Sheet1

Number in accord to Dario's classification

10

11

12

19

Page 1

Sheet1

26

39

40

41

42

43

48

49

50.00
51

52

Page 2

Sheet1

53

54

55

56

57.00

58

59.00

Page 3

Sheet1

60

61

62

63

64
65

66

67

68

Page 4

Sheet1

69

70

71.00
72

73

74.00

75

76

Page 5

Sheet1
78

77
79

80

81

82

Page 6

Sheet1

83

84

86

87

88

Page 7

Sheet1
Title

Authors

Wastewater treatment: New insight provided by interactive multiobjective optimization

Hakanen, Jussi
Miettinen, Kaisa
Sahlstedt, Kristian

Benchmarking energy consumption in municipal wastewater treatment plants in Japan.

Mizuta, Kentaro
Shimada, Masao

Energy benchmarking of South Australian WWTPs

Krampe

Multi-criteria selection of optimum WWTP control set points based on microbiologyrelated failures, effluent quality and operating costs

Guerrero, J.
Guisasola, A.
Comas, J.

WWTP design in warm climates - guideline comparison and parameter adaptation for
a full-scale activated sludge plant using mass balancing.

Walder, C
Lindtner, S
Proesl, A
Klegraf, F
Weissenbacher, N

Benchmarking of large municipal wastewater treatment plants treating over 100,000

PE in Austria

Lindtner, S.
Schaar, H.
Kroiss, H.

Benchmarking of WWTP design by assessing costs, effluent quality and process

variability

Benedetti, L.
Bixio, D.
Vanrolleghem, P.a.

Comparing the efficiency of wastewater treatment technologies through a DEA

metafrontier model

Sala-Garrido, R.
Molinos-Senante,
M.
HernndezSancho, F.

Page 8

Sheet1

Waste-to-Energy (W2E) software - a support tool for decision making process

Tous, M
Bebar, L
Houdkova, L
Pavlas, M
Stehlik, P

Making Water Resource Decisions More "Informationally" Efficient: Development of a

Pease, Michael
Geospatial Water Rights Decision Support System for Kittitas County, Washington
Murray, Jeremy
Puig, S
van Loosdrecht, M
Data evaluation of full-scale wastewater treatment plants by mass balance.
CM
Colprim, J
Meijer, S C F
Multi-criteria analysis of wastewater treatment plant design and control scenarios under
uncertainty

Benedetti, L.
De Baets, B.
Nopens, I.
Vanrolleghem, P.a.

A systematic approach for fine-tuning of fuzzy controllers applied to WWTPs

Ruano, M.V.
Ribes, J.
Sin, G.
Seco, A.
Ferrer, J.

Improving the performance of a WWTP control system by model-based setpoint

optimisation

Guerrero, Javier
Guisasola, Albert
Vilanova, Ramon
Baeza, Juan a.

Introduction to Decision support system

[ebook] Cognition-Driven Decision Support for Business Intelligence

Marakas
Niu, Li
Lu, Jie
Zhang, Guangquan
Test, Bla

Cruise Management
Information and Decision Support Systems
Decision Support - An Examination of the DSS Discipline

Different authors

Decision Support Systems

Collaborative Models and Approaches
in Real Environments

Zarate, Jorge E.
Hernndez Pascale
Delibaic, Ftima
Dargam Boris
(Eds.), Shaofeng
Liu Rita Ribeiro

Page 9

Sheet1

Ebook: Decision Support Systems II Recent Developments Applied to DSS Network

Environments

Liu, Jorge E.
Hernndez
Shaofeng
Zarat, Boris
Delibaic Pascale
(Eds.), Ftima
Dargam Rita
Ribeiro

Handbook on decision support system 1 e 2

Frada Burstein; W.
Holsapple

Intelligent Decision-making Support Systems

Development of a knowledge-based decision support system for identifying adequate

wastewater treatment for small communities

Environmental Decision Support Systems

An advanced integrated expert system for wastewater treatment plants control

A knowledge based system to support the process selection during waste water treatment

Page 10

Jatinder N.D.
Gupta, Guisseppi
A. Forgionne
T., and Manuel
Mora
Comas, J
Alemany, J
Poch, M
Torrens, A
Salgot, M
Bou, J
Girona, Universitat
De
Montilivi, Campus
Barcelona,
Universitat De
Cortes

Paraskevas, P.a
Pantelakis, I.S
Lekkas, T.D
Wukovits, W
Harasek, M
Friedl, A

Sheet1

Model-based knowledge acquisition in environmental decision support system for

wastewater integrated management.

