Sei sulla pagina 1di 109

HTM 209 Hospitality

Operations Management
Semester Two - 2014

Welcome to HTM 209:


Hospitality Operations Management

Tutor : Julian Galt


Room : B2-24
E mail : julianv.galt@sit.ac.nz

Introduction to HTM 209:


Hospitality Operations Management

What
is this all about?

Management is about getting


things done...;

It is about working with people and other resources to


achieve organisational goals...; and achieving these
goals effectively and efficiently

Operations management...;

Focuses on managing the systems and resources used


to create products and services
Include all activities necessary to fulfil customer needs
Managing operations is central, critical, and demanding
Is one of three core functions of organisations;
marketing; product development; and operations

Operations in an Organization;
The operations function is key to an organization because it
produces the goods and services, but it is neither the only,
nor necessarily the most important, function. The three core
functions of any organization are:

The marketing function responsible for communicating


the organizations product and services to its markets in
order to generate customer request for goods and services.
The product/service development function responsible
for creating new and modified products and services in
order to generate future customers requests.
The operations functions responsible for fulfilling
customer requests for service throughout the production
and delivery of goods and services.

Kitchen unit
manufacturing
operation

Back office
operation in a bank

They are all


operations

Retail operation

Take-out / restaurant
operation

The support functions of any organization are:

The accounting and finance function provides the


information to help economic decision making and
manages the financial resources of the organization
The human resources function - recruits and
develops the organizations staff as well as looking
after their welfare.

In practice, functional names, boundaries


and responsibilities vary significantly
between organizations

Consider operations in practice...;


Think of an international airport that you have
visited. These are characterised by;
Dozens of aircraft movements daily

Crowded terminals
Check-in queues
Transfers of passengers and luggage
...and so on

Airports are a complex network of interlocking


systems...;

The Context...

Considering the airport


example...;

List as many operations that you can think


of that contribute to the effective running of
an airport

Then identify and record...;

The main inputs to operation of a large airport


Key processes that are of priority to travellers
Key processes that are of priority to airlines
The main outputs of an airport operation

Systems view of organisations


Environment
Inputs

Transformation
Process

Feedback

Outputs

If you operated an airport dutyfree shop...; List the inputs, processes,


outputs, and feedback applicable to your business...

Environment
Inputs:

Transformation
Processes:

Feedback:

Outputs:

If you operated an airport dutyfree shop...;

What effects may the environment have on


management of operations? Examples?

For each of your inputs note;

Where they originate from


Who supplies the input, and how

Management issues arising from this situation

How will you achieve alignment between


your inputs, your processes, and outputs?

Consider; why might effective


operations management be
important to an enterprise?
In your groups..;

Discuss this question


Identify several reasons why effective
operations management may be important to
a business

and be prepared to report back

Operations Management is
Important;
Operations management can;

Reduce costs of producing products and


service by being efficient.
Increase revenue by increasing customer
satisfaction through good quality and service.
Reduce need for investment by increasing the
effective capacity of the operation and by being
innovative in how it uses its physical resources
Enhance innovation by building a solid base of
operations skills and knowledge within the
business.

Operations Management is:


The business function responsible
for planning, coordinating, and

controlling the resources needed


to produce products and services

for a company
17

Operations Management is:

A management function

An organizations core function

In every organization whether service or


manufacturing, profit or not for profit

Wiley 2010

18

How...
...do I approach this course?
...treat it as a project;

Project
Management;
What is your purpose?
What is the scope of the work to be
completed?
How is the course organised what
are the requirements?
How is my time best managed?
How do I ensure I get best value out
of the time spent?
What represents quality? What is
expected? Assessment criteria?

Key Challenge #1 Managing Time;


80

70
60
50
40

30
20
10
0

Non-class

Class

Key Challenge #2 Keeping it Real;

Operations management theory and concepts are


not enough...

Application of theory to practice is essential

Keep good records; complete required reading; and


come to class prepared for discussion of set topics

Make a start on the assessment tasks early in the


course much of this work requires you to
demonstrate good practice; a last minute cram
session will not suffice...

