Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
PREVIOUS RESEARCH
2.1
Introduction to Rockbolting
Rockbolts are now the primary means of roof support in modern underground mining,
replacing timber prop and crib methods. This has been attributed to the increased safety
and productivity gained in their use (Peng and Tang, 1984).
Brady and Brown (1985) identified four objectives for the application of rockbolting in
the mining industry, these being:
Rockbolting is not limited to soft rock roof support, but also rib support in coal mining,
and drive support in hard rock mining.
-3-
2.1.1
Types of Rockbolts
While there are ma ny different rockbolts currently on the market, all can be classified
based on the length of anchorage used. These are:
Point anchorage
Full-length anchorage
Anchor
Point
Type
Anchorage Method
Comments
Hard
Primitive method
Expansion Shell
Medium
Common in USA
Resin Cartridge
Cementitous
Soft
cementitous)
Full-length
Suitable Strata
Weak
Swellex
Hard Rock
-4-
2.1.1.1
Point-anchored Rockbolts
technology, the use of resin rather than cementitous or mechanical anchorage has been
favoured where appropriate.
The two families of point-anchored support systems are mechanical and grouted
anchorage.
2.1.1.1.1
Mechanical Anchorage
This anchorage system relies on the development of physical interlock between the
rockbolt and the surrounding rock. Rockbolts using this system are slot and wedge
rockbolts, or more commonly, the expansion shell rockbolt.
-5-
High contact stresses are generated between the shell and the rock, limiting application
to strata with uniaxial compressive strengths of greater than 50MPa. If used in weaker
rocks, localised fracturing may occur about the anchorage, lessening mechanical
interlock and resulting in decreased anchor strength (Wagner, 1997).
2.1.1.1.2
Grouted Anchorage
Grouted anchorage systems substitute a resin or cementitous grout for the mechanical
anchor, bonding the rockbolt to the rock. This system provides higher load capacity and
the grout encapsulation length can be adjusted according to in situ conditions (Peng and
Tang, 1984).
2.1.1.2
Disadvantages:
o High contact stresses at anchorage and borehole collar, that can lead to
localised fracturing and reduction in tendon tension
o Mechanical anchor and tendon susceptible to corrosion
o Resistance to shear displacement of strata limited
o Anchorage reliant on presence of competent rock horizon
o Failure of point anchorage which then leads to total loss of load bearing
capacity of rockbolt
-6-
2.1.1.3
Full-length anchored rockbolts have continuous contact, either directly or via grout,
with the borehole along the full length of the rockbolt. The mechanism of anchorage is
distinct to that of point-anchored rockbolts, and developments in resin technology have
advanced their use throughout the mining industry.
2.1.1.3.1
Friction Rockbolts
Split Sets
Consist of a hollow steel tube slotted along the entire length and tapered at one end.
The tube is forced into the borehole, this being of a slightly smaller diameter than that
of the expanded tube. The tube then acts to generate a radial force onto the borehole
wall. Frictional resistance acts along the length of the tube, as shown in Figure 2.
Swellex
These operate on the same frictional model as the split set, but the tube is placed into a
slightly larger borehole and water is pumped in to pressurise and expand the tube,
forcing the tube against the borehole. This provides immediate support, and unlike
split-set rockbolts, relies on hydraulic rather than physical energy for installation.
-7-
However, susceptibility to corrosion and a small capacity for deformation limit Swellex
rockbolts to hard rock conditions.
2.1.1.3.2
Grouted Rockbolts
For this method, the rockbolt is grouted into the borehole with either a cementitous or
two-part resin grout, providing continuous contact between the encapsulated rockbolt
and the borehole surface.
Grouted rockbolts may be characterised into one of three groups (Peng and Tang,
1984):
Untensioned
Pretensioned
Post-tensioned
Untensioned grouted rockbolts are most commonly used, as the time saved over
installation of tensioned rockbolts outweighs the minimal support benefits gained
through the tensioning process (Haas, 1975; Nitzche, 1976).
Cementitous grout has high strength and elastic modulus, but requires time to reach full
strength.
-8-
Polyester resin grout is suited to soft and weak rocks, where high strength and rapid
curing times are required. The resin is usually supplied in cartridge form, with the
action of the spinning rockbolt rupturing the plastic wrapping and mixing the resin
mastic and catalyst.
-9-
2.2
Rockbolt Mechanics
This section details the mechanisms of interaction between rockbolt, resin and rockmass
that govern performance. The principle objective of support systems is to provide
support to the rockmass itself, and this depends on (Bieniawski, 1987):
2.2.1
Support Mechanisms
The support mechanisms through which rockbolting systems achieve strata control can
be summarised as follows (Whitaker, 1998):
Pinning
- 10 -
2.2.1.1
Thin strata layers in the immediate roof can be supported through suspension by
rockbolts anchored in a stable strata horizon, such as an overlying massive strata, or
stiffer stratum, as shown in Figure 4.
Stable Horizon
Supporting Tendons
Figure 4: Cross-Section of Drive, suspension of thin roof slab shown (Wagner, 1997)
Design of a support system through the suspension mechanism must consider the
following factors (Wagner, 1997):
Rockbolt anchorage load capacity must be greater than the weight of the roof
layer to be supported
- 11 -
2.2.1.2
Beam Building
Beam building theory is applied where the strata are thinly laminated and a competent
layer is out of practical rockbolting range. By clamping together through rockbolting
these layers, multiple beams then become a single beam. This thick beam provides
increased effective stiffness and strength, as shown in Figure 5:
Laminated Stratum
When the beam deflects, compression occurs in the upper layers, and tension in the
immediate roof layers. This results in differential movement between layers, thus
generating frictional shearing. Resistance to this mechanism is through the following:
- 12 -
Panek (1956) applied beam mechanics to this mechanism, determining stresses in terms
of bending stress, x, and shearing stress, xy, at any point of the beam. The normal and
shear stress components are shown in Equation 1and Equation 2.
( x )max = wL
2t
( )max = 3wL
xy
where:
w
As the roof span increases, tension cracks appear mid-span on the base of the beam and
near the ends of the beam of the top. Propagation of these cracks leads to failure. The
maximum displacement of the beam, , is determined with Equation 3.
wL4
32Et 2
Equation 3: Maximum Displacement of Beam
where:
E
= Youngs modulus
- 13 -
2.2.1.3
Voussoir Arch
In addition to rockbolts, cable bolts are also used to maximise support effectiveness, and
to increase the scope of the compressive arch. In blocky ground, shotcrete and mesh
can also be used to bind the surface together. It should be noted that this mechanism is
rarely encountered in soft rock mining, though jointing in stratum is possible.
