Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
k< g ng /
tr tr' dr r
&REF'(E
c/ c/< 51 nC
"s ts< dF
t t' d n
P p< b m
w
1/e researc/ on w/ic/ t/is paper is based was carried o,t ,nder a
grant fro- t/e Foreign Area Fellowsc/ip Progra- and was cond,ct =
ed in t/e /ill station of 3al/o,sie, 6i-ac/al Prades/, w/ere t/e
re-nants of -any of t/e great 1ibean -onastic centers /ave
gat/ered5
6ere -y wife and " lived wit/ a gro,p t/at calls itself t/e 1ibetan
Craft Co--,nity for t/e Progress of t/e 3/ar-a, earning its living
-ainly by t/e prod,ction of 1ibetan /andicrafts and centering ,pon
t/e c/aris-atic person of D<a-tr, 2inpoc/<e M""" 3onBii nyi-a,
t/e Precio,s "ncarnation of D<a-, #,n of t/e 1r,e Lineage5 1/is
co--,nity consists of abo,t (& -onks and abo,t )(& lay people,
preserving a-ong t/e-selvesEper/aps better t/an any ot/er re=
f,gee gro,p " /ave enco,nteredEt/eir traditional practices and
co--,nity relations/ips5 " wo,ld like to e9press -y deep gratit,de
to D<a-tr, 2inpoc/<e for /is kindness to ,s, w/ic/ sprang spon=
taneo,sly and openly fro- a nat,re 7precio,s7 by -ore t/an title5
" wo,ld like to t/ank t/e -anager of t/e lay co--,nity, Ieleg
na-Be, and /is brot/er, t/e gifted artist 1s<ewang tobBe, for opening
t/eir /o,se and t/eir /earts to ,s, and all t/e -onks and lay people
w/o beca-e o,r friends5
8y -aBor infor-ant in t/is gro,p was t/e yo,ng C/oBe Bats<o,
/ead of t/e -onastery of 3r,g, and t/e eig/t/ in /is line of incar =
nations, w/ose nat,ral gracio,sness, sc/olars/ip, and ;,ick grasp
of w/at " as a 4estern sc/olar was atte-pting to acco-plis/ -ade
/i- bot/ an ideal infor-ant and a good friend5 8y -aBor infor-ant
for t/e vario,s artistic traditions was 1endFin yongdii, a venerable
and learned lay artist w/o /as been depicting t/ese deities on
painted scrolls for all t/e 1ibetan sects for -ore t/an fifty years5
#o-e of /is drawings are reprod,ced in t/is book5 For infor-ation
on t/e act,al perfor-ance of rit,alE/and gest,res, c/ants, and
offeringsE" a- gratef,l to DaBii dr,gBe, t/e /ead -onk of t/e
-onastery, w/o, " t/ink, got as -,c/ delig/t fro- -y singing as "
got fro- /is, t/o,g/ for different reasons5
" wo,ld f,rt/er like to e9press -y indebtedness to 8iss 3iane
Perry GAni 1endFin Pe-oH for /er advice and enco,rage-ent, and
especially for /er Perfection of Forbearance in t/e face of inf,riating
9v
s/ F/
9vi &REF'(E
sc/olarly nit'pickingC to -y late teac/er 2ic/ard 2obinson, of t/e 3epart-ent of "ndian
#t,dies, University of 4isconsin, w/o constantly c/allenged -e wit/ /is own fierce
intellect,al /onestyC and to 2oger 4illia-s, w/o drew t/e frontispiece for t/is book5 And
especially " want to t/ank -y wife L,dy, w/o did not type ,p -y -an,script, renew -y
library books or correct -y spelling, b,t w/o rat/er perfor-ed t/e -,c/ -ore i-portant
f,nction of constantly re-inding -e, in "ndia and in A-erica, t/at a B,d'd/ologist does not
deal wit/ B,dd/is- so -,c/ as /e deals wit/ B,dd/ists5
Contents
"LLU#12A1">$#
"
4>2#6"P% >FFE2"$I#, PRAISES, A$3 P2AJE2
1
""
APPL"CA1">$% P2>1EC1">$ A$3 A11ACD
))
"""
ACPU"#"1">$% "$"1"A1">$ A$3 2"1UAL #E2M"CE
*+1
$>1E#
.+9
B"BL">I2AP6J
(&*
"$3EQ
()1
9vii
"ll,strations
Fig,res
1H 4/ite ?@A@5 Fro- a wood'block print by 2oger Frontis'
4illia-s5 piece
)H #ongtsen ga-po wit/ 1r<itsiin GleftH and 4en'c/<eng
k,ng'c/, Grig/tHC note t/e national cost,-es5 Fro- an
iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 (
*H Ireen ?@A@5 Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin
yongdii5 9
.H #ketc/ -ap of D<a-, according to C/<oBe Bats<o5 1+
(H 1/e type of 6er,ka% Cakrasa-vara and MaBravara/l5
Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 .1
+H 1/e type of fierce patron% Ja-antaka in t/e 7ancient7
for- of P,icksilver, t/e black poison'faced5 Fro- an
iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 ..
H 1/e type of dakinl% MaBravara/l, t/e dia-ond sow5
Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 .(
!H 1/e 7ancient7 dakinl Lion'faced, t/e g,ardian of /idden
te9ts5 Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 .+
9H 1/e type of 8a/akala% t/e Fo,r'/anded Lord5 Fro- an
iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 .9
1&H 1/e 7ancient7 protectors% FkaBata, g,ardian of -antras5
Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 (&
11H 1/e 7ancient7 protectors% Ra5 Fro- an' iconograp/ic
sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 (1
1)H 1/e 7ancient7 protectors% 3a-c/en 3oBe legpa, t/e
oat/'bo,nd e9cellent dia-ond5 Fro- an iconograp/ic
sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5
()
1*H 1/e type of Ilorio,s Ioddess% 8agic 4eapon Ar-y5
Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 (*
1.H 1/
e
-a
ntr
as
and
t/e
ges
t,r
es
t/a
t
G1H
s,
-
-o
n,
G)H
ab
sor
b,
G*H
bin
d,
and
G.H
dis
sol
ve
t/e
kno
wle
dge
bei
ng5
1&)
XX
.++12#R'#.O32
1/e o,ter offerings5
1/e precio,s ge-s of sovereignty5
1/e signs of good fort,ne5
1/e secret offerings5
1/e secret offerings, contin,ed5
1/e -andala gest,re5
1/e tor-as for t/e Fo,r 8andala rit,al5
Pal-s Boined in reverence5
1/e dia-ond'lady'of't/e'-ind gest,re5
1/e bell and vaBra5
1/e flying'bird gest,re5
1/e tor-a gest,re5
1/e asking'to'depart gest,re5
3rawing t/e /eart/5
Ladles for li;,ids GtopH and solids Gbotto-H5
A protection against gossip and slander% a fig,re
w/ose
lips are locked5
A protection to bind -alevolent spirits5
A peacef,l lu and a fierce hi4 Fro- a sketc/ by 1endFin
yongdii5
A tsen4 Fro- a sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5
8ac/<en po-ra, a -o,ntain deity5 Fro- a sketc/ by
1endFin yongdii5
D,r,k,lla, goddess of s,bB,gation5 Fro- an icono'
grap/ic sketc/ by 1endFin yongdii5 1/e linga- effigy in
its iron /o,seEt/e black triang,lar bo9Es,rro,nded by
t/e weapons of its destr,ctionC t/e syllabes $2 12" on its
body cast t/e de-ons 7down into for-7 to be 7liberated75
Fro- a 1ibetan woodblock print5
1/e tor-as for t/e t/read'cross rit,al5 A proof s/eet p,lled
fro- a 5en par, a wooden -old for -aking s-all
s,bstit,tes5 1/e block is carved in intaglio, /ence t/e
pec,liar appearance of t/e paper print5
&*otong and motong offered as s,bstit,tes5
1/e f,ll'blown'lot,s'flower gest,re5
1/e si9 gest,res t/at generate t/e s,bstit,tes5
4/ite ?@A@5 Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/ by 1endFin
yongdii5
A -etal initiation tor-a GleftH and a flask of life Grig/tH5
.++12#R'#.O32 99i
1(H1/e working flask GleftH and t/e c/ief flask Grig/tH5 .&9
1+H#olitary conte-plation% a yogin in -editative post,re,
s/o,lders t/rown back, elbows t,rned in, and ar-s
locked on t/e t/ig/s5 Fro- a 1ibetan wood'block
print5 .(9
Plates
Following page )+&
Coating t/e food tor-as wit/ b,tter5 #etting ,p t/e
altar for t/e Fo,r 8andala >ffering5 >ffering ,p t/e
-andala to ?@A@5 4ayside s/rine in 3al/o,sie,
6i-ac/al Prades/5 1/e Lady of t/e Ioring Jak5 1/e
b,rnt offering5
A co-ple9 t/read'cross ,sed in t/e large ann,al evocation
of t/e Fo,r'/anded Lord5
4inding t/e five'colored t/reads on t/e fra-e of t/e
t/read'cross5
P,tting b,tter flowers on t/e tor-a5 1/e portrait -olded of
barley flo,r, in deep relief5 Fo,r'tiered 8o,nt 8e- and
t/e e9cellent /o,se5 Planting s/r,bbery on t/e s,rro,nding
iron -o,ntains5 1/e portrait co-plete wit/ /o,se,
servants, livestock, and property5
1/e entire str,ct,re tied aro,nd wit/ t/read and set
on t/e altar facing t/e asse-bly5
Carrying t/e t/read'cross down t/e -o,ntain5
1/e -,ltit,de tor-as5
1
5
1
6
1
7
18
19
20
21
22
23
21
25
26
27
28
3
1
3
2
33
31
*(
*+
9
1&
11
1)
1*
M
1
(
1
*
5
.!