References and Resources...;

Course text SIT Bookshop


Course Outline includes assessment
details

Course Readings and Cases, (1) and (2)

SIT Library

The process of management...;


Planning
Resources
Human
Financial
Materials
Technology
Information

Management Functions

Controlling

Organising

Leading

Performance
Goals
Products
Services
Efficiency
Effective

Operations Management is:


The business function responsible

for planning, coordinating, and


controlling the resources needed
to produce products and services
for a company
25

Operations Management is:

A management function

An organizations core function

In every organization whether;

Service or manufacturing

Profit or not for profit


Wiley 2010

26

Operations Management Activities


Direct
(steering)

Develop

Design

(build
capability)

(shaping)

Deliver
(plan/control)

Consider Operations Activities in


Practice: (as applicable to IKEA...;text, pp 5-6)

Read the IKEA case example, note and prepare to report


back from your group on...;

In what ways does the IKEA operations model reduce costs?

In what ways does their operations model increase efficiency?


To what extent does IKEA demonstrate what OM is all about?

Use the case information to complete the following analysis...

Operations
Activity

Examples identified in IKEAs


operation

Direct

Planning to improve customer


service remove bottlenecks

Design
Deliver
Develop

Operations Function

Process design smooth flow

Consider Operations Activities in


Practice: (as applicable to IKEA...;text, pp 5-6)
Operations
Activity

Examples identified in IKEAs


operation

Operations function

Direct

Planning to improve customer


service remove bottlenecks

Improve efficiency and


effectiveness

Design

Improve layout of stores


Stylish flat-pack furniture
Staff contributions
Convenient store location

Process design smooth flow


Product design
Job design
Supply network design

Deliver

Delivery of products to stores


Manage changes in demand
Maintaining stocks

Supply chain management


Capacity management
Inventory management

Develop

Enhancing service to customers


Improving processes, and
practices

Quality management
Operations improvement

Operations Processes...;

Input
Resources

Operations Management

Output
Products

Operations Management Model...;


Direct
(steering)

Input
Resources

Develop

Design

(build
capability)

(shaping)

Operations Management

Deliver
(plan/control)

Output
Products

Consider how this model applies


to your duty-free shop scenario;

Categorise your list of inputs into


transformed and transforming inputs
What transformation of materials and
customers takes place in this operation?
Which elements of the transformation
represent...;

A product?
A service?
Which of these is likely to be of most
importance to the customer?

Inputs to the Process;

Transformed resources resources that are treated,


transformed or converted in the process. They are a
mixture of
Materials
Information
Customers
Transforming resources these are the resources
which act upon the transformed resources. They are two
types:
Facilities
Staff

Within the Process

Materials processing transforms materials physical


properties, location, possession or materials are stored.

Information processing transforms information


properties, possession, location or information is stored.

Customer processing transforms customers physical


properties, location, physiological state, psychological
state or store (accommodate) customers.

Outputs from the Process

Outputs from process can be differentiated between


products and service based organization tangibility of
products and intangibility of services

Most operations produce both products and services

Services and products are merging all operations are


service providers who may produce products as a
means of serving customers.

Psychotherapy clinic

Tangible
Can be stored
Production precedes
consumption
Low customer contact
Can be transported
Quality is evident
Management
consultancy

Computer systems
services

Restaurant

Specialist machine tool


manufacturer

Pure goods
Aluminium smelting

Crude oil production

The output from most types of operation is


a mixture of goods and services

Intangible
Cannot be stored
Production and
consumption are
simultaneous
High customer contact
Cannot be transported
Quality difficult to judge

Pure services

However, when comparing


product with service operations

Both use technology

Both have quality, productivity, & response issues

Both must forecast demand

Both will have capacity, layout, & location issues

Both have customers, suppliers, scheduling and


staffing issues
Manufacturing often provides services
Services often provides tangible goods

Consider how this model


applies to your duty-free
shop processes;
Categorise your processes
to reflect the four Ds, and
provide some examples of
applicable processes...;

Direct

Develop

Operations
Activities

Includes...

