Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
,OURNl,
OF
CARDIO-THORACIC
SURGERY
Development
of a non-pulsatile
Yukihiko
permanent
Baylor College of Medicine, Department of Surgery, One Baylor Plaza, Houston TX 77030, USA
Abstract
For many years, a common belief was that non-pulsatile
perfusion produced physiological
and circulatory abnormalities.
Since
1977 our group has reported, if a 20% higher blood flow was used more than required for a pulsatile blood pump, there would
be no circulatory or physiological
abnormalities.
These experimental
findings confirmed that there was no difference in clinical
outcome when using a pulsatile or non-pulsatile
blood pump. Furthermore,
the non-pulsatile
rotary blood pump has demonstrated efficient and reliable performance
in various clinical situations. The non-pulsatile
blood pump is a simple and reliable
design, that can be easily manufactured,
and has the following desirable features. There is no need to incorporate
heart valves,
a large orifice inflow conduit, or a compliance volume-shifting
chamber. Since an electrical motor operates continuously,
the
on-and-off
motion required for a pulsatile pump is not necessary; therefore, it becomes a more efficient and durable system.
Further, the control algorism is simpler and more reliable than a pulsatile pump. Considering
these factors, the non-pulsatile
blood pump can be selected for a permanently
implantable assist device. To develop an implantable non-pulsatile
cardiac device,
it is necessary to incorporate
seven features in the system such as: small size, atraumatic
features, anti-thrombogenic
features,
anti-infection
features, durable and simple design, and low energy requirement with easy controllability.
0 1997 Elsevier Science
B.V.
1. Justification
of non-pulsatile
perfusion
reserved.
s33
V61.
Treadmill exercise tests demonstrated that both nonand pulsatile groups showed moderate to good tolerance at 1.5 mph tests without hemodynamic
or
metabolic deterioration [17- 191. The increased 0, demand during exercise was met by augmented 0, extraction for non-pulsatile
bi-ventricular
bypass while
increased cardiac output and 0, extraction for pulsatile
TAH recipients. The non-pulsatile group has a higher
norepinephrine response to exercise than the pulsatile
TAH group. Although patients can tolerate moderate
exercise with the constant flow of non-pulsatile circulation, a regulation system which can increase pump flow
during exercise is necessary for a higher quality of life.
Thus, our experiences demonstrate that if a 20%
higher blood flow was used more than that required for
a pulsatile blood pump, there would be no circulatory
or physiological abnormalities.
These experimental
findings confirm that there is no difference in the clinical outcome if we use a pulsatile or a non-pulsatile
blood pump as a permanent blood pump. Based on this
information, a non-pulsatile blood pump can be chosen
as a long-term implantable blood pump.
blood pump
to develop
Small size
Atraumatic
features
Anti-thrombogenic
features
Anti-infection
features
Durable and simpler design
Lower energy requirement
Easy controllability
a totally
implantable
non-pulsatile
pump
s34
Fig. 1. (Comparative picture of an electro-mechanical pulsatile LVAD (left ventricular assist device) (right) and DeBakey/NAS A axial flow L\ AD
(left). The volume of this axial flow LVAD is only 15 ml.
In order to achieve a permanently implantable nonpulsatile rotary blood pump, it is necessary to incorporate at least seven features in the system as listed below
and in Table 1. In addition, the pump should be
noiseless, operating independently, and stable. It is also
necessary to eliminate electric and electromagnetic influence inside or outside of the system.
Journal of Cardio-thoracic
Surgery
s35
Table 2
Size requirement of ventricular assist device
Height (cm)
Width (cm)
Volume (cc)
Weight (g)
DeBakey/NASA
axial flow LVAD
10.1
98.9
310
570
40.0
86.0
130
125
7.0
2.7
15
54
Table 3
Blood trauma induced by a blood pump
N.I.H.
(g/l00 1)
Abbreviations:
Pulsatile
LVAD
Non-pulsatile
CIE3 centrifugal pump
DeBakey/NASA
0.04 &
< 0.002
<0.003
S36
- >c
Ea
Lf=e
ik
~-- 273
Tj+
I
298 >
pump.
This pump
pump
which
is typically
in the range of 10 W or higher.
As mentioned, the endurance life of the electronic
components is heavily dependent upon their exposure
to higher temperatures. Since this lower-power-requiring pump generates less wasted heat, we anticipate less
electrical and mechanical failure from the system.
Therefore, the life of the system is expected to be
longer. In addition, we expect less heat dissipation
problems and less thermal damage to the tissue. Thus,
the rotary blood pump is expected to have a longer life
than that of the pulsatile pump.
is a seal-less
centrifugal
pump
by replacing
s37
4. Conclusion
Ten years ago, to develop a permanent rotary blood
pump was considered to be an impossible dream. But
now, almost all the technical problems associated in
developing a permanent non-pulsatile rotary blood
pump have been solved. Although achieving this goal is
not an easy task, advance of the technology has made
this idea a reality.