39
40
II
42
43
14
7
15
2
155
160
161
168
174
178
179
183
218
220
224
266
267
28
5
29
3
301
31
1
32
326
328
338
347
364
376
I
I
4>2#6"P
Offerings, &raises, and &rayer
" read so-ew/ere of a
s/ep/erd w/o, w/en asked
w/y /e -ade, fro- wit/in
fairy rings, rit,al obser=
vances to t/e -oon to
protect /is flocks, replied%
7"<d be a da-n< fool if "
didn<tK7
EDylan #homas, note to
C>LLEC1E3 P>E8#
1/e Eternal Body of 8an
is 1/e "-agination, t/at
is, 1/e 3ivine Body 5 5 5
G"n Eternity All is MisionH5
EWilliam lake, LA>C>>$
6E 4>2#6"P of t/e goddess ?@A@ is one of t/e -ost
widespread of 1ibetan c,lts, ,ndifferentiated by
sect, ed,cation, class, or positionC fro- t/e
/ig/est to t/e lowest, t/e 1ibetans find wit/ t/is goddess a
personal and end,ring relations/ip ,n-atc/ed by any ot/er single
deity, even a-ong t/ose of t/eir gods -ore potent in appearance or
-ore profo,nd in sy-bolic association5 1/is fact in itself -eans t/at
/er c,lt -ay repay sc/olarly interest, for 1ara<s rit,als differ fro-
t/ose of t/e 7/ig/ patron deities7 of t/e -onastic c,lt in t/at t/ey
esc/ew -,c/ of t/e deeperEpri-arily se9,alEsy-bolis- w/ic/
/as so ,pset -any 4estern researc/ers, and yet t/ey confor- to
t/e basic patterns of all 1ibetan rit,al5 1/eir straig/tforward
avoidance of t/e te9t,al co-ple9ities of t/e /ig/est 1antras is an
advantage, beca,se we can direct o,r attention to t/eir str,ct,re
rat/er t/an to t/e 7-eaning7 of t/eir sy-bolis-5 >nce t/ese
str,ct,res /ave been establis/ed, t/ey -ay be generaliFed to incl,de
t/e -ost profo,nd 1antric revelationsC b,t we -,st first ask,
si-ply, w/at t/e 1ibetans are doing before we can go on to decide
t/e 7real7 reason t/ey do it5
1
Per/aps t/e -ost i--ediately i-pressive aspect of t/ese rit,als
is t/e tr,e devotion wit/ w/ic/ t/e 1ibetans approac/ t/e goddess%
s/e g,ards and protects /er people, t/ey say, fro- t/e cradle to
beyond t/e grave, and /er devotees cry o,t to /er in t/eir distress and
s/are wit/ /er t/eir Boys5 1/is f,nda-ental attit,de of wors/ip,
/owever, is inevitably c/anneled t/ro,g/ a rit,al process of 7offer=
ings, praises, and prayer7 and is directed to t/e goddess by t/e
cere-onial for-s of t/e -onastic<co--,nity5 1/,s to ,nderstand
so-et/ing of /er c,lt is to ,nderstand so-et/ing of t/e w/ole str,c=
t,re of 1ibetan c,lt,re and religion5
LEIE$3A2J BEI"$$"$I#
1/is ,niversal veneration for t/e goddess was t/e res,lt of a grad,al
process w/ic/ began wit/ t/e c/aris-atic devotion of ST@, beca-e
. #!E (1+# OF #'R'
a potent religio,s force by t/e fo,rteent/ cent,ry, and c,l-inated
in t/e early seventeent/ cent,ry wit/ t/e great 1aranat/a, fro-
w/ose ti-e t/e c,lt as we know it /as e-erged5 And yet t/is
goddess, t/o,g/ everyone knows t/at /er c,lt was i-ported fro-
"ndia, is related by -yt/ to t/e very beginning of t/ings in 1i =
bet5
>ne of t/e early pre'B,dd/ist -yt/s relating t/e origins of t/e
1ibetan people /olds t/at 7a devil and an ogress /eld sway, and t/e
co,ntry was called Land of t/e 1wo 3ivine >gres5 As a res,lt, red'
faced fles/'eating creat,res were born57
1
1/ese de-onic offspring
were grad,ally given t/e crafts of c,lt,re by s,ccessive generations
of c,lt,re'/ero kings, and t/ey beca-e t/e civiliFed 1ibetans5 >t/er
versions of t/e -yt/ say t/at t/e 1ibetans were originally t/e si-ian
descendants of a ,nion between a rock ogress and a -onkey5 1/is
latter acco,nt was event,ally adopted as t/e official B,dd/ist
version, and t/e -onkey beca-e identified first as a disciple and
t/en as an incarnation of Avalokitesvara5 B,t, s,rprisingly eno,g/,
t/e fierce ogressE7l,stf,l and lascivio,s, ,nder t/e sway of desire7
Ebeca-e identified as an incarnation of ?@A@5 As t/e Red 'nnals
s,ccinctly says, 71/en, fro- t/e -onkey Bod/isattva, an incar=
nation of Avalokitesvara, and t/e rock ogress, an incarnation of
?@A@, t/ere sprang t/e 1ibetan people57
)
1/e point to be noted in t/e evol,tion of t/is -yt/ is t/e infl,ence
,pon it of t/e developing c,lt of ?@A@, for so pervasive /ad /er
wors/ip beco-e by t/e ti-e of t/e Red 'nnals in 1*.+
*
t/at t/e
a,t/or co,ld give t/is final version of t/e tale as a received tradi =
tionC so pop,lar was t/e goddess t/at t/e 1ibetans so,g/t to relate
/er to t/eir very origins, at w/atever price in logic5 1/o,g/ t/ere
is, after all, good reason to consider t/e -onkey ancestor related
to AvalokitesvaraEt/e ogress t/reatened to eat ,p t/o,sands of
sentient beings every day ,ntil t/e -onkey agreed to ass,age /er
l,st, so /is act in fat/ering t/e 1ibetan people -ig/t indeed be con=
sidered to be one of ,niversal co-passionEt/e identification of
t/e ogress w/o sed,ced /i- wit/ t/e goddess ?@A@ appears grat,i=
to,s, for in no version is /er divine nat,re -ade obvio,s in /er
actions, even in t/e late and e9panded retelling of #,-pa k<enpo5
.
B,t t/e pio,s intention of t/e attrib,tion is clear, and t/e devo=
tees of t/e goddess, looking at t/e /istory of t/eir people, find -ore
t/an r/etorical ca,se to call /er 7-ot/er57
WOR2!.&
16E EA2L"E2 #P2EA3 >F 16E LA4
A f,rt/er and /istorically -ore i-portant tradition relates t/e
act,al introd,ction of 1ara<s c,lt into 1ibet to t/e $epalese prin=
cess 1r<itsiin, da,g/ter of A-s,var-an and wife of t/e first great
1ibetan king #ongtsen ga-po G+1'+(&, according to t/e calc,lation
of Boeric/H5
(
"t is clai-ed in t/e vario,s c/ronicles t/at t/is prin=
cess bro,g/t wit/ /er, a-ong ot/er i-ages, a sandalwood stat,e of
?@A@, w/ic/ was placed in t/e 1e-ple of 8irac,lo,s 8anifestation
Fig5 )5 #ongtsen ga-po wit/ 1r<itsiin GleftH and 4en'c/<eng k,ng'
c/, Grig/tHC note t/e national cost,-es5 Fro- an iconograp/ic sketc/
by 1endFin yongdii5
#!E (1+# OF #'R '
constr,cted at t/e princess<s orders5
+
1/ere is so-e do,bt as to t/e
final disposition of t/is i-age5 1/e great la-a and geograp/er
La-yang c/<entse wangpo G1!)&'1!9)H gave an acco,nt of t/e
te-ple and described a -irac,lo,s i-age of t/e goddess w/ic/ was
na-ed 7Lady w/o Accepts t/e Cere-onial #carf7C
b,t in t/e
seventeent/ cent,ry t/e fift/ 3alai La-a /ad already reported, in
/is g,idebook to t/e te-ples of L/asa, t/at t/e original sandal'
wood i-age was no longer t/ere5
!
