Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
classification, Textural
classification. Unified soil classification and IS classification - Plasticity chart and its
importance, Field identification of soils.
CLAY MIERALOGY AND SOIL STUCTURE: Single grained, honeycombed, flocculent
and dispersed structures, Valence bonds Soil-Water system, Electrical diffuse double layer,
adsorbed water, base-exchange capacity, Isomorphus substitution. Common clay minerals in
soil and their structures- Kaolinite, Illite and Montmorillonite.
(8 Hours)
Classification of soils
Introduction:
Soil classification is the arrangement of soils into different groups such that the soils
in a particular group have similar behaviour. As there are a wide variety of soils covering
earth, it is desirable to systematize or classify the soils into broad groups of similar
behaviour.
Soils, in general, may be classified as cohesionless and cohesive or as coarse-grained
and fine-grained. These terms, however, are too general and include a wide range of
engineering properties. Hence, additional means of categorization are necessary to make the
terms more meaningful in engineering practice. These terms are compiled to form soil
classification systems.
It is important to note that soil classification is no substitute for exact analysis based
on engineering properties. For final design of large structures, the engineering properties
should be determined by conducting elaborate tests on undisturbed samples.
ii)
It should be based on the engineering properties, which are most relevant for the
purpose for which the classification has been made.
iii)
It should be simple and should use the terms, which are easily understood.
Any soil classification must provide us with information about the probable
engineering behaviour of a soil. Most of the classification systems developed satisfy the
above requirements.
iv)
2. Textural Classification:
The visual appearance of a soil is called its texture. The texture depends upon the
particle size, shape of particles and gradation of particles and gradation of particles. The
textural classification incorporates only the particle size. Here, the term texture is used to
express the percentage of the three constituents of soils, namely, sand, silt and clay.
According to the textural classification system, the percentages of sand (size 0.05 to
2.0 mm), silt (size 0.005 to 0.05 mm) and clay (size less tan 0.005 mm) are plotted along
the three sides of an equilateral triangle. The equilateral triangle is divided into 10 zones,
each zone gives a type of soil. The soil can be classified by determining the zone in
which it lies. A key is given that indicates the directions in which the lines are to be
drawn to locate the point.
For e.g. If a soil contains 30 % sand, 20 % silt and 50 % clay, it is shown by point P in
the figure. The point falls in the zone labeled clay. Therefore, the soil is classified as clay.
The textural classification system is useful for classifying soils consisting of different
constituents. The system assumes that the soil does not contain particles larger than 2-mm
size. However, if the soil contains a certain percentage of soil particles larger than 2 mm,
a correction is required in which the sum of the percentages of sand, silt and clay is
increased to 100 %. For e.g. if a soil contains 20 % particles of size larger than 2-mm
size, the actual sum of the percentages of sand, silt and clay particles is 80 %. Let these
be respectively 12, 24, and 44 %. The corrected percentages would be obtained by
multiplying with a factor of 100/80. Therefore, the corrected percentages are 15, 30 and
55 %. The textural classification of the soil would be done based on these corrected
percentages.
Q 1. How are soils classified based on the Indian Standards Classification. List the salient
features of this classification.
Q 2. What is plasticity chart? Explain how it is useful for classification of fine-grained soils
5) Indian Standard Soil Classification System:
Indian Standard Soil Classification system is in many respects similar to the Unified
system. However, there is one basic difference in the classification of fine-grained soils.
The fine-grained soils in this system are sub-dived into three categories of low, medium
and high compressibility instead of two categories of low and high compressibility in
Unified soil classification system.
Soils are divided into three broad divisions:
1) Coarse-grained soils, when 50 % or more of the total material by weight retained on
75 m IS sieve.
2) Fine-grained soils, when more than 50 % of the total material passes 75 m IS sieve.
