Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
www.technicalanalyst.co.uk
Strategies
Automated Trading
Sector performance
in the S&P500
Overview of
execution algorithms
presents
Global Equities
Outlook and investment
strategies for global stocks
2008
26 June 2008
Chandos House
London W1
Topics covered:
+ Fund managers
+ Hedge funds
+ Traders
+ Risk managers
+ Analysts
+ Brokers
Speakers include:
Charles Morris
HSBC Investments
Max Knudsen
PIA First
Antonio Manzini
UBS
Richard Ramyar
Lipper
Laurens Swinkels
Robeco
Robin Griffiths
Cazenove Capital
WELCOME
Although a great deal is written in books and magazines (including this one) about
how to employ technical trading strategies, the subjects of risk and money management are often overlooked. As any successful trader will tell you, this is often
as important a subject as choosing a successful entry and exit strategy. In this
issue Julian McCree, a trader at Erste Bank, gives us his views on how trade management is best approached when combined with a technical trading strategy.
We also discuss the importance of funds flows and examine if data can be used to
predict market movements.
We hope you enjoy this edition of the magazine
Matthew Clements, Editor
JUNE
Managing Risk
Julian McCree of Erste Bank talks about
his approach to trade management.
S&P500 Outlook
Kamran Sheikh of Informa Global Markets
breaks down the S&P500 and gives
his outlook for its various sectors.
2008 Global Markets Media Limited. All rights reserved. Neither this publication nor any part of it may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,
photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of Global Markets Media Limited. While the
publisher believes that all information contained in this publication was correct at the time of going to press, they
cannot accept liability for any errors or omissions that may appear or loss suffered directly or indirectly by any
reader as a result of any advertisement, editorial, photographs or other material published in The Technical
Analyst. No statement in this publication is to be considered as a recommendation or solicitation to buy or sell
securities or to provide investment, tax or legal advice. Readers should be aware that this publication is not
intended to replace the need to obtain professional advice in relation to any topic discussed.
June 2008
>36
>04
> 19
>>
THE TECHNICAL ANALYST
28
43
MARKET VIEWS
S&P500 - Divergence in sector performance
Emerging Markets Outlook
Outlook for Crude Oil
04
10
12
TECHNIQUES
Volume - The voice of the market
The Predictive Power of Weekly Fund Flows
The ARMS Index
Trading Variations in Double Tops and Double Bottoms
16
19
28
32
INTERVIEW
Julian McCree, Erste Bank
36
RESEARCH UPDATE
41
BOOKS
The Encyclopedia of Candlestick Charts
Top Ten Books
43
44
45
TRAINING DIARY
48
ADVERTISING
For information, please contact:
advertising@technicalanalyst.co.uk
PRODUCTION
Art, design and typesetting by
Stuart Field.
Printed by Goodman Baylis
ISSN(1742-8718)
June 2008
Market Views
June 2008
Market Views
S&P500
DIVERGENCE IN SECTOR PERFORMANCE
By Kamran Sheikh
Sector performance
After a notably weak start to the year by the entire market,
there has been a marked divergence in sector performance in
2008. While the S&P500 has lost only 2.90% (by 16 May)
after recovering from its early losses, sharp declines were
seen in sectors like Financials (-10.4%), Healthcare (-10.4%)
and Telecommunication (-8.1%). See Figure 1. On the other
hand some sectors outperformed the broader market, such as
Materials (+10.0%), Energy (+9.0%) and Consumer
Discretionary (+1.5%).
Historically out performance by the Energy Sector has
coincided with a decline in the broader market. The Energy
Sector also has a tendency to rally at the end of an expansion
in the economic cycle. While weight of the Energy sector
(and of course fuel prices) can be seen adversely affecting the
stock market, out performance the Materials and Consumer
Discretionary sectors is evidence of confidence in the economy via strong manufacturing and high levels of spending
on the luxury goods and services, respectively, even in the
current market conditions.
