Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CONTENTS
5 Foreword
54
6
7
Industry News
10
50
Cover Feature
16
24
24
48
Education
The Edward Arthur Metzger Collection, The Photographs of Jeffrey A. Scovil
Federation for European Education in Gemology
Gemology
34
44
47
51
Book Review
51
56
www.gemstone.org
FORE W ORD
Dear Readers,
D
19 West 21st Street, Suite 705
New York, NY 10010-6805 USA
Tel: 212.620.0900, Fax: 212.352.9054
www.gemstone.org
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Barbara Wheat
Barbara@gemstone.org
BUSINESS MANAGER
Aashish Shah
Ash@gemstone.org
OFFICE MANAGER
Claudiu Margarit
ica@gemstone.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
Jean Claude Michelou
EXECUTIVE EDITOR
Barbara Wheat
SENIOR EDITOR
Cynthia Unninayar
CONTRIBUTING EDITOR
Delphine Leblanc
PRODUCTION
Innovative Productions
The contents of InColor magazine may be
reprinted with proper attribution. For more
information, articles, or photo material, contact
the ICA office at ica@gemstone.org.
uring the Tucson gem shows earlier this year, ICA held the Gemstone
Industry & Laboratory Conference (GILC) for the rst time since 2007.
While we didnt know what the response from the industry would be
after this hiatus, registration numbers were double what we anticipated. GILC
has always been an invitation-only event, but word spread quickly resulting in
many calls to the ICA ofce from people active in industry debates requesting to
be added to our list. The end result was that we had excellent participation from
all major international gemological laboratoriesincluding representatives from
CIBJO and LMHCheads of associations and organizations, and leading members of the industry from both
the wholesale and retail sectors.
Our industry fosters many people who are passionate about issues relating to gemstone treatments,
nomenclature, and disclosure. Fortunately, a great number of these passionate individuals were in attendance at
GILC. With topics ranging from the origin of andesine,
colored stone grading standards, and glass-lled rubies,
to ethical mining and Fair Trade certication challenges
for the colored gemstone sector, there was plenty to be
passionate about during the all-day meeting.
The format of GILC allowed for discussions of the
scheduled topics with presentations from well-known industry experts followed
by questions addressed to the speaker and then by open discussion and debate.
The strength of GILC is that all parties involved in these issues are in the same
room at the same time where questions can be raised, answers proposed, and
solutions debated among key industry players and those with knowledge and
inuence on gemstone related issues.
At the end of each session, working groups were formed to engage in followup discussions, with the responsibility to report back to the GILC participants
with their conclusions. To facilitate this communication among committees,
and also to serve the entire GILC community, an online forum, www.GILC
Forum.org, was created featuring a public area for general discussion of industry
issues and a private area for committee members only. The ruby committee has
already worked on and concluded a new treatment classication. This and other
information as well as downloads will soon be available on the website.
I extend my thanks to all participants in GILC in Tucson, and especially our
appreciation to the speakers who prepared material for presentations. Our noted speakers included Christopher P. Smith, president of American Gemological
Laboratories; Dr. Lore Kiefert, chief gemologist, Gubelin Gem Lab; Dr.
Ahmadjan Abduriyim of the Gemological Association of All Japan; Dr. Pornsawat
Wathanakul, academic adviser, Gem & Jewelry Institute of Thailand; Shane McClure,
director, West Coast Identication Services, Gemological Institute of America; and
ICA vice president and World Bank consultant, Jean Claude Michelou.
The tentative date for the next GILC is set for September 2010 in Hong
Kong. Further details will be sent as soon as the venue is conrmed. GILC will
be held in Tucson next year, most likely on January 31st. We look forward to
seeing you there.
ISSN: 1158934X
To Subscribe to InColor, send an email to:
ica@gemstone.org
www.gemstone.org
Sushil Goyal
ICA Director
GILC Chairman
InColor | Spring 2010 5
E T H I C A L M I N I N G & FA I R T R A D E
Recent Reports on
Responsible Practices
tarting with this issue, InColor will present a section on responsible practices in the gem and jewelry
industry. These practices include Fair Trade, ethical
mining practices, and sustainable development. This section begins with a look at the Rapaport Fair Trade Jewelry
Conference held at BaselWorld 2010, followed by a report
on one of Gemelds environmental projects.
www.gemstone.org
E T H I C A L M I N I N G & FA I R T R A D E
artisanal miners a channel for their products to reach wholesalers and retailers.
