Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
for
Sharing of Transmission Charges
Tracing of Electricity
Based on a paper published by Bialek in 1996
Requires base case load flow
Uses concept of proportional flows
Inconsistent with laws of physics
Attempts to identify which generators are
supplying which loads
Marginal Participation
The Procedure
Solve Base case LF on basic
network.truncate to 400 kv
Identification of responding buses-tracing
Increment 1 MW Marginal generation/Load
at desired bus absorbed/generated by
responding buses
Calculate line utilization factors
Allocate costs to nodes
Calculate poc rate/nodal prices
Generator #1
260 MW
0 Mvar
180 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 2
Bus 1
Line 1
Line 4
Line 2
Line 3
Bus 3
100 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 4
220 MW
Line 6
Line 5
0 Mvar
Bus 5
slack
400 MW
0 Mvar
The LF studies have been done using Power World Simulator evaluation/student edition
Pout Records
Base Case
Bus Flows
BUS
11
GENERATOR
TO
22
TO
33
TO
55
400.0 MW
180.00
0.0
1 192.62 0 0.0
1 60.38 0 0.0
1 -73.00 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
261.00
1 -193.07 0 0.0
1 -67.93 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.62 0
1 -67.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.21 0 0.0
1 -159.79 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.38 0
1 -159.62 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.93 0 0.0
1 -167.93 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.38 0
1 -167.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
401.00
1 73.28 0 0.0
1 159.79 0 0.0
1 167.93 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 73.00 0 0.0
1 159.62 0 0.0
1 167.38 0 0.0
Generator #1
260 MW
0 Mvar
180 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 2
Bus 1
192.62 MW
Line 1
60.38 MW
Line 4
Line 2
Line 3
73 MW
Bus 3
100 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 4
220 MW
Line 6
Line 5
0 Mvar
Bus 5
slack
400 MW
0 Mvar
Generator #1
260 MW
0 Mvar
P1=253
180 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 2
Bus 1
1-2=192.62
Line 1
1-3=60.38
P2=260
4-2=67.38
Line 4
Line 2
Line 3
P4=167.38
Bus 3
P3=220
100 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 4
220 MW
Line 6
Line 5
0 Mvar
5-4=167.38
5-3=159.62
Bus 5
slack
400 MW
0 Mvar
P5=400
5-1=73.00
1
-|Pj-i|/Pj
0
if i=j
if j belongs to set of
nodes directly supplying
to node i
otherwise
Au Matrix
Au
Inv
Au
1.000
-0.183
1.000
0.183
-0.759
1.000
-0.403
0.759
1.000
0.403
0.307
-0.239
1.000
-0.399
0.239
1.000
0.443
1.000
-0.418
0.000
1.000
0.418
1.000
1.000
PLi*[Au-1]ik*PGk/Pi
1
-|Pj-i|/Pj
0
if i=j
if j belongs to set of
nodes directly supplied
from node i
otherwise
Ad matrix
Ad
Inv
Ad
1.000
-0.741
-0.274
0.000
0.000
1.000
0.741
0.274
0.000
0.000
1.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
1.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
1.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
1.000
0.000
0.000
-0.259
0.000
1.000
0.000
0.000
0.259
0.000
1.000
0.000
-0.289
0.000
-0.726
-1.000
1.000
0.289
0.473
0.805
1.000
1.000
Line1(1-2)
Line2(4-2)
Line3(5-1)
Line4(1-3)
Line5(5-3)
Line6(5-4)
Generator
1 (MW)
137.04
42.96
71
71
Generator
2(MW)
55.58
67
73
17.42
159.62
167.38
29
100
100
29
100
100
Total
192.62
67
73
60.38
159.62
167.38
Line1(12)
Line2(4-2)
Line3(5-1)
Line4(1-3)
Line5(5-3)
Line6(5-4)
192.6
67.38
55.59
67.38
100
100
76
40
Load (bus 3)
17.41
60.38
