Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
IN BRIEF
The study revealed substantial problems in oral healthcare of people with mild learning disability
after their resettlement into the community.
Change from institutional living to community-based housing for such a group of adults with
learning disability may be associated with changes in dental attendance and treatment patterns.
In the community, people with such disability were less likely to receive regular dental
examinations and operative dental treatment.
Daily oral hygiene regimes were generally of a satisfactory frequency but only 37% of the clients
and/or their carers had received any oral health education from dental professionals while living
in the community.
Health Care Sciences, UCL, University of London, 256 Grays Inn Road, London WC1X 8LD;
2Senior Dental Officer (Special Care), Northern Lincolnshire and Goole Hospitals NHS Trust
*Correspondence to: Professor Crispian Scully, Eastman Dental Institute for Oral Health
Care Sciences, University College, University of London, 256 Grays Inn Road, London
WC1X 8LD
Email: dean@eastman.ucl.ac.uk
Refereed Paper
Received 22.10.01; Accepted 5.11.02
British Dental Journal 2003; 194: 271277
BRITISH DENTAL JOURNAL VOLUME 194 NO. 5 MARCH 8 2003
disabilities are more severe.2,6,7 In addition people with mild learning disability are more likely to receive restorative dental care
rather than dental extractions compared with those individuals
with profound learning disability.2
Adults with learning disability resident in institutions can have
lower caries levels than those living in community-based or private housing4 despite the former group having poorer oral hygiene
and more periodontal disease4 and significantly poorer oral
hygiene than age-matched individuals who are non-institutionalised.8
In the United Kingdom in the past two decades, many patients
with learning disability have been relocated from long-stay hospital residence into the community, to allow such individuals to live
in more normal and less rigidly institutionalised surroundings.
There have, however, been concerns regarding the subsequent
degree of access to community-based services, including healthcare facilities.9,10 For, example, in one study 106 of 191 adults with
learning disabilities who had been living in the community were
examined and found to have at least one unattended but treatable
medical condition.11
Little is known of the effects of community-based living upon
oral health and the availability of dental services for those people
who have left long-stay institutions. Hence the present study has
examined the changes in oral healthcare of a substantial group of
adult people with learning disability after transference from longstay hospital care to community-based care.
RESEARCH
How long has your client been living under your care?
2.
3.
Check up
Toothache/emergency
Problems with dentures
Treatment
Others (please specify)
5.
You
Client
Client's family/friends
Dentist
Others (please specify)
6.
Examination
Cleaning of teeth
Filling (s)
Extraction (s)
Denture treatment
Others (please specify)
7.
8.
RESULTS
During the period April 1995 until April 1998, 217 clients from
the hospital had been resettled into the community. Of these, 49
had died, returned to the hospital or had moved from their original resettlement address so that their whereabouts were
unknown. In addition a further 11 people had only been living
in the community for less than 6 months. Thus the final intended study group comprised 157 former hospital residents who
had been living in community-based housing for at least 6
months.
After the first mailing, 90 questionnaires were returned,
increasing to 106 with the follow-up mailing, a good final
response rate of 68%. Of these responses concerning 106 individu272
Number (% of group)
74
34
37
16
73
(70)
(32)
(35)
(15)
(69)
RESEARCH
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Dental floss
Mouth washes (please specify which type)
Fluoride supplements
14.
Yes
No
15.
Yes
No
16.
Yes
No
Please specify
Are these problems being dealt with
by a dentist?
Yes
No
Examination
Professional cleaning
Restorative treatment with LA*
Extractions with LA*
Prosthetics
General anaesthesia
Sedation
*LA = local analgesia
Number (% of group)
106
66
19
16
4
3
1
(100)
(62)
(17)
(15)
(4)
(3)
(1)
273
RESEARCH
No
effect
Bad
effect
a) What effect does your client's oral health have on their eating or enjoyment of food?
b) What effect does your client's oral health have on their appearance?
c) What effect does your client's oral health have on their speech?
d) What effect does your client's oral health have on their general health or
general well being?
e) What effect does your client's oral health have on their sleep or ability to relax?
f) What effect does your client's oral health have on their social life?
g) What effect does your client's oral health have on their romantic relationships?
h) What effect does your client's oral health have on their smiling or laughing?
i) What effect does your client oral health have on their confidence (lack of embarrassment)?
j) What effect does your client's oral health have on their carefree manner (lack of worry)?
k) What effect does your client's oral health have on their mood or happiness?
l) What effect does your client's oral health have on their work or ability to do usual jobs?
m) What effect does your client's oral health have on their finances?
n) What effect does your client's oral health have on their personality?
o) What effect does your client's oral health have on their comfort (lack of pain/discomfort)
p) What effect does your client's oral health have on their breath?
Examination
Professional cleaning
Restoration using LA*
Extractions using LA*
Prosthetics
General anaesthesia
Sedation
*LA = local analgesia
Number (% of group)
89 (84)
35 (33)
9 (8)
10 (9)
3 (3)
7 (7)
4 (4)
RESEARCH
While living in the community 52 (49%) individuals had
received some form of operative dental care (including scaling)
during their last course of dental treatment, while when the
same individuals were living at hospital, 72 (68%) had operative treatment in their last course of care (P < 0.01). In particular, only 35 (33%) people had their teeth professionally cleaned
in the community compared with 66 (62%) in the hospital
(P < 0.01).
