Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Page 2 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
Mw (Wind moment)
= M_roof + M_shell = 22.449.296 + 1.365.219
= 23.814.515 ft-lbf
W
Page 3 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
MF =
=
=
=
Criteria 1
0,6*(23.814.515) + 0 < (27.067.530 + 365.941)/1,5
Since 14.288.710 < 18.288.980, Tank is stable.
Criteria 2
23.814.515 + 0,4 * 0 < (27.067.530 + 51.938.387)/2
Since 23.814.520 < 39.502.960, Tank is stable.
RESISTANCE TO SLIDING (per API-650 5.11.4)
F_wind = vF * 18 * As
= 0,6944 * 18 * 5.530
= 69.125 lbf
F_friction = Maximum of 40% of Weight of Tank
= 0,4 * (W_Roof_Corroded + W_Shell_Corroded +
W_Btm_Corroded + RoofStruct + W_min_Liquid)
= 0,4 * (83.293 + 303.386 + 197.499 + 101.242 + 7.935.733)
= 3.448.461 lbf
No anchorage needed to resist sliding since
F_friction > F_wind
<Anchorage Requirement>
Anchorage NOT required since Criteria 1, Criteria 2, and Sliding
ARE acceptable.
Page 4 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
SEISMIC CALCULATIONS PER API-650 11TH ED., ADDENDUM 2
< Non ASCE7 (Sp) Method >
WEIGHTS
Ws = Weight of Shell (Incl. Shell Stiffeners & Insul.)
= 307.673 lbf
Wf = Weight of Floor (Incl. Annular Ring)
= 197.499 lbf
Wr = Weight Fixed Roof, framing and 10% of Design Live Load & Insul.
= 297.060 lbf
Page 5 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
SEISMIC VARIABLES
SUG = Seismic Use Group (Importance factor depends on SUG)
= III
Site Class = E
Sp = Design level peak ground acceleration parameter for sites not
addressed by ASCE methods
= 0,44 Decimal %g
Ss = Design Spectral Response Param. (5% damped) for Short Periods
(T=0.2 sec)(Ss = 2.5*Sp per E.4.3 formula E.4.3-1)
= 1,1 Decimal %g
S1 = Design Spectral Response Param. (5% damped) for 1-Second Periods
(T=1.0 sec)(S1 = 1.25*Sp per E.4.3 formula E.4.3-2)
= 0,55 Decimal %g
T_L = Regional Dependent Transition Period for Long Period Ground
Motion
(per API-650 E.4.6.1 for regions outside the USA)
= 4 sec.
Av = Vertical Earthquake Acceleration Coefficient
= 0 Decimal %g
Q = Scaling factor from the MCE to design level spectral accelerations
= 1
Fa = Acceleration-based site coefficient (at .2 sec period)(Table E-1)
= 0,9
Fv = Velocity-based site coefficient (at 1 sec period)(Table E-2)
= 2,4
I = Importance factor defined by Seismic Use Group
= 1,5
Rwi = Force reduction factor for the impulsive mode using allowable
stress design methods.
= 4
Rwc = Force reduction factor for the convective mode using allowable
stress design methods.
= 2
Ci = Coefficient for impulsive period of tank system (Fig E-1)
= 7,58
tu = Equivalent uniform thickness of tank shell
= 0,4282 in.
Density = Density of tank product. SG*62.4
= 57,408 lbf/ft^3
E = Elastic modulus of tank material (bottom shell course)
= 28.799.999 PSI
Sds = The design spectral response acceleration param. (5% damped)
at short periods (T = 0.2 sec) based on ASCE7 methods.
= Q*Fa*Ss
= 1*0,9*1,1
= 0,99 decimal %g
Sd1 = The design spectral response acceleration param. (5% damped)
at 1 second based on ASCE7 methods.
= Q*Fv*S1
= 1*2,4*0,55
= 1,32 decimal %g
Page 6 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
E.4.5 STRUCTURAL PERIOD OF VIBRATION
E.4.5.1 Impulsive Natural Period
Ti = (1/27,8)*(Ci*H)/((tu/D)^0,5)*(Density^0,5/E^0,5)
= (1/27,8)*(7,58*37/((0,4282/140)^0,5)*(57,408^0,5/28.799.999^0,5)
= 0,26 sec.
E.4.5.2 Convective (Sloshing) Period
Ks = 0,578/SQRT(TANH(3,68*H/D))
= 0,578/SQRT(TANH(3,68/3,784))
= 0,6675
Tc = Ks*SQRT(D)
= 0,6675*SQRT(140)
= 7,9 sec.