"t is t/,s proble-atical w/et/er t/e i-age c,rrently ens/rined is
t/e sa-e as t/e one bro,g/t fro- $epal in t/e early or -iddle
sevent/ cent,ry Gt/e c/ronicles periodically report t/e s/,ffling
of i-ages fro- one te-ple to anot/er, according to t/e religio,s
policy of t/e co,rtH, and it is diffic,lt to tell at t/is late date /ow
-,c/ of a c,lt developed aro,nd any of t/ese early i-ages in 1ibet,
w/et/er t/ose bro,g/t by 1r<itsiin or t/e -,c/ -ore fa-o,s Lowo
rinpoc/<eEan i-age of #akya-,ni as a twelve'year'old prince
Ebro,g/t by t/e king<s C/inese wife 4en'c/<eng k,ng'c/,5
9
1/ere
is no partic,lar evidence t/at ?@A@ received any special veneration
at t/is ti-e Gindeed, t/e C/inese i-age of #akya-,ni see-s fro- t/e
c/ronicles to /ave received -,c/ t/e larger s/are of attention, being
considered t/e original i-age -ade in t/e ti-e of t/e B,dd/a /i-=
selfH, or in fact t/at any partic,larly B,dd/ist c,lt spread far beyond
co,rt circles5 1ara<s i-age was to t/e king -ost likely a piece of
political -agic, an alien god to be treated wit/ respect for its sacred
Gand diplo-aticH potency, to be p,t in a special s/rine w/ere it co,ld
do little /ar- to t/e native gods and -ig/t per/aps do so-e good,
especially for an i-perial policy in t/e process of consolidating a
centraliFed govern-ent5 1/e i-age represented bot/ religio,s and
political forces to be dealt wit/, b,t not necessarily to be wors/iped5
1&
4/atever do,bts t/ere -ay be abo,t t/e w/ole tradition of
#ongtsen ga-po<s -arriages, t/ere is not/ing c/ronologically i-=
probable in t/e original contention t/at s,c/ an i-age of ?@A@ was
bro,g/t fro- $epal, or t/at at least so-e knowledge of t/e goddess
was carried to 1ibet abo,t t/is ti-e, even t/o,g/ t/e precise date
of origin of 1ara<s c,lt in "ndia is still very -,c/ a ve9ed ;,estion%
t/e earliest epigrap/ical doc,-ent relating to /er wors/ip is a Lava=
nese inscription of !,
11
and it is diffic,lt to place wit/ ass,rance
any te9t devoted to /er -,c/ earlier t/an t/e early eig/t/ cent,ry,
w/ic/ is too late by far to verify t/e 1ibetan tradition5 B,t t/ere
does e9ist one reference to t/e goddess prior to t/ese dates, fo,nd
WOR2!.&
WOR2!.
&
+(
16E PA2A3>Q >F P>4E2
1/e celebration of t/is rit,al is per/aps t/e -ost evocative e9=
pression of t/e 1ibetans< devotion to t/e goddess ?@A@5 Jet in t/eir
devotion lies one of tfre basic parado9es of t/e 1ibetan religion% in spite
of /er close to,c/ <wit/ t/e lives of /er people, ?@A@ s/ares in t/e
essential nat,re of t/e deities of t/e -onastic c,lt5 #/e, too, is basically
alien to t/e /,-san e9perience, ,lti-ately 7ot/er,7 wit/o,t personality,
appearing and dispensing /er -irac,lo,s favors as ,napproac/able
and i-personal lig/t5 #/e, too, is a cos-ic force w/ic/ -ay be
-anip,lated by an e9pert in /er rit,al or -ay be directed to one<s
benefit by t/e recitation of /er -antra, t/e sonic reverberation of /er
power'"n t/is rit,al 1ara<s devotees e9press t/eir love for and t/eir
personal relations wit/ t/be goddess in t/e offerings, praises, and
prayers wit/ w/ic/ t/ey seek to 7aro,se /er /eart57 1/ey /ave
co-plete confidence in t/e effectiveness of t/e rit,al, fostered by t/eir
reliance ,pon t/e bbsic parado9 of 1ara<s divine nat,re% for s/e is
kind and loving, ready to /elp t/e- in any afflictionC and t/e -onks
w/o perfor- /er rit,al /ave i-bibed /er power, /ave co-pleted all t/e
recitations of /er rit,al service, and are e-powered not only to aro,se
/er /eart b,t also to e-ploy /er, to direct /er divine energy by t/e
i-personal recitation of /er -antra5
1o ,nderstand t/e nat,re of t/is basic d,ality of t/e 1ibetan
religio,s and devotional attit,de we -,st first seek to ,nderstand t/e
sort of deity w/o is approac/ed and t/e nat,re of t/e powers t/at
are dealt wit/5 "t is in t/e -yt/s of 1ara<s spirit,al origins, w/ic/
e9press t/e -anifold and rec,rring -anifestations of /er divine
essence in t/e re-ote ages of t/e past, t/at we find a val,able cl,e to
/er rit,al5
16E #>U2CE >F P>4E2
A beginningless ti-e ago, we are told, t/ere was a worldly real-
na-ed Mario,s Lig/ts, in w/ic/ t/ere appeared a 1at/agata na-ed
#o,nd of 3r,-s, and to /,- t/e princess 8oon of 4isdo- s/owed
great fait/ and devotion5 For a t/o,sand billion years s/e did re=
verence to t/e B,dd/a and t/e -eas,reless /ost of /is retin,e, t/e
Bod/isattvas and 4ort/y >nes, and finally s/e awakened t/e
s,pre-e t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent5 71/e proper t/ing to do,7 t/e
-onks t/en said to t/e princess, 7is to -ake an earnest wis/ t/at yo,r
body Gwit/ w/ic/ yo, attend to t/e teac/ingsH -ay beco-e t/at of a
-an, for s,rely t/is desire will be granted57 #/e replied% 7#ince t/ere is
no s,c/ t/ing as a <-an< or a <wo-an< Gand no s,c/ t/ing as a <self< or a
<person< or < awareness<H t/is bondage to -ale and fe-ale is /ollow% >/
/ow worldly fools del,de t/e-selves K7And t/is is t/e earnest wis/ s/e
-ade% 71/ose w/o wis/ to attain s,pre-e enlig/ten-ent in a -an<s
body are -any, b,t t/ose w/o wis/ to serve t/e ai-s of beings in a
wo-an<s body are few indeedC t/erefore -ay ", ,ntil t/is world is
e-ptied o,t, serve t/e ai- of beings wit/ not/ing b,t t/e body of a
wo-an57
1/en t/e princess re-ained in -editation in t/e palace for a
t/o,sand billion years, and s/e t/ereby attained to an acknowledg-ent
t/at events do not ariseC s/e entered into t/e -editation called #aving
All Beings, and by t/e power of t/at -editation s/e resc,ed fro- t/eir
worldly -inds a t/o,sand billion beings every -orning and fi9ed
t/e- in t/eir attain-ent of acceptanceC and s/e did not eat ,ntil s/e
/ad done so5 Every evening s/e fi9ed t/erein t/e sa-e n,-ber of
beings, and s/e t/,s beca-e fa-ed as ?@A@, t/e #avioress5
1/en, in t/e world era called Mastly E9tended, t/e princess took a
vow in t/e presence of t/e 1at/agata A-og/asidd/i t/at s/e wo,ld
protect fro- /ar- all t/e sentient beings t/ro,g/o,t t/e n,-berless
real-s of t/e ten directions5 #/e settled into t/e -editation called
3efeating All 8aras and t/ereby fi9ed in conte-plative -editation
ten billion billion lords of beings eac/ day, and eac/ nig/t s/e ta-ed
a t/o,sand billion -asters of t/e 6eaven of Power >ver t/e Misions of
>t/ers5 1/,s /er na-e beca-e fa-ed as P,ick >ne and 6eroine5
1/en, in t/e world era called Beginningless, a -onk na-ed #tain'
css Lig/t was initiated by t/e lig/t of great co-passion of all t/e
at/agatas of t/e ten directions, and /e beca-e t/e noble Avaloki'
e vara5 1/en, initiated by t/e great lig/t w/ose in/erent nat,re was
ce s,perior knowledge of all t/e 1at/agatas of t/e ten directions,
e two lig/tsEof co-passion and of ,nderstandingE-i9ed to'
! ieA in t/e -anner of a fat/er and -ot/er and transfor-ed into
aC and s/e, born fro- t/e /eart of t/e noble Lord of t/e 4orld,
jk
lem
n
!