Despite having lived in the community for at least a year, 17
(16%) people had received no dental examination since resettlement. A further seven patients who had received a dental
examination in the community had not been re-examined by a
dentist for more than a further year. Thus a total of 24 (23%)
people had received no dental examination in the previous 12
months or more whilst living in the community. The perceived
reasons for these findings, as reported by the care staff comprised no need (5 patients, 5%), few or no teeth (11, 10%),
patient anxiety/fear (6, 6%) and lack of patient co-operation
(2, 2%), as shown in Table 4.
No need
Client edentulous/has few teeth
Patient's fears/anxieties
Patient unco-operative
Number (% of group)
5 (5)
11 (10)
6 (6)
2 (2)
275
RESEARCH
Table 5 Person responsible for daily cleaning of the dentate client's teeth
residing in the community (Total n = 70*)
Responsible person
Care staff
Patient
Patient with help from staff
*Only 70 of the 106 patients were fully or partially dentate
Number (% of group)
37 (53)
25 (36)
8 (11)
Bleeding gums
Bad breath
Mouth ulcers
Problems with denture
Broken teeth
Loose teeth
Acid regurgitation from stomach
Number (% of group)
7
2
2
1
1
1
1
(7)
(2)
(2)
(1)
(1)
(1)
(1)
ing that 24% of the present group of patients had not received a
dental examination within the previous year of communitybased living, despite knowledge that they might have been able
to cope with a dental examination, as they had all had dental
care when hospitalised. There is controversy as to the recommended frequency of dental examinations, but at least one
expert has recommended annual examination31 and there is no
reason to suggest it should be carried out less frequently in a
group of individuals who are acknowledged to suffer from dental disease more than the general population.
In the present study the most common reason for an individual not receiving dental care while living in the community possibly reflected a lack of perceived need on behalf of the carers,
particularly if their client had few or no teeth. This observation
tallies with those of other similar studies that indicate that care
staff often do not appreciate the importance of oral health19,32
and/or are unaware of the oral healthcare needs of their
clients.18 In agreement with studies of patients with learning
disabilities resident in the community in the UK14 and Australia29 the present group of patients received dental care from a
general dental practitioner or professional staff of the community dental service, although it is unclear if the choice of dental
clinician reflected the opinions of the carer, degree of physical
disability2,30 or the access or facilities of the clinic. While the
majority of the present group of clients were managed in a clinic, 35% were treated in their homes. The precise reasons for this
high rate of home-based examinations is not evident, but may
reflect patient physical disability and/or limited co-operation,
limited physical access to dental surgeries 20,23,24 or remuneration. However, in contrast to previous relevant studies, as the
majority of patients did at least receive a dental examination it
seems likely that dentists were willing to provide at least some
care for such people.8,12,33
Unsurprisingly the type of treatment provided was influenced
by location. Operative treatments such as scaling, restorations
and extractions were fairly equally prescribed to patients attending local dental surgeries and the health centres. In contrast only
oral examinations and scaling were prescribed to patients during
home visits, although one subject did receive prosthetic treatment
at home. Two people each received sedation in hospital or a health
centre clinic. All general anaesthesia was undertaken in hospital
except for one patient who was treated in a local dental surgery.
276
RESEARCH
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
year outcomes for adults with learning disability discharged to the community. Br J
Psych 1996; 168: 598-606.
Tesini D A, Fenton S J. Oral health needs of persons with physical and mental
disabilities. The Dental Clinics of North America 1984; 38: 483-498.
Wilson K I. Treatment accessibility for physically and mentally handicapped people
a review of the literature. Community Dent Health 1992; 9: 187-192.
Siegal M D. Dentists' reported willingness to treat disabled patients. Special Care Dent
1985; 5: 102-105.
Ferguson F S, Berentsen B, Richardson P S. Dentists' willingness to provide care
for patients with developmental disabilities. Special Care Dent 1991; 11: 234237.
Russell G M, Kinirons M J. A study of the barriers to dental care in a sample of patients
with cerebral palsy. Community Dent Health 1992; 10: 57-64.
Oliver C H, Nunn J H. The accessibility of dental treatment to adults with physical
disabilities in North East England. Special Care Dent 1996; 16: 204-209.
Gordon S M, Dionne R A, Smyder J. Dental fears and anxieties as a barrier to accessing
oral health care among patients with special needs. Special Care Dent 1998; 18:
88-92.
Russell G M, Kinirons M J. The attitudes and experiences of community dental officers
in Northern Ireland in treating disabled people. Community Dent Health 1993; 11:
327-333.
Bickley S R. Dental hygienists' attitudes towards dental care for people with a mental
handicap and their perceptions of the adequacy of their training. Br Dent J 1990;
168: 361-364.
Reedman R, Adams E K, Gelbier S. The provision of primary dental care for patients
with special needs. Primary Dent Care 1997; 4: 31-34.
Scott A, March L, Stokes M L. A survey of oral health in a population of adults with
developmental disabilites: comparison with a national oral health survey of the
general population. Aust Dent J 1998; 43: 257-261.
Francis J R, Stevenson D R, Palmer J D. Dental health and dental care requirements for
young handicapped adults in Wessex. Community Dent Health 1991; 8: 131-137.
Kay E J. How often should we go to the dentist? Br Med J 1999; 319: 204-205.
Glassman P, Miller C, Woznick T, Jones C. A preventive dentistry training program for
caretakers of persons with disabilities residing in community residential facilities.
Special Care Dent 1994; 14: 137-143.
O'Donnell D. The special needs patient. Treatment in general dental practice, is it
feasible? Int Dent J 1996; 46: 315-319.
Shaw M J, Shaw L. The effectiveness of differing dental health education programs in
improving the oral hygiene of adults with mental handicap attending Birmingham
adult training centres. Community Dent Health 1991; 8: 139-145.
277