E.4.6.1 Spectral Acceleration Coefficients
Ai = Impulsive spectral acceleration parameter
= MAX(2.5*Q*Fa*Sp*I/Rwi,0,007,0,6255*Sp*I/Rwi)
= MAX(2,5*1*0,9*0,44*1,5/4,0,007,0,6255*0,44*1,5/4)
= MAX(0,3712,0,007,0,1032)
= 0,3713 decimal %g
K = Coefficient to adjust spectral acceleration from 5% - 0.5% damping
= 1,5
Ac = Convective spectral acceleration parameter
= 2,5*K*Q*Fa*Sp*TS*T_L/Tc^2*I/Rwc
= 2,51,5*1*0,9*0,44*1,3333*4/7,9^2*1,5/2
= 0,0952 decimal %g
E.6.1.1 EFFECTIVE WEIGHT OF PRODUCT
D/H = Ratio of Tank Diameter to Design Liquid Level
= 3,784
Wp = Total Weight of Tank Contents based on S.G.
= 32.706.300 lbf
Wi = Effective Impulsive Portion of the Liquid Weight
= TANH(0,866*D/H)/(0,866*D/H)*Wp
= TANH(0,866*3,784)/(0,866*3,784)*32.706.300
= 9.952.337 lbf
Wc = Effective Convective (Sloshing) Portion of the Liquid Weight
= 0,23*D/H*TANH(3,67*H/D)*Wp
= 0,23*3,784*TANH(3,67/3,784)*32.706.300
= 21.310.240 lbf
Weff = Effective Weight Contributing to Seismic Response
= Wi + Wc
= 31.262.580 lbf
Wrs = Roof Load Acting on Shell, including 10% of Live Load
= 142.279 lbf
Page 7 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
E.6.1 DESIGN LOADS
Vi = Design base shear due to impulsive component from effective
weight
of tank and contents
= Ai*(Ws + Wr + Wf + Wi)
= 0,3713*(307.673 + 297.060 + 197.499 + 9.952.337)
= 3.992.634 lbf
Vc = Design base shear due to convective component of the effective
sloshing weight
= Ac*Wc
= 0,0952*21.310.240
= 2.028.309 lbf
V = Total design base shear
= SQRT(Vi^2 + Vc^2)
= SQRT(3.992.634^2 + 2.028.309^2)
= 4.478.299 lbf
E.6.1.2 CENTER OF ACTION for EFFECTIVE LATERAL FORCES
Xs = Height from Bottom to the Shell's Center of Gravity
= 14,921 ft
RCG = Height from Top of Shell to Roof Center of Gravity
= 1,094 ft
Xr = Height from Bottom of Shell to Roof Center of Gravity
= h + RCG
= 39,5 + 1,094
= 40,594 ft
E.6.1.2.1 CENTER OF ACTION for RINGWALL OVERTURNING MOMENT
Xi = Height to Center of Action of the Lateral Seismic force related
to
the Impulsive Liquid Force for Ringwall Moment
0,375*H
0,375*37
13,88 ft
Height to Center of Action of the Lateral Seismic force related
=
=
=
Xc =
to
the Convective Liquid Force for Ringwall Moment
= (1-(COSH(3,67*H/D)-1)/((3,67*H/D)*SINH(3,67*H/D)))*H
= (1-(COSH(0,9699)-1)/((0,9699)*SINH(0,9699)))*37
= 19,83 ft
E.6.1.2.2 CENTER OF ACTION for SLAB OVERTURNING MOMENT
Xis = Height to Center of Action of the Lateral Seismic force
related to
=
=
=
Xcs =
Page 8 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
E.6.1.4 Dynamic Liquid Hoop Forces
0,75 * D = 105
D/H = 3,784
SHELL SUMMARY
Width
Y
Ni
Nc
ft
ft lbf/in lbf/in
Shell #1
4,5
36 3966,541113,217
Shell #2
5,9
31,5 3881,731124,482
Shell #3
5,9
25,6 3592,62 1163,17
Shell #4
7,9
19,7 3101,641229,891
Shell #5
15,3
11,8 2128,131366,031
Nh
lbf
12391
10884
8908
6932
4286
SigT+
lbf/in
20086
22717
26648
31023
26631
SigTlbf/in
10062
10415
10781
10862
6867
wt =
=
=
=
wint =
=
=
=
Page 9 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
E.6.2.2 Maximum Longitudinal Shell-Membrane Compressive Stress
E.6.2.2.1 Shell Compression in Self-Anchored Tanks
ts1 = Thickness of bottom shell course minus C.A.