Patrick Schein of the Alliance for Responsible Mining
(ARM) introduced the new alliance with Fair Trade Labeling
Organizations International (FLO) for the development of
the rst ever third-party independent certication for gold.
Its goal is to bring about social, environmental, and economic development in ASM communities. The partnership will
enable both organizations to meet shared strategic objectives and to create a system ensuring that ASM miners earn a
better price for gold while improving mining conditions and
protecting the environment. The partnership will be communicated on the product with a co-labeling hallmark using
both FAIR TRADE and FAIR MINED.
Robin Smith, founder of Host Universal, shared his views
on the fundamental drivers behind the success of Fair Trade.
He insisted that Fair Trade be considered as much more than
just a label on a product. Fair Trade is about a new relationship between producers and consumers, supply chain transparency, and market access for self-determined producers.
Were here to help create the right market conditions, rather
than lay down the law. The Fair Trade label, he argued, is
a vital signpost and assurance, but only a thriving producer
economy will deliver the evidence of transformation; only
the evidence of transformation will drive belief; and only belief will drive the transformation of consumers into investors.
Robin expressed his concerns that if Fair Trade becomes perceived as corporate access to Fair Trading producers because
it pays a little more, then nothing much has changed.
Other speakers included Elisabetta Molina, from Italian
jewelry manufacturer Garavelli, who presented the brands
Globo collection, which uses ethically produced gold from
Oro Verde in Colombia and Ecoandina in Argentina. Another
speaker was Elisabeth Umlas from SMART, who highlighted
a social venture whose goal is to construct a transparent route
to market for responsibly mined minerals and metals, thus delivering sustainable economic development to communities.
Gemelds
Zambian
emeralds. The Emerald
Queen will also take part
in the London Elephant
Parade, between May
and July.
The collection is
showcased at Selfridges
during May and into
mid-June, and then
will be sold at auction
at Sothebys. A percentage of the prots will
go towards the Indian
Elephant Corridor proj- The Emerald Queen, a life-size fiberect. The WLT is work- glass elephant, designed by Sabine
ing to safeguard tradi- Roemer using Gemfields Zambian
tional migration routes emeralds, in support of the World
for elephants so that Land Trusts Indian Elephant
they can move safely Corridor project.
between national parks
and other protected forests. Other supporters of the trusts
project include Sir David Attenborough and David Gower.
Gemelds says that its
mine-to-market capability guarantees the provenance of every gem,
through a full disclosure
and certication program.
It focuses on the consistent
supply of what it describes
as ethically produced
emeralds, which are
mined under a rigorous
set of standards in regards
to Fair Trade, environmental, social, and safety
practices. Earlier, the
company announced the
discovery of a 6,225-carat rough emerald at its
Kagem mine in Zambia.
The rough emerald has
been dubbed Insofu,
meaning elephant in the
vernacular of the regions indigenous Bemba
Necklace in Gemfields Zambian people, in honor of
emeralds by Jim Currens, in support the Elephant Corridor
of the World Land Trusts Indian Project and the stones
Elephant Corridor project.
unusually large size.
InColor | Spring 2010 7
E T H I C A L M I N I N G & FA I R T R A D E
Comprehensive...accurate an adventure
book with passion and understanding.
Emeralds, A Passionate Guide by Ronald Ringsrud
contains 70 photomicrographs, 250 color photos,
with 23 chapters and foreword by John Koivula.
Info & Ordering: www.emeraldpassion.com
$<>Dn><877@
:7>B4D111
Dealer of Fine Gemstones, Tanzanite & Zambian Emeralds
Manufacturer of Fine Sterling Jewelry
IND UST RY N E WS
anzanias parliament passed a new mining law that increases the rate of royalties paid on minerals such as
gold from 3 to 4 percent and requires the government to
own a stake in future mining projects. The Mining Act
2010 also requires mining companies to list on the Dar Es
Salaam Stock Exchange. Gemstones identied by the new
law include diamonds, tanzanite, emerald, ruby, sapphire,
turquoise, topaz, etc. The new law requires that the Tanzanian government own a stake in future mining projects and
that the country will no longer issue gemstone mining licences to foreign rms, although current agreements with
foreign companies remain unchanged. Tanzanite One, for
example, will not be affected by the new ownership rules.
www.gemstone.org
IND UST RY N E WS
a decision by the CIBJO Diamond Commission to broaden the number of acceptable terms to describe synthetic
diamonds; and the release by the CIBJO Marketing and
Education Commission of a diamond, colored gemstone,
pearl, and precious metals guide for jewelry consumers.
