1. Introduction 1.1 Project Name 1.2 Project Team 1.3 Project Description 2. Background 2.1 The Industry 2.2 The Current Scenario 2.3 Problem Definition 2.4 Why to Implement ERP 3. Defining Measurable Organizational Values 3.1 Quantifying MOVs 4. Cost Benefit Analysis 5. Evaluation of Alternatives 6. Recommendation
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Project Name Implementation of Enterprise Resources Planning Rapid Deployment Solution in Sahara INDIA Ltd. Q shop Project. 1.2 Project Team The team consist of basically 1. Steering committee: The members of this particular committee includes Project Director, Executive Sponsor, and Customer Representatives. 2. Project Manager 3. Consultants 4. Technical Members 5. Change Managers 6. Operation team which include people like Inventory Managers 7. Financial Consultants 1.3 Project Description The project is about implementation of Enterprise Resources Planning Rapid Deployment Solution in Sahara INDIA Ltd. Q shop Project. Technology has given consumers the ability to quickly and easily find the products they want. If one retailer doesnt have the items they need, customers have no problems placing orders with competitors. This makes inventory management an essential part of retaining patrons. Supply chains are becoming increasingly complex, as they now span multiple channels that need to be fully integrated to maintain accurate assessments of inventories. Purchases made from smartphones are often returned to physical store fronts, making it necessary for each section of the supply chain to be incorporated into the larger system. With an accurate assessment of where merchandise is located and in what quantities, businesses can improve order fulfilment strategies and reduce waste. ERP is the solution to help company in revisiting the business model for poor logistics and distribution compounded by weak consumer sentiment in a slowing economy.
2. BACKGROUND 2.1 The Industry India is the fifth largest retail destination globally. The Indian retail industry has experienced tremendous growth over the last decade with a significant shift towards organised retailing format and development taking place not just in major cities and metros, but also in Tier II and Tier III cities. The overall retail market in India is likely to reach Rs 47 trillion (US$ 792.84 billion) by FY 17. The Indian retail market, currently estimated at around US$ 490 billion, is project to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 6 per cent to reach US$ 865 billion by 2023. Food and grocery is the largest category within the retail sector with 60 per cent share followed by the apparel and mobile segment. India has about one million online retailers small and large which sell their products through various e-commerce portals. The online retail industry in the country touched US$ 12.6 billion in 2013, according to a recent report by the Internet and Mobile Association of India (IAMAI). 2.2 Current Scenario Sahara Q Shop is a mega quality consumer merchandise retail business from Sahara India Pariwar. Its aim is to provide pure, and adulteration-free products to the esteemed citizens of the country. Sahara Q Shop supply chain is a mega effort by Sahara group by which people of India would get high quality products of their daily needs at their doorstep, even in small cities. The whole distribution process in Q Shop strives to optimise the entire supply chain process to ensure timely delivery to the customer at minimum cost. Q Shop supply chain covers everything from product development, inventory planning, sourcing, production, logistics, warehousing and delivery at customers' end. Our 305 Q Shop warehouses are well connected with national and state highways, will cover pan-India customers and are capable of keeping stocks to serve their customers in minimum delivery lead time at the customer's house.
2.3 Problem Definition Sahara Q shop has been facing difficulty in managing their inventory from the beginning of venture. They have never been able to forecast of quantities of different products that needed to be ordered on time. The biggest problem they face is the stock out of their most sold SKUs. And they havent been able to replenish the stock in time. Thats why to be not able to deliver their order in time causing customer dissatisfaction. Company is currently focusing on increasing their SKUs in the market whereas they should consider giving inventory management a greater priority. The answer to inventory problem is Enterprise Resources Planning Rapid Deployment Solution. The implementation of a ERP along with automated data collection will likely give you increases in accuracy, reduction in labour costs (provided the labour required to maintain the system is less than the labour saved on the warehouse floor), and a greater ability to service the customer by reducing cycle times.
2.4 Why to Implement Enterprise Resources Planning Rapid Deployment Solution With the changing scenario, the ERP implementation and use will have a major influence on the growth of the Indian retail industry. Initially a system to control movement and storage of materials within a warehouse, the role of ERP is expanding to including light manufacturing, transportation management, order management, and complete accounting systems. With Indian retail sector is growing exponentially it has become a necessity to become the best. It has become difficult to ignore the benefits of ERP difficult. So it has become important for Sahara to implement ERP in its warehouses.
3. DEFINING MEASURABLE ORGANISATIONAL VALUES (MOVs) By implementing ERP, the company wants to improve its monitoring mechanism for inventory in its Supply Chain mechanism. Now breaking down the benefits of implementing ERP:
1. Scalability: An ERP system is easily scalable. That means adding new functionality to the system as the business needs change is easy. This could mean easy management of new processes, departments, and more. 2. Improved reporting: Much of the inefficiency in operational work stems from improper reporting. With an ERP system, this possibility is eliminated as reporting follows an automated template system, allowing various departments to access information seamlessly. 3. Data quality: As compared with manual record-keeping or other traditional approaches, an ERP system improves data quality by improving the underlying processes. As a result, better business decisions can be reached. 4. Lower cost of operations: An ERP system introduces fundamental innovations in managing resources, which eliminates delays and thus reduces cost of operations. For instance, use of mobility allows real-time collection of data, which is indispensable to lowering costs. 5. Better CRM: A direct benefit of using a good ERP system is improved customer relations as a result of better business processes. 6. Business analytics: Having high-quality data allows businesses to use the power of intelligent analytics tools to arrive at better business decisions. In fact, many good ERP systems have built-in analytics functionality to allow easier data analysis. 7. Improved data access: Controlling data access properly is always a challenge in organizations. With an ERP system, this challenge is overcome with the use of advanced user management and access control. 8. Better supply chain: Having the right ERP system in place means improved procurement, inventory, demand forecasting, etc., essentially improving the entire supply chain and making it more responsive. 9. Regulatory compliance: Having the system in control means organizations can better comply with regulations. Further, the most important and recurring regulatory requirements can be built right into the system. 10. Reduced complexity: Perhaps the most elegant argument in the favor of ERP systems is that they reduce the complexity of a business and introduce a neatly designed system of workflows. This makes the entire human resource chain more efficient.