159.62
24
100
100
load (bus 4)
100
60
192.6
67.38
73
60.38
159.62
167.38
Load (bus2)
Load (bus
2)
136.62
Load (bus
3)
43.02
Load (bus
4)
0
53
20
Gen
2(bus5)
%
123.38
176.98
100
47
80
100
Total
260
220
100
Gen
1(bus1)
%
Generator #1
261 MW
0 Mvar
181 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 2
Bus 1
Line 1
Line 4
Line 2
Line 3
Bus 3
100 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 4
220 MW
Line 6
Line 5
0 Mvar
Bus 5
slack
400 MW
0 Mvar
400.0 MW
261.00
1 -193.33 0 0.0
1 -67.67 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.31 0 0.0
1 -159.69 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.67 0 0.0
1 -167.67 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.47
0.0
1 73.11 0 0.0
1 159.69 0 0.0
1 167.67 0 0.0
Pout Records
Base Case
Bus Flows
BUS
11
GENERATOR
TO
22
TO
33
TO
55
400.0 MW
180.00
0.0
1 192.62 0 0.0
1 60.38 0 0.0
1 -73.00 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.62 0
1 -67.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.38 0
1 -159.62 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.38 0
1 -167.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 73.00 0 0.0
1 159.62 0 0.0
1 167.38 0 0.0
Line
Ue2l
1-2
Marginal Base
case
case
193.33
192.62
184.6
Ue2(1-2)
1-3
60.31
60.38
Ue2(1-3)
5-1
73.11
73.00
28.6
Ue2(5-1)
4-2
67.67
67.38
75.4
Ue2(4-2)
5-3
159.69
159.62
18.2
Ue2(5-3)
5-4
167.67
167.38
75.4
Ue2(5-4)
400.0 MW
260.76
1 -193.39 0 0.0
1 -67.37 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.24
1 -60.54 0 0.0
1 -159.70 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.37 0 0.0
1 -167.37 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 72.93 0 0.0
1 159.70 0 0.0
1 167.37 0 0.0
Pout Records
Base Case
Bus Flows
BUS
11
GENERATOR
TO
22
TO
33
TO
55
400.0 MW
180.00
0.0
1 192.62 0 0.0
1 60.38 0 0.0
1 -73.00 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.62 0
1 -67.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.38 0
1 -159.62 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.38 0
1 -167.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 73.00 0 0.0
1 159.62 0 0.0
1 167.38 0 0.0
Line
Ue1l
1-2
Marginal Base
case
case
193.39
192.62
138.6
Ue1(1-2)
1-3
60.54
60.38
28.8
Ue1(1-3)
5-1
72.93
73.00
Ue1(5-1)
4-2
67.37
67.38
Ue1(4-2)
5-3
159.70
159.62
14.4
Ue1(5-3)
5-4
167.37
167.38
Ue1(5-4)
Pout Records
Base Case
Bus Flows
BUS
11
GENERATOR
TO
22
TO
33
TO
55
400.0 MW
180.00
0.0
1 192.62 0 0.0
1 60.38 0 0.0
1 -73.00 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.48 0 0.0
1 -67.52 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.62 0
1 -67.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
221.00
1 -60.81 0 0.0
1 -160.19 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.38 0
1 -159.62 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.52 0 0.0
1 -167.52 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.38 0
1 -167.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.80
0.0
1 73.09 0 0.0
1 160.19 0 0.0
1 167.52 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 73.00 0 0.0
1 159.62 0 0.0
1 167.38 0 0.0
Line
Ue3l
1-2
Marginal Base
case
case
192.48
192.62
Ue3(1-2)
1-3
60.81
60.38
94.6
Ue3(1-3)
5-1
73.09
73.00
19.8
Ue3(5-1)
4-2
67.52
67.38
30.8
Ue3(4-2)
5-3
160.19
159.62
125.4
Ue3(5-3)
5-4
167.52
167.38
30.8
Ue3(5-4)
Pout Records
Base Case
Bus Flows
BUS
11
GENERATOR
TO
22
TO
33
TO
55
400.0 MW
180.00
0.0
1 192.62 0 0.0
1 60.38 0 0.0
