Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
327
SYPHILIS
EDWARD W. HOOK III
DEFINITION
Syphilis, which is a chronic infectious disease caused by the bacterium Treponema pallidum, is usually acquired by sexual contact with another infected
individual. Syphilis is remarkable among infectious diseases for its large
variety of clinical manifestations. It progresses, if untreated, through primary,
secondary, and tertiary stages. The early stages (i.e., primary and secondary)
are infectious. Spontaneous healing of early lesions occurs, followed by a long
latent period. In about 30% of untreated patients, late disease of the heart,
central nervous system (CNS), or other organs may develop years after the
initial infection. Although the disease is less common now than previously, it
remains a challenge to clinicians because of its protean manifestations, and it
is of interest to biologists because of the prolonged, tenuous balance between
the host and the invading spirochete.
The Pathogen
The causative agent of syphilis, T. pallidum, is closely related to other pathogenic spirochetes (Chapter 328), including those causing yaws (T. pallidum
subspecies pertenue) and pinta (Treponema carateum). T. pallidum is a thin,
helical bacterium approximately 0.15m wide and 6 to 15m long. The
organism has 6 to 14 spirals and is tapered on either end. It is too thin to be
seen by ordinary Gram stain microscopy but can be visualized in wet mounts
by dark-field microscopy or in fixed specimens by silver stain or fluorescent
antibody methods.
Unlike most bacteria, which have protein-rich outer membranes, the
T. pallidum outer membrane appears to be composed of predominantly phospholipids, with few surface-exposed proteins. It has been hypothesized that
because of this structure, syphilis can progress despite the brisk antibody
response to nonsurface-exposed internal antigens, which is the basis for
serologic tests for the diagnosis and management of syphilis. Between the
outer membrane and the peptidoglycan cell wall are six axial fibrils; three are
attached at each end, and they overlap in the center of the organism. They are
structurally and biochemically similar to flagella and are in part responsible
for the organisms motility.
It is possible to culture T. pallidum, but sustained in vitro cultivation is not
yet possible, and yields are very low. Culture is of limited use in research and
of no use in clinical practice. All isolates studied have been susceptible to
1923
penicillin and are antigenically similar. The only known natural hosts for
T. pallidum are humans and certain monkeys and higher apes.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
With the exception of congenital syphilis, syphilis is acquired almost exclusively by intimate contact with the infectious lesions of primary or secondary
syphilis (e.g., chancres, mucous patches, condylomata lata). Disease is usually
acquired through sexual intercourse, including anogenital and orogenital
intercourse. Health care workers are sometimes infected during the unsuspecting examination of patients with infectious lesions. Infection by contact
with fomites is extremely uncommon. Before the advent of modern blood
banking techniques, syphilis was occasionally transmitted through the transfusion of blood from persons with T. pallidum bacteremia, and occasional
parenteral transmission still occurs as a result of the sharing of contaminated
needles.
Syphilis is most common in large cities and in young, sexually active individuals. The highest rate is found in men between the age of 20 and 29 years.
In 2008, 69% of the 3141U.S. counties reported no cases of primary or
secondary syphilis, and just 26 locales accounted for about 50% of all reported
infections. The disease is most prevalent in the Southeast.
Syphilis spares no class, race, or group but is more prevalent among
persons living on the margins of society. U.S. syphilis rates are about eightfold greater in African Americans than in non-Hispanic whites (17.3 vs. 2.2
cases per 100,000 people). Increased numbers of different sexual partners
and perhaps the indiscriminate choice of partners increase the risk of acquiring sexually transmitted disease (Chapter 293). Patients with primary and
secondary syphilis name, on average, nearly three different sexual contacts
within the previous 90 days. A traditional cornerstone of syphilis control has
been the epidemiologic investigation and treatment of sexual contacts of
patients with primary or secondary lesions and patients with early latent
disease. As syphilis has become associated with drug use and anonymous sex,
epidemiologic investigations have become less efficacious.
The incidence of syphilis has generally declined worldwide for more than
100 years, with the exception of periods of war or social upheaval. With the
introduction of penicillin, there was a rapid decline in primary and secondary
syphilis, to approximately 4 cases per 100,000 people in 1957. This decline
was followed by reductions in federal expenditures for syphilis control, which
resulted in a resurgence of infectious primary and secondary syphilis in the
United States; peaks of more than 12 cases per 100,000 people were attained
several times from 1965 through the mid-1990s. Because many cases of
syphilis are not reported, the true incidence is much higher.
