Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
AbstractProbabilistic seismic hazard analysis (PSHA) has been carried out for Iraq. The earthquake
catalogue used in the present study covers an area between latitude 2938.5 N and longitude 3950 E
containing more than a thousand events for the period 19052000. The entire Iraq region has been divided
into thirteen seismogenic sources based on their seismic characteristics, geological setting and tectonic
framework. The completeness of the seismicity catalogue has been checked using the method proposed by
STEPP (1972). The analysis of completeness shows that the earthquake catalogue is not complete below
Ms 4.8 for all of Iraq and seismic source zones S1, S4, S5, and S8, while it varies for the other seismic zones.
A statistical treatment of completeness of the data le was carried out in each of the magnitude classes.
The Frequency Magnitude Distributions (FMD) for the study area including all seismic source zones were
established and the minimum magnitude of complete reporting (Mc) were then estimated. For the entire Iraq
the Mc was estimated to be about Ms 4.0 while S11 shows the lowest Mc to be about Ms 3.5 and the
highest Mc of about Ms 4.2 was observed for S4. The earthquake activity parameters (activity rate k, b
value, maximum regional magnitude mmax) as well as the mean return period (R) with a certain lower
magnitude mmin m along with their probability of occurrence have been determined for all thirteen seismic
source zones of Iraq. The maximum regional magnitude mmax was estimated as 7.87 0.86 for entire Iraq.
The return period for magnitude 6.0 is largest for source zone S3 which is estimated to be 705 years while the
smallest value is estimated as 9.9 years for all of Iraq.
The large variation of the b parameter and the hazard level from zone to zone reects crustal heterogeneity
and the high seismotectonic complexity. The seismic hazard near the source boundaries is directly and
strongly aected by the change in the delineation of these boundaries. The forces, through which the
geological structure along the plate boundary in Eastern and Northeastern Iraq are evolved, are still active
causing stress-strain accumulation, deformation and in turn producing higher probabilities of earthquake
activity. Thus, relatively large destructive earthquakes are expected in this region. The study is intended to
serve as a reference for more advanced approaches and to pave the path for the probabilistic assessment of
seismic hazard in this region.
Key words: PSHA, earthquake catalogue characteristics, b value, mmax, Iraq.
Introduction
The ultimate goal of seismic hazard assessment for a particular site or area is to
condense seismotectonic knowledge and experience into parameters used for
1
952
A. S. Ameer et al.
predicting ground motion which in turn can be applied by engineers in design and
subsequent earthquake resistant construction. The seismic hazard has to be
considered for sensitive structures like dams, mines, nuclear power plants, underground depositories for radioactive waste, oil platforms, etc.
The primary advantage of probabilistic seismic hazard analysis (PSHA) is that it
integrates over all seismicity: temporal and spatial along with ground motions to
calculate a combined probability of exceedence that incorporates the relative
frequencies of occurrence of dierent earthquakes and ground-motion characteristics. In practicality in any earthquake catalogue the quality of the dierent parts
(periods and areas) varies signicantly with respect to completeness, magnitude
reliability, homogeneity and location accuracy. In an edgy formulation one may
say that on the basis of an incomplete, inhomogeneous and inaccurate catalogue, the
science is challenged with the task of deriving parameters that condently reect the
seismic potential of the region.
Specically, the estimation of the maximum regional magnitude mmax and its
occurrence in space and time is the most dicult of the seismic hazard parameters to
assess. Mostly the methods employed in estimating mmax, are dependent on the
extrapolation of the classical, log-linear, frequency-magnitude Gutenberg-Richter
relationship. To avoid confusion mmax, is dened here as the upper limit of
magnitude for a given region. Also, synonymous with the upper limit of earthquake
magnitude, is the magnitude of the largest possible earthquake. The estimation of
mmax is necessarily required for engineering applications and seismic hazard analyses
(see KIJKO, 2002). In addition to reviewing newly available data for inclusion in
updated probabilistic analyses, the primary aim of the present study is to consider the
potentially damaging earthquakes throughout Iraq and to consider new models of
FMD (Frequency Magnitude Distributions) for Iraq. PSHA is conducted for Iraq
taking into account the newly compiled data set and the new models of FMD, and an
endeavor is made to interpret the results with respect to the various seismogenic
sources present in Iraq.
