Sei sulla pagina 1di 8

BIOLOGY OF REPRODUCTION 68, 516–523 (2003)

Published online before print 17 October 2002.


DOI 10.1095/biolreprod.102.009662

Role of Arachidonic Acid and Protein Kinase C During Maturation-Inducing


Hormone-Dependent Meiotic Resumption and Ovulation in Ovarian Follicles
of Atlantic Croaker1

Reynaldo Patiño,2,3,4 Goro Yoshizaki,5 Digbo Bolamba,4 and Peter Thomas6


U.S. Geological Survey,3 Texas Cooperative Fish & Wildlife Research Unit,4 Texas Tech University,
Lubbock, Texas 79409-2120
Department of Aquatic Biosciences,5 Tokyo University of Fisheries, Minato-ku, Tokyo 108-8477, Japan
University of Texas Marine Science Institute,6 Port Aransas, Texas 78373-1267

ABSTRACT respectively, relative to PKC, and 2) PKC is downstream of ge-


nomic activation.
The roles of arachidonic acid (AA) and protein kinase C (PKC)
during in vitro maturation-inducing hormone (MIH)-dependent follicle, meiosis, ovary, ovulation
meiotic resumption (maturation) and ovulation were studied in
ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus).
The requirement for cyclooxygenase (COX) metabolites of AA INTRODUCTION
was examined using a nonspecific COX inhibitor, indomethacin The role of arachidonic acid (AA) during the meiotic
(IM), as well as two COX products, prostaglandin (PG) F2a and resumption (maturation) of oocytes is not fully understood.
PGE 2, whereas the role of lipoxygenase (LOX) was investigated Stimulation of maturation by AA or its metabolites has
using a specific LOX inhibitor, nordihydroguaiaretic acid been reported in some starfishes [1], European sea bass [2],
(NDGA). The involvement of PKC was examined using phorbol
12-myristate 13-acetate (PMA), a PKC activator, as well as
mouse [3–5], and sheep [6]. Conversely, inhibition of mei-
GF109203X (GF), a specific inhibitor of PKC and 1-(5-isoquin-
otic resumption by cyclooxygenase (COX) products (pros-
olinesulfonyl)-2-methylpiperazine (H7), nonspecific inhibitor of taglandins [PGs]) of AA metabolism was observed in
protein kinases. Genomic mechanisms were examined with the mouse [7] and Xenopus laevis [8]. Furthermore, in other
transcription-inhibitor actinomycin D (ActD) and the function- species of starfishes, AA and its metabolites appeared to
ality of heterologous (oocyte-granulosa) gap junctions (GJ) with have no involvement in oocyte maturation [1]. Concerning
a dye transfer assay. The AA (100 mM) and PGF2a (5 mM) did ovulation, it is generally believed that AA is required for
not induce maturation, and NDGA (10 mM) did not affect MIH- this process in most vertebrates, including teleost fishes, but
dependent maturation. However, IM (100 mM) partially inhib- the relative importance of the COX and lipoxygenase
ited MIH-dependent maturation. Conversely, AA and both PGs (LOX) metabolic pathways is the subject of disagreement
induced, and IM and NDGA inhibited, MIH-dependent ovula- among species or studies [9–15].
tion in matured follicles. The PMA (1 mg/ml) did not induce The involvement of protein kinase C (PKC) in oocyte
maturation but caused ovulation in matured follicles, whereas maturation is also unclear. For example, negative [16, 17]
PKC inhibitors (GF, 5 mM; H7, 50 mM) did not affect MIH-de- as well as positive [18–21] regulation of meiotic resump-
pendent maturation but inhibited MIH- and PMA-dependent tion by PKC has been reported in several different species.
ovulation. The PMA-dependent ovulation was inhibited by IM Nevertheless, general agreement is found in the literature
but not by NDGA. In addition, ActD (5 mM) blocked MIH-de- that ovulation in most vertebrates, including teleost fishes,
pendent, but not PMA-dependent, ovulation, and PGF2a restored requires PKC-dependent pathways [10, 22–27].
MIH-dependent ovulation in ActD-blocked follicles. The AA and The process of LH-dependent ovarian follicle maturation
PGs did not induce, and GF did not inhibit, MIH-dependent can be described in two distinct stages for some teleost
heterologous GJ uncoupling. In conclusion, AA and PKC medi-
ate MIH-dependent ovulation but not meiotic resumption or
fishes [28, 29]. The basic mechanisms of each stage have
heterologous GJ uncoupling in croaker follicles, but a permissive
been relatively well studied in Atlantic croaker and other
role of COX products of AA during maturation is possible. A sciaenid species [28]. Namely, the competence of ovarian
novel model of MIH-dependent ovulation is proposed in which follicles to produce steroidal maturation-inducing hormone
1) LOX and COX metabolites of AA are both required for ovu- (MIH) and of the oocyte to resume meiosis in response to
lation, but at upstream and downstream sites of the pathway, MIH is acquired during the first stage [30]. These events
are accompanied by increases in heterologous (granulosa
1
Funding for this work was provided by the U.S. Department of Agricul- cell-oocyte) gap junctions (GJ) [31] and MIH-receptor ac-
ture (NRICGP Animal Reproduction, 00-35203-9135) and Japan Society tivity [32–34]. Activation of protein kinase A (PKA) is suf-
for the Promotion of Science’s Research for the Future program ficient and necessary for LH induction of the first stage of
(97L00902). The U.S. Geological Survey, Texas Tech University, Texas maturation [35]. Production of MIH marks the beginning
Parks and Wildlife Department, and the Wildlife Management Institute of the second stage [30]. The MIH binds to a high-affinity
jointly sponsor the Texas Cooperative Fish and Wildlife Research Unit.
2
Correspondence. FAX: 806 742 2946; e-mail: r.patino@ttu.edu
receptor on the surface of the oocyte [32, 34], and this
hormone-receptor complex associates with a pertussis tox-
in-sensitive inhibitory G protein [36]. Oocyte cAMP and
Received: 22 July 2002.
First decision: 14 August 2002.
PKA activity levels presumably decline and, eventually,
Accepted: 28 August 2002. lead to meiotic resumption in sciaenid species, as has been
Q 2003 by the Society for the Study of Reproduction, Inc. reported for other teleosts [37]. To our knowledge, the role
ISSN: 0006-3363. http://www.biolreprod.org of AA in follicular maturation has not been investigated for
516
MECHANISMS OF MATURATION AND OVULATION IN CROAKER OVARIAN FOLLICLES 517