Compression Zone
Wright (1973) discussed the Voussoir arch, explaining that the blocks in the immediate
roof become self-supporting, with load transferred to the walls of the opening. Thus,
load is distributed around the opening as an arch. Wright also explained how a cracked
mine roof will unload, and within the rock a distributed load arch will form. Hence, the
Voussoir arch method aims to enhance the natural load distribution arching effect.
- 14 -
2.2.1.4
Keying of Blocks
Keying of blocks is a secondary support measure, where spot bolting is carried out to
prevent perceived possible failure of unstable rock wedges and blocks. Examples of
conditions where keying is appropriate include zones of localised roof failure, in a
jointed rockmass and in locations where rib spall is likely (Whitaker, 1998). W-straps
and mesh can also be used to prevent roof surface movement.
- 15 -
2.2.2
Anchorage Mechanisms
2.2.2.1
Point-anchored Rockbolts
Also, often the rockbolt will be acting through different strata layers, each with
individual mechanical properties and stress conditions.
Unlike resin-encapsulated
rockbolts, individual stratum stresses will load cumulatively along the entire length of
the rockbolt. The non-encapsulated portion of the rockbolt carries the load generated
between the anchor and the collar, and the total tensile capacity of the rockbolt may
never be achieved.
Thus, the performance of the system relies of the performance of the anchor and collar,
which must transfer loading onto the tendon, while localised contact stresses acting at
these points can lessen this performance. This is why FERB will perform better than
point-anchored rockbolts. Also, in situations where shearing between strata occurs,
considerable displacement will occur before the rockbolt can provide restraint, due to
the absence of a grout between the tendon and the rock (Eaton, 1993).
- 16 -
2.2.2.1.1
FB
Figure 7: Mechanically Point-anchored Rockbolt Anchorage Mechanism (Wagner, 1997)
- 17 -
The relationship between anchorage and axial forces can be represented thus:
FH = FB
Equation 4: Relationship between anchorage and axial forces
where:
FH
= anchorage force
FB
= axial force
- 18 -
2.2.2.1.2
In the case of resin or cementitous grout anchorage, the anchorage force, FH, is
proportional to the encapsulation length (Wagner, 1996). This relationship can be
expressed as:
FH = LE
Equation 5: Relationship between anchorage force and encapsulation length
where:
FH
= anchorage force
LE
- 19 -
Thus, as strata separation occurs, a cumulative axial load will be placed on the unencapsulated tendon. This axial load will then diminish to zero at the top of the tendon,
through load transfer mechanisms. Cumulative load can be measured at the borehole
collar. This is illustrated in Figure 10.
- 20 -
2.2.2.2
The main failing of point-anchored rockbolts is that system capacity is often dependent
on the performance of that anchorage point. Thus, while full load capacity for the
tendon may not be reached, the system may fail through anchor failure, or the rock
surrounding the anchor may fail through excessive contact stresses.
Figure 11: Comparison between Support Capacity of Fully Encapsulated and Point-anchored
Rockbolts
- 21 -
2.2.3
2.2.3.1
Loading Conditions
Weight-controlled Loading
The weight of the rock to be supported drives this condition. The rockbolts support the
rock by countering this weight, using the suspension support mechanism. Both pointanchored mechanical and resin-encapsulated rockbolts can be used in this condition.
2.2.3.2
Displacement-controlled Loading
The driving component of this condition is deformation and buckling of strata layers
along bedding planes.
Fully
encapsulated rockbolts are more effective than point-anchored rockbolts, as they act to
clamp layers together, as well as providing shear resistance.
- 22 -
2.3
2.3.1
Components of FERB
The widespread use of FERB has given the mining industry improved control over
strata conditions, increased safety and production, improved ventilation and reduced
costs (Peng and Tang, 1984).
Tendon
Resin
2.3.1.1
Tendon
From an operations perspective, the tendon should be of low cost, as well as easy to
transport, store and install. The tendon itself dominates the performance of the support
system. Mechanical properties, relative dimensions and geometry all contribute greatly,
and variations within these factors will alter performance considerably.
2.3.1.1.1
Mechanical Properties
The mechanical properties of the tendon must be adequate for the loading conditions
expected. That is, the tendon must be able to withstand the stresses placed upon it by
the surrounding strata (Eaton, 1993).
- 23 -
Typical mechanical characteristics of rockbolt steel are shown in Figure 12, with points
of interest labelled.
Figure 12: Typical Stress/Strain Relationship for Rockbolt Steels (SCT, 1996)
where:
R
= Elastic Strain
= Yield Point
= Ultimate Strength
= Breaking Strength
= Breaking Strain
Yield Strength
Yield strength is the stress at which the tendon no longer will behave elastically, and
after which plastic behaviour occurs. That is, beyond this strength, deformation will
proceed with little additional loading.
Elastic Modulus
The elastic modulus of steel used for rockbolt tendons is commonly 200-220 GPa.
- 24 -
Ultimate Strength
This is the peak stress, after which failure of the bar begins through necking, which
sheds load and lowers stress.
Breaking Strength
This follows tendon failure through necking, and precedes the rapid, physical failure.
Thus, it is the stress after which the tendon physically fails, through applied load and
deformation.
Elongation
Measured at peak load, this allows determination of available elongation of the tendon,
after which the failure process begins.
Rockbolt manufacturers commonly offer a variety of steel strengths for each tendon
design. Table 2 details those offered in Australia, by Celtite and DSI Arnall, formerly
ANI Arnall (Celtite, 1999; ANI Arnall, 1995).
Table 2: Yield and Ultimate Strengths for a range of Rockbolt steel grades (ANI Arnall, 1995;
Celtite, 1999)
Company
Celtite
ANI Arnall
Strength (kN)
Load Point
Standard Grade
High Grade
Yield
125
182
220
Ultimate
174
302
344
Yield
110
145
220
Ultimate
165
230
310
- 25 -
2.3.1.1.2
Tendon Diameter
Tendons are available in various diameters, ranging between 18-24mm. This diameter
is the maximum measured across the tendon cross-section. An equivalent diameter is
taken from the maximum measure less the height of the deformation on the surface.
2.3.1.1.3
Tendon Profile
The tendon profile, or deformation pattern, is designed to increase resin mixing abilities
and adherence between resin and rockbolt. While there are many designs available
within the industry, most are based on a helical ridging, allowing this deformation to be
a continuation of the rolling process.
