Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
DATE:
excessively burdened.2
Former Attorney General Spitzer attempted to streamline the
system in 2005 by reducing allowable megabytes.3 That method
proved too difficult to implement. As Governor, he is now
modernizing the e-mail communication system by imposing a 90-day
time limit for retention of e-mails.
We are conforming our
policy to match that of the Executive.
http://www.oag.lawnet/technology/pdfs/groupwise/saving_groupwise_email.pdf
2- Eliminate the e-mail message.
It would be ideal to do this frequently. However, knowing
that we are all very busy, we are establishing a time-table that
is more flexible.
We are re-configuring the system so that the
messages on your desktop will be centrally removed after sixty
days.4 This procedure will automatically send the messages into
the Trash bin on your desktop. If for some reason you need to
retrieve it from the Trash bin, you will have an additional
thirty days in which to do so. After this period of time, the
messages will be centrally removed from Trash.
All told, then, you will have access to your e-mails for 90
days. Please save any substantive messages and important
attachments before then. This will assure a volume that our
present technology can manage.
In the next few days, we will be setting up our centralized
e-mail maintenance system along these lines. Once it is in
place, please be certain to move and save all substantive
messages and attachments prior to the 90-day period.
I will, of course, alert you as to when the system is in
effect. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to
ask. I thank you in advance for your cooperation.
#######################################
email preservation folders in Outlook, or into a folder on the shared drive. Under our new email
policy, permanent email archives will no longer be an option. Instead, all users will have 1-, 5- and
8-year email preservation folders in Outlook. Any email that is saved to these three folders will be
preserved for 1, 5, or 8 years after the date it was sent or received. IT will share more information
about these folders how they work and how to use them when your Bureau is scheduled to
transition from .pst folders to these new email preservation folders. Bureaus will be given a period of
time to cull their archives in Phase II, moving them either to the network, or to the 1-, 5-, and 8-year
folders. However, we strongly urge you to use the next month to thin the email currently in your
archive folders.
Obligation to Retain Emails That Are Records
Certain OAG emails are records and under state law must be transferred to our Record
Management System for retention and disposition according to Arts and Cultural Affairs Law 57.05.
A record is defined as all materials, including electronic files and email, (1) made or received in
connection with the transaction of public business and (2) which are appropriate for preservation . .
. as evidence of the organization, functions, policies, decisions, procedures, operations, or other
activities, of the Office. 8 N.Y.C.R.R. 188.2(h). Some examples of emails that may count as
records include emails from clients regarding a case, minutes of meetings, documents that initiate
or complete a business transaction, and final reports. The State Archives, the agency charged with
implementing and interpreting this statute, has concluded that most email communications are not
records. Whether an email message (or its attachment) is a record depends on its content. A link
to the OAGs current Record Retention schedule can be found here. If you have records-related
questions, you may also email Records@ag.ny.gov. Please note that, although we are working on a
more modern document management approach that will include electronic records, currently our
email system may not be used to satisfy the OAGs obligations regarding retention of records. If
you have emails that must be preserved, you should continue to send that email to the OAGs Record
Management System in the same way you do today.
Shanti Nayak
Chief Operating Officer
NYS Office of the Attorney General
120 Broadway - 25th Floor
New York, NY 10271
212-416-6303
Shanti.Nayak@ag.ny.gov
POLICY OBJECTIVES.......................................................................................................... 2
II. DEFINITIONS........................................................................................................................ 2
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
III.
PROCEDURES................................................................................................................... 4
2.
CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................... 8
1/16/2015
FOIL 150106 000006
POLICY OBJECTIVES
This policy applies to the Office of the Attorney General (OAG) as a custodian of Potential
Evidence in civil litigation, setting forth how and when special preservation measures will be
taken to ensure that the OAG fulfills any legal obligation to preserve evidence.1 In particular, this
document identifies the circumstances in which a Litigation Hold will be issued to suspend the
normal operation of OAGs Email Retention Policy and OAGs Record Retention Schedule to
preserve Potential Evidence from routine deletion according to those policies, and sets forth the
process for initiating, implementing, monitoring, and releasing a Litigation Hold.
The policy does not address OAGs obligation to advise clients about their preservation
obligations. Nor does this policy address OAGs obligation to preserve evidence in a criminal
proceeding.
II.
DEFINITIONS
1. Affected Parties
Affected Parties are all parties to whom a Litigation Hold Notice is addressed, including, but
not limited to, OAG employees (whether volunteer, temporary, permanent, full time or part
time). Affected Parties may include OAG employees who are custodians of Potential Evidence
from a former OAG employee. Affected Parties may also include OAG agents, contractors, and
vendors. Although the OAG generally does not control the document retention policies of its
agents, contractors, and vendors, it may be appropriate to provide such third parties with notice
concerning the need to preserve Potential Evidence.
2. Electronically Stored Information (ESI)
Electronically stored information or ESI is computer data or electronic recorded media of
any kind that is stored in a digital medium from which it can be retrieved and examined. ESI
may include: (i) email (Outlook); (ii) documents (Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Adobe Acrobat,
etc.); (iii) databases (Litigation and case management databases such as Concordance and
Clearwell); or (iv) any other software program that stores ESI (text messages, web pages, or any
other software or electronic communication program or database). ESI may be stored on hard
drives, network servers, smartphones, thumb drives, CDs, DVDs, floppy disks, computers, cell
phones, laptops, backup tapes, or any other electronic device or media used to do or store
government work (including personal smartphones and other personal devices used at home or
otherwise for such purpose).