1 -73.00 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -193.01 0 0.0
1 -66.99 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.62 0
1 -67.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.23 0 0.0
1 -159.77 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.38 0
1 -159.62 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
101.00
1 66.99 0 0.0
1 -167.99 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.38 0
1 -167.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 73.00 0 0.0
1 159.62 0 0.0
1 167.38 0 0.0
BUS
55
400.0 MW
GENERATOR 1
401.00
0.0
TO
11
1 73.24 0 0.0
TO
33
1 159.77 0 0.0
TO
44
1 167.99 0 0.0
Line
Ue4l
1-2
Marginal Base
case
case
193.01
192.62
39
Ue4(1-2)
1-3
60.23
60.38
Ue4(1-3)
5-1
73.24
73.00
24
Ue4(5-1)
4-2
66.99
67.38
Ue4(4-2)
5-3
159.77
159.62
15
Ue4(5-3)
5-4
167.99
167.38
61
Ue4(5-4)
Pout Records
Base Case
Bus Flows
BUS
11
GENERATOR
TO
22
TO
33
TO
55
400.0 MW
180.00
0.0
1 192.62 0 0.0
1 60.38 0 0.0
1 -73.00 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.31
1 -192.75 0 0.0
1 -67.56 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
260.00
1 -192.62 0
1 -67.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.44
1 -60.46 0
1 -159.98 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -60.38 0
1 -159.62 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW 1
100.25
1 67.56 0 0.0
1 -167.81 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 67.38 0
1 -167.38 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
401.00
1 73.22 0
1 159.98 0
1 167.81 0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
400.00
0.0
1 73.00 0 0.0
1 159.62 0 0.0
1 167.38 0 0.0
1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Line
Ue4l
1-2
Marginal Base
case
case
192.75
192.62
52
Ue5(1-2)
1-3
60.46
60.38
32
Ue5(1-3)
5-1
73.22
73.00
88
Ue5(5-1)
4-2
67.56
67.38
72
Ue5(4-2)
5-3
159.98
159.62
144
Ue5(5-3)
5-4
167.81
167.38
172
Ue5(5-4)
Line
1-2
1-3
Bus 4
Bus 5
.0941
0.1255
0.6088 0
0.2059
1-5
2-4
0.4231 0.1728 0
3-5
4-5
0.4040
Load 2
Load 3
Gen 1(bus
1) %
30
20
50
Gen 2(bus
2) %
40
25
35
Zone A
Generator #1
260 MW
0 Mvar
180 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 2
Bus 1
Line 1
Line 4
Line 2
Line 3
Bus 3
100 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 4
220 MW
Line 6
Line 5
0 Mvar
Bus 5
slack
400 MW
0 Mvar
from bus
to bus
length in KM
160
160
112
112
200
200
80
80
152
152
99
99
Total=803 Cr
Line cost considered as 1 crore/km for indicative purposes only
Marginal
Participation
case
(Cost in Rs
Cr)
Uniform
Charges
(Cost in Rs
Cr)
50 % Marginal
Participation
50% Uniform
Charges
PoC rates
Rs Lakh
/MW/mont
h
Node/Bus
1
75
125
100
4.62
Node/Bus
2
185
180
182.5
5.85
Node/Bus
3
162
152
157
5.95
Node/Bus
4
70
69
69.5
5.79
Node/Bus
5
311
277
294
6.13
Total
803
803
803
Generator shares
Generator
Generator Node 1
% share
Generator Node 5
% share
Loads
Load bus 2
10
50
Load bus 3
30
30
Load bus 4
60
20
Node
s
MPTrace
UC
50 %
MP &
50%
UC
PoC
rates
Rs Lakh
/MW
/month
Monthly
Charges to
be paid Rs
Lakhs/mont
h based on
share
Node/
Bus 1
75
125
100
4.62
(3.47)
Generator
node
Node/
Bus 2
185
180
182.5
5.85
(5.93)
2830
Node/
Bus 3
162
5.95
(6.14)
2294
Node/
Bus 4
70
5.79
(5.83)
1568
Node/
Bus 5
311
277
294
6.13
(6.48)
Generator
node
Total
803
803
803
152
69
157
69.5
Monthly
Charges to
be paid Rs
Lakhs/month
based on
trace
2905
2596
1192
Present Issues
Whether a generator/supplier or
Load/Consumer is to be penalized for its
geographical location?