Directing

Overall strategy and operations

Designing

Services, products, and


processes

Delivering

Through planning and control

Developing

Improving process
performance; capabilities

Design

Deliver
Examples of processes from
the duty-free scenario

Systems view of organisations


Environment
Inputs

Transformation
Process

Feedback

Outputs

The activities of core functions in some organization


Core functional
activities
Marketing and
sales

Internet service
provider
Promotes service
to users and get
registration
Sell advertising
space

Product/service Device new


services and
development
commission new
information
content

Operations

Maintain
hardware,
software and
content

Fast-food chain

Furniture
manufacturer

Advertise on TV
Device
promotional
materials

Design
hamburgers,
pizzas, etc.
Design dcor for
restaurants

Design new
furniture
Coordinate with
fashionable
colours

Make burgers,
pizzas, etc.
Serve customers
Maintain
equipment

Make
components
Assemble
furniture
Deliver furniture

Advertise in
magazines
Determine pricing
policy
Sell to stores

New Trends in Operations


Management;

Ethics

Global focus

Environmentally sensitive production

Rapid product development

Mass customization

Empowered employees

Supply-chain partnering

Just-in-time performance

From Heizer and Render; 2011


Pearson Education, Inc. publishing
as Prentice Hall

Changing Challenges#1;
Traditional
Approach

Reasons for
Change

Current
Challenge

Ethics and
regulations
not at the
forefront

Public concern over


pollution, corruption,
child labor, etc.

??

Local or
national
focus

Growth of reliable, low


cost communication
and transportation

??

Lengthy
product
development

Shorter life cycles;


growth of global
communication; CAD,
Internet

??

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Changing Challenges#2
Traditional
Approach

Reasons for
Change

Current
Challenge

Low cost
production,
with little
concern for
environment;
free
resources
(air, water)
ignored

Public sensitivity to
environment; ISO
standard; increasing
disposal costs

??

Low-cost
standardized
products

Rise of consumerism;
increased affluence;
individualism

??

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Changing Challenges#3
Traditional
Approach

Reasons for
Change

Current
Challenge

Emphasis on
specialized,
often manual
tasks

Recognition of the
employee's total
contribution; knowledge
society

??

In-house
production;
low-bid
purchasing

Rapid technological
change; increasing
competitive forces

??

Large lot
production

Shorter product life


cycles; increasing need
to reduce inventory

??

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Changing Challenges#1-A;
Traditional
Approach

Reasons for
Change

Current
Challenge

Ethics and
regulations
not at the
forefront

Public concern over


pollution, corruption,
child labor, etc.

Local or
national
focus

Growth of reliable, low


cost communication
and transportation

High ethical and


social
responsibility;
increased legal
and professional
standards
Global focus,
international
collaboration

Lengthy
product
development

Shorter life cycles;


growth of global
communication; CAD,
Internet

Rapid product
development;
design
collaboration

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Changing Challenges#2-A
Traditional
Approach

Reasons for
Change

Current
Challenge

Low cost
production,
with little
concern for
environment;
free
resources
(air, water)
ignored

Public sensitivity to
environment; ISO
standard; increasing
disposal costs

Environmentally
sensitive
production; green
manufacturing;
sustainability

Low-cost
standardized
products

Rise of consumerism;
increased affluence;
individualism

Mass
customization

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Changing Challenges#3-A
Traditional
Approach

Reasons for
Change

Current
Challenge

Emphasis on
specialized,
often manual
tasks

Recognition of the
employee's total
contribution; knowledge
society

Empowered
employees;
enriched jobs

In-house
production;
low-bid
purchasing

Rapid technological
change; increasing
competitive forces

Supply-chain
partnering; joint
ventures,
alliances

Large lot
production

Shorter product life


cycles; increasing need
to reduce inventory

Just-In-Time
performance;
lean; continuous
improvement

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Consider operational processes in


a hospitality context...#1;
Environment
Supply
Chain:

Input
Resources:

Transformation
Processes:

Transformed
Transforming

Operations
management (4 Ds)

Outputs:

Feedback:

For a hospitality business that you familiar with, note and


prepare to report back from your group on...;

The key inputs, transformations, & outputs of this operation

Main sources of supply, & feedback into the system? Examples?

Identify a key environmental factor, & explain the likely impact

Consider operational processes in


a hospitality context...#2;
(Refer to the text, pages 6, and 14 17)

Using your selected hospitality business as an example,


note and prepare to report back from your group on...;

Operations Activities
Process design
Job design
Supply chain
management
Capacity management
Inventory management
Quality management
Operations improvement

Example of Occurrence

Required Processes

The Process Hierarchy;


All macro operations are made up many microoperations.