3.1 Quantifying MOVs In order to calculate whether the project is successful or not it was very essential to find out a quantified targets which will be achieved with the help of this project .So in this case we have calculated the measurable organisational value for a period of 5 years and have formulated certain targets which the project is supposed to meet at the end of 1year to become a successful project. The company's top objectives Improve visibility and efficiency across the supply chain Company has been able to grow at a very high rate in last year. Also made a Guinness book world record by opening more than 400 stores in 1 day. Company target to continue growth future years. Integrate sales and distribution with warehouse operations Company has 305 warehouses in 285 different locations. Company needs ERP software to run Supply Chain more efficiently. POS implementation increases flow of information between distribution and warehouses. The target is to increase the flow the enterprise information by 70%. Improved relationships with suppliers and partners, thanks to integrated sales, distribution, and materials management Reduce inventory levels to improve turnover rate, quality and cut costs ERP will reduce the inventory by optimizing asset performance and utilization in warehouse and distribution centre. ERP provides current cost data through cost centre and profit centre analysis which help in reducing costs and hence deliver a superior quality. Benefits expected from implementation of ERP is 25% faster inventory turnover ratio by the end of year. Process data faster to increase order fulfilment rate ERP implementation will lead to increase in on-time deliveries and order fulfilment rates, improving customer satisfaction. Software will result in accelerated data processing and enabled real-time reporting. Expected benefits expected is the increase in order fulfilment to 90%.
4. COST BENEFITS The following table shows the total cost and benefits of ownership of the ERP system: YEAR Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Total Cost $200K $220K $242K $266K $290K Increased Revenue $324K $435K $640K $810K $990K
In the above analysis, we have assumed that the initial cost of hardware installation is $150,000 and the maintenance cost is $10,000 in year 1 and increasing at rate of 10% per annum for 5 years. Similarly, the one-time software installation cost is $60,000 and maintenance cost is 10% of software cost also increasing at the rate of 10 % per annum. The revenue generated is from Faster Inventory turnover ratio, faster order fulfilment rate, faster access to enterprise information, increased brand presence and awareness, and improved customer satisfaction is estimated to be $324,000 over the year 1 and increasing at the rate of 30 % per annum. So, The Net present Value of all the cash Flows comes out to be $ 1.9 million, which is much more than the initial investment.
5. EVALUATION OF ALTERNATIVES There are different ERP service providers: 1. NetSuite ERP It is a complete cloud based ERP solution that integrate with inventory, warehouse management, accounting, customer management. Ideal for business managing inventory and distribution centres. Key Benefits Accelerate the order-to cash process by 50%+. Slash financial close by over 50%. Drive better, faster decision-making with real-time data and reporting, and personalized dashboards. Improve workforce productivity with anytime, anywhere access. Lower cost of ownership by eliminating upfront and ongoing IT expenditures, and delivering automatic product upgrades. Cost of NetSuite ERP - $200,000 but the price will increase by $1,200/person as number of outlet increases. 2. EPICOR With extensive functionality for inventory, accounting, EPICOR deliver a fully integrated web based software. Cost of EPICOR ERP will vary around $180,000 to $300,000. 3. Oracle - Oracle's proven cloud solutions can help you grow smarter, empower your teams, and maximize the value of your IT investment. Founded on modern best practice, Oracle ERP Cloud delivers flexible cloud solutions that support automated and standardized global business processes. The results are increased agility, insightful decision-making, greater productivity, lower costs, and an enhanced ability to innovate all enabling you to drive business success. Oracle ERP will cost around $350,000. Extra capabilities will cost more. 4. SAP - SAP ERP consists of several modules, including utilities for marketing and sales, field service, product design and development, production and inventory control, human resources, finance and accounting. SAP ERP collects and combines data from the separate modules to provide the company or organization with enterprise resource planning. SAP ERP will cost around $250,000. 5. Microsoft - Microsoft Dynamics ERP applications are designed to help customers: Connect the entire supply chain. Make current financial data and reports accessible for business planning and regulatory compliance. Automate repetitious and routine functions so that employees can focus on more critical tasks. Minimize the cost and complexity of administering salaries, benefits, recruiting, and performance management. Provide greater visibility into key performance factors, such as profitability and potential issues. Meet industry-specific needs with functionality for vertical business processes. Microsoft ERP will required functionality will cost more than $500,000. 6. Sage - Sage 300 ERP is a Windows based range of ERP software, available with a variety of database back ends. This can run under a Windows environment and has an option of being hosted by Sage. Sage 300 ERP has the following modules/features: Multi-Company and Global Operations Management, Customer Relationship Management, Intelligence Reporting, Accounts Payable, Accounts Receivable, Inventory Control, Purchase Orders, (Sales) Order Entry, Intercompany Transactions. Sage ERP will cost $2600 per user. So total cost will increase as number of outlet increases.
6. RECOMMENDATION As per the above discussion, the Sahara Q shop should go for ERP implementation as the return on investments for ERP is too high to be ignored. For the implementation of ERP, it should go with the solution offered by SAP ERP Rapid Development Solution as it covers more options and is suitable with respect to our needs.