Despite the fact that the S&P Information Technology
Sector is still down 4% this year so far (16 May), the recent
breakouts on the Sector Index and the relative strength of
S&P500 charts is of significant importance as this sector has
an history of leading bull markets. Another positive development is the recent weakness of the Consumer Staples Index
relative to the S&P500. Historically Consumer Staples sector
is considered resilient to overall bearish stock market conditions and outperforms S&P500 during times of poor confidence in the economy. By contrast, it usually underperforms
during times of confidence. The recent deterioration in the
Sectors relative strength to the broader market, after a period of out performance in Q4 2007 and Q1 2008, is a positive signal for the stock market.
In this article we take a brief look at US stock market sectors. Since global stock markets are closely interconnected,
similar trends can be observed in other markets around the
globe.
Market Views
near 480 (2006 peak) during August and January dips. The
early April break above the trendline resistance near 580 was
followed by fresh all time highs. Despite some overbought
conditions, neither indicators nor the chart structure shows
any signs of reversal at this stage.
The Energy sector has been outperforming the S&P500
since late 2003. However, the out-performance significantly
accelerated following a break above the neckline of a double
bottom formation (Sep 2006-Jan 2007) in mid last year. The
relative strength chart is solidly entrenched within a bull
channel since early this year. We look for this trend to continue for the time being. A break below the channel support on
the relative strength charts would warn of diminishing interest in the Energy Sector and may be a positive sign for the
rest of the stock market.
Market Views
levels of volatility but this did not have any significant affect
on the relative performance against the S&P500. The recent
advance has broken above the uptrend resistance line near
278 to make fresh record highs, with the relative performance
chart solidly entrenched in a bull channel implying sector
strength (Figure 6). We expect this trend to continue. Only a
breach of the series of higher troughs on the relative performance chart would raise concerns.
Healthcare potential downside
The early 2008 breach of the support at 282 completed a 10
month double top with a downside objective of 338 (Figure
7). Despite the recent broader recovery, the S&P Health Care
sector has failed to rally and current consolidation within a
potential bear flag formation warns of a risk of a further
breakdown towards the double bottom objective sited at 338.
The Consumer Staples sector has a history of outperforming the broader market during adverse conditions and underperforming during overall favourable stock market conditions. On the weekly relative performance charts (Figure 9) a
breakout above the 3 year bear trendline, which also coincided with completion of a 1 year base, was seen in November
last year. During the period from November to March,
despite a decline in the value of the index in line with the
broader market, the sector overall outperformed the
S&P500. However, since late March the index has failed to
rally along with the broader market resulting in a sharp
June 2008
Market Views
Market Views
10
June 2008
Market Views
dollar. And the Asian markets are benefiting from the strong
Euro. Indeed, while export growth from Asia to the US has
slowed over the past year, total Asian export growth has actually risen.
TA: What other markets or data do you think are useful as leading indicators for emerging market equities?
MH: Our best short term sentiment indicators are the Merrill
Lynch Fund Managers Survey and the EPFR fund flow data.
Emerging Markets are of course also highly correlated with
many other market indicators, such as commodities, the US
dollar, volatility and the S&P500.
TA: Re portfolio/country allocation, what are the key
factors in your decision-making process?
MH: We are always overweight markets with attractive valuations (cheap PEs) and large current account surpluses. The
latter implies high levels of savings and liquidity. If you can
get that cheap then you are onto a winner.
TA: Can you give us an idea of how you use EPFR
data? Are you looking to follow trends or spot potential reversals when the market is over-extended? How
good is EPFR data in helping you to do this?
MH: EPFR flow data helps us to identify inflexion points in
the equity market. We use flow data to develop trading rules
and make directional calls on emerging markets. The data is
very useful.
TA: What techniques do you use to fine-tune/time
your entries and exits? How and to what extent do
you use technical analysis?
MH: In addition to our flow and sentiment tools, we use
technical indicators such as 200 day moving averages and so
on to indicate breakouts and the extent to which markets are
overbought and oversold.