Atlantic croaker. Furthermore, although pharmacological 14 h to induce maturational competence (first stage of maturation). Folli-
activation of PKC does not induce meiotic maturation in cles were then incubated with MIH (290 nM) or the appropriate experi-
mental reagent for an additional 22–24 h (total incubation time, 36 h).
Atlantic croaker [35, 38], the role of MIH-regulated PKC Although MIH-dependent germinal vesicle breakdown (GVBD) under
is also unknown for this species. It has been reported that these conditions is first observed in some follicles within 4–5 h [38], a
heterologous GJ decline during the periovulatory period in 22- to 24-h incubation with MIH was used, because pilot observations
croaker follicles [31, 38], but the mechanisms of this down- indicated that most ovulation occurs within 36 h of total incubation time.
regulation are uncertain. When inhibitors were used, they were added 45–60 min before the addi-
We are unaware of the mechanisms of ovulation having tion of MIH (or other stimuli) to allow adequate time for their action. At
the end of the incubations, ovulation was determined by counting the
been examined in Atlantic croaker. However, in spotted sea- number of oocytes that were expelled from their follicles. Meiotic re-
trout [39] and in yellow perch [40], MIH-dependent ovu- sumption was then determined by measuring the incidence of GVBD in
lation involves genomic mechanisms regulated by a nuclear follicles cleared with Serra solution (ethanol:formalin:glacial acetic acid,
receptor [39]. In addition, as noted already, AA and its 60:30:10 [v/v]). These observations were made using a binocular stereo-
metabolites as well as PKC are generally believed to be scope.
part of the transduction pathway of hormonally induced The ability of croaker ovarian follicles to ovulate in response to MIH
is LH-dependent and follows the acquisition of maturational competence
ovulation across vertebrate species. Although AA and its (unpublished observations). Thus, the second series of experiments, fo-
metabolites also are effective uncouplers of GJ channels in cusing on ovulation, used ovarian follicles at a more advanced stage of
a variety of tissues [41–43], to our knowledge the role of follicular maturation to ensure adequate ovulatory responses. For this pur-
AA in the periovulatory uncoupling of heterologous GJ has pose, the length of the priming incubation with hCG was increased to 14–
never been examined. 18 h, until follicles showed signs of endogenous MIH-dependent ooplas-
The present study examined the role of AA and PKC mic clarification and hydration (stages D and E according to Yoshizaki et
al. [38]), which correspond to the second (and irreversible) stage of mat-
during MIH-dependent meiotic resumption and ovulation uration [28]. Also, for experiments concerning PMA-induced ovulation,
in Atlantic croaker. The results obtained suggest that AA follicles were first incubated with exogenous MIH (290 nM) for 30 min
and PKC are primary transducers of MIH-dependent ovu- immediately after the hCG incubation and before adding the appropriate
lation but not of maturation. These results also suggest a inhibitors (45–60 min) or PMA. This strategy was used to ensure that the
novel transduction pathway for MIH-induced ovulation. process of maturation was well underway and to prevent the atypical mor-
phology of croaker follicles that results when PMA is added early during
the maturational process (unpublished data). A similar protocol was used
MATERIALS AND METHODS in a study of MIH-dependent ovulation with spotted seatrout [39]. Total
incubation times in this second series of experiments were also 36 h.
Fish and Tissue Collection All treatments within an experiment were conducted with quadruplicate
Atlantic croaker (Micropogonias undulatus) were collected in the fall incubates using ovarian fragments obtained from a single fish. Except
near Port Aransas, Texas, and were maintained in indoor circular tanks when noted, all experiments were repeated with tissues from three or more
under standard conditions as previously described [30]. During sampling fish.
for tissue collection, fish were deeply anesthetized with quinaldine sulfate
and spinally transected. Ovaries were removed into Dulbecco modified
Eagle medium (DME) supplemented with streptomycin sulfate (100 mg/ Dye Transfer Assay for Heterologous Coupling
L) and penicillin (60 mg/L) at pH 7.6. All procedures were reviewed and
approved by the animal care and use committees of Texas Tech University The methods of Yoshizaki et al. [38] were used for this procedure.
and the University of Texas at Austin. Briefly, following their appropriate treatment, ovarian follicles were iso-
lated using watchmaker forceps under a binocular stereoscope. The iso-
lated follicles were held in grooves made on an agarose plate, and ap-
Chemicals proximately 10 nl of a Lucifer Yellow (457.2 daltons) solution (0.1% in
DME) were microinjected into the cytoplasm of the oocytes using a glass
General chemicals, DME, antibiotics, hCG, AA, PGF2a, PGE 2, indo- micropipette (outer diameter, ;10 mm). The position of the micropipette
methacin (IM), nordihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA), phorbol 12-myristate was controlled using a micromanipulator (IM-5B; Narishige, East Mead-
13-acetate (PMA), 1-(5-isoquinolinesulfonyl)-2-methylpiperazine (H7), ow, NY). After an equilibration period of 15 min, the follicular wall con-
bisindolylmaleimide GF109203X (GF), and actinomycin D were obtained taining the thecal cell layer, basement membrane, and granulosa cell layer
from Sigma Chemical (St. Louis, MO). 17a,20b,21-Trihydroxy-4-preg- was manually peeled off the oocyte surface using watchmaker forceps
nen-3-one (MIH of Atlantic croaker) was purchased from Steraloids, Inc. under the binocular stereoscope and carefully rinsed. The isolated follic-
(Newport, RI), and Lucifer Yellow from Molecular Probes (Eugene, OR). ular cell layer was observed under a fluorescence microscope (Nikon
The carrier solution was ethanol for AA, PGs, and MIH and dimethyl E600; Nikon Instruments, Inc., Lewisville, TX) with B-filter set (excitation
sulfoxide for IM, NDGA, PMA, H7, and GF. The final concentrations of filter, 465–495 nm; emission filter, 515–555 nm). The appropriate treat-
carrier solutions in incubation medium never exceeded 0.1% (v/v). All ment was continued during the entire procedure to eliminate the possibility
other chemicals were dissolved in incubation medium. of reversal of effects on coupling. The presence or absence of fluorescence
in the follicle wall was interpreted as indicating the presence or absence
Experimental Design of functional heterologous coupling, respectively.
The roles of AA and PKC in MIH-dependent maturation and ovulation
were investigated with in vitro bioassays using a variety of compounds Data Analysis
that act at different sites along the AA metabolic pathway as well as drugs
that alter PKC activity. Namely, the involvement of COX products of AA Percentage GVBD (100 3 number of GVBD 4 number of full-grown
metabolism was examined using a nonspecific inhibitor of COX, IM, as follicles) and percentage ovulation (100 3 number ovulated eggs 4 num-
well as two COX products, PGF2a and PGE 2, whereas the role of the LOX ber of GVBD) were scored in all replicates. The results of all four repli-
pathway of AA metabolism was investigated using a specific inhibitor of cates per treatment per fish were averaged to obtain an individual fish
LOX, NDGA. The role of PKC was studied using PMA, a PKC activator, value, and sample size for statistical analyses was considered to be the
as well as GF, a specific inhibitor of PKC, and H7, a nonspecific inhibitor number of fish. The variability in percentage ovulation among individual
of protein kinases. The requirement for genomic mechanisms was exam- fish was sometimes high, but this variability was greatly reduced with data
ined with actinomycin D, a transcription inhibitor. transformed relative to stimulated values. The among-fish variability in
Human chorionic gonadotropin was used as a homologue of LH. All GVBD was also generally reduced when using relative values. Thus, ex-
incubations were carried out at 258C under gentle agitation. Two series of cept when noted, relative values were used for one-way ANOVA followed
experiments were conducted. The first series focused primarily on meiotic by, when appropriate, Duncan multiple-range tests. This data transforma-
resumption, although ovulation was also recorded. For these experiments, tion has been previously used in studies of ovarian follicle maturation with
fragments of ovarian lamella containing approximately 50 full-grown ovar- Atlantic croaker [35, 44]. All analyses were conducted using the Statistica
ian follicles were incubated in 1 ml of DME with hCG (5 IU/ml) for 12– for Windows 1998 software package (StatSoft, Inc., Tulsa, OK).
518 PATIÑO ET AL.

