Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Thisarticleisbroughttoyouwiththesupportof
SingaporeConcreteInstitute
www.scinst.org.sg
AllRightsreservedforCIPremierPTELTD
YouarenotAllowedtoredistributeorresalethearticleinanyformatwithoutwrittenapprovalof
CIPremierPTELTD
VisitOurWebsiteformoreinformation
www.cipremier.com
30th Conference on OUR WORLD IN CONCRETE & STRUCTURES: 23 24 August 2005, Singapore
Abstract
Recently, hybrid prestressed concrete bridges with corrugated steel webs have
been increasing rapidly in Japan. In general a hybrid prestressed concrete bridge with
corrugated steel webs is a sophisticated modification of the conventional prestresssed
concrete box girder bridges by replacing the concrete webs with corrugated steel
plates. Reducing the dead load of main girders, improving the prestress efficiency,
and reducing the construction work and cost are principally main advantages of this
structure. The hybrid prestressed concrete bridge with corrugated steel webs was
originally developed in France in the 1980s, and later introduced to Japan in the
1990s. Thereafter, researching into this structure has been increased and several
unique techniques have been developed in Japan. As a cost reduction technique, the
hybrid prestressed concrete bridge with corrugated steel webs has been gaining
attention based on a number of constructions increasing every year in Japan.
Recently, the hybrid prestressed concrete bridge with corrugated steel webs has been
applied to long span bridges, for example, extradosed bridges and cable stayed
bridges with spans in excess of 200m.
Keywords:
1.
Introduction
Recently, there have been many attempts in Japan to reduce the dead load of the superstructure of
bridges, and reduce the work and cost involved in construction. One attempt is hybrid prestressed
concrete bridges with corrugated steel webs (hereafter, corrugated web bridges), which is currently
gaining attention as a method to reduce the cost of prestressed concrete bridges. In Japan, all over 50
bridges of this type were either completed or are under construction. The idea of using corrugated steel
plate as webs was presented in Japan in 1965 [1] and was realized in 1976 as the supporting girders
for the crane in the steel factory as shown in Photo1 [2]. The technique of using corrugated steel plate
as the webs in prestressed concrete bridges was originally developed in France, and realized in 1986
[3]. The first corrugated web bridge in Japan was completed in 1993 [4]. Thereafter, experimental and
analytical researches into this structure increased, and several unique techniques were also developed
in Japan [5][6][7]. This paper describes the basic properties, latest technology, and actual construction
of corrugated web bridges which have been developed rapidly in the last 10 years.
2.
steel plates. By replacing the concrete webs with corrugated steel plates, the following benefits can be
obtained: (1) reduced self weight of the main girder, (2) improved efficiency of the prestress, (3)
improved shear resistance, (4) reduced manpower in construction work, and (5) reduced cost.
In conventional prestressed concrete box girder bridges, the concrete webs account for 30~40% of
the self weight of girder; therefore, this self weight can be greatly reduced by replacing the concrete
webs with corrugated steel plates. Furthermore, the corrugated steel plate does not resist axial forces
and bending moments but has high resistance to shear buckling as shown in Fig. 2. According to these
characteristics, the corrugated steel plates are quite beneficial for the webs of presstressed concrete
bridges for the efficiency of prestress and the shear force resistance. In the construction, formworks,
reinforcement, and other site operations are not required since the construction of concrete webs can
be neglected. As a result, the construction work on site can be reduced. In addition, the environmental
impact can be reduced in accordance with the reduction of formworks.
Concrete Slab
Corrugated
Steel Web
Corrugated Steel Web
External Tendons
Concrete Slab
Internal Tendons
3. Structural Behavior
3.1 Flexural Behavior
As shown in Fig. 2, the axial stiffness of corrugated steel webs can be neglected in engineering
point of view. Furthermore, only upper and lower concrete slabs are considered on resisting the axial
forces and bending moments as shown in Fig. 3. Based on the many experiments and analyses, the
assumption that plane sections remain plane was verified and the similar ultimate flexural moment
between corrugated web bridges and conventional prestressed concrete bridge was also verified [5][7].
Therefore, apart from ignoring the stiffness of corrugated steel webs, the design for bending moments
and axial forces is the same as the conventional prestressed concrete bridges [8].