Michael Hartnett is Chief Global Emerging Markets Equity
Strategist at Merrill Lynch in New York.
THE TECHNICAL ANALYST
11
Market Views
Outlook for
Crude Oil
12
June 2008
Market Views
Lars Steffensen,
Ebullio Capital Management
The days of talking about demand
destruction are over. This myth has
been busted. On the supply side,
OPEC wont deliver and non-OPEC
countries cant, and there is no end in
sight. US and Europe are not growing,
June 2008
Eduardo Lopez,
International Energy Agency
High prices, coupled with worsening
economic prospects and milder winter
conditions are certainly affecting
OECD demand. Yet, in non-OECD
countries, demand has actually turned
out to be much higher than expected.
By 2012 non-OECD growth will be
about three times higher than the
OECDs. In general, when a manufacturing sector emerges, income per capita rises significantly and oil demand
takes off (as cars, flights, air conditioning etc become part of everyday life).
Empirically, the pace of demand
growth becomes very brisk between
$3000 and US$9,000 per capita. Its
notable that several non-OECD
economies are in or about to reach
that stage.
Our forecast is that transportation
fuels will account for the bulk of oil
demand and oil demand growth will
come from non-OECD countries.
Within the OECD, demand is sustained by North America which will
represent 53% of the total by 2012.
With regard to non-OECD countries,
Asian demand will account for 47%
and the Middle East for 19% of the
total. Biofuels are gaining much attention and are seen as an alternative for
expensive and polluting oil-based
transportation fuels. However, despite
speculator growth in a few countries
such as Brazil biofuels are likely to
account for less than 2% of global
product demand by 2012.
13
Market Views
Margaret Chadwick,
Oxford Petroleum Research
There are four key reasons to explain
why oil prices are so high: Upstream
supply rationing from OPEC, particularly in 2006-2007; strong demand for
transport fuels combined with a fullyutilised refinery upgrading capacity (in
relation to upgrading heating fuel to
transport fuel); A Q1 surge in middle
distillate demand caused by a cold snap
(with reference to the 14 large oil-consuming countries); and downstream
refinery bottlenecks. As such, in
2007/2008, Europes deficit soared and
China became a large importer. To
make matters worse, non-OPEC production has also been below expectations.
We also summarise below a few of the
key points in relation to conventional
and non-conventional oil reserves:
Geological Uncertainty and
Risk: Implications for
Hydrocarbon Resource
Assessment
Jonathan Redfern,
University of Manchester
The calculation and estimation of
reserves is complex and open to error
and interpretation. Generally for any
discovered prospect or field, three
14
Techniques
16
June 2008
Techniques
volume
- the voice of the market
By Per-Erik Karlsson
The next thing is to look at what happened on those specific days. The key is
to try and figure out if the professionals are accumulating or distributing and
then try to play along with them. A
common misperception is that people
think weakness shows on down bars
and strength on up bars. Weakness will
always show first in an up bar and
strength will always show itself first on
a down bar. This is of course due to the
fact that at certain levels professionals
will turn their positions around or show
new interest. This will eventually lead
to a change in trend.
Reversals on extremely high
volume
A good example is the recent reversal
in the S&P 500 E-mini futures on the
17th of March (Figure 1). This was a
classic reversal formation and the chart
actually gave several signals that a low
was in the making. On 16th March the
volume was extremely high trading 3.87
million contracts, 64% more than the
20 day average at that time. The next
day it traded slightly less with 3.69 million contracts but still way above the 20
day average of 2.46 million. The significant clue was that the close on both
those days was some way off the lows.
The only way this can happen is if professionals are buying into the selling
and therefore creating extreme volume
and forcing the market off the lows.
