Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
AND OTHER
EUROPEAN POLEARMS
1300-1650
by George A. Snook, M.D.
Bloomfield, Ont.
EUROPEAN POLEARMS
Cover Illustration: A poleaxe of the mid 15th century superimposed over a late
16th century woodblock print by an unidentified artist. This illustration which
was removed from a 17th century German text, shows warriors (Dopplesoldners) carrying two-handed swords with S-shaped quillons, a type which had
disappeared by about 1600, and "half-moon" shaped halberds.
623.4'41'094
C98-900515-1
MUSEUM RESTORATIONP.O.
SERVICE
Box 390
Alexandria Bay, NY
U.S.A. 13607-0070
Bloomfield, ON
Canada, KOK 1GO
thrusting,
cutting,
percussion,
combination types.
reached its final form, only to await advances in metallurgy to obtain stronger and
more durable tools and weapons.
The halberd is an axe blade surmounted
by a thrusting point backed by a pointed
beak. This three part head is secured to a
six to eight foot long shaft by a number of
nails generally inserted through long straps
known as langets. The langets extend along
the shaft from the head towards the butt.
The nails may be fastened from one side
straight through the shaft to appear in a
hole in the opposite langet and then peened
over or alternatively they may be staggered
so that they strike the opposite langet and
are bent in a curved manner to lock themselves in place. The head weighs about four
pounds depending on the size of the blade.
The first recorded mention of the halberd is found in a poem about the Trojan
War by Konrad of Wurzburg written sometime before 1287. It mentions 6,000 men,
many carrying halberds.
There are two theories regarding the
halberd's initial appearance. One, sug-
The Spear
Fig. 6. An Early form of halberd which has a flat rectangular blade with a rudimentary
beak and no flange. The spear
is flat with no median ridge, c.
1420.
depicting an event of the 14th century, il- was soon simplified by combining the eyes
lustrates a similar example with a wooden into a socket and forging the beak to the
shaft extending beyond the blade and back of the socket. This gives the halberd
sharpened to a point. Wagner shows sev- the basic form which persisted throughout
eral of these types in his illustrations taken its existence.
from sources as early as 1315 which would
The changes in design of the halberd
make this blade contemporary with the from this time onwards is very fluid. While
Morgarten blade.
it would be desirable to precisely date
At that time the rear facing beak was them, it cannot be done. Instead changes in
added. This will be found attached to the the appearance of different parts of the
upper eye or sometimes as a separate de- weapon will be noted, and later these will
tached part of the head with its own eye be combined to make some stylistic order
between the two eyes of the axe blade. It of its development.
The Blade
The most striking change in the halberd's appearance is in the shape of the
blade. The earliest blades were rectangular
as noted above, and the ratio was of greater
length to the width of the blade. This gradually changed to a greater width of the blade
although the edge remained parallel to the
shaft. (Fig. 7) Realizing that the cutting
The Beak
The beak started as a simple spike on
the back of the weapon. (Fig. 5) After it
became attached to the blade it remained as
a short flat beak for a short period, but then
became longer and as it did, it gradually
inclined towards the butt end of the shaft.
This inclination eventually became a defi-
The Socket
The socket for the shaft is first positioned at the rear of the head when it is
formed from a merging of the two eyes. It
then appears to move forward towards the
center of the blade and in front of the spear
Fig. 11. Convex bladed halberd. The spear is flat for part
of its length before becoming
quadrangular, c. 1520.
Fig. 13 This illustration which was removed from a 17th century German text, shows warriors
(Dopplesoldners) with two-handed swords with S-shaped quillons which had disappeared by about
1600, and "half-moon" shaped halberds.
active in the 17th century, have been identified to provide a fairly precise date.
Marks on the shaft are usually arsenal
marks but they are of little help in dating.
The summary of halberd identification
which follows is designed to serve as a
rough guideline to halberd identification
and dating although they cannot be precise.
These weapons were manufactured in
A HALBERD CHRONOLOGY
13th Century
14th century
Upper eye may be smaller than lower eye
Upper edge of blade elongates and indents to form a true spear
Head becomes larger and heavier and more rectangular
14th Century
15th Century
c.l 440-50
c.1430
c.1470
c.1490
c.1480-1500
16th Century
c.1510
c.1510
c.1520
c.1530
C.1570I
c.1590
I I
Fig. 18. Early Landsknecht halberd with
oblique blade, a tapered socket in front of the
heavily reinforced spear, and a rudimentary
flange, c. 1420.
17th century
CUTTING POLEARMS
"and when the arrows were exhausted, seizing up axes, poles, swords,
and sharp spears which were lying about, they prostrated, dispersed,
and stabbed the enemy.3
Fig. 26
Fig. 27
wagoner's axe, but is generally indistinguishable from the style of a German type
of broadaxe. Some of the doloires have
engraving on the blade.