Over the past 40 years, syphilis epidemics have occurred serially in at least
three U.S. population subgroups. In the 1970s and 1980s, men who had sex
with other men accounted for a disproportionate number of the total cases
of infectious syphilis. Similar trends occurred in other countries. Then, after
a period of decline, U.S. syphilis rates nearly doubled from 1986 to 1990, with
50,578 cases reported in 1990 in an epidemic disproportionately affecting
multiracial heterosexual men and women and occurring contemporaneously
with an epidemic of crack cocaine use. After 1990, syphilis rates again
declined; in 2001, there were 6103 cases of primary and secondary syphilis
reported, one of the lowest numbers since 1959. The epidemic of the late
1980s probably contributed to the spread of human immunodeficiency virus
(HIV) infection (see Syphilis-HIV Interactions) and to dramatic increases in
the rate of congenital syphilis. Since 2000, syphilis rates have begun to
increase in men, especially men infected with HIV, and they have been
increasing since 2005 in women.
Patients with clinically evident late syphilis, particularly those with cardiovascular or gummatous syphilis, are becoming less common, perhaps as a
result of the effectiveness of penicillin therapy for early syphilis. However,
surveys indicate that there are still significant numbers of patients with
untreated neurologic syphilis, especially in older age groups.
PATHOBIOLOGY
1924
CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS
Primary Syphilis
Secondary Syphilis
Between 4 and 8 weeks after the appearance of the primary chancre, signs
and symptoms of secondary syphilis typically develop. Symptoms may
include malaise, fever, headache, sore throat, and other systemic complaints.
Most patients have generalized lymphadenopathy, including involvement of
the epitrochlear nodes. Approximately 30% of patients have evidence of a
healing chancre, although many patients (including a disproportionate
number of women and of men who have sex with men) give no history of a
primary lesion.
At least 80% of patients with secondary syphilis have cutaneous or
mucocutaneous lesions at some point in their illness. The diagnosis is generally first suspected on the basis of the cutaneous eruption. The rash is
often minimally symptomatic, and many patients with late syphilis do not
recall primary or secondary lesions. The rashes are quite varied in appearance but have certain characteristic features. The lesions are usually widespread, are symmetrical in distribution, and are frequently pink, coppery,
or dusky red (particularly the earliest macular lesions). They are generally
nonpruritic, although occasional exceptions have been reported, and they
are rarely vesicular or bullous in adults. They are indurated, except for the
very earliest macular lesions, and frequently have a superficial scale (i.e.,
papulosquamous lesions). The lesions tend to be polymorphic and rounded,
and on healing, they may leave residual pigmentation or depigmentation.
They may be quite faint and difficult to visualize, particularly on darkskinned individuals.
The earliest pink macular lesions are typically seen on the trunk, with
later spread to the rest of the body. The face is often spared, except around
the mouth. Subsequently, a papular rash appears that is usually generalized
but is quite marked on the palms and soles (Fig. 327-1B). These rashes
are often associated with a superficial scale and may be hyperpigmented.
When the rash occurs on the face, it may be pustular and resemble acne
vulgaris. Occasionally, the scale may be so great that it resembles psoriasis.
Ulceration may occur and produce lesions resembling ecthyma. In malnourished or debilitated patients, extensive and destructive ulcerative lesions
with a heaped-up crust may occur, the so-called rupial lesions. Lesions
around the hair follicles may result in patchy alopecia of the beard or
scalp.
Ringed or annular lesions may occur, especially around the face, and particularly on dark-skinned individuals. A lesion at the angle of the mouth or
the corner of the nose may have a central linear erosion, the so-called split
papule.
The palate and pharynx may be inflamed. In approximately 30% of secondary syphilis patients, so-called mucous patches (Fig. 327-1C) develop; these
slightly raised, oval areas are covered by a grayish white membrane that, when
raised, reveals a pink base that does not bleed. These lesions may be seen on
the genitalia, in the mouth, or on the tongue; like condylomata lata, they are
highly infectious.
In warm, moist areas such as the perineum, large, pale, flat-topped papules
may coalesce to form condylomata lata (Fig. 327-1D). Papules may also be
seen in the axilla and rarely occur in a generalized form. They are extremely
infectious. These papules are not to be confused with the common venereal
warts (i.e., condylomata acuminata), which are small, often multiple, and
more sharply raised than condylomata lata.
Other manifestations of secondary syphilis include hepatitis, which has
been reported in up to 10% of patients in some series. Jaundice is rare, but
an elevated alkaline phosphatase level is common. Liver biopsy reveals small
areas of focal necrosis and mononuclear infiltrate or periportal vasculitis.
