Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION.......................................................................................3
2. STRATEGIC PLANNING...........................................................................4
2.1 Definition and goals of strategic planning:............................................4
2.2 Tourism Planning Process.....................................................................5
2.3 Barriers to Tourism planning development...........................................5
2.4 Strategic Tourism Planning Process......................................................6
2.5 Sustainable Tourism.............................................................................9
2.6 Importance of sustainable tourism.....................................................10
2.7 Importance of Sustainable Tourism in Spain and the Bahamas...........11
1. Introduction
Tourism has always been a great pleasure to people all around the world. According
to Mathieson and Wall (1982), tourism is a temporary movement of people out of
their regular destinations. It also covers their actions while staying at the
destination. Also the facilities which are installed to assist them also fall under the
category of tourism. Tourism is the relationship that is created between tourists,
hosts, the suppliers and the government due to the actions relating to attracting
the tourist (Macintosh and Goeldner, 1986). In the words of World Tourism
Organization (UNWTO, 1995) Tourism means
travelling to destinations beside ones regular destinations for twenty-four hours
but not to one year for the purpose of business, travel and other intentions.
Tourism has a huge potential too. Tourism adds up almost 11% of the world GDP
(WTTC, 2011). It has the capability to enhance economic, social and political
growth. In many countries, the growth in infrastructure has been possible due to
the advancement of tourism. United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO)
has affirmed that in 2009 alone, almost $852 Billion has been earned as revenue
through tourism all around the world. The industry employs 1 in every 15 persons
either directly or indirectly (UNWTO, 2010).
Such a crucial industry for the world economy must be well maintained. The
sustainability and growth of tourism depends on the strategic planning and policies.
But in most of the cases, no effective policies are created or implemented for the
maintenance of the industry. Even if there exists policies in different regions, they
are often not sustainable and differ from each other. To ensure the perfect growth
and sustainability of environment, United Nations World Tourism Organization is
working (UNWTO, 1995). For the comparison, two countries like Spain and The
Bahamas has been chosen. The report tries to provide an insight about strategic
planning and the overall strategic planning process and its impact on the society. It
also provides an overview of sustainable tourism approaches, its benefits and the
comparison between the effects of strategic tourism planning between the two
selected countries, Spain and the Bahamas.
3
2. Strategic Planning
2.1 Definition and goals of strategic planning
Many authors have defined planning process in different perceptions. However, they
all point to one single intention, the achievement of a set of goals. According to
Dror (1973), planning is determining a set of decision and action process for future
which will assist in achievement of a set of goals. According to Hall (2000), Planning
means making policies and decisions regarding all the aspects of the organizations
future operations and activities. Integrating all the operations makes the planning
more realistic and appropriate than making decisions individually.
However, prioritizing the different issues of the business and organization is equally
important (Campbell et.al, 2002). This is where Strategic planning comes forward.
Veal (2002) argued that strategic planning is the initial and most important aspect
for an organization to achieve its short term and long term goals. According to him,
strategic planning is the strategy to ensure that more emphasis is given to acquire
long term and medium term goals of the organization over shorter term goals.
Like any other industry, tourism industry also needs strategic planning and
determination of long-term, medium-term and short-term goals to ensure the
growth and prosperity of the industry worldwide. The importance is increased due
to the benefits reaped by different countries around the world. And due to its
importance in employment, GDP growth, revenue and foreign currency generation,
the continuous success of the industry is intensified. Without perfect planning such
a potential industry might go astray. According to Murphy (1991), the main
objective of strategic tourism planning is to make changes in the policies and
strategies of tourism through which social, cultural, environmental and economic
welfares towards the society becomes easy. The objectives are only achieved by
maintaining the balance among the operations and plans.
At this matter, Cooper et al (2008) stated that in order to ensure the positive
growth of the tourism development planning, all the parties of a certain society
such as public, private and local communities must work together.
the previous planning is often inactive and unsuccessful. The time lags hamper the
overall development.
Cooper et al (2008) have opined that proper development of tourism can only be
achieved when all the related parties in the society co-ordinate and co-operate.
