SCHOOL OF CIVIL AND ENVIRONMENTAL

ENGINEERING

CVEN4304 Structural Analysis and

Finite Elements
Hand-in 2
Student Name:
Student Number:
Due Date:

Firas MATAR
3279378
14:00, Friday 11th May 2012

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

1 Question 1
1.1 Rayleigh-Ritz Method

Figure 1: Configuration of the problems

Consider the left support as x=0. For the linearly variable distributed load,

q( x ) q 0

q0
x
x q0 ( 1 )
L
L

The trial function to use with the Rayleigh-Ritz method is given as

displacement v( x ) a1 x( L x )
Differentiating once and twice gives

slope

v
a1 ( L 2 x )
x

curvature

2v
2a1
x 2

The potential energy of a general beam is expressed as

L
T
T
1
2 v( x ) 2
p
EI (
)
dx

v
(
x
)
q
(
x
)
dx

{
v
}
{
F
}

} {M }
2
x 2
0
0
L

As there are no concentrated loads on this beam and EI is constant, the potential energy is
expressed as

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

L
L
T
1
2 v( x ) 2
p EI (
)
dx

v
(
x
)
q
(
x
)
dx

} {M }
spring
2 0 x 2
0

In the above equation four terms need to be substituted for. Substitution for the first term
gives
L

1
4
2
EI ( 2a1 )2 dx EIa1 dx
2 0
2
0

2EIa1 L
2

(1)

Substitution for the second term yields

1
U spring ( kD2 )
2
Where D is the deflection at mid span (L/2) and is as follows

D v(

L
L
L
L
) a1 ( )( L ) a1 ( )2
2
2
2
2

Therefore,

1
1
L
U spring ( kD2 ) ka12 ( )4
2
2
2

1 2 4
a1 kL
32

(2)

Now, substituting for the third term, noting that the distributed load q(x) is acting downwards,
therefore,
L

v( x )[ q( x )] dx v( x )q( x )dx a1 x( L x )q0 ( 1

x
)dx
L

a1 and q0 are constants and as a result, the third term is simplified to

L

x
x
x3
a1 x( L x )q0 ( 1 )dx a1q0 x( L x )(1 )dx a1q0 Lx 2 x 2 dx
L
L
L
0
0
0

Integrating and substituting L lets the third term be

1
2
1 x4
1
2
1 L4
a1q0 [ Lx 2 x3 ] xL 0 a1q0 ( L3 L3 )
2
3
4 L
2
3
4 L

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

1
a1q0 L3
12

(3)

As for the fourth term

M [ a1( L 2 x )] M L
And at the point where ML is acting x=L, therefore, the fourth term becomes

M [ a1( L 2L )] M L
M L La1

(4)

Summing equations (1), (2), (3) and (4) yields the potential energy equation,

p 2EIa1 L
2

1 2 4 1
a1 kL a1q0 L3 M L La1
32
12

(5)

Applying the principle of stationary potential energy by differentiating equation (5),

p
a1

4 EIa1 L

1
1
a1kL4 q0 L3 M L L
16
12

(6)

Equating equation (6) to zero to obtain and expression for a1 at the stationary point

0 4EIa1 L

1
1
a1kL4 q0 L3 M L L
16
12

0 a1 [ 4 EIL

a1 [ 4 EIL

1 4
1
kL ] q0 L3 M L L
16
12

1 4
1
kL ] [ q0 L3 M L L ]
16
12

1
q0 L3 M L L
16 3
12
a1

1 4 16 3
4 EIL kL
16

a1

4q0 L3 48M L L
192EIL 3kL4

Equation (7) is now substituted in the trial function given,

(7)

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

v( x )

4q0 L3 48M L L
x( L x )
192EIL 3kL4

Equation (8) represents the approximate deflection distribution.

As a check, substituting x=0 and x=L and x=L/2 in equation (8) gives,

v( 0 )

4q0 L3 48M L L
( 0 )( L 0 ) 0
192EIL 3kL4

v( L )

4q0 L3 48M L L
( L )( L L ) 0
192EIL 3kL4

and

and

v(

4q0 L3 48M L L L
4q0 L3 48M L L L 2 4q0 L4 48M L L2
L
L
)
(
)(
L

( )
2
2
2
2
192EIL 3kL4
192EIL 3kL4
768EI 12kL3

respectively.

