Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
With its head office in Oak Brook, Illinois, fast food giant McDonalds has ridden the
wave of global trends towards eating out and fast food since it took its modern form
in the early 1950's. Outside the USA, customers of the global chain were not,
however, only eating hamburgers- they were "eating and drinking America". In
societies that never had enough meat, the rapid emergence of fast food chains was
linked to the availability at reasonable prices of hot beef and chicken.
By the 1970s and 1980s, McDonald's and its golden arches logo had become a global
brand. By 1996 McDonald's operated in 100 countries and was finally earning more
revenue than McDonald's International than McDonald's America. In deed the Big
Mac had become so globally recognizable that it was adopted as a measure of
purchasing power across different markets.
Mc Donald's has packaged itself as a multi-local company, which has a high level of
local ownership through a network of franchise outlets. The products offered are
tailored to meet the needs of the local market, for example, beer is sold at
McDonald's in the Czech Republic and different chicken sandwich are sold in
England as compared to Germany. Sourcing of products is also global in some cases,
sesame seeds come from Mexico but others are local.
Despite its global dominance McDonalds began to see a slowing of its growth in the
late 1990s. By 1996, it reported a decline in sales in the USA. In part McDonald's
become a victim of its own success in that instead of generating new customers it just
spread its existing customer over more stores so that they did not increase their
market shares. In response to the lost of it market shares and decline in sales
McDonalds lunched a fierce marketing strategy that included extensive promotion
("I'M Loving' It" campaign) , the introduction of new healthier options and
expansion into new markets such as Hong Kong, Singapore, the Philippines and
Malaysia.
Recently, McDonald's fortunes has changed yet again and in the last quarter of 2008
they announced an increase in sales and profit in the UK which they attribute in part
to the credit crunch as people are now looking for cheaper eating out options . In
January 2009, announced that it will be opening 1000 new stories across the UK in
order to meet market demand for the brand. (Business: BBC, 2009).
Business Case for a healthier Menu
In recent years there have been numerous campaign and TV programs feature
McDonalds as an unhealthy fast food option. The movie, SuperSize Me, altered the
public to the danagers of eating McDonalds and explained exactly how unhealthy the
fast food is. Research has shown that a Big Meal contains approximately 2,400
calories, which equals the recommended calorie intake for a man and excess the
recommended intake for a woman.
Jaime Oliver, in his Channel Four Program, Jamie's School Dinners further
reiterated the damage being done to our bodies by eating McDonalds on a regular
basis. In fact, his research shows that on average children who ate junk food, such as
McDonalds, where often lethargic and unable to concentrate and has poor academic
performance as a result. Such programs have led consumers to think about what they
eat and they are seeking healthy options that are affordable.
New EU regulation regarding salt and fat content and the removal of the use of
certain oils and fats from fast food, has reinforced the need for McDonalds to offer its
customers healthier options. Additionally, the UK government, in its drive to reduce
obesity and encourage Britons to be healthier has used companies such as
McDonalds as examples of foods that should be avoid. In 2009, the UK government,
in an attempt to regulate the fast food industry, has set out guidelines for including
calorie and fat contents on the package of meals so that consumer can make an
informed choice.
McDonalds has also seen a decline in its sales due to socio-cultural factors such as
lifestyle changes. Growing health consciousness together with social and government
pressure to eat healthy and reduce the levels of obesity in countries like the UK and
USA has adversely affect the sales of McDonalds in these markets. Few years ago
people start to change their eating habit, and start eating healthy and vegetarian
food. As a result McDonalds saw a decline in sales in UK, Germany and Japan.
McDonald's, since some of them were offering healthy and affordable meals. For
example , they has phased out the use of trans fats and now use a new cooking oil
designed to make the food healthier without losing its taste.
While the recent economic recession has seen an increase in McDonald's fortunes,
studies indicated that customer's whiles regarding McDonalds as an affordable
option still regard them as unhealthy and would rather pay more to have a healthy
meal. McDonald's original forage into healthy eating, by introducing sales, was
unconvincing as it was found that these has as much calories as a Big Mac.
In light of the changing circumstance, McDonalds needs to focus on introducing a
healthier menu by reducing the fat content of its existing meals and adding healthier
options such as salad, low fat sandwiches and grilling rather than frying it nuggets,
chicken and fish burgers.