Micro operations have inputs.


Each micro operation produces outputs of goods and services
for the benefit of customers.
Within each micro operation there might be sections or groups.

Internal customers and internal suppliers

Internal customers take outputs from other micro operations.


Internal suppliers take give inputs to other micro operations.
Each micro operations is an internal customer and internal
supplier.
By treating their internal customers with care the effectiveness
of the operation is improved.

Consider the Process Hierarchy:

...as applicable to a hospitality operation...;


(Refer to the text, pages 18 20, Table 1.4, and Fig 1.6...)

In your groups, and using your selected hospitality


business as an example,

Develop a series of diagrams that illustrate, and then


prepare to explain the concept of the process hierarchy,
and levels of analysis, including...;

Supply network level e.g. All hospitality providers in area


Operation level e.g. Your selected operation
Process level e.g. Your selected business process

Note and explain...;

Network of resources; and network of processes

Levels of analysis

Operations Management Model...;


Direct
(steering)

Input
Resources

Develop

Design

(build
capability)

(shaping)

Operations Management

Deliver
(plan/control)

Output
Products

Consider ways operations differ;


Compare the in-store fast-food dining experience
with hotel restaurant dining:
McDonalds Restaurant
The dining experience...

Hotel Restaurant
The dining experience...

?
?
?

?
Include factors including
volume of patrons, menu,
speed of service,
duration, decor, service...

?
?
?
?
Include factors including
volume of patrons, menu,
speed of service,
duration, decor, service...

Which operation would you


prefer to work in?

In your groups consider and prepare to report on


the following...;

Which operation McDonalds, or a hotel


restaurant - would you prefer to work in?
Note why you have decided this. What are the
advantages and disadvantages of each model...

For those working there


For customers

Complete this analysis for the Formule 1 and


Anatara Bangkok hotel cases that are detailed on
pages 24 25 of the text

Operations Processes Have Different


Characteristics;
Operations processes differ in four distinctive ways:

The volume of their output

The variety of their output

The variation in the demand for their output

The degree of visibility which customers have of the


production of the product or service

Consider ways operations differ;


the 4 Vs characteristics...#1:
(Refer to the text, pages 23 27, and Fig 1.8...)

In your groups, consider the two hotel cases that are detailed on
pages 24 25

Factors
Location
Hotel environment
Construction and decor
Room sizes
Room facilities
Guest services
Food and beverage
Staffing and servicing
Technology

Formule 1

Anatara Bangkok

Consider ways operations differ;


the 4 Vs characteristics...#1-A:
Factors

Formule 1

Anatara Bangkok

Location

Accessible, close to roads


and city road junctions

In tropical gardens near river,


central Bangkok

Hotel environment

Basic and functional

Luxurious

Construction and
decor

Prefabricated, functional,
sound-proof

Cultural features, lavish


building, silk and hardwood

Room sizes

Small, 9 square metres

Large rooms river views

Room facilities

Functional, all the same,


bunk bed

Fine furniture, internet,


electronics, private balconies

Guest services

Minimal service

Full, sensitive service

Food and beverage

Self service check in, short


staff hours, no restaurant,
self serve breakfast

Ten restaurants and bars.


Wide range of cuisine

Staffing and servicing Minimal staff allocation

Many attentive staff

Technology

Guest facilities

High usage, used for


servicing rooms

Compare the 4V attributes...

The volume dimension


High volume means high repeatability people can
specialize
High volume leads to systemization of work
High volume gives lower unit costs

The variety dimension


High variety of products and services offered
High variety increases cost of goods and services
High variety operations must be flexible
Standardization minimizes cost

Compare the 4V attributes...