Two axe like weapons which have national associations are the bardiche and the
Lochaber axe.
The bardiche (Fig. 41, 47) has a long
crescentic blade extending far beyond the
pole and attached to the shaft with a socket
at the upper end and a flange at the bottom
which was nailed to the pole. It is mainly
associated with Russian infantry of the
16th century.
The lochaber (Fig. 32) axe usually has
two sockets attaching a large curved blade
to a pole. Its characteristic feature is a hook
at the upper end facing the opposite direction from the edge of the blade. The hook
probably appeared later than the early Ren-
Fig. 32. Lochaber axe. A later version with the posterior facing
hook. Earlier versions did not have the hook.
Fig. 29. Military Fork - A development of the pitchfork. The tires are
straight and there is usually a stop at
the base to limit penetration.
Fig. 30. Awlspiess (awlpike) - A
long but rugged needle which has a
circular hand guard mid way between
point and butt.
PERCUSSION POLEARMS
"You warriors of God and His Law, Pray for God's help and believe in Him,
So that with Him you will ever be victorious. You archers and lancers of
knightly rank, Pikemen and flailsmen of the common people, Keep you all in
mind the generous Lord . . . . You will all shout "At them, at them!" And feel
the pride of a weapon in your hands, Crying "God is our Lord! "4
Fig. 33. Glaive. A weapon with the cutting edge on the convex side.
This is actually a knife or sword-like blade mounted on a shaft. It differs
from the military scythe in that the cutting edge is on the concave side
of the scythe.
Fig. 34. Doloire. A two handed axe which was also called a waggoner's axe. The blade may be mounted at a slight angle to the socket.
Engraving is present in this specimen.
grains from the stalks or chaff. The linking of the two sticks
served to bring a greater striking surface to the wheat and it also
increased the striking force.
Reinforcing the primitive flail with metal bands decreased
the tendency of the wood to break and also increased its impact.
The military flail (Fig. 35) had metal knobs or spikes added to
the striking part. When the hinged striker is replaced with a
knobbed or spiked wooden or metal ball and attached to the shaft
with one or more chains it becomes a much more complex flail.
This weapon, while difficult to master, it is also more difficult
to defend against because of the flexibility of the chain. Flails
were a principal weapon of Jan Ziska's Taborites in the Hussite
Wars which took place at the beginning of the fifteenth century.
The spiked club (Fig. 36) was similar but without the mobile
end. It is basically a two handed mace with additional refinements such as spikes . It usually had a spear type point to use as
a thrusting weapon. This weapon was known by many names
such as a "holy water sprinkler" or "morgenstern." The
and again:
Cil baton sont longs et traitis Pourferir a
deux mains faitis. (The shafts are made
long in order to permit swing with both
hands).5
COMBINATION POLEARMS
Combination polearms are those which blade differs from the halberd as it has a
combine several functions and in this cate- pronounced forward curve at the upper end
gory the halberd takes precedence. The which accounts for either its name or the
other weapons are similar to the halberd in name of its agricultural counterpart the
function if not in appearance. Each com- billhook. The shape of the blade may take
bines at least two of the functions and they different forms but the forward curve or
all have the capacity for thrusting and hook to the blade is characteristic. The
either cutting or percussion.
spear and the fluke may be round, square
The English bill (Fig. 37, 38, 49) can be or flat in cross section. The shaft can be
considered as the English halberd. The either round or octagonal. Most seem to
Fig. 40. Roncone (Italian bill, rosschinder). This is a much more sophisticated weapon
than the bill, it does not have the weight of the halberd, and there are more piercing points.
It is called a bill because of the upper curve of the blade. The German name (rosschinder)
best describes its use (horse cutter) as it could easily hamstring a horse.
Fig. 41 The Bardiche is a cutting poleami with a long crescentic blade attached to the
shaft by a socket at the lower end and in the mid point of the blade.
Fig. 42. Military Scythe. A scythe-like blade attached in line with the shaft with the
cutting edge on the concave side. It differs from the agricultural scythe only in the angle
of the tang and the blade.
outrance" (serious combat) using sharpened weapons rather than "a plaisance"
(friendly combat) in which blunted weapons were used and little harm done to an
opponent and was probably an answer to
sturdier armor. It had a spear point and an
axe blade but the beak was replaced by a
hammer with rudimentary knobs to serve
as a crushing tool. They were frequently
ornamented with brass inlays and they are
heavier than the halberd with a shorter
shaft, and might have a rondel for a hand
guard. It appears in the first half of the 15th
century and disappears shortly thereafter.