The GLBB is a guide for the management and technical
operations of gemological laboratories. It suggests best
practices and general requirements for laboratories to
12
One of the sessions at the CIBJO 2010 annual congress (photo courtesy of CIBJO).
www.gemstone.org
IND UST RY N E WS
carry out tests, grading, and internal calibrations on instruments, colored gemstones, diamonds, and pearls.
In his address to the CIBJO Assembly of Delegates,
CIBJO president Dr. Gaetano Cavalieri announced
the development of Corporate Social Responsibility
(CSR) programs by the World Jewellery Confederation
Education Foundation (WJCEF). The rst course will be
an intensive WJCEF Executive Program, which will operate according to a model developed for CIBJO by a
United Nations-appointed team of CSR experts. CIBJO
had created a 50,000 Swiss franc scholarship fund, and
it will be used to help nance the rst WJCEF executive course, which will be hosted by HRD Antwerp in
Belgium in June.
>O`^V\SKH+LHSLYULLKH
7YVMLZZPVUHS(WWYHPZLYMYVT
5(1(&
*VUYTH[PVU
0KLU[PJH[PVU
(\[OLU[PJH[PVU
*VUZ\S[H[PVU
4HYRL[
*VTWHYPZVU
MVY`V\Y
PU]LU[VY`
<UIPHZLK
VIQLJ[P]L
WYVMLZZPVUHSNLTVSVNPZ[
HWWYHPZLYZLY]PJLZPUJS\KPUN
MHPYTHYRL[]HS\LPUZ\YHUJL
KVUH[PVUHWWYHPZHSKVJ\TLU[Z
5IF/BUJPOBM"TTPDJBUJPOPG
+FXFMSZ"QQSBJTFST
^^^5(1(HWWYHPZLYZJVT-PUKHU(WWYHPZLY
14
COVER S TO RY
16
www.gemstone.org
COVE R STORY
Zero Vat pavilion shared by African rough stone dealers at the Bangkok Fair (photo courtesy of Jean Claude Michelou).
COVER S TO RY
The Thai government appointed the SME Bank to begin providing loans for working capital to gem and jewelry businesses using gemstones as collateral (photo courtesy of SME Bank).
According to information released by the Gem and Jewelry Business Development Committee of Thailand, benets
of the quality standards and reference-pricing index are:
1. Gem trading prices will reect the world market situation, and are adjusted in accordance with the realities of
the world market.
2. The standards will establish condence among consumers both in Thailand and abroad.
3. The reference documents will facilitate sales at every level
of the market, and will permit more exibility in trading.
4. As listings, the documents inform traders of market
conditions, and enable traders to adapt their operations
to suit the market.
5. The standards reduce the contrast between producers and
small-scale merchants, and facilitate trading at fair prices.
6. The standards facilitate increased trading volume, in both
the Thai market and in international markets.
18
COVE R STORY
www.gemstone.org
COVER S TO RY
20
www.gemstone.org
COVE R STORY
Trade Name
www.gemstone.org
COVER S TO RY
22
www.gemstone.org
E D U C AT I O N
One of the many acquisitions Irma Vollrath made for Edward Metzger is this 22K gold necklace containing 32 unheated rubies of
exceptional color from the Valley of Mogok (approximately 38 total carats).
24
www.gemstone.org
E D U C AT I O N
The collection contains many colors of zoisite including pink, green, yellow, and of course the magnificent
variety so familiar to alltanzanite. The color and brilliance of this spectacular 33.55-ct stone is nothing less
than dazzling as it graces this lovely platinum brooch
(designed and executed by Claus Vollrath).
This portrait seems to come alive, conveying how every movement brings out
a magnificent kaleidoscope of changing colors in this stunning 20.45-ct black
opal brooch (designed and executed by Claus Vollrath).
www.gemstone.org
E D U C AT I O N
This magnificent 13.01-ct (16.69 x 11.50 x 8.30 mm) spinel was cut
from a 32-ct rough crystal originating from Okkampitya, Sri Lanka
in the late 1980s.