Wastewater treatment plant design and operation under multiple

conflicting objective functions
A linear ASM1 based multi-model for activated sludge systems

ACTIVATED SLUDGE MODELS ASM1, ASM2, ASM2d AND ASM3

Prat, Pau
Benedetti, Lorenzo
Corominas, Llus
Comas, Joaquim
Poch, Manel

Hakanen, J.
Sahlstedt, K.
Miettinen, K.
Smets, Ilse
Verdickt, Liesbeth
Van Impe, Jan
Henze, Mogens
Gujer, Willi
Mino, Takashi
Loosdrecht, Mark
Van

Ebook:Non linear multiobjective optimization

Reti Neurali Artificiali: Teoria ed Applicazioni

Crescenzio Gallo

Introduzione alle Reti Neurali

Lazzerini

Ebook: Artificial Neural Networks

and Machine Learning
ICANN 2013

23rd International
Conference on
Artificial Neural
Networks
Sofia, Bulgaria,
September 2013
Proceedings

Artificial neural networks for rapid WWTP performance evaluation: Methodology and
case study

Rduly, B.
Gernaey, K.V.
Capodaglio, A.G.
Mikkelsen, P.S.
Henze, M.

Page 11

Sheet1

Application of Artificial Neural Network (ANN) for the prediction of EL-AGAMY

wastewater treatment plant performance-EGYPT

Nasr, Mahmoud S.
Moustafa, Medhat
a.E.
Seif, Hamdy a.E.
El Kobrosy, Galal

Prediction of wastewater treatment plant performance using artificial neural networks

Hamed, Maged M
Khalafallah, Mona
G
Hassanien, Ezzat a

Simulation of an industrial wastewater treatment plant using

artificial neural networks
A fuzzy neural network approach for online fault detection in waste water treatment
process

Artificial Intelligence and Environmental Decision Support Systems

Environmental decision support systems: Current issues, methods and tools

Data-driven modeling approaches to support wastewater treatment plant operation

Honggui, Han
Ying, Li
Junfei, Qiao

Ceccaroni, L
Es, U Cort
Poch, M
Montilivi,
Matthies, Michael
Giupponi, Carlo
Ostendorf, Bertram

Drrenmatt, David
Jrme
Gujer, Willi

Artificial neural network modelling of a large-scale wastewater treatment plant

operation.

Gl, Dnyamin
Dursun, Skr
Page 12

Sheet1
Ebook: applied fuzzy aritmetics

Designing and building real environmental decision support systems

Poch, Manel
Comas, Joaquim
Rodrguez-Roda,
Ignasi
Snchez-Marr,
Miquel
Corts, Ulises

Decision Making support system in multi objective issues of quality management in the Semenova,
Smirnova,
field of information technology
Tushavin
Evaluation of multivariate linear regression and artificial neural networks in prediction of
Zare Abyaneh,
water quality parameters
Hamid
McIntosh, B.S.
Ascough, J.C.
Twery, M.
Chew, J.
Elmahdi, A.
Haase, D.
Harou, J.J.
Hepting, D.
Cuddy, S.
Jakeman, A.J.
Chen, S.
Kassahun, A.
Lautenbach, S.
Environmental decision support systems (EDSS) development Challenges and best
Matthews, K.
practices
Merritt, W.
Quinn, N.W.T.
Rodriguez-Roda, I.
Sieber, S.
Stavenga, M.
Sulis, A.
Ticehurst, J.
Volk, M.
Wrobel, M.
van Delden, H.
El-Sawah, S.
Rizzoli, A.
Voinov, A.