The variation dimension


Demand for goods and services can change depending
on the external environment seasonal factor
Creates change in resources needed
Activities must be planned effectively forecasting
Variation in demand can increase cost

The visibility dimension


Visibility means process exposure
Customers in a high visibility operation may judge the
operation by their perceptions customer contact skill is
important

A Typology of Operations
IMPLICATIONS
repetition
Each staff member performs
more of job
Less systemization
High unit costs

IMPLICATIONS

Low

High

Low

Volume

High

Flexible

Well

Complex
Match

customer needs
High unit cost
capacity
Anticipation
Flexibility
In touch with demand
High unit cost

repeatability
Specialization
Systemization
Capital intensive
Low unit cost

High

Variety

Low

defined
Routine
Standardized
Regular
Low unit costs

Changing

waiting tolerance
Satisfaction governed by
customer perception
Customer contact skills
needed
Received variety is high
High unit cost

Stable

High Variation in demand

Low

Routine
Predictable
High

utilization
Low unit costs

Short

Time

High

Visibility

Low

(Refer text, page 26)

lag between production


and consumption
Standardized
Low contact skills
High staff utilization
Centralization
Low unit costs

Compare the 4V attributes of


Formule 1, and Anantara Bangkok
Formule 1

Anantara Bangkok

Volume

Volume

Variety

Variety

Variation

Variation

Visibility

Visibility

Then compare your conclusions with Fig 1.9, page 27

Introduction to HTM 209:

HOSPITALITY OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT

TEST:
Concepts and Terminology!
Note two examples of a transforming resource
Note two examples of a transformed resource

1.
2.

Define the 4Ds of operations management


Define the 4Vs; factors that are used to
compare operational processes

3.
4.

For supply network; operation; and process;


which are at

5.

1.
2.

Macro level of analysis?


Micro level of analysis?

1 - 3A:
Operations Management Model
Direct
(steering)

Input
Resources

Develop

Design

(build
capability)

(shaping)

Operations Management

Deliver
(plan/control)

Output
Products

4-A:Operations Processes Have


Different Characteristics;
Operations processes differ in four distinctive ways:

The volume of their output

The variety of their output

The variation in the demand for their output

The degree of visibility which customers have of the


production of the product or service

5-Ai, ii:
The Process Hierarchy;
All macro operations are made up many microoperations.

Micro operations have inputs.


Each micro operation produces outputs of goods and services
for the benefit of customers.
Within each micro operation there might be sections or groups.

Internal customers and internal suppliers

Internal customers take outputs from other micro operations.


Internal suppliers take give inputs to other micro operations.
Each micro operations is an internal customer and internal
supplier.
By treating their internal customers with care the effectiveness
of the operation is improved.

Map the 4V attributes of


McDonalds and a hotel restaurant
Low

Volume

High

High

Variety

Low

High

Variation

Low

High

Visibility

Low

Refer to the example in Fig 1.9, page 27, for guidance...

Consider the tasks & attributes of


a competent operations manager...
Using the information on pages 26, and 28 - 29, note and prepare
to report back from your group on the key tasks and attributes of
an operations manager...;

Tasks:

Attributes:

Operations
Managers..

Consider the tasks & attributes of


a competent operations manager...
Using the information on pages 28 - 29, note attributes of an
operations manager...;
Tasks:
Directing organisation strategy
Designing the organisations
products, services, processes
form, shape, composition
Planning and controlling
delivery from the suppliers to
the customers

Developing process
performance develop
capabilities, and improve
process performance

Attributes:
Understanding the range of
operations responsibilities
Ability to get things done
Understanding customers
knowing how to meet customer
needs effectively
Strong communication skills

Operations
Managers

Ability to learn and improve


Ability to innovate; contribute
Calm under pressure
Strong analytical ability

The Ten Critical Decisions facing


Operations Managers#1
1.

Design of goods and services

2.

What good or service should we offer?


How should we design these products and
services?

Managing quality

How do we define quality?

Who is responsible for quality?

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

The Critical Decisions#2


3.

Process and capacity design

4.

What process and what capacity will these


products require?
What equipment and technology is necessary
for these processes?

Location strategy

Where should we put the facility?


On what criteria should we base the location
decision?

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

The Critical Decisions#3


5.

Layout strategy

6.

How should we arrange the facility?


How large must the facility be to meet our
plan?

Human resources and job design

How do we provide a reasonable work


environment?
How much can we expect our employees to
produce?

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

The Critical Decisions#4


7.

Supply-chain management

8.

Should we make or buy this component?


Who should be our suppliers and how can we
integrate them into our strategy?

Inventory, material requirements planning,


and JIT

How much inventory of each item should we


have?
When do we re-order?

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

The Critical Decisions#5


9.

Intermediate and shortterm scheduling

10.