Research Methods
This research will be conducted using both primary and secondary data.
Primary Data collection
Primary Research: "It is information that does not exist until you carry out your own
investigation" (EDEXCEL HNC/HND, 2004). The mixed methods approach will be
used combining primary and secondary data. "One of the benefits of this is that it can
overcome one of the main drawbacks of secondary data, which is that it is often not
of direct relevance to your research objective. By using appropriate primary data to
'plug the gaps' you should be able to obtain the complete picture. This might be the
case where you are researching an issue within an organisation" (EDEXCEL
HNC/HND Business, 2004)
Greater control over the type of data collected and the sample size
Efficient way of spending time as the data being research is topic specific
Disadvantages
Costly- this include costs such as postage, printing material, and cost of time
to conduct the research.
Research bias- the researcher can impose his or her view on the research
subjects
Questionnaires
These are seen as a logical and easy way of collecting information from people. The
research will design a series of questions related to the research topic and using a
survey hand out the questionnaires to the potential subjects.
Types of questionnaires
Open questionnaires- this is where the answers are not provide and the
subjects need to offer their opinion. This type of questionnaire provides more
information but can be difficult to interpret and may lead to inaccurate and
incomplete assumptions by the researcher.
Inexpensive to use
Secondary data
Is the data have already been collected by elsewhere for someone else for some other
purpose, but which can be used or adapted for the survey being conducted"
(EDEXCEL HNC/HND, 2004) Information will be collected from websites, journal,
newspapers etc in relation to McDonalds.
Advantages of secondary data
Ease to access and less time consuming than primary research as the data
already exist.
Low cost- secondary data collection is much cheaper that primary research
collection
Inconsistency and inaccuracy of data may hinder the research from getting a
clear understand of the research topic and may lead to incorrect assumptions.
Information is not specific to the researchers need and means that the
research may need to spend a large amount of time sorting through irrelevant
information.
Literature Review
New product development is a company's lifeblood. Growth and profits suffer
without aggressive product development introducing new product's and services into
the market.
All companies need to find out what their customers/potential customers want in
order to meet any gaps in the market. However, asking your customers to take the
role of R&D personnel to find out what they want will not always lead to success. The
key to successful market research for new product development comes from an
understanding of what customers value and not simply from asking them to submit
their own solutions.
New product development research is not always about looking at the product in
isolation; the product, the packaging, the advertising and the pricing strategy are all
integral parts of the research. Any new product launch is inherently risky as it is a
venture into the unknown.
Competitive Advantage
Jones and George suggest that competitive advantage can be created by one or more
of the four factors: - (Jones & George, 2007)
Qaulity-this refers to the quality of output in terms of does the product meet
the customer requirements. This aspect emphasis quality of design,
conformance to quality and reliability. McDonalds has continued to product
high quality products that meet customer needs.
A change in lifestyle for instance healthier eating habits has seen the biggest
change in McDonalds. McDonalds now offer health options such as salads,
grilled chicken, flatbreads, breakfast porridges fruits and fruit juices. They
even offer concern parents the opportunity to replace fries with carrot stick.
The firm also dropped it's supersize portions.
Michael Porter (1998) argues that there are five forces that affect competition. He
states that"the five-force framework provides the structure for analysing effect, while
activities and the value chain provide the structure for examining the competitive
advantage effect."
Porter's five forces are useful, because it helps to understand both the strength of
your current competitive position, and the strength of a position you're looking to
move into.
1. Bargaining power of suppliers: in this case it is for suppliers to drive up prices.
It is driven by the number of suppliers of each key input, the uniqueness of
their product or service, their strength and control. Not to be under suppliers
control McDonalds are producing their own products for example potato and
Power Distance Index (PDI) this refers to the extent to which the less powerful accept
and expect that power is distributed unequally. Hosfetde suggests that the societal
inequality is endorsed as much by the less powerful as it is by the more powerful.
Individualism (IDV) - in some society individual achievement and freedom is
paramount as everyone is expected to look after themselves. However, other society
strives for collectivism and people are integrated into strong cohesive groups which
shape their values and attitudes.
Masculinity (MAS) this refers to the distribution of roles based on gender. In
masculine societies the focus is on achievement and power while in feminine
societies the focus is on values such as caring.