fr
a- t/e eig/t and t/e si9teen great terrors57
nese -yt/ological renewals of 1ara<s vows, /er creation fro-
7atory /g/t, sy-boliFe to t/e 1ibetans t/e so,rce of /er divine
66 THE CULT OF TARA
WORSHI
P
67
power, /er contact wit/ t/e ,lti-ate potency of enlig/ten-ent, /er
literal 7to,c/ing7 of o-nipotent E-ptiness5 All t/eir deities are
centers of t/is power, w/ic/ is i-pelled into t/e present by s,c/
pri-ordial vows, w/ic/ is fed by t/e deities< own -editation, and
w/ic/ is given its final for- and direction Gin re'creation of its
pri-al genesisH by a rit,al5 "t is, ,lti-ately, t/is cos-ic power t/at is
sy-boliFed by t/e -,ltit,dino,s ar-s and weapons and by t/e se9,al
e-braces of t/e /ig/est deitiesC and it is t/is power t/at t/e practitioner
for-s 7fro- t/e real- of E-ptiness7 by t/e Process of Ieneration5
14> 4AJ# >F APP2>AC6
1/e 1ibetans -ake a broad distinction between two types of rit ,al
approac/ to t/e ,tiliFation of t/is divine and pri-ordial power5 "n a
rit,al of evocation, t/ro,g/ t/e process of self'generation, t/e
practitioner first applies t/e Process of Ieneration to /i-self% /e
vividly vis,aliFes /i-self as t/e deity and grasps t/e divine pride or
egoC /e directs t/e power of t/e deity into /i-self and beco-es, in
effect, t/e transfor-er t/ro,g/ w/ic/ t/e divine power can pass o,t of
t/e real- of knowledge and into t/e world of events5 1/,s /e ne9t
generates or evokes t/e sa-e deity Goccasionally, a different deityH in
front of /i- by t/e sa-e Process of IenerationEplacing t/e power
in t/e sky or wit/in an obBect Ga flask of p,re water, say, or an a-,let
of protectionHEand finally directs it into a rit,al f,nction or -agical
e-ploy-entC /e conscio,sly -anip,lates and cond,cts it into an
activity, into a -agical device, or even, as in t/e betsowing of
initiations, into anot/er person5 An ordinary nondi'vine /,-an body, "
was told, si-ply co,ld not stand t/e press,re5 Alt/o,g/ we note in t/e
-yt/s of /er origin /ow ?@A@ s/ares in t/e basic potency of t/e
divine, /ow little tr,e personality s/e /as w/en co-pared wit/ 6ind,
or Ireek deities, /ere too t/e attit,de of wors/ip strives to break
t/ro,g/ t/e wall of in/,-an power, of 7ot/erness,7 w/ic/ s,rro,nds
/er5 1/e Fo,r 8andalas are a rit,al of offering rat/er t/an of
evocation% /ere t/ere is no self'generation, no -anip,lation of /er power
t/ro,g/ t/e person of t/e practitioner5 1/ere is no conte-plation of t/e
-antra in t/e practitioner<s own /eart d,ring self'generation, b,t
rat/er t/e effect,ation of t/e -antra in t/e deity<s /eart generated 7in
front7% t/e ne9,s of power w/ic/ is t/e deity is given iconograp/ic
for- by t/e rit,al Process
of Ieneration and vividly vis,aliFed before t/e practitioner, t/at t/e
goddess -ay be approac/ed, /er power tapped t/ro,g/ /er -antra,
and t/e 7strea- of /er /eart aro,sed7 wit/ offerings, praises, and
prayers5
Jet /ere, too, t/e sa-e preparatory re;,ire-ents are set ,p for t/e
perfor-ance of t/is rit,al as for all ot/ers5 "t is not w/olly tr,e to say
t/at 7t/e fait/f,l -ay appeal to /er directly wit/o,t t/e inter-ediary
of a la-a7C
9+
rat/er it is better to say t/at /er powerE born of /er
to,c/ing of E-ptiness an i-pelled by /er vows of love E-ay
-anifest itself spontaneo,sly in answer to t/e s,pplication of a
devotee, wit/o,t t/e de-ands of conscio,s -anip,lation5 B,t w/en t/e
deity is for-ed and approac/ed in rit,al and /er power is applied
t/ro,g/ t/e effect,ation of /er -antra, t/e perfor-ance re;,ires, as we
/ave seen, t/e presence of -onks w/ose vows are ,nbroken, w/o /ave
been d,ly initiated, and w/o /ave gone t/ro,g/ t/e prior rit,al service
of t/e goddess5 7All t/e 1antras and all t/e te9ts of t/e great -agicians
agree,7 says Jes/e Bets<en, 7in /olding t/at one -,st /ave attained t/e
power to recite t/e -antra and to perfor- t/e -antra rit,als by being
possessed of yogaE<,nion<E wit/ t/e deity% t/at is, t/e
conte-plation of oneself as t/e /oly ?@A@57
9
1/ere is t/,s never a rit,al of offering in isolation fro- t/e con=
te-plative preparation of self'generation% an offering is always t/e
delayed second /alf of an evocation, t/e first /alf of w/ic/ was perfor-ed
per/aps years before as t/e prior rit,al service of t/e deity5 1/is fact
leads to so-e se-antic level'switc/ing% in a rit,al of evocation t/e
self'generation is often called Gby analogy wit/ t/e act,al se;,ence of
conte-plative trainingH t/e 7rit,al service,7 and t/e generation in front
is t/en called t/e 7evocation7 proper5 1/is rat/er invol,ted
ter-inology -ay per/aps be clarified by t/e following table%
)eneration 9antra #itle Ritual approach
self conte-plation rit,al service
` o evocation
EevocationE offering L
Again we see t/e parado9 of power controlling t/e f,nctional
relations/ip between t/e lay and -onastic co--,nities, for t/e
necessity of prior rit,al service, even for t/e wors/ip of t/e deity,
li-its access to t/e -agical powers of t/e rit,al, w/ic/ are available
J
effect,ation
68
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
+9
only to t/ose able to invest t/e ti-e re;,ired for t/e conte-plative
training t/at alone -akes one fit to ,se t/e-5 1/,s t/e -onastery acts
as a service gro,pE a pool of rit,al talentEfor t/e lay co--,nity, and
s,itable reco-pense in t/e for- of food, tea, and -oney is given to
t/e -onks for any special call ,pon t/eir professional services5 1/e
relations/ip is reciprocal, /oweverC t/e lay co--,nity de-ands a
proportionate ret,rn on its invest-ent in t/e -onastery<s s,pport,
and lay people are often ;,ite concerned t/at t/e -onks -aintain t/e
-oral c/aracter necessary for t/e s,ccess of t/e rit,al5
4it/in t/e life of t/e -onastic co--,nity bot/ rit,al approac/es
play an i-portant role% all t/e rit,als of t/e afternoon asse-bly Gt/at
is, t/e prayers to t/e vario,s protectorsH are rit,als of offeringC all t/e
rit,als for t/e /ig/ patron deities in t/e -orning asse-bly Gincl,ding t/e
s/ort 7/idden treas,re7 rit,al for ?@A@H are rit,als of evocation5 "n
addition, all t/e great ann,al cere-onies of t/e -onastic c,lt are
evocationsC for e9a-ple, t/e afternoon prayer to t/e Fo,r'/anded
Lord is an offering, b,t /is ann,al rit,al is an evocationC and every
rit,al for t/e /ig/ patron deity Cakrasa-vara, w/et/er perfor-ed
daily, -ont/ly, or ann,ally, is an evocation5 1/ere are ot/er
i-portant and occasional rit,als of offering% t/e offering to t/e g,r,s
on deat/ anniversaries, t/e offerings to t/e si9teen 4ort/y >nes on
t/e -orning of $ew Jears< 3ay, and t/e deat/ rit,al of t/e 7great
liberation57
1/ese two approac/es to t/e deity often sy-boliFe a difference in t/e
practitioner<s psyc/ological distance fro- t/e deity<s power5 1/e
rit,als of evocation are -ore clearly soteriological or -anip,latory in
intent% t/e practitioner is t/e deity, and gains t/ereby godlike
-agical attain-ents to ,nderstand and control reality5 1/e rit,als of
offering are perfor-ed, for t/e -ost part, to t/ank t/e deity Gas a
power beyond t/e practitionerH for favors received, or to pray for f,t,re
kindness5 1/e distance is -ost clear in t/e often ;,ite blatant bribery
and coercion of t/e lower oat/'bo,nd protectorsC in t/e case of ?@A@,
one infor-ant preferred t/e si-ile of a -ot/er granting favors to a
son w/o /ad pleased /er5
16E C>$1E8PLA1"ME P2>CE##
"n bot/ rit,al approac/es t/e divine power -,st be given for-
fro- t/e wo-b of E-ptiness and directed to a specific loc,sC t/e
/eart and -otive power of t/e rit,al are always t/e conte-plation of
t/e deity, w/et/er t/e practitioner is generating /i-self as t/e goddess,
evoking /er before /i-, or proBecting /er into an obBect5 "f
conte-plation is t/e /eart of t/e rit,al, t/en vis,aliFaton is its living
so,l5 1/e ability to for- a vivid pict,re of t/e deity being conte-plated
in t/e rit,al is t/e basis for all t/e ,ses to w/ic/ t/e rit,al is p,t and
t/e fo,ndation of all e-ploy-ent of t/e deity in /er f,nctions,
w/et/er to prevent /ailstor-s or to gain enlig/ten-ent% it is t/e
-eans by w/ic/ t/e power of t/e deity can be directed and t/e
forces in t/e ,niverse given s/ape5 1/e ability to control 7appearances7
is t/e affir-ation of t/e practitioner<s control of reality itself5 1/is
point is wort/ repeating% in a ,niverse w/ere all events dissolve
ontologically into E-ptiness, t/e to,c/ing of E-ptiness in t/e rit,al is
t/e re'creation of t/e world in act,alityC w/ere solid reality is b,t a
fabric of constr,ctions, t/e deity<s rit,al gestation and birt/ are no
-ere i-itation of /er pri-al genesis, b,t t/e concrete for-ation of a
sy-bolically potent reality5
6ow /ave " labo,red:
6ow /ave " not labo,red
1o bring /er so,l to birt/,
1o give t/ese ele-ents a na-e and a centreK
#/e is bea,tif,l as t/e s,nlig/t, and as fl,id5
#/e /as no na-e, and no place5
6ow /ave " labo,red to bring /er so,l into separationC
1o give /er a na-e and /er beingK
EEFra Po,nd, Ortus
6ivid appearance
1/e final goals of t/is vis,aliFation are in general s,bs,-ed ,nder
t/ree /eads% vivid appearance, pride or ego, and recollection of
p,rity5 As one infor-ant p,t it, t/e first is a clear -ental pict,re, t/e
second is one<s identification wit/ t/e pict,re, and t/e t/ird is t/e
,nderstanding of t/e -eaning of t/e pict,re5 "n one of /is te9ts
1songk<apa gives clear instr,ctions for ac/ieving t/e vivid appearance
w/ic/ is t/e basis for bot/ t/e ot/ers5 1/e practitioner first -,st
conte-plate t/e se;,ence of for-ationEt/e Process of Ieneration as
given in t/e te9t of t/e partic,lar rit,alE,ntil t/e deity is co-pleteC
b,t if t/e deity /as -any /eads and -any /ands, t/e practitioner -,st
begin by concentrating on t/e -ain face and t/e two -ain /ands,
leaving t/e ot/er faces and /ands as a ,nifor- vag,eness5 6e s/o,ld
-ake vivid in a ro,g/ way t/e parts of t/e
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
deity<s body fro- t/e top down and fro- t/e botto- ,pC and w/en
/e is able to see t/e deity for-ed as a w/ole, /e s/o,ld concentrate
,pon it one'pointedly, neit/er too slackly nor too tensely, b,t in
proper -oderation5
At first /e s/o,ld vis,aliFe only vag,ely t/e parts given in t/e
te9t w/ic/ /e is not deliberately -aking vivid, beca,se it is /ar-f,l
to /is concentration to c/ase after t/e- wit/ /is -indC and if t/e
vividness fades, /e -,st n,rse it back again ,ntil t/e deity is once
-ore vividly conte-plated5 As /e practices, all t/e parts grow -ore
and -ore vivid, ,ntil finally /e s/o,ld be able to for- a pict,re of
w/at /e is deliberately -aking vivid and to leave ,nfor-ed every=
t/ing else, t/e pict,re beco-ing so vivid t/at /e t/inks /e co,ld not
see it better wit/ /is own eyes5 "n order to concentrate /is -ind
,pon t/is vividness, /e -,st work at it steadily t/ro,g/o,t t/e en=
tire conte-plative period, free fro- drowsiness or distraction5
>nce t/e deity<s body /as appeared in t/is ro,g/ way, t/e practi=
tioner -,st practice in t/e sa-e way t/e for-ation of all t/e
s,btle parts, t/e ot/er faces and /ands, t/e orna-ents and so on5
After t/at /e -,st conte-plate t/e deity<s consort in t/e sa-e
wayC t/en /e adds on t/e ot/er deities of t/e retin,eC and finally /e
s/o,ld be able to settle /is -ind one'pointedly on a co-plete and
vivid for-ation of all t/e ro,g/ and s,btle parts si-,ltaneo,sly,
t/e entire retin,e of t/e residential palace and all t/e deities w/o
are its residents5
9!