This 18K gold ring sports an 11.71-ct cats eye that nearly defines
the variety. It is one of several such chrysoberyls including an
alexandrite cats eye (designed and executed by Claus Vollrath).
Sri Lankan Sapphire: 18.78 cts, 18.85 x 11.96 x 9.97 mm. Besides the stone dealer, who in 1983 watched this Padparadschas
cutting from the rough outside of Ratnapura, as well as that of
a magnificent 51.54-ct sapphire, Edward was the first of Irmas
clients to view these untreated marvels. Needless to say, Edward
added both to his collection without hesitation.
www.gemstone.org
E D U C AT I O N
Topaz and diamond brooch: 58.21 cts, 28.45 x 19.70 x 13.30 mm.
Color Change Diaspore: 11.05 cts, 13.41 x 13.10 x 9.42 mm. (Left: daylight; Right: incandescent light.)
www.gemstone.org
E D U C AT I O N
Kashmir Sapphire Ring: 14.63 cts, 15.13 x 12.16 x 8.39 mm. An unheated magnificent facet-grade sugarloaf cabochon set in platinum, from the early 1990s (Raymond Yard design).
www.gemstone.org
E D U C AT I O N
E D U C AT I O N
30.22-ct Peridot.
E D U C AT I O N
In 2003, with Stephens assistance, Irma was able to fulll Edwards long quest for a diamond which rivals ruby in
its blood red hue: the 0.89-carat Brazilian diamond now
known as The Metzger Red. At that time, this stone,
whose origin was the alluvial diamond elds in the country
of Edwards birth, ranked as eighth largest in the world in
the red family and was the largest fashioned as an emerald
cut. Since that time, its rank has dropped considerably, but
it still holds a historic place among this family of rarest
color (Hofer, 2003 personal correspondence).
Tragically in 2004, Edward succumbed quickly to illness, but not before he made arrangements to share with
the larger world what up until then had been a very private
passionate pursuit. Edward completed what he could of the
color wheel of fancy diamonds by making sure that one of
the rarest colors was represented, a so-called pumpkin
diamond, adding the stone to the collection just two days
before he passed way.
www.gemstone.org
About the book authors: Gemologist Elise A. Skalwold, BSc, FGA, GG, is a 1982
Cornell graduate; William A. Bassett, Ph.D, is professor emeritus of geology, Cornell
University, a 1996 Roebling Medalist, and one of the pioneers of diamond anvil
cell high pressure research.
All photographs are copyright Cornell University and Jeffrey A. Scovil. Text is
copyright of the authors and InColor magazine.
The Metzger Red: 0.89-ct Fancy Purplish Red VS1. The extremely
rare color of this Brazilian diamond defines the exact boundary
between pure and purplish-red making it a master stone with
which to judge all others (Hofer, 2003 personal correspondence).
InColor | Spring 2010 33
GEMO LO GY
hen the rst gemological laboratory was founded in London in 1925, the science of gemology
had just been born. The advent of the rst synthetics (Verneuil synthetic corundum and synthetic spinel) and diamond irradiation treatments were the main
challenges in this early period of gemstone analysis. Until the 1970s, the laboratories were mainly equipped with
standard equipment such as microscopes, direct vision
spectroscopes, refractometers, polariscopes, and dichroscopes, among others, and some had access to certain
mineralogical techniques such as X-ray diffraction and, at
a later time, scanning electron microscopy via collaboration with universities or large geological institutes. For
most challenges during this time, the so-called standard
gemological techniques were sufcient and the need for
more sophisticated instrumentation was not imminent.
In 1976, the well-known mineralogist and gemologist George Bosshart introduced spectrometers into the
gemological eld and was the rst one to record UV-Vis
spectra of gemstones and even low-temperature spectra of
diamonds in a gemological laboratory.
Following this initial step by Mr. Bosshart, the instruments that started to be used in the major gemological
laboratories included UV-Vis-NIR spectrometer, infrared spectrometer, and EDXRF chemical analysis systems.
Interestingly, many laboratories, especially the ones doing
mostly diamond grading, were not following this evolu-
tion and only in the 1990s with the advent of many new
treatments and more and more synthetics, many started to
invest in analytical equipment.