Uncertainty Avoidance Index (UAI) this refers to society level of tolerance for
uncertainty. Uncertainty avoiding cultures try to minimize uncertainty by strict laws
and rules, safety and security measures, and on the philosophical and religious level
by a belief in absolute Truth. People in uncertainty avoiding countries are also more
emotional, and motivated by inner nervous energy. Uncertainty accepting cultures
are more tolerant and try to have few rules that might restrict individual choice.
New Product Development
According to Johnson and Scholes , strategy development is a dynamic process which
should be carried out on a regaular basis , in order that strategies and plans can be
adjusted can be adopted to changes within the organization itself and within the
wider business environment. (Johnson & Scholes, 2002) .
Strategy development is important in that is will help McDonalds to identify their:
Strengths and weaknesses as well as the opportunities and threats facing the
organizations. These give McDonald's an idea of where potential opportunities
for expansion existing as well as it the company have the necessary resources
in place to meet the changing organizations needs
Idea generation- develop new idea for product through customer survey and
brainstorming sessions
Screening new ideas- this stage allows further analysis of the ideas addressing
areas such as target market, size of growth forecasts, competitive pressure and
feasibility of developing the product.
Test Marketing- involves testing the product using focus groups. Any
necessary changes are made at this stage.
The Fuzzy Front End is the messy "getting started" period of new product
development processes. It is in the front end where the organization formulates a
concept of the product to be developed and decides whether or not to invest
resources in the further development of an idea. It is the phase between first
consideration of an opportunity and when it is judged ready to enter the structured
development process (Kim and Wilemon , 2002; Koen et al., 2001). It includes all
activities from the search for new opportunities through the formation of a germ of
an idea to the development of a precise concept. The Fuzzy Front End ends when an
organization approves and begins formal development of the concept.
Although the Fuzzy Front End may not be an expensive part of product development,
it can consume 50% of development time (see Chapter 3 of the Smith and Reinertsen
reference below), and it is where major commitments are typically made involving
time, money, and the product's nature, thus setting the course for the entire project
and final end product. Consequently, this phase should be considered as an essential
part of development rather than something that happens "before development," and
its cycle time should be included in the total development cycle time.
Koen et al. (2001, pp.47-51) distinguish five different front-end elements (not
necessarily in a particular order):
1. Opportunity Identification
2. Opportunity Analysis
3. Idea Genesis
4. Idea Selection
5. Concept and Technology Development
The first element is the opportunity identification. In this element, large or
incremental business and technological chances are identified in a more or less
structured way. Using the guidelines established here, resources will eventually be
allocated to new projects.... which then lead to a structured NPPD (New Product &
Process Development)strategy. The second element is the opportunity analysis. It is
done to translate the identified opportunities into implications for the business and
technology specific context of the company. Here extensive efforts may be made to
align ideas to target customer groups and do market studies and/or technical trials
and research. The third element is the idea genesis, which is described as
evolutionary and iterative process progressing from birth to maturation of the
opportunity into a tangible idea. The process of the idea genesis can be made
internally or come from outside inputs, e.g. a supplier offering a new
material/technology, or from a customer with an unusual request. The fourth
element is the idea selection. Its purpose is to choose whether to pursue an idea by
analyzing its potential business value. The fifth element is the concept and
technology development. During this part of the front-end, the business case is
developed based on estimates of the total available market, customer needs,
investment requirements, competition analysis and project uncertainty. Some
organizations consider this to be the first stage of the NPPD process (i.e., Stage 0).
The Fuzzy Front End is also described in literature as "Front End of Innovation",
"Phase 0", "Stage 0" or "Pre-Project-Activities".
can be handled in a structured manner.Peter A.Koen (2004) argue that in the FFE
for incremental,platform and radical projects,three separate strategies and processes
are typically involved. The traditional Stage Gate (TM) process was designed for
incremental product development,namely for a single product.The FFE for
developing a new platform must start out with a strategic vision of where the
company wants to develop products and this will lead to a family of products.
Projects for breakthrough products start out with a similar strategic vision,but are
associated with technologies which require new discoveries.It is worth mentioning
what are incremental,platform and breakthrough products. Incremental products are
considered to be cost reductions, improvements to existing product lines,additions to
existing platforms and repositioning of existing products introduced in markets.
