Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
11291139, 1999
Cambridge University Press
' 1999 Association for Child Psychology and Psychiatry
Printed in Great Britain. All rights reserved
00219630}99 $15.000.00
Introduction
The term Idiot-Savants was first used by Langdon
Down in 1887 to describe the concurrence in some
individuals of low general cognitive functioning together
with an above-average specific ability. Such people
appear to be able to use processing strategies within a
particular domain that seems to be independent of their
general level of intelligence. For nearly 200 years such
savants have been noted but in the past reports have
mostly been in the form of descriptive case histories. In
1983 OConnor and Hermelin began a series of systematic
and controlled experimental studies with groups of
musical, calculating, and artistic savants. Subsequently
Hermelin, Pring, and their colleagues have attempted to
account for the marked frequency of individuals with
autism in the savant population (Heaton, Hermelin, &
Pring, 1998 ; Heaton, Pring, & Hermelin, in press ;
Heavey, Pring, & Hermelin, 1999 ; Pring, Hermelin, &
Heavey, 1995).
In discussing the characteristics of the outstandingly
gifted savant artist Stephen Wiltshire, Sacks (1995) posed
the question whether one could speak of a distinctive
autistic art . He points to the concreteness, detailed
perceptual accuracy, and to what he calls the thisness
in the drawings of this talented individual. He observes
that individual savant drawings also often show a
repetitive preoccupation with particular themes, in
Stephens case with cars and buildings. In an assessment
of this savants progress in art school (Pring & Hermelin,
1997) we have drawn attention to his exceptional ability
to depict space and distance in perspective. Such a
remarkable focusing on perceptual details of a display
Requests for reprints to : Beate Hermelin, Psychology Department, Goldsmiths College, University of London, New
Cross, London, SE14 6NW, U.K.
1129
1130
B. HERMELIN et al.
1131
Method
The method adopted here was to compare Richards
paintings with the photographs from which they were derived,
in order to describe and evaluate some of the changes these
showed when produced from memory. We are of course aware
of the inherent methodological shortcomings that such a
qualitative evaluation entails. Nevertheless, it is widely and
almost exclusively used to determine the outcome of
examinations at art academies and colleges, and no alternative
objective or quantifiable method for scoring pictures has as yet
been devised. The present single case study must thus be
regarded as a pilot project, which will serve to refine future
procedures analogous to those used widely in the psychology of
music. Although music appears to have a firmer, more specified
grammatical structure than seems to be the case for the
visual arts, dimensions such as veridity, composition, colour,
and perspective drawing, as well as inventiveness, may be
isolated and quantified in future investigations.
As for the study of Stephen Wiltshires progress in art school
(Pring & Hermelin, 1997), the evaluation of Richards work was
carried out by our collaborator Michael Buhler, a painter
himself as well as a qualified art expert and an experienced
teacher at the Guilds of London Art School. He has never met
Richard but was provided with copies of his pictures as well as
with the initial photographs on which these were based. These
photographs had been identified for us by Richard himself, and
thus provided us with the opportunity for a direct comparison.
One question we asked was whether a true artistic talent, here
defined as an inherent high-level ability for picture production,
was evident. We also attempted to specify the transformations
in the perceptual and}or memory schemata in regard to
compositional and structural features such as simplifications of
form, omissions or additions of details, and changes in distance
and perspective. Special attention was paid to colour and light
rendering leading to changes of the overall mood conveyed
by a painting in contrast to the original colour photograph.
Such a mood transformation, as defined by Michael Buhler,
signifies a personal intention of the individual painter through
the object matter of a picture (Pring & Hermelin, 1997). It thus
contrasts how something is drawn or painted with what
the objects are that the picture represents.
Results
General Assessment
To the question of whether Richards paintings indicated a true artistic talent, here defined as an apparently
1132
B. HERMELIN et al.
A.
B.
A.
B.
1133
1134
B. HERMELIN et al.
A.
B.
1135
A.
B.
tional picturesque object matter. There is nothing threatening in his representations. Richards landscape scenes
of snowy mountain peaks against blue skies, rippling
lakes, and meadows full of flowers were judged as very
different from much of the 18th and 19th century
Romantic art that depicts the awesome grandeur and
power of nature. Richard focuses on light, colour, and
space, and can conjure up very subtle effects of atmos-
1136
A.
B.
B. HERMELIN et al.
1137
Discussion
As far as we are aware, there has been up to now no
report of a pictorial artist who suffers not only from
marked cognitive developmental disabilities, but also
from a severe congenital impairment of visual perception.
To the puzzling question of why somebody born with
such multiple handicaps should have shown from early
childhood a preoccupation with and a gift for producing
pictures, we can at present offer no definite answer.
There seems to be, in this case, no obvious genetic or environmental factors to account for such a predisposition.
Richard not only has an inherent artistic talent but also a
diagnosis of autism. Obsessive preoccupations and a
small repertoire of interests and activities are typical for
autistic individuals, and might well have contributed to
the development of his artistic skill. Whatever his initial
motivation, his talent is not only functioning independently from his general cognitive ability and his autism,
1138
B. HERMELIN et al.
References
Bartlett, F. C. (1932). Remembering : A study in experimental
and social psychology. Cambridge : Cambridge University
Press.
Frith, U., & Happe! , F. G. E. (1994). Autism : Beyond theory
of mind . Cognition, 50, 115132.
Happe! , F. G. E. (1994). Wechsler IQ profile and theory of mind
in autism : A research note. Journal of Child Psychology and
Psychiatry, 35, 14611471.
Heaton, P., Hermelin, B., & Pring, L. (1998). Autism and pitch
processing : A precursor for savant musical ability ? Music
Perception, 15, 291305.
Heaton, P., Pring, L., & Hermelin, B. (in press). A pseudosavant : A case of exceptional musical splinter skills. Neurocase.
Heavey, L., Pring, L., & Hermelin, B. (1999). A date to
remember : The nature of memory in savant calendrical
calculators. Psychological Medicine, 29, 145160.
Hermelin, B., & OConnor, N. (1983). The idiot-savant : Flawed
genius or clever Hans ? Psychological Medicine, 13, 479481.
1139