FIG. 2. Effects of GF and H7 on MIH-dependent GVBD and ovulation


in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovarian fragments containing ap-
proximately 50 follicles were each incubated in 1 ml of medium with
hCG (5 IU) for 12–14 h. Following a brief rinse period, follicles were
incubated with or without GF (5 mM) or H7 (50 mM) for 45–60 min and
then with or without MIH (290 nM) for the appropriate length of time for
a total of 36 h (exposure to GF or H7 continued until the end of the
incubation). The incidence of ovulation and GVBD were determined. Re-
sults are expressed relative to the values obtained in the presence of MIH.
Bars indicate the mean (6 SEM) of three separate experiments, and those
associated with common letters (large, GVBD; small, ovulation) are not
significantly different (one-way ANOVA and Duncan multiple-range test;
P , 0.05). Average MIH-dependent GVBD and ovulation were 82% and
17%, respectively.

Ovarian Follicles During Early Maturation


When added before the irreversible commitment to mei-
FIG. 1. Effects of IM and NDGA on MIH-dependent GVBD and ovula- otic resumption in most follicles, IM (100 mM), a nonse-
tion in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovarian fragments containing lective inhibitor of COX, partially inhibited MIH-dependent
approximately 50 follicles were each incubated in 1 ml of medium with GVBD, but NDGA (10 mM), a selective inhibitor of LOX,
hCG (5 IU) for 12–14 h (upper panel) or 14–18 h (lower panel). Following
a brief rinse period, follicles were incubated with or without IM (100 mM)
was without effect (Fig. 1, upper panel). However, neither
or NDGA (10 mM) for 45–60 min and then with or without MIH (290 AA (0, 1, 10, and 100 mM; one-way ANOVA, P . 0.05,
nM) for the appropriate length of time for a total of 36 h of incubation n 5 4) nor PGF2a (0, 0.5, and 5 mM; one-way ANOVA, P
(exposure to IM or NDGA continued until the end of the incubation). The . 0.05, n 5 2) was able to induce GVBD (in both instanc-
incidence of ovulation and GVBD were determined. Results are expressed es, negative controls [untreated medium] yielded negligible
relative to the values obtained in the presence of MIH. Bars indicate the or no GVBD, whereas positive controls [MIH-induced]
mean (6 SEM) of three (upper panel) or eight (lower panel) separate ex-
periments, and those associated with common letters (large, GVBD;
showed near 50% GVBD). The selective inhibitor of PKC,
small, ovulation) are not significantly different (one-way ANOVA and GF (5 mM), as well as the nonselective inhibitor of protein
Duncan multiple-range test; P , 0.05). Follicles incubated for 14–18 h kinases, H7 (50 mM), did not affect MIH-dependent GVBD
showed relatively high levels of ‘‘spontaneous’’ GVBD and ovulation (Fig. 2). In contrast, inhibitors of AA metabolism (IM and
when subsequently placed in untreated medium, indicating that consid- NDGA) and of PKC activity (GF and H7) completely
erable production of endogenous MIH occurred as result of the longer blocked the small incidence of MIH-dependent ovulation
hCG incubation time. Average MIH-dependent GVBD and ovulation were
38% and 5% (upper panel), respectively, and 86% and 40% (lower
observed in these follicles (Figs. 1, upper panel, and 2).
panel), respectively. The PKC-stimulator PMA, but not AA, PGF2a, or PGE 2,
induced the uncoupling of heterologous GJ after a 6-h in-
cubation, which is the time period necessary for MIH- and
PMA-dependent uncoupling of heterologous GJ in croaker
RESULTS follicles (Table 1) [38]. However, MIH-dependent meiotic
resumption and uncoupling of heterologous GJ were not
Preliminary experiments indicated that IM (1–100 mM), affected by coincubation with GF (PKC inhibitor). Namely,
NDGA (1–50 mM), GF (0.05–5 mM), and H7 (5–50 mM) all follicles that underwent GVBD after a 10-h incubation
inhibited MIH-dependent ovulation in a dose-dependent with MIH had completely lost their heterologous GJ cou-
manner. However, NDGA at 50 mM occasionally caused pling regardless of the presence or absence of GF (a longer
atypical follicular appearance, presumably resulting from incubation time was used in this second experiment to en-
toxic effects. Thus, in subsequent experiments, we used IM sure complete maturation of the ovarian follicles).
at 100 mM, NDGA at 10 mM, GF at 5 mM, and H7 at 50
mM. The effective dose-response ranges for GF and H7 Ovarian Follicles During Late Maturation
observed in the present study are similar to those reported
in an earlier study of maturational competence in croaker High incidences of ‘‘spontaneous’’ maturation were ob-
follicles [35]. served when follicles preincubated for 14–18 h in hCG
MECHANISMS OF MATURATION AND OVULATION IN CROAKER OVARIAN FOLLICLES 519

TABLE 1. Effects of PMA, AA, PGF2a, and PGE2 on heterologous gap-


junction coupling in maturationally competent ovarian follicles of Atlantic
croaker. Each treatment was applied to 12 hCG-pretreated (12–14 h) ovar-
ian follicles per individual fish (experiment), and each experiment was
repeated with ovarian follicles from three fish.