With the appearance of HPHT-treated diamonds, the
technique of photoluminescence spectroscopy and Raman
spectroscopy, which is associated with it, was added to the
equipment list of the major labs. Even later, mainly for the use
of light-element detection in beryllium-treated sapphire, for
example, destructive techniques such as ICPMS (inductively coupled plasma mass spectroscopy), LIBS (laser induced
breakdown spectroscopy) and rarely SIMS (secondary ion
mass spectroscopy) were introduced into the gemological
eld. Other instruments that were adapted for gemological
purposes included x-ray diffraction, radiography, computer
tomography, and scanning electron microscopy.
Even today, gemology is still regarded by some as something between science and art since much that has been
done in earlier days was rather rudimentary compared to
other sciences such as mineralogy, geology, and chemistry.
Nowadays, most researchers working in gem labs come
from one of these sciences and advanced gemology has
truly evolved into a science.
The evolution of gem treatments and synthesis in
the past 20 years has changed the requirements for gem
analysis. In todays complex gemology world, the most
sophisticated instrumentation operated and interpreted by
very experienced gemologists are required to solve most
of the problems. The following paragraphs give a brief description of the methods and their uses, potential, and risks.
UV-Vis-NIR Spectroscopy
This technique is the modern equivalent to the spectroscope,
with the main difference being that the spectrum does not
show up as lines and bands visible within the rainbow of all
spectral colors but rather is shown on a screen as a continuous graph, which represents the intensity of absorbance or
transmittance measured at each point on the spectrum. Another important difference is that, depending on the system
used, such a UV-Vis-NIR spectrometer can cover a much
larger domain than the standard spectroscope, which covers
400 to 700 nm; a spectrometer typically covers the range of
190 to 1,100 nm but can go all the way to about 3,000 nm.
There are NIR spectrometers that cover the entire near infrared but such systems are rarely in use. Two different types
www.gemstone.org
GE MOLOGY
Figure 2. The prototype of the high resolution UV-Vis-NIR spectrometer system used at the GEMLAB laboratory (top). The graphs show
the polarized spectra recorded on this instrument from a natural emerald from the Habachtal/Austria of 1.04 cts (left) and the comparison of the reflectance spectra recorded on this instrument of a natural black pearl from Pinctada margaritifera (blue trace, photo) and a
color-treated black pearl (red trace).
Infrared Spectroscopy
Infrared spectroscopy is a technique that mainly determines
vibrational absorptions due to vibrating molecules in materials. In diamonds, this method detects also a variety of
electronic transitions, which are found in the near-infrared
portion of the spectrum. The domain from about 1,200
to 25,000 nm (~7800 to 400 cm-1) is covered by most of
todays infrared spectrometers. This domain represents the
energetically lower wavelengths of light which are invisible
www.gemstone.org
Raman Spectroscopy
This method, although known since the 1930s, is only
popular since lasers have become widely available. Thanks
to the intense lasers and very sensitive detectors, it has
become possible to efciently detect extremely small
amounts of inelastically scattered light (Raman scattering) within elastically scattered light (Raleigh scattering)
from a sample to be analyzed. It has been estimated that,
as an average, approximately one out of one million scattered photons is a Raman signal. In Raman spectroscopy,
the frequency of such inelastically scattered laser light
is measured and thus the identity of a substance can be
determined. The use of this method is mainly for material identication (including lling materials in treated
gemstones), determination of inclusions, and certain
InColor | Spring 2010 35
GEMO LO GY
Figure 3. The FTIR spectrometer used at the GEMLAB laboratory (left) and the infrared spectra recorded on this instrument from untreated emerald as well as emeralds treated by various commonly used organic fillers (right), which are identified by the features in the
spectral domain from 2,800 to 3,100 cm-1.
Photoluminescence Spectroscopy
Photoluminescence is a term that stands for emission of
photons, thus phenomena such as uorescence. In such phenomena, the absorption of a photon (light) puts a material
into an excited state, and the energy loss when falling back
to the ground state occurs in the form of an emission. Photoluminescence spectroscopy is a technique that is commonly
measured with the same instruments used for Raman measurements. Lasers are perfect sources to excite luminescence
in gem materials. The vast variability of lasers covering the
entire range of wavelengths of interest permits one to excite
emissions related to all possible types of defects in a material.
