
lorazepam was weaned over the same number of days
of continuous exposure. If lorazepam exposure was
10 days, patients were weaned from lorazepam over
20 days.
Patients with an increased NAS were assessed for
other causes of agitation (pain, infection, other medication administration) and treated accordingly before
attributing symptoms to opioid withdrawal. On the
basis of prior studies (2,3,5,7,10), the presence of a
NAS of 8 for 3 consecutive scores performed 2 h
apart would allow for routine variation of behavior
initially and limit the duration of abnormality if withdrawal was the diagnosis of exclusion. Patients who
had 3 consecutive NAS scores of 8 at 2-h intervals
during their weaning period were placed in the rescue
arm of the study.
Children who met rescue criteria were initially
given an additional dose of the study medication
equal to the dose administered the day before the
rescue event. Children were reassessed in 1 h. If comfortable (NAS 8 and sedation score 4) the child
Results
During the study period, May 2001 to December 2003,
there were 52 patients eligible for enrollment. Of these,
8 were not enrolled because of attending physician
discretion, lack of parental consent, or initiation of
methadone wean before the decision regarding enrollment. One patient agreed to participate if rescue
therapy was deemed necessary but did not develop
symptoms of opioid withdrawal syndrome and, consequently, required no methadone therapy. Six patients were enrolled and then withdrew from the
study after initiation of methadone therapy. Of these,
3 patients required reinitiation of opioid infusions for
changes in their clinical status, 2 patients were removed from the study at the parents request, and 1
patient was removed from the study when diagnosed
with a chromosomal abnormality of unknown neurologic impact.
Thirty-seven patients were enrolled, randomized
and completed the protocol. Of these, 16 were randomized to the 5-day wean and 21 to the 10-day wean
1048
PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA
BERENS ET AL.
OPIOID WEANING IN OPIOID-DEPENDENT CHILDREN
ANESTH ANALG
2006;102:104550
Table 4. Magnitude of Medication Exposures, Dosages, Effects on Neonatal Abstinence Score (NAS) and Need for Rescue
Variable
5 Day (n 16)
10 Day (n 21)
1415.7 780.1
11.38 5.25
4.53 .58
235 24
5.37 2.11
3
2210.6 1728.9
15.54 10.74
4.05 .42
277 38
4.98 2.94
4
Discussion
We found that opioid-tolerant patients were weaned
with oral methadone as effectively in 5 days as in 10
days. The pediatric literature regarding iatrogenic opioid withdrawal syndrome mainly comprises individual case reports, case series, and retrospective chart
reviews of accepted clinical practices. This is the first
prospectively randomized, double-blind study to
ANESTH ANALG
2006;102:104550
PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA
BERENS ET AL.
OPIOID WEANING IN OPIOID-DEPENDENT CHILDREN
1049
Table 5. Description of Lorazepam Exposure, Number of Patients and Duration of Exposure to Both Methadone and
Lorazepam Weans and Number of Rescue Events
Variable
5-day wean
10-day wean
7
3.57 2.39
9.57 5.9
6.7 3.9
5
3
0
10
4.25 4.89
14.4 12.5
7 3.4
6
5
1
Figure 1. Mean neonatal abstinence score (NAS) per wean day (11,
15).
the limitations in using this tool is that one-time increased scores may reflect withdrawal but also could
be a marker for other etiologies of agitation. Unremitting agitation at a level 8 for 3 scores, 2 hours apart,
was previously used as a reasonable marker for withdrawal (3).
Figure 1 demonstrates mean NAS scores as well as
the number of events treated as withdrawal episodes.
The line chart shows the mean NAS per wean day of
1050
PEDIATRIC ANESTHESIA
BERENS ET AL.
OPIOID WEANING IN OPIOID-DEPENDENT CHILDREN
References
1. Arnold J, Truog R, Scavone J, Fenton T. Changes in the pharmacodynamic response to fentanyl in neonates during continuous infusion. J Pediatr 1991;119:63943.
2. Katz R, Kelly H, Hsi A. Prospective study on the occurrence of
withdrawal in critically ill children who receive fentanyl by
continuous infusion. Crit Care Med 1994;22:7637.
3. Finnegan L, Kron R, Connaughton J, Emich J. Neonatal abstinence syndrome: assessment and management. Addict Dis
1975;2:14158.
4. Arnold J, Truog R, Orav E, et al. Tolerance and dependence in
neonates sedated with fentanyl during extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. Anesthesiology 1990;73:113640.
ANESTH ANALG
2006;102:104550