953
boundary is marked by the left-lateral Dead Sea fault system which extends from the
Gulf of Aqaba in the south to the northern Triple Junction of Cyprus subduction
zone, Bitlis zone and the Dead Sea Transform (BEYDOUN, 1991; ALSINAWI and AL
DILAIMI, 1993).
The Arabian Subcontinent plate is subducted under the Anatolian and Iranian
plates compressing the Tethyesides geosyncline belt as part of the Alpine movement,
which reached its climax in the Tertiary and continued until the Oligocene and early
Pliocene, where the Tethys Sea was completely closed in the region. The Zagros
mountains which are part of the Alpine-Himalayan orogenic system can be divided
into three structural zones: an inner crystalline zone of overthrusting, an imbricate
belt, and a zone of folding often referred to as the simply folded belt (the north and
northeastern parts of the study area). The Taurus belt took an E-W trend in the
north of the study area. These two plate boundaries have complicated patterns and
their seismicity is diused without sharp borders, and is believed that the forces that
have formed these plate boundaries are still active (Fig. 1) (GHALIB and ALSINAWI,
1974; ALSINAWI, 1988).
The tectonic framework of Iraq (Fig. 1) has a NE-SW classication starting with
(i) the stable shelf restricted by a set of deep faults of AbuJir, Euphrates and Palmyra
fault zones and characterized by a reduced thickness of sedimentary cover. (ii) The
Mesopotamian zone. (iii) The simply folded zone which lies to the northeast of the
Mesopotamian zone, most foldings are buckle folds, e.g., Hatra-Bekhme fault,
Fatha-Houran fault and Diyala faults. (iv) The thrust zone which comprises the
Alpine Euogeosynclinal rocks is characterized by complex thrust structures and
subjected to orogenic movements in late Triassic, upper Cretaceous, Miocene and
Pliocene. Ophiolite facies and ysch sediments ascertained the latest movements. (v)
The Central Iranian zone which is characterized by a chain of Mesozoic and
Cenozoic volcanic.
The region was folded and faulted during the Alpine movement in the Tertiary.
More comprehensive analyses are given by AL NAQIB (1967), BUDAY and JASSIM
(1987), and ALSINAWI (2002).
954
A. S. Ameer et al.
Figure 1
Main structural zones of Iraq.
955
elements and sudden variations in the homogeneity of the seismicity. In total 13seismic source zones (S1 to S13) have been identied. The seismic sources so selected
are shown in Figure 3 along with the seismicity plot.
To analyze the nature of the completeness of the data sample in detail, the
entire data set has been grouped in several magnitude classes and each magnitude
class was modeled as a point process in time. The method as given by STEPP
(1972) has been used to check the completeness of data for rstly, Iraq as a whole
as shown in Figure 4 and secondly, for the entire 13-seismic source zones S1 to
S13 individually. Figure 4 reveals that the data are complete for magnitudes
(3.6 < Ms > 4.1) and (4.2 < Ms < 4.7) for the last 45 years. For magnitude
Ms > 4.8 the data sets are complete for 95 years. The same procedure was
applied for all 13 seismic source zones and the result of completeness for dierent
magnitude ranges has been compiled in Table 1. For seismic source zones S10 and
S11 the magnitude range for 3.0 < Ms < 3.5 has also been included, which is
due to the denser networks of seismographs reporting lower magnitudes from
these sources. The analysis of completeness of the updated seismicity le shows
that the earthquake catalogue is not complete below Ms 4.8 for entire Iraq.
Based on the analysis, similar conclusions have also been drawn for seismic
source zones S1, S4, S5, and S8. The value of Mc for entire Iraq has been
estimated as Ms 4.0, which varies slightly for the 13 seismic source zones
considered in this study (AMEER et al., 2002a, b).