(8)

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

2 Question 2
2.1 Plot of the deformed shape of the frame:
Plotting the deformed shape using ANSYS 13 the following are obtained:

Figure 2: ANSYS 13 deformed frame with node numbers

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

Figure 3: ANSYS 13 deformed frame without node numbers

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

2.2 Bending moment diagram of the horizontal beam

First, the members were meshed to eight elements using ANSYS 13. Notice that the
following is using kilo-Newton Metre units. From ANSYS 13 the moments in Table 1 are
found:
Table 1: ANSYS 13 Moments for the 8-element meshed beam
ANSYS 13 Data
BMD
(kNm)
ELEM= 17 MX
MY
MZ
MZ
2 -2.35E-12 2.20E-12
-51791
-51.791
19 2.35E-12 -2.20E-12
1285.1
1.2851
ELEM= 18
19 -1.62E-12 -1.34E-12 -1285.1
-1.2851
20 1.62E-12 1.34E-12
-33596
-33.596
ELEM= 19
20 -8.96E-13 -3.58E-12
33596
33.596
21 8.96E-13 3.58E-12
-52852
-52.852
ELEM= 20
21 -1.69E-13 -4.52E-12
52852
52.852
22 1.69E-13 4.52E-12
-56483
-56.483
ELEM= 21
22 5.58E-13 -4.18E-12
56483
56.483
23 -5.58E-13 4.18E-12
-44489
-44.489
ELEM= 22
23 1.29E-12 -2.54E-12
44489
44.489
24 -1.29E-12 2.54E-12
-16870
-16.87
ELEM= 23
24 2.01E-12 3.93E-13
16870
16.87
25 -2.01E-12 -3.93E-13
26374
26.374
ELEM= 24
25 2.74E-12 4.62E-12
-26374
-26.374
18 -2.74E-12 -4.62E-12
-85243
-85.243
BMD (Nm)

They are plotted against the length of the horizontal beam in Microsoft Excel as such in
Figure 4:

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

Figure 4: Bending Moment diagram for the 8-element mesh horizontal beam
The excel trend line equation is:

M ( x) 20 x 2 93.31x 51.791
dM ( x )
40 x 93.31
dx

0 40 x 93.31

40 x 93.31
x

93.31
2.333
40

Therefore, maximum moment occurs at x=2.333m and it is equal to

M (2.333) 20(2.333) 2 93.31(2.333) 51.791

M (2.333) 57.043
Then, the maximum moment of the horizontal beam is 57.043 kNm

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

For purposes of obtaining more accurate results, a fifteen element mesh for all the elements
is made. The following results are obtained. Note that with the following, the units NewtonMetres are used:
Table 2: Moments log for the 15-element Mesh of the horizontal beam
x [m]

M(x) [Nm]

M(x) [kNm]

0.00
0.33
0.67
1.00
1.33
1.67
2.00
2.33
2.67
3.00
3.33
3.67
4.00
4.33
4.67
5.00

-52420
-23527
922.72
20928
36488
47604
54275
56502
54285
47623
36517
20966
970.57
-23469
-52353
-85682

-52.420
-23.527
0.923
20.928
36.488
47.604
54.275
56.502
54.285
47.623
36.517
20.966
0.971
-23.469
-52.353
-85.682

The following moment diagram is plotted with Microsoft Excel in Figure 5. Also, refer to the
following page for a full page diagram.

Figure 5: Bending Moment diagram for the 15-element mesh horizontal beam
9

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

Figure 5: Bending Moment diagram for the 15-element mesh horizontal beam
10

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

The excel trend line equation is:

M ( x) 20000 x 2 93348x 52420

(9)

Differentiating equation (9) with respect to x yields (10):

(10)

dM ( x)
40000 x 93348
dx
Equating equation (10) to zero gives equation (11):

0 40000 x 93348

(11)

Solving equation (11) gives equation (12):

(12)

93348
2.3337
40000

Therefore, maximum moment occurs at x=2.334m. Substituting this value in equation (9)
gives equations (13) and (14):

M (2.334) 20000(2.334) 2 93348(2.334) 52420

M (2.334) 56503

(13)
(14)

Then, the maximum moment of the horizontal beam is 56503 Nm 56.503 kNm. Lastly;
there is an improvement in the calculated moment using the 15-element mesh over the
moments of the 8-element mesh.

2.3 Location and value of the maximum deflection

From ANSYS 13 the maximum deflections are summarised in Table 3:
Table 3: Maximum Deflections from ASYS 13

Node
Value (m)

X-direction
displacement
(ux)
125
3.23E-03

Y-direction
displacement
(uy)
188
-2.99E-03

Z-direction
displacement
(uz)
0
0

Absolute
Maximum
Deflection
125
3.23E-03

From the ANSYS 13 results, the maximum deflection occurs at node 125. The magnitude of
the deflection is 3.23 millimetres and it is in the positive x-direction.