Even though there are many applications of this technique
in many different gem materials, the main use of photoluminescence spectroscopy can be found in diamond analysis.
Unlike any other gem material, diamond spectra exhibit a
very large variety of rather sharp vibronic-type absorptions
and emissions caused by many different defects (point and
extended defects). Diamond needs to be studied at room
temperature and low temperature (commonly by the use of
liquid nitrogen with a temperature of -196C) because the
spectra can be dramatically different. Usually, the emissions
sharpen strongly at low temperature, but in certain cases
they are even absent at room temperature but very dominant
at low temperature (see gure 4).
Although diamond is the main gemstone analyzed by
this method, there are vast possibilities for the analysis of
all other gem materials, which are by far not all studied in
detail by this method.
Photoluminescence spectra can show a variety of artifacts from laser, lter, and anything else that is in between
the laser and the spectrometer. Knowing these and reducing or eliminating them is important for the proper interpretation of the resulting spectra.
www.gemstone.org
GEMO LO GY
UV Imaging Techniques
UV imaging is a very useful method to study luminescence
and its distribution microscopically. There are basically two
types, one using very high-energy UV light (< 225 nm) and
one using anything from about 250 nm to about 450 nm in
the blue part of the spectrum. The rst one is known from
the instrument DiamondView which has its main uses in
the eld of diamonds, since the UV wavelength just below
the diamond intrinsic UV absorption allows one to observe
surface-restricted luminescence phenomena, which give
direct insights into the growth of diamond.
The other type is used for all sorts of analyses such as
detection and quantication of organic llers and the observation of irregular defect distribution in gemstones. There
are many ways to use a UV microscope and, with the right
Figure 6. The setup of the xenon-based luminescence spectroscopy system (left) and the result obtained from a blue-fluorescing diamond
using various excitation wavelengths (right).
38
www.gemstone.org
GEMO LO GY
Other Methods
Scanning electron microscopy usually permits the observation of the surface of a sample with magnications up to
several ten thousands, the visualization of compositional
uctuations, and variations in a substance and if available
also the luminescence of a sample under the electron beam
used in the microscope. Additionally, many instruments
www.gemstone.org
GEMO LO GY
GEMO LO GY
or more than a year, yet another new ruby heat treatment has been entering the global marketplace. As this
treatment was rst acquired in Bangkok by wholesalers
and manufacturers, then distributed through other markets
across the world, issues arose as how to properly represent
and disclose this treatment. Of concern for the industry was
whether it had to be disclosed similarly to the lead-glass
treated ruby, known as Composite Ruby (AGL 2007), and
what special care requirements did it carry. Following its initial investigations, the American Gemological Laboratory
(AGL) released its conclusions and policies for their reports
(AGL 2010). The ndings indicate this latest treatment is
essentially the same as the more traditional ux-assisted
heating of rubies, with some additional features.
Gemological Findings
All of the standard gemological properties were consistent
with ruby in general. Microscopic examination revealed
the presence of several naturally-occurring inclusions
that showed evidence of heat treatment (gure 2). All of
the stones possessed thermally induced healed ssures
with heating residues that ranged from faint or minor to
prominent (gure 3). Many of the samples possessed s44
Durability Tests
Initial durability studies were conducted in collaboration with Craig A. Lynch of Ouellet & Lynch in Phoenix,
Arizona. Stones that had primarily ssures healed during the
heating process, as well as ones that possessed a combination
of ssure healing and in-lling were exposed to conditions
that would be typically encountered at the work-bench of
manufacturers and retailers. Standard bench jeweler practices were employed during the re-tipping of prongs, sizing,
repair, rhodium plating, and polishing.
Figure 3: Shown here are the typical constituents and patterns of
heating residues present as a result of induced healing of fissures
by the adding of fluxing agents
during heating.
GE MOLOGY
Discussion
For this treatment, AGL was told that a selection of the rough
material suitable for the Composite Ruby treatment is made.
This sub-group of rough is then treated using various chemicals or uxing agents, similar to the more traditional heating
of ruby that results in ssure healing and heating residues
(B. Hakimi 2010; Pardieu et al., 2010).