Length of treatment (h)


Treatment 0 3 6
Untreated medium 95 6 3* 95 6 3 (A)** 97 6 3 (A)
PMA (1 mg/ml) — 36 6 14 (B) 28 6 5 (B)
AA (100 mM) — 95 6 3 (A) 97 6 3 (A)
PGF2a (5 mM) — 100 6 0 (A) 97 6 3 (A)
PGE2 (5 mM) — 89 6 3 (A) 100 6 0 (A)
* Percent follicles coupled (mean 6 SEM, n 5 3 fish).
** Values within individual columns associated with common letters are
not significantly different (one-way ANOVA and Duncan multiple range
test; P , 0.05).

FIG. 4. Effects of GF, IM, and NDGA on AA-dependent ovulation in


ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovarian fragments containing ap-
proximately 50 follicles were each incubated in 1 ml of medium with
hCG (5 IU) for 14–18 h. Following a brief rinse period, follicles were
incubated with or without GF (5 mM), IM (100 mM), or NDGA (10 mM)
for 45–60 min and then with or without AA (100 mM) for the appropriate
length of time for a total of 36 h (exposure to inhibitors continued until
the end of the incubation). The incidence of ovulation was determined.
Results are expressed relative to the values obtained in the presence of
AA (average ovulation, 31%). Bars indicate the mean (6 SEM) of three
separate experiments, and those associated with common letters are not
significantly different (one-way ANOVA and Duncan multiple-range test;
P , 0.05). This experiment was conducted in conjunction with that for
AA shown in Figure 3.

were subsequently placed in untreated medium. This spon-


taneous maturation is caused by the onset of endogenous
MIH production after prolonged hCG incubations [30, 45].
As noted already, the longer preincubation times were to
ensure adequate development of gonadotropin-dependent
ovulatory competence. In these follicles, IM (COX inhibi-
tor) inhibited the small increase in (exogenous) MIH-de-
pendent GVBD, but NDGA (LOX inhibitor) was without
effect (Fig. 1, bottom panel). Both IM and NDGA effec-
tively blocked MIH-dependent ovulation (Fig. 1, bottom
panel).
Ovulation was induced in a dose-dependent manner with
AA and PGF2a (Fig. 3). In addition, PGE 2 (5 mM) induced
ovulation, but its potency seemed to be lower than that of
PGF2a (data not shown). The AA-induced ovulation was
inhibited by IM and the PKC inhibitor, GF, but not by
NDGA (Fig. 4). Ovulation was also induced by activation
of PKC with PMA (1 mg/ml), and like AA-induced ovu-
lation, PMA-induced ovulation was suppressed by IM and
GF but not by NDGA (Fig. 5).
The MIH-induced ovulation was inhibited by the tran-
scription inhibitor, actinomycin D (5 mM), and restored by
cotreatment with PGF2a (Fig. 6). The AA-induced ovula-
tion, but not the PMA- or PGF2a-induced ovulation, was
FIG. 3. Effects of AA (upper panel) and PGF2a (lower panel) on ovulation also inhibited by actinomycin D (Fig. 7). Finally, PMA-
in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovarian fragments containing ap-
proximately 50 follicles were each incubated in 1 ml of medium with
and AA-induced ovulation were completely inhibited by
hCG (5 IU) for 14–18 h. Following a brief rinse period, follicles were GF, but PGF2a-induced ovulation was only partially inhib-
incubated with or without AA (1–100 mM) or PGF2a (0.5–5 mM) for the ited by GF (Fig. 7).
appropriate length of time for a total of 36 h. The incidence of ovulation
was determined. Results are expressed relative to the values obtained in DISCUSSION
the presence of AA at 100 mM (average ovulation, 31%) or PGF2a at 5
mM (average ovulation, 34%). Bars indicate the mean (6 SEM) of three Maturation
(upper panel) or two (lower panel) separate experiments, and those as-
sociated with common letters are not significantly different (one-way AN- At concentrations that induce ovulation (see later dis-
OVA and Duncan multiple-range test; P , 0.05). cussion), AA was insufficient to induce meiotic resumption
520 PATIÑO ET AL.

FIG. 7. Effects of actinomycin D (ActD) and GF on PMA-, AA-, and


FIG. 5. Effects of GF, IM, and NDGA on PMA-dependent ovulation in PGF2a-dependent ovulation in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovar-
ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovarian fragments containing ap- ian fragments containing approximately 50 follicles were each incubated
proximately 50 follicles were each incubated in 1 ml of medium with in 1 ml of medium with hCG (5 IU) for 14–18 h. Following a brief rinse
hCG (5 IU) for 14–18 h. Following a brief rinse period and a 30-min period and a 30-min incubation with MIH (290 nM), follicles were in-
incubation with MIH (290 nM), follicles were incubated with or without cubated with or without ActD (5 mM) and GF (5 mM) for 45–60 min and
GF (5 mM), IM (100 mM), or NDGA (10 mM) for 45–60 min and then then with or without PMA (1 mg/ml), AA (100 mM), or PGF2a (5 mM) for
with or without PMA (1 mg/ml) for the appropriate length of time for a the appropriate length of time for a total of 36 h (exposure to inhibitors
total of 36 h (exposure to inhibitors continued until the end of the incu- continued until the end of the incubation). The incidence of ovulation
bation). The incidence of ovulation was determined. Results are expressed was determined. Results are expressed relative to the values obtained in
relative to the values obtained in the presence of PMA (average ovulation, the presence of PMA (average ovulation, 86%). Bars indicate the mean
65%). Bars indicate the mean (6 SEM) of three separate experiments, and (6 SEM) of four separate experiments, and those within experimental
those associated with common letters are not significantly different (one- groups (indicated by a line over the bars) associated with common letters
way ANOVA and Duncan multiple-range test; P , 0.05). in reference to the negative control (medium) are not significantly differ-
ent (one-way ANOVA and Duncan multiple-range test on all treatments;
P , 0.05).