11

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

Figure 6: Annotated deformed shape

12

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

3 Appendices
3.1 ASYS Log of Nodal Displacements
PRINT U

NODAL SOLUTION PER NODE

44
0.0000
45
0.0000
46
0.0000
62
0.0000
63
0.0000
64
0.0000
65
0.0000
66
0.0000
67
0.0000

***** POST1 NODAL DEGREE OF FREEDOM

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
0
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING DEGREE OF FREEDOM

RESULTS ARE IN THE GLOBAL COORDINATE
SYSTEM
NODE
UZ
1
0.0000
2
0.0000
3
0.0000
4
0.0000
5
0.0000
6
0.0000
7
0.0000
8
0.0000
9
0.0000
10
0.0000
11
0.0000
12
0.0000
13
0.0000
14
0.0000
15
0.0000
16
0.0000
32
0.0000
33
0.0000
34
0.0000
35
0.0000
36
0.0000
37
0.0000
38
0.0000
39
0.0000
40
0.0000
41
0.0000
42
0.0000
43
0.0000

UX
UY
USUM
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.11736E-02-0.68374E-04
0.11756E-02
-0.19174E-05-0.45583E-05
0.49451E-05
-0.39061E-05-0.91166E-05
0.99182E-05
-0.33073E-05-0.13675E-04
0.14069E-04
0.25383E-05-0.18233E-04
0.18409E-04
0.16289E-04-0.22791E-04
0.28014E-04
0.40605E-04-0.27350E-04
0.48957E-04
0.78144E-04-0.31908E-04
0.84408E-04
0.13157E-03-0.36466E-04
0.13653E-03
0.20353E-03-0.41025E-04
0.20762E-03
0.29669E-03-0.45583E-04
0.30017E-03
0.41372E-03-0.50141E-04
0.41674E-03
0.55726E-03-0.54699E-04
0.55994E-03
0.72998E-03-0.59258E-04
0.73238E-03
0.93453E-03-0.63816E-04
0.93671E-03
0.32058E-02-0.81185E-04
0.32069E-02
0.14225E-02-0.69228E-04
0.14242E-02
0.16535E-02-0.70082E-04
0.16550E-02
0.18670E-02-0.70936E-04
0.18684E-02
0.20634E-02-0.71790E-04
0.20647E-02
0.22430E-02-0.72644E-04
0.22442E-02
0.24063E-02-0.73498E-04
0.24074E-02
0.25537E-02-0.74352E-04
0.25547E-02
0.26855E-02-0.75206E-04
0.26865E-02
0.28021E-02-0.76060E-04
0.28031E-02
0.29040E-02-0.76914E-04
0.29050E-02
0.29915E-02-0.77768E-04
0.29925E-02

0.30650E-02-0.78622E-04
0.30661E-02
0.31250E-02-0.79476E-04
0.31260E-02
0.31718E-02-0.80330E-04
0.31728E-02
0.0000
0.0000
0.0000
0.11531E-02-0.80435E-04
0.11559E-02
0.23613E-04-0.53623E-05
0.24215E-04
0.84700E-04-0.10725E-04
0.85376E-04
0.17637E-03-0.16087E-04
0.17710E-03
0.29172E-03-0.21449E-04
0.29251E-03

***** POST1 NODAL DEGREE OF FREEDOM

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
0
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING DEGREE OF FREEDOM

RESULTS ARE IN THE GLOBAL COORDINATE
SYSTEM
NODE
UZ
68
0.0000
69
0.0000
70
0.0000
71
0.0000
72
0.0000
73
0.0000
74
0.0000
75
0.0000
76
0.0000
77
0.0000
93
0.0000
94
0.0000
95
0.0000
96
0.0000
97
0.0000
98
0.0000
99
0.0000
100
0.0000
101
0.0000