2.3.1.1.4
Tendon Length
Tendon length is governed by the strata into which the tendon is placed, as well as the
dimensions of the roadway. While the location within the roof of a stable anchorage
stratum determines the optimum tendon length, this being the length required to reach
that stratum, the dimensions of the roadway will govern the maximum possible length
of tendon that can be inserted.
Unfavourable roadway dimensions can be mitigated through the use of coupled drill
rods and rockbolts.
- 26 -
2.3.1.1.5
Tendon Thread
The design of the threaded end of the tendon is vital, as it governs the installation
process. Current standard is a torque nut, with either plastic resin insert or pin, fitted to
the threaded lower end of the tendon. This allows rotation of the tendon into the hole
for resin mixing. After sufficient time for the resin to set, this nut then has additional
torque applied, which allows the insert or pin to break out, and the nut is tightened up
the thread to the collar.
Advantages
Disadvantages
Forged Head
Simple
No tensioning possible
running
change of dollies
damage to threads
Resin/Plastic
Plug
on end of rockbolt
debris in dolly
Bulbed Bolt
on end of rockbolt
rolling of bolt
rockbolt
in dolly
Standard nut
Drive Square
Crimped Nut
Crimped Washer
Shear Pin
2.3.1.2
Bearing Plate
The bearing plate acts to contain the rock surface surrounding the borehole collar,
providing a large, stable surface for the rockbolt to act against. Most bearing plate
designs include alignment correction mechanisms to compensate for non-perpendicular
installation.
- 27 -
2.3.1.3
Resin
The primary grouting system for FERB (Eaton, 1993) is resin. This is considered
superior in performance to cementitous grouts as it gives a better anchorage for many
rock types with a shorter setting time.
polyester resin cartridges were readily adopted by mines, as fast curing times shortened
the installation cycle time.
The design of these cartridges has remained basically the same. However, advances in
resin technology have resulted in increased strength and elasticity, while curing times
have reduced.
A resin cartridge is shaped like a sausage and contains two compartments. The outer
compartment contains the resin mastic, and the inner compartment contains the catalyst.
During installation the cartridge is pushed into the hole, the plastic wrapping is pierced
and shredded by the spinning rockbolt, thus allowing mixing between the mastic and
catalyst. These react to form a hardened resin that bonds the rock to the rockbolt.
The mastic contains polyester polymer and styrene monomer, which react with the
introduction of the benzoyl peroxide catalyst. It also contains up to 75% by volume of
inert powdered limestone filler, which prevents shrinkage during setting, as well as
small amounts or accelerator and inhibitor compounds, which regulate the gel time
and maintain homogeny of the filler.
- 28 -
The resin should have the following properties (ANI Arnall, 1995).
Resistance to degradation
A typical cured resin will display the following physical properties (ANI Arnall, 1995):
Compressive Strength:
60-80MPa
Tensile Strength:
15-20MPa
Youngs Modulus:
6-8GPa
- 29 -
2.3.2
Until the early 1990s, support systems were designed to form reinforced rock beams in
the roof strata, using pre-tensioned rockbolts to hold the strata layers together, thus
stiffening the rock and minimising sag. However, advances in rockbolt monitoring
have confirmed that differing rock strata often behave as discrete units (Eaton, 1993;
Gale, 1998).
While rock strength has been shown to increase with the application of active confining
forces, through the use of pre- or post-tensioning of rockbolts, the confinement offered
by any rockbolting system offers negligible measurable strength increase. Rockbolts
are thus a passive system, activated in response to strata dilation of any orientation
(Serbousek and Signer, 1987).
Post failure strength of rock can be increased with the application of relatively small
confinement forces. Rockbolts can generate this confinement after rock movement,
activating against small deformations and preventing significant further deformation.
Thus, FERB improves the load capacity of failing stratum by acting to clamp together
shear planes and cracks within the rock (Gale, 1998). In addition, as a FERB can
transfer its full load capacity at multiple locations along the rockbolt, a system can
actively contain failure at multiple strata horizons (Gray et al, 1998).
- 30 -
- 31 -
2.3.3
This
2.3.3.1
Axial restraint
The mechanism by which a rockbolt resists axial loading is shown in Figure 14. As
strata layers separate along a parting, shear forces are generated within the resin, acting
in turn on the tendon (Gale, 1998). This mechanism is driven by adhesion and/or
mechanical interlock within the resin (Signer, 1990).
- 32 -
2.3.3.1.1
Adhesion
Adhesion is the result of chemical bonding between the borehole surface, grout and
tendon surface. While in the past it has been accepted that adhesion was the primary
factor in the shear resistance mechanism (Signer, 1990), recent testing (SCT, 1996) has
suggested that peak load is generated after up to 2mm of movement of the tendon
relative to the borehole.
Displacement of this magnitude would result in resin failure through shear. Thus,
adhesion cannot be considered the major factor in load generation.
2.3.3.1.2
Mechanical Interlock
Mechanical interlock is the result of keying of resin into surface irregularities on the
tendon and borehole. Irregularities in the borehole surface are the result of lithological
variation and the action of the drill bit. Rockbolt profiles are designed to provide an
irregular surface.
Load is transferred
through the rockbolt surface, resin and borehole surface through contact surfaces
(Signer, 1990). When loaded, stress concentrations occur at points of irregularity,
potentially exceeding the strength of the resin or rock, and resulting in failure and
further deflection of the tendon.
The minimum length of encapsulation required for transfer of maximum possible load
from rock to rockbolt is termed the anchorage length (Signer, 1990).
- 33 -
2.3.3.2
Shear Resistance
A FERB provides excellent resistance to sliding between roof strata layers. For a
parting to shear, the tendon and grout have to be deformed through bending, so that the
resistance of the tendon to bending governs resistance of the system to strata slippage
(Gale, 1998). This is shown in Figure 15.
Factors that influence rockbolt shear resistance effectiveness include (Wagner, 1997):
Tendon diameter
Rockmass characteristics
Resin characteristics
- 34 -
2.3.3.3
Axial failure of a FERB can occur though failure of the tendon, grout, or rock, or by
failure of the interfaces between these components.
2.3.3.3.1
Tendon Failure
Provided anchorage length is sufficient, the full support capacity of the steel tendon can
be reached, after which the required support load exceeds the ultimate strength of the
steel, which then fails. This failure can be corrected through either design, by altering
support density or pattern, or by the use of a higher capacity tendon, either
metallurgically or physically.
2.3.3.3.2
Resin Failure
The resin may fail due to the proximity of the ductile steel tendon, whose deformation
places the resin in tension. As the resin is weak in tension, plastic deformation and
failure will occur. Alternatively, the length of resin encapsulation may be insufficient to
support the required load.