in maturationally competent ovarian follicles of Atlantic


croaker. Ovulation-inducing concentrations of PGF2a (COX
product) were also insufficient to induce maturation. Fur-
thermore, ovulation-inhibiting concentrations of NDGA
(LOX inhibitor) did not affect MIH-dependent maturation.
These results differ from those obtained with another teleost
fish, the European sea bass, in which exogenous AA as well
as the COX products, PGF2a and PGE 2, were sufficient to
induce meiotic resumption in maturationally competent
ovarian follicles [2]. The mechanisms of AA-induced oo-
cyte maturation were not examined in European sea bass,
however, and whether the action of AA was indirect, via
regulation of follicular MIH production, or direct, as trans-
ducer of MIH action, is unclear [2]. The possibility of in-
direct effects via induction of MIH production is suggested
by the results of studies with goldfish showing that exog-
enous AA can enhance the steroidogenic activity of ovarian
follicles [46]. Nevertheless, in the present study, IM seemed
to partially inhibit MIH-induced meiotic resumption. Al-
though the latter observation allows the possibility that an
intact COX pathway is necessary to facilitate MIH-induced
maturation in Atlantic croaker, caution must be used when
interpreting results obtained with IM, because effects of this
FIG. 6. Blockage of MIH-dependent ovulation by actinomycin D (ActD) reagent on cell functions unrelated to AA metabolism have
and rescue by PGF2a in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Ovarian frag-
ments containing approximately 50 follicles were each incubated in 1 ml
been described [47]. Overall, the results of the present study
of medium with hCG (5 IU) for 14–18 h. Following a brief rinse period, strongly suggest that AA and its metabolites are insufficient
follicles were incubated with or without ActD (5 mM) for 45–60 min and to directly or indirectly induce meiotic resumption in ovar-
then with or without MIH (290 nM) or PGF2a (5 mM) for the appropriate ian follicles of Atlantic croaker, but the possibility of a
length of time for a total of 36 h (exposure to ActD continued until the permissive role of COX metabolic pathways in MIH-de-
end of the incubation). The incidence of ovulation was determined. Re- pendent meiotic resumption cannot be ruled out.
sults are expressed relative to the values obtained in the presence of MIH
(average ovulation, 46%). Bars indicate the mean (6 SEM) of three sep-
Studies with vertebrates other than teleosts also have
arate experiments, and those associated with common letters are not sig- yielded inconsistent observations regarding the involve-
nificantly different (one-way ANOVA and Duncan multiple-range test; P ment of AA and its metabolites in oocyte maturation. For
, 0.05). example, the LOX pathway of AA metabolism was linked
MECHANISMS OF MATURATION AND OVULATION IN CROAKER OVARIAN FOLLICLES 521

FIG. 8. Major steps of the proposed transduction pathway for MIH-induced ovulation in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. The MIH binds to a
nuclear receptor (nMIHR), possibly in granulosa or thecal cells, and activates genomic mechanisms. Enzymes associated with the LOX pathway of AA
metabolism are consequently synthesized or activated, and an undefined product or products (X) of LOX directly or indirectly induce the activity of
preexisting PKC. Increased PKC activity in turn induces COX and increases the synthesis of prostaglandins (PGF2a) from AA. The PGF2a causes rupture
of the follicle and consequent expulsion of the oocyte (ovulation). Lines ending with solid circles point toward steps along the pathway that are blocked
by the inhibitors used in the present study (see text). The PMA directly activates PKC and bypasses the actinomycin D (ActD)- and NDGA-sensitive
steps of ovulation.

