Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
TABLE I.
Polarization
By-products of Partial Discharges
Aging molecules at interfaces
Arcing by-products
Oxidation by-products
Products of spilled lubricating oil & dust
Chemical dust including salts
Corrosive products
Thermal aging products
Moisture in adsorbed or molecular state
I.
INTRODUCTION
249
II.
A. No Problem
The dielectric response results of phase-to-phase (L-L) and
ground insulation (L-G) of a new generator stator (not yet in
service) in good condition are presented in fig. 1 for reference.
When the insulation system is good and dry, the
polarization current (I pol.) and the depolarization current (I
depol.) are nearly equal for about one-tenth of the charging
time such as in fig. 1a. Both currents are straight in log-log
scale, following inverse power law. The magnitude of PDC
depends mostly on the capacitance and insulation condition.
For any machine, L-G always has much higher PDC magnitude
than L-L at the same test voltage and temperature no matter
how good/bad the insulation is because L-G always has much
larger capacitance than L-L. Since insulation resistance is the
result of a constant test voltage divided by I pol., the insulation
resistance of L-L is always higher than L-G, as shown in fig.
1b. It does not mean L-L has better insulation quality than L-G.
The shape of insulation resistance for a good and dry machine
is also straight in log-log scale but increases with time. So the
ratio of insulation resistance between 1 and 10 minutes is more
than 1. In another word, P.I. shows a good result.
250
PDC at 100V, 20 o C
L-L
L-G
(a)
1.E-0 7
1.E-0 8
1.E-0 9
I pol.
I depol.
1.E-10
1.E-11
1
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
Resistance (Ohm)
1.E+13
T ime (s)
(b)
1.E+12
1.E+0 5
(c)
1.E+0 4
1.E+11
1.E+0 3
L-L
L-G
1.E+10
L-L
L-G
1.E+0 2
1.E+0 9
1.E+0 8
1.E+0 1
1.E+0 0
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
10
T ime (s)
1.E+0 0
(d)
C ratio
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
(e)
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 3
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 3
DDF
1.E+0 0
(f)
1.E-0 1
Frequency (Hz)
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
(g)
1.E-0 1
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 2
Frequency (Hz)
Frequency (Hz)
1.E+0 1
1,0 0 0
1.E-0 1
1.E-0 2
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 3
10 0
T ime (s)
DDF
1.E+0 1
C ratio
Current (A)
1.E-0 6
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
Frequency (Hz)
1.E-0 6
PDC at 100V, 19 o C
1.E-0 8
1.E-0 8
L-G
L-L
1.E-0 9
I pol.
I depol.
1.E-10
1.E-10
1
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
10
10 0
1.E+0 5
1.E+0 3
1.E+10
1.E+0 2
L-L
L-G
1.E+0 9
1.E+0 8
L-G
L-L
1.E+0 1
10 0
1,0 0 0
10
T ime (s)
1.E+0 0
(d)
C ratio
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
1.E+0 0
1.E+0 1
DDF at 19 o C, L-L
Suggested limit for L-L
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
10
10 0
(d)
1,0 0 0
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
T ime (s)
L-L
1.E+0 1
(e)
L-L
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 4
Before
After
Suggested limits for L-L
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
Frequency (Hz)
1.E-0 1
DDF at 19 o C, L-G
Suggested limit for L-G
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
RC plot in fig. 2c gives a hint that L-L is low and inferior to LG. But the decisive answer of unacceptable L-L but acceptable
L-G comes from the PDC evaluation results of C ratio and
DDF (fig. 2d - fig. 2g) which include the suggested limits for
safe operation (L-L and L-G have different limits).
Frequency (Hz)
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 1
1.E-0 2
Frequency (Hz)
(g)
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 3
Frequency (Hz)
Before
After
Suggested limit
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 4
1.E+0 0
Frequency (Hz)
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 1
T ime (s)
1.E-0 1
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 3
DDF
C ratio
1.E-0 2
1,0 0 0
1.E+0 2
L-L
After
Before
1.E+0 0
1.E+0 0
(f)
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 3
10 0
(e)
Frequency (Hz)
1.E+0 1
10 ,0 0 0
1.E+0 0
T ime (s)
DDF
1.E+0 1
L-L
After
Before
1.E+0 8
C ratio
10
(c)
1.E+0 3
1.E+10
1.E+0 9
1.E+0 0
1.E+0 4
(b)
DDF
1.E+11
1.E+11
(c)
1.E+0 4
Resistance (Ohm)
Resistance (Ohm)
19 o C
(b)
1.E+12
1,0 0 0
T ime (s)
T ime (s)
1.E+13
Before
I pol.
I depol.
After
I pol.
I depol.
1.E-0 9
1.E-11
L-L
(a)
1.E-0 7
(a)
1.E-0 7
Current (A)
Current (A)
1.E-0 6
L-L
(oC)
(pF)
(G)
(G)
(G)
(s)
251
(a)
1.E-0 6
PDC at 50V, 18 o C
1.E-0 7
Current (A)
Current (A)
1.E-0 6
1.E-0 8
I pol.
I depol.
1.E-10
1.E-11
1.E-0 9
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
10 ,0 0 0
T ime (s)
(c)
1.E+0 4
1.E+11
1.E+0 3
1.E+10
1.E+0 2
1.E+0 9
1.E+0 8
1.E+0 1
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
10 ,0 0 0
Frequency (Hz)
1.E+0 0
(d)
(e)
1.E-0 1
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
10
C ratio
DDF
C ratio
(d)
1.E-0 2
V-W, 30 o C
W-U, 30 o C
1.E+0 1
10 0
1,0 0 0
10
10 0
1,0 0 0
T ime (s)
T ime (s)
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 3
(c)
T ime (s)
1.E+0 1
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 4
V-W, 30 o C
W-U, 30 o C
1.E+10
T ime (s)
1.E+0 1
1,0 0 0
1.E+0 2
1.E+0 9
1
10 ,0 0 0
10 0
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 4
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 4
Frequency (Hz)
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
(e)
1.E+0 0
1.E-0 1
Frequency (Hz)
1.E+0 0
1.E+0 1
DDF
1,0 0 0
(b)
1.E+11
1.E+0 0
10 0
1.E+0 3
1.E+0 5
Resistance (Ohm)
Resistance (Ohm)
(b)
10
T ime (s)
1.E+12
10
W-U, I depol.
V-W, I depol.
1.E-10
1
V-W, I pol.
W-U, I pol.
1.E-0 8
1.E-0 9
1.E+12
(a)
1.E-0 7
V-W at 30 o C
W-U at 30 o C
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 4
1.E-0 3
1.E-0 2
1.E-0 1
1.E+0 0
Frequency (Hz)
252
III.
REFERENCES
CONCLUSION
253
[1]