This failure can be minimised through optimising support efficiency, to reduce large
deformations and thus minimise tension loads on the resin.
2.3.3.3.3
Rock Failure
The loading of the tendon also places the rock in tension, which may cause plastic
deformation and eventually exceed the tensile strength of the rock. Again, this failure
may be prevented through support optimisation, to reduce deformation and minimise
tensional loading.
- 35 -
2.3.3.3.4
Interface Failure
The shear stresses present at the tendon/resin interface are often of a greater magnitude
than those at the resin/rock interface, as the radial forces act on a smaller surface area.
Failure on the tendon/resin interface is possible if the resin and rock are of similar
physical properties and the anchorage length is insufficient, as the shear stresses acting
on this interface are greater. However, in soft rocks, the strength of the rock is often
less than that of the resin, and failure will then occur at the resin/rock interface.
2.3.3.4
In situ loading
While these failure modes are valid for ideal installation conditions, which are possible
in the laboratory, they are seldom found in the field. In practice, the following factors
may influence the failure mode (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998):
Loss of resin into partings and voids in strata, thus lessening volume available
for bonding
Glove Fingering, where portions of the resin cartridge plastic wrapping are not
shredded during installation, and instead act to prevent bonding between tendon
and rock
- 36 -
2.3.4
2.3.4.1
Introduction
Factors influencing the performance of load transfer in FERB are grouped here as
properties of each component of the system, as well as factors arising from installation
techniques.
Tendon properties
Grout properties
Rock Properties
Installation Factors
2.3.4.2
Tendon Properties
Critical tendon properties include design of deformation profile, behaviour under load,
tendon diameter to borehole ratio and surface finish. There has been little published
research into these key properties even though these variables can be engineered for
specific geotechnical conditions.
2.3.4.2.1
The profile of the tendon deformations creates an irregular surface for grout adhesion,
and drives the frictional control mechanism, by which radial forces are generated in
response to axial loading, applying confinement to the resin annulus.
Thus, the
There have been few published studies on the role of deformation profile design in load
transfer, as much of this research is done in-house by manufacturers and kept
confidential with little information released in the public domain. As a result, while
tendon manufacturers may have greatly advanced technology, the mining industry has a
knowledge deficiency, resulting in empirical rather than scientifically optimised support
systems.
- 37 -
2.3.4.2.2
The diameter of the tendon in relation to the borehole sizing governs the size of the
grout annulus. Commercial tendons are supplied with core diameters ranging 5% of
the specified value (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998).
Peel (2001) found that small variations in annulus thickness could slightly alter support
capacity, while large annuli (+5mm) exhibit substantially reduced capacity. Thus, if a
support system is designed for a certain annulus thickness, installation of tendons with
smaller than specified cores will result in reduced capacity support. If the designed
annulus thickness is 5mm or greater, this can result in dramatic reductions in support
capacity.
2.3.4.2.3
As axial load is applied to a tendon, the diameter of that tendon reduces. Thus, during
loading the deformations, which act to provide confining force against the grout, are
actually moving away from that grout.
effective resin annulus thickness is increased (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998). Once the tendon
yields, this reduction is intensified, as the tendon proceeds to failure.
The magnitude of this reduction can be minimised metallurgically, through the selection
of steel tendons with higher yield strength.
2.3.4.2.4
Elongation Characteristics
- 38 -
However, after yielding has occurred, the full length of the tendon experiences
diametric reduction at an increased rate. This acts to reduce the confinement offered by
the deformation profile. Once ultimate strength has been reached, localised necking of
the tendon occurs, which releases all confinement around that point.
Figure 16: Elongation and profile characteristics during loading (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998)
- 39 -
2.3.4.2.5
Surface Finish
The surface finish of the tendon can affect the strength of bonding between grout and
tendon, and therefore the load transfer characteristics of the support system. Rusting
and pitting alter this finish, as does the presence of contaminants such as grease, oil and
dust.
Figure 17: Effect of surface finish on load transfer performance (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998)
- 40 -
Figure 18 compares initial load transfer performance between a rusted rockbolt, a clean
rockbolt and a clean rockbolt previously rusted. The increase in loading for the rusted
rockbolts was attributed to an increase in adhesion between resin and surface pitting.
Thus, a rusted surface performs better than a clean surface during initial loading.
However, once sufficient load is applied, this advantage is lost.
Figure 18: Effect of Rusted Tendon Surface on Initial Load Transfer Performance (SCT, 1996)
2.3.4.2.6
Quality Control
Installing warped
rockbolts will result in poor resin mixing and varying annulus thickness, giving reduced
anchorage strength.
Poor storage may allow the tendon to come into contact with lubricants, chemicals and
water, and result in altered surface characteristics, corrosion and rusting.
strength characteristics are reduced.
Hence,
- 41 -
2.3.4.3
Resin Properties
The performance of the resin with the borehole surface or tendon is critical to the
system performance. Properties that may influence this performance include physical
properties, confinement properties and the annulus thickness.
2.3.4.3.1
Resin Performance
Maximising load transfer of a support system requires the following resin properties
(Eaton, 1993):
Resin strength greater than strata, allowing transfer of stresses to tendon during
strata dilation, rather than failure
High compressive modulus, allowing stress transfer from resin to tendon before
significant strata movement occurs
Eaton (1993) compared the load-transfer characteristics of low and high performance
resin, keeping other elements of the support system identical. It was found, as shown in
Figure 19, that the high performance Celtite AT resin was effective in resisting strata
deformation, by keeping total deformation to 10mm, while the low performance resin
experienced 50mm total deformation.
- 42 -
2.3.4.3.2
Laboratory push tests carried out (Fabjanczyk et al, 1992) found that system
performance generally increased in response to increased resin stiffness. In addition, it
was found that the confined behaviour of the resin significantly affected the load
transfer of the support system.
Confinement is generated within the resin in response to the relative displacement of the
tendon. Radial forces, which act against the borehole surface, are generated. The
generation of these forces is related to the deformation profile of the tendon, as well as
the resin characteristics.
- 43 -
2.3.4.3.3
Resin Annulus
The size of the resin annulus is driven by economic and operational factors, such as drill
cycle times and volumes of resin used, as well as geotechnical factors. Eaton (1993)
advised that resin annulus should be minimised as the closer the tendon to the borehole
the more immediate the stress transfer within the system.
Gale (1990) found that for optimum performance, the annulus thickness should be
minimised to aid mixing during installation, and to improve load transfer between
tendon and rock through proximity. However, smaller annuli often contain air pockets,
formed on the tendon during the installation process.