High volume up bars closing off
THE TECHNICAL ANALYST
17
Techniques
Huge volume
Lack of
interest
Again no interest
to participare in the
up move
Techniques
The Predictive
Power of Weekly
Fund Flows
By Bernd Meyer,
Joelle Anamootoo
and Ingo Schmitz
June 2008
19
Techniques
June 2008
Techniques
Box 1: Key findings about the predictive power of weekly fund flows
We find no evidence of seasonal patterns in weekly fund flow, such as the rush in January, the sell off in the summer and
tax loss selling. In our view fund flow data therefore do not require seasonal adjustment.
Weekly fund flows show inertia as flows drive performance and performance leads flows. The average first-order autocorrelation coefficient is 0.27, with emerging market equity flows showing autocorrelation up to 0.54. The probability that a
positive inflow follows a positive inflow is around 68%. A negative inflow follows a negative inflow with 60% probability.
We observe a high (0.28) average contemporaneous correlation between weekly fund flows and equity market performance (as measured by the respective MSCI indices). We also find a strong positive correlation between performance and
lagged fund flows, providing clear evidence that performance leads flows. We do not find strong evidence that fund flows
lead performance in the following weeks.
In the bear market until March 2003 as well as in sideways markets the direction of fund flows in one week (or in 4
weeks on average) carries predictive power for subsequent performance. In a rising market the direction of fund flows
does not seem helpful and actually gives wrong signals on average. Hence, simple strategies that go long or short based
on the previous weeks direction of flows do not generally work.
Focusing on the changes in the direction of the flow rather than the direction of the flows does not improve the
explanatory power for the market direction.
Including the Liquidity Pulse, a measure of rising or contracting liquidity momentum, proves helpful for predicting the
market direction. We were able to develop trading rules for the market based on the direction of the weekly fund flows,
the direction of the average 4-week flow and the Liquidity Pulse that have worked for the regions for which we have the
longest history. Generally these strategies suggest to remain invested in the market unless all measures send a negative signal. Extremely strong/weak readings of the Liquidity Pulse should be seen as negative/positive signal. The May 2006 correction though was not predicted by these strategies.
Our cross-sectional analysis shows that the relative strength of fund flows for different regions contains explanatory
power for subsequent relative performance of the regions. Excluding transaction costs we find information ratios larger
than 1. Even if results after transaction costs are unlikely to be that positive, this suggests in our view that the relative
strength of fund flows does add value to models of regional equity allocation.
Finally a word of warning. One needs to be careful with any major conclusions as the earliest data available is from
January 2000. All data available for developed markets lies in the positive part of the current market cycle. In this market
cycle cheap money was available globally due to low interest rates in Japan, Europe and the US, which lead to a strong
appreciation in value of all asset classes. The data could be misleading and not reflect the true long-term fund flow picture. As no other data is available we can neither prove our findings to be right nor wrong. We believe however the data
can among other things be used to confirm economic or equity performance trends.
* Based on Deutsche Bank report Predictive power of weekly fund flows, 10 August 2006.
June 2008
21
Techniques
2
1
-1
-2
Liquidity M o m entum C o nt rac ting
Jun-06
Apr-06
Feb-06
Dec-05
Oct-05
Aug-05
Jun-05
Apr-05
Feb-05
Dec-04
Oct-04
Aug-04
Jun-04
-3
Apr-04
-1
4%
-2
3%
2
2%
1%
-3
Ju n-06
Apr-06
Feb-06
Dec-05
Oct-05
Au g-05
Ju n-05
Apr-05
Feb-05
Dec-04
Oct-04
Au g-04
Ju n-04
Apr-04
0%
0
-1%
-1
-2%
-3%
-2
-4%
June 2008
Ju n-06
May -06
Apr-06
Mar-0 6
Ja n-06
Fe b-06
Dec -05
No v-05
Oc t-05
Se p-05
Ju l-05
Aug-05
Ju n-05
May -05
Apr-05
Mar-0 5
Ja n-05
Fe b-05
Dec -04
No v-04
Oc t-04
Se p-04
Ju l-04
Aug-04
Ju n-04
-5%
Apr-04
-3
May -04
Techniques
All the funds included are pure plays equity funds invest
only in equities, and bond funds invest only in debt securities, and not a mixture of both.
