Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
DON'T BAN IT
The distinction between cosmetic surgery and other types of surgery such as reconstructive surgery
is that cosmetic surgery involves techniques intended for the 'enhancement' of appearance.
Cosmetic surgery involves both surgical and medical techniques and it is specifically concerned with
maintaining normal appearance, restoring it, or enhancing it beyond the average level toward some
aesthetic ideal. Cosmetic procedures have grown in popularity dramatically, in 2006, nearly 11
million cosmetic procedures were performed in the United States alone. The number of cosmetic
procedures performed in the United States has increased over 50 percent since the start of the
century. Nearly 12 million cosmetic procedures were performed in 2007. In Europe, the second
largest market for cosmetic procedures, cosmetic surgery is a $2.2 billion business. Cosmetic
surgery is now very common in countries such as the United Kingdom, France, and Germany. In
Asia, cosmetic surgery has become an accepted practice; currently most widely prevalent and
normal in China where it is currently Asia's biggest cosmetic surgery market1. Proponents argue
that the risks inherent in surgery that is not medically necessary are too great and that women are
merely succumbing to the pressures of men. Opponents, in contrast, argue women have a right to
choose both how they look and what methods they choose to get to how they look. Teen may wish
to correct include a misshapen nose, protruding ears, overly large breasts, asymmetrical breasts,
or severe acne and scarring. Teens frequently gain self-esteem and confidence when their
physical problems are corrected. In fact, successful plastic surgery may reverse the social
withdrawal that so often accompanies teens who feel different. This debate will examine whether
cosmetic surgery should be banned.
Cosmetic Surgery is a method by which a specifically targeted feature can be altered or modified to improve
perceived physical beauty, or reconstruct the appearance of a damaged body part. These techniques can range
from reducing the signs of ageing, to completely rebuilding facial features in the event it has been damaged
beyond repair. What this debate is focused around though, is whether this form of surgery should be reserved to
medical reconstruction and repair only, rather than the alteration of perfectly healthy tissue for the benefits of
beauty or general appearance. On the one hand, it could be argued that in a world that revolves around celebrity
rolemodels; our human obsession to change ourselves to match those of socially acceptable figures is damaging
to our society, forcing us to undergo radical surgery to erase or modify traits that we are not pleased with.
However, on the other hand, if someone wishes to alter their physical appearance, should it be restricted by the
government? Should limits be imposed to prevent abuse or pressure to undergo such procedures?
When people undergo plastic surgery, its because of
low self esteem, which is a much deeper problem
than just not liking how you look. It's not someone's
features that are the problem; If someone gets
surgery to fix what they feel is "wrong" with them and
boost self esteem, even though after the surgery they
may look different, they are still the same person
they were before they had the surgery. This means,
the person should be getting psychiatric help from a
professional, not turning to a surgeon who only cares
if your insecurities fill his bank account. Someone
who has low self confidence and self esteem will
always find something wrong with themselves,
surgery or not. Cosmetic surgery is just a way to
cover up and mask real problems, and not go deep to
the root of someone's reasons for insecurity. Get real
help.
Death and Infection and Harms! Oh no!
BAN IT
DON'T BAN IT
BAN IT
DON'T BAN IT
BAN IT
surgery patients raises questions about the
mental health of women who choose implants1.
It's only a plaster patched over a much deeper
problem. There are also studies that show
negative psychological effects on patients after
their surgery has been completed. For example,
a recent analysis 37 studies on patients'
psychological and psychosocial functioning
before and after cosmetic surgery by social
worker Roberta Honigman and psychiatrists
Katherine Phillips, MD, and David Castle, MD,
found several predictors of poor outcomes,
especially for those who hold unrealistic
expectations or have a history of depression and
anxiety. The researchers found that patients who
are dissatisfied with surgery may request repeat
procedures or experience depression and
adjustment problems, social isolation, family
problems, self-destructive behaviours and anger
towards the surgeon and his or her staff.
DON'T BAN IT
BAN IT
augmentation, liposuction, nasal surgery, eyelid
surgery and abdominoplasty.[1] There surgeries
cost between 3,000 and 5000, between
2,500 and 6,000, between 3,500 and 4,000
and between 2,000 to 6,000 respectively.
[2] So if it has the advantages the opposition
claims, the rich will look good, and the poor will
not.
DON'T BAN IT
opted to have a breast enlargement surgery and
reflecting on the experience, Carole has
absolutely no regrets I feel sexier, more
confident and extremely proud of my body.[2]
Thats nice. But given that the reality is that were judged
on our appearance all the time, its perfectly rational to
want to look good. Nobodys forcing anyone to have
cosmetic surgery the market is driven by demand.