These parties involve public sector, private sector and both the local and
international community. The co-ordination of all these parties is not easy. And they
often come at a price of bureaucracy. The initiatives of the government are a must
for this industry. The involvement of government eases the functioning of the plan.
But at the same time, bureaucracy increases. Thus it hinders development.
There are often a large number of parties involved in the planning and
implementation process. Also an important consideration is the seasonality of the
industry. The uncertainty of the actual size of the parties and industry obstructs
development. The uncertainty of the seasonality and limit of future assumptions
limit the success of the plan causing a probable shift in the actual planning which
increases loss of time, money and labor.
2.4 Strategic Tourism Planning Process
The strategic tourism planning has a few basic processes. These processes are
followed through 7 stages (Cooper, 2005). The steps of tourism planning are:
Analysis of background
Analysis and research
Synthesis and visioning
Objective determination and strategy determination
Development of plan
Implementation and monitoring of the plan
Reviewing the plan and changing unsuccessful strategies
The first step includes background analysis. This step includes identifying the need
for a plan and policies. The need of a plan might emerge from the changing need of
customers, government, the organization or the community as a whole. The
changing circumstances might demand to create or change a new or existing plan.
Also, crisis and emergencies might also require the authorities to formulate and
implement a plan or policy (Hall and McArthur, 1998; Hall, 2000).
The second step calls for a detailed research and analyses on the basis of the need.
Every plan needs data for success analysis. At this step of the cycle, data has to be
6
collected through primary or secondary data collection tools. The data analysis has
four major parts; Resource analysis, Market analysis, Activity analysis and
Competitor analysis. At first, the authority must determine the existing and
probable availability of resources. These resources will be used to formulate the
plan. So correct assumptions of the availability is a must for the success of the
plan.
Next the market analysis helps to determine the existing tourism market,
behavior and attitude of the tourists, their need and satisfactions etc. The analysis
also helps to get a clear idea of the future demand by the potential customers and
helps to fulfill them. Thirdly, the activity analysis helps to determine the present
activities of the parties among the industry. Also it is possible to determine the
activities necessary to formulate and the lacking of activities which are essential for
customer satisfaction. And lastly, competitor analysis creates an idea of the
competitors among and outside the industry and gives a competitive edge to the
user of the data.
The third step is called synthesis and visioning. These steps include two basic
elements namely, position statement and vision statement. The position statements
describe
the
present
situation
of
the
industry, the
development
process,
On the basis of the determined goals, objectives and decided possible strategies to
acquire the goals, plan and policy are developed. The plans and policies are usually
selected from a set of alternatives. The plans which seem to be most potential to
acquire the objectives are usually selected. But furthermore, the costs and benefits
associated with the plans are considered. If a plan is both potential in achieving the
target, provides most benefit and needs the lowest possible cost and labor to
implement, the plan(s) is selected (Cooper , 2005).
Following the development of plan, the implementation stage comes. In this stage,
the plans selected are implemented. The resources are put into actions and
constant follow-ups are done to identify any problems in implementation. By the
time the implementation stage is reached, all the legal and regulatory frameworks
start working in the process. During this phase, many confusions and imbalances
are met. These are addressed according to the resources available and possible
business environmental situations (Cooper, 2005).
The final stage or phase of the process is supervision and re-evaluation. In the first
five phases of the development process, the ideas and plans had been theoretical.
In the implementation stage, the theory meets reality. So in the implementation
stage, there lie many deviations from the actual plan. The supervision and reevaluation stage works to reduce these deviations. Often the plans deviate due to
lack of addressing important aspects of the plan. These problems can be easily
found out in the implementation stage and changed accordingly in the following
stage. Also, the plans might deviate due to undesirable events such as breakout of
epidemics, instable political condition of the country, terrorist attacks or even at the
simplest situation, bad weather condition. If the plans are not changed according to
the changed condition, it is bound to fail. In the implementation phase, the actual
impacts and usefulness of the plan are measured and evaluated. If there needs to
be any changes, they are done at this stage (Cooper, 2005).