3) If the soil is highly organic and contains a large percentage of organic matter and
particles of decomposed vegetation, it is kept in a separate category marked as peat
(Pt)
In all, there are 18 groups of soils
Coarse-grained soils 8 groups
Fine-grained soils
9 groups
Peat
- 1 group
Coarse-Grained Soils:
The classification of coarse-grained soils is done on the basis of their grain and gradation
characteristics as illustrated in Table, when the fines (75 m) present in them are less
than 5 % by weight. Coarse-grained soils are sub-dived into gravel and sand. The soil is
termed gravel (G) when more than 50 % of coarse fraction (>75 m) is retained on 4.75
mm IS sieve, and termed sand (S) if more than 50 % of coarse fraction is smaller than
4.75 mm IS sieve. These are further sub-divided as given in Table into 8 groups.
Coarse-grained soils which contain more than 12 % fines (< 75 m) are classified as
GM or SM if fines are silty in character (meaning, the limits plot below the A-line on the
plasticity chart). On the other hand they are classified as GC or SC if the fines are clayey
in character (meaning the limits plot above the A-line on the plasticity chart).
Fine-grained Soils:
The fine-grained soils are classified on the basis of their plasticity characteristics using
the I.S Plasticity chart shown in Fig.
The fine-grained soils are further divided into three sub-divisions depending upon the
values of the liquid limit:
a) Silts and clays of low compressibility These soils have a liquid limit less than 35 %
(represented by a symbol L)
b) Silts and clays of medium compressibility These soils have a liquid limit > 35 %
but < 50 % ( represented by a symbol I)
c) Silts and clays of high compressibility These soils have a liquid limit > 35 %
(represented by a symbol H)
Fine-grained soils are further sub-divided, as given in table in 9 groups.
Boundary Classifications:
Sometimes, it is not possible to classify to classify a soil into any one of 18 groups
discussed above. A soil may possess characteristics of two groups, either in particle
distribution or in plasticity. For such cases, boundary classifications occur and dual
symbols are used.
a) Boundary classification for coarse-grained soils:
Coarse-grained soils having 5 % to 12 % fines are borderline cases and given a dual
symbol. While giving dual symbols, first assume a coarse soil and then a finer soil i.e.,
the first part of the symbol is indicative of the gradation of coarse fraction, while the
second part indicates the nature of fines.
For example, a soil with the dual symbol SW-SC is a well-graded sand with clayey
fines that plot above A-line.
(i)
Boundary classifications within gravel or sand groups can occur. The following
classification are common
GW-GP, GM-GC, GW-GM, GW-GC, GP-GM,
SW-SP, SM-SC, SW-SM, SW-SC, SP-SM.
(ii)
Boundary classifications can occur between the gravel and sand groups such as
GW-SW, GP-SP, GM-SM, and GC-SC
Note: The rule for correct classification is to favour the non-plastic classification.
For eg. A gravel with 10 % fines, Cu = 20 and Cc = 2 and IP= 6 will be classified as GW
GM, and not GW GC.
b) Boundary classification for fine-grained soils:
Fine-grained soils also can have dual symbols.
(i)
If the limits plot in the hatched zone on the plasticity chart, i.e., IP between 4 and
7, the soil has a group symbol CL ML.
(ii)
If the position of the soil on the plasticity chart falls close to the A-line, dual
symbol is used, such as CI MI , CH MH
(iii)
If the liquid limit is very close to 35 % or 50 %, dual symbols are used, such as
ML MI, MI MH, CL CI, CI CH, OL OI, OI OH.
Step-by-step procedure:
A step-by-step procedure for classifying the soils as per IS: 1498 1970 is illustrated
below:
1. Determine whether the given soil is of organic origin or coarse-grained or finegrained. An organic soil is identified by its colour (brownish black or dark) and
characteristic odour. If 50 % or more of the soil by weight is retained on the 75 m
sieve, it is coarse-grained, if not, it is fine-grained.
2. If the soil is coarse-grained:
(a) Obtain the GSD curve from a sieve-analysis. If 50 % or more of the coarse
fraction (>75 m) is retained on the 4.75 mm sieve, classify the soil as gravel (G);
if not, classify it as sand (S)
(b) If the soil fraction passing through the 75 m sieve is less than 5 %, determine the
gradation of the soil by calculating Cu and Cc from the GSD curve. If well graded
(according to the criteria laid down), classify the soil as GW or SW; if poorly
graded, classify as GP or SP.