13

UX
UY
USUM
0.42388E-03-0.26812E-04
0.42472E-03
0.56593E-03-0.32174E-04
0.56685E-03
0.71101E-03-0.37536E-04
0.71200E-03
0.85220E-03-0.42899E-04
0.85328E-03
0.98262E-03-0.48261E-04
0.98381E-03
0.10954E-02-0.53623E-04
0.10967E-02
0.11836E-02-0.58986E-04
0.11851E-02
0.12404E-02-0.64348E-04
0.12420E-02
0.12588E-02-0.69711E-04
0.12607E-02
0.12320E-02-0.75073E-04
0.12343E-02
0.16677E-02-0.97387E-04
0.16705E-02
0.10595E-02-0.81565E-04
0.10627E-02
0.99518E-03-0.82695E-04
0.99861E-03
0.95744E-03-0.83826E-04
0.96110E-03
0.94383E-03-0.84956E-04
0.94764E-03
0.95182E-03-0.86086E-04
0.95571E-03
0.97891E-03-0.87216E-04
0.98279E-03
0.10226E-02-0.88346E-04
0.10264E-02
0.10803E-02-0.89476E-04
0.10840E-02

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

102
0.0000
103
0.0000
104
0.0000
105
0.0000
106
0.0000
107
0.0000
123
0.0000
124
0.0000
125
0.0000
126
0.0000
127
0.0000
128
0.0000
129
0.0000
130
0.0000
131
0.0000
132
0.0000
133
0.0000
134
0.0000

0.11497E-02-0.90606E-04
0.11532E-02
0.12280E-02-0.91736E-04
0.12314E-02
0.13129E-02-0.92866E-04
0.13162E-02
0.14018E-02-0.93997E-04
0.14050E-02
0.14923E-02-0.95127E-04
0.14953E-02
0.15817E-02-0.96257E-04
0.15847E-02
0.24473E-02 0.65394E-03
0.25332E-02
0.32224E-02-0.99255E-04
0.32239E-02
0.32253E-02-0.10373E-03
0.32269E-02
0.32138E-02-0.93802E-04
0.32151E-02
0.31877E-02-0.69244E-04
0.31884E-02
0.31473E-02-0.30405E-04
0.31474E-02
0.30935E-02 0.21790E-04
0.30936E-02
0.30279E-02 0.85837E-04
0.30291E-02
0.29525E-02 0.15965E-03
0.29568E-02
0.28700E-02 0.24059E-03
0.28801E-02
0.27837E-02 0.32539E-03
0.28026E-02
0.26972E-02 0.41027E-03
0.27282E-02

155
0.0000
156
0.0000
157
0.0000
158
0.0000
159
0.0000
160
0.0000
161
0.0000
162
0.0000
163
0.0000
164
0.0000
165
0.0000
166
0.0000
182
0.0000
183
0.0000
184
0.0000
185
0.0000
186
0.0000
187
0.0000
188
0.0000
189
0.0000
190
0.0000
191
0.0000
192
0.0000
193
0.0000
194
0.0000
195
0.0000

***** POST1 NODAL DEGREE OF FREEDOM

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
0
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING DEGREE OF FREEDOM

RESULTS ARE IN THE GLOBAL COORDINATE
SYSTEM
NODE
UZ
135
0.0000
136
0.0000
137
0.0000
153
0.0000
154
0.0000

UX
UY
USUM
0.26151E-02 0.49081E-03
0.26608E-02
0.25423E-02 0.56207E-03
0.26037E-02
0.24843E-02 0.61848E-03
0.25601E-02
0.17341E-02-0.32829E-04
0.17344E-02
0.17973E-02 0.28452E-04
0.17975E-02

0.18592E-02 0.88468E-04
0.18613E-02
0.19213E-02 0.14865E-03
0.19270E-02
0.19844E-02 0.20986E-03
0.19954E-02
0.20488E-02 0.27238E-03
0.20668E-02
0.21142E-02 0.33590E-03
0.21407E-02
0.21797E-02 0.39955E-03
0.22160E-02
0.22439E-02 0.46188E-03
0.22910E-02
0.23048E-02 0.52085E-03
0.23629E-02
0.23597E-02 0.57386E-03
0.24285E-02
0.24054E-02 0.61773E-03
0.24835E-02
0.24383E-02 0.64869E-03
0.25231E-02
0.24539E-02 0.66239E-03
0.25417E-02
0.11722E-02-0.56915E-03
0.13031E-02
0.11708E-02-0.11401E-02
0.16342E-02
0.11695E-02-0.17093E-02
0.20711E-02
0.11681E-02-0.22181E-02
0.25069E-02
0.11667E-02-0.26206E-02
0.28686E-02
0.11654E-02-0.28841E-02
0.31107E-02
0.11640E-02-0.29892E-02
0.32078E-02
0.11626E-02-0.29292E-02
0.31515E-02
0.11613E-02-0.27106E-02
0.29488E-02
0.11599E-02-0.23530E-02
0.26234E-02
0.11585E-02-0.18891E-02
0.22161E-02
0.11572E-02-0.13646E-02
0.17892E-02
0.11558E-02-0.83825E-03
0.14278E-02
0.11544E-02-0.38189E-03
0.12160E-02

