(https://www.

facebo
(https://twitter.c
(https://plu
Search...

LIVE
(/cricketlivescore/updatenamibiavpapuanewguineat20/2397/179020

LIVE Cricket Australia:32for0in7.5(R/R:4.27)

(/cricketlivescore/updateenglandvaustraliatest/2325/177940.html)

FIRSTPOST.
(HTTP://WWW.FIRSTPO
Mumbai29(/weather/?utm_source=topnav)

(http://www.firstpost.com/india/3
civilians2bsfmendeadinpakfiring
aheadofpmsjkvisit10keyfacts
2345620.html)

Saturday,July18,2015 | LatestEbook
(http://www.firstpost.com/ebook_download.php)

BAAHUBALISTORM

3 civilians, 2 BSF men

dead in Pak firing
ahead of PMs J&K
visit: 10 key facts
(http://www.firstpost.com/india/3civilians-2-bsf-mendead-in-pak-firingahead-of-pms-jkvisit-10-key-facts2345620.html)

15

TRENDING
ARTICLES

(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/the
curiouscaseofthespydronewhat
indiaandpakistanhavesaidabout
theaerialspy2345634.html)
NEWSTRACKER

Blame game on
between India,
Pakistan over Chin
made 'spy' drone: A
you need to know
(http://www.firstpo
curious-case-of-the
spy-drone-whatindia-and-pakistan
have-said-about-th
aerial-spy2345634.html)

FRONT PAGE (/)

POLITICS (/CATEGORY/POLITICS)
SPORTS (/CATEGORY/SPORTS)
INDIA (/CATEGORY/INDIA)
WORLD (/CATEGORY/WORLD)
BUSINESS (/CATEGORY/BUSINESS)
LIFE (/CATEGORY/LIVING)
ENTERTAINMENT (/CATEGORY/BOLLYWOOD)
Delhi (http://www.firstpost.com/delhi)
Mumbai (http://www.firstpost.com/category/mumbai)
Salon with Tharoor (http://www.firstpost.com/salon)
Baahubali (http://www.firstpost.com/?s=Baahubali)
Property Masters (http://www.firstpost.com/property-masters)
Wimbledon (http://www.firstpost.com/?s=Wimbledon)
IOS(HTTPS://ITUNES.APPLE.COM/IN/APP/FIRSTPOST/ID445829858?MT=8)

ANDROID(HTTPS://PLAY.GOOGLE.COM/STORE/APPS/DETAILS?ID=COM.FIRSTPOST)

WINDOWS(HTTP://APPS.MICROSOFT.COM/WINDOWS/ENIN/APP/E6956E76CE134B01AAAD5CB67B22AA83)

Youarehere: LatestNews(/) IdeasNews(http://www.firstpost.com/category/ideas)

Wendy's revenge: Plagiarism charge against Rajiv

Malhotra is a red herring
byRajeevSrinivasan(http://www.firstpost.com/author/rajeev)Jul18,201520:27IST

#Hinduism(http://www.firstpost.com/tag/hinduism)#Indra'sNet
(http://www.firstpost.com/tag/indrasnet)#Plagiarism(http://www.firstpost.com/tag/plagiarism)
#RajivMalhotra(http://www.firstpost.com/tag/rajivmalhotra)#WendyDoniger
(http://www.firstpost.com/tag/wendydoniger)#WesternAcademics
(http://www.firstpost.com/tag/westernacademics)

114

33

TOP STORIES

Comments
(http://www.firstpost.com/ideas/wendys

revenge
(http://www.addthis.com/bookmark.php)
Email(http://www.addthis.com/bookmark.php)

PrintthisArticle

plagiarism
Therehasbeenalotofcommotionoveronsocialmedialatelyaboutthebookswritten
byIndianAmericanauthorRajivMalhotra,whohassinglehandedlystooduptoforces
inUSacademiawhopaint,accordingtohim,anegative,motivated,andfalsepictureof
Hinduism.Thisisnotapurelyabstractissue,asitimpingesonsoftpower,positioning,
andthemarketingofIndiatotheworld,somethingthatpreviousgovernmentspaid
scarcelyanyattentionto,butthecurrentonedoes.
Toputitsimply,theissueisas
follows:oneRichardFox
Young,apparentlyan
employeeofaChristian