(c) If more than 12 % passes through the 75 m sieve, perform the liquid limit and
plastic limit tests on the soil fraction passing though the 0.425-mm sieve. Use the
I.S. plasticity chart to determine the classification (GM, SM, GC, SC, GM GC
or SM SC)
(d) If between 5 % and 12 % passes through the 75 m sieve, the soil is assigned a
dual symbol appropriate to its gradation and plasticity characteristics. (GW GW,
GW GC, GP GC, GP GW, GM, SW - SM, SW - SC, SP SC, SP - SM)
3. If the soil is fine-grained (inorganic):
(a) Determine wL and wP on the minus 0.425 mm sieve fraction and determine the
plasticity index.
(b) If the limits plot below the A line, classify as silt (M). Further, if wL is less than
35, classify as ML; if wL is between 35 50 %, classify as MI; if wL is greater
than 50, classify as MH.
(c) If the limits plot above the A line, classify as clay . Assign the group symbol
CL or CI or CH, depending on the value of liquid limit, as in (b).
(d) If the limits plot in the hatched zone, classify as CL ML. If the limits plot close
to the A line or close to wL= 35 % or wL= 50 % lines, assign dual symbols as
outlined earlier.
4. If the soil is of organic origin, the plasticity chart is used after determining wL and wP
and the soil classified as OL, OI or OH.
5. If the soil has about 50 % each of fines and coarse grained fractions,
(a) Determine whether the coarse grained fraction is gravel (G) or sand (S)
(b) Determine wL and wP on the minus 0.425 mm fraction
(c) Depending on whether the limits plot above the A line or below the A line,
classify as C or M
(d) Based on wL, classify as L, I or H
(e) Assign the dual symbol from the information obtained in steps (a), (b), (c), and
(d) as for example, GM ML, GM MI, etc.,
GRAVEL
SAND
Dilatancy test:
It consists of placing a pat of moist soil in the palm of the hand, and then shaking the
hand. If a shiny, moist surface appears on the soil after shaking it in the open hand
and then becomes dull and dry when the pat is squeezed by closing the hand, a nonplastic soil (e.g. silt) is indicated.
Note: squeezing the pat causes shearing deformations in the soil, which in turn cause
a non-plastic soil to expand from low volume obtained by shaking. The water flows
into the soil to make up for the increased volume of pores and, thereby, leaves the
surface with a dry appearance.
If it is clay, the water cannot move easily and hence, it continues to look dark. If it is
a mixture of silt and clay, the relative speed with which the shine appears may give a
rough indication of the amount of silt present. This test is also known as shaking test
or water mobility test.
(ii)
Strength test:
A small lump of the soil is dried slowly. Then the dry lump is tested for its dry
strength by trying to powder the lump between the fingers. If it can be broken easily
or powdered with the fingers, the material is silt. If it is clay, it will require effort to
break. Also, if it is silt one can dust off loose material from the surface of the lump.
When moist soil is pressed between fingers, clay gives a soapy touch; it also sticks to
the fingers, dries slowly, and cannot be dusted off easily.
(iii)
Plasticity test:
A measure of the plasticity of a soil can be obtained by noting how much working of
the soil between the fingers is required to dry it from a wet state (near the liquid limit)
to the crumbling state (near the plastic limit). The greater the plasticity the longer the
kneading time required. The reasons being: a) the more plastic the soil, the larger the
difference in water contents between the wet and crumbling stages;
b) the more plastic the soil, more the effort required to expel a given quantity of
water. This because, silts possess little plasticity, they usually dry after a few minutes
of working with the fingers.
(iv)
Rolling test:
A thread is attempted to be made out of a moist soil sample with a diameter of about
3-mm. If the material is silt, it is not possible to make such a thread without
disintegration and crumbling. If it is clay, such a thread can be made even to a length
of about 30-cm and supported by its own weight when held at the ends. This is also
called the Toughness test.
