Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
org/sceaStudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014
TheImprovementofBitumenPropertiesby
AddingNanoSilica
FarhadZafari1,MohammadRahi2,NazaninMoshtagh3,HosseinNazockdast4
HeadofResearchandDevelopmentDepartment,PasargadCompany,Tehran,Iran
PolymerEngineeringDepartment,AmirkabirUniversityofTechnology,Tehran,Iran
2,3
AssociatedProfessor,PolymerEngineeringDepartment,AmirkabirUniversityofTechnology,Tehran,Iran
farhad_zafari@yahoo.com;2mohamadrahi@yahoo.com;3nazanin.moshtaq@gmail.com;4nazdast@aut.ac.ir
1
Abstract
Asphalt oxidative aging is one of the prevalent causes of
pavementdistresseswhichincreasepavementsusceptibility
to fatigue andlow temperature cracking. This phenomenon
is mainly studied through oxidation kinetics and through
evaluating oxygen diffusivity rate into asphalt binders.
Whileoxidativeaginginpavementisinevitable,application
of antiaging additives shown to be an effective method in
delayingoxidativeaging.Assuchthispaperinvestigatesthe
meritofapplicationofnanosilicaasanantiagingadditive.
To do so, different percentages of nanosilica was added to
neat asphalt binder. Asphalt binder was then exposed to
short term oxidative aging using a rolling thin film oven
(RTFO). To study the change in the chemical, rheological
andmorphologicalpropertiesofasphaltbindersinpresence
of nanosilica, the Superpave tests, Fourier transform
infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) as well as SEM imaging were
conducted. The FTIR study shows that nanosilica can
improve the aging resistance of the asphalt binder as
reflectedinlowerlevelofcarboxylicacids(observedat1400
1440cm1)andsulfoxide(observedat~1050cm1)innano
silicamodifiedspecimencomparedtothoseinnonmodified
specimens. Carboxylic acids occur naturally in asphalt;
however its concentration has been known to be increased
significantly due to oxidative aging. This in turn reduces
oxidation aging in modified asphalt. In addition, it was
foundthatpresenceofnanosilicasignificantlyincreasesthe
complex modulus (G*) and complex viscosity (*) of the
asphaltbinder.Thisinturnimprovespavementresistanceto
rutting. It was concluded that introduction of nanosilica to
asphalt binder can improve the antiaging property, rutting
performanceandrheologicalpropertiesofasphaltbinder.
Keywords
Nanosilica;NanoModifiedAsphalt;Rheology;Aging
Introduction
Thechemicalcompositionofasphaltisquitecomplex,
therefore,researchersmainlyusepercentagesofSARA
(Saturates, Asphaltene, Resin and Aromatic) to
compare various asphalt binder produced from
different origins. Composition of each asphalt binder
62
StudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014www.seipub.org/scea
Whentheasphalttemperaturereachedto180o98C,
specified amount of nanosilica was added to the
can and mixing for two hours. Using this
procedure one neat sample and three nanosilica
modifiedasphalt(NSMA)sampleswereproduced.
For simplicity in referring to each sample, they
were named using following abbreviation: NEAT,
NSMA2%, NSMA4% and NSMA6%. To ensure
nanosilicaparticlesaredisperseduniformlywithin
the asphalt matrix. The Scanning Electron
Microscopy (SEM) images of asphalt were mainly
usedtounderstandthemicrostructuralchangesof
modified samples and to evaluate the matrix
structure such as the physical dispersion of nano
silica particles (Kavussi and Barghabani, 2014). As
can be clearly seen in FIGURE 1, nanosilica
particlesarewelldispersedintheasphaltmatrix.
(a)
MaterialsandTestMethods
This section will describe various materials used in
thisstudyaswellasthesourcesofeachmaterialand
itspreparationmethod.