Increased annuli resulting from larger boreholes display reduced shear stress capacity
(Fabjanczyk and Tarrant, 1992). Laboratory push tests found a 30% drop in the load
transfer capacity of a 22mm diameter tendon when the annulus was increased from
2.5mm to 3.5mm thickness. This downward trend is shown in Figure 20.
Figure 20: Effect of Hole Diameter on Load Transfer (Fabjanczyk and Tarrant, 1992)
- 44 -
Gerdeen et al (1977) suggested that larger boreholes would provide improved anchorage
due to a greater surface area to distribute shear forces.
diameter rockbolt in this borehole would result in a large annulus thickness, thus
lowering anchorage capacity. Therefore, in large boreholes, larger diameter rockbolts
must be used to ensure performance is optimal.
Optimum resin annulus can be defined as the minimum thickness that can be applied,
given operational constraints, viscosity requirements and the need for adequate mixing
of mastic and catalyst.
Peng and Tang (1983) found that the optimum annulus was 3.2mm, or 6.4mm
difference between tendon and borehole diameter. This optimum was true for that
experimental series, and may not be universal.
- 45 -
Peel (2001) conducted pullout tests of 21.7mm core diameter tendons anchored in a
variety of borehole sizes. Mix-and-pour resin was used in these experiments to avoid
anchorage inconsistencies due to the presence of cartridge wrapping. He found that
capacity was similar for annulus thicknesses of 2mm to 4mm, with a 25% capacity
reduction once annulus thickness reached 5mm. This reduction was attributed to an
alteration in the failure mechanism, with the resin playing a greater role.
These results are shown in Figure 21. While these results differed from those of
Fabjanczyk and Tarrant, it is likely this is due to different testing methods.
- 46 -
2.3.4.4
Rock Properties
The third component of a support system is the rock into which the tendon has been
grouted. The behaviour of the rock under load contributes greatly to the performance of
the support system as a whole.
Peng (1988) identifies rock types commonly associated with coal mining, in order of
decreasing strength, as:
Sandstone
Limestone
Sandy Shale
Shale
Clayey Shale
Clay
2.3.4.4.1
Physical Properties
Given that soft rock is largely heterogeneous, points of weakness often occur at many
points along the length of tendon. These variables include:
Lithology
Bedding planes
Presence of Water
Bedding planes in particular will affect support systems, as these are frequently of much
different strength to the surrounding stratum.
deform easily, leaving stronger stratum to carry this load. Thus, partings will cause load
redistribution, resulting in increased loading of stiff stratum and deformation of weak
stratum.
- 47 -
While a typical uniaxial strength of weak rock lies in the range of 20.8MPa to 48.2MPa,
the presence of water will greatly reduce this, into a range of 0.0MPa to 13.8MPa (Peng,
1994).
2.3.4.4.2
Weathering
Weak roof is especially susceptible to air weathering. Weathered roof surface rock will
fail between rockbolts, causing the roof beam to lose integrity. In addition, weathering
of the newly exposed rock will occur, furthering the failure process. This surface failure
can be controlled using straps or mesh, or avoided through the application of shotcrete.
2.3.4.4.3
The demonstrated strength of a resin anchorage is related to the strength of the rock and
volume of included resin, which governs the length of encapsulation formed along the
tendon. Franklin and Woodfield (1971) found that weaker rocks required more resin, or
greater encapsulation length, to achieve the same strength found in stronger rocks. A
longer length of encapsulation allows greater length of load distribution, reducing peak
load and thus not exceeding rock strength.
2.3.4.4.4
- 48 -
2.3.4.5
Installation Processes
In order for a support system to achieve full potential, the installation of the tendon
must follow the designed process. Resin and tendon manufacturers have developed
processes to ensure optimum installation. However, in an operational environment
these cannot always be replicated, resulting in incorrect installation and diminished
performance.
2.3.4.5.1
Borehole Quality
Roughness
Karabin and Bebevec (1978) investigated FERB performance against borehole quality.
Their study indicated that the bond between resin and borehole surface was purely
mechanical, with the deformation profile of the tendon and the irregular surface of the
borehole providing physical resistance to displacement. Hence, shearing across these
surfaces would precede shear failure of the system.
Field observations of boreholes concluded that the condition of the borehole surface
significantly affected the load transfer characteristics of a FERB support system.
Borehole
Roughness
19mm Tendon
25mm Tendon
25
28
32
38
32
38
Clean
56.0
36.6
32.3
75.2
59.7
Clean Wet
74.0
Dirty
69.1
56.4
66.3
Clean
38.5
18.1
15.9
27.5
37.8
10.4
Worked
Clean Wet
31.4
27.3
Smooth
Dirty
Cast Smooth
24.3
Random
Clean
116.2
178.8
Grooving
Dirty
89.9
90.9
86.4
109.6
189.8
87.7
As-drilled
Presence of Water
Dunham (1973) compared load transfer performance of rockbolts installed in dry and
water filled holes. He found similar average anchorage capacities for dry and wet
boreholes, and concluded that the effect of water is negligible.
Gray and Fabjanczyk (1992) suggested that the presence of water might reduce
anchorage capacity in clay rich rocks. The use of water flushing during drilling may
liberate clay particles from the rock, resulting in a thin film of clay depositing on the
borehole surface, which then would inhibit resin adhesion to that surface.
- 50 -
2.3.4.5.2
Resin Mixing
During installation, it is vital that manufacturer specified spinning and setting times are
adhered to. Over- or under-spinning will alter final characteristics, diminishing loadbearing capacity.
2.3.4.5.3
Glove Fingering
During installation, the rockbolt is spun to shred the plastic resin capsule between the
deformation profile and the borehole surface, and to mix the mastic with the catalyst.
Ideally, the plastic cartridge will be pushed to the top of the borehole.
If the installation is incorrect, the cartridge may not be shredded adequately. This then
may glove the tendon, preventing adhesion between grout, tendon or borehole
surface. This reduces the effective length of encapsulation, which in turn diminishes
load-bearing capacity.
- 51 -
2.4
Load Transfer
2.4.1
Introduction
efficiency of this load transfer mechanism. Thus, load transfer capacity is a measure of
the effectiveness of the system (Gray et al, 1998).
generates and sustains reinforcing force in the tendon as a result of strata deformation
(Fabjanczyk and Tarrant, 1992).
The FERB support system is comprised of three elements: the grouting material, the
surrounding rockmass and the tendon, including the faceplate and nut. When installed
this system initially provides passive support. That is, the support system is activated
once bedding planes within the rock separate, which places load onto the tendon, which
is then transferred along the length of the tendon and separation is resisted.