A sensor-software based on a genetic algorithm-based neural fuzzy system for

modeling and simulating a wastewater treatment process

Page 13

Huang, Mingzhi
Ma, Yongwen
Wan, Jinquan
Chen, Xiaohong

Sheet1

Knowledge discovery with clustering based on rules by states: A water treatment

application

Where are we in wastewater treatment plants data management? A review and a

proposal

Gibert, K.
Rodrguez-Silva, G.
Rodrguez-Roda, I.
Poch, Manel
Comas, Joaquim
Porro, Jos
Garrido-Baserba,
Manel
Corominas, Lluis
Pijuan, Maite

An Efficiency-Centred Hierarchical Method to Assess Performance of Wastewater

Treatment Plants

Chen, Z.*, Zayed,

T.
Qasem, A.
Design, Development and Implementation of a Robust Decision Support Expert
System (branDEC) in Multi Criteria Decision Making

Evaluation of process conditions triggering emissions of green-house gases from a

biological wastewater treatment system.

Page 14

Jha, N.K.
Kumar, R.
Kumari, A.
Bepari, B.
RodriguezCaballero, A
Aymerich, I
Poch, M
Pijuan, M

Sheet1
Macrotags

DSS & Optimization

Tags
Note
Related paper Evaluation
Decision support; INDNIMBUS; Interactive
methods; Multicriteria
It works on multioptimization; Simulationobjective
8,5
based optimization;
optimization, it uses
Wastewater treatment
NINBUS technique
planning; wastewater
treatment planning

Benchmarking

Benchmarking; EnergyGenerating Resources;

Environmental
Monitoring; Greenhouse
Effect; Japan; Waste
Disposal; Fluid; Waste
Disposal; Fluid: methods

Benchmarking

Benchmarking;
Conservation of Energy
Resources; South
Australia

DSS & Optimization

WWTP generic

Benchmarking

Benchmarking

DSS & Optimization

Bioreactors; Climate;
Sewage; Sewage:
chemistry; Waste
Disposal; Fluid; Waste
Disposal; Fluid: methods

Important for
benchmarking
approach and for
reference values

7.5

Important for
benchmarking
approach and for
reference values
Important for
literature, plant
performance
function
development,
operational cost,
Pareto front
reference quality
data by mass
balance

7.5

[40]

IWA_Performa
Important for
nce indicators;
statistical analysis of
Austrian
KPIs
benchmarking
system
benchmarking; costeffectiveness;
Important for
mathematical modelling; calculation of quality
Monte carlo simulation;
KPIs
probabilistic
DEA approach,
Pareto frontier and
meta-frontier to
data envelopment analysis;
compare different
dea
technologies

Page 15

8,5

Sheet1

DSS & WWTP

Not so much
info

WWTP generic

out of our topic

WWTP & data analysis

data analysis using

mass balance

DSS & Optimization

MC simulation on
Benchmark
Simulation Model
no. 2(BSM2)

6.5

activated sludge model

WWTP & Fuzzy Logic

da rivedere

It define the function

Operational Cost
depending on VOL
Maybe it is possible
apply some
optimization for the
linear function
(SIMPLEX ?)

DSS & Optmization

DSS & Optmization

DSS & Optmization

7.5

Just an intro
Models, Techniques,
Systems and Applicatins

Compplete
handbook about
DSS

0.00
Collection of
paper on DSS

DSS & Optmization

not classified

Page 16

Sheet1

DSS

not classified

Compplete
handbook about
DSS

DSS & Optmization

Cap 26
ANN & DSS

not classified

DSS & Optmization

DSS & Optmization

adequate treatment;
decision support;
knowledge-based; small
communities; wastewater
environmental decision;
environmental science

DSS & WWTP

activated sludge; artificial

intelligence; automatic
control; expert systems;
wastewater treatment

DSS & WWTP

costs; processes;
selection; sequencing;
treatment; wastewater;
water

Important for the

knowledge
acquisition and for
related literature

NOT USEFUL

0.00
cfr. Fig 1
Structure for
DSS

NOT USEFUL

Page 17

8.5

0.00

Sheet1

DSS & WWTP

Computer Simulation;
Decision Support
Systems; Management;
Environmental
It gives different
Monitoring;
cause of reflection:
Environmental
sensitivity analysis,
Monitoring: methods;
Monte Carlo
Models; Theoretical;
simulations,
Rivers; Spain; Waste
reference models
Disposal; Fluid; Waste
Disposal; Fluid: methods;
Water Pollutants;
Chemical; Weather