The availability of cosmetic surgery People pay handsomely for cosmetic surgery. It costs
increases pressures on women that the state nothing, except in situations in which the
operation is necessary medically. Cosmetic surgery can
they must look beautiful. There is
considerable evidence that women's
attractiveness is judged more harshly than
men's. For example, in a study by Adams and
Huston, 1975, participants were asked to rate the
attractiveness of photographs of people of
varying ages. They found that although
attractiveness ratings of both men and women
declined with age, the rate of decline for women
was greater.[1] Researchers report that womens
magazines have ten and one-half times more ads
and articles promoting weight loss than mens
magazines do, and over three-quarters of the
covers of womens magazines include at least
one message about how to change a womans
bodily appearanceby diet, exercise or cosmetic
surgery.[2] These views about appearance are
damaging because it leads to seriously unhealthy
BAN IT
lifestyles that women think they need to look
beautiful. For example, in 2003, Teen magazine
reported that 35 per cent of girls 6 to 12 years
old have been on at least one diet, and that 50 to
70 per cent of normal weight girls believe they
are overweight.[3] Cosmetic surgery sends the
message that the prejudices some have about
appearance are valid.
DON'T BAN IT
that have it as being mentally unstable.
BAN IT
DON'T BAN IT
BAN IT
DON'T BAN IT
opportunity?
[4]The highly publicized death due to
complications in plastic surgery of mother of hip hop
star Kanye West, Donda West, have made people to
think twice before undergoing any plastic surgery. This
was a shock therapy to the world, underlining that
As previously mentioned, cosmetic surgery has
become a lucrative field. This might be a compelling plastic surgeries may cause deaths. Some people say
that having a plastic surgery is not worth the risk and
reason to ban the practice. Professionals are
will certainly not do you any good. However, if you
becoming concerned that it is so easily accessible
think about it, no surgeries are risk-free, without
and a field where patients enter with so little
exception. Even the safest dental surgery poses risk
reflection and information that more harm than
that may lead to infection, complications in anesthesia
good is becoming evident. Professionals around the and bleeding. Furthermore,[5] the American Society
of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) has published a study
medical field are calling for a greater regulation or
showing that serious complications in plastic surgeries
outright banning of the practice: "Over the last
decade the BAAPS has worked tirelessly to educate only occurs 1 in 298 cases or 0.34% and death only
occurring 1 in 51,459 cases or 0.0019%. Therefore,
the public on the many aggressive marketing
plastic surgeries are safer than people perceive. At the
gimmicks that not only trivialise surgery but
same time, plastic surgery is becoming safer and
endanger the patient." This reality where patients
safer, with the forever advancement in technology
are endangered, as well as lured with targeted
used for surgery and implants; causing the risks within
marketing campaigns that cloud the health risks to plastic surgery to keep decreasing.
cosmetic surgery demonstrate how the field is a
Nobody is forcing anybody to undergo plastic
dangerous one. The need to prevent cosmetic
surgery; it is their choice alone to take. Therefore, we
surgery patients from experiencing greater pain and must respect each and every persons own opinion
harm can be seen as another reason to ban
and choices because what we experience might be
cosmetic surgery.
very different from what they experience throughout
We live in a world that is image obsessed, and this kind their lives. They may feel neglected and left out due to
their awkward physical appearance and decided to
of procedure panders to that. We should promote the
idea that appearance is not as important as character.
undergo plastic surgery. Who are we to decide what
People should be content with themselves and not be
others must do?
so hung up on their looks.
In conclusion, I strongly believe that plastic
There are dangers involved in any kind of surgery.
Sometimes we must accept those dangers, as they
come in the course of necessary medical procedures.
But with elective surgery procedures people dont
need, but rather merely want the risks cant be
justified. These risks apply both to the surgery itself, and
to the long term. For example, leaking silicone breast
implants have been a widespread problem and can lead
to death. Once, paraffin was often injected into the face
to smooth wrinkles, with disastrous effects. Silicon often
finds its way into other parts of the body, such as the
lymph glands, and can prevent the early detection of
breast cancer as doctors often think real lumps are
silicon leakage. Who today knows the full future
implications of injecting the highly dangerous poison
Botox into ones face?
BAN IT
meet male standards of beauty, exaggerating their
shape and seeking to remain youthful lest their partner
leave them for (often literally) a younger model. Today
many operations are arranged by male partners rather
than by the women themselves. Cosmetically-enhanced
celebrities are redefining definitions of attractiveness for
new generations, leading young girls who would have
been considered naturally beautiful in past decades to
see themselves as plain and to seek their own surgical
remedies.