(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/sonias
iftaarpartyrevivescongressregional
outfitbonhomieisitgivingbjpjitters
2349642.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)

Sonias iftaar party revives

Congress-regional outfit
bonhomie: Is it giving BJP jitters?
(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/soniasiftaar-party-revives-congressregional-outfit-bonhomie-is-itgiving-bjp-jitters-2349642.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)

seminaryinPrinceton,NJ,
whereMalhotraalsoresides,
hasgoneonthewarpath
againstMalhotra,accusing
himofplagiarism,basedon
(http://s4.firstpost.in/wp
RajivMalhotra.ImagecourtesyRajivMalhotra'sFacebook
page
content/uploads/2015/07/RajivMalhotra380FB.jpg)

somematerialthatwas
allegedlyquotedwithout
explicitattributioninhis

(http://www.firstpost.com/bollywood/bajrangi
bhaijaanissalmankhansgifttobhaktsthis
eid2349526.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)
ThisEid,Bajrangi
BhaijaanisSalman
Khan'sgifttobhakts

booksIndrasNetandBreakingIndia.YoungscrusadeagainstMalhotraisnotnew:I
personallyhavehadtoblockYoungonTwitterbecausehebombardedmewhenI
supportedMalhotra.

(http://www.firstpost.com/bollywood/bajrangi
bhaijaanissalman
khansgifttobhaktsthis
eid2349526.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)

Now,adisclaimerisinorder:IhaveknownRajivMalhotraforsomeyears,andwehave
correspondedonoccasion,althoughwehavenevermet.WhileIdontagreewithhim
oneverything,IambroadlyinsyncwithhimandIhavehadnofinancialdealings
whatsoeverwithhimoranyentitieswithlinkstohim.Therearefriendsofminewho
disagreewithhimonstyleorsubstance,butwhenitcomestoanexternalattack,weall
standwithRajiv.
Ontakingabrieflookatthewholeimbroglio,Iseeanoldgamebeingrehashed:certain
antiIndiaandantiHinduforcesareatplay,andhavebeen,inacademiaand
elsewhere,forsomeyears.Thereisacertain#DeepStateatplay,whichIalludedtoa
fewmonthsagoinwhenIsuggestedthatIndiahasbeendeemedapartofanew
#AxisOfEvil(http://www.firstpost.com/india/usdeepstateindiasdaughterindia
nowpartnewaxisevil2152087.html).Iseenoreasontochangethatview,asthesame
dramatispersonaeareatworkheretoo:palsoftheUSCIRFColdWarriorsof
religion,focusedonconversions.

(http://www.firstpost.com/world/indian
nationalrajivmohankulshresthaheld
inchinaforallegedterrorlinks
releasedanddeported2349436.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)
IndiannationalRajiv
MohanKulshresthaheld
inChinaforalleged
terrorlinksreleased,
deported
(http://www.firstpost.com/world/indian
nationalrajivmohan
kulshresthaheldin
chinaforallegedterror
linksreleasedand
deported2349436.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)

IwroteaboutthisclashofcivilisationsinFearofEngineering
(http://www.rediff.com/news/2002/nov/01rajeev.htm)in2002,includingthefactof
RajivMalhotra,SankrantSanu,etalstandinguptoentrenchedantipathytowards
HindusinAmericanacademia,ledbydenmotherWendyDonigerFlahertyand
WendysChildren,asMalhotradubbedheracolytes.Whatwasasomewhatobscure
tiffinAmericanacademiathenhasnowbecomequiteanissueinIndianow.
Thereisanevengreaterlink.ThisfussaboutMalhotrasbooksmaybedirectrevenge
forwhathappenedtoWendysbooksafewmonthsago:uponbeingaccusedofhurting
thesentimentsofHindus,herpublisherunilaterallywithdrewherbooksonHinduism,
whichwereallegedlyatravestyoftrueresearch,nottomentionfullofgratuitous
titillationandinsults.MalhotrawasthepersonwhofirstchallengedWendyandher