1)
(b)
MaterialsandSamplePreparation
(c)
FIGURE1SEMMICROSTRUCTUREIMAGESOFNANOSILICA,
NEATANDNANOSILICAMODIFIEDASPHALTAT18000X
MAGNIFICATION,(A)NSMA2%,(B)NSMA4%AND
(C)NSMA6%
63
www.seipub.org/sceaStudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014
2)
AgingProcedure
TABLE1CONVENTIONALPROPERTIESOFNEATANDNANOSILICA
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDERS
Sample
NEAT
NSMA2%
NSMA4%
NSMA6%
2)
Penetration Softening
(mm)
point(oC)
58
47
56
50.5
50
54.1
43
58
Ductility
(cm)
>150
93
53
27
Elastic
recovery(%)
12
16
19
23
StorageStability
BasicPhysicalProperties
64
Sample
NEAT
NSMA2%
NSMA4%
NSMA6%
Top
47.8
52.5
57.3
61.9
SofteningPoint(oC)
Bottom
SPtopSPBottom
47.8
0
52.4
0.1
57.6
0.3
91.6
0.6
TABLE2showsthesofteningpointsofthetopand
bottomspecimensandthedifferencebetweenthese
twotemperatures.AscanbeobservedfromTABLE
2, the differences between the top and bottom
softening points in all samples are less than 2.5C.
This indicates that nanosilica modified specimens
have appropriate storage stability. Therefore
addition of nanosilica into asphalt will not
negatively affect storage stability of the modified
samples.
DynamicRheologicalCharacterization
1)
FrequencySweep
StudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014www.seipub.org/scea
silicaconcentration.Ananosilicamodifiedasphalt
binderwithhighviscositycanleadtodevelopment
ofathickerfilmsurroundingtheaggregateswhich
increases the cohesive strength. This in turn can
promotepavementdurability.
(a)
(a)
(b)
FIGURE3THEISOCHRONALPLOTSOFCOMPLEXVISCOSITY
VERSUSTEMPERATUREAT10RAD/S,(A)UNAGEDNEAT
ANDMODIFIEDASPHALTBINDERAND(B)AGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER.
(b)
FIGURE2THEBLACKDIAGRAMOFASPHALTBINDERSAT30
C,(A)UNAGEDNEATANDMODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER
AND(B)AGEDNEATANDMODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER
2)
TemperatureSweep
(a)
65
www.seipub.org/sceaStudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014
(b)
FIGURE4THEISOCHRONALPLOTSOFCOMPLEXMODULUS
VERSUSTEMPERATUREAT10RAD/S,(A)UNAGEDNEAT
ANDMODIFIEDASPHALTBINDERAND(B)AGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER
(a)
(a)
(b)
(b)
FIGURE5THEISOCHRONALPLOTSOFPHASEANGLEVERSUS
TEMPERATUREAT10RAD/S,(A)UNAGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDERAND(B)AGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER
FIGURE6THEISOCHRONALPLOTSOFG*/SINVERSUS
TEMPERATUREAT10RAD/S,(A)UNAGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDERAND(B)AGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER
66
StudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014www.seipub.org/scea
3)
ShearCreep
FourierTransformInfraredSpectroscopy(FTIR)
Theresultsofcreeptestat50Chavebeenshown
in FIGURE 7. At each loading cycle, the loading
and recovery time was equal to 1 s and 9 s,
respectively and loading cycles repeated for 20
times(10 cycles with 100Pa loading and10 cycles
with 3200 Pa loading). Instantaneous elastic strain
ofasphaltdevelopedduringtheloadingstage,and
the viscoelastic strain of asphalt was calculated as
the total creep strain accumulated at the time of
unloading. The instantaneouselastic strain of
asphalt disappeared after unloading, and the
delayed elastic strain recovered gradually (Wang,
2011). The unrecoverable viscoelastic strain is the
permanentstrain(Wangetal.,2011).Analysisofthe
data indicates that increasing the nanosilica
content and aging in RTFO have noticeable effect
on reducing the level of permanent strain. As
shown in FIGURE7 the trend is consistent among
various cycles. However, the level of total
permanentstrainincreasesasthenumberofcycles
increases.
