Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
PAREIDOLIA
DO YOU SEE
WHAT YOU THINK YOU SEE?
STUDENT EDITION
about the
JREF
Providing educational resources and grants to educators and students who are
working to advance critical thinking and skepticism in their communities.
Demonstrating to the public and the media, through educational seminars and
To raise public awareness of these issues, the Foundation offers a $1 Million prize to any
person or persons who can demonstrate psychic, super natural, or paranormal ability of
any kind under mutually agreed upon scientific conditions.
* Donations are tax deductible for U.S. residents to the full extent of the law.
to the reader...
Back when our ancestors had to watch for big
beasties who might jump out of the trees and
gobble em up, they had to learn to tell what
shadows, light, noises and shapes meant as they
mastered the art of survival. Magicians know this,
too, and they slip in small hints and suggestions
that will mislead the decisions of their audiences
Well, we still tend to invent shapes and patterns
where there really are none, and this booklet will
lead you around some of the bumps in the road
that arent there, the eyes, the faces, and the
threats we can and we do make up so easily.
So here we go on our very own Yellow Brick Road where
well see lions, and tigers, and bears, oh my! that pop up
because were still a bit worried about that funny sound,
but more about those faces
Oh, my!
James Randi
introduction
Human beings are not the biggest, strongest, or fastest creatures
in the animal kingdom. We do not have the best eyesight, the best
hearing, or the best sense of smell. Yet human beings have managed
to survive and thrive in a dangerous world. We avoid obstacles and
predators, communicate with other humans, and find food, thanks to
an extraordinary brain that uses information from all of the senses to
figure out the world around us.
The human eye, for example, is a truly amazing organ. It is able to
sense light and measure its energy. Yet, the eye cannot see. Seeing is
a process of the entire visual system and most of the work is done by
the brain.
One common misconception is that our eyes work like cameras,
sending pictures to the brain, which then records those pictures along
with sounds that enter from our ears. The process is really much more
complex than that.
ASK
If the best your brain can do is
guess what a shape, object, or
scene is, then why is it usually
right? How do you think we
are we able to figure out what
most things are?
ASK
Our brains decide what a shape, object, or sound is by
using past experience. How does your brain deal with
things that you have never encountered before?
As an astronomer, Dr. Plait is interested in the patter ns that people claimed to see in
pictures taken by telescopes and space probes. For example, in 1976 a picture of Mars
taken by the Viking 1 spacecraft drew a lot of attention due to what looked like a f ace in a
rock formation (see Figure 4). Many claimed it was evidence of life, perhaps a monument
left by ancient Martians. However, much better images were taken in the years that
followed and it was clear by 2001 that the formation was not really face-shaped after all
(see Figure 5).
ASK
Todays computers are capable of identifying some objects and
even people. Do you think they see faces in everything, too? Do
they experience pareidolia? Why do you/dont you think so?
try this:
Can you make pareidolia happen? The answer is yes. You may need to try several times
before you have a successful example, but all you need is a sound or image that is similar to
something familiar. An easy way to do this is to create inkblots:
10
RELIGIOUS IMAGES
Images of Jesus Christ have been thought
to appear in everything from snack foods
to bird droppings. In 2004, a ten-year-old
grilled cheese sandwich sold on eBay for
$28,000 because it contained the image
of a woman thought to be the Virgin Mary.
In 2005, a cinnamon bun that looked
strikingly similar to Mother Theresa (now
a saint) was stolen from a display case in
the coff ee shop where it was baked. Many
people have traveled great distances and
stood in line for hours for a chance to see
vague Madonna-shaped figures formed by
dripping water, reflections of light, halfmelted candles, and knots in tree trunks,
even if they have to be tur ned upside-down.
In each case, there is no credible evidence
that anything extraordinary has happened,
but the f aithful often say that they f eel
comforted by such things. They believe
that God, Jesus Christ, or the spirit of Mary
placed the image as a sign that they are
watching over the f aithful.
Figure 8:
Ghost box
photo
courtesy
of Ben
Radford
11
SATANIC MESSAGES
Much like those who
hear messages from
spirits in static and
random sounds, many
people in the 1970s
and 80s heard what
they thought where
were evil hidden
messages in rock
music. In fact, several
bands were forced to
defend themselves in
court when messages
were discovered in
recordings that were
played backwards.
2. Vokey, J. R. & Read, J. D. (1985). Subliminal messages. American Psychologist, 40(11), 1231-1239.
12
try this:
Play a game of telephone. This is a game which requires a group of at least five people,
but twice that is better.
3. The first person will then whisper the sentence into the ear of the
second person once and only once. This is tricky; they must whisper
it loud enough for the second person to hear it, but soft enough that
nobody else hears it.
4. The second person will then whisper what they heard into the ear of
the third, and so on.
5. The last person in the chain must repeat what they heard out loud.
6. The first person will then read the sentence they chose and compare.
What happened? Did the sentence change? This game is usually played to demonstrate
how easily communication can break down and misinformation can be spread, but there
is more to learn from it. For example, if the sentence changed, was the gist the same?
Players usually try to repeat the sentence exactly as they heard it, so they tend to replace
any words they did not hear correctly with words that sound similar rather than those that
make sense. As a result, the outcome is often hilarious.
13
Psychologists use
ambiguous figures
to study perception
and other behavior.
Research shows that
priming, which
involves calling
attention to a word or
concept, can aff ect how
people interpret these
figures. For example, if
you spend time looking
through your cupboards
for something to put
flowers in, and then
look at the vase/two
faces image for the
first time, you are more
likely to see a vase
first. If , however, you
have been watching a
lot of romance movies,
the faces may be more
apparent.
14
Figure 10: James Randi reveals his copy of Barbara Walters drawing
15
16
try this:
HOW VAGUE CAN YOU BE?
1. Give one of the four photos below to a friend and ask them to rate the
accuracy of the following description on a scale of 1 to 10:
There is green in the distance, like trees or hills. There is a flat area,
which is brown or tan. There is also a curved line or arches.
2. Repeat this process using the other photos, but with different friends.
Do this with as many people as possible, and then calculate the average
score for each photo.
3. Were the ratings higher or lower than you expected? Were they very
different for each photo? If they were not different, why do you think
such different photos could fit the same description?
4. Create more descriptions like the one above for the same photos and
try it again.
17
GoogleEarth
18
glossary
Agent or Agency
Heuristic
Ambiguous Figure
An image that may be interpreted in more
than one way. Ambiguous ref ers to
information that is unclear.
Barnum Effect
See Forer Eff ect.
Forer Effect
A tendency for people to rate sets of
general statements as highly accurate for
them personally when such statements
apply to most people.
Ghost Box
A device that randomly samples radio
signals in small intervals. Some paranormal
investigators claim that the sampling
process is controlled by spirits to allow
them to communicate with the living.
Pareidolia
A tendency to perceive meaningful shapes
or messages in random or ambiguous
images or sounds.
Priming
Exposure to a concept or thought that
increases the likelihood that it or a similar
concept will come to mind in response to
a prompt. For example, if you are in the
market for a specific new car, you may
think that there are suddenly more of those
cars on the road than there were before
because you are more likely to notice them.
notes