(http://www.firstpost.com/business/amartya
senrightwrongsocialsectorcutsfm
needsexplain2347660.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)
AmartyaSenwasright
andwrongonsocial
sectorcutstheFMneeds
toexplain
(http://www.firstpost.com/business/amartya
senrightwrongsocial
sectorcutsfmneeds
explain2347660.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)

brood15yearsago,andnowtheobjectiveistobullyhispublisherintowithdrawinghis
books:sweetrevengeindeed.
Thisisaprettygoodtactic,andisanoldone.TheRISAgroupofmostlyAmerican
religiousacademicswhoactasgatekeepersforWesternIndologyhasconsistently
excludedthoseotherthantheirownthroughthespuriousargumentofscholarship.
ThisisdefinedashavingbeenaPhDcandidateunderoneofthem:aclearcaseof
intellectualincest.Indeed,WendyhasspawnedinnicecounterpointtoRomila
ThaparinIndiaanentiregenerationofHinduhatingscholars,bothIndianand
Western.
TheyhavesoughttodenigratetheinsiderperspectiveofHinduism,asexperiencedby
practicingHindusorsympatheticscholars,andlionisedanoutsiderperspective(the

(http://www.firstpost.com/sports/dday
cskrrgoverningcouncilmeets19july
laynewroadmapipl2349870.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)
DDayforCSK,RR:IPL
GoverningCouncilmeets
on19Julytolaynewroad
mapforleague
(http://www.firstpost.com/sports/d
daycskrrgoverning
councilmeets19july
laynewroadmapipl
2349870.html?
utm_source=fp_top_internal)

wordsemicandeticareusedtorefertothesepointsofview)ofhostile
anthropologists(orcolonialadministratorsinBritishRajdays).Forinstance,theyhave
keptoutscholarslikeMichelDanino,quitepossiblytheforemostauthorityonthe
SarasvatiriverandtherebythebestdebunkeroftheentireAryanInvasionFairytale.
Thisisnotsurprising:letusrememberGalileoGalilei,whowasalmostburntatthe
stakeforupsettingthecarefullybuiltupsinecuresofinsiderswhohadmadetheir
careersoutofheliocentrism.
ButthatRISAcitadelisunderattack,asHindus,bothscholarsandlaypeople,have
beguntoquestionthem,turningthemicroscopebackonthem,andassertingthatthe
westernworldviewisnotuniversal(whichMalhotrahasdoneexplicitly,bytreatingthe
WestasanthropologicalspecimenstobeviewedthroughthelensofHindu
philosophicalsystems).

MORESTORIESFROM
RajeevSrinivasan
(http://www.firstpost.com/author/rajeev)
(http://www.firstpost.com/alert.php?
CID=317c313139)

BehindAmartyaSen'soutburst:Anoldman's
oldtrickstograbattention
(http://www.firstpost.com/india/behind
amartyasensoutburstoldmansoldtricks
grabattention2337844.html)
WhatAruvikkarabypollresultmeansfor
Congress,CPM,BJP:someworryforall
(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/aruvikkara
bypollresultmeanscongcpmbjpworry
2325408.html)