The FERB may provide support at a single point, such as a parting, or multiple points
along the grouted length. The manner of this load transfer distribution has led to
conflicting linear and exponential transfer theories.
Load transfer is defined as the change in load with respect to the distance along the
tendon, giving a load transfer rate (Serbousek and Signor, 1987). It has also been
stated as a measurement of peak shear stress capacity and system stiffness (Fabjanczyk
and Tarrant, 1992), where peak shear stress is the average shear stress over an
encapsulated length at the maximum applied load.
In these definitions, the support system fails when any of the components in the system
fail through shear or yield failure, due to the stresses generated by stratum separation.
The system will also fail if the rock/grout or grout/tendon interface shear strength is
exceeded. Shear stress capacity can be calculated using Equation 6.
- 52 -
F =
where:
F
= Shear stress
- 53 -
2.4.2
The load transfer mechanism ensures that load is distributed along a portion of the
tendon rather than acting at a point, or acting on the full length of encapsulation. Figure
22 details axial load distribution for successive levels of deformation as the working
face moves ahead of the supporting tendon. Load transfer can be measured as the rate
of loading, with superior support systems able to generate loads along small portions
with little deformation.
Figure 22: FERB axial force build-up about strata partings as face advances (Gale, 1990)
- 54 -
- 55 -
2.4.3
Mechanisms
FERB provides strata reinforcement through axial restraint and shear resistance. As the
focus of this research project is axial restraint, and as the facility would require
significant modification to allow study of shear resistance, axial restraint will be the
mechanism assumed to be acting during load transfer. This assumption is accurate as
the applied load is purely axial, with any shear force due to weight of the jack negated
once the jack bears against the face of the core.
2.4.3.1
The mechanism of load transfer in a FERB is driven by the behaviour of the support
system displacing under load relative to the resin and rock. Load transfer includes the
mechanisms of adhesion and mechanical interlock, which is the transferral of load
between tendon, resin and rock through contact surfaces (Signer, 1990).
It is accepted that load is transferred from rock to tendon by shear resistance of the
grout, but the nature of this resistance has not been proven. It is believed that shear
resistance is created through adhesion or mechanical interlock, or a combination of the
two (Signer, 1990).
loading, mechanical interlock is the primary means of transferral of shear force between
the support components.
2.4.3.2
The key components of the FERB are the tendon, grouting substance and the
surrounding rock. While the tendon is comprised of ductile, high strength and high
elasticity steel, the grout and resin are weaker, brittle materials of lower strength
(Serbousek and Signer, 1987).
- 56 -
These components acting together govern the performance of the FERB, with the
tendon absorbing load and deformation, thus preventing the tensional failure of the
grout and rock. As long as there is a sufficient length of encapsulation, the ultimate
capacity of the tendon can be reached (Serbousek and Signer, 1987).
This
Borehole smoothness
In order for optimal performance of the FERB to be achieved, the following conditions
are necessary (Gale, 1990):
Borehole surface free of particulate matter that may interfere with resin/rock
interface
- 57 -
2.4.4
Quantitative Measurement
Load transfer may be determined through the measurement of either the peak shear
stress sustainable on the tendon/resin or resin/rock interface, or the system stiffness, as
the rate of developed shear stress for a given displacement (SCT, 1996).
2.4.4.1
Peak shear stress is defined as the average stress over encapsulation at the maximum
applied force (Fabjanczyk, 1992), as shown here in Equation 7.
F
L
Equation 7: Peak Shear Stress
where:
= shear stress
- 58 -
Figure 23: Force distribution in FERB around strata dilation (SCT, 1996)
2.4.4.2
System Stiffness
Stiffness of the tendon/resin or resin/rock interface is the rate of shear stress generated
for a given strata displacement (Wagner, 1997), and is calculated using Equation 8.
k=
AE
l
Equation 8: System Stiffness
where:
k
= system stiffness
- 59 -
For a FERB, l is related to the strata displacement, and the shear strength of the
tendon/resin and resin/rock interfaces. Figure 24 illustrates the benefit of using FERB,
as a longer tendon length allows greater distribution of load transfer, resulting in a
reduction of generated forces (Wagner, 1997).
Figure 24: Effect of active rockbolt length on support resistance (Wagner, 1997)
- 60 -
2.4.4.3
FB =
ks
2l
Equation 9: Loading due to strata separation
where:
FB
= system stiffness
Figure 25: Forces generated around strata separation in FERB (Wagner, 19970
- 61 -
Figure 26 illustrates this, with a series of diagrams of load profiles along tendon lengths,
with the position of weaker stratum bands noted.
performance for good and poor load transfer systems is also made.
- 62 -
Figure 26: Comparison between good and poor load transfer in FERB (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998)
- 63 -
2.4.5
2.4.5.1
Exponential Distribution
As the use of FERB became widespread, rockbolt knowledge remained confined to pull
out tests, which provided details on load bearing capabilities of the support system but
very little on the mechanisms within that system. Pells (1974) observed that some
rockbolts failed at a very low overall rockbolt strain. He deduced that the rockbolt loads
were confined to a small distance on either side of the loading point. Thus, the rockbolt
was failing due to this concentration of strain. Subsequent testing indicated that the full
length of the rockbolt might not be experiencing full loading.
Farmer (1975) further investigated FERB stress distribution, deriving a theoretical stress
distribution model showing exponential decay along the rockbolt. This theory was built
around a finite slice through tendon, grout and rock, based on a boundary element
processes.
0.2 x
X
= 0.1
0
where:
x
- 64 -
Figure 27: Theoretical Stress Distribution of FERB in rigid socket with thin resin annulus
(Farmer, 1975)
Farmer then sought to validate this theory through laboratory testing to compare
experimental with theoretical stress distributions. The testing consisted of pullout tests
of strain-gauged tendons from cores of cement, limestone and chalk. Farmer found that
the experimental results were consistent with theoretical distributions up to a certain
high load. Above this load, it was found that debonding was occurring at the rock/grout
and resin/tendon interfaces. It was concluded that the theory was valid for elastic
loading of the system.
Figure 28 and Figure 29 show the theoretical behaviour (broken lines) and experimental
results (solid lines) for encapsulated lengths of 350mm and 500mm respectively. At
low loads, there is reasonable correlation between both sets of results, but as load
increases, this correlation is reduced. In addition, at high loads a greater portion of the
rockbolt experiences loading, rather than the small length predicted.