= 0,822 in.
SigC = Maximum longitudinal shell compression stress
= ((Wt*(1+0,4*Av) + wa)/(0,607-0,1867*J^2.3) - wa)/(12*ts1)
= ((1.023*(1+0,4*0) + 2.737)/(0,607-0,1867*0,9518^2.3) -
2.737)/(12*0,822)
= 588 psi
E.6.2.2.3 Allowable Longitudinal Shell-Membrane Compression Stress
Fty = Minimum specified yield strength of shell course
= 36.000 psi
G*H*D^2/ts1^2 = 987.420
Fc = Allowable longitudinal shell-membrane compressive stress
= 10^6*ts1/(2,5*D) + 600*(G*H)^0,5
= 10^6*0,822/(2,5*140) + 600*(0,92*37)^0,5
= 5.849 psi
Shell Membrane Compressive Stress OK
E.6.2.4 Hoop Stresses
Shell Summary
SigT+ Sd*1.333 Fy*.9*E Allowable
Membrane
Stress
Shell #1
20086
33168, 32400,
32400,
Shell #2
22717
33168, 32400,
32400,
Shell #3
26648
36492, 32400,
32400,
Shell #4
31023
36492, 32400,
32400,
Shell #5
26631
36492, 32400,
32400,
t-Min Shell OK
0,5096
0,4607
0,3915
0,3169
0,2103
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Page 10 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
E.6.2.2.2 Shell Compression in Mechanically-Anchored Tanks
SigC_anchored = Maximum longitudinal shell compression stress
= (Wt*(1+0,4*Av) + 1,273*Mrw/D^2)/(12*ts1)
= (1.023*(1+0,4*0) + 1,273*70.142.660/140^2)/(12*0,822)
= 566 psi
Fc = longitudinal shell-membrane compression stress
= 5.849 psi
Shell Membrane Compressive Stress OK
Shell Membrane Hoop Stress OK? Verdadero
Tank Adequate with Anchors? Verdadero
E.7 Detailing Requirements
E.7.1 Anchorage
SUG = III
Sds = 0,99 decimal %g
E.7.1.1 Self Anchored
NOTE: Butt-welded annular plates are required.
Annular plates exceeding 3/8 in. thickness shall be butt-welded
The weld of the shell to annular plate shall be checked for
the design uplift load.
E.7.2 Freeboard - Sloshing
TL_sloshing = 4 sec.
I_sloshing = 1,5
Tc = 7,9
K = 1,5
Sd1 = 1,32
Af = K*Sd1*TL/Tc^2
= 1,5*1,32*4/7,9^2
= 0,1269
Delta_s = Height of sloshing wave above max. liquid level
= 0,5*D*Af
= 0,5*140*0,1269
= 8,8832 ft
0,7*Delta_s = 6,2182 ft
Per Table E-7,
A freeboard equal to Delta_s is required unless one of the following
alternatives are provided:
1. Secondary containment is provided to control product spill.
2. The roof and tank shell are designed to contain sloshing liquid.
E.7.6 Sliding Resistance
mu = 0,4 Friction coefficient
V = 4.478.299 lbf
Vs = Resistance to sliding
= mu*(Ws + Wr + Wf + Wp)*(1 - 0,4*Av)
= 0,4*(307.673+297.060+197.499+32.706.300)*(1-0,4*0)
= 13.403.410 lbf
E.7.7 Local Shear Transfer
Vmax = 2*V/(PI*D)
= 2*4.478.299/(PI*140)
= 20.364 lbf/ft
Page 11 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:45
ANCHOR BOLT DESIGN
Bolt Material : A-193 Gr B7
Sy = 105.000 PSI
< Uplift Load Cases, per API-650 Table 5-21b >
D (tank OD) = 140 ft
P (design pressure) = 0 INCHES H2O
Pt (test pressure per F.4.4) = P = 0 INCHES H2O
Pf (failure pressure per F.6) = N.A. (see Uplift Case 3 below)
t_h (roof plate thickness) = 0,25 in.