No,thewesternviewistrueforallpeopleandforalltime.Anexampleisintheconcept
ofintellectualpropertyrights.Thetraditionalknowledgeandintellectualpropertyof
Hindus,freelygivenbypundits,havebeenquietlyexpropriatedbywesternscholars
(embraceextendexterminate,thefamousMicrosoftstrategy),whothenturnaround
andassertthatitistheirproperty(theUturnHypothesis),forwhichtheyholdIPR.
WesternerszealouslyguardtheirIPRswithpatentsandcopyrightsandsoon.We
remembertheneemandturmericpatents.Thetacticisalsosubtler:theappropriation
ofyogaintoChristianyogathedemonisationofcoconutoilbycleverlycomparing
hydrogenatedcoconutoiltoextravirginoliveandsaffolaoilandsoforth.
Hindushaveadifferent,yetinternallyconsistent,viewofknowledge.Theyhave
traditionallycreatedknowledgeandsimplyputitinthepublicdomainforanyoneto
use,withoutevensigningtheirwork.Isthatwrong?DoesthismeanthatHinduswere
notinnovative?Farfromit.Wedontknowwhoinventedthedecimalsystem(itwas
possiblyBrahmagupta),butdiditbenefitsociety?Yes,itdid,althoughitmaynothave

HowModiiselbowingSonia,Rahul,
CongressfromIndia'sculturalmemes
(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/modi
elbowingsoniarahulcongressindias
culturalmemes2306426.html)
#LalitModiGateisaredherring,thegovt
shouldignoreitwiththecontemptit
deserves
(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/lalitmodigate
isaredherringthegovtshouldignoreit
withthecontemptitdeserves
2304548.html)
Donebeingasoftstate:IndianArmyplaying
avengerinMyanmarisamessagetoChina,
Pakistan
(http://www.firstpost.com/india/done
beingasoftstateindianarmyplaying
avengerinmyanmarisamessagetochina
pakistan2288004.html)
Viewmore(http://www.firstpost.com/author/rajeev)

benefitedBrahmaguptapersonallythroughroyalties,andindeedhemaynothavecared
aboutthemoney,anyway.
IntheWest,too,theriseofUnix/Linuxandopensourcesoftwarehasmadeitclearthat

(http://www.fakingnews.firstpost.com)

copyleftorfreelyopeningupintellectualproperty,isnottheendofcivilisationaswe
knowitonthecontrary,itcanleadtoveryfineproductsandbenefitsociety.Indeed,as
opposedtoMicrosoftsIPRheavyWindows,98percentofusnowcarrymobiledevices
basedontheopensourcephilosophyofUnix/Linux,GNUandtheFreeSoftware
Foundation.Soitsclearthatanalternativepointofviewmaywellbeasvalidasthe
conventionalwisdom.CreativeCommonsisanotherexample.
StayingwithIPRforamoment,letusconsiderthebasisoftheattackonMalhotra:that
hehasplagiarised.InsofarasIcantell,whatheisaccusedofisacceptableunderthe
definitionoffairuseintheUSCopyrightAct1976,17USCSection107,andunderfair
dealingintheIndianCopyrightActof1957,Section52.Ifyouperusetheseprovisions,
youwillfindthatthequotingofcopyrightmaterialsforresearchisallowedwithout
hindrance,asitisforteachingaswell,solongasitisnotusedformonetarybenefitto
theuser.
Thus,thereislittlebasisinfactfortheallegation,apriori,andIsuspectthatif
Malhotrasues,hewillwin.However,itisanexcellenttactic,knownasthrowingsome
mudandseeinghowmuchwillstick.Theobjectiveisnottopenalisethealleged
plagiarism,buttocreatetheimpressionthatMalhotraisintellectuallydishonest,the
equivalentofaccusinghimofafelony,whichwillremainasastainevenifheis
exonerated.ThatistheobjectiveofWendysRevenge:hopefully,itwillcausehimto
selfcensor.
Thistechniquehasbeenusedtodevastatingeffectinthepast.OneexampleistheNun
RapeSyndrome.In1998,therewasabighoohaoveranallegedrapeoffourCatholic
nunsinJhabua,intheforestsofMadhyaPradesh,andHindugroupswereimmediately
accused.Tobehonest,itsnotclearwhytherapeofanunismoreheinousthantherape
ofanylaywoman:its,alas,prettyroutine,justaskSistersAnitaandJesmi
(http://indiafacts.co.in/guesswhoactuallyoppresseschristiansinindia/).Anywayit
turnedoutthattherapistswerethemselvesChristians.Thestorythendisappeared,but
therewerenoapologiesforlibelagainstHindus.