to hormonally induced oocyte maturation in some, but not showed that neither AA nor its COX metabolites, PGE 2
all, species of starfishes [1]. Also, PGE1 and PGE 2 inhibited and PGF2a, are able to uncouple heterologous GJ in mat-
progesterone-dependent meiotic resumption in Xenopus oo- urationally competent croaker follicles within the time
cytes [8], whereas positive [3–6], negative [7], or no [15] frame necessary for MIH-dependent uncoupling and mat-
involvement of AA or its metabolites was suggested in oo- uration [38]. Furthermore, although pharmacological acti-
cytes of a number of mammalian species. Although it is vation of PKC (by PMA) caused heterologous GJ to un-
possible that conditions associated with specific experimen- couple in croaker follicles ([38]; present study), specific
tal systems can lead to artifactual results, the information inhibitors of PKC (GF) had no effect on MIH-dependent
available also suggests that differences exist in the roles GJ uncoupling. Thus, AA and PKC do not seem to partic-
and mechanisms of AA during oocyte maturation among ipate in the MIH-dependent periovulatory uncoupling of
species. heterologous GJ.
In croaker follicles, activators of PKC (PMA) do not
seem to induce meiotic resumption ([35, 38]; present Ovulation
study), and inhibitors of PKC (GF and H7) do not affect
MIH-induced meiotic resumption at concentrations that In contrast to maturation, MIH-dependent ovulation in
suppress ovulation (see later discussion). Also, treatment of croaker follicles seems to require functional PKC and intact
croaker follicles with PMA before MIH stimulation appears COX and LOX pathways of AA metabolism. Namely, in-
to be toxic to the oocytes (data not shown). These obser- hibitors of PKC (GF and H7), COX (IM), and LOX
vations indicate that MIH-dependent meiotic resumption in (NDGA) all blocked MIH-dependent ovulation, whereas
croaker oocytes does not involve PKC and that premature PMA, AA, PGF2a, and PGE 2 were all sufficient to induce
PKC activation may be inhibitory or toxic to maturation. ovulation. Furthermore, actinomycin D blocked MIH-de-
A maturation-suppressing effect of PKC was also suggested pendent ovulation, and coincubation with PGF2a restored
for mouse oocytes [17] and Xenopus oocytes [16]. Con- ovulation. (Transcription is not required for MIH-dependent
versely, pharmacological activation of PKC was reported meiotic resumption in croaker follicles [30].) These various
to promote oocyte maturation in species such as the rat findings are generally consistent with those obtained in oth-
[18], the amphibian Rana dybowskii [19], and the teleost er vertebrates. For example, a requirement for de novo tran-
killifish [20, 21]. However, like in Atlantic croaker, PKC scription during MIH-dependent ovulation has been previ-
activation was found to be unnecessary for MIH-dependent ously reported in spotted seatrout [39] and yellow perch
oocyte maturation in killifish [21]. Thus, PKC does not [40]. This transcription requirement suggests that MIH-de-
seem to have a physiological role in the process of MIH- pendent ovulation in teleost fishes occurs via interaction
dependent maturation in those teleost species examined to with a nuclear (classical) steroid receptor recently charac-
date. Preliminary information (unpublished data) suggests terized in teleost ovaries [39]. Similar conclusions were
that specific inhibitors of PKA (H89) also do not affect made regarding progesterone-dependent ovulation in rats
MIH-induced meiotic resumption in croaker follicles at [48]. Furthermore, PKC has been previously linked to ovu-
concentrations that inhibit hCG-dependent maturational lation in other teleosts [10, 22–24], amphibians [27], and
competence (first stage of maturation) [35]. Furthermore, mammals [10, 25, 26]. Finally, as observed in the present
PKA inhibitors are sufficient to induce maturation in killi- study with Atlantic croaker, AA seems to be involved in
fish follicles [21]. These observations are consistent with the ovulation process of most other vertebrates that have
the concept that a decline in PKA activity is involved in been studied to date [9–15].
MIH-dependent meiotic resumption of teleost oocytes [37]. The PMA-dependent ovulation was completely blocked
Correlations between meiotic resumption and uncou- by a specific PKC inhibitor (GF), thus confirming that PMA
pling of granulosa cell-oocyte GJ have been observed in acts via activation of PKC. Furthermore, PMA-dependent
all vertebrate species examined, including Atlantic croaker ovulation was inhibited by IM but not by actinomycin D
[31, 38]. Given the recently proposed involvement of AA or NDGA. These latter observations suggest that the re-
in oocyte maturation of some teleosts [32] and the inhibi- quirements for transcription and LOX during MIH-depen-
tory effect of AA on GJ coupling in a number of tissues dent ovulation are both upstream of PKC activation, where-
[41–43], the present study examined the hypothesis that AA as the requirement for COX is downstream of PKC (Fig.
is part of the signaling pathway for MIH-dependent uncou- 8). This proposed sequence of events implies that AA-de-
pling of heterologous GJ. However, the present results pendent ovulation should not be markedly affected by the
522 PATIÑO ET AL.

