Two Way Analysis of Variance

Senin, Februari 09, 2015, 10:13:44

Data source: Data 1 in Data

Balanced Design
Dependent Variable: permukaa
Normality Test (Shapiro-Wilk): Failed

(P < 0,050)

Equal Variance Test (Brown-Forsythe):

Failed

Source of Variation

DF

SS

dosis
durasi
dosis x durasi
Residual
Total

4 27867,850
3 282,535
12 133,990
180 12046,500
199 40330,875

(P < 0,050)
MS

6966,962
94,178
11,166
66,925
202,668

F
104,101
1,407
0,167

P
<0,001
0,242
0,999

The difference in the mean values among the different levels of dosis is greater than would be expected by
chance after allowing for effects of differences in durasi. There is a statistically significant difference (P =
<0,001). To isolate which group(s) differ from the others use a multiple comparison procedure.
The difference in the mean values among the different levels of durasi is not great enough to exclude the
possibility that the difference is just due to random sampling variability after allowing for the effects of
differences in dosis. There is not a statistically significant difference (P = 0,242).
The effect of different levels of dosis does not depend on what level of durasi is present. There is not a
statistically significant interaction between dosis and durasi. (P = 0,999)
Power of performed test with alpha = 0,0500: for dosis : 1,000
Power of performed test with alpha = 0,0500: for durasi : 0,130
Power of performed test with alpha = 0,0500: for dosis x durasi : -Least square means for dosis :
Group
Mean
0,500
5,775
1,000
3,450
1,500
1,775
2,000
0,925
kontrol
32,200
Std Err of LS Mean = 1,293
Least square means for durasi :
Group
Mean
15,00010,520
30,000 9,260
45,000 8,160
60,000 7,360
Std Err of LS Mean = 1,157
Least square means for dosis x durasi :
Group
Mean

0,500 x 15,000
8,900
0,500 x 30,000
6,500
0,500 x 45,000
4,700
0,500 x 60,000
3,000
1,000 x 15,000
6,000
1,000 x 30,000
4,400
1,000 x 45,000
2,600
1,000 x 60,000
0,800
1,500 x 15,000
3,500
1,500 x 30,000
2,200
1,500 x 45,000
0,800
1,500 x 60,000
0,600
2,000 x 15,000
2,000
2,000 x 30,000
1,000
2,000 x 45,000
0,500
2,000 x 60,000
0,200
kontrol x 15,000 32,200
kontrol x 30,000 32,200
kontrol x 45,000 32,200
kontrol x 60,000 32,200
Std Err of LS Mean = 2,587
All Pairwise Multiple Comparison Procedures (Fisher LSD Method):
Comparisons for factor: dosis
Comparison
Diff of Means
kontrol vs. 2,000
kontrol vs. 1,500
kontrol vs. 1,000
kontrol vs. 0,500
0,500 vs. 2,000
0,500 vs. 1,500
0,500 vs. 1,000
1,000 vs. 2,000
1,000 vs. 1,500
1,500 vs. 2,000

31,275
30,425
28,750
26,425
4,850
4,000
2,325
2,525
1,675
0,850

Comparisons for factor: durasi

Comparison
Diff of Means
15,000 vs. 60,000
15,000 vs. 45,000
15,000 vs. 30,000
30,000 vs. 60,000
30,000 vs. 45,000
45,000 vs. 60,000

3,160
2,360
1,260
1,900
1,100
0,800

LSD(alpha=0,050)
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610
3,610

5,900

<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,009
0,030
0,205
0,169
0,361
0,643

LSD(alpha=0,050)
3,229
3,229
3,229
3,229
3,229
3,229

Comparisons for factor: durasi within 0,5

Comparison
Diff of Means
LSD(alpha=0,050)
15,000 vs. 60,000

7,219

P
0,055
0,151
0,442
0,247
0,502
0,625

Diff >= LSD

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

P
0,109

Diff >= LSD

No

15,000 vs. 45,000

15,000 vs. 30,000
30,000 vs. 60,000
30,000 vs. 45,000
45,000 vs. 60,000

4,200
2,400
3,500
1,800
1,700

Comparisons for factor: durasi within 1

Comparison
Diff of Means
15,000 vs. 60,000
15,000 vs. 45,000
15,000 vs. 30,000
30,000 vs. 60,000
30,000 vs. 45,000
45,000 vs. 60,000