MAXIMUM ABSOLUTE VALUES

NODE
125
188
0
125
VALUE
0.32253E-02-0.29892E-02
0.0000
0.32269E-02

3.2 ANSYS 13 Log of Moments in the Z-direction [For the 15-element

meshed horizontal beam]:
PRINT M
ELEMENT

ELEM=
MZ

ELEMENT SOLUTION PER

MX

MY

1 -0.77868E-14-0.27787E-12
2580.2

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

0.77868E-14 0.27787E-12 -

67.428
ELEM=
MZ

2
3

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

67.428

14

MX

MY

0.69936E-14-0.27787E-12

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

4 -0.69936E-14 0.27787E-12

ELEM=
12 MX
MY
MZ
13 0.15480E-12-0.27787E-12 25060.
14 -0.15480E-12 0.27787E-12
27573.

2445.3
ELEM=
MZ

3
4

MX

MY

0.21774E-13-0.27787E-12 -

2445.3

ELEM=
13 MX
MY
MZ
14 0.16958E-12-0.27787E-12 27573.
15 -0.16958E-12 0.27787E-12
30085.

5 -0.21774E-13 0.27787E-12
4958.1
ELEM=
MZ

4
5

MX

MY

0.36554E-13-0.27787E-12 -

4958.1

ELEM=
14 MX
MY
MZ
15 0.18436E-12-0.27787E-12 30085.
16 -0.18436E-12 0.27787E-12
32598.

6 -0.36554E-13 0.27787E-12
7470.8
ELEM=
MZ

5
6

MX

MY

0.51335E-13-0.27787E-12 -

7470.8

ELEM=
15 MX
MY
MZ
16 0.19914E-12-0.27787E-12 32598.
2 -0.19914E-12 0.27787E-12
35111.

7 -0.51335E-13 0.27787E-12
9983.5
ELEM=
MZ

6
7

MX

MY

0.66115E-13-0.27787E-12 -

9983.5

ELEM=
MZ

8 -0.66115E-13 0.27787E-12
12496.
ELEM=
MZ

7
8

MX

0.80896E-13-0.27787E-12 -

MX

MY

9 0.95676E-13-0.27787E-12 15009.
10 -0.95676E-13 0.27787E-12
17522.

ELEM=
18 MX
MY
MZ
34 -0.96322E-13-0.41315E-13
16562.
35 0.96322E-13 0.41315E-13 16188.

ELEM=
9 MX
MY
MZ
10 0.11046E-12-0.27787E-12 17522.
11 -0.11046E-12 0.27787E-12
20035.
ELEM=
MZ

10

MX

ELEM=
19 MX
MY
MZ
35 -0.94124E-13-0.41315E-13
16188.
36 0.94124E-13 0.41315E-13 15815.

MY

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

MY

ELEM=
17 MX
MY
MZ
33 -0.98519E-13-0.41315E-13
16936.
34 0.98519E-13 0.41315E-13 16562.

9 -0.80896E-13 0.27787E-12
15009.
8

MX

2 -0.10072E-12-0.41315E-13
17309.
33 0.10072E-12 0.41315E-13 16936.

MY

12496.

ELEM=
MZ

16

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

11 0.12524E-12-0.27787E-12 20035.
12 -0.12524E-12 0.27787E-12
22547.

ELEM=
20 MX
MY
MZ
36 -0.91927E-13-0.41315E-13
15815.
37 0.91927E-13 0.41315E-13 15441.

ELEM=
11 MX
MY
MZ
12 0.14002E-12-0.27787E-12 22547.
13 -0.14002E-12 0.27787E-12
25060.

ELEM=
21 MX
MY
MZ
37 -0.89729E-13-0.41315E-13
15441.

15

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

38
15068.

0.89729E-13 0.41315E-13 -

ELEM=
31 MX
MY
MZ
62 0.22745E-12-0.72021E-12 41924.
64 -0.22745E-12 0.72021E-12
35412.

ELEM=
22 MX
MY
MZ
38 -0.87531E-13-0.41315E-13
15068.
39 0.87531E-13 0.41315E-13 14694.

ELEM=
32 MX
MY
MZ
64 0.18914E-12-0.72021E-12 35412.
65 -0.18914E-12 0.72021E-12
28899.

