Development Manager, Dolby Laboratories, explains some of the implications of HD for OBs. igh Definition TV services have been available for several years in the US and Japan, but the launch of HD services in Europe has only recently been announced with many European broadcasters planning to go on air with HDTV by early 2006. The falling prices of living room friendly flat-screen displays and the availability of new coding technology that enables HD broadcasts to be squeezed more easily into Europes crowded broadcast spectrum are often mentioned as factors that make HD more viable in the region than ever before. From the viewers point of view, the overall HDTV experience is more vivid, more realistic, and plunges them into the centre of the action. This experience is created not just by larger images with greater resolution, but is completed by immersive 5.1 surround sound. It is expected that sport will feature significantly in early HD programming in Europe one of the three new satellite channels planned to launch later this year by German operator Premiere will be devoted to sport. So how is Europes outside broadcast industry preparing for this rapidly
24 LINE UP Sept/Oct 2005
developing demand for live HD
programming with 5.1 sound? Several major outside broadcast facility providers have already equipped trucks ready for HD production, but providing surround sound involves more than just installing a 5.1 capable mixing console and suitable monitoring. The truck needs to be able to deliver the mix in the format that the broadcaster wants to use to feed it back to the broadcast centre via their telecoms link, or to record onto tape. The most common format used for this purpose is Dolby E, which enables up to eight channels of audio to be fed over a standard digital stereo AES link. Additionally, where the final mix is being generated in the truck, the mixer should ideally also be generating the metadata that will ultimately be broadcast alongside the audio. This metadata is used to control how the mix will sound when replayed on different home systems, and can be used to optimise stereo and mono compatibility. OB Trucks at the Olympic Games Never were OB trucks tested as much as at last years Olympic Games in Athens. Twelve trucks covered more than 14 venues and 16 different sports in surround sound at the Games and many engineers had never mixed in surround before. The surround sound feeds they produced were offered to broadcasters around the world to transmit their Olympic coverage in Dolby
Digital 5.1, or in Dolby Pro Logic II for
those limited to stereo sound transmission channels. Just two weeks before the Games began, Dolby consultants flew to Athens to support the final installation of equipment by the host broadcaster Athens Olympic Broadcasting (AOB), prepare their mixing teams, and provide assistance throughout the Games coverage. In total, 51 Dolby units were employed by AOB throughout the broadcast chain, including encoders, decoders, test tools, and loudness meters. Dolby sound consultant, Andrea Borgato visited each of the 12 outside broadcast trucks in turn to install and calibrate the equipment, and helped to train the sound mixers in surround production techniques. Broadcasting live sport is a complicated process and so surround audio production is generally kept relatively simple. However, the mixers at the Olympic Games still managed to provide several mixes simultaneously using a single mixing console (International TV mixes in 5.1, Pro Logic II encoded stereo, and plain stereo plus the International Radio Stereo Mix). Preparing the OB trucks for mixing and monitoring was made that bit more complicated as many of them were designed only for stereo production. So each truck was equipped with a rack containing a DP571 Dolby E Encoder for 5.1 sound feeds, as well as a DP563 Encoder and a DP564 Decoder for the Dolby Pro Logic II feeds. Vistek units to compensate for video re-synchronisation delays were included in the rack, and Voice Systems BEEE 5.1 loudspeaker monitoring was provided, with SPL model 2380 surround monitoring controllers. Capturing the Sound In the production of 5.1 extra microphones are typically used to capture the rear channel ambiance and to help give the viewer that sense of being in the midst of the action. Generally, standard stereo mic configurations were used for the frontal image, supplemented in most of the venues with a spaced pair to provide the rear channel contribution of the environment and crowd. By far the most complicated microphone setup at the Olympic Games was in the main Olympic stadium which played host to the athletics, the football gold medal match, and the opening and closing ceremonies. A number of miniature shotgun microphones covered the action on the track, supplemented with additional stereo microphones. The crowd was picked up with five microphones hung around the
stadium, as well as by extra crowd
microphones for smaller localised events. A strategy was developed to enable a single audio mixer to create all of the various stereo and surround mixes needed. For example, in the 5.1 mix, the centre channel was kept free to simplify the addition of commentary by local broadcasters and to simplify mixing on stereo consoles. This also meant that the front left and right channels of the 5.1 mix could be used as the international stereo FX mix. The disadvantage of this approach was that the centre speaker could not be used to anchor the sounds of on-screen action for 5.1 listeners, but this was considered to be an acceptable compromise. A basic set of metadata was created within the Dolby E encoder at each location for the rights-holding broadcasters to use as a guide, but it did not prove necessary to monitor or adjust metadata in the truck whilst mixing. Since the 5.1 was an international mix, each individual broadcaster was left to create or modify the metadata once they had added their local elements (such as commentary in the centre channel). Each events 5.1 mix and accompanying metadata was encoded as
Dolby E, embedded into an SDI signal and
transmitted to the Olympic broadcast centre via a standard fibre-optic link. Production Challenges The complexity of the coverage and the sheer number of events to cover presented some unique difficulties, which often resulted in some equally unique solutions. For example, the sound mixer for the track events shared a console with the mixer for the field events yet even in this difficult environment, he was still able to create and monitor a surround sound mix. When his colleague was using the surround monitoring in the truck, he used Dolby Headphone technology to listen to a guide version of the 5.1 mix. Of course, the odd nudge was needed to alert him to important calls over talkback! Examples such as this demonstrate that, even in circumstances where production facilities are not optimised for 5.1, a convincing surround soundtrack can be created without compromising the production of the other required feeds. Fortunately, in Europe where use of 5.1 is spreading even on standard definition (SD) television, many broadcasters are already
devoting more care and attention to 5.1
production without adding prohibitive complexity. With demand for 5.1 audio growing, there is every chance that live surround sound production will continue to be an area of innovation, and with international events such as the Winter Olympics and the football World Cup taking place in Europe next year, it should be an exciting time for audio in outside broadcasts. www.dolby.com