No Ax ia l Force
No Bend ing Moment
rce
Fo
r
ea
Sh
r
ea
Sh
rce
Fo
Ax ia l Force
Shear Force
a) General Buckling
b) Combined Buckling
Photo 2 Shear buckling of corrugated steel webs
3.4 Torsional Behavior
Compared with the conventional prestressed concrete box girders, the stiffness in out-of-plane
direction of corrugated steel webs is relatively small. Thus, the cross-section tends to deform easily as
shown in Fig. 5. When the cross-section deforms, it causes a reduction in the cross-sectional stiffness
or increases warping torsional stresses. Therefore, on curved or skewed bridges it is necessary to
place the diaphragms at suitable intervals in order to restrict the cross-sectional deformation. Past
researches showed that the effect of cross-sectional deformation is virtually eliminated when the
diaphragms are reinforced at suitable intervals [13][14]. In Japan, the curved bridge with corrugated
steel webs has been constructed with a minimum radius of curvature of 140m.
a) St.Venant deformation
b) Warping deformation
New Technologies
4.1 Connections
In hybrid structures, the connections between the concrete and steel greatly affect on the structural
performance and cost. Initially studs or angle shear connectors were used to connect the concrete
slabs and corrugated steel webs. However, unique
connections were developed in Japan in order to
reduce the cost of connections and improve the
structural performance as shown in Fig. 6.
(1) Embedded Connection
In an embedded connection, the corrugated
steel webs are directly embedded in the concrete
slabs. Since the steel flange plates fitted with shear
connectors are not required, this is the most
economical connection method [6][7]. According to
its characteristics, fatigue durability is high and
construction tolerances are easy to absorb.
However, there is a concern that rain water or
condensation might be led to the webs and
seepage into the connections, causing the
Photo 3 Water proof of embedded connection
corrosion of connections. Therefore, the waterproof
is necessary as shown in Photo 3.
a) Stud connection
b) Angle connection
c) Embedded connection
d) S-PBL connection
f) T-PBL connection
4.2 Joints
The details of the joint between steel plates largely influence on the structural performance and
cost of corrugated web bridges. Unlike conventional steel bridges, the web of corrugated web bridges
resists shear forces without any effect of axial forces; thus, the joint is not necessary to have the axes of
the web plates in one line [6][7]. Accordingly, single shear friction joints or lapped fillet welded joints, as
shown in Fig.7, can be applied to corrugated web bridges. Compared with conventional double shear
friction joint or butt welded joints, single shear friction joints or lapped fillet welded joints are much
simpler, and construction work and cost can be reduced.
Secondary Steel
Plate Cross Beam
Steel Plate
Anchor
could be simplified. Furthermore, by effectively using precast concrete panels as embedded formwork,
as shown in Photo 20, execution was rationalized and proceeded faster.
6.
Conclusion
The corrugated web bridge introduced here are the structures with lower self weight, improved
prestress efficiency, reduced construction work, and lower cost compared with conventional
prestressed concrete box girder bridges. Currently in Japan over 50 corrugated web bridges were
either completed or are under construction, which are the evidence of the effectiveness of this
structure. Also, this type of bridges is aesthetically appreciated.
In preparing this paper, technical documents gathered in the society for research on composite
structures with corrugated steel webs were used. The society for research on composite Structures with
corrugated steel webs was founded in 1993 with the objectives of promoting, developing and improving
corrugated steel web bridges. The society has been playing an important role in the development of
corrugated web bridges in Japan. The authors hope that this paper can contribute to the promotion and
development of corrugated steel web bridges, and to the provision of quality social capital.
Acknowledgement
In preparing this paper, the authors received assistance from the following members of the society
for research on composite structures with corrugated steel webs: Mr. Takashi Oura, President, Dr.
Hisao Tachikami, Mr. Akira Morohashi, Mr. Keisuke Takaba, Mr. Tsutomu Machi, and Mr. Shuuji
Tachida. The authors would like to express their deep gratitude to them for their assistance.