Planning leads the tourism to success. But often even with great plans industries
fail and suffer. The main reason is the lack of implementation of plan and lack of
realistic views in the plan. According to World Tourism Organization (1980), a
survey of more than 1600 tourism plans showed that in almost 33% of the cases
potential plans were considered but not implemented (Wilkinson, 1997). And in the
words of Pearce (1989), Tourism planning can lead the industry and society to a
greater success but only if their implementations are observed properly. So,
adequate flexibility should be ensured in the plan to allow any emergency
modifications (Cooper, 2005).
2.5 Sustainable Tourism:
According to UNWTO (2005), Sustainable tourism is the tourism which considers
and realizes the impacts of tourism and activities on the economic, social, cultural
and environmental values and also fulfills the needs of all the parties involved.
According to UNESCO (2011), Sustainable tourism refers to tourism that values and
takes into account all the parties involved, the sustainability of the nature and the
host countrys cultural heritage as well. The first formal definition of sustainable
tourism was provided in Brundtland Report (World Commission on Environment and
Development, 1987), and later was intensified in United Nations Conference on The
Environment and Development (CNUMAD) in Rio de Janeiro conference in 1992
(Torres-Delgado, 2010).
Bell and Morse (2003) have opined that tourism sustainability in a specific region
can be achieved through following a few steps. At first, the historical tend data
should be analyzed; second, the data should be compared to the recent data.
Thirdly, some references on the basis of the principles should be suggested. And
lastly, attention must be given to the possible best and worst case scenario and
sensitivity analysis.
Although many experts believe that a theoretical framework for evaluation of the
sustainability must be created (Castellani & Sala, 2010;Crabtree & Bayeld, 1998;
European Commission, 2003; Gahin, Veleva, & Hart, 2003; Smeets &Weterings,
1999), it is definite that the sustainability approach largely depends on the users
positive attitude (Hunter, 1997; Naredo, 2004).
the
benefit
and
Economic Benefits:
Tourism is a prime source of earning for many countries. Almost all countries
earn 38% of their foreign exchange revenues by better export of tourism
can
be
to
differentiated
governmental
into
direct
and
revenue.
These
indirect.
Direct
contributions involve travel and eco-tax. Whereas indirect ones involve taxes
urban facilities.
Local economies are also influenced by tourism. The tourists often buy goods
and services form the local vendors. Thus the contribution, although not
easily measurable is multiplied in the local area over and over again. A study
10
expenditure (http://www.biodiversity.ru).
Through tourism revenues, the authority can invest in nature protection.
Thus it increases direct investment and better management of natural
resources.
11
the tourism marketing and planning approach of their authorities. Their planning
approaches are explained below:
3.1 Tourism Planning in Spain:
The tremendous rise of tourism in Spain began in the early 1990s due to
diversification of supply and spatial dispersion process. The natural beauty and
cultural heritage of Spain accelerated the growth of tourism in the country (Vera
and Marchena, 1998).
Since the 1960s tourism boom in Spain, both the demand and supply of hospitality
industry has increased (Hall, 1994). The need for a planned tourism development
has been rising since then. But for a long time there had been no organized plan for
tourism development in Spain (Bote, 1994). Until the early 1990s, there had been
little effort given to provide a formalized and centralized planning policy.
The first few plans for development of tourism in Spain were provided between the
years 1964 to 1975. Between these times, three 4-year plans were formulated in
Spain. The aim was to make tourism industry of Spain a more productive and
effective contributor in the national economy (Richardson, 1976). But the policies
were more centralized with little space for individual regional development. It
created regional imbalance among the potential tourism regions of the country
(Tamames, 1978). The policies imposed excessive emphasis on promotion and little
resources were allocated for regional infrastructural development (Bote and
Marchena, 1996; Figuerola, 1999). The plans lacked proper town planning and land
development and did not have enough infrastructural assistance (De Teran, 1982).
After the oil crisis in 1973, need for a decentralized policy approach increased. The
need for land integration policy along with tourism policy was realized. Two types of
regional and local plans were introduced by the tourist administration. One for the
inland areas where there were fewer resources, another for coastal naturally
enriched areas. But the policy was hindered by recession (Bote and Marchena,
1996). The idea was to decentralize the planning system according to the need of
the regions.