Mw (Wind Moment) = 23.814.515 ft-lbf
Mrw (Seismic Ringwall Moment) = 70.142.660 ft-lbf
W1 (Dead Load of Shell minus C.A. and Any
Dead Load minus C.A. other than Roof
Plate Acting on Shell)
W2 (Dead Load of Shell minus C.A. and Any
Dead Load minus C.A. including Roof
Plate minus C.A. Acting on Shell)
W3 (Dead Load of New Shell and Any
Dead Load other than Roof
Plate Acting on Shell)
For Tank with Structural Supported Roof,
W1 = Corroded Shell + Shell Insulation
= 303.386 + 0
= 303.386 lbf
W2 = Corroded Shell + Shell Insulation + Corroded Roof Plates
Supported by Shell + Roof Dead Load Supported by Shell
= 303.386 + 0
+ 83.293 * [1 + 2.221.033*-0,0000004/(144 * 157.258)]
= 386.679 lbf
W3 = New Shell + Shell Insulation
= 303.386 + 0
= 303.386 lbf
Uplift Cases 1 to 3 are N.A.
Uplift Case 4: Wind Load Only
PWR = Wind_Uplift/5,208
= 20,8333/5,208
= 4,0003 IN. H2O
PWS = vF * 18
= 0,6944 * 18
= 12,5 lbf/ft^2
MWH = PWS*(D+t_ins/6)*H^2/2
= 12,5*(140+0/6)*39,5^2/2
= 1.365.219 ft-lbf
U = PWR * D^2 * 4,08 + [4 * MWH/D] - W2
= 4,0003*140^2*4,08+[4*1.365.219/140]-386.679
= -27.780 lbf
bt = U / N = -772 lbf
Sd = 0,8 * 105.000 = 84.000 PSI
A_s_r = Bolt Root Area Req'd
A_s_r = N.A., since Load per Bolt is zero.
Page 12 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:46
Uplift Case 5: Seismic
U = [4 * Mrw / D] U = [4 * 70.142.660
= 1.617.397 lbf
bt = U / N = 44.928
Load Only
W2*(1-0,4*Av)
/ 140] - 386.679*(1-0,4*0)
lbf
Page 13 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:46
ANCHOR CHAIR DESIGN
(from AISI 'Steel Plate Engr Data' Dec. 92, Vol. 2, Part VII)
Entered Parameters
Chair Material:
Top Plate Type:
Chair Style:
A-36
DISCRETE
VERT. TAPERED
= 4,000 in.
= 4,000 in.
= 3,000 in.
c
d
e
f
g
h
j
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
2,000 in.
1,000 in.
1,680 in.
0,750 in.
3,000 in.
12,000 in.
0,500 in.
= 0,3130 in.
= 1,3820 in.
= 839,869 in.
P = 67,39 KIPS
Page 14 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:46
e_min = 0,886 * d + 0,572 = 1,458 in.
g_min = d + 1 = 2 in.
f_min = d/2 + 0,125 = 0,625 in.
c_min = SQRT[P / Sd_Chair / f * (0,375 * g - 0,22 * d)]
= SQRT[67,392 / 28,8 / 0,75 * (0,375 * 3 - 0,22 * 1)]
= 1,681 in.
j_min = MAX(0,5, [0,04 * (h - c)])
= MAX(0,5, [0,04 * (12,000 - 2,000)])
= 0,5 in.
b_min = e_min + d + 1/4
= 1,458 + 1 + 1/4
= 2,708 in.
<Stress due to Top Plate Thickness>
S_actual_TopPlate = P / f / c^2 * (0,375 * g - 0,22 * d)
= 67,39/0,75/2^2 * (0,375 * 3 - 0,22 * 1)
= 20,33 KSI
<Repad>
ClearX =
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
yields F5 =
=
yields F4 =
=
yields z =
=
yields F7 =
=
yields F6 =
=
yields F1 =
=
Page 15 of 15
CE&SAC - ANALISIS SISMICO DE TANQUE TK-44
ANCHOR, WIND, AND SEISMIC REPORT: Printed - 02/02/2015 14:42:46
now F2 = 0,031 / SQRT(r * t)
yields F2 = 0,031 / SQRT(839,869 * 1,382)
= 0,0009
yields F3 = 0,0948 + 0,0009
= 0,0957
yields S_actual_ChairHeight = 67,392 * 1,68 / 1,382^2 * 0,0957
= 5,6744 KSI
Maximum Recommended Stress is 25 KSI for the Shell
(per API-650 E.6.2.1.2)
Sd_ChairHeight = 25 KSI
< ANCHOR CHAIR SUMMARY >
S_actual_TopPlate Meets Design Calculations
(within 105% of Sd_Chair)
S_actual_TopPlate/Sd_Chair
= 20,33/36,4101 = 55,8%
S_actual_ChairHeight Meets Design Calculations
(within 105% of Sd_ChairHeight)
S_actual_ChairHeight/Sd_ChairHeight
= 5,6744/25 = 22,7%