ALSOSEE

ThesamethinghappenedinWestBengalrecently.
Anelderlynunwasallegedlyraped,andsincetheBJP

Plagiarism charge:
isrunningthegovernmentofIndia,blamewas
Why Rajiv Malhotra
is on the gunsights of
immediatelydirectedatHinduorganisations.Thenit
western Indologists
(http://www.firstpost.com/india/rajivturnedoutthattherapistswereMuslims,illegal
malhotras-netBangladeshiimmigrants,andthenunwasalso
plagiarism-chargeshows-no-longerspiritedaway.Onceagain,thestorywassweptunder
man-ignorethecarpet,butnoapologies.
2349652.html)

(http://www.fakingnews.firstpost.com/2015/07/man
planstowatchprokabaddimatches
toboarddelhimetroatrajivchowk
station/?utm_source=fp_widget)
ManplanstowatchProKabaddi
matchestolearnboardingDelhi
MetroatRajivChowkstation
(http://www.fakingnews.firstpost.com/2015/07/man
planstowatchprokabaddi
matchestoboarddelhimetroat
rajivchowkstation/?
utm_source=fp_widget)

Pakistanrunsoutofits
flags,orders1lakhnew
flagsfromKashmir
(http://www.fakingnews.firstpost.com/2015/07/pakistan
runsoutofitsflags
orders1lakhnew
flagsfromkashmir/?
(http://www.fakingnews.firstpost.com/2015/07/pakistan
(http://www.fakingnews.firstpost.c
utm_source=fp_widget)

The Rajiv Malhotra

Interestingly,Indiansepoys,thebrainwashedorthe
debate: Sorry,
mendacious,areintheforefrontoftheattacks.Ihave
plagiarism is not the
vice of only those we
readseveralofthem,andalsodevastatingcounters
dislike
(http://www.firstpost.com/living/thebyMalhotraandDaninoaswellasanexcellentpiece
rajiv-malhotrabyAtanuDey
debate-sorryplagiarism-is-not(http://www.deeshaa.org/2015/07/17/circular
the-vice-of-onlyfiringsquadofflyingattackmonkeystargetrajiv
those-we-dislike2343632.html)
malhotra/)showinguptheirhypocrisy.
Historian Richard
Sadly,IalsofoundtheusualchampionsofFreedom
Fox Young accuses
writer Rajeev
ofSpeechincludingabunchthatwenttoabig
Malhotra of
conferenceinSingaporejustweeksagoonthistopic
plagiarism
(http://www.firstpost.com/living/historianstrangelysilent.Butthatisparforthecourse.They
richard-fox-youngshoutedfromtherooftopsaboutMFHusainsFoS,
accuses-writerrajeev-malhotrabutwerequietaboutTasleemaNasrinsFoS,even
plagiarismwhenshewasmanhandledbysomepeople.They
2331532.html)

wentonandonaboutPerumalMurugansFoS,but
weredeafeninglysilentaboutJoeDCruzsFoS.Thesepoysobviouslyknowwhatto
thinkandwheretheirselectiveoutragemustbedirected:theirhandlersmustbetelling
themregularly.
Thustheentirearsenal(http://www.firstpost.com/topic/organization/arsenalfootball
clubprofile51000.html)ofthe#DeepStatehasbeenbroughtout,includingthesleeper
cells.Thefactthattheallegationsarebaselesswillnotmatter,andthenastieswill
succeedintheirobjectiveofshuttingdownRajivMalhotraunlessallofuswhosupport
ourcivilisationarevocalinourresistance.Tostartwith,youcouldsignthepetitionthat
iscirculatingonlinehere(https://www.change.org/p/publishersofrajivmalhotras
booksdonotyieldtomafiapressuretacticsthatseektocompromiseintellectual
freedom?
recruiter=15510047&utm_source=share_petition&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=share_twitter_responsive).
Butthatisntenough:dogetactiveinfightingback.Thisisjustthetipoftheicebergin
thewitheringassaultonHinducivilisation.