References
[1] Shimada, S.: Shearing Strength of Steel Plate Girder with Folded Web Plate (Ripple Web Girders),
Journals of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers, No.124, 1965.12, pp.1-10
[2] Tagawa, K., Okamoto, H. and Nakata, K.: Studies on Corrugated Web Girders, Technical Report of
NKK Corporation (Japan), No.71, 1976, pp25-33
[3] Lebon, J. D.: Steel Corrugated Web Bridges -First Achievements, Developments in Short and
Medium Span Bridge Engineering 98 (Canada), 1998, pp.101-111
[4] Kondo, M., Shimizu, Y., Kobayashi, K. and Hattori, M.: Design and Construction of the Shinkai
Bridge -Prestressed concrete Bridge using Corrugated Steel Webs-, Bridge and Foundation
Engineering, Vol.28, No.9, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 1994.9, pp.13-20
[5] Yamaguchi, K., Yamaguchi, T. and Ikeda, S.: The Mechanical Behavior of Composite Prestressed
concrete Girders with Corrugated Steel Webs, Concrete Research and Technology, vol.8, No.1,
Japan Concrete Institute, 1997.1, pp.27-40
[6] Mizuguchi, K., Ashiduka, K., Furuta, K., Oura, T., Taki, K. and Kato, T.: Design and Construction of
the Hondani Bridge -prestressed concrete Bridge using Corrugated Steel Webs-, Bridge and
Foundation Engineering, Vol.32, No.9, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 1998.9, pp.2-10
[7] Mizuguchi, K., Ashiduka, K., Yoda, T., Sato, K., Sakurada, M. and Hidaka, S.: Loading Tests of the
Hondani Bridge, Bridge and Foundation Engineering, Vol.32, No.10, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan),
1998.10, pp.25-34
[8] Society for Research on Composite Structures with Corrugated Steel Web (Japan): Proposed
Planning Manual for Composite Prestressed concrete Bridges with Corrugated Steel Webs,
1998.12
[9] Easley, J. T.: Buckling Formulas for Corrugated Metal Shear Diaphragms, Journal of the Structural
Division Proc. of ASCE, Vol.101, No.ST7, 1975.7, pp.1403-1417
[10] Kadotani, T., Aoki, K., Tomimoto, M. and Kano, M.: Study of Shear Buckling for Corrugated Steel
Web, Journal of Prestressed concrete, Vol.43, No.1, Japan Prestressed Concrete Engineering
Association, 2001.1, pp.96-101
[11] Kadotani, T., Aoki, K., Ashizuka, K., Mori, T., Tomimoto M. and Kano, M.: Shear Buckling Behavior
of Prestressed concrete Girders with Corrugated Steel Webs, fib Proceedings of the 1st fib
Congress, 2002.10
[12] Ichinomiya, T., Ikeda, H., Ashiduka, K. and Yamanobe, S.: A Study on Shear Buckling of
Corrugated Steel Webs by Geometrical and Material Non-Liner Analysis, Proceedings of the 11th
Symposium on Developments in Prestressed concrete, Japan Prestressed Concrete Engineering
Association, 2001.11, pp.451-454
[13] Uehira, K., Tategami, H., Honda, H. and Sonoda, K.: Study on The Shearing and Torsional
Rigidities of prestressed concrete Box Girder with Corrugated Steel Web, Journal of Prestressed
concrete, Vol.40, No.3, Japan Prestressed Concrete Engineering Association, 1998.6, pp.16-25
[14] Uehira, K., Shintani, E., Ebina, T. and Sonoda, K.: To the Relationship between of the Torsional
Behavior and the Cross-Girder Interval for the prestressed concrete Box Girder with Corrugated
Steel Plates at Web, Journal of Prestressed concrete, Vol.41, No.1, Japan Prestressed Concrete
Engineering Association, 1999.1, pp.38-42
[15] Kobayashi, H. and Mori, Y.: Prestressed concrete Box Girder Bridge with Corrugated Steel Webs
-Nakano Viaduct in Hanshin Expressway Kita-Kobe Line-, Concrete Journal, Vol.38, No.12, Japan
Concrete Institute, 2000.12, pp.44-50
[16] Higashida, N., Ichijyo, H., Kaneko, H., Yoshida, M. and Tategami H.: Design and Construction of
YOURAPGAWA Bridge(Corrugated Steel Web Bridge Using Twin-Perfobond Strip), Proceedings
of The 5th Symposium on Research and Application of Composite Constructions, Japan Society of
Civil Engineers, 2003.11, pp.77-82
[17] Sakurada, M., Higashida, N., Kamamoto, T. and Shimizu T.: Experimental Study of Twin-PBL
Connection, Proceedings of the 13th Symposium on Developments in Prestressed concrete,
Japan Prestressed Concrete Engineering Association, 2004.10, pp.297-302
[18] Hosaka, T., Kato, J. and Kusunoki, T.: Development of High Performance Weathering Steel and its
Application to a Steel Bridge, Bridge and Foundation Engineering, Vol.36, No.6, Kensetsu-Tosho
(Japan), 2002.6, pp.31-38