Figure 2
Annual distribution of earthquales for Iraq 19052000, grouped in six magnitude classes.
956
A. S. Ameer et al.
Figure 3
Seismicity map of Iraq during the last 95 years (19052000) with Ms 3.0 (borders outlined) and the area
surrounding it. The seismic source zones used for seismic hazard estimation shown as (S#).
The FMDs for entire Iraq and for all 13 seismic source zones have been reevaluated after correcting for incomplete reporting in the data sample, i.e., by
creating an articially complete sample of data below the magnitude which was
completely reported over the total 95 years of data. For this purpose Table 1 was
utilized and the complete mean rate of recurrence for each incomplete magnitude
class was used to ll in the lower end of FMD. For example Figures 5, 6 and 7
illustrate this treatment for entire Iraq and seismic sources zones S11 and S13
respectively, where the open circles represent the complete data below the
complete magnitude reporting over 95 years and solid circles show the incomplete
data. The regression analysis (least-squares, LS) was then applied to the
incomplete (b-LS incomplete) and complete data sets (b-LS complete) (see
Table 2) to select the minimum magnitude of complete reporting, Mc, as the value
where the FMD graph clearly departs from the straight line plot, while the largest
earthquake in the sample was usually taken to be the upper magnitude. The
better estimates in evaluation of the b-slope after the treatment for incompleteness
have been achieved in sources S7, S11 and S6, which tend to increase the b-slope
to about 27%, 25% and 17%, respectively.
957
Figure 4
Completeness analysis for the entire Iraq region for dierent magnitude classes.
958
A. S. Ameer et al.
Table 1
Variability in the Beginning of Completeness Times for Magnitude Ranges
Sources
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Ir
5.4 5.9
4.8 5.3
4.2 4.7
3.6 4.1
3.0 3.5
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19052000
19452000
19302000
19052000
19052000
19202000
19252000
19052000
19152000
19202000
19252000
19152000
19202000
19052000
19452000
19552000
19302000
19352000
19402000
19552000
19602000
19252000
19452000
19252000
19552000
19452000
19802000
19552000
19502000
19552000
19852000
19602000
19552000
19652000
19802000
19452000
19552000
19552000
19602000
19802000
19802000
19552000
19602000
19602000
Figure 5
The frequency magnitude distribution for Iraq.
959
Figure 6
The frequency magnitude distribution for seismic source zone S11.
estimate other hazard parameters for entire Iraq and 13 seismic source zones. A
computer program written by A. Kijko was used for the analysis. Table 3
summarizes the input data used for the estimation of mmax and seismic hazard of
Iraq and those of thirteen seismic source zones.
960
A. S. Ameer et al.
Figure 7
The frequency magnitude distribution for seismic source zone S13.
Table 2
Values after Re-evaluation of FMD for Complete and Incomplete Data Sets
Source
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Ir
b-LS incomplete
0.69
0.78
0.79
0.92
0.71
0.75
0.52
0.62
0.73
0.70
0.73
0.90
0.85
0.84
0.02
0.04
0.04
0.09
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.04
0.04
0.03
0.05
0.06
0.06
0.03
b-LS complete
0.74
0.81
0.91
0.95
0.81
0.90
0.71
0.66
0.70
0.74
0.97
1.10
1.00
0.89
0.02
0.04
0.04
0.09
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.04
0.02
0.03
0.05
0.04
0.06
0.02
b-ML
0.72
0.66
1.09
0.49
0.74
0.93
0.95
0.78
0.86
0.60
0.68
0.98
0.77
0.82
0.05
0.06
0.14
0.19
0.13
0.10
0.09
0.10
0.08
0.05
0.05
0.07
0.10
0.03
minimum and maximum estimates for mmax are 5.66 0.33 and 7.92 1.55 (zones
S11 and S8), respectively.