- 65 -
Figure 28: Theoretical and Experimental Stress Distribution - 350mm rockbolts (Farmer, 1975)
Figure 29: Theoretical and Experimental Stress Distribution - 500mm Rockbolts (Farmer, 1975)
- 66 -
A model was created using finite element methods assuming symmetry of stress
distribution into the immediate rock. This model showed that loading of the rockbolt
was not uniform and that the stress variation along the rockbolt was non-linear. This
behaviour was similar to that found in Farmers research, and is shown in Figure 30.
Figure 30: Variation of Rockbolt Load into Grout (Haas and Nitzsche, 1976)
It was concluded that almost 80% of the pre-tension was lost within 125mm (5 inches)
of the nut, and the residual load was only 5% 210mm (10 inches) from the nut.
- 67 -
Hyett, Moosavi and Bawden (1996) used numerical and analytical methods as well as
Farmers equation to create a model describing a passive FERB with free ends, with
loading being applied at the centre of the rockbolt due to bed displacement. The
conclusions drawn using this approach were:
There is an exponential stress distribution, with peak load located at the point of
displacement (in this case bed separation)
At low displacements the load is transferred along the whole tendon length
Whitaker (1998) derived two models of stress distribution along a FERB, these being
field and laboratory models. The laboratory model was based on the FERB Pull-test
facility at UNSW, and simulated a strain-gauged rockbolt, grouted in a concrete core
and confined within a biaxial cell. The tendon was loaded axially by use of a jack
acting against a nut on the end of the tendon, as well as against a plate positioned on the
face of the core.
- 68 -
This model displayed an exponential stress distribution, and found that increases in
confinement resulted in increased load transfer rates.
conflicted with this, because it described linear transfer rates, as discussed in the next
section.
- 69 -
2.4.5.2
Linear Distribution
Gerdeen (1977) investigated the influence of tendon length on the load transfer process
through laboratory experimentation.
rockbolts encased in a plaster material he found that the entire length of the tendon was
utilised to transfer loads, with stress distribution along the tendon decaying linearly.
This transfer rate increased with increased loading, as shown in Figure 32.
Extensive field studies using strain-gauged rockbolts have sought to determine the stress
distribution in a mining environment, as opposed to a laboratory environment.
Radcliffe and Stateham (1980) observed 50 strain-gauged rockbolts in three different
mines with bedded strata. They found a linear stress distribution along the length of
encapsulation, and that load transfer rates were symmetrical around a parting located at
- 70 -
the centre of a rockbolt. However, load transfer rates were not symmetrical about a bed
separation that did not occur in the centre of the rockbolt, as shown in Figure 33.
Figure 33: Linear Stress Distribution due to Bed Separation (Radcliffe and Stateham, 1980)
Patrick and Haas (1980) conducted similar tests at different mines and reached similar
conclusions. They also found that a rockbolt might experience both tensional and
compressive loading due to bed separation. Deflection of the lower layers placed the
region about the lower parting in tension, while deflection of the upper layers, if the
middle stratum remained stable, would put the region about the middle and upper
parting in compression.
Serbousek and Signor (1987) sought to prove that loading was confined to short
distances around partings or from the rockbolt head, as found by Pells (1974), rather
than the full length of encapsulation. Laboratory and field pull-out tests of straingauged FERB found that anchorage length required to dissipate load remained constant
as applied load was increased. This is shown in Figure 34. They concluded that
increased loading generated a stiffer system allowing increased load transfer rates.
- 71 -
Figure 34: Increased Load Transfer rate as applied load increased on constant anchorage length
(Serbousek and Signor, 1987)
The second finding of this research was that the length of tendon was insignificant to
the systems load transfer characteristics. It was found that a short tendon transferred
loads over a similar distance as a longer tendon. Thus, the shorter tendon generated a
stiffer system allowing increased load transfer rates. This is shown in Figure 35.
Figure 35: Similar load transfer rates for varied anchorage length (Serbousek and Signor, 1987)
- 72 -
Serbousek and Signor concluded that 90% of applied load in a standard pull-out test
dissipates into the rock within 24 inches of the rockbolt head.
Strata Control Technology (SCT) carries out numerous field strain-gauged pull-out
tests. Results consistently demonstrate linear decaying stress distribution along the full
length of encapsulation. Results also show that transfer rates vary as the tendon passes
through strata layers of differing strengths, suggesting that peak transfer rate is related
to strata strength. This mechanism is shown in Figure 36, where stress is distributed
along the full length of the tendon as it passes through several different strata layers.
Figure 36: Fiel d distribution of stress, highlighting loading around strata parting (SCT, 1996)
- 73 -
Whitakers second model, describing field conditions, conflicted with the laboratory
model in that it showed a linear decaying load transfer rate. The model described the
same tendon, core and grout, with the differentiating factor being the loading
mechanism.
A parting was located in the centre section of the core, representing a strata bedding
plane or joint. Loading was then placed on both ends of the tendon, representing the
loading resulting from a deflecting lower layer and subsequent support from the anchor
located in the upper layer. The stress distribution was found to be symmetrical about
the parting, and is shown in Figure 37.
Figure 37: Linear Load Distribution around parting - Field Model (Whitaker, 1999)
- 74 -
2.4.5.3
It is apparent from studying the literature that the mechanism of load distribution has
not been adequately proven. An exponential decay of load has been found in the
laboratory, in computer modelling and in the field, while linear decay has been
consistently found in field measurements.
concluded a discrete distance is required to dissipate load, others have found that the
entire tendon length is required.
- 75 -
2.5
Deformation Profile
2.5.1
Introduction
While FERB load transfer mechanisms have been extensively researched and the result
of these investigations published, little public knowledge exists regarding the impact of
the design of tendon deformation profile. The studies available frequently neglect to
specify rib height or spacing, although these factors are credited as the driving
mechanism of load transfer. Thus, it is difficult to compare studies due to uncertainties
regarding the actual profiles.
- 76 -
2.5.2
Manufacturers commonly release the following basic information regarding their tendon
products:
Yield Strength
Ultimate Strength
Uniform Elongation
Density
Core Diameter
Bar Diameter
- 77 -
- 78 -
Figure 39: Load/Displacement behaviour variation between different deformation profiles (Gale et
al, 1995)
The load transfer performance of these profiles is shown in Figure 39. It is clear from
these curves that different profiles behave in quite distinct manners. Thus, a clear
knowledge of profile performance mechanisms is vital in designing optimal support
systems.
- 79 -
2.5.3
FERB deformation profiles are designed to assist in the installation process through
shredding of the resin cartridge and by mixing the mastic and catalyst. The profile is
also designed as an irregular surface, promoting adhesion with the resin. The geometry
of the profile is designed to assist in the generation of confinement, through the
mechanical interlock mechanism.