Calculation of flows
On a weekly basis we obtain the raw data from EPFR, who
in turn obtain it each Wednesday from the respective fund
managers. EPFR releases the data on Thursday night, hence
the Weekly fund flows note we publish each Friday contains
very timely information.
The calculation of the weekly net flow is as follows:
June 2008
Weekly flow as % of NAV = Weekly net flows in dollars/Assets BoW in dollars using beginning of the week
exchange rate
The flow data table which features in our Weekly fund flows
note contains information on weekly flows, the 4-week average flow as well as the year-to-date net flow for all funds in
our universe. The 4-week moving average of the flows
smoothes the data as the weekly flows can at times be quite
volatile. Flow information is provided in absolute dollars
and as a percentage of total assets. The latter improves the
comparability of the flows across regions.
Focus on fund flow as a proportion of total assets
We recommend analysing fund flow data as a % of total
assets, rather than in dollar terms, because it provides a better comparison between regions:
23
Techniques
2. 10
350
1. 90
300
1. 70
250
1. 50
200
1. 30
150
1. 10
100
Feb -06
Ma y-06
Nov -05
Aug-05
Feb -05
Ma y-05
Nov -04
Aug-04
Feb -04
Ma y-04
Nov -03
Aug-03
Feb -03
Ma y-03
Nov -02
Aug-02
Feb -02
Ma y-02
Aug-01
Nov -01
Feb -01
0. 90
Ma y-01
50
2. 10
350
June 2008
1. 70
250
1. 50
200
1. 30
150
1. 10
100
Feb -06
Ma y-06
Nov -05
Aug-05
Feb -05
Ma y-05
Nov -04
Aug-04
Feb -04
Ma y-04
Nov -03
Aug-03
Feb -03
Ma y-03
Aug-02
Nov -02
Feb -02
Ma y-02
Nov -01
Aug-01
0. 90
Feb -01
50
Ma y-01
1. 90
300
25
Techniques
26
June 2008
presents
Automated Trading
Backtesting and
optimisation
2008
15 October 2008
Royal Society of Medicine
London W1
Topics include:
+ Traders
+ Fund managers
+ Hedge funds
+ Proprietary dealers
+ Quantitative analysts
+ Algorithmic trading
managers
+ Data integrity
+ Statistical analysis of test results
+ Correlation between asset classes
+ Issues in data mining
+ Monte Carlo techniques
+ Avoiding curve fitting
Speakers include:
Woon Wong
Cardiff Business School
David Aronson
Baruch University
Daniel Jones
Oxford University
Emmanuel Acar
Directional Trading
Gaurav Mangla
Collage LLC
Richard Ramyar
Lipper
Register Today!
Telephone: +44 (0)1483 573150
Web: www.technicalanalyst.co.uk Email: events@technicalanalyst.co.uk
Techniques
Figure 1.
28
THE TECHNICAL ANALYST
June 2008
Advances
Number of
declining stocks
the number of
close higher
Declines
the number of
close down
Advancing volume the volume of
Declining volume the volume of
Advancing
volume
Declining
volume
Techniques
June 2008
29
Techniques
30
June 2008
probably because before the use of computers, it was an easier figure to work with.
Despite the index being considered bullish when it is below
1.0 and bearish when it is above 1.0, Richard Arms himself
concedes that the index appears to be most effective when
used as an overbought/oversold indicator. However, there is
no consensus on what constitutes overbought or oversold
conditions and furthermore, they depend on what moving
average of the index is being used. John Murphy states that
the TRIN can be used as a contrary indicator, especially in
intraday trading. A very high figure (strongly bearish) is therefore bullish as it indicates a turning point.