WWTP & Optimization

multiobjective
optimization

it is an interesting
update of 05 with
GPS-X-INDIBUS

DSS & Opmization

asm1; cost benchmark;

linearization; model
complexity reduction

It use simplified
modelling ASM1

[05]

6.5

WWTP

not classified

not classified
Neural Network

Introduzione
alle reti neurali

Neural Network

Introduzione
alle reti neurali

not classified

WWTP and Neural

Network

artificial neural networks;

modeling; performance
evaluation; plant design; ANN used to predict
simulation speed; time
WWTP
series; wastewater
treatment plant

Page 18

7.5

Sheet1

WWTP and Neural

Network

WWTP and Neural

Network

ANN used to predict

WWTP
artificial neural networks
biochemical oxygen
demand; model studies;
neural networks;
optimization; prediction;
suspended solids; waste
water treatment

It use ANN on
WWTP but without
energy

8,5

cfr. Fig. 5 with

STEPS OF
MODEL
DEVELOPME
NT PROCESS

8,5

0.00
It uses fuzzy neural
network to detect
error in sensor data

7.5

It works on DSS
framework, listing
different alternatives
Fig. 1 e Fig. 2
to develop black-box
functions. Fig. 1 and
Fig.2 are important

8.5

WWTP & Fuzzy Logic

Data cleaning

Artificial intelligence &

DSS

artificial intelligence;
environmental decision
support systems;
problem solving

Generic DSS

DSS

NOT Useful

WWTP & software

sensor

acquisition; data-driven
modeling; supervisory
control and data;
wastewater treatment
plant

Software sensor

WWTP and Neural

Network

Algorithms; Cities;
Computer Simulation;
Computers; Equipment
Design; Models;
Theoretical; Neural
Networks (Computer);
It uses ANN
Reproducibility of
approach to predict
Results; Time Factors;
the output of a
Turkey; Waste Disposal; WWTP. To be used
Fluid; Waste Disposal;
if we choose this
Fluid: methods; Water
option
Pollutants; Chemical;
Water Pollutants;
Chemical: analysis;
Water Purification; Water
Purification: methods

Page 19

0.00

80 & 76

Sheet1
not classified

DSS, optimization, ANN

It uses ANN in a
DSS to predict
WWTP behaviour

DSS & Optmization

Figura 2 - figura 3 - Figura 9.5

6

DSS & Optmization

WWTP & Neural

Network

EDSS

WWTP & Neural

Network

ann; bod; cod; mlr;

wastewater treatment
plant

It talks about
selection of
alternatives using
fuzzy logic
It uses ANN to
predict BOD & COD
by other
measurement

6.5

7.5
76

It debate about
strenght and
weakness of EDSS.
It focuses on real
experiences, it
provides best
pratices and it
suggests the main
features of a
successful EDSS

It predict COD, NO,

and PO using online
Anoxic/oxic process;
measurementIt
Genetic algorithm; Neural
tried with GENETIC
fuzzy system; On-line
ALGORITMS and
monitoring
with Fuzzy Neural
Network

environmental decision
support systems

Page 20

80

Sheet1

DSS & WWTP

DSS & WWTP

WWTP

DSS

WWTP

It uses the concept

of classes and
Clustering; Data mining;
trajctoryit could be
Dynamics; Inductive
useful in a predictive
learning; Knowledge
model it is also
discovery from data;
useful for
Profiles induction; Rules;
Knowledge
States; Wastewater
Discovery by data
(KDD) approach
It is just a literature
review but it is
mixing
Data mining; Heuristic
updated and it
heuristic and
knowledge; WWTP
suggest to mix
qualitative
management
Euristic and
knowledge
Qualitative
Knowledge

condition rating;
infrastructure; model;
performance index;
wastewater treatment

It gives a
methodology to
easily evaluate the
plant performance
and the performance
of stages alsoit
works just on quality
of effluentit could
be an useful
approach also with
KPI and energy

MCDM techniques;
aggregated/group
Currently not
decision making.;
interestingmaybe
decision support expert
later
system
Activated sludge; Fullscale monitoring; GreenCurrently not
house gas emissions;
interestingmaybe
Methane; Nitrous oxide;
later
Wastewater treatment

Page 21

7.5