References
[I] Pae WE, Miller CA, Matthews Y, Pierce WS. Ventricular
assist
devices for postcardiotomy
cardiogenic
shock: a combined registry experience. J Thorac Cardiovasc
Surg 1992;104:541-543.
[2] Noon GP. Bio-Medicus ventricular assistance. Ann Thorac Surg
1991;52:180-181.
[3] Curtis JJ, Walls JT, Schmaltz R, Boley TM, Nawarawong
W,
Landreneau
RJ. Experience with the Sarns centrifugal
pump in
postcardiotomy
ventricular
failure. J Thorac Cardiovasc
Surg
1992;104:554-560.
[4] Magovern
GJ, Jr. The biopump and postoperative
circulatory
support. Ann Thorac Surg 1993;55:245-249.
S38
[51 Griffith LD, Shoor PM, Dilley RB, Bernstein EF. Beneficial
effects of nonpulsatile left ventricular bypass on myocardial
energy utilization: interaction of oxygen demand and supply.
Trans Am Sot Artif Intern Organs 1978;24:298-304.
Fl Kanamori Y, Shimono T, Tanaka K, Yada I, Kusagawa M.
Effect of left heart assist device for the heart: a comparative
study of asynchronous pulsatile, synchronous pulsatile, and nonpulsatile left heart bypass. Artif Organs 1991;14(suppl):492-496.
[71 Golding LR, Harasaki H, Loop FD, Sukalac R, Reich S, Nose
Y. Use of a centrifugal pump for temporary left ventricular assist
system. Trans Am Sot Artif Intern Organs 1978;24:93-97.
PI Johnston GG, Hammill FS, Johansen KH, Marzec U, Gerard
D, Dilley RB, Bernstein EF. Prolonged pulsatile and nonpulsatile LV bypass with a centrifugal pump. Trans Am Sot Artif
Intern Organs 1976;22:323-331.
[91 Nose Y. My life with the National Institute of Health Artificial
Heart Program. Artif Organs 1990;14:174- 190.
PO1 Golding LR, Jacobs G, Murakami T, Takatani S, Valdes F,
Harasaki H, Nose Y. Chronic nonpulsatile blood flow in an
alive, awake animal 34day survival. Trans Am Sot Artif Intern
Organs 1980;26:251-255.
VII Golding LR, Murakami G, Harasaki H, Takatani S, Jacobs G,
Yada I, Tomita K, Yozu R, Valdes F, Fujimoto LK, Koike S,
Nose Y. Chronic nonpulsatile blood flow. Trans Am Sot Artif
Intern Organs 1982;28:81-85.
WI Yada I, Golding LR, Harasaki H, Jacobs G, Koike S, Yozu R,
Sato N, Fujimoto LK, Snow J, Olsen E, Murabayashi S,
Venkatesen VS, Kiraly R, Nose Y. Physiopathological studies of
nonpulsatile blood flow in chronic models. Tram Am Sot Artif
Intern Organs 1983;24:520-525.
P31 Takatani S, Ozawa K, Golding L, Jacobs G, Murakami T,
Valdes F, Harasaki H, Kiraly R, Nose Y. Comparative evaluation of nonpulsatile and pulsatile cardiac prosthesis. Trans Am
Sot Artif Intern Organs 1980;26:438-443.
1141Valdes F, Takatani S, Jacobs GB, Murakami T, Harasaki H,
Golding LR, Nose Y. Comparison of hemodynamic changes in
a chronic nonpulsatile biventricular bypass (BVB) and total
artificial heart (TAH). Trans Am Sot Artif Intern Organs
1980;26:455-460.
[I51 Nose Y. Nonpulsatile mode of blood flow required for cardiopulmonary bypass and total body perfusion. Artif organs
1993;17:92-102.
[16] Sugita Y, Golding LR, Jacobs G, Harasaki H, Yozu R, Sato N,
Fujimoto LK, Morimoto T, Snow J, Olsen E, Smith W, Murabayashi S, Kambic H, Kiraly R, Nose Y. Comparison of osmotic and body fluid balance in chronic nonpulsatile
biventricular bypass (NPBVB) and total artificial heart (TAH)
experiments. Trans Am Sot Artif Intern Organs 1984;30:148154.
[17] Valdes F, Golding LR, Harasaki H, Takatani S, Jacobs G, Nose
Y. Hemodynamic response to exercise during chronic ventricular
fibrillation and nonpulsatile biventricular bypass (BVB). Trans