The pressures of appearance apply particularly to
women. Pregnancy and ageing have predictable effects:
they should be accepted with grace, not fought against.
The messages sent when some women have
procedures are firstly that the prejudices some have
about appearance are valid, and secondly that those
women secure enough not to contemplate going under
the knife are letting themselves go.
Doctors should heal, not waste their talent on
appearance. Precious talent and resources are spent on
this frivolous activity. Surgeons should do medical
operations that are needed, not cosmetic procedures
that are desired.
The black market argument applies to everything illegal.
Of course that risk exists, but the number of those
undertaking the activity will be smaller, as you concede.
Lack of legal safeguards and medical accountability,
and the probability that only badly qualified doctors will
offer illegal operations will deter almost everyone from
risking black market surgery. Fewer operations must be
desirable if it is agreed that the activity concerned
should be banned. Black market activity will be
vigorously policed and after all, its usually pretty
obvious if someone has had surgery.
Cosmetic surgery is addictive: look at Michael Jackson,
or Lolo Ferrarri, who got breast implant after breast
implant despite the harm it did her body. The
compulsion to change ones body is often a symptom of
a deeper mental instability. It should be treated as a
problem, not indulged and encouraged with surgery. Its
only a plaster patched over a much deeper problem.
Pointing to accidental side-benefits of cosmetic surgery
will not cover up the fact that its intention is to make
money, not make people better. If a fraction of the efforts
pumped into it went into proper medicine, the medical
world would be much more advanced than it is today.
And the fact that the benefits arise from chance merely
serves to highlight the greed that constitutes the
essential nature of cosmetic surgery: those benefits
DON'T BAN IT
they aren't. The thing is EVERYONE is entitled to their
own self adavntages and self harms. You, yourself know
the consequences are dangerous but like everyone is
stating technology has been highly advanced lately with
my/our generation.
People who say that cosmetic surgeries are really
dangerous and risky and may lead to death and
everything let them be known that cosmetic surgeries of
today have got a lot advanced.. There are very less
chances of death caused by cosmetic surgeries than
accidents and maternal deliveries!! You can't blame the
surgery for someone's death! Only this is not the kind of
medical treatments that causes death, what do you
have to say about people who die because of heart
surgeries and others, huh??! And as far as cosmetic
surgery "not afforded by everyone" is concerned then
every surgery is expensive, people cannot afford to live,
then why are people only criticizing cosmetic
surgeries?!?!
No. It may in some cases be silly and a reflection of
superficial values, but the bottom line is your body, your
business, do what you want with it. It isn't my place, or
anyone else's to tell you what you can and can not do. It
gets a little tricky when expecting insurance to pay for it
is the question, but no one should be told that they can
not have it done if s/he can figure out a way to pay for it.
THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH PLASTIC
SURGERY WHETHER ITS COSMETIC OR
RECONSTRUCTIVE! Most people don't approve of
plastic surgery because 'God' made us one way and we
should learn to love ourselves the way we are. Excuse
me if I'm wrong but isn't it the same thing when
someone dyes their hair, or wears coloured contact
lenses? They are doing it to change their appearance?!
And yet because it would only cost about 80euro to dye
your hair people don't look down upon it. If everyone
was really concerned about the fact that people
shouldn't change the way they look, then everyone
needs to stop dying their hair, getting spray tanned,
wearing coloured contact lenses etc. It's the individual's
choice about what they do and it shouldn't be anyone
elses problem. And others are saying well oh, we can
use the money spent on plastic surgery to help find a
cure for some disease. Well then DON'T GO OUT AND
SPEND ABOUT 150EURO GETTING HIGH LIGHTS
AND LOW LIGHTS AND WHAT HAVE YOU. If you
weren't blessed from 'God' to have platinum blonde hair
then that's too bad cause apparently we now live in a
world where murderers and rapists roam the street free
but when someone decide's to improve the way they
look by a small procedure which they do WITH THEIR
OWN MONEY( it's not as if they are going to rob 5
grand to pay for their surgery) people are outraged! And
now my rant is over, how refreshing!
I am against it if the proper regulations ( Federal law for
all state medical boards) are not put into place that will
ensure proper patient welfare and safety. During
subsequent pre-op visits to the plastic surgeons office
BAN IT
ought to be all of medicines aim, not an accident
resulting from it. Certainly people make money and
careers in normal medicine, but they are giving
treatments that aim to make people well, not look
different.