Spirochetes can often be visualized with silver stains. Periostitis with widespread lytic lesions of bone has been reported occasionally; bone scanning
appears to be a sensitive test for early syphilitic osteitis. An immune complex
type of nephropathy with transient nephrotic syndrome has been documented rarely. There may be iritis or an anterior uveitis. Between 10 and 30%
of patients have pleocytosis in cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), but symptomatic
meningitis is seen in less than 1% of patients. Symptomatic gastritis may
occur.
Relapsing Syphilis
Latent Syphilis
By definition, latent syphilis is the stage at which there are no clinical signs
of syphilis and the CSF is normal. Latency, which begins when the first attack
of secondary syphilis has passed and may last for a lifetime, is usually detected
by reactive serologic tests for syphilis (see Diagnosis). Congenital syphilis
must also be excluded before the diagnosis of latent syphilis can be made.
Patients may or may not have a clinical history of earlier primary or secondary
syphilis.
Latency has been divided into two stages: early and late. Most infectious
relapses occur in the first year, and epidemiologic evidence shows that the
most infectious period is during the first year of infection. Early latency is
therefore defined as the first year after resolution of the primary or secondary
lesions, or as a newly reactive serologic test for syphilis in an otherwise
asymptomatic individual who has had a negative serologic test within the
preceding year. Late latent syphilis is ordinarily not infectious, except for
pregnant women, who can transmit infection to the fetus after many years.
Most cases of latent syphilis are most accurately called latent syphilis of
unknown duration and should be treated in the same manner as late latent
syphilis (see later).
Late Syphilis
NO. OBSERVED*
72
45
11
13
1
2
44
16
13
15
4
Cardiovascular Syphilis
Neurosyphilis
CNS involvement occurs throughout the natural history of syphilis. Neurosyphilis can be divided into five groups: asymptomatic, syphilitic meningitis,
1925
Acute to subacute aseptic meningitis can occur at any time after the primary
stage, but it usually occurs within the first year of infection. It frequently
involves the base of the brain and may result in unilateral or bilateral cranial
nerve palsies. Mild aseptic meningitis may be relatively common in patients
with early syphilis, but severe disease occurs in only about 1.5% of untreated
patients. Syphilitic meningitis typically resolves without treatment.
Meningovascular Syphilis
Tabes dorsalis, which appears to be far less common than in the pre-penicillin
era, is a slowly progressive, degenerative disease that involves the posterior
columns and posterior roots of the spinal cord and results in progressive loss
of peripheral reflexes, impairment of vibration and position sense, and progressive ataxia. There may be chronic destructive changes in the large joints
of the affected limbs in far-advanced cases (i.e., Charcots joints). Incontinence of the bladder and impotence are common. Sudden and severely
painful crises of uncertain origin are a characteristic part of the syndrome.
These features typically involve the lower extremities but can occur at any
site. Severe, sharp abdominal pain may lead to exploratory surgery. These
attacks may be triggered by exposure to cold or other stresses or may arise
with no obvious precipitating cause.
Optic atrophy is seen in 20% of cases. In 90% of patients, the pupils are
bilaterally small and fail to constrict further in response to light, but they do
respond normally to accommodation (i.e., Argyll Robertson pupils).
The onset of tabes dorsalis is usually first noticed 20 to 30 years after the
initial infection. Its cause is unclear, and spirochetes cannot be demonstrated
in the posterior column or dorsal root.
General Paresis
Syphilis-HIV Interactions
Syphilis, like other genital ulcer diseases, is associated with a three- to fivefold increased risk for acquisition of HIV infection. Presumably, genital ulcers
act as portals of entry through which HIV may more readily infect exposed
individuals. As a result, HIV serologic testing 3 months after a diagnosis of
1926
Congenital Syphilis
DIAGNOSIS
Dark-Field Examination
USE
EIA = enzyme immunoassay; FTA-ABS = fluorescent treponemal antibody absorption test; RPR =
rapid plasma regain test; TP-PA = Treponema pallidumparticle agglutination; VDRL = Venereal
Disease Research Laboratory.
VDRL (%)
70
FTA-ABS (%)
85
TP-PA (%)
50-60
Secondary
99
100
100
Latent or late
70
98
98
Serologic Tests
Two basic types of serologic tests (Table 327-2) are widely used to diagnose
infection with T. pallidum: (1) nontreponemal tests that detect antibodies
reactive with diphosphatidylglycerol (cardiolipin), which is a normal component of many tissues, and (2) tests that detect antibodies to specific treponemal antigens.