Fig. 43 Lucerne hammer. This weapon utilizes a four pronged hammer in place of the
blade of the halberd. The shorter the points on the hammer the better it would be for
crushing armor. The longer points would be better used against unarmored opponents. It
appears in the 15th century and the soldier was usually placed in the middle of the Swiss
phalanx along with the halberdiers. It seems to be a local favorite with the city of Lucerne
and takes its name from that city.
Fig. 44. Pole axe with a four-prong beak. Another version had a hammer-like beak as
seen on the cover. In either case it is sturdier and shorter than the halberd and can easily
crush or pierce armor. Many poleaxes are engraved or otherwise decorated and were
probably used in the tournaments.
emphasized that no single weapon was responsible for the development. Several
available weapons had to be used together
as any single weapon had its particular
weakness.
The long spear or pike as it was known such as the crossbow and the longbow were
in the 16th century had two separate peri- significant as well, but only in good
ods of ascendancy. In the 4th century B.C., weather. In the rain or in open fields unprothe Macedonians under Philip II took the tected by other weapons the archer was at
short spear of the Greeks and lengthened it the mercy of the horseman unless he could
to approximately 18 feet. This weapon, the flee (as in the case of the steppe horse
sarissa, when presented in serried ranks archer). Furthermore in close combat on
formed a nearly impenetrable hedge of foot, the archer was also at a disadvantage
points which the hoplite, the heavily ar- as the bow and crossbow are ineffectual
mored Greek soldier, with his shorter spear hand to hand weapons.
could not disrupt.
In Scotland the long spear or pike apAn 18 foot spear which had to be peared to be an established weapon as early
handled with two hands precluded the con- as 1298 at Falkirk, and it had been seen in
ventional use of a shield. The Macedonians Wales even earlier. The Scottish spear was
solved this problem by decreasing the size about 12 feet long; a length that could be
and weight of the Hoplite shield. It was handled with two hands or on occasion,
hung by a strap around the neck and even with one hand. At Falkirk in 1298 the
strapped to the arm of the soldier so that formations of spearmen the schiltrons were
both hands could be used to wield the defeated by the English under the astute
spear. The advance of a Macedonian pha- generalship of Edward I. His cavalry first
lanx must have been an impressive and routed the Scottish archers, and then he
terrifying sight. This compact phalanx proceeded to destroy the schiltron formawhen used in conjunction with cavalry and tion with his own archers.
lighter forms of siege weapons dominated
It is at this point that we see the rise in
the battlefield of its time.
importance of the polearm. It appears to
At Cynocephalae, in 197 BC, the more have started in the more agrarian rugged
mobile Romans lured the ponderous Mace- terrains where a fierce degree of indedonian phalanx onto uneven ground, and pendence coupled with relative lack of
attacked it from the flank. The Macedoni- wealth prohibited the general use of armor.
ans with the long sarissas were helpless In Wales while spearmen were an imporwhen facing the Romans with their short tant part of their levies, it is probable that
stabbing swords. This open formation the abundance of the yew tree favored the
quickly dominated tactics, the phalanx for- development of the archer. In Scotland and
mation was abandoned, and military affairs especially Switzerland, however, it was the
for the next few centuries were controlled polearm that appeared.
by the Roman legions.
The pike rose to prominence as a result
Their success was mainly due to their of two battles. At Courtrai in 1302 the
tight discipline in combat and on the Flemish burghers and peasants inflicted a
march. This coupled with good generalship crushing defeat on the French armored
led to their continued success unless poor horse. At Bannockburn, (1314) the Scots
leadership such as that of Varus in the maintained steady discipline in the ranks of
Teutoburgerwald intervened.7 At Adri- pikemen, and with the judicious use of teranople, in 378 AD, the Roman legions were rain and supporting cavalry and archers,
crushed by the Gothic armored horsemen successfully defeated the English army of
ending the battlefield supremacy of the in- Edward II. It must be stated, however, that
fantry for nearly the next 1000 years.
in each case the ineptness of the attacking
Armored cavalry in turn was not invin- forces contributed to their defeat. The often
cible. Terrain was certainly a factor, as overlooked factor at Bannockburn was that
mountainous country, bogs and forests re- while the pikemen were used as a defensive
stricted its movement. Missile weapons wall at the start they were also used as an
GLOSSARY
In probably no other field of arms history is the vocabulary so confusing as in the study of
medieval arms and armor. This is due to many factors including language, personal bias, lack
of communication, tradition, and sometimes pedantic obfuscation. This glossary makes no
pretensions to being the only correct one, It is included to be of assistance to readers.
Ahlspiess A polearm having a long needle
like blade with a rondel hand guard. The
blade is about as long as the shaft.