MOREINIDEAS

(http://www.firstpost.com/ideas/shashi(http://www.firstpost.com/ideas/syed(http://www.firstpost.com/living/varuntharoor-sings-slams-media-and- ali-shah-geelani-certainly-isntgandhi-rediscovers-poet-secondopens-up-on-sunanda-5-keyan-indian-but-he-is-not-atime-15-years-2219146.html)
moments-from-firstpost-salonkashmiri-either-2282776.html)
Varun Gandhi rediscovers the
2340480.html)
Syed Ali Shah Geelani certainly
poet in himself - second time in
Shashi Tharoor sings 'Lily The
isn't an Indian; but he is not a
15 years
Pink', slams media, opens up on
Kashmiri either
(http://www.firstpost.com/living/varun-

PROMOTEDSTORIES

10PeopleThatHid
TheirTrueRacial
Identity

MyBigFatGreek
Solution

TheWhoandthe
What

Someincrediblysexist
Irishsayings

TalkMarkets

TheaterMania

IrishCentral

(http://www.talkmarkets.com/content/us
(http://www.theatermania.com/chicago
(http://www.irishcentral.com/culture/craic/Some
markets/mybigfat
theater/reviews/the
incrediblysexistIrish
(http://www.lolwot.com/10
greeksolution?
whoandthewhat
sayings.html?
peoplethathidtheir
post=69054&utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=referral)
victorygardens
utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=content&utm_campaign=paid)
trueracialidentity/?
review_73418.html?
utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=referral)
cid=outbrain)
LOLWOT

Recommendedby

MOREFROMFIRSTPOST

FROMAROUNDTHEWEB

Chinesemangrowsbreastsaftereatingalot
offriedchicken

3millionpeopleintheworldaredescended
fromoneIrishHighKing (IrishCentral)

(http://www.firstpost.com/living/chinese-mangrows-breasts-after-eating-a-lot-of-friedchicken-2348378.html)

(http://www.irishcentral.com/roots/niall-tookno-hostages-43038522-237784201.html)

NarendraModi'ssupertweetthathasthe
Internetinsplits

(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/narendramodis-super-tweet-internet-splits-2332810.html)
HowillisAmma?Rumoursofkidneyailment
swirlasJayalalithaagoesAWOL

The10CommandmentsofAttracting
MillennialstoManufacturing (EBN)

(http://www.ebnonline.com/author.asp?
doc_id=275762&itc=ebnonline_sitedefault&section_id=3219&cid=sem_ob_pv_rss_nc)
MuslimleadersinIrelandsplitonplanto
protestISISatrocities (IrishCentral)

(http://www.firstpost.com/politics/ill-ammarumours-kidney-ailment-swirl-jayalalithaagoes-awol-2339304.html)

(http://www.irishcentral.com/news/Muslims-inIreland-plan-to-gather-in-Dublin-to-protestISIS-atrocities.html?
utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=content&utm_campaign=paid)

Plutohasaheart!NASArevealsmostdetailed
photooftheformerplanet

30OfHistorysMostFamous(AndHilarious)
Insults (All That Is Interesting) (http://all-that-is-

(http://www.firstpost.com/living/pluto-heartnasa-reveals-detailed-photo-former-planet2334126.html)

interesting.com/hilarious-insults?
utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=outbrainglobal)

DharmendrainLBD,Jeetendrainminiskirt:
BaahubalisentushuntingforBollywood's
epiccostumefails (http://www.firstpost.com/?