5,200
3,400
1,600
3,600
1,800
1,800

7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

LSD(alpha=0,050)
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

Comparisons for factor: durasi within 1,5

Comparison
Diff of Means
LSD(alpha=0,050)
15,000 vs. 60,000
15,000 vs. 45,000
15,000 vs. 30,000
30,000 vs. 60,000
30,000 vs. 45,000
45,000 vs. 60,000

2,900
2,700
1,300
1,600
1,400
0,200

Comparisons for factor: durasi within 2

Comparison
Diff of Means
15,000 vs. 60,000
15,000 vs. 45,000
15,000 vs. 30,000
30,000 vs. 60,000
30,000 vs. 45,000
45,000 vs. 60,000

1,800
1,500
1,000
0,800
0,500
0,300

7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

LSD(alpha=0,050)
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

Comparisons for factor: durasi within kontrol

Comparison
Diff of Means
LSD(alpha=0,050)
15,000 vs. 60,000
15,000 vs. 45,000
15,000 vs. 30,000
30,000 vs. 60,000
30,000 vs. 45,000
45,000 vs. 60,000

0,000
0,000
0,000
0,000
0,000
0,000

Comparisons for factor: dosis within 15

Comparison
Diff of Means
kontrol vs. 2,000
kontrol vs. 1,500

30,200
28,700

7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

LSD(alpha=0,050)
7,219
7,219

0,252
0,513
0,340
0,623
0,643

P
0,157
0,354
0,662
0,326
0,623
0,623

P
0,429
0,461
0,723
0,662
0,702
0,956

P
0,623
0,682
0,785
0,827
0,891
0,935

P
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000
1,000

P
<0,001
<0,001

Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

Yes
Yes

kontrol vs. 1,000

kontrol vs. 0,500
0,500 vs. 2,000
0,500 vs. 1,500
0,500 vs. 1,000
1,000 vs. 2,000
1,000 vs. 1,500
1,500 vs. 2,000

26,200
23,300
6,900
5,400
2,900
4,000
2,500
1,500

Comparisons for factor: dosis within 30

Comparison
Diff of Means
kontrol vs. 2,000
kontrol vs. 1,500
kontrol vs. 1,000
kontrol vs. 0,500
0,500 vs. 2,000
0,500 vs. 1,500
0,500 vs. 1,000
1,000 vs. 2,000
1,000 vs. 1,500
1,500 vs. 2,000

31,200
30,000
27,800
25,700
5,500
4,300
2,100
3,400
2,200
1,200

Comparisons for factor: dosis within 45

Comparison
Diff of Means
kontrol vs. 2,000
kontrol vs. 1,500
kontrol vs. 1,000
kontrol vs. 0,500
0,500 vs. 2,000
0,500 vs. 1,500
0,500 vs. 1,000
1,000 vs. 2,000
1,000 vs. 1,500
1,500 vs. 2,000

31,700
31,400
29,600
27,500
4,200
3,900
2,100
2,100
1,800
0,300

Comparisons for factor: dosis within 60

Comparison
Diff of Means
kontrol vs. 2,000
kontrol vs. 1,500
kontrol vs. 1,000
kontrol vs. 0,500
0,500 vs. 2,000
0,500 vs. 1,500
0,500 vs. 1,000
1,000 vs. 2,000
1,000 vs. 1,500
1,500 vs. 2,000

32,000
31,600
31,400
29,200
2,800
2,400
2,200
0,600
0,200
0,400

7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

LSD(alpha=0,050)
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

LSD(alpha=0,050)
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

LSD(alpha=0,050)
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219
7,219

<0,001
<0,001
0,061
0,142
0,429
0,276
0,495
0,682

P
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,135
0,241
0,567
0,354
0,548
0,743

P
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,252
0,288
0,567
0,567
0,623
0,935

P
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
<0,001
0,445
0,513
0,548
0,870
0,956
0,913

Yes
Yes
No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

Diff >= LSD

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test
Do Not Test

A result of "Do Not Test" occurs for a comparison when no significant difference is found between two

means that enclose that comparison. For example, if you had four means sorted in order, and found no
difference between means 4 vs. 2, then you would not test 4 vs. 3 and 3 vs. 2, but still test 4 vs. 1 and 3 vs.
1 (4 vs. 3 and 3 vs. 2 are enclosed by 4 vs. 2: 4 3 2 1). Note that not testing the enclosed means is a
procedural rule, and a result of Do Not Test should be treated as if there is no significant difference between
the means, even though one may appear to exist.