961
Table 3
Input Data for Fourteen Seismic Zones in IRAQ and Surrounding Area
Seismic zone
Mc
Number of events
Standard deviation
Max. observed
magnitude
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Ir
3.7
4.0
4.0
4.2
3.9
3.7
3.9
3.8
3.9
3.7
3.5
3.9
3.9
4.0
237
137
58
31
43
89
110
63
122
143
364
189
76
783
0.56
0.57
0.44
0.42
0.49
0.45
0.51
0.58
0.55
0.63
0.49
0.42
0.47
0.53
7.30
7.30
6.00
5.70
5.80
6.20
5.80
6.80
6.50
7.30
5.60
6.10
6.00
7.20
8.62 0.72
4.65 0.51
4.30 0.94
1.04 0.35
1.81 0.41
5.16 0.88
5.75 0.76
2.39 0.37
5.18 0.60
4.13 0.41
14.22 1.16
12.71 1.60
3.44 0.61
34.03 1.65
Seismic zone
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Ir
1.70
1.56
2.57
1.15
1.75
2.17
2.23
1.84
2.02
1.38
1.60
2.31
1.81
1.93
0.11
0.14
0.94
0.44
0.31
0.23
0.22
0.23
0.19
0.12
0.11
0.17
0.23
0.07
0.72
0.66
1.09
0.49
0.74
0.92
0.95
0.78
0.86
0.59
0.68
0.98
0.77
0.82
0.05
0.06
0.14
0.19
0.13
0.10
0.09
0.10
0.08
0.05
0.05
0.07
0.10
0.03
b-ML
0.52
0.42
0.91
0.35
0.77
0.64
1.10
1.55
0.51
0.39
0.33
1.54
0.67
0.86
mmax
7.68
7.53
6.53
5.85
6.45
6.62
6.52
7.92
6.80
7.51
5.66
6.99
6.53
7.87
Table 4
34.0
25.3
705.3
232.8
339.5
257.0
157.4
125.7
26.5
114.3
127.9
9.9
RMs 6:0
0.9471
0.9809
0.1322
0.3492
0.2551
0.3217
0.4702
0.5486
0.9770
0.5830
0.5425
1.0000
Pr
(T = 100)Ms 6:0
962
A. S. Ameer et al.
Pure appl. geophys.,
963
Figure 8
Return periods using complete data for fourteen seismic source zones in Iraq.
Figure 9
Probability-magnitude diagram for the fourteen seismic source zones for 50-year return periods for Iraq.
964
A. S. Ameer et al.
Figure 10
Probability-magnitude diagram for the fourteen seismic source zones for 50-year return periods for Iraq.
Conclusion
In the present study the probabilistic seismic hazard analysis has been carried
out for the seismically active region of Iraq. The seismicity catalogue has been
prepared for the period 19052000. The whole Iraq region has been divided into
thirteen seismic source zones based on their seismic characteristics, geological
setting and tectonic framework. The analysis of completeness of the updated
seismicity le indicates that the earthquake catalogue is not complete below
Ms 4.8 for entire Iraq and seismic source zones S1, S4, S5, and S8. The Mc
estimated for entire Iraq was Ms 4.0 and varies slightly for the 13 seismic
source zones. The gradually curved FMDs (as happened for most seismic zones in
Iraq) tend to underestimate Mc, which is indicative of spatial and temporal
heterogeneity of the earthquake catalogue for these seismic zones, making it
necessary to re-evaluate FMDs.
The FMD relation re-evaluated after correcting for incompleteness of entire
Iraq and for most of the seismic source zones shows an increase in b slope. The
better estimates in evaluation of the b slope after the treatment for incompleteness
have been achieved in sources S7, S11 and S6, which tend to increase the b slope
about 27%, 25% and 17%, respectively. For all source zones the slope (b values)
of FMD varies between 0.49 0.19 and 1.09 0.14, with most zones having
values around 0.80, obviously depending on the size and the seismicity of the
source zone. Such type of results poses a major problem in seismic hazard
965
Acknowledgment
The authors sincerely acknowledge the valuable suggestions and comments from
the anonymous reviewers in the preparation of this paper. The computer program
provided by Dr. Andrzej Kijko is used in this study and is gratefully acknowledged.