LOX inhibitor, NDGA (because AA-derived PGs produced Conclusion


by COX would bypass the upstream requirement for LOX),
or by actinomycin D. The present results are consistent with The present observations suggest that AA and PKC are
the first condition, but the inhibitory effect of actinomycin key elements of the transduction pathway for MIH-depen-
D on AA-dependent ovulation is seemingly inconsistent dent ovulation but not meiotic resumption or heterologous
with the proposed model. However, because PKC inhibitor GJ uncoupling in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker.
(GF) completely blocked AA-induced ovulation, it can be However, these results are inconclusive regarding the pos-
postulated that MIH-induced PKC activity not only serves sibility of a permissive role of COX products during MIH-
dependent maturation. A novel model of MIH-dependent
to increase the activity of existing COX enzymes but also
ovulation is proposed for Atlantic croaker in which LOX
to slow down their turnover rate or that of their mRNAs. and COX metabolites of AA are both required for ovulation
In such a scenario, the combination of a transcription block- but at upstream and downstream sites of the pathway, re-
age (as when in the presence of actinomycin D) and con- spectively, relative to PKC and in which PKC is down-
ditions of basal PKC activity would lead to a gradual de- stream of genomic activation. This heuristic model is ame-
cline in COX protein and activity and, thus, to a reduced nable to experimental testing and, if verified, would allow
follicular capacity to metabolize AA into the ovulation-ac- further studies focusing on specific steps of the pathway
tive products, PGs. The overall outcome would be a re- and their respective mechanisms.
duced ability of AA to induce ovulation, thus explaining
the observation of the present study. Alternatively, tran-
scription-mediated induction of COX by AA could also ex- ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
plain the inhibition of AA-dependent ovulation by actino- Dr. Frederick W. Goetz and Mr. Naresh Pandey provided critical com-
mycin D, but this scenario would be difficult to reconcile ments on a draft version of this manuscript.
with the findings that the IM-sensitive site of ovulation
(COX) is downstream of PKC and that PKC-dependent
REFERENCES
ovulation is insensitive to actinomycin D.
The proposed transduction pathway (Fig. 8) also indi- 1. Meijer L, Maclouf J, Bryant RW. Contrasting effects of fatty acids on
cates that PG-dependent ovulation should not be affected oocyte maturation in several starfish species. Prostaglandins Leukot
by transcription inhibitors. This condition was met by the Med 1986; 23:179–184.
present results. Interestingly, PGF2a-induced ovulation was 2. Sorbera LA, Asturiano JF, Carrillo M, Zanuy S. Effects of polyunsat-
urated fatty acids and prostaglandins on oocyte maturation in a marine
partially diminished in the presence of a concentration of teleost, the European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax). Biol Reprod
GF that completely blocked PMA-induced ovulation. Thus, 2001; 64:382–389.
it appears that PKC activity facilitates, but is not strictly 3. Neal P, Baker TG, McNatty KP, Scaramuzzi RJ. Influence of prosta-
required for, PG-induced ovulation. Although endogenous glandins and human chorionic gonadotropin on progesterone concen-
tration and oocyte maturation in mouse ovarian follicles maintained
PGs were not measured in the present study, ovarian PGEs in organ culture. J Endocrinol 1975; 65:19–25.
and PGFs have been observed in all vertebrate species for 4. Downs SM, Longo FJ. Effects of IM on preovulatory follicles in im-
which measurements have been taken [10]. In teleost fishes, mature, superovulated mice. Am J Anat 1982; 164:265–274.
PGF2a has consistently induced ovulation, whereas the ef- 5. Downs SM, Longo FJ. Prostaglandins and preovulatory follicular mat-
fects of PGEs have been variable [10]. In Atlantic croaker, uration in mice. J Exp Zool 1983; 228:99–108.
6. Murdoch WJ. Disruption of cellular associations within the granulosal
exogenous PGF2a and PGE 2 both induced ovulation, but compartment of periovulatory ovine follicles: relationship to matura-
PGF2a seemed to be slightly more potent. tion of the oocyte and regulation by prostaglandins. Cell Tissue Res
The transduction pathway for MIH-induced ovulation 1988; 252:459–462.
proposed here for Atlantic croaker (Fig. 8) is remarkably 7. Cho WK. The effects of prostaglandin E1 and F2a on maturation of
consistent with the following observations in the rat: 1) LH- mouse oocytes in vitro. J Reprod Fertil 1976; 47:1–5.
8. Zhao J, Kung HF. Modulation of progesterone-induced Xenopus oo-
induced PG production and ovulation seem to be mediated cyte maturation by prostaglandins E1 and E 2. Cell Mol Biol Res 1994;
by progesterone production and interaction with a classical 40:63–68.
progesterone receptor [48], 2) LOX metabolites (leukotri- 9. Carvalho CB, Yeik BS, Murdoch WJ. Significance of follicular cy-
enes) are produced earlier than COX products (PGs) during clooxygenase and lipooxygenase pathways of metabolism of arachid-
hCG-induced ovulation [49], 3) treatment of perfused ova- onate in sheep. Prostaglandins 1989; 37:553–558.
10. Goetz FW, Berndtson AK, Ranjan M. Ovulation: mediators at the
ries with LOX inhibitor (NDGA) inhibits LH-dependent PG ovarian level. In: Pang PKT, Schreibman MP (eds.), Vertebrate En-
production and ovulation [12], and 4) certain LOX metab- docrinology: Fundamentals and Biomedical Implications. San Diego:
olites can induce PG production by ovarian granulosa cells Academic Press; 1991: 127–203.
[50]. These observations suggest that LH (progesterone)- 11. Downey BR, Mootoo JE, Doyle SE. A role for lipooxygenase metab-
olites of arachidonic acid in porcine ovulation. Anim Reprod Sci
dependent ovulation in rat follicles is mediated by LOX 1998; 49:269–279.
product-dependent synthesis of PGs. Furthermore, although 12. Mikuni M, Yoshida M, Hellberg P, Peterson CA, Edwin SS, Bränns-
its relative position in the transduction pathway is un- tröm M, Peterson CM. The lipooxygenase inhibitor, nordihydroguaiar-
known, PKC is also thought to be required for LH-depen- etic acid, inhibits ovulation and reduces leukotriene and prostaglandin
dent ovulation in rat follicles [26, 51]. In yellow perch, the levels in the rat ovary. Biol Reprod 1998; 58:1211–1216.
13. Mikuni M, Pall M, Peterson CM, Hellberg P, Brännström M, Richards
COX and LOX pathways of AA metabolism have been JS, Heidin L. The selective prostaglandin endoperoxide synthase-2
implicated in ovulation as well [52], but unlike in Atlantic inhibitor, NS-398, reduces prostaglandin production and ovulation in
croaker, PMA-induced ovulation is inhibited only by vivo and in vitro in the rat. Biol Reprod 1998; 59:1077–1083.
NDGA and not by IM [22]. Thus, the requirements for 14. Espey LL. Ovulation. In: Knobil E, Neill JD (eds.), Encyclopedia of
LOX and COX during perch ovulation seem to be down- Reproduction, vol. 3. San Diego: Academic Press; 1999: 605–614.
15. Matsumoto H, Ma W-G, Smalley W, Trzaskos J, Breyer RM, Ney SK
stream and upstream of PKC, respectively, which is the Diversification of cyclooxygenase-2-derived prostaglandins in ovula-
reverse situation relative to the proposed croaker ovulation tion and implantation. Biol Reprod 2001; 64:1557–1565.
pathway (Fig. 8). 16. Stith BJ, Goalstone ML, Kirkwood AJ. Protein kinase C initially in-
MECHANISMS OF MATURATION AND OVULATION IN CROAKER OVARIAN FOLLICLES 523