12
In 1982, a new policy was initiated which would reduce the authority of the central
tourism planning body and emphasize equally on both public and private
investment in tourism (Bote and Marchena, 1996; Figuerola, 1993). Also policies
were initiated to emphasize on specialized tourism sectors like snow tourism, golf
tourism etc (Costa and Jime nez, 1999). At this time the municipal authorities also
took initiatives to sustain
General
de
Turismo,
1990).
Later
in
1993
new
Master
13
confirmed in 2010 that their tourism GDP was US$53 billion which is second highest
in the world (UNWTO, 2012).
15
success. But if they are not properly addressed, they might as well ruin such an
important industry and its potentials.
REFERENCES
Bahamas National Trust (2013), Sustainable Tourism for Exuma Land and
Seas
Park
extracted
from
http://www.thebahamasweekly.com/publish/serviceclubs/Sustainable_Tourism_
for_Exuma_Park26307.shtml on January 28, 2013.
Bell, S., & Morse, S. (2003). Measuring sustainability: Learning from doing.
London: Earthscan Publications.
16
Dames & Moore Ltd. (1981) Tourism development programme final report:
Volume
1.
Report
for
Ministry
of
Tourism,
Government
of
the
17
Ezquiaga,
J.
(1994)
El
planeamiento
municipal.
In
La
pra ctica
del
Gunn, C.A. and Var, T. (2002) Tourism planning: Basics, concepts, cases. (4th
ed.). London: Routledge.
Hall, M.C (2000) Tourism Planning Policies, Processes and Relationships.
Prentice Hall. England.
Hall, C.M. and Mc Arthur, S. (1998) Integrated Heritage Management. London:
Stationery Office.
Hall, C. (1994) Tourism and Politics. Chichester: Wiley.
Hall, C. (2000) Tourism Planning. Policies, Processes and Relationships. Essex:
Prentice Hall.
Hunter, C. (1997). Sustainable tourism as an adaptive paradigm. Annals of
Tourism Research, 24(4), 850867.
Inskeep,
(1991)
Tourism
Planning
an
Integrated
and
Sustainable
A, Wall
(1982).
Tourism
economic,
physical
and
social
NITP (2012), National and Integral Tourism Plan (Plan Nacional e Integral de
Turismo: PNIT) 2012-2015.
Pearce, D. (1989). Tourist development. (2nd ed.). Harlow: Longmann.
Prats, F. (1995) Turismo, Territorio y Medioambiente: El caso del Plan Insular de
Lanzarote. In Conferencia Mundial de Turismo Sostenible: Cabildo de
Lanzarote.
Ramsaran, R. (1979). Tourism in the economy of the Bahamas. Caribbean
Studies 19 (1, 2), pp. 75-91.
Richardson, H. (1976)
UNEP
from
UNWTO (2005); Making Tourism More Sustainable - A Guide for Policy Makers,
UNEP and UNWTO, 2005, p.11-12
UNWTO Technical Manual Collection of Tourism Expenditure Statistics World
Tourism Organisation (1995), page 14.
UNWTO (2010), United Nation World Tourism Organization. Extracted from
http://www2.unwto.org/
Veal, A.J. (2002) Leisure and tourism policy and planning.
Wallingford: Cabi.
20
(2nd ed.).
Vera, F., and M. Marchena (1998) Efectos del turismo en las estructuras
regionales perife ricas. Una aproxi- macio n anal tica. Millars
21:109144.
WEF
(2009
&
2011),
World
Economic
Forum.
Extracted
from
http://www.weforum.org/
Wilkinson, P.F. (1997) Tourism policy and planning: Case studies from the
Commonwealth
Caribbean.
New
York:
Cognizant
Communication
Corporation.
World Commission on Environment and Development (1987). Our Common
Future.
Oxford,
United
Kingdom:
Oxford
University
Press.http://www.biodiversity.ru/coastlearn/tourismeng/why_economicbenefits.html
WTTC:
World
Travel
&
Tourism
Council
Research
Data
http://www.wttc.org/research/
WTO (1980), World trade organization. Extracted from http://www.wto.org/
WTO (2012), World trade organization. Extracted from http://www.wto.org/
WTO
(2012);
http://www.world-tourism.org/
extracted
form
http://www.biodiversity.ru/coastlearn/tourism-eng/why_economicbenefits.html
21