Bardiche (Berdysh) A cutting type of
polearm with a long crescentic blade attached to the shaft by a socket at the lower
end and in the mid point of the blade. The
blade extends beyond the shaft. It was a
weapon of Russian infantry.
Beak the rearward facing point on a halberd.
Is sometimes called a fluke.
Bearded Axe. An axe which has a straight
or only slightly curved upper edge and a
pronounced curve at the lower edge such that
it appears to have a beard. It was an important weapon of the Vikings and of the Housecarles of Saxon England.
Bill A British weapon which has several
forms. It could be called a variant of the
halberd. It has an axe like blade which terminated at the upper end in a forward curving sickle shaped point. It also has a
thrusting point and may have a beak.
Celt A paleolithic tool, a stone sharpened on
one edge and used as a scraper or knife, and
if held in the hand to strike anything it could
be called a hand axe.
Chauve Souris (Bat winged) A form of
runka which has forward pointing wings of
large size. The wings and the main blade are
sharpened and have notches which give it an
appearance of a bat's wings.
Corseque (Korseke, Spetum) A form of partisan with wings which curve backwards towards the butt of the weapon. The forward
edges are sharp.
Couteau de Breche An early form of cutting
polearm which basically is a knife mounted
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
Bardiche.
Bearded Axe.
Bill.
Chauve Souris.
Corseque.
Couteau de Breche.
Doloire.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
Glaive.
Guisarme
Kriegsgertel.
Lochaber Axe.
Lucerne Hammer.
Lugged Spear.
Military Fork.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
Fig.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
Military Scythe.
Ox Tongue.
Partisan.
Poleaxe.
Roncone
Runka.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Fig. 60
Fig. 61
Fig. 62
Fig. 63
Fig. 64
NOTES
John of Winterthur retelling the description by the
King of Bohemia of the mercenaries of Claris in
the army of Louis of Austria in 1330 near Colmar.
This quotation, a translation from a Latin manuscript in the British Museum was written by a
priest who accompanied the English on the Agincourt campaign. It was originally published in Sir
Harris Nicholas' History of the Battle ofAgin-
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This study owes much to two persons,
John Waldman and James Gooding. Dr.
Waldman's knowledge and enthusiasm for
medieval artifacts is responsible for steering my interest towards a period earlier
than the 17th century. Prof. Gooding as the
publisher, has had to deal with a sometimes
obdurate author with tact and firmness and
the study is much better for it. I owe a great
deal to both.
The Hugo Schneider article described
on page 27 was translated for me by Dr.
Klaus Kroner of the University of Massachusetts. The notes pertaining to his experiments were extracted from an
unpublished manuscript written by Dr.
Waldman and myself and I am grateful to
him also for the photographs of the
Solothurn skulls which were taken by him.
Dr. David Navon of the University of Massachusetts provided insight and instruction
on the physics of speed, acceleration and
impact as it related to these experiments.
There are many others who have assisted me in many ways: Col. John Elting,
USA Retired, has been my inspiration and
instructor on prior projects and read this
work; Prof. Donald Murray of the University of New Hampshire read the work as did
Brian Dunnigan, formerly of Old Fort Niagara. Dr. Donald Chrisman provided information on the late 19th century head
wounds and the Northampton Police Dept.
provided the speed gun tests of pole arms.
Finally there is the unstinting encouragement that my family provided and deserves
acknowledgement.
There were many museums and collectors who graciously allowed their collections to be studied and in most cases to be
photographed. These included Dr. Marco
Leutenegger of the Altes Zeughaus of
Solothurn, Switzerland; Mr. K. Corey Keeble of the Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto,
Canada; Messrs. Guy M. Wilson and
Graeme Rimer of the Royal Armouries Museum in Leeds, England; Mr. Keith Matthews of the Castle Museum in York,
England; Mr. Walter Karcheski of the Higgins Armory in Worcester, Massachusetts;
Mr. Jiirg Meier of the Fischer Galleries in
Lucerne, Switzerland; and Dr. C. Keith
Wilbur of Northampton, Massachusetts.
PHOTO CREDITS
Altes Zeughaus, Solothurn, Switzerland: Fig. 6, 19, 29, 44, 45; The Castle Museum, York,
England: Fig. 18; The Fischer Galleries, Lucerne, Switzerland; Cover, Fig. 63; Royal Armouries
Museum, Leeds, England: Fig, 22,46, 58, 65 (photos by the author reproduced by permission of
the Trustees of the Armouries): Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Canada: Fig. 24, 32, 41, 56;
Schweizersches Landesmuseum, Zurich: Fig. 28; C. Keith Wilbur: Fig. 1.
Errata: Page 30, Fig. 60 to 64 renumber as Fig. 62 to 66.