76e s/o,ld practice t/is conte-plation fro- beginning to end,7
says 1songk<apa in anot/er te9t, 7/is -ind not giving in to drowsi=
ness or distraction, wit/ great effort settling /is -ind one'pointedly
on t/e obBect /e is conte-plating% beca,se /owever long /e -ay
yield to drowsiness or distraction, /e will grad,ally reac/ t/e point
in /is practice w/en, fro- t/e beginning to t/e end of eac/ conte-=
plative period, t/ey will no longer be able to interr,pt /i-57
99
1/e
Longdo la-a $gagwang loFang describes drowsiness and distraction
as follows% 71/ere are two sorts of drowsiness and distraction, t/e
coarse and t/e s,btleC and t/o,g/ t/is designation as s,c/ does not
appear in t/e "ndian te9ts, it was asserted by LoFang dragpa
N1songk<apaO in reply to a ;,estion by L/agsa- rabkar5 "f,
/e says, w/en one is preserving an ,nwavering conte-plation,
t/e details of t/e vis,aliFation fade a little, one /as been interr,pted
by < s,btle drowsiness5< "f t/e details disappear b,t t/e brig/tness
re-ains, <-iddling drowsiness< /as co-e ,pon one5 And if
t/e
WOR2!.&
brig/tness disappears, t/is is <great drowsiness5< 1/e defining c/ar=
acteristic of drowsiness is t/e -ental fading away, w/ile concentrat=
ing one'pointedly, of t/e 6oly >ne w/o- t/e pratitioner is atte-pt=
ing to grasp wit/ -ental vividness5 5 5 5 3istraction, on t/e ot/er
/and, is a disr,ption, as w/en so-e pleasing i-age obstr,cts t/e
Cal- of perfor-ing t/e vis,aliFation, and one is bot/ered by t/ings
in t/e category of l,st5 6ere too t/ere are s,btle and coarse types5
For one<s attention to be diverted so-eplace else w/ile concentrat=
ing ,pon t/e obBect of vis,aliFation -ay be considered a <s,btle
distraction5< For one<s attention to be diverted to t/e e9tent t/at
t/e vis,aliFation fades away is <coarse distraction5< B,t not all
diversions of attention are <distractions< in t/e tec/nical sense,
beca,se one<s attention -ay also be diverted by /atred57
1&&
1/e ability to ac/ieve single'-inded concentration on a vividly
appearing pict,re is t/e res,lt of long and really rat/er fr,strating
practice5 4e -,st re-e-berEand t/is point s/o,ld be e-p/a=
siFedEt/at t/e vis,aliFation is perfor-ed d,ring a rit,alC t/at is,
t/e practitioner is reciting a te9t Gw/ic/ is eit/er placed on a s-all
table in front of /i- or w/ic/ /e /as -e-oriFedH, and t/e vis,al=
iFation takes place in ti-e wit/ t/e r/yt/-ically c/anted te9t,al
description of t/e evocation5 "ndeed, a good percentage of any
a,t/or<s corp,s consists of precisely t/ese rit,als, e-bellis/ed and
refined according to /is own conte-plative and poetic skills5 1/e
reading of t/e rit,al te9t in t/e asse-bly /all often goes at break=
neck speed, and t/e vast -aBority of -onks are ,nable to vis,aliFe
t/at ;,ickly, if indeed t/ey are able to vis,aliFe at all5 Practice in
speed and acc,racy ca-e in a -onk<s periods of solitary conte-=
plation, w/ere t/e pace -ig/t be slowed s,fficiently to allow concen=
tration on t/e process of for-ing t/e deity, b,t t/ere was never a
break in t/e rit,al process itself, for t/e solitary yogin so ti-ed /is
conte-plative periods t/at t/ey fitted t/e str,ct,re of t/e rit,al
as a w/ole5
#peed and acc,racy are bot/ necessary, and bot/ for- t/e stand=
ard by w/ic/ is -eas,red t/e progress of one<s conte-plative ability5
1/ere are considered to be fo,r states of ability in vis,aliFation5 As
long as a pratitioner is ,nable to vis,aliFe t/e deity so vividly t/at
it appears to be -anifestly t/ere, even in B,st a ro,g/ way, /e is clas=
sified as a 7beginner57 6e beco-es 7one to w/o- a little knowledge
/as fallen7 w/en /e is able to vis,aliFe t/e entire -andala of deities
in a ro,g/ way and w/en /e is able to 7-ake it -anifest in only a
70
1
72
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
-in,te57 1/is is B,st a si-ple
vis,aliFation, /owever, co-pared wit/
t/ose called for in -ost rit,als, w/ic/
give t/e process called 7deep
conte-plation of t/e s,btle,7 /ere
referring to t/e s,btle deities t/at
-,st be pict,red in t/e vario,s places
of one<s body, 7filling one<s w/ole
body wit/ t/e -andala7 to 7e-power
t/e senses7 of t/e divinity one /as
beco-e5 >ne of t/e -ost detailed of
t/ese vis,aliFationsEact,ally rat/er a
conte-plative to,r de forceEis
fo,nd in a rit,al of I,/yasa-aBa
perfor-ed at t/e 1antric College at
1ras/il/,npo5
1&1
First t/e body is
vis,aliFed as literally a divine -ansion,
t/e -andala in w/ic/ t/e practitioner
Gnow in divine for-H will array t/e
s,btle deities%
Before and be/ind -y body, to
t/e rig/t and left, are t/e fo,r sides
of t/e -andalaC -y -o,t/ and
nose, an,s and penis, are t/e fo,r
gatesC t/e five'colored winds of -y
five knowledgesEt/e steeds of -y
constr,ctsEare t/e five'tiered wallsC
-y tong,e'perception is t/e Beweled
border, -y intestines t/e net, -y
sinews t/e /alf net, -y portion of
se-en t/e /alf'-oons, -y eye
perception t/e -irrors, -y nose
perception t/e flower garlands, -y
tong,e t/e bells, -y body t/e yak
tails, -y ear and body perceptions
t/e flags and silken strea-ers on t/e
balconiesC -y calves, t/ig/s, ,pper
and lower ar-s are t/e eig/t pillars,
-y sto-ac/ t/e flask wit/in t/e
-andala, -y ears t/e vaBra'-arked
/alf'-oons in t/e inter-ediate
directionsC -y five aggregates,
p,rified, are t/e five colors of t/e
-andalaC -y secret place, navel,
/eart, and tip of -y nose are t/e
fo,r gateways, -y eyes t/e w/eels,
-y -ind perception t/e deer and -y
nose t/e flags t/at decorate t/e
gatewaysC -y -ind is t/e lot,s in
t/e -iddleEand in t/is way all t/e
parts of -y body beco-e t/e vario,s
parts of t/e divine -ansion5
1/e practitioner t/en fills t/is body
-andala wit/ t/e t/irty'two s,btle
deities, vis,aliFing t/e- as ;,ickly as
/e reads alo,d t/e te9t,al description%
Fro- t/e top of -y /ead to t/e
/airline a w/ite >8 Gessence of t/e
aggregate of for-H transfor-s into
w/ite Mairocana, adorned on /is
crown wit/ Aksob/ya, /is t/ree faces
w/ite, black, and red, /olding in /is
t/ree rig/t /ands a w/eel, a vaBra,
and a w/ite lot,s, and in /is t/ree
left /ands a bell, a ge-, and a
sword5
Fro- -y /airline to -y t/roat a
red A6 Gessence of t/e aggregate of
conceptionH transfor-s into red
A-itab/a, adorned on /is crown
wit/ Aksob/ya, /is t/ree faces red,
black, and w/ite, /olding in /is t/ree
rig/t /ands a lot,s, a vaBra, and a
w/eel, and in /is t/ree left /ands a
lot,s bell, a ge-, and a sword5
Fro- -y t/roat to -y breast a
bl,e 6U8 Gessence of t/e
aggregate of perceptionH transfor-s
into bl,e Aksob/ya, adorned on /is
crown wit/ Aksob/ya, /is t/ree
faces black, w/ite, and red, /olding
in /is t/ree rig/t /ands a vaBra, a
w/eel, and a lot,s, and in /is t/ree
left /ands a bell, a ge-, and a
sword5
Fro- -y /eart to -y navel a
yellow #MA Gessence of t/e aggre=
gate of feelingH transfor-s into
yellow 2atnasa-b/ava, adorned on
/is crown wit/ Aksob/ya, /is t/ree
faces yellow, black, and w/ite,
/olding in /is t/ree /ands a ge-, a
vaBra, and a w/eel, and in /is t/ree
left /ands a bell, a yellow lot,s,
and a sword5