Theres a fair debate to be had here about what we all
know we mean when we talk about cosmetic surgery.
Balloon-breasted Barbie-doll models and self-indulgent
collagen boosters are the issue, and trying to squirm out
of defending them by pointing to sad children is pretty
weak. Because the answer is obvious - hare lip
correction is legitimate surgery. Collagen injection to
hide aging is not.
If the opposition is right and plastic surgery is desirable,
then such surgery is unfair. Only those that can pay for it
get it. So if it has the advantages the opposition claims,
the rich will look good, and the poor will not.
In fact, often, people look appalling after plastic surgery.
Celebrities with trout pout overblown lips, or absurd,
balloon-like breasts, are only the most well known
examples.
There is a good case for banning it on non-medical,
essential grounds.
There is something to be said for putting up with the
way we are and this makes accepting people for what
they are much better.
Too many people are taking the chance of plastic
surgery to what they see as enhancing their looks and
figures when there was nothing wrong in the first place.
Cosmetic surgery has been known to disfigure people
and to cause a lot of harm and distress. Many young
men and women who undergo surgery may regret this is
later life.
Cosmetic surgery can become a real psychological
problem to people who don't know when to stop. It's
costly and the money could be spent on less selfish and
better causes.
This type of surgery for medical reasons is totally
different and should be allowed to those who truly need
it.
DON'T BAN IT
and before an actual surgery date is agreed upon by the
prospective patient and the plastic surgeon, the
following information must be imparted by the plastic
surgeon to the prospective patient:
1 A verifiable verbal informed consent process by which
the attending cosmetic plastic surgeon explains in detail
his/her technique, where the incisions will be made,
research articles submited to the prospective patient
explaining the optimal and sub-optimal outcomes of the
procedure to be performed and alternative surgical
techniques where-by the outcome may be more optimal
whether or not the attending plastic surgeon performs
such techniques within his/her own practice. The entire
doctor patient pre-op appointment would be verified via
a real time video taping of the doctor/ patient verbal
informed consent process. In addition, the attending
plastic surgeon must ask the patient what his/her
aesthetic outcome expectations will be following the
surgical intervention. The surgeon must then explain
what he/she can reasonably accomplish in satisfying the
patients desired aesthetic outcome. This conversation
between the plastic surgeon and the prospective patient
must also be verified via a real time video taping of the
exchange.
2 After the entire verbal informed consent process,
imparted by the plastic surgeon to the prospective
patient has been accomplished, the verification video
must be sent to the state medical board for an official
revue.
3 Following the state medical boards review of the
verbal informed consent verification video for the proper
doctor patient disclosure of information regarding
expectation's resulting from the cosmetic surgery
intervention, the medical board will either approve or
deny the exchange as being sufficiant to proceed with
the surgical procedure.
The doctor/patient verifiable verbal informed consent
process explained above should be implemented ASAP.
Cosmetic plastic surgery is an elective procedure and
not a neccessary medical intervention. By taking the
neccessary precautions, at the end of the day, there use
will help to ensure the highest degree of patient care
and satisfaction. Relying solely on the current legal
informed consent forms that are signed by the
prospective cosmetic surgery patient after the final preop appointment, does not address the intimate details
and complexities involved in a cosmetic surgery
process.
Most patient complaints regarding cosmetic plastic
surgery involve poor communication with their plastic
surgeon and subsequently the sub-optimal aesthetic
outcomes that result from the procedure. Under the
current legal informed consent process there is no proof
regarding the verbal exchange that takes place at the
pre-op appointment(s) between the plastic surgeon and
the prospective patient. Because of this fact, poorly
informed patients who would have either opted for
another surgical technique or decided against a
cosmetic surgical operation altogether, have no leg to
stand on when filing a complaint with their state medical
BAN IT
DON'T BAN IT
BAN IT
consequences. Cosmetic surgery is performed by
qualified surgeons. Once it is banned, illegal providers
would arise for those who want it, and the operations
would be far more risky.
DON'T BAN IT
choice as to whether or not based of their morals as a
surgeon they want to perform on the patient.
Everyone is amazing . However, this may not be what people think of themselves. In our highly advanced and
competitive society today, it is understandable to want to be better at things, but beauty can sometimes be the exception.