Breakthrough products are new to the company or new to the world and offer a 5-10
times or greater improvement in performance combined with a 30-50% or greater
reduction in costs. Platform products establish a basic architecture for a next
generation product or process and are substantially larger in scope and resources
than incremental projects (Koen, Peter A., 2004 )
McDonald's financial performance in recent years has suffered from the perceived
dreariness of its traditional menu.
And investors have become afraid of lawsuits from obese customers, some of whom
blame the chain for their expanding waistlines.
'Only the beginning'
"I'm pleased with the strong customer response to our innovative new products,"
said chairman and chief executive Jim Cantalupo.
" But I'm far from satisfied. This upturn reflects only the beginning of our worldwide
revitalisation plan."
Part of this plan is a drive to invest in new products, and to market them
aggressively.
Mr Cantalupo heaped praise on launches such as the "McGriddle" breakfast concept,
and the roll-out of wi-fi internet access in some US restaurants, both of which, he
said, chime with changing lifestyles.
The other part of the recovery plan involves far tighter control of spending.
The pace of restaurant openings is being reined in: last year, the firm opened 1,000
more outlets than it closed; in 2003, the net increase will be just 360.
(www.mcdonalds.com, 2009)
Research indicated that 35% of people who currently do not purchase McDonalds
would do so if they had healthier options as they were cheaper than many other
restaurants. Additional, 67% of existing Customers indicated that they were
concerned about their health and would purchase healthier options if they were
available and attractive. Customers still want to enjoy the eating out experience
during the economic recession and see McDonalds as a viable option. However,
concern over the high fat and calorie content of McDonalds food have deterred
individual who are health conscious and want to eat health. Introducing more
healthy options such as a variety of salads and healthy kids meal can see a potential
increase in McDonalds sales.Introducing healthier options will allow McDonalds to
increase their customer base and attract new customers so that they can expand
through product development.
Marketing Strategy
Ansoff Matrix
The Ansoff matrix is a tool that helps businesses decides their market growth
strategy and their product. It presents distinct opportunities, threats, resource
requirements, returns and risks. (Hollensen, 2003)
Market penetration strategies
This is the most frequently used strategy and focuses on increase market shares. This
can be done by attracting new customers or increasing sales to existing customers.
For example, the introduction of the adult burger and redecorating the restaurant to
make it more attractive to adults.
Market development strategies
This entails marketing existing products to new customer groups and regions. This
strategy requires the full implementation of the marketing and focuses on finding
new markets, distribution channel and promotion strategies as well as products
specialisation. For example,open in new market example Singapore and Hong Kong
and adapting products to suit culture needs.
Diversification Strategies.
This concerns the development of new products for new markets. This is the most
risky options, especially when the entry strategy is not based on core competences of
the business. McDonalds has used vertical integration by purchasing the own potato
farm as well as the factory for production of the own chips.
Marketing Mix
This following marketing mix will be used for McDonalds new Healthier Menu.
Price: due to the unique quality of unique of the products McDonalds will use
a premium pricing strategy with salads and healthy sandwiches. However,
they will maintain their value pricing strategy with regards to the kids meals
as fruits and fruits will be replaces existing foods in the meal package and are
not additionally options. ..
Resources Needed
Financial resources- The development and introduction of a new menu will require
financial investments. McDonalds will either have to source money from existing
funds or from external investors.
Monitoring and review
Sales:- McDonalds will review its sales at the end of 6months to see if there have
been an increase in the number of healthy foods sold as well as overall sales. Volume
of new menu sales will indicate that the new products have been successful and
management can then decide if to continue with the products.
Customer feedback: McDonalds will conduct a post-implementation questionnaire
and focus group to determine what customers think about the healthier menu. This
will give the company and indicate as to whether people like the healthier option.
Also it will tell them if they have attracted new customers and have therefore grown
as a result of the new products
References
1. ^ Ulrich, Karl T. and Eppinger, Steven D (2004) Product Design and
Development, 3rd Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York, 2004
2. ^ Ullman, David G. (2009) The Mechanical Design Process, Mc Graw-Hill, 4th
edition
3. ^ Kim, J. and Wilemon, D. (2002), Sources and assessment of complexity in
NPD projects. R&D Management, 33 (1), pp. 16-30.