Fro- -y navel to -y t/ig/s a
green 6A Gessence of t/e aggregate
of -otivationH transfor-s into green
A-og/asidd/i, adorned on /is
crown wit/ Aksob/ya, /is t/ree
faces green, black, and w/ite,
/olding in /is t/ree rig/t /ands a
sword, a crossed vaBra, and a
w/eel, and in /is t/ree left /ands a
bell, a green lot,s, and a ge-5
1/e vis,aliFation contin,es wit/ t/e
re-aining deities% on /is navel LA8
transfor-s into t/e goddess Locana,
essence of eart/C on /is /eart 8A8
transfor-s into 8a-ak", essence of
waterC on /is t/roat pSY transfor-s
into Pandara, essence of fireC and on
t/e top of /is /ead ?SY transfor-s
into ?@A@, essence of wind5 >n /is eyes,
ears, nose, tong,e, and penis t/e
practitioner vis,aliFes in t/e sa-e way
t/e five great Bod/isattvas, eac/
arising fro- /is 7seed7 and t/,s
e-powering t/e five senses of sig/t,
/earing, s-ell, taste, and to,c/C and
t/ese e-brace t/eir five consorts, t/e
3ia-ond Ladies of for-s, so,nds,
s-ells, tastes, and tangibles5 1/e
eig/t fierce g,ardians of t/e -andala
are placed on /is /ands, ar-s,
knees, -o,t/, and penisC /is Boints are
#a-antab/adra, /is sinews are
8aitreya, and /is -ind is 8anB,sr"5
"n a rit,al evocation of
Cakrasa-vara, written by Pe-a
karpo,
1&)
t/e practitioner, after
generating /i-self as t/e deity and
vis,aliFing t/e entire retin,e of t/e
-andala abo,t /i-, pict,res an eig/t'
petaled lot,s in /is /eart on w/ic/ is
a 7knowledge being7 in t/e sa-e
divine for- as /i-self, B,st fo,r
fingers tallC on t/e fo,r petals in t/e
fo,r cardinal directions /e vis,aliFes
t/e fo,r 7inner yoginls7 of t/e
-andala, and in t/e inter-ediate
directions t/e fo,r offerings5 4it/ t/e
ring finger of /is left /and t/e
practitioner to,c/es /i-self on t/e
twenty'fo,r places of /is body, reciting
t/e following syllables and vis,aliFing
t/e- in t/eir respective places as fast
as /e recites t/e-% PU8 LA8 >8 A8
I>8 2A8 3E8 8A g A8 >8
12"8
A LA ! A H" PRE
#RE SAU SU $A S"
8A8 DU85 1/ese 7seeds7 t/en
dissolve into lig/t and 7in t/is
1
74
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
(
divine pavilion of radiance7 t/e syllables transfor- into t/e twenty'fo,r
deities of t/e o,ter circles of t/e -andala, eac/ vis,aliFed separately
and co-pletely in t/e appropriate part of t/e body, and eac/ part of
t/e body identified wit/ a great site of 1antric pilgri-age5 And t/e
yogin f,rt/er vis,aliFes t/e fe-ale g,ardians of t/e gates and
inter-ediate directions of t/e -andala g,arding t/e bodily orifices of
/is -o,t/, nose, penis, an,s, left ear, eyes and rig/t ear, 7and /is
w/ole body is filled wit/ t/e -andala57 1/en /is 7e-powered7 body
is f,rt/er 7ar-ored7 wit/ -ore deities%
>8 6A6 K >n t/e /eart of t/e Lord is MaBrasattva% w/ite, /aving
t/ree /eads Gw/ite, yellow, redH, /aving si9 ar-s Gin t/e t/ree
rig/t ones grasping vaBra, dr,-, and /ead of Bra/-a, in t/e
t/ree left ones bell, sk,ll bowl, and sk,ll staffH5
$A8A 6"K >n /is fore/ead is yellow Mairocana5
#> 6A 6U " >n t/e top of /is /ead is red 2atnasa-b/ava5
BAU #A ?S [q K >n /is two s/o,lders is black 6er,ka5
6U8 6U8 6>6 K >n /is t/ree eyes is bl,e A-itab/a5
P6A1 6A8K >n all /is li-bs is green A-og/asidd/i5 All t/ese
/ave one /ead and fo,r ar-s Gt/e first two crossed ,pon t/eir
breasts, /olding a bell and, respectively, w/eel, Bewel, vaBra,
lot,s, and crossed vaBra, t/e re-aining two grasping a dr,- and
a sk,ll bowlH, are adorned wit/ t/e acco,tre-ents of a daka,
and stand wit/ t/eir rig/t legs stretc/ed o,t5
>8 BA8K >n t/e navel of t/e 8ot/er is 3ia-ond #ow% red,
/aving t/ree /eads Gred, green, yellowH, /aving si9 ar-s Gin t/e
t/ree rig/t ones grasping c/opper, sk,ll staff, and iron /ook, in t/e
t/ree left ones sk,ll bowl, /ead of Bra/-a, and nooseH5
6A J>8 K >n /er /eart is bl,e Lady #layer'of'3eat/5
62"8 8>8 K >n /er t/roat is w/ite Lady "nfat,ation5
62E8 62"8 K >n /er /air is yellow Lady Agitation5
6U8 6U8K >n /er crest is green Lady 1error5
P6A1 P6A1 K >n all /er li-bs is green Candika5 All t/ese /ave one
/ead and fo,r ar-s Gin t/e first two c/opper and sk,ll bowl, in t/e
re-aining two sk,ll staff and dr,-H, are adorned wit/ t/e
acco,tre-ents of a dakinl, and stand wit/ t/eir left legs
stretc/ed o,t5
1/is, again, is vis,aliFed as fast as it is read alo,dC and w/en t/e
practitioner is able to vis,aliFe in all t/eir detail all t/ese s,btle
deities w/ic/ are placed in t/e body of t/e ro,g/ deity, and w/en /e is
able to 7-ake t/e- -anifest in only a -in,te,7 /e /as reac/ed t/e t/ird
level of co-petence and is called 7one w/o /as gained a little power in
knowledge57
" once asked a /ig/ly placed incarnate la-a if /e co,ld really
vis,aliFe t/e s,btle deities5 6e replied t/at, ro,g/ly and in a general
way, /e co,ldC b,t /e added t/at t/e 1oden rinpoc/<e Gt/e /ead of all
t/e yoginsH, wit/ -ore t/an fifty years of practice in vis,aliFation,
co,ld pict,re t/ese deities in perfect detail and keep track of t/e- all
at once5 1/is ability is, by t/e way, one of t/e reasons for t/e /ig/
val,e placed ,pon /aving a yogin present at a rit,al Ganot/er is t/at a
yogin is often a -ost delig/tf,l person to /ave aro,nd anywayH% /e is
one of t/e few w/o are able, t/ro,g/ long and ard,o,s training, to do
t/e vis,aliFations properly, to i-pose /is conte-plative control ,pon
t/e appearances of reality5 An incarnate la-a, too, is e9pected to /ave
spent at least one of /is past lives in t/is constant practice and, in /is
present life, to /ave t/e kar-ic e;,ivalent of w/at we wo,ld call an
innate talent for vis,aliFation5
Finally, w/en t/e practitioner reac/es t/e fo,rt/ and /ig/est
level of conte-plative ability /e is called 7one w/o /as gained
perfect power in knowledge57 6e /as attained a co-plete control of
appearancesC not only is /e able to 7-ake -anifest in only a -in,te all
t/e ro,g/ and s,btle bodies of t/e deities,7 b,t /e /as also 7reac/ed t/e
very li-its of /is own ai-, and /e is able, t/ro,g/ /is conte-plation
alone, to serve t/e ai- of ot/er beings55 5 5 6e ,nderstands t/e -agical
attain-ents, and /e is able to acco-plis/ t/e ai-s of co,ntless
ot/ers5 5 5 5 "f /e fir-ly places /i-self in E-ptiness and t/en arises
t/erefro-, /e is able t/ereby to e-power t/e appearance of anyt/ing /e
wis/es57
1&*
6e is, t/en, t/e owner of t/e ,niverse, for t/e ,nderstands
and is able to -anip,late t/e very processes t/at create t/e cos-os% /e
can dissolve reality at will and re'create it as a divine -ansion filled
wit/ deitiesC /e can prod,ce real effects ,pon ordinary appearances
by t/e -erest proBection of a -ental event5 1o know a t/ing is to own
it, and to create it fro- E-ptiness is to know it in its essence5
1o gain s,c/ conte-plative control of reality is t/e work of -any
lifeti-es5 1/e beginner learns to vis,aliFe slowly and grad,ally5
1/e process is per/aps analogo,s to learning to play a -,sical
instr,-ent, t/e st,dent enco,raged to play diffic,lt pieces straig/t
t/ro,g/ rat/er t/an devoting /i-self only to t/e -ost co-ple9
passages5 1songk<apa offers t/e following enco,raging words%
1&.