3. Litigation Requiring Special Preservation
Litigation Requiring Special Preservation means any litigation in which the routine operation
of OAGs retention schedule may not be sufficient to preserve evidence relevant to the litigation.
The legal obligation of a party to preserve evidence is defined by New York and federal, common and statutory
law. See, e.g., Kronisch v. United States, 150 F.3d 112, 126-27 (2d Cir. 1998); Zubulake v. UBS Warburg LLC, 220
F.R.D. 212 (S.D.N.Y. 2003); Strong v. City of New York, 112 A.D.3d 15, 21-22 (1st Dept 2012); C.P.L.R. 3126;
Fed. R. Civ. Proc. 26 & 37. The appropriate application of this policy to particular circumstances should be assessed
in light of this case law.
Potential Evidence includes tangible items possessed or controlled by an OAG employee outside of the Office
(e.g., on personal computers or in files kept at home or on the cloud), if the tangible item was used for or reflects
government work. OAG employees are discouraged from maintaining work files at home or using personal
computers to do government work (except through the OAGs remote access program),
PROCEDURES
A. REPORTING INFORMATION RELATING TO A PENDING OR POTENTIAL
LITIGATION REQUIRING SPECIAL PRESERVATION
Although State and Federal case law include a variety of phrases to describe when the obligation to preserve is
triggered, the case law has been synthesized as providing that a reasonable anticipation of litigation exists when an
organization is on notice of a credible probability that it will become involved in litigation. The Sedona
Conference, The Sedona Conference Commentary on Legal Holds: The Trigger & The Process, 11 Sedona Conf.
J. 265, 269 (2010) [hereinafter, Sedona Commentary]; VOOM HD Holding LLC v. EchoStar Satellite LLC, 93
A.D.3d 33 (1st Dept 2012) (using credible probability formulation); see also Byrnie v. Town of Cromwell, 243
F.3d 93, 107 (2d Cir. 2001) (preservation obligation upon notice of the prospect of potential litigation); Fujitsu
Ltd. v. Fed. Exp. Corp., 247 F.3d 423, 436 (2d Cir. 2001) (same); Kronisch v. United States, 150 F.3d 112, 126 (2d
Cir. 1998) (preservation obligation when a party should have known that the evidence may be relevant to future
litigation); Strong v. City of New York, 112 A.D.3d 15, 22 (1st Dept 2013) (preservation obligation when party was
on notice that [the evidence] might be needed for future litigation).
Sedona Commentary at 280-82 (describing and discussing the factors to be weighed in determining the scope of a
particular hold).
Depending on the circumstances, a Litigation Hold Notice may either (or both) require Affected Parties to search
their own ESI for Potential Evidence or/and rely on IT to search ESI for Potential Evidence.
Absent a Litigation Hold, the OAG Email Retention Policy provides that emails sent or received
by OAG accounts will be deleted from email servers after 90 days. A Litigation Hold issued
pursuant to this policy will suspend or modify the automatic operation of the OAG Email
Retention Policy to preserve emails of Affected Parties that are Potential Evidence.
B. OAG RECORD RETENTION AND DISPOSITION SCHEDULE
Absent a Litigation Hold, the OAG Record Retention and Disposition Schedule (the OAG
Retention Schedule)6 and the General Retention and Disposition Schedule for New York State
Government Records (the General Retention Schedule)7 provide legal authorization to dispose
of covered records (as defined by 8 N.Y.C.R.R. 188.2(h)) on a regularly scheduled basis after
minimum retention periods have been met. See Arts & Cultural Affairs Law 57.05(11), 8
N.Y.C.R.R. Part 188.8 A Litigation Hold issued pursuant to this policy supersedes any provision
of the OAG Retention Schedule, the General Retention Schedule, or State law that would
otherwise authorize the destruction, deletion, or disposal of Potential Evidence while litigation is
pending or reasonably anticipated.
C. FREEDOM OF INFORMATION LAW (FOIL) REQUESTS
This policy sets forth the procedure for preserving Potential Evidence in a pending or reasonably
anticipated Litigation Requiring Special Preservation. A routine FOIL request does not require
preservation of Potential Evidence pursuant to this policy. FOIL preservation is governed by
OAGs procedures for the handling of FOIL requests. Nothing in this policy modifies the
policies and procedures for the handling of FOIL requests.
IV.
CONCLUSION
The consequences of failing to preserve evidence may be significant. It is important that OAG is
prepared to preserve ESI and other evidence from the outset of a case, to avoid costly data
recovery processes, the possibility of court-imposed sanctions, or adverse inferences. In addition,
violations of this policy and procedures may be subject to disciplinary action up to and including
dismissal.
If you have questions regarding Potential Evidence preservation, please contact the Counsels
Office.
Available at http://www.oag.silvernet/facilities/pdfs/Records_Retention_Disposition_Schedule.pdf.
Available at http://www.oag.lawnet/policies/GenSchedule.pdf.
Please email Records@ag.ny.gov if you have any questions relating to your obligation to retain records in the
absence of a Litigation Hold.