Nontreponemal Tests
The standard tests to detect anticardiolipin antibody are the VDRL and rapid
plasma reagin (RPR) tests, which are slide flocculation tests. The VDRL and
RPR are readily quantified, so they are the tests of choice for monitoring
patients responses to treatment. The relative proportion of patients with a
false-positive VDRL result depends on the prevalence of syphilis in the community; the lower the prevalence of syphilis, the higher the proportion of
reactive VDRL test results from nonsyphilitic causes.
The VDRL test begins to turn positive less than 1 week after onset of the
chancre; thus, a nonreactive VDRL test does not exclude primary syphilis,
particularly if the lesion is less than 1 week old. The VDRL test result is positive in 99% of patients with secondary syphilis (Table 327-3). Patients with
advanced HIV infection may have negative test results, and some patients
have such high titers of antibody that they are in antibody excess; dilution of
their serum paradoxically results in conversion of a negative test result to a
positive one, the so-called prozone reaction. VDRL reactivity tends to diminish in later stages of syphilis, and only about 70% of patients with cardiovascular or neurosyphilis have positive VDRL test results.
The quantitative titer of the VDRL or RPR test is somewhat useful in diagnosis and is quite useful for monitoring the therapeutic response. The titer is
reported as the highest dilution that gives a positive response. Most patients
with secondary syphilis have titers of at least 1:16. Most patients with falsepositive VDRL test results have titers of less than 1:8. No single titer is
diagnostic by itself. Significant rises (four-fold or greater) in paired sera,
however, strongly indicate acute syphilis.
Treponemal Tests
Differential Diagnosis
The VDRL or RPR test is reactive in patients with other treponemal diseases
such as pinta, yaws, and endemic syphilis (Chapter 328). These tests may also
be falsely reactive in persons who do not have treponemal infections based
on a negative clinical history or negative results of serum treponemal tests.
Acute (<6 months) false-positive VDRL test results occur with low frequency in patients with atypical pneumonia, malaria, and other bacterial or
viral infections, and they may occur after smallpox or other vaccinations as
well. Chronic false-positive VDRL test results (persisting >6 months) are
relatively common in patients with autoimmune disorders such as systemic
lupus erythematosus (SLE; Chapter 274), parenteral drug users, HIVinfected patients, patients with leprosy, and the aged. Between 8 and 20% of
patients with SLE have false-positive VDRL test results. Chronic false-positive VDRL test results in female patients 20 years or younger indicate a significant risk for the future development of SLE, thyroiditis, or other
autoimmune disorders. As many as a third of parenteral drug users have
1927
false-positive VDRL test results. More than 1% of persons 70 years old and
10% of those older than 80 also have low-titer, false-positive VDRL test
results. In most cases of false-positive VDRL tests, the titer is less than 1:8,
although a few patients with lymphoma and other diseases have very hightiter, false-positive results.
There is also an increased incidence of false-positive treponemal test
results in other chronic inflammatory diseases associated with hyperglobulinemia, including rheumatoid arthritis and biliary cirrhosis. Occasionally,
reproducible positive FTA-ABS results are obtained in patients with no clinical or historical evidence of syphilis and no evidence of diseases typically
associated with false-positive FTA-ABS results. If the diagnosis is in doubt
and if the patient is not allergic to penicillin, it is often prudent to treat for
possible syphilis.
Neurosyphilis
Congenital Syphilis
TREATMENT
T. pallidum is inhibited by less than 0.01g/mL of penicillin G. Because
treponemes divide slowly and penicillin acts only on dividing cells, it is necessary to maintain serum levels of penicillin for many days (Table 327-4).
Early syphilis (<1 year) can be treated with a single injection of 2.4 million
U of benzathine penicillin G, which provides low but effective serum levels for
more than 2 weeks and cures approximately 95% of patients. It is not necessary to examine CSF at this stage because penicillin prevents the later development of neurosyphilis.
Individuals with other sexually transmitted diseases may have been exposed
to syphilis at the time they became infected. Treatment with a single dose of
-lactam antibiotics (penicillins, cephalosporins), which provide relatively high
1928
TABLE 327-4 PENICILLIN TREATMENT FOR SYPHILIS AS RECOMMENDED BY THE U.S. PUBLIC HEALTH SERVICE
Dosage and Administration
BENZATHINE PENICILLIN G
Total of 2.4 million U; single IM dose of two
injections of 1.2 million U in one session
Congenital
Infants
Older children
Individual doses can be divided for injection in each buttock to minimize discomfort.
For aqueous penicillin, give in two divided intravenous doses per day; for procaine penicillin, give as one daily dose intramuscularly.