For /ow long a ti-e -,st one conte-plate before one can generate
deities w/ic/ appear vividly and distinctly : 555 "n no te9t w/ic/
sets o,t t/e lengt/ of ti-e one -,st conte-plate does anyone
L
+ #!E (1+#* OF #'R '
say t/at it takes -ore t/an a year5 6ence, if one w/o /aas accepted
/is vows and pledges, and w/o knows eno,g/ to keep t/e- well,
p,ts fort/ an ,ninterr,pted effort wit/ great striving, no very
great ti-e is necessary for /i- to co-plete t/e vivid
appearance of t/e deities of t/e -andala5 B,t if one is r,bbing sticks
rof wood toget/er to -ake afire, yet does not doit energetically
anid for a long ti-e, if /e stops to take a rest in between ti-es,
t/en t/e fire will not co-e% t/is is t/e e9a-ple t/at Arya#,ra ,sed
tos s/ow t/e necessity of working at it contin,o,sly5
1/is constant practice /as its inevitable psyc/ological effect5 7"n
general,7 says 1songk<apa, 7t/e vivid appearance of any abBect of
perception is gained si-ply by concentrating ,pon t/at obBect -ore
and -ore% it is t/,s t/e res,lt of not/ing b,t practice5 As 2igpe
wangc/<,g says%
4/en one is s/aken wit/ wis/es, fears and sorrows,
worried by t/ieves and drea-s, t/en one will see t/e-
as if placed before one even t/o,g/ t/ey are not t/ere5
1/is -eans t/at one w/o /as l,st, for e9a-ple, -ay concentrate /is
attention -ore and -ore ,pon t/e obBect of /is l,st, ,ntil /e ac=
t,ally sees t/at obBect as clearly as if it were in front cf /i-5 5 5 5
1/,s, too, it is not necessary t/at one practice ,pon a proper obBect
to prod,ce its vivid appearance% for if one practice ,pon iny obBect,
w/et/er it be perverted or not, its vivid appearance is prod,ced
nat,rally57
1&(
1/is awareness of t/e psyc/ological dangers of ,n=
controlled vis,aliFation is one of t/e reasons for t/e trection of
preparatory standards and for t/e constant insistence ,pon t/e
necessity for preli-inary practices, not only beca,se t/e -prepared
practitioner is a danger to /i-self, wit/ t/e ever'presentpossibility
of self'ind,ced /all,cinatory sc/iFop/renia, b,t also leca,se /e
presents a real t/reat to ot/ers, s/o,ld /e /appen to a/ieve any
control over reality wit/o,t being -orally prepared to /andle /is
power5
Divine Ego
$ot only -,st t/e practitioner vis,aliFe t/e deity asvividly as
possible, b,t /e -,st also, in any rit,al of evocation Gt/i is, w/en=
ever /e generates /i-self as t/e deityH, e9c/ange for /iiown ordi=
nary ego t/e ego of t/e deity, w/ic/ is t/e s,bBective corelative of
t/e e9c/ange of ordinary appearances for t/e special apearance of
WOR2!.&
t/e deity and /is retin,e of t/e -andala5 7"n all t/ese practices,7
s
ays 1songk<apa, 7one s/o,ld increasingly gain t/e ability to c,t
o
ff one<s ordinary ego t/ro,g/ G1H t/e vivid appearance of t/e deity,
and G)H t/e ego of t/e deity% and for t/at reason it is not eno,g/ B,st
to concentrate on for-ing t/e deity<s body, b,t one -,st also
concentrate ,pon -aking fir- /is ego57
1&+
1/,s t/e Process of
Ieneration, /e says, does two special t/ings% it -akes one abandon
t/e ordinary appearance of t/e 7residence and its residents,7 and
it -akes one abandon one<s clinging to t/e ordinary ego of t/e
7residence and its residents7C t/at is, t/e 7two -andalas7Et/e
dwelling and its in/abitantsEare c/anged fro- t/e ordinary world
filled wit/ people into a divine -ansion filled wit/ t/e retin,e of t/e
deity, w/o is t/e practitioner /i-self%
1&
1/is sort of conte-plationEt/e creation of 7special appearances7
as t/e residence and its residents, to n,llify 7ordinary appear=
ances7 and clinging to 7ordinary ego7Eis not fo,nd in t/e Me/icle
of t/e Perfections, and it is t/,s a special doctrine of t/e Me/icle
of t/e 8antra alone5 According to t/is e9planation of t/e Process
of IenerationEt/at it consists in t/e conte-plation of t/e resi=
dence as a divine -ansion and of its residents as deitiesEit is
G1H by conte-plating t/e 7special appearance7 of t/e residence
for-ed as a divine -ansion and of its residents for-ed as deities
t/at one n,llifies 7ordinary appearances,7 and it is G)H by conte-=
plating wit/ co-plete certainly, t/inking 7" a- Aksob/ya7 or
7" a- Mairocana7 and so on, t/at one n,llifies one<s 7ordinary
ego57 5 5 5 "t says in -any te9ts t/at 7one -,st clear away one<s
ordinary ego7% and t/,s t/e conte-plation of t/e ego of t/e
-andalas of residence and residents, as an antidote to one<s
7ordinary ego,7 is t/e -ost i-portant t/ingC and t/e conte-plation
of t/e 7special appearance7 of t/e residence and residents, to
n,llify 7ordinary appearances,7 is b,t a s,bsidiary of t/e for-er5
"t is only w/en one /as first t,rned away fro- one<s ordinary ego,
/e says, t/at one -ay e9c/ange for it t/e ego of t/e deity5 For
e9a-ple, at t/e -o-ent t/e knowledge being descends into one,
one casts away one<s grasping of one<s for-er essence, w/atever it
-ay been, and t/inks 7" a- t/e deity K7 $ow t/is t/o,g/t is artifi=
cial, a 7t/ing of -ere words,7 insofar as one still t/inks 7" a- Aks=
ob/ya, or Mairocana,7 and so on, as if one were still an ordinary
beingC it is by t/e grad,al transfor-ation of t/is artificial t/o,g/t
t/at one finally gains t/e special and gen,ine ego of t/e deity5
1&!
Elsew/ere, 1songk<apa describes t/e act,al tec/ni;,e of reac/ing
t/is co-plete identification wit/ t/e deity%
1&9
77
! #!E (1+# OF #'R'
"n t/e practice of 7ego,7 one generates an ego w/ic/ t/inks
7" a- t/at deity,7 and one dwells t/ereon one'pointedly5 "f its
strengt/ s/o,ld fade, one s/o,ld n,rse back t/e strengt/ of t/e
deity<s ego as we /ave described previo,sly Nfor 7vivid appear=
ance,7 aboveO and settle oneself t/erein5 3oing it in t/is way, at
first it will be b,t an artificial t/o,g/tC b,t if, after
conte-plating it 5 5 5 t/e deity<s ego beco-es fir-, /e can
abandon /is -ind t/erein and be able to e9c/ange t/e ego of a
deity for /is own ego of an ordinary being, and do so t/ro,g/o,t
all of t/e conte-plative periods, and even between t/e-5
>f t/e two t/ingsEt/e vivid appearance of t/e deity and t/e ego
of t/e deityE/e s/o,ld vis,aliFe eac/ in t,rn, beginning wit/ t/e
for-er, and n,rse t/at along5 1/en, if /e can conte-plate t/e
7special appearance7 of t/e residence and its residents and bear
it contin,ally in -ind, if /e can cast o,t fro- /is -ind t/e 7ordi=
nary appearances,7 so t/at t/ey can no longer arise, and for- t/e
7special appearance7 aloneEt/en will /is -ind be p,rified of
7ordinary appearances7% and if /e can e9c/ange for /is own a
gen,ine divine ego, as we /ave e9plained above, t/en will /is
-ind be p,rified of its clinging to /is 7ordinary ego57 1/en,
arising fro- /is deep conte-plation, w/atever 7appearances7
t/ere -ay be of t/e ani-ate or inani-ate worlds, /e sees t/e-
all as t/e deities and t/eir divine -ansionC /is deep conte-plation
beco-es bot/ fir- and nat,ral, and /ence /e is co,nted as /aving
p,rified, wit/ t/e Process of Ieneration, /is 7ordinary appear=
ance7 and /is clinging to 7ordinary ego57 5 5 5
As Aryadeva says% 7"f yo, know t/at all t/ese vario,s t/ings
are t/e retin,e of t/e -andala, /ow can yo, ever be conf,sed:7
And again, 1songk<apa says% 7>n t/ese occasions, one -,st evoke
t/e <vivid appearance< of t/e deity, and so one -,st -ake /i- -ore
and -ore vivid t/ro,g/ discri-inating conte-plation5 6ere, one
first perfor-s t/e rit,al of Ieneration% t/en, after t/e partic,lar
residence and its residents /ave been vividly vis,aliFed Gb,t before
proceeding to t/e recitation of t/e -antraH 5 5 5 one s/o,ld generate
as well t/e ego w/ic/ t/inks < " a- really /e<Eand bot/ of t/ese -,st
be done5 5 5 5 1/is is not si-ply bearing in -ind s,c/ aspects as t/e
body'color, t/e faces and /ands and so on of Mairocana or Akso'
b/ya, etc5, taking t/ose t/ings to be t/eir <ego<% b,t rat/er one -,st
vis,aliFe oneself as really being a B,dd/a w/o /as obtained all
;,alities and /as e9/a,sted all obsc,rations5 5 5 5 1/,s if one gains
t/e ability to root o,t one<s <ordinary appearances< and clinging to
<ordinary ego,< wit/ t/e power to e9c/ange t/e- for <special
appearance< and <special ego< fro- t/e beginning of eac/ conte-'
WOR2!.&
nlative period ,ntil its endEt/en after t/at one -,st go on to
settle one<s -ind fir-ly t/erein, gaining t/e power to be wit/o,t
any accidental relapse in body or -ind5 1/en it is no longer neces=
sary to do t/ings like contin,ally t/ink < " a- t/e deity,< for once
one /as generated a gen,ine divine ego /e is able t/ereby to c,t off
/is ordinary ego entirely5 For e9a-ple, s,ppose so-eone /as fallen
to a non'/,-an destiny% t/o,g/ /is -ind is tro,bled t/ereby, /e
does not i-pose ,pon /is e9perience t/e -ental constr,ct < " a- a
non'/,-an<C b,t rat/er, as long as /e e9periences /is kar-a, t/e
concept <>nce " was a /,-an< si-ply does not arise57
11&
4e -ay easily see t/e soteriological t/r,st of t/is evocation% t/e
practitioner ac;,ires a divine ego, t/e total cessation of any -erely
/,-an personality, acco-panied by t/e act,al re'creation of t/e
world as a divine -ansion for /is dwelling5 Even in t/ose rit,als of
evocation w/ose intent is -anip,latory, w/erein t/e power of t/e
deity is applied to specific, even worldly, ends Gas w/en t/e practi=
tioner vis,aliFes, say, a person w/o- /e wis/es to s,bB,gate as bo,nd
naked before /i-, to be do-inated by t/e -antraH, we find t/e intro=
d,ctory p/rase, 76aving grasped t/e ego of t/e deity5557 1/e per=
-anent ac;,isition of t/is ego d,ring t/e lengt/y self'generation in
t/e deity<s prior rit,al service is a prere;,isite to following t/is in=
str,ction, and possession of t/is ego is necessary for t/e -agical
-anip,lation of t/e divine power before one% to e9ercise a godlike
power over reality, one -,st indeed be a god5 1o ;,ote 1songk<apa
one -ore ti-e%
111
4/en one grasps t/e -andalas of residence and residents and t/e
ego t/ereof, t/en one is able to e9c/ange t/at ego for one<s own,
as e9plained above, as long as t/ere are no accidental relapses5
And w/en one vividly vis,aliFes t/ose two -andalasEvis,aliFing
t/eir 7vivid appearance7 as vividly as one can, and t/ereby n,lli=
fying t/e 7ordinary appearance7 of one<s 1r,e 8indEone effec=
tively n,llifies bot/ 7ordinary appearances7 and clinging to 7or=
dinary ego57 B,t it is ins,fficient for one -erely to be able to
n,llify t/ose for a little w/ileC it is necessary t/at t/is be -ade
;,ite fir-5 And w/en a 3ia-ond 8aster Gw/o /as properly
perfor-ed /is prior rit,al service by a -et/od s,c/ as t/isH per=
for-s for e9a-ple a protection rit,al against /indering de=
-ons 5 5 5 /e gen,inely generates t/e deity and /is ego w/en /e
recites 7Ilorio,s MaBrad/ara 5 5 5 7 "f /e /as not done so, /e gains
an ego of -ere words, and /ence it is said t/at prior rit,al service
is of t/e ,t-ost i-portance5
9
!&
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
'
WOR2!.
