Submitted By: Group 03: 2013PGPM014 BASAMGARI MOUNICA
2013PGPM016 ANAND CHAURASIA
2013PGPM023 HIMANI KOTHARI
2013PGPM039 RACHIT DEVENDRA PRADHAN
Natureview Farm Case Summary Group 03 Page 2
Objective: Natureviews revenue needs to be increased from 13 Million to 20million (over 50% by 2001) Constraints Identified: 1) Entry to supermarket channel was not easy taking into consideration the demands of resources in terms of advertising ,S,G&A expenses, technology and staffing 2) Slotting expenses for each SKU and associated trade promotions 3) Presence of Big Competitors: Dannon,Yoplait & Breyer who can afford . 4) Possibility of spoiling the established relations with current natural food channel leader to dropping the brand and replacing it with competitors Lines 5) Horizon Organic, Natureviews greatest organic dairy competitor was planning to enter into supermarket distribution hence a threat of losing the benefit of 1 st organic brand entering the supermarket benefits. Options available with Natureview: 1) Option 1: Expand into the supermarket channel with 6 SKUs of 8oz yogurt in two regions 2) Option 2: Expand into the supermarket channel with 4 SKUs of 32oz yogurt nationally. 3) Option 3: Introduce 2 SKU of children multi pack into natural foods channel Option Advantages Disadvantages Expand into the supermarket channel with 6 SKUs of 8oz yogurt in two regions -Sales Potential of 35 million Units(1.5% Supermarket Share) -High Purchaebility in North- eastern and Western Regions -High Potential for Increased Revenue -High advertising cost - $1.2millionper region per year -$20000 towards sales staff & $1,20,000 towards additional marketing staff -High level of competition Expand nationally into the supermarket channel with 4 SKUs of 32oz yogurt -Higher Profit Margin 43.6 % as compared to 36% for 8 oz -Low Trade promotion & marketing expense - Expected 1 st year sales of 5.5million units -Difficult to achieve national distribution -Increased sales staff needed that would increase S,G&A expense -High Risk Introduce 2 SKU of children multi pack into natural foods channel -Lowest Risk - Already Positioned for this option - Leveraging existing relationship with natural food channel - Multi packet Market expected to grow at 12.5% - R&D cost to be incurred - Low expected revenue
Cost Benefit Analysis of Each Option is Done on : PGP2_SDM_Natureview_Group03.xlsx Natureview Farm Case Summary Group 03 Page 3
Recommendation for Natureview: Option 3 presents least risk but also least reward .The top line with option 3 is 19.03 Million which is below the target of 20 Million with the profit margin of 18.80%(This would originally be less as the R&D cost were not given in the case for multipacks).Option 1 Achieves the top Line of 38.9 Million Much Above than 27.85 Million as compared to Option 2 with better Net Profit Margin of 17.67%.This option is most realistic one as 8-0z is the largest dollar and unit share of yogurt market (74%) thus has larger consumption. It also gives Natureview a first mover advantage in entering the super market channel as first organic yogurt brand from natural food Channel. Case also strengthens the argument that other brands from natural food channel like Silk soymilk and Amys Organic Food increased revenues by 200% within two years of entering the supermarkets. Hence we Recommend Natureview to go ahead with Option 1 of expanding into the supermarket channel with 6 SKUs of 8oz yogurt in two regions. **********************************************************************************