According to Katie Townshend chief market technician at
MKM Partners, a proprietary trading and research firm based
in Greenwich, Connecticut, the real value of the TRIN lies in
its application as a breadth indicator, as well as an overbought/oversold oscillator. Furthermore, the TRIN should
not be used in isolation but only when other indicators confirm it. I publish the TRIN reading on a daily basis in an
email to clients but only heed it when it reaches extremes.
Lately, a high extreme has been about >2.0 and a low extreme
has been about <0.5.
When it reaches a high extreme, which usually happens on
sharp down days, it can be considered an oversold reading
that suggests the next day or two will be more bullish.
Conversely, when it reaches a low extreme, which usually is
associated with strong up days, it can be considered an overbought reading that suggests the next day or two will be more
Techniques
Trading rules
Richard Arms recommended trading rules based on using the
TRIN as an overbought/oversold oscillator are as follows:
Moving Average
Overbought
(sell)
Short term (4 to 10 day)
<0.75
Medium term (21 day)
<0.85
Long term (55 day)
<0.90
Oversold
(buy)
>1.25
>1.10
>1.05
The TRIN suffers to some extent from a lack of consensus regarding not only which moving averages to use but
what readings of the index indicate a buy and sell signal. This
is a drawback because it suggests that the ideal parameters
may change as market conditions change so the optimal readings to use are likely to remain unknown at any particular
time.
31
Techniques
Chart patterns like Double Tops and Head-and-Shoulders essentially convey the
same signal that of a trend reversal at the end of the pattern. Given the potentially important long-term Double Tops forming in the FTSE and S&P (see
Figures 1 and 2), we ask Suri Duddella to discuss the many variants of Double
Tops and Double Bottoms and to highlight some of their different trading rules.
Double Top and Double Bottom patterns are part of classic technical analysis. Double Top/Bottom patterns are
very common and form in all timeframes and in all instruments. These
patterns form when prices fail to make
new highs/new lows at significant previous levels. Double Top and Bottom
patterns are relatively reliable and easy
to trade. When Double Bottoms/Tops
fail, they may be signaling potential
Triple Top or Triple Bottoms patterns.
Double Top/Bottom patterns have several variants and these variations involve
different trading rules and different pattern recognition methods.
Formation of Double Top/
Bottom patterns
In active markets, Double Top/Bottom
patterns are found as the market works
up rapidly in a peak or trough accompa-
Figure 2.
Figure 1.
32
June 2008
Techniques
Figure 3.
Figure 4.
Figure 5.
Figure 6.
reversal bar or a divergence in any oscillator indicators. The price rise in the
second leg is usually followed by a spike
in the volume. A trend line is drawn
June 2008
33
Techniques
Figure 7.
Figure 8.
Target:
2B Sell Setup
1. New High
2. Pullback
3. Another bar Close above
Bar 1High
4. Mark Low of Bar 3. Wait for
Close below 4
5. Short below the Low of 4
6. Target Previous Swing Lows
Figure 9.
2B Buy Setup
1. New Low
2. Decent Retracement
3. Another bar close below Bar
1 Low
4. Mark High of Bar 3. Wait for
Close above 4.
5. Long above the High of 4
6. Target previous Swing
Highs
Figure 10.
June 2008
Techniques
formations are very profitable. The targets can be set at the previous swing
high/swing low of the first swing in the
Double Top or Double Bottom.
Subsequent targets would be set at the
next higher swing high or the next
lower swing low.
Stop: Adam and Eve patterns also fail.
Protect trades using the pattern high for
short trades and the pattern low for
long trades.
Conclusion
Most chart patterns have natural variations that require slightly different pattern detection methods and different
trading rules. Knowing these variations
and their trading rules greatly improves
any traders success when recognizing
the development of a pattern.
Figure 11.
Suri Duddella is the author of Trade Chart Patterns like the Pros. Suri has
been trading Futures and Equities markets full-time for over 13 years.