During the course of microscopic investigations, it
was clear that virtually all rubies possessed ssures that
had been healed. Many of the stones also possessed
ssures that had been in-lled with a glass-like or vitreous
material. The lead-glass of a Composite Ruby does not participate in the healing of ssures, and the golden color of
the lead-glass further augments the color of rubies treated
by that method. Neither is the case with this new treatment.
Figure 4: Many of the treated Mozambique rubies had unhealed
fissures in-filled with a glass-like
or vitreous material. Ancillary fiber-optic lighting reflects off the
in-filled fissures, making them
readily visible. This contrasts to
the very low relief of the leadglass filling of a Composite Ruby.
From our durability studies, immersion in the pickling solution and rhodium plating produced no discernible damage.
The results are in contrast to the etching that occurs with
Composite Rubies (Smith et al., 2005; McClure et al., 2006;
Lynch, 2010). The heat of re-tipping and/or sizing, however, could cause the glass to bubble at the surface (gure 6).
These results are similar to those of the more traditionally
heated rubies possessing induced healed ssures and heating
residues (as performed by the author previously).
Concluding Comments
When the rubies from the Mong Hsu area of Burma (Myanmar)
rst came to the market in the early 1990s, there was great
controversy surrounding the extent of ssure healing and glass
in-lling in many of these stones (McClure and Smith, 2000).
This topic eventually died down as treaters focused more of
the treatment process on ssure healing and the use of acids to remove the larger masses of glass at the surface of the
stones. As a result, less often were unhealed, glass in-lled ssures and cavities encountered. Today, this latest treatment of
Mozambique rubies parallels the early Mong Hsu material.
Although the extent of this treatment may be signicant,
there are several differences between this and the material
AGL classies as Composite Ruby. The glass infused into
the Composite Ruby material contains lead and/or bismuth,
as well as other potential elements to raise the refractive
InColor | Spring 2010 45
GEMO LO GY
6XEVFULEHWR
,Q&RORU
46
commercial household products. Professional bench jewelers should already be familiar with the proper handling
of a heated ruby. In contrast, Composite Ruby carries with
it certain intrinsic special care requirements that must be
conveyed to bench jewelers and consumers, in order to
avoid inadvertent damage to the stones.
Over the past two years, Mozambique has become an
important source of rubies of all three types: Unheated,
Heated, and Composite (see sidebar). This treatment has
made these stones an interesting low-cost alternative for
those who dont want to work with Composite Rubies yet
are having difculties in obtaining heated rubies of nonBurmese origin since rubies from Burma (Myanmar) are
banned in the U.S. and elsewhere.
References:
AGL (13 November 2007) AGL modifies its disclosure policy on lead-glass filled
rubies. http://www.aglgemlab.com/News/composite%20ruby.pdf
AGL (3 May 2010) AGL Will Not Be Classifying New Ruby Treatment As
Composite Ruby. http://www.aglgemlab.com/News/New%20Ruby%20TreatmentMay%202010-AGL.pdf
GIT-GTL (Gem and Jewelry Institute of Thailand - Gem testing Laboratory: 2009).
Some characteristics of Mozambique ruby. http://www.git.or.th/eng/testing_center_en/
lab_notes_en/glab_en/2009/GIT_article_ruby_mozambique_web.pdf
GIT-GTL (Gem and Jewelry Institute of Thailand - Gem testing Laboratory:
2010). New ruby deposits in Mozambique. http://www.git.or.th/eng/testing_center_en/
lab_notes_en/glab_en/2010/new_ruby_deposits_mozambique.pdf
LMHC Information sheet #3: Corundum with glass filled fractures and/or cavities
enhancing the clarity. http://www.giathai.net/pdf/IS3_18012010.pdf
Lynch C.A. (2010) Is that really a ruby? Private publication Ouellet & Lynch, pp. 46.
McClure S.F., Smith C.P. (2000) Gemstone enhancement and detection in the 1990s.
Gems & Gemology, Vol. 36, No. 4, pp. 336-359.
McClure S.F., Smith C.P., Wang W., Hall M. (2006) Identification and durability
of lead glass-filled rubies. Gems & Gemology, Vol. 42,
No. 1, pp. 22-34.
Pardieu V., Thanachakaphad J., Jacquat
S., Senoble J.B., Bryl L.P. (2009) Rubies from
First Name __________________
the Niassa and Cabo Delgado regions of
Last Name __________________
Northern Mozambique. http://www.giathai.