ELEM=
23 MX
MY
MZ
39 -0.85334E-13-0.41315E-13
14694.
40 0.85334E-13 0.41315E-13 14320.

ELEM=
33 MX
MY
MZ
65 0.15083E-12-0.72021E-12 28899.
66 -0.15083E-12 0.72021E-12
22386.

ELEM=
24 MX
MY
MZ
40 -0.83136E-13-0.41315E-13
14320.
41 0.83136E-13 0.41315E-13 13947.

ELEM=
34 MX
MY
MZ
66 0.11252E-12-0.72021E-12 22386.
67 -0.11252E-12 0.72021E-12
15873.

ELEM=
25 MX
MY
MZ
41 -0.80939E-13-0.41315E-13
13947.
42 0.80939E-13 0.41315E-13 13573.

ELEM=
35 MX
MY
MZ
67 0.74215E-13-0.72021E-12 15873.
68 -0.74215E-13 0.72021E-12
9360.6

ELEM=
26 MX
MY
MZ
42 -0.78741E-13-0.41315E-13
13573.
43 0.78741E-13 0.41315E-13 13200.

ELEM=
36 MX
MY
MZ
68 0.35906E-13-0.72021E-12 9360.6
69 -0.35906E-13 0.72021E-12
2847.8

ELEM=
27 MX
MY
MZ
43 -0.76543E-13-0.41315E-13
13200.
44 0.76543E-13 0.41315E-13 12826.

ELEM=
37 MX
MY
MZ
69 -0.24030E-14-0.72021E-12 2847.8
70 0.24030E-14 0.72021E-12 3664.9

ELEM=
28 MX
MY
MZ
44 -0.74346E-13-0.41315E-13
12826.
45 0.74346E-13 0.41315E-13 12452.
ELEM=
MZ

29

MX

ELEM=
38 MX
MY
MZ
70 -0.40712E-13-0.72021E-12
3664.9
71 0.40712E-13 0.72021E-12 10178.

MY

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
0

LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

45 -0.72148E-13-0.41315E-13
12452.
46 0.72148E-13 0.41315E-13 12079.

ELEM=
39 MX
MY
MZ
71 -0.79021E-13-0.72021E-12
10178.
72 0.79021E-13 0.72021E-12 16690.

ELEM=
30 MX
MY
MZ
46 -0.69951E-13-0.41315E-13
12079.
32 0.69951E-13 0.41315E-13 11705.

ELEM=
MZ

16

40

MX

MY

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

72 -0.11733E-12-0.72021E-12
16690.
73 0.11733E-12 0.72021E-12 23203.

ELEM=
50 MX
MY
MZ
97 0.11314E-12-0.26248E-12 20420.
98 -0.11314E-12 0.26248E-12
18047.

ELEM=
41 MX
MY
MZ
73 -0.15564E-12-0.72021E-12
23203.
74 0.15564E-12 0.72021E-12 29716.

ELEM=
51 MX
MY
MZ
98 0.99174E-13-0.26248E-12 18047.
99 -0.99174E-13 0.26248E-12
15673.

ELEM=
42 MX
MY
MZ
74 -0.19395E-12-0.72021E-12
29716.
75 0.19395E-12 0.72021E-12 36229.

ELEM=
52 MX
MY
MZ
99 0.85212E-13-0.26248E-12 15673.
100 -0.85212E-13 0.26248E-12
13300.

ELEM=
43 MX
MY
MZ
75 -0.23226E-12-0.72021E-12
36229.
76 0.23226E-12 0.72021E-12 42741.

ELEM=
53 MX
MY
MZ
100 0.71250E-13-0.26248E-12 13300.
101 -0.71250E-13 0.26248E-12
10926.

ELEM=
44 MX
MY
MZ
76 -0.27057E-12-0.72021E-12
42741.
77 0.27057E-12 0.72021E-12 49254.

ELEM=
54 MX
MY
MZ
101 0.57288E-13-0.26248E-12 10926.
102 -0.57288E-13 0.26248E-12
8552.5

ELEM=
45 MX
MY
MZ
77 -0.30888E-12-0.72021E-12
49254.
63 0.30888E-12 0.72021E-12 55767.

ELEM=
55 MX
MY
MZ
102 0.43326E-13-0.26248E-12 8552.5
103 -0.43326E-13 0.26248E-12
6178.9

ELEM=
46 MX
MY
MZ
63 0.16898E-12-0.26248E-12 29915.
94 -0.16898E-12 0.26248E-12
27541.