Contact suriNotes@gmail.com / www.suriNotes.com
June 2008
35
Interview
36
June 2008
Interview
INTERVIEW
37
Interview
I prefer to trade with the trend. As regards the basic philosophy, I use the quote by William Eckhardt that appeared in his
section in Schwagers Market Wizards. He said one of the
most important facts about trading; that is, even if a trader
gets a trade wrong but has good risk management, theyll be
ok. This is because eventually theyll hit a home run and make
money. The crucial thing is not to miss the big moves. A trader can miss one or two but if he or she consistently misses
the big trends then they are finished as a trader.
JM: Well, lets look at the equity markets. They have enjoyed
a good couple of months although they have started to turn
down again recently. This may be a good buying opportunity.
I attach a great deal of importance to sentiment in my trading so its difficult to see how the stock markets can fall much
further from here when everybody I speak to is so negative
about the market. This means they must either be flat or close
to it.
MY BELIEF IS THAT
MARKETS ARE
ESTABLISHED FOR
THE BENEFIT OF THE
COMMERCIALS,
NOT THE
SPECULATORS
TA: Generally speaking, how do you come to a decision
when to trade? To what extent is it based on technical or
fundamental factors?
JM: My process, which is similar to that of Jake Bernstein, is:
Set-up, Timing and Management. What I call the set-up is
usually a combination of technical and fundamental indicators. Timing is then used to place a trade and finally, probably the most important part of the trade, management in
terms of trade and money management.
TA: Which markets do you trade? Are you free to trade
more or less any market you wish?
JM: Im a global macro trader and as long as it has a futures
market, I can trade pretty much what I want to as long as I am
active in the most liquid markets. This includes FX, commodities, interest rates and equity indices. Im also beginning to
look at ETFs because of the sectoral diversity that they offer.
38
June 2008
Interview
June 2008
39
Interview
June 2008
Research Update
TESTING COMBINATIONS
DOUBLING UP
TA in Asia
COMPLEX RULES
41
Research Update
IRRATIONAL
DIVERSIFICATION
PAIRS TRADING
Is it possible to improve on the Pairs
Trading strategy by introducing greater
complexity? In a paper entitled M of a
Kind, Marcelo Perlin of the ICMA
Centre, University of Reading, suggests a
multivariate version of pairs trading,
which tries to create an artificial pair for a
particular stock based on the information
of m assets, instead of just one. The performance of three different versions of
the multivariate approach was assessed
for the Brazilian financial market using
42
Book Review
THE ENCYCLOPEDIA OF
CANDLESTICK CHARTS
T
By Thomas N. Bulkowski
Published by Wiley
227 pages
ISBN 0470182016
80.00
here are relatively few books available on candlestick charting which is perhaps surprising given the popularity of the technique. By far the most famous author on the subject is Steve Nison with his famous book Japanese Candlestick Charting Techniques
(Prentice Hall) which is perhaps the definitive book on the subject. However, whenever a single volume tends to dominate a subject, there is often much to be gained from a fresh perspective.
Thomas Bulkowski is a US based trader who now runs a consultancy specialising in pattern
recognition research. His last book was the mammoth Encyclopaedia of Chart Patterns
(Wiley) which broke new ground in its exhaustive description and study of most of the well
know (and many lesser know) price patterns. This new book, focusing exclusively on candlestick formations, is in a similar vain.
Candlestick charting is really a subject in itself because a trader using this technique is for all
intents and purposes self sufficient from a TA perspective. Because there exists a candlestick
pattern for every market condition and situation, he or she has little need to adopt additional
technical analysis strategies, except perhaps for the odd moving average overlay. It is for this
reason that more research has been needed into the effectiveness (and profitability) of the
numerous candlestick patterns that exist.
Bulkowskis book contains in-depth coverage of around 100 candlestick patterns or signals.
Each chapter covers a single pattern and offers a detailed description, market examples, guidelines to identification and suggested trading techniques. These may include such analysis as to
whether a pattern works best as a continuation or reversal, how they perform when used with
moving averages, and if they provide effective signals prior to breakouts. For example, the Doji
is one of the best know candlestick formations. Bulkowski lists more then eight versions of
the Doji along with performance statistics, best trading conditions and even statistics on variations of the pattern, i.e Dojis with long upper shadow or short lower shadow. The publication of candlestick analysis to this extent is, to my knowledge, unique.