Unaged
neatbitumen
bitumen+2%
nanosilica
bitumen+2%
nanosilica
bitumen+2%
nanosilica
C=O(1690cm1)
0.082
0.044
0.039
0.052
Aged
neatbitumen
bitumen+2%
nanosilica
bitumen+2%
nanosilica
bitumen+2%
nanosilica
C=O(1690cm1)
0.095
0.055
0.041
0.031
(a)
FIGURE8FTIRSPECTRAANALYSISOFNEATANDMODIFIED
ASPHALTBINDER(A)UNAGEDASPHALTBINDERSAND(B)
AGEDASPHALTBINDERS
(b)
FIGURE7THERESULTSOFCREEPTESTFORUNMODIFIED
ANDMODIFIEDSAMPLESAT50C,(A)UNAGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDERAND(B)AGEDNEATAND
MODIFIEDASPHALTBINDER
Conclusion
This paper investigates the merit of application of
nanosilicainasphaltbinderasanantiagingadditive.
To investigate the effectiveness of the nanosilica in
reducingasphaltaging,differentpercentagesofnano
67
www.seipub.org/sceaStudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Lu,X.,andIsacsson,U.(2002).Effectofageingonbitumen
chemistry and rheology.construction and building
materials,16(1),1522.
Onochie, A., Fini, E., Yang, X., MillsBeale, J., and You, Z.
REFERENCES
BoardWashingtonD.C.
Petersen, J. C. (1984). Chemical composition of asphalt as
PavementDesign,3(4),403424.
Cheng, C.F., Cheng, H.H., Cheng, P.W., and Lee, Y.J.
(2006). Effect of Reactive Channel Functional Groups
39(22),75837590.
constructionandbuildingmaterials,23(7),24872491.
of
Nanomaterials,S.Sinha,andN.K.Navani,eds.,Studium
M.,andAhalawat,S.(2013).Beneficialroleofnanosilica
PressLLC.
modified
binder.
Nanotechnology:Properties
68
buildingmaterials,47(0),10691077.
Sinha Ray, S., and Okamoto, M. (2003). Polymer/layered
silicate nanocomposites: a review from preparation to
processing. Progress in Polymer Science, 28(11), 1539
1641.
Tayfur,S.,Ozen,H.,andAksoy,A.(2007).Investigationof
rutting performance of asphalt mixtures containing
StudyofCivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA)Volume3,2014www.seipub.org/scea
Wang,L.(2011).MechanicsofAsphalt,McGrawHill.
Tamimi,A.A,Zubaidy,I.A.H.A,Upadhye,A.Ali,L.(2014).
constructionandbuildingmaterials,29(0),573580.
CivilEngineeringandArchitecture(SCEA),Vo.3,pp.4147.
(1999).Coagulationofbitumenwithfinesilicainmodel
characteristicsofcrumbrubbermodifiedasphaltbinder.
J.WuhanUniv.Technol.Mat.Sci.Edit.,26(1),118120.
Yao,H.,You,Z.,Li,L.,Lee,C.,Wingard,D.,Yap,Y.,Shi,X.,
and Goh, S. (2012a).Rheological Properties and
ChemicalBondingofAsphaltModifiedwithNanosilica.
JournalofMaterialsinCivilEngineering,25(11),16191630.
Yao,H.,You,Z.,Li,L.,Shi,X.,Goh,S.W.,MillsBeale,J.,and
Wingard, D. (2012b). Performance of asphalt binder
blended with nonmodified and polymermodified
nanoclay.construction and building materials, 35(0), 159
170.
You,Z.,MillsBeale,J.,Foley,J.M.,Roy,S.,Odegard,G.M.,
Dai, Q., and Goh, S. W. (2011). Nanoclaymodified
asphalt materials: Preparation and characterization.
constructionandbuildingmaterials,25(2),10721078.
EngineeringAspects,148(3),199211.
69