Are we better off keeping people on the payroll


during slowdowns?
Which jobs do we perform next?

Maintenance

How do we build reliability into our processes?


Who is responsible for maintenance?

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Application of Concepts

SUNBRIGHT OPERATIONS

Application of these process


concepts in a product context...;
Sunbright Outdoor Furniture

Supply
Chain:

Inputs:

Transformation
Processes:

Outputs:

Distrib.
Chain:

Feedback:

For Assessment 1: What are the key inputs, transformations,


and outputs of this business operation?

Sunbright Outdoor Furniture:


products and services...;

What elements of their outputs are services, and


which are products?
Where should we locate Sunbright on a product
service continuum?

(Ref also the text pages 16 17)

Pure
products

Mixture of products
and services
Product Elements

Service Elements

Pure
services

Sunbright Outdoor Furniture...;

Evaluate the new GMs...;

marketing objectives

marketing strategy, and implementation process

Identify the key elements of the supply chain


Assess the impact of the changes occurring in the
distribution chain, and the implications arising
Evaluate the causes, and effects, of the operational
issues arising, including...;

Communications

Supply-chain management

Consider, and then respond to questions 1 3

Sunbright Outdoor
Furniture

Direct

Four D strategies...;
Consider, and then identify
potential improvements to
operating processes;

Develop

Operations
Activities

Includes...

Directing

Overall strategy & operations

Designing

Services, products, and


processes

Delivering

Through planning & control

Developing

Improving process
performance; capabilities

Design

Deliver
Possible strategies to resolve
process issues at Sun-bright

Understanding Customer Needs is


Key to Operations Management...#1;
Consider in your groups, discuss, note and prepare to report back as
follows: (Refer to Slack et al., pp15 & 18)
For the case examples, identify how customer needs are identified, and how
operations are managed to ensure that the business delivers customer value

First Direct (Co-creation):

Pret A Manger (Service):

Customer
Value

Understanding Customer Needs is


Key to Operations Management #1-A;
(Refer to Slack et al., pp15 & 18)
For the case examples, identify how customer needs are identified, and how
operations are managed to ensure that the business delivers customer value

First Direct (Co-creation):

Pret A Manger (Service):

Internet and phone bank

Strong word of mouth

Training in customer care

Training investment, not cost

Invites customer input/advice

Customer
New ideas on website
Value
customers can comment
Direct customer engagement

Customers at heart of

operations learn from this

Sandwich service chain


Invite customer contact
Fast fresh healthy food
Food prepared on site
Focus on building teams who
care about customer service
Weekly review of feedback
Bonus pay for service
Mystery shoppers rate staff
engagement level

Understanding Customer Needs is


Key to Operations Management...#2;
Consider in your groups, discuss, note and
prepare to report back as follows:
(Refer to Slack et al., pp18 and 34)

Complete exercise one on page 34

For part (a), use table 1.4 on page 19 as a guide


For part (b), develop a list of implications with
examples of each
For part (b), be prepared to justify each advantage
and disadvantage

Application of Concepts

SUGAR AND SPICE DESSERTS

Competitive Model Porters 5


Forces

Application to a case study:


Sugar and Spice Desserts #1
Read the case-study from Readings (1)
Develop a brief analysis of the...;

Operating environment opportunities/threats


Direct competition focus on capabilities

Compare the transformation systems applicable


to both Sparkles, and to Sugar and Spice, i.e.;

Inputs
Transformation Processes

Outputs
Note any key similarities and differences

Application to a case study:


Sugar and Spice Desserts #1-A
Operating Environment:
Trendy product rising demand

Small indulgence in a tight economy


High margin business quick and easy to make
Portable and appealing product
Considered relatively healthy
Competitive environment; market entry barriers
low, high threat of new entrants, many substitute
products, and buyers have power / choice

Application to a case study:


Sugar and Spice Desserts #1-A
Factor

Sparkles

Sugar and Spice

Input

Customers mainly general


public, passing traffic.
Ingredients are bulk mixes.
Permanent PT / FT staff.
Facility a specialised bakery.
Inventory planned and based
on previous sales

Corporate customers
High quality product
Wide variety flavour and design
mix and match
Made in apartment, moved to
commercial kitchen. Orders over
phone, large, placed in advance

Transformation Advantage of scale; operates


9 hours / day. Sold off the
shelf in retail outlet. Visibility
and branding

Based on customisation, made to


order. High level of variety and
design. Scale limited to orders recd;
limited by production system

Output

Wide range of product variety


Distributed by courier, or customer
pick-up. Customised at $48/doz...