Plain tendons, bent into worm profile, providing economical rib with good
mixing ability (Wriggle rockbolts)
- 80 -
2.5.4
As tendons are manufactured with a deformed surface, the process of adding thread to
attach a nut is made difficult. A smooth, round bar would allow simple cold rolling of
the thread (Gray et al, 1998); this then provides the problem of adding a deformed
profile.
Thus, the following alternate techniques are used to add the thread to a deformed
tendon:
Swaging the end of the bar, then cold rolling the thread on
Cold rolling the deformation and thread simultaneously onto a plain, round bar
Each of these methods is costly to the manufacturer. While large profiles have greater
load transfer performance, they are more expensive to manufacture due to the threading
process. Thus, cost as well as performance need to be considered in the design process.
- 81 -
2.5.5
Given that deformation profile is a key component in the load transfer mechanism, the
relationship between design and effectiveness must be fully understood for engineering
use. That is, by understanding the role of deformation profile in load transfer, the
system may be optimised through engineering an optimal design.
Fabjanczyk and Tarrant (1992) carried out laboratory analysis of 50mm push tests,
finding that the deformation profile significantly affected confinement generation within
the resin annulus, with the height of the deformations being critical.
- 82 -
Figure 41: Load/Confinement of AX Bar with reduced deform thickness (Fabjanczyk et al, 1998)
Research (Gray et al, 1998) has also found that large deformations act to concentrate
stresses.
Stress Raisers are formed at the base of the profile, at the joining of
deformation and tendon core. Rounding this join into a smooth curve can reduce this
stress concentration. This then reduces the chance of crack propagation in the tendon.
- 83 -
2.5.6
After failure has occurred, the rate of load transfer is governed by friction. Figure 42
demonstrates the process whereby the loaded tendon displaces relative to the resin,
causing the deformation profile to apply radial force to the resin, and thus to the rock.
Assuming the resin and rock are of similar strength, failure will occur on the
tendon/resin interface. As the tendon displaces under load, the radial forces applied by
the deformation profile will fracture resin. As it is in a post-failure state, the strength of
the crushed resin is sensitive to the confinement generated by the tendon. Thus, if
generated confinement is reduced, support capacity of the resin declines and the load
transfer characteristics of the system are reduced (SCT, 1996).
- 84 -
2.6
Testing Methods
2.6.1
Comparative Testing
2.6.1.1
Introduction
2.6.1.2
In order to define superior performance, the purpose of the support system must be
considered, with the support system closest in characteristics to those deemed optimal
considered the superior.
Optimal FERB behaviour is rapid load generation, little displacement before retardation
and prolonged sustainment of the required load (Gray et al, 1995).
- 85 -
2.6.2
2.6.2.1
2.6.2.1.1
The International Society of Rock Mechanics (ISRM) has guidelines for evaluating rock
anchor testing. Figure 43 details the apparatus recommended for this testing.
In this test, care must be taken to ensure the load is applied axially to the tendon by the
jack. Applied load is measured using gauges on the hydraulic jack, while displacement
is recorded using dial gauges to an accuracy of less than 0.1mm. A reliable datum is
required to measure displacement, and all surfaces must be clean of loose material to
ensure application of load is axial.
This test is not destructive, and the anchor is not pulled out of the hole. It is an
acceptance test, to determine if the anchor can sustain a specified load.
- 86 -
2.6.2.1.2
The ISRM method is more suited to Civil Engineering applications than Mining
conditions, as it neglects to account for adverse conditions frequently encountered
underground. Specifically the requirement for surfaces to be clean can be difficult to
maintain, and the use of specified equipment may not be feasible in the confines of a
mining environment.
This test supplies the following data about the support system:
- 87 -
2.6.2.2
Laboratory Testing
2.6.2.2.1
Push Test
The push test was developed by SCT (1996) as a measure of sustainable peak shear
stress and stiffness of the tendon-resin interface. The test itself aimed to provide
standardised components and procedures, to remove the effect of variables inherent in
field support systems. The set up of this test is shown in Figure 45.
Only clean rockbolts should be tested using this method, not those rusted or stained with
oil or paint. Comparative tests have shown considerable variation in initial loading
behaviour for clean, cleaned rusted, and rusted rockbolts, although it should be noted
that peak loads were similar for all three, as shown in Figure 18.
- 88 -
2.6.2.2.2
Gun-Barrel Testing
This method removes many of the uncertainties involved with pull-testing, as free-end
elongation corrections and compressive face loads are avoided.
- 89 -
2.6.2.2.3
Field conditions are replicated through the incorporation of a biaxial cell, which
provides confinement to the test core during loading. This confinement simulates the
horizontal stress field acting on the rock in a mine roof.
The testing method employed by this facility is termed the Short Encapsulation Pull-Out
Test.
- 90 -
2.6.3
2.6.3.1
The Short Encapsulation Pull-Out Test provides tensile loading, replicating the
diametric reduction of the tendon under load. The UNSW Pull-Test Facility allows the
following variables to be controlled:
- 91 -
2.7
2.7.1
Load Distribution
Review of rockbolt literature has shown conflict between several core theories, these
being concerned with the form, and length, of load distribution along a tendon.
Exponential and linear load distributions have been shown both in laboratory and field
testing, and while some tests have shown that load is concentrated at specific points of
the tendon, others have shown the full length is loaded to some degree.
It is clear that these discrepancies are a result of two different loading mechanisms:
Bed separation
Bed separation is the mechanism present in the field, whereas jacking is used in
laboratory and field pullout testing.
jacking method, and linear distributions found through the use of in situ strain-gauged
rockbolts undergoing bed separation. Thus, the additional confineme nt offered by the
bearing surface to the rock may have some effect on load distribution.
- 92 -
2.7.2
In addition, while evaluations of some variables present in support systems have been
published, a comprehensive evaluation of all variables has not been completed and
published. These variables include:
Geometry of tendon
Borehole contaminants
Resin composition
Thus, a complete evaluation of all variables present in support systems would greatly
increase the level of knowledge in the public domain.
2.7.3
Standardised Testing
While many researchers have used pullout testing as a means of evaluating load transfer
performance, standardised means of testing and analysing often are not published.
Thus, establishment of a standardised, systematic pullout testing method is a
requirement for future test work, as this will allow a stable framework for comparisons
between the findings of different research projects.
- 93 -
2.7.4
Research Objectives
Verification of load distribution mechanism for both field and laboratory loading
methods