-----generation zones are predetermined
based on availability of resources
----load zones/industrial belts are also result
of historical development, resource
availability
Whether generator or Consumer be
penalized due to asymmetries in
transmission network created during
historical development of ISTS ?
Future Concerns
Integration of Renewables in the Grid
---run of the river hydro, wind and solar run
on very low PLF. However, transmission
must be developed for entire capacity.
---higher transmission cost/unit due to low
PLF which is not under the control of
generator may result in disincentive for
growth of renewables
Generator #1
390 MW
0 Mvar
180 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 2
Bus 1
Line 1
Line 4
Line 2
Line 3
Bus 3
100 MW
0 Mvar
Bus 4
220 MW
Line 6
Line 5
0 Mvar
Bus 5
slack
530 MW
0 Mvar
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.79 0
1 -138.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.27 0
1 -182.73 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.21 0
1 -238.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.06 0 0.0
1 182.73 0 0.0
1 238.21 0 0.0
Load (bus
2)
156.78
Load (bus
3)
23.22
Load (bus
4)
0
40
11
Gen
2(bus5)
%
232.74
197.26
100
60
89
100
Total
390
220
100
Gen
1(bus1)
%
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.87
1 -252.64 0 0.0
1 -138.23 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.79 0
1 -138.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.13
1 -37.37 0 0.0
1 -182.76 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.27 0
1 -182.73 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.23 0 0.0
1 -238.23 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.21 0
1 -238.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.01 0 0.0
1 182.76 0 0.0
1 238.23 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.06 0 0.0
1 182.73 0 0.0
1 238.21 0 0.0
400.0 MW
391.00
1 -252.44 0 0.0
1 -138.56 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.17 0 0.0
1 -182.83 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.56 0 0.0
1 -238.56 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.60
1 109.21 0 0.0
1 182.83 0 0.0
1 238.56 0 0.0
0.0
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.79 0
1 -138.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.27 0
1 -182.73 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.21 0
1 -238.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.06 0 0.0
1 182.73 0 0.0
1 238.21 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.61 0 0.0
1 -138.39 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.79 0
1 -138.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
221.00
1 -37.68 0 0.0
1 -183.32 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.27 0
1 -182.73 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.39 0 0.0
1 -238.39 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.21 0
1 -238.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.06 0 0.0
1 182.73 0 0.0
1 238.21 0 0.0
BUS
55
400.0 MW
GENERATOR 1
530.89
0.0
TO
11
1 109.18 0 0.0
TO
33
1 183.32 0 0.0
TO
44
1 238.39 0 0.0
Pout Records
Bus Flows
BUS
11
400.0 MW
GENERATOR 1
180.00
0.0
TO
22
1 252.19 0 0.0
TO
33
1 37.11 0 0.0
TO
55
1 -109.30 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -252.19 0 0.0
1 -137.81 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.79 0
1 -138.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.11 0 0.0
1 -182.89 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.27 0
1 -182.73 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
101.00
1 137.81 0