10DespicableRulersFromHistoryToBe
ThankfulYouDidn'tKnow (LOLWOT)

p=2336260)

(http://www.lolwot.com/10-despicable-rulersfrom-history-to-be-thankful-you-didnt-know/?
utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=referral)

ShashiTharoor:Anuncommontimelineofa
oneofakindpolitician

71HeartwarmingPicturesToRestoreYour
FaithInHumanity (Runt of the Web) (http://runt-

(http://www.firstpost.com/?p=2334834)

of-the-web.com/faith-in-humanity?
utm_source=outbrain&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=outbrainglobal)
Recommendedby

11Comments

FIRSTPOST

Share

Recommend 1

Login

SortbyNewest

Jointhediscussion
DoDiDa aminuteago

WestandwithRajivMalhotra.It'snnotjustanattackonRajivbutanattackon
Indians.
RequesteveryIndiantopleasereadandsignthispetition(Removespaces):
http://www.cinemarasik.com/2015/07/signthispetitionsupportfree
intellectualexpression/

Reply Share

UdayabhanuPanickar 5minutesago

IsaluteyoubothRajivandRajeevthatisMrRajivMalhotraandMrRajeev
Srinivasan.

Reply Share

KrisAntiHypocrisy 9minutesago

Plagarism?Rofl!Youjustneedtocomparekrishnaandjesus.Lookhowsimilarthey
look.Ironyjustdied...

Reply Share

URbecozUthink 13minutesago

Iamincompleteagreementwiththeauthorandhavesignedthepetition...Hopethis
helps,ithasalreadyhelpedmealot....thanksforhelpingushelpourselves
1

Reply Share

IntheMiddle 15minutesago

Ithinkthenun'scasewasaCongressvsBJPissue,whendiditbecomewestvsus?
ButIagreethattheChristianevangelicaltypes(notallofthem,onlytheextremists)are
somethingtobewaryof.Theyarenothingbutabunchofvultures.

Reply Share

FuturaLogic>IntheMiddle 12minutesago

KHANGressGodMOTHERwasSonia,avaticanstooge,vaticanisproxyfor
ChristianWest!Simple!
Christianevangelicaltypes==TERRORISTS!AnyonewhosaysMyGod
takesyoutoheaven,yourstoHellisTerrorizing!That'showTHEY
COLINZED150+countriesexterminatingnativepopulationssometimes!
1

Reply Share

gunse007 26minutesago

abrahamreligionsgoingextinct...churchisEmptyinwesterncountrieswhilemoslems
BZkillingnbombingeachotherduringEidalso....
1

Reply Share

34minutesago


34minutesago

UnderminingHinducultureisnotonlyanagendaoftheWestbutalsotheliberaleliteof
ourowncountrywithHindunames.Petitionswon'tchangeathing.It'shightimewe
stopcaringabouttheirmeaninglessopinions.
1

Reply Share

KinaMinna anhourago

Rajeevsrinivasanisrightthatthisaccusationofpgairismonrajivmalhotrashouldbe
seenassnotherattemptbyantihinduandprojehhadisandprovaaticcanacdemiaof
westerncountriestonsufffoutalloppositiontotheirnefariousconversionandanti
hinduactivitiesallovertheworld.Theantihinduandantiindianmediasposnorredby
followersofsmeticcullltsissslamandchristainityhavebeentryingtheirbestformore
than200yearsandmoretodegrade,denigrateandmalignandblackenandattemtping
togivethenameofanevildogtohindusandhindusim,includingspiritutal,religious
andpoliticalleadersandnonstop24hourfightbytheseforcestoimplicatemodijiand
tomalignhimandblackenhimandtorturehimusingalldirtytricksandusingantihindu
indianmediaandTVchannelsandnespapersandpresttitutesmustbeseeninthis
contexttoo!
Itistimeforallhindusoftheworldtouniteandfighttheacisofjehhadivaaticcanevil
withallmightsothattheyarenotabletogetawaywiththeirdirtynationaland
internationalwaragainsthindusandhinduismanymoretoo!
Allindiansmustreadindianandworldhistroy
ofpast2000yeartoseehowfollowersofhatefilledsEmticterrorcultsissslam
andchristainittyhavedoneGenocidesofmillionsandmilllionsofothersor
seemore