ELEM=
56 MX
MY
MZ
103 0.29364E-13-0.26248E-12 6178.9
104 -0.29364E-13 0.26248E-12
3805.3

ELEM=
47 MX
MY
MZ
94 0.15502E-12-0.26248E-12 27541.
95 -0.15502E-12 0.26248E-12
25168.
ELEM=
MZ

48

MX

ELEM=
57 MX
MY
MZ
104 0.15402E-13-0.26248E-12 3805.3
105 -0.15402E-13 0.26248E-12
1431.7

MY

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES
95 0.14106E-12-0.26248E-12 25168.
96 -0.14106E-12 0.26248E-12
22794.

ELEM=
58 MX
MY
MZ
105 0.14403E-14-0.26248E-12 1431.7
106 -0.14403E-14 0.26248E-12 941.95

ELEM=
49 MX
MY
MZ
96 0.12710E-12-0.26248E-12 22794.
97 -0.12710E-12 0.26248E-12
20420.

ELEM=
MZ

17

59

MX

MY

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

106 -0.12522E-13-0.26248E-12
941.95
107 0.12522E-13 0.26248E-12 3315.6

ELEM=
69 MX
MY
MZ
131 -0.22838E-12-0.18477E-12
6798.2
132 0.22838E-12 0.18477E-12 3684.8

ELEM=
60 MX
MY
MZ
107 -0.26484E-13-0.26248E-12
3315.6
93 0.26484E-13 0.26248E-12 5689.2

ELEM=
70 MX
MY
MZ
132 -0.25113E-12-0.23574E-12
3684.8
133 0.25113E-12 0.23574E-12 15.907

ELEM=
61 MX
MY
MZ
32 0.36864E-13 0.13977E-12
11705.
124 -0.36864E-13-0.13977E-12 13036.

ELEM=
71 MX
MY
MZ
133 -0.27158E-12-0.28902E-12
15.907
134 0.27158E-12 0.28902E-12
4208.6

ELEM=
62 MX
MY
MZ
124 -0.43782E-14 0.10729E-12
13036.
125 0.43782E-14-0.10729E-12 13812.

ELEM=
72 MX
MY
MZ
134 -0.28971E-12-0.34461E-12 4208.6
135 0.28971E-12 0.34461E-12
8988.6

ELEM=
63 MX
MY
MZ
125 -0.43310E-13 0.72500E-13
13812.
126 0.43310E-13-0.72500E-13 14032.

ELEM=
73 MX
MY
MZ
135 -0.30554E-12-0.40250E-12 8988.6
136 0.30554E-12 0.40250E-12
14324.

ELEM=
64 MX
MY
MZ
126 -0.79931E-13 0.35398E-13
14032.
127 0.79931E-13-0.35398E-13 13696.

ELEM=
74 MX
MY
MZ
136 -0.31905E-12-0.46271E-12 14324.
137 0.31905E-12 0.46271E-12
20215.

ELEM=
65 MX
MY
MZ
127 -0.11424E-12-0.40151E-14
13696.
128 0.11424E-12 0.40151E-14 12805.

ELEM=
75 MX
MY
MZ
137 -0.33026E-12-0.52523E-12 20215.
123 0.33026E-12 0.52523E-12
26662.

ELEM=
66 MX
MY
MZ
128 -0.14624E-12-0.45739E-13
12805.
129 0.14624E-12 0.45739E-13 11358.
ELEM=
MZ

67

MX

ELEM=
76 MX
MY
MZ
93 -0.18374E-12 0.14678E-12
5689.2
153 0.18374E-12-0.14678E-12 3198.5

MY

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES
129 -0.17593E-12-0.89773E-13
11358.
130 0.17593E-12 0.89773E-13 9356.0

ELEM=
77 MX
MY
MZ
153 -0.13768E-12 0.11912E-12
3198.5
154 0.13768E-12-0.11912E-12 1263.3

ELEM=
68 MX
MY
MZ
130 -0.20331E-12-0.13612E-12
9356.0
131 0.20331E-12 0.13612E-12 6798.2

ELEM=
MZ

18

78

MX

MY

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

154 -0.93922E-13 0.89151E-13
1263.3
155 0.93922E-13-0.89151E-13
116.27

ELEM=
88 MX
MY
MZ
164 0.21654E-12-0.33762E-12
12467.
165 -0.21654E-12 0.33762E-12 16643.