hibits the induction of meiotic cell division in Xenopus oocytes. Cell 35. Chang X, Patiño R, Thomas P, Yoshizaki G. Developmental and pro-
Signal 1992; 4:393–403. tein kinase-dependent regulation of ovarian connexin mRNA and oo-
17. Downs SM, Cottom J, Hunzicker-Dunn M. Protein kinase C and mei- cyte maturational competence in Atlantic croaker. Gen Comp Endo-
otic regulation in isolated mouse oocytes. Mol Reprod Dev 2001; 58: crinol 1999; 114:330–339.
101–115. 36. Thomas P, Zhu Y, Pace, M. Progestin membrane receptors involved
18. Aberdam E, Dekel N. Activators of protein kinase C stimulate meiotic in the meiotic maturation of teleost oocytes: a review with some new
maturation of rat oocytes. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 1985; 132: findings. Steroids 2002; 67:511–517.
570–574. 37. Nagahama Y. 17a,20b-Dihysroxy-4-pregnen-3-one, a maturation-in-
19. Kwon HB, Lee WK. Involvement of protein kinase C in the regulation ducing hormone in fish oocytes: mechanisms of synthesis and action.
of oocyte maturation in amphibians (Rana dybowskii). J Exp Zool Steroids 1997; 62:190–196.
1991; 257:115–123. 38. Yoshizaki G, Patiño R, Thomas P, Bolamba D, Chang X. Effects of
20. Cerdá J, Petrino TR, Wallace RA. Functional heterologous gap junc- maturation-inducing hormone on heterologous gap junctional coupling
tions in Fundulus ovarian follicles maintain meiotic arrest and permit in ovarian follicles of Atlantic croaker. Gen Comp Endocrinol 2001;
hydration during oocyte maturation. Dev Biol 1993; 160:228–235. 124:359–366.
21. Cerdá J, Reich G, Wallace RA, Selman K. Serotonin inhibition of 39. Pinter J, Thomas P. Induction of ovulation of mature oocytes by the
steroid-induced meiotic maturation in the teleost Fundulus heterocli- maturation-inducing steroid 17a,20b,21-trihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one
tus: role of cyclic AMP and protein kinases. Mol Reprod Dev 1998; in the spotted seatrout. Gen Comp Endocrinol 1999; 115:200–209.
49:333–341. 40. Theofan G, Goetz FW. The in vitro effects of actinomycin-D and
22. Berndtson AK, Goetz FW, Duman P. In vitro ovulation, prostaglandin cycloheximide on germinal vesicle breakdown and ovulation of yel-
synthesis, and proteolysis in isolated ovarian components of yellow low perch (Perca flavens) oocytes. Comp Biochem Physiol 1981;
perch (Perca flavens): effects of 17a,20b-dihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one 69A:557–561.
and phorbol ester. Gen Comp Endocrinol 1989; 75:454–465. 41. Weingart R, Bukauskas FF. Long-chain n-alkanols and arachidonic
23. Goetz FW, Hsu SY, Selover A. Stimulation of prostaglandin synthesis acid interfere with the Vm-sensitive gating mechanism of gap junction
in fish follicles by a phorbol ester and calcium ionophore. J Exp Zool channels. Pfueg Arch 1998; 435:310–319.
1991; 259:355–364. 42. Boger DL, Sato H, Lerner AE, Guan X, Gilula NB. Arachidonic acid
24. Goetz FW. Involvement of protein kinase C in agonist-stimulated amide inhibitors of gap junction cell-cell communication. Bioorg Med
goldfish ovulation. Biol Reprod 1993; 48:846–850. Chem Lett 1999; 9:1151–1154.
25. Kaufman G, Dharmarajan AM, Takehara Y, Cropp CS, Wallach EE. 43. Martinez AD, Saez JC. Arachidonic acid-induced uncoupling in rat
The role of protein kinase-C in gonadotropin-induced ovulation in the cortical astrocytes is mediated by arachidonic acid byproducts. Brain
in vitro perfused rabbit ovary. Endocrinology 1992; 131:1804–1809. Res 1999; 816:411–423.
26. Shimamoto T, Yamamoto M, Nakano R. Possible involvement of pro- 44. Chang X, Patiño R, Yoshizaki G, Thomas P, Lee VH. Hormonal reg-
tein kinase C in gonadotropin-induced ovulation in the rat ovary. En- ulation and cellular distribution of connexin 32.2 and connexin 32.7
docrinology 1993; 133:2127–2132. RNAs in the ovary of Atlantic croaker. Gen Comp Endocrinol 2000;
27. Chang KJ, Kim JW, Lee J, Im WB, Kwon HB, Schuetz AW. Prosta- 120:146–156.
glandin production and ovulation during exposure of amphibian ovar- 45. Patiño R, Thomas P. Gonadotropin stimulates 17a,20b,21-trihydroxy-
ian follicles to gonadotropin or phorbol ester in vitro. Gen Comp 4-pregnen-3-one production from endogenous substrates in Atlantic
Endocrinol 1995; 100:275–266. croaker ovarian follicles undergoing final maturation in vitro. Gen
28. Patiño R, Yoshizaki G, Thomas P, Kagawa H. Gonadotropic control Comp Endocrinol 1990; 78:474–478.
of ovarian follicle maturation: the two-stage concept and its mecha- 46. Van Der Kraak G, Chang JP. Arachidonic acid stimulates steroido-
nisms. Comp Biochem Physiol 2001; 129B:427–439. genesis in goldfish preovulatory follicles. Gen Comp Endocrinol
29. Pang Y, Ge W. Gonadotropin and activin enhance maturational com- 1990; 77:221–228.
petence of oocytes in the zebrafish (Danio rerio). Biol Reprod 2002; 47. Murdoch WJ, Lund SA. Prostaglandin-independent anovulatory
66:259–265. mechanism of indomethacin action: inhibition of tumor necrosis factor
30. Patiño R, Thomas P. Effects of gonadotropin on ovarian intrafollicular a-induced sheep ovarian cell apoptosis. Biol Reprod 1999; 61:1655–
processes during the development of oocyte maturational competence 1659.
in a teleost, the Atlantic croaker: evidence for two distinct stages of 48. Pall M, Mikuni M, Nisube K, Brännström M. Time-dependent ovu-
gonadotropic control of final oocyte maturation. Biol Reprod 1990; lation inhibition of a selective progesterone receptor antagonist (Org
43:818–827. 31710) and effects on ovulatory mediators in the in vitro perfused rat
31. York WS, Patiño R, Thomas P. Ultrastructural changes in follicle cell- ovary. Biol Reprod 2000; 63:1642–1647.
oocyte associations during development and maturation of the ovarian 49. Higuchi Y, Yoshimura T, Tanaka N, Ogino H, Sumiyama M, Kawaka-
follicle in Atlantic croaker. Gen Comp Endocrinol 1993; 92:402–418. mi S. Different time-course production of peptidic and nonpeptidic
32. Patiño R, Thomas P. Characterization of membrane receptor activity leukotriene and prostaglandins E 2 and F2a in the ovary during ovu-
for 17a,20b,21-trihydroxy-4-pregnen-3-one in ovaries of spotted sea- lation in gonadotropin-primed immature rats. Prostaglandins 1995; 49:
trout (Cynoscion nebulosus). Gen Comp Endocrinol 1990; 78:204– 131–140.
217. 50. Wang J, Yuen BH, Leung PC. Stimulation of progesterone and pros-
33. Thomas P, Patiño R. Changes in 17a,20b,21-trihydroxy-4-pregnen-3- taglandin E 2 production by lipooxygenase metabolites of arachidonic
one membrane receptor in ovaries of spotted seatrout during final oocyte acid. FEBS Lett 1989; 244:154–158.
maturation. In: Scott AP, Sumpter JP, Kime DE, Rolfe MS (eds.), Pro- 51. Morris JK, Richards JS. Luteinizing hormone induces prostaglandin
ceedings of the Fourth International Symposium of the Reproductive endoperoxide synthase-2 and luteinization in vitro by A-kinase and
Physiology of Fish. Sheffield, UK: FishSymp91; 1991: 122–124. C-kinase pathways. Endocrinology 1995; 136:1549–1558.
34. Thomas P, Pinter J, Das S. Upregulation of the maturation-inducing 52. Bradley JA, Goetz FW. The inhibitory effect of indomethacin, nor-
steroid membrane receptor in spotted seatrout ovaries by gonadotropin dihydroguaiaretic acid, and pyrrolidinedithiocarbamate on ovulation
during maturation and its physiological significance. Biol Reprod and prostaglandin synthesis in yellow perch (Perca flavens) follicle
2001; 64:21–29. incubates. Prostaglandins 1994; 48:11–20.

Potrebbero piacerti anche