Reply Share

varunreddy2 anhourago

PlagiarismisawaytosilenceMalhotraandtodiscredithisfutureworksasevery
laypersonwilllookathisworkwithsuspicionfromnowon.Ineverunderstandthis
sepoymentalityofmanypeopleofIndia.Mostly,theyareHinduswhoimmediatelysay
theyarenotRSStypeHindus,meaning"wedonthaveanyselfrespectandwewill
supportandevencollaboratewithanyonewhotriestomalignHinduism".
ThesearetheactivesupportersofthisDonigerandmanywesternIndologistswhose
analysisofHindusocietyreeksofasickmindatwork.
IftheysucceedinsilencingRajivMalhotra,thenIguess,weareinforatoughtime
aheadandalsothatwillbeanindicationofhowdeeptheirinfluencerunsinIndiainthe
"intellectual'circlesandthemedia.
TheusualsuspectsTrollandtheusualJehadijournoswhohateanythingIndianor
evenhidetheirownreligionwhileattackingHindusforeveryflimsyreasonareinfull
flowregurgitatingnonsenseandslanderingonSocialmedia.
WhiletheinternetwarriorsofHindusasusualarebusyinpastingscreenshotsof
somemoronicjournalists'stupidtweetsandwritingpunchlinesaboutthem.
6

Reply Share

KinaMinna>varunreddy2 42minutesago

Goodcomment,varunreddy,Sadlythemediapresttitiutesandbrainlessanti
hinduandpesudosickularintellectualsandslavesofjehhadisandvaatiican
agentswillnothesitateeventoselltheirmotherorthemothercountryforafew
thousanddollarsandthatisthegreatestCurseofHindusandhindustannow
too
3

Reply Share

WHAT'STHIS?

AROUNDTHEWEB

LifestyleJournal

WorthyTrend

UniqueMethodRegrowsLost
Hair(DoThisDaily)

5JobsYou'llMake$300k/yr
FromHome

SITEINDEX

(/)

VERTICALS

PLUS

AboutFirstpost
(http://www.firstpost.com/about
firstpost?
utm_source=fp_footer)

FrontPage
(http://www.firstpost.com/?
utm_source=fp_footer)

NewDelhi
SamplePapersOnline
RSSFeeds
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/delhi?
(http://www.topperlearning.com/learn/sample
(http://feeds.feedburner.com/firstpost/xfJh?
utm_source=fp_footer)
papers?ps1)
utm_source=fp_footer)

OTHERS

TOOLS

India
Mumbai
BusinessTechnologyNews
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/india?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/mumbai?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/business/biztech?
Newsletter
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
(http://www.firstpost.com/xtras/subscribe.php?
utm_source=fp_footer)
Politics
Photos
MTVIndia(http://mtv.in.com/?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/politics?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/photos?
utm_source=fp_footer)
RSS
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
(http://feeds.feedburner.com/firstpost/xfJh?
OnlineShoppinginIndia

utm_source=fp_footer)

World
FPExclusives
(http://www.homeshop18.com/?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/world?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/exclusives?
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
ThinkIndia
Business
Cartoons
(http://thinkindia.in.com/?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/business?
(http://www.firstpost.com/cartoon.html?
utm_source=fp_footer)
Facebook
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
(http://www.facebook.com/pages/Firstpost/165818073477856?
DelhiElection2015
utm_source=fp_footer)
Life
VideoRoom
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/delhi?
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/living?
(http://www.firstpost.com/videos/?
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
WorksheetforKids
Bollywood
eBooks
(http://www.topperlearning.com/learn/junior/worksheets/b122e1)
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/bollywood?
(http://www.firstpost.com/ebook_download.php?
utm_source=fp_footer)
utm_source=fp_footer)
Twitter
(http://twitter.com/firstpostin?
utm_source=fp_footer)

Sports
Budget2014
(http://www.firstpost.com/category/sports?
(http://www.firstpost.com/budget
utm_source=fp_footer)
2014/?
utm_source=fp_footer)
Tech
(http://tech.firstpost.com/?
Weather
utm_source=fp_footer)
(http://www.firstpost.com/weather/?
utm_source=fp_footer)
Copyright2014FirstpostAllrightsreserved Termsofuse(/termsofuse) Privacy(/privacy)