ELEM=
79 MX
MY
MZ
155 -0.52478E-13 0.56872E-13 116.27
156 0.52478E-13-0.56872E-13
940.30

ELEM=
89 MX
MY
MZ
165 0.23488E-12-0.39301E-12
16643.
166 -0.23488E-12 0.39301E-12 21375.

ELEM=
80 MX
MY
MZ
156 -0.13344E-13 0.22283E-13 940.30
157 0.13344E-13-0.22283E-13
1208.8

ELEM=
90 MX
MY
MZ
166 0.25090E-12-0.45070E-12
21375.
123 -0.25090E-12 0.45070E-12 26662.

ELEM=
81 MX
MY
MZ
157 0.23479E-13-0.14617E-13 1208.8
158 -0.23479E-13 0.14617E-13
921.69

ELEM=
MZ

ELEM=
93 MX
MY
MZ
183 0.13273E-11 0.64263E-13
922.72
184 -0.13273E-11-0.64263E-13 20928.

ELEM=
84 MX
MY
MZ
160 0.12008E-12-0.13918E-12
1319.1
161 -0.12008E-12 0.13918E-12 3272.9

ELEM=
94 MX
MY
MZ
184 0.10324E-11 0.16886E-12
20928.
185 -0.10324E-11-0.16886E-12 36488.

ELEM=
85 MX
MY
MZ
161 0.14766E-12-0.18533E-12
3272.9
162 -0.14766E-12 0.18533E-12 5782.2
MX

ELEM=
95 MX
MY
MZ
185 0.73755E-12 0.24732E-12
36488.
186 -0.73755E-12-0.24732E-12 47604.

MY

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

MY

ELEM=
92 MX
MY
MZ
182 0.16222E-11-0.66480E-13 23527.
183 -0.16222E-11 0.66480E-13 922.72

ELEM=
83 MX
MY
MZ
159 0.90192E-13-0.95350E-13 79.051
160 -0.90192E-13 0.95350E-13 1319.1

86

MX

2 0.19171E-11-0.22337E-12 52420.
182 -0.19171E-11 0.22337E-12
23527.

ELEM=
82 MX
MY
MZ
158 0.57991E-13-0.53829E-13 921.69
159 -0.57991E-13 0.53829E-13
79.051

ELEM=
MZ

91

LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES
162 0.17293E-12-0.23378E-12
5782.2
163 -0.17293E-12 0.23378E-12 8847.1

ELEM=
96 MX
MY
MZ
186 0.44266E-12 0.29963E-12
47604.
187 -0.44266E-12-0.29963E-12 54275.

ELEM=
87 MX
MY
MZ
163 0.19589E-12-0.28454E-12
8847.1
164 -0.19589E-12 0.28454E-12 12467.

ELEM=
MZ

19

97

MX

MY

CVEN4304 Hand-in 2

Firas MATAR | 3279378

187 0.14776E-12 0.32581E-12
54275.
188 -0.14776E-12-0.32581E-12 56502.

192 -0.13267E-11 0.64517E-13

20966.
193 0.13267E-11-0.64517E-13 970.57

ELEM=
98 MX
MY
MZ
188 -0.14713E-12 0.32583E-12
56502.
189 0.14713E-12-0.32583E-12 54285.

ELEM=
103 MX
MY
MZ
193 -0.16216E-11-0.66170E-13
970.57
194 0.16216E-11 0.66170E-13
23469.

ELEM=
99 MX
MY
MZ
189 -0.44202E-12 0.29972E-12
54285.
190 0.44202E-12-0.29972E-12 47623.

ELEM=
104 MX
MY
MZ
194 -0.19165E-11-0.22300E-12 23469.
195 0.19165E-11 0.22300E-12
52353.

ELEM=
100 MX
MY
MZ
190 -0.73691E-12 0.24746E-12
47623.
191 0.73691E-12-0.24746E-12 36517.

ELEM=
MZ

102

MX

MX

MY

***** POST1 ELEMENT NODE TOTAL FORCE

LISTING *****
LOAD STEP=
1
TIME=
1.0000

ELEM=
101 MX
MY
MZ
191 -0.10318E-11 0.16906E-12
36517.
192 0.10318E-11-0.16906E-12 20966.
ELEM=
MZ

105

SUBSTEP=
1
LOAD CASE=

THE FOLLOWING X,Y,Z FORCES ARE IN

GLOBAL COORDINATES
195 -0.22114E-11-0.40597E-12 52353.
63 0.22114E-11 0.40597E-12
85682.

MY

20