Ten flavours per day. Low


variety, and rel. high volume.
$36/doz. Store and truck for
distribution. Some specialty
items and merchandise sold

Comparing product service at


Sugar and Spice, and Sparkles #2

Compare the product - service elements of the


two operations featured in the case article

What are the advantages and disadvantages of


Allisons approach to providing service

(Ref also the text pages 16 17)

Pure
products

Mixture of products
and services
Product Elements

Service Elements

Pure
services

The 4 Ds: Sugar and


Spice Desserts #3;
Consider, and then identify
potential improvements to
operating processes;

Direct

Develop

Design

Deliver
Operations
Activities

Includes...

Directing

Overall strategy & operations

Designing

Services, products, and


processes

Delivering

Through planning & control

Developing

Improving process
performance; capabilities

Possible improvement strategies


for Sugar and Spice Desserts

The 4 Ds: Sugar and


Spice Desserts #3-A;
Consider, and then identify potential improvements to
operating processes; (as per text page 26...)
Operations
Activities

Includes...

Possible improvement strategies for


Sugar and Spice Desserts

Directing

Overall strategy &


operations

Develop clear goals and a business model


that will improve efficiency and profitability

Designing

Services, products,
and processes

Identify and remove process bottlenecks


Consider moving to an increased volume of
standardised products

Delivering

Through planning &


control

Manage and control the input;


transformation; output process to maximise
capacity, and use resources more efficiently

Developing

Improving process
performance;
capabilities

Assess options to build capability and


capacity evaluate cost benefit of changes
to production facility, staffing use, marketing

The 4 Vs, at Sugar and Spice;


Volume; Variety; Variation; Visibility #4
Using the information on pages 23 27 of the text,
complete the following analysis;
Element
Volume
Variety
Variation
Visibility

Effect on process,
labour, and costs

Application to
Sugar and Spice

Application to
Sparkles

The 4 Vs, at Sugar and Spice;


Volume; Variety; Variation; Visibility #4-A
Using the information on pages 23 27 of the text, complete;
Element

Effect on process,
labour, and costs

Application to
Sugar and Spice

Application to
Sparkles

Volume

High volume high level of


repeatability and
systematisation; lower unit
costs

Low volume high


cost per item

High volume , lower


unit costs

Variety

Low variety, routine,


defined, standard, lower
unit costs

High variety high


cost

Narrow range which


assists with lowering
costs

Subject to irregular
demand, peaks and
troughs. Cannot hold
stock or capacity;
casual staff

Retail outlets meet


daily demand needs
and smooth
throughput.
Inventory history

Low visibility lower


costs as a result

High visibility for


retail staff, low for
others. Costly facility

Variation Low variation in demand


stable, routine, predictable;
lower cost.
High - requires changing
capacity, ...higher costs

Visibility Exposure to customers if


high, waiting time, staff
attitude are important. Cost

Map the 4V attributes of


Sugar and Spice, and Sparkles #5
Low

Volume

High

High

Variety

Low

High

Variation

Low

High

Visibility

Low

Map the 4V attributes of


, and
#5-A
Low

Volume

High

High

Variety

Low

High

Variation

Low

High

Visibility

Low

Case study: Sugar and Spice


Desserts #6;

Consider the case, and identify issues that


may be of concern to Allison Thatcher;

With regard to operational processes

In terms of competitiveness

For her proposed growth strategy

Case study: Sugar and Spice


Desserts #7;
Consider, note and prepare to report back
as follows:

If you were advising Allison on her business


expansion options, what criteria should she
use to evaluate these alternative strategies?
Assess the suitability of her expansion options

What are the advantages and disadvantages


of each one?

What further information would you need in


order to be able to evaluate these properly?
What should she do, and why?

How may we assess:

PRODUCTIVITY?

Productivity
Units produced
Productivity =

Input used

Factors supporting productivity?


Factors reducing productivity?