(v)
Dispersion test:
A spoonful of soil is poured in a jar of water. If it is silt, the particles will settle in
about 15 minutes to one hour. If it is clay, it will form a suspension, which will
remain as such for hours, and even for days, provided flocculation does not take
place.
Dispersion Test
Covalent Bond:
This type of bond develops between two atoms by sharing of electrons in their outer shell.
Two atoms, each lacking one electron, may combine by sharing of pair of electrons.
E.g.: Oxygen, O2.
In other words, a covalent bond occurs when there is sharing of electrons by atoms of like
valence. The covalent bond occurs generally in elements of negative valences or in nonelectrolytes, such as carbon (A non electrolytes does not form ions).
Primary valence bonds are very strong. These bonds do not break in normal soil engineering
applications. Therefore, primary valance bonds are not much relevance in soil engineering.
Hydrogen Bond:
The hydrogen bond has only one electron. The number of electrons required to fill the first
shell is 2. The atom can be considered either as a cation (with one excess electron) or an
anion( with one electron deficiency). The bond between the hydrogen cation(H+) and anions
of two atoms of another element is called Hydrogen Bond.
E.g.: H2O
Hydrogen bond is considerably weaker than primary valence bond. However, it is fairly
strong and cannot be broken during normal soil engineering problems.
1. Tetrahedral Unit:
A tetrahedral unit consists of a silicon atom (Si
4+
atoms( O 2-), forming a shape of a tetrahedron. Oxygen atoms are at the tips of the
tetrahedron, whereas the silicon atom is at the centre. There is a net negative charge
of 4. An individual tetrahedron unit cannot exist in nature.
Tetrahedral Unit
A number of tetrahedron unit combine to form a sheet. Each oxygen at the base is shared by
two tetrahedra. A silica sheet is formed by tetrahedral units. Due to this sharing of oxygen
atom at the base, the negative charge per tetrahedra at the base is three and two at the tip and
4 positive charges due to silica atom at the centre, leaving a net negative charge of one per
tetrahedron.
Figure below gives a simple representation of silica sheet, commonly used in clay minerals.
2. Octahedral Unit:
It consists of six hydroxyles (OH-) forming a configuration of an octahedron and
having one aluminium atom at the centre. As the aluminum (Al +3) has three positive
charges, an octahedral unit has 3 negative charges. Because of net negative charges,
an octahedral unit cannot exist in isolation.
Octahedral Unit
Several octahedral units combine to form a gibbsite sheet. Figure shows a gibbsite sheet
formed by four octahedral units. The sheet is electrically neutral.
CLAY MINERALS:
1. Kaolinite Mineral:
Kaolinite is the most common mineral of the kaolinite group of minerals. Its basic
structural unit consists of alumina sheet (G) combined with a silica sheet (S) . Tips of
the silica sheet and one base of the alumina sheet form a common interface. The total
thickness of the structural unit is about 7 Angstron (), ehere one = 10 -10 m or 10 -7
mm. The kaolinite minral is formed by stacking, one over the other, several such
basic structural units.
Fig shows two such units.
The Structural units join together by hydrogen bond, which develops between the
oxygen of silica sheet and the hydroxyles of alumina sheet. As the bond is fairly
strong, the mineral is stable. Moreover, water cannot easily enter between the
structural units. So, expansion or swelling will not take place.
It is a clay mineral which has the same basic structure as kaolinite, but in which the
successive structural units are more randomly packed and are separated by a single
molecular layer if water. The properties of halloysite depend upon this water layer. If
the water layer is removed by drying , the properties of the mineral drastically
change.
Halloysite particles are tubular in shape, in contrast to the platy shape of kaolinite
particles. The soils containing halloysite have a very low mass density.
montmorillonite exhibits high shrinkage and high swelling characteristics. The water
in the intervening space can be removed by heating to 2000 - 3000C.
Montmorillonite minerals have lateral dimensions of 0.1 to 0.5 and the thickness of
0.001 to 0.005. The specific surface is about 800m2/g.