The authors are thankful for the assistance provided by Prof. and Head, Department
of Earthquake Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee.
REFERENCES
AL-NAQIB, K. M. (1967), Geology of the Arabian Peninsula Southeastern Iraq, US Geological Survey,
Professional Paper 569 G, 147.
ALSINAWI, S. A. (1988), Seismotectonics of Iraq, Engineering Seismology and Earthquake Engineering
Training Course, Baghdad, 1, 2127 Nov., 132.
ALSINAWI, S. A., and AL DILAIMI, J. M. H. (1993), Seismic zoning, seismic sources and seismotectonics of
the Arabian Peninsula, Proc. 5th Inter. Conf. on Natural and Man Made Hazards, Qingado, China.
ALSINAWI, S. A. (2002), Seismicity, Seismotectonics, Crustal Structure and Attenuation Data on Iraq, The
Relemr Meeting, Antakya, Turkey, Dec. 1214.
AMEER, S. A., SHARMA, M. L., and WASON, H. R. (2002a), Maximum likelihood estimation of seismic
hazard for Iraq from complete data les, Proc. 12th Symp. on Earthquake Engineering, Roorkee, India,
Vol. 1, 306312.
AMEER, S. A., SHARMA, M. L., and WASON, H. R. (2002b), Completeness of earthquake catalogue and its
implications in seismic hazard estimationA case study for Iraq, Proc. 12th Sympos. on Earthquake
Engineering, Roorkee, India, Vol. 1, 342349.
BEYDOUN, Z. R. (1991), Arabian Plate Hydrocarbon Geology and PotentialA Plate Tectonic Approach
Studies in Geology, 33, Am. Assoc. Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, Oklahoma, USA, pp. 77.
BUDAY, T., and JASSIM, S. Z. (1987), The Regional Geology of Iraq, Tectonism, Magmatism and
Metamorphism V.2. Iraqi Geological Survey and Mineral Investigation Press, Baghdad, pp. 352.
966
A. S. Ameer et al.
GHALIB, H. A., and ALSINAWI, S. A. (1974), Seismotectonics of the Arabian PeninsulaA Global Tectonic
Approach, Bull. Coll. Sci. 15, 151169.
CORNELL, C. A. (1968), Engineering Seismic Risk Analysis, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. 58, 5, 15831606.
FAHMI, K. J., and AL ABBASI, J. N. (1989), Some Statistical Aspects of Earthquake Occurrence in Iraq,
Earthq. Spectra 4, 735765.
KIJKO, A. (2002), Statistical Estimation of Maximum Regional Earthquake Magnitude mmax, 12th European
Conference on Earthquake Engineering, Sept. 913, London.
KIJKO, A., and SELLEVOLL, M. A. (1992), Estimation of Earthquake Hazard Parameters from Incomplete
Data Files. Part II. Incorporation of Magnitude Heterogeneity, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am 82, 1, 120134.
KIJKO, A., and SELLEVOLL, M. A. (1989), Estimation of Earthquake Hazard Parameters from Incomplete
Data Files. Part I. Utilization of Extreme and Complete Catalogue with Dierent Threshold Magnitude
Heterogeneity, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. 79, 645654.
STEPP, J. C. (1972), Analysis of the completeness of the earthquake sample in the Puget Sound area and its
eect on statistical estimates of earthquake hazard, Proc. Inter. Conf. Microzonation for safer construct.
Res. Appl., Seattle, Washington, U.S.A. 64, 11891207.
TINTI, S., and Mulargia, F. (1985), Eect of Magnitude Uncertainties on Estimating the Parameters in the
Gutenberg-Richter Frequency-magnitude Law, Bull. Seismol. Soc. Am. 75, 16811697.
(Received March 10, 2003, accepted March 1, 2004)