Productivity:
Units produced
Productivity =

Input used

Measure of process improvement

Represents output relative to input

Only through productivity increases


can our standard of living improve

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Productivity Calculations
Labour Productivity
Productivity =

=
One

Units produced
Labour-hours used
1,000
250

= 4 units/labour-hour

resource input single-factor productivity

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Multi-Factor Productivity
Output
Productivity =
Labor + Material + Energy
+ Capital + Miscellaneous

Also known as total factor productivity

Output and inputs are often expressed


in dollars

Multiple

resource inputs multi-factor productivity

From Heizer and Render 2011 Pearson


Education, Inc. publishing as Prentice Hall

Case study: Sugar and Spice


Desserts #8;
Consider in your groups, discuss, note and
prepare to report back as follows:
If you were advising Allison on improving
operations management, how might she;

Evaluate her operational processes relative to


her main competitor?

Judge her productivity against that of her main


competitor? (Productivity = Outputs/Inputs)

Factor
Expenditure
Ingredients/dozen
Decoration
Packaging
Ingredient total
Time Required - minutes @ 4 dozen
Time Required - minutes /dozen
Hours per dozen
Labour cost per dozen
Variable Salaries / hourly rate
Fixed Salaries
Total Salaries

Sugar and Spice - Current


Standard
$5.58

$ Total/Month

$0.69
$6.27

Custom
$6.90
$7.20
$0.69
$14.79

55.00
13.75
0.23
$2.98

164.00
41.00
0.68
$8.88

$13.00

Rent

Labour productivity / month


Productivity (dozen per month/ Month Cost)

(138 dozen / $6225.90 in salaries)


(138 dozen / $11266.92 costs)

Month

$2,041.02

$2,041.02

$1,225.90
$5,000.00
$6,225.90

$6,225.90

$3,000.00

$3,000.00

0.0222
0.0122

Total
Income
Price per dozen
Capacity/Volume (dozen)

Total
Balance

$11,266.92

$30.00

$51.00
138.00

$7,038.00

$7,038.00
-$4,228.92

Factor
Expenditure
Ingredients/dozen
Decoration
Packaging
Ingredient total
Time Required - minutes @ 4 dozen
Time Required - minutes /dozen
Hours per dozen
Labour cost per dozen
Variable Salaries / hourly rate
Fixed Salaries
Total Salaries

Sugar and Spice - Projected @400 units


Standard
$5.58
$0.69
$6.27

Custom
$6.90
$7.20
$0.69
$14.79

55.00
13.75
0.23
$2.98

164.00
41.00
0.68
$8.88

$13.00

Rent
Labour productivity / month
Productivity (dozen per month/ Month Cost)

400 / 8553.33
400 / 17469.33

$ Total/Month
Month

$5,916.00

$5,916.00

$3,553.33
$5,000.00
$8,553.33

$8,553.33

$3,000.00

$3,000.00

0.0468
0.0229

Total

Income
Price per dozen
Capacity/Volume (dozen)

Total
Balance

$17,469.33

$51.00
400.00

$20,400.00

$20,400.00
$2,930.67

Factor
Expenditure
Ingredients/dozen
Decoration
Packaging
Ingredient total
Time Required - minutes @ 4 dozen
Time Required - minutes /dozen
Hours per dozen
Labour cost per dozen
Variable Salaries / hourly rate
Fixed Salaries
Total Salaries

Sparkles

$ Total/Month

Standard
$7.95
$0.50
$8.45

Custom
$9.83
$7.20
$0.69
$17.72

36.50
9.13
0.15
$1.98

145.50
36.38
0.61
$7.88

Day

Month

$12.00

Rent
Labour productivity / month
Productivity (dozen per month/ Month
Cost)

$15,210.00

$15,210.00

$3,558.75
$8,750.00
$12,308.75

$12,308.75

$15,000.00

$15,000.00

1800 / 12308.75

0.1462

1800 / 42518.75

0.0423

Total

Income
Price per dozen
Capacity/Volume (dozen)

Total
Balance

$42,518.75

$36.00
60.00

1800.00

$64,800.00

$64,800.00
$22,281.25

HOMEWORK...
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Review the Course Outline document


Consider the assessment requirements carefully...
Readings and cases
Textbook, Slack et. al.; Chapters 1 - 3
Prepare for next sessions

Potrebbero piacerti anche