CSF = cerebrospinal fluid.
serum levels for a brief period, is ineffective in established early syphilis but is
curative if the disease is still in the incubating stage. The ceftriaxone regimen
used for gonorrhea (Chapter 307) is probably curative for incubating syphilis,
but careful follow-up is indicated if there is reason to suspect exposure to
syphilis in a patient treated for gonorrhea with ceftriaxone. Single-dose
therapy with 2.0g of azithromycin administered orally was as effective as
benzathine penicillin therapy in several studies of early syphilis, but treatment
failures have been reported in persons with coexistent HIV infection.1 Currently, azithromycin should not be used for the treatment of early syphilis
unless close follow-up can be ensured.
For patients allergic to penicillin, 100mg of doxycycline orally twice daily
for 14 days is recommended. Particularly careful follow-up is necessary for
patients treated with drugs other than penicillin because they may not be fully
compliant with these prolonged courses of oral therapy and these regimens
have been less fully evaluated clinically. Ceftriaxone, given in doses of 500mg
to 1.0g intramuscularly daily for 10 days, may be effective but has been
studied only in small numbers of patients with syphilis. Quinolone antibiotics
have essentially no effect on syphilis.
Syphilis in Pregnancy
Prolonged therapy with intramuscular injections of 2.4 million U of benzathine penicillin G weekly for 3 weeks is recommended for the treatment
of late latent syphilis and latent syphilis of unknown duration. Limited evidence suggests that treating latent syphilis with a total dose of 7.2 million
U of benzathine penicillin over a 3-week period is curative, even if the patient
has asymptomatic neurosyphilis. However, because of the possible lack of
efficacy of benzathine penicillin G in some patients with CNS syphilis, CSF
examination should be considered in those with latent syphilis to exclude
asymptomatic neurosyphilis, particularly HIV-positive patients, in whom the
prevalence of asymptomatic neurosyphilis is higher. Alternatively, a lumbar
puncture can be performed at the conclusion of the follow-up period
(2 years); if the CSF is normal, the patient can be reassured that neurosyphilis
will not develop.
Larger doses of penicillin are recommended for persons with proven neurosyphilis (see Table 327-4). General paresis responds well to penicillin therapy
if administered early, although progressive neurologic decline may develop
later in as many as a third of treated patients. Carbamazepine in doses of 400
to 800mg/day reportedly treats the lightning pains of tabes dorsalis effectively. Published studies show that a total of 6.0 to 9.0 million U of penicillin G
results in a satisfactory clinical response in approximately 90% of patients with
neurosyphilis who do not have HIV infection. There are anecdotal reports of
increased treatment failures in patients with concomitant HIV infection, and
there is considerable rationale to treat these patients with intravenous penicillin G (20 million U/day for at least 10 days). Therapy for neurosyphilis can result
in increased CSF pleocytosis for 7 to 10 days after starting treatment and may
transiently convert a normal CSF to abnormal.
Although there is no evidence that therapy with antimicrobial drugs is clinically beneficial in patients with cardiovascular syphilis, treatment is recommended to prevent further progression of disease and because approximately
15% of patients with cardiovascular syphilis have associated neurosyphilis. If
patients are allergic to penicillin, it is mandatory that the CSF be examined
before therapy is undertaken; if the CSF is abnormal, desensitization to penicillin is generally recommended. With a normal CSF, tetracycline (500mg orally
four times a day) or doxycycline (100mg orally two times a day) taken for 4
weeks is probably effective.
Congenital Syphilis
Jarisch-Herxheimer Reactions
PREVENTION
PROGNOSIS
Follow-up Examinations
1. Hook EW, Behets F, Van Damme K, et al. A phase III equivalence trial of azithromycin versus benzathine penicillin G for treatment of early syphilis. J Infect Dis. 2010;201:1729-1735.
SUGGESTED READINGS
French P, Gomberg M, Janier M, et al. IUSTI: 2008 European guidelines on the management of syphilis.
Int J STD AIDS. 2009;20:300-309. Consensus guidelines.
Tucker JD, Bu J, Brown LB, et al. Accelerating worldwide syphilis screening through rapid testing: a
systematic review. Lancet Infect Dis. 2010;10:381-386. Review of several available rapid tests, with a
focus on the best evaluated immunochromatographic strip test to detect Treponema antibody.
Wolff T, Shelton E, Sessions C, et al. Screening for syphilis infection in pregnant women: evidence for
the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force reaffirmation recommendation statement. Ann Intern Med.
2009; 150:710-716. New evidence to support universal screening of pregnant women for syphilis.
Workowski KA, Berman S; Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Sexually transmitted
diseases treatment guidelines, 2010. MMWR Recomm Rep. 2010;59:1-110. National recommendations.