[19] Japan Society of Steel Construction: Methods for Life Elongation of Bridges, 2002
[20] Research Association of Metal Spraying System for Structures (Japan): Proposed Manual for
Design and Construction of Metal Splaying to Steel Bridges, 2001.4
[21] Sagawa, N., Sakai, N., Okazawa, Y., Mashiko, H., Kasuga, A. and Tazoe, K.: Design and
Construction of Himi Bridge -Extradosed Bridge with Corrugated Steel webs-, Bridge and
Foundation Engineering, Vol.37, No.6, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2003.6, 2-10
[22] Miyauchi, H., Yasukawa, Y., Nakazono, A., Mori, T. and Cho, K.: Planning and Design of Ritto
Bridge -Extradosed Bridge with Corrugated Steel Webs-, Bridge and Foundation Engineering,
Vol.37, No.12, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2003.12, pp.9-18
[23] Nakazono, A., Fukuhara, H., Nishida, T. and Suda, T.: Construction of Ritto Bridge on the New
Meishin Expressway, Bridge and Foundation Engineering, Vol.38, No.10, Kensetsu-Tosho
(Japan), 2004.10, pp.5-11
[24] Suzuki, Y., Ikeda, H., Mizuguchi, K.: Planning of Yahagigawa Bridge on New Tomei Expressway
-Composite Cable Stayed Bridge with Corrugated Steel Webs, Bridge and Foundation
Engineering, Vol.39, No.2, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2005.2, pp.5-8
[25] Ishiguro, W., Murata, Y. and Sugo, T.: Design and Construction of Matsunoki 7th Bridge (Ginzan
-Miyuki Bridge), Journal of Prestressed concrete, Vol.38, No.5, Japan Prestressed Concrete
Engineering Association, 1996.9, pp.5-14
[26] Sugimoto, I., Murata, K., Hiraoka, C., Toyohara, M., Mizoe, Y. and Machida, F.: An Experimental
Study on Fatigue Durability of Joint Part under Out-of-Plane Cyclic Bending in Corrugated Steel
Web prestressed concrete Box Railway Bridge, Journal of Structural Engineering, Vol.48A, Japan
Society of Civil Engineers, 2002.3, pp.1339-1349
[27] Nishida, H., Hiraoka, C., Kanamori, M. and Toyohara, M.: An Experimental Study on Fatigue
Durability of Joint Part under Cyclic Bending in Corrugated Steel Web prestressed concrete Box
Girder Railway Bridge, Concrete Research and Technology, Vol.13, No.3, Japan Concrete
Institute, 2002.9, pp.61-70
[28] Hiraoka, C., Asakura, Y., Sugawara, A. and Kameda, S.: Design and Construction of Kurobegawa
Bridge on Hokuriku Shinkansen -The First Railway bridge with Corrugated Steel Webs, Bridge and
Foundation Engineering, Vol.37, No.7, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2003.7, pp.11-20
[29] Sumi, M., Terada, N., Sekine, N., Yamauchi, A. and Sekiguchi, T.: Structural Outline of Yahagigawa
Bridge, Bridge and Foundation Engineering, Vol.39, No.2, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2005.2,
pp.9-12
[30] Kamihigashi, Y., Kutsuna, Y., Tarumi, Y., Yamamoto, T. and Okuyama, G.: Design of Superstructure
of Yahagigawa Bridge, Bridge and Foundation Engineering, Vol.39, No.2, Kensetsu-Tosho
(Japan), 2005.2, pp.17-25
[31] Kamihigashi, Y., Miyamoto, K., Yamamoto, T., Hirose, T., Nakamura, Y., Kasahara, H., Naganuma,
K. and Otani, M.: Construction of Superstructure of Yahagigawa Bridge, Bridge and Foundation
Engineering, Vol.39, No.2, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2005.2, pp.35-45
[32] Murao, M., Miyauchi, H., Mouri, T., Tanaka, K., Sagawa, N. and Nishimura, I.: Design and
Construction of Shigaraki 7th Bridge and Tsukumigawa Bridge, Bridge and Foundation
Engineering, Vol.38, No.2, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2004.2, pp.5-13
[33] Aoki, K., Wada, N., Matsumoto, K. and Nakamura A.: Design and Construction of Katsurashima
Viaduct, Bridge and Foundation, Vol.39, No.1, Kensetsu-Tosho (Japan), 2005.1, pp.13-20
[34] Combault, J. and Oura, T. (Translation): The Maupre Viaduct near Charolles, France, Journal of
Prestressed concrete, Vol.34, No.1, Prestressed Concrete Engineering Association,
1992.1,pp.63-71
[35] Express Highway Research Foundation of Japan: Report on the 1997 EHRF Study Mission of
Composite Bridges, 1997
[36] Roesler, H. and Denzer, G.: The Prestressed concrete Bridge Altwipfergrund with Corrugated Steel
Webs, fib Proceedings of the 1st fib Congress, 2002.10
[37] Lee, S., Jo, C. and Park, D.: The first Corrugated Steel-web Prestressed concrete Bridge in Korea
-Design Outline of The Ilsun Bridge-, Journal of Prestressed concrete, Vol.45, No.3, Japan
Prestressed Concrete Engineering Association, 2003.5, pp.65-69