Company ___________________
net/pdf/Niassa_Mozambique_Ruby_SeptemAddress ____________________
ber13_2009.pdf
___________________________
Pardieu V., Sturman N., Saesaew S., Du Toit
___________________________
G., Thirangoon K. (2010) FAPFH/GFF Treated
Ruby from Mozambique. http://www.giathai.net/
City _______________________
pdf/Flux_heated_and_glass_filled_rubies_from_
State ______________________
Mozambique.pdf
Zip _______________________
Smith C.P., McClure S.F., Wang W., Hall M.
Country ___________________
(2005) Some characteristics of lead-glass-filled
Tel _______________________
corundum. Jewellery News Asia, November, No.
E-mail _____________________
255, pp. 79-84.
Smith C.P. (2010) Mozambique Rubies. Gems &
Jewellery. Vol. 19, No. 1, pp. 3-5.
www.gemstone.org
GE MOLOGY
E D U C AT I O N
Photos ING
n 1996, eight gemological institutes founded the Federation for European Education in Gemology (F.E.E.G.).
Today, FEEG diploma regroups twelve institutes in
eight countries.
Q Gemmologische Akademie Linz (Austria)
Q sterreichische Gemmologische Gesellschaft (Austria)
Q Academie voor Mineralogie (Belgium)
Q Socit Belge de Gemmologie (Belgium)
Q Institut National de Gemmologie (ING) (France)
Q Deutsche Gemmologische Gesellschaft (Germany)
Q Gem-A (Great Britain)
Q Istituto Gemmologico Italiano (Italy)
Q Dutch Gemmological Institute (Netherlands)
Q Netherlands Gemmological Laboratory (Netherlands)
Q Escola de Gemmologia de la Universitat de
Barcelona (Spain)
Q Instituto Gemolgico Espaol (Spain)
www.JewelleryNetAsia.com
IND UST RY N E WS
BOOK RE VIE W
Boulliard.
Verdelite Elbaite. 7.5 x 2.2 x 2.3 cm. Bevaondrano, Ikalamavony, Madagascar. An elongated
tourmaline crystal showing an incredible natural
green color.
TRADE SHOWS
TRADE SHOWS
TREN D S
Renewed Hope
With optimism that the economic crisis may be over,
expectations at all the shows were hopeful yet realistic.
The Centurion show
was the rst on the
jewelry calendar and,
in a complete mood
turnaround from the
doldrums of last year,
the ambiance was
very upbeat. The hallways were crowded,
the booths were busy,
Gold ring with center 4.34-ct rubel- and most exhibitors
lite, two golden beryls, and six tanza- expressed great satisnites by Julia Behrends.
faction at the results.
Earrings in aquamarine,
smoky quartz, and gold
by Julieli Pure Jewelry.
www.gemstone.org
TRE NDS
MARKE T T R EN D S
56
T R A D E FA I R S
T R A D E FA I R S
58
ISRAEL 5 : 0 0 P M
Cutter checks parameters online with
GIA Facetware Cut Estimator.
NEW YORK
10:00 A M
GIA Master Color Comparison Diamonds
conrm color quality of a fancy yellow.
CARLSBAD
7:00 AM
MUMBAI 7 : 3 0 P M
Staff gemologist submits new ndings on
coated diamonds to GIA global database.
HONG KONG 10 : 0 0 P M
Wholesaler views grading results and requests
additional services online at My Laboratory.
BANGKOK 9:00 P M
Gemologist confers with Carlsbad lab
about ruby country of origin.
All across the planet, GIA labs and gemological reports are creating a common language for accurate, unbiased gemstone
evaluation. From convenient locations in major gem centers, to frontline detection of emerging treatments and synthetics,
to online services that include ordering, tracking, and report previews GIA is pioneering the technology, tools and talent
that not only ensure expert service, but also advance the public trust in gems and jewelry worldwide.
W W W. G I A . E D U
CARLSBAD
DUBAI
NEW YORK
MOSCOW
LONDON
MUMBAI
ANTWERP
BANGKOK
FLORENCE
HONG KONG
GABORONE
TAIPEI
SEOUL
JOHANNESBURG
OSAKA
TOKYO