Many people are turning to cosmetic surgery, a highly risky surgical procedure that enables one to look flawless, beautiful
and of course, highly regarded in society. Statistics in South Korea have shown that 1 out of 5 people are going for cosmetic
surgery to change the way they look. However, have these people wondered what is the exact reason that is making them
turning to cosmetic surgery? Have they considered the consequences behind cosmetic surgery? Well, certainly they have
not. The pressure to meet societys expectations, the flawless appearances of the celebrities and the implications involved
in cosmetic surgery are reasons why we should ban it. Hence, I feel that cosmetic surgery should be banned.
Today, we live in a society that is obsessed with looks. Many women in society are becoming more concerned with their
appearances and are willing to undergo cosmetic surgery to change the way they look so that they can be prettier.
However, going for cosmetic surgery only masks the inner problem and it only gives temporary relief to the patients of
cosmetic surgery. Many people feel that they have to look good to ascend the social ladder or be accepted into society.
Furthermore, everyone has their own flaws. One should not change their appearance just for the sake of meeting the
expectations of society. The only ugly thing about us are our insecurities, is a very valid quote. Patients of cosmetic
surgery should learn to appreciate their looks and not to undergo cosmetic surgery to escape from harsh judgement. In
South Korea, a 13 year old teenager went for cosmetic surgery just because she admired the flawless faces of the
celebrities in the K-pop groups and yearned to be as beautiful as them. This instance shows that cosmetic surgery does not
affect only adults , but it also affects teenagers as young as the age of 13. People are undergoing cosmetic surgery to be
like their celebrity idols, but they do not consider the real reason why they are going for cosmetic surgery. Many people are
impulsive in deciding to undergo cosmetic surgery so that they can be accepted into the society. By transforming into an
ideal beauty, they earn the approval of others and receive positive attention. Hence, the society is a trap that encourages
people to undergo cosmetic surgery even though their appearances are perfectly fine. Hence, cosmetic surgery should be
banned and it is worthless to undergo cosmetic surgery simply to meet societys expectations of beauty.
Next, cosmetic surgery is a real surgery with many potential risks and implications connected to it. The risks are not
justified and in most cases, the nerves may be damaged or severed during the surgical procedure. If the facial nerves are
damaged, the patients will lose the ability to make facial expressions. In worst cases, the drooping of the eyes and mouth
will occur. Cosmetic surgery also results in hematoma, a disease that causes our skin to swell and be bruised. As a result,
cosmetic surgery may cause ones appearance to be worse that before, and people who are obsessed with looks will
repeatedly go for cosmetic surgery until they get the results that satisfy them. Then, why should one go for cosmetic
surgery when they are bringing greater harm to themselves? According to a 2001 medical science research, statistics have
shown that 7 out of 10 cosmetic surgeries are failures, making the patients appearance to be much worse than before.
Hence, this shows that cosmetic surgery should be banned as it brings greater harm to the patients instead and put their
lives at risk and danger.
Another reason why people are interested in cosmetic surgery is because certain features are trendy and they wish to feel
like they are keeping up with the trend. However, trends are always changing in society. What is trendy now may not be so
in the future. Some people in society feel that they have to obtain a high nose bridge in order to fit into the society.
However, we have to know that trends never stay long and are always changing. Does this mean that these people have to
go for repeated surgeries to keep up with the changing trends? In Australia, a 14 year old teenage boy is inspired to get
pointed ears to resemble the elf from his favourite film, The Lord Of The Rings. In South Korea, teenage girls are also
undergoing cosmetic surgery to get sharper chins so that they can look prettier in photos. Hence, this shows that trends
are changing so quickly and people who are obsessed with their looks will keep on undergoing cosmetic surgery to change
their appearances according to the trend. Hence, cosmetic surgery should be banned as it is a harmful influence on people
as they follow trends whenever it changes. People ask cosmetic surgeons to make them look like the latest famous star and
doing so ignores the nature of beauty and diversity of their culture.
Naysayers would argue that going for cosmetic surgery is ones freedom of choice and patients have the rights to decide
for themselves. However, when one thinks carefully, it is laughable to consider having long pointy nose as a freedom of
expression. When someone feels that undergoing cosmetic surgery is a freedom of expression, they are insecure about
their own appearances and are afraid to be criticized by a society that puts a premium on looking good. Many people can
also become addicted to cosmetic surgery because they think that they have to look a certain way to be accepted into the
society. Furthermore, cosmetic surgery is a trap that causes people to feel insecure regarding their looks and appearances,
resulting them to go for continual surgeries till the patients get the results that they desire. Instead of focusing on their
appearances, patients should focus on their jobs instead.
In conclusion, cosmetic surgery should be banned because patients should appreciate their looks, be happy with who they
are regardless of their appearances and be people who are concerned in other aspects of life such as family and work.