The gibbsite sheet in a montmorillonite mineral may contain iron or magnesium
instead of aluminium. Some of the silicon atoms in the silica sheet may also have
isomorphous substitution. This results in giving the mineral a residual negative
charge. It attracts water to form an adsorbed layer, which gives plasticity
characteristics to the soil.
4. Illite Mineral:
Illite is the main mineral of the illite group. The basic structural unit is similar to that
of the mineral montmorillonite. However, the mineral has properties different from
montmorillonite due to following reasons.
a. There is always a substantial amount of isomorphous substitution of silicon by
aluminium in silica sheet. Consequently, the mineral has a larger negative charge
than that in montmorillonite.
b. The link between different structural units is through non-exchangeable potassium
(K+) and not through water. This bonds the units more firmly than in
montmorillonite.
c. The lattice of illite is stronger than that of montmorillonite and is therefore less
susceptible to change.
d. Illite swells less than montmorillonite. However, selling is more than in kaolinite.
e. The space between different structural units is much smaller than in
montmorillonite, as the potassium ion just fit between the silica sheet surfaces.
Cation Adsorption
The Base Exchange Capacity of clay depends upon the pH value of the water in the
environment. If the water is acidic (pH < 7), the BEC is reduced. Some cations are more
strongly adsorbed than others. The adsorbed cations commonly found in soils, arranged in a
series in terms of their affinity for attraction are as follows:
Al3+ > Ca2+ > Mg+2 >NH4+>K+ > H+>Na+> Li+
For e.g.,: Al
+3
3+
ions can
replace Ca2+ ions. Likewise Ca2+ ions can replace Na+ ions.
Adsorbed Water:
The water held by electro-chemical forces existing on the soil surface is known as adsorbed
water. As the adsorbed water is under the influence of electrical forces, its properties are
different from normal water. It is much more viscous, and its surface tension is also greater.
It is heavier than normal water. The boiling point is higher, but the freezing point is lower
than that of the normal water.
The thickness of adsorbed water layer is usually about 10 to 15. This water imparts
plasticity characteristics to soils.
Soil Structure:
The geometrical arrangement of soil particles with respect to one another in a soil mass is
known as soil structure.
Engineering properties and the behavior of both coarse grained and fine grained soils depend
upon the soil structure.
The following types of structures are usually found.
a. Single grained structure:
Cohesionless soils, such as gravel and sand, are composed of bulky grains in which
the gravitational forces are more predominant than surface forces. When deposition of
these soils occurs, the particles settle under gravitational forces and take an
equilibrium position on deposition. Each particle is in contact with those surrounding
it. The soil structure so formed is known as single grained structure.
formed is known as honey comb structure. This structure usually develops when the
particle size is between 0.0002mm and 0.02mm.
Honey-comb structure occurs in soils having small granular particles which
have cohesion because of their fineness. The particles are held in position by mutual
attraction due to cohesion. The particles, however, do not possess plasticity
characteristics associated with clayey soils.
c. Flocculated Structure:
Flocculated structure occurs in clays. The clay particles have large surface area and,
therefore, the electrical forces are important in such soils. The clay particles have a
negative charge on the surface and a positive charge on the edges. Inter particle
contact develops between the positively charged edges and the negatively charged
faces. This results in a flocculated structure.
Flocculent structure is formed when there is a net attractive force between
particles.
When clay particles settle in water, deposits formed have a flocculated structure. The
degree if flocculation of a clay deposit depends upon the type and concentration of
clay particles , and the presence of salts in water. Clays settling out in a salt water
solution have a more flocculent structure than clays settling out in a fresh water
solution. Salt water acts as an electrolyte and reduces the repulsive forces between the
particles.
In general, the soils in a flocculated structure have a low compressibility, a high
permeability and high shear strength.
converts the edge to face orientation to face to face orientation. The dispersed
structure is formed in nature when there is a net repulsive force between particles.
The soils in dispersed structure generally have a low shear strength, high
compressibility and low permeability.