1 -238.81 0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.21 0
1 -238.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
531.00
0.0
1 109.30 0 0.0
1 182.89 0 0.0
1 238.81 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.06 0 0.0
1 182.73 0 0.0
1 238.21 0 0.0
0.0
0.0
Pout Records
Bus Flows
BUS
11
400.0 MW
GENERATOR 1
180.00
0.0
TO
22
1 251.98 0 0.0
TO
33
1 37.30 0 0.0
TO
55
1 -109.29 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.44
1 -251.98 0 0.0
1 -138.46 0 0.0
BUS
22
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
44
400.0 MW
390.00
1 -251.79 0
1 -138.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.37
1 -37.30 0 0.0
1 -183.07 0 0.0
BUS
33
LOAD 1
TO
11
TO
55
400.0 MW
220.00
1 -37.27 0
1 -182.73 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.19
1 138.46 0 0.0
1 -238.65 0 0.0
BUS
44
LOAD 1
TO
22
TO
55
400.0 MW
100.00
1 138.21 0
1 -238.21 0
0.0
0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
531.00
0.0
1 109.29 0 0.0
1 183.07 0 0.0
1 238.65 0 0.0
BUS
55
GENERATOR
TO
11
TO
33
TO
44
400.0 MW
530.00
0.0
1 109.06 0 0.0
1 182.73 0 0.0
1 238.21 0 0.0
Node/b Bus 2
us 1
Line
1-2
1-3
Bus 3
Bus 4
Bus 5
0.280
0.463
0.000
0.073
0.184
0.145
0.000
0.727
0.000
0.128
0.000
0.253
0.114
0.104
0.528
0.012
0.437
0.127
0.000
0.424
0.015
0.105
0.350
0.043
0.487
0.008
0.289
0.084
0.127
0.493
1-5
2-4
3-5
4-5
0.5
0.45
0.4
0.35
0.3
0.25
peak case
0.2
earlier case
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
Node/bus 1
Bus 2
Bus 3
Bus 4
Bus 5
300
250
200
peak case
earlier case
150
100
50
0
Node/bus 1
Bus 2
Bus 3
Bus 4
Bus 5
Earlier
cost
allocated
to node
Peak
%
scenario change
cost
Earlier
cost/
Lakh/MW
/month
MP
Earlier
cost/
Lakh/MW/
month
MP+UC
Peak
Scenario
cost/
Lakh/MW/mo
nth
75
61
18.66
3.47
4.62
2.82
185
218
17.83
5.93
5.85
4.66
162
157
3.08
6.14
5.95
5.94
70
51
27.14
5.83
5.79
4.25
311
316
1.61
6.48
6.13
4.97
While the load at bus 2 had increased 1.5 times the total cost allocated to the node
has increased only 1.18 times( 1.19 for MP+UC)
cost/MW/Month will go down (as MW increased). New entrants/ST customers incentivized
Charges allocated to a node will change only if due to it flow in different lines change.
Otherwise the charge may remain same under peak scenario also. May also reduce.
TABLE 2
DIC
Withdrawal/Load
PoC Charges
Scaled PoC
Charges
45,79,42,697
50,45,52,461
18,96,39,554
20,89,41215
TABLE 3
Zone
Uniform Charges
(UC)\(Rs./Month)=Unifo
rm Rate*LTA
Scaled PoC
Charges
Rs/Month
50% UC and
50% PoC
Rs./Month
25,22,12,087
1,41,822
16,44,90,088
1,07,280
LTA (MW)
Withdrawal
Charges
(Rs/MW/Month)
TABLE- 4
LTA
(MW)
Slab Rate
(Rs/MW/Month)
Actual Usage
(Rs/ Month)
Payment
(Rs/ Month)
DIC
Drawal
(MW)
4989
2668
1,09,544
1414
1741
1,09,544
18,96,39,554 19,07,16,104
Variation
0.56%
TABLE-5
Load
PoC
(Rs./MW
/Month)
Zone
Generation
(MW)
Load
(MW)
Generation
Charges
(Rs.)
Load
Charges
(MW)
LTA
(Generation)
(MW)
LTA
(Demand)
(MW)
Generation
PoC
(Rs./MW/
Month)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
194
29
29160
16,64,638
2,160,51,386
280
4784
5945
45166
TABLE-6
Zone
Generation
PoC
(Rs./MW/
Month)
Load
PoC
(Rs./MW
/Month)
Software Computed
8,594
74,229
Generation
PoC
(Rs./MW/
Month)
Load
PoC
(Rs./MW
/Month)
LTA Based
5,945
45,166
Generation
PoC
(Rs./MW/
Month)
Load
PoC
(Rs./MW/
Month)
50,547
72,154
Generation
PoC
(Rs./MW/
Month)
Load
PoC
(Rs./M
W/Mo
nth)
After Slabs
79,544
79,544
TABLE-7
Sl.No.
State /DIC
% Allocation
BIHAR
42.89%
JHARKHAND
8.13%
DVC
0.31%
ODISHA
WEST BENGAL
SIKKIM
2.4
TAMIL NADU
0.85%
NER
3.22%
TABLE-8
Sl.No.
State /DIC
ODISHA
82.97
DVC
12.1
WEST BENGAL
4.93
Thank you