After having analysed almost 5 million candlesticks, Bulkowski also ranks the top 15 performing candlestick patterns in each of several different scenarios including best overall performance, bull market reversals, bull market continuation etc. Also included at the end of the
book is a very useful visual index of every candlestick pattern discussed in the main text.
Some readers may take issue with some of the authors testing statistical methods for each
pattern. While each pattern is backtested, it is done in fairly simplistic terms and doesnt go
into details of trade set-ups so excludes such statistics as the number of winning trades, P&L
and drawdowns from trading a particular pattern. Furthermore, he doesnt establish confidence
limits for his tests and look to establish if his results could have occurred by chance.
Despite these drawbacks, Bulkowskis book is undoubtedly a valuable addition to the limited literature available on candlestick charting and should become essential reading for any trader who uses candles on a regular basis.
June 2008
43
Book Review
Swing Trading
Mark Rivalland
Published by Harriman
House
ISBN: 1897597193
Martin Prings
Introduction to Technical
Analysis
Martin Pring
Published by McGraw Hill
ISBN: 0070329338
Ichimoku Charts
Nicole Elliott
Published by Harriman
House
ISBN: 1897597843
Investors Guide to
Charting
Alistair Blair
Published by FT Prentice
Hall
ISBN: 0273662031
Source: Global-Investor.com. All of the above books are available from the Global Investor bookshop at a discount. Please
call +44 (0)1730 233870 and quote "The Technical Analyst magazine".
44
June 2008
Over the past several years, structural, economic, technological and regulatory forces have fundamentally reshaped the global equity markets. In the
US and Europe, competition has increased, new types of execution venues have materialized, order sizes have plummeted and volumes have
surged. As a result, firms today face a global marketplace that is fractured, technology-driven and complex.
To help clients operate in this new trading environment, brokers and independent technology vendors have
rolled out increasingly sophisticated
trading tools. Among these are a growing number of algorithmic trading
strategies, ranging from basic algorithms such as VWAP and implementation shortfall to advanced strategies
that address more specific trading
requirements (i.e. sourcing liquidity
from crossing networks and dark pools,
automating share buybacks, etc.).
Virtually all leading broker dealers,
agency brokers and trading technology
vendors offer a full complement of
algorithms from which clients can
choose.
Unfortunately, the sheer number of
strategies out there can lead to confusion among end-users. Furthermore,
the names that brokers have bestowed
on their more advanced algorithms
may sound impressive, but in most
cases they have nothing to do with the
algorithms themselves. (If you have
never used EdgeTrades Sumo algorithm, Credit Suisses Guerilla or
Goldmans Port-X, you would be
hard pressed to explain exactly what
they do based on their names.) As
45
46
June 2008
47
Training Courses
Johannesburg
Sydney
London
Hong Kong
Course Details
SHORT TERM TRADING WORKSHOP (2 DAYS)
Duration:
Courses are run from 9am to 5pm and
include lunch and refreshments.
Who Should Attend:
Traders, fund managers, hedge funds,
risk managers, analysts and brokers
London
Johannesburg
Sydney
London
Hong Kong
FURTHER COURSES
PAIRS TRADING
1 October
London
DEMARK INDICATORS
13 November
London
Research
Meetings
Representation The STA lobbies on behalf of analysts with data vendors, exchanges and regulators.
The STA represents the UK at the International Federation of Technical Analysts (IFTA)
Accreditation
groundbreaking application
that unleashes the power of
your Bloomberg.
For a low monthly fee and
UPTA<GO>
www.updata.co.uk
ta@updata.co.uk
Updata is a registered Bloomberg 3rd Party Application type REG<GO> All trademarks are the property of their respective owners