&
!1
Recollection of &urity
A practitioner w/o can t/,s for-, at will, t/ese special appearances
and special ego is in conscio,s control of bot/ /is e9ternal and internal
reality% t/e world /e lives in is one of /is own c/oosing, one t/at /e
owns5 1/ere is a f,rt/er conte-plative e9ercise to reinforce t/e
sy-bolic potency of t/is new reality, called t/e 7recollection of p,rity,7
w/ic/ is a -editation ,pon t/e i-plicit -eaning of t/e divine i-age
t/e practitioner /as vividly vis,aliFed and ,pon t/e ontological val,es
of /is new identity5 "n so-e conte-plative rit,als t/e recollection of
p,rity is perfor-ed i--ediately after t/e vivid appearance and
before t/e e9c/ange of egos, w/ile in ot/ers it is perfor-ed last of
t/e t/ree5 1/e sy-bolic interpretations of t/e deity w/o- t/e
practitioner /as beco-e are often rat/er farfetc/ed and obvio,sly
after t/e factC and t/e sa-e interpretations are often applied to
different deities, since B,dd/ist p/ilosop/y is so fond of n,-erical
lists t/at it can easily provide a -eaning for anyt/ing t/at can be
en,-erated5 B,t t/e conte-plative e9ercise is an antidote to any
reification of t/e vis,aliFed deityC t/e practitioner is re-inded t/at /e
/as beco-e not a t/ing b,t an e9pression, t/at /is new set of
appearances, ontologically B,st as false or as real as /is old set, is at least
-eaningf,l sy-bolically in a way t/at /is old reality, 7fabricated and
constr,ed,7 co,ld not /ave been, and /e is provided by its very
artificiality wit/ a cl,e to t/e so,rce of all appearances and a
-ec/anis- for ,nderstanding t/eir genesis5 1/,s it is a recollection of
purityC t/e vis,aliFation is p,re of any constr,ct of reality i-posed ,pon
it, B,st as all t/e events of /is ordinary appearances were p,re, co,ld
t/ey /ave been ,nderstood as t/e 7"nnate Union of appearance and
E-ptiness57 Every alternate realityEordinary or divineEis
-eaningf,l only insofar as it is E-ptyC ot/erwise t/ere co,ld be no
interpenetration of -eaning, and /ence t/ere co,ld be no -agic5
As an e9a-ple of t/is type of -editation, $agarB,na gives t/e
following 7e9planation of t/e co-plete p,rity of t/e vis,aliFation7%
11)
1/e single face of t/e C/ief Lady is t/e ,nderstanding of all events as
a single knowledge5 1/e green color of /er body is power in all
f,nctions5 6er two /ands are t/e ,nderstanding of t/e two tr,t/s%
/er rig/t /and t/e conventional tr,t/, /er left /and t/e absol,te
tr,t/5 6er rig/t foot stretc/ed o,t is t/e abandon-ent of all t/e
defects of 8araC /er left foot drawn back is t/e ,nderstanding of all
;,alities5 6er adorn-ent wit/ all orna-ents is t/e
co-pletion of t/e stocks of -erit and knowledge5 5 55 6er rig/t
/and in t/e gift'bestowing gest,re is t/e co-pletion of t/e Per=
fection of C/arityC /er left /and in t/e protection gest,re is t/e
g,arding of all beings fro- terror5 6er /olding t/e lot,s flower is
t/e giving of Boy to all beings5 6er being si9teen years of age is
t/e ability to acco-plis/ t/e ai-s of all beings5 6er t/rone of t/e
orb of t/e -oon is t/e possession of 4isdo-, and /er t/rone of a
varicolored lot,s is t/e possession of an essence of Co-passion5
16E C>$1E8PLA1"ME 2EAL"1J
1/is sy-bolic reality is rendered even -ore potent by t/e process of
its creation, t/e way in w/ic/ t/e divine power is given for- and
directed toward an end5 "t is t/e power of t/e deity w/ic/ after all is
evoked fro- t/e real- of E-ptiness by t/e Process of IenerationC it is
a divine reality t/e practitioner creates, and into w/ic/ /e gives
/i-self birt/5
Even -ore striking is t/e assertion t/at t/e yogin not only
creates /is own reality b,t also i-poses it at will ,pon ot/ers, t/at /is
ability to control t/e ,niverse e9tends also to t/e appearances
perceived by ot/er people% /e -ay -ake /i-self appear invisible, or
bea,tif,l, to t/e-C /e -ay s,bB,gate or destroy si-ply by vis,aliFing t/e
effect /e wis/es to bring abo,tC /e -ay generate a person or a de-on
into an effigy and destroy it ,tterly5 6ere is a present danger in
,ncontrolled conte-plation, and t/e te9ts are f,ll of warnings of t/e
dreadf,l fate of practitioners w/o -is,se t/eir powerC b,t /ere too
t/e social benefits are clear, for a practitioner -ay e9ercise /is reality'
creating power, for e9a-ple, to trick a de-on into t/inking t/at a
7s,bstit,te7 or 7ranso-7 isEt/at is, 7appears as7Et/e real obBect of
/is -alevolence5 1/e yogin can c/ange t/e weat/er, re-ove spirit,al
/indrances fro- /is followers, and spread virt,e a-ong /is people5 #o
potent is t/e vis,aliFation of a great yogin t/at /e -ay appear to /is
disciples as t/e very deity w/ose vivid appearance and ego /e /as
grasped5 1/is /appens especially, we are told, d,ring initiations,
w/ere t/e yogin first generates /i-self as t/e deity before trans-itting
t/e divine power to /is followers5 "n /is a,tobiograp/y, 8ila repa gives
t/e following acco,nt of /is depart,re fro- t/e /o-e of /is g,r,
8arpa%
11*
8y g,r, said to /is wife% 73a-e-a, set o,t t/e food and t/e
e9cellent offerings ,pon t/e altar5 8ila is abo,t to go now, and "
/ave given /i- -y per-ission57
1
!) #!E (1+# OF N
8y 8ot/er laid o,t t/e offerings to t/e g,r,s and /ig/ patrc
2
deities, t/e tor-as for t/e dakinis and protectors of t/e Law, ar
d
t/e e9cellent feast for -y 3ia-ond Brot/ers5 And before tl
Ne
asse-bly -y g,r, appeared as t/e /ig/ patron deities 6evaBrc
Cakrasa-vara, and I,/yasa-aBa, as t/eir e-ble-s GvaBra, beB<
w/eel, ge-, lot,s, sword, and so onH, as t/e syllables >8 Ac
6U8, w/ite, red, and bl,e, as a drop of brilliant lig/t, and fBt
nally disappeared altoget/er5
1/ese -any t/ings 8arpa s/owed, and /e said% 71/ese t/inc
" /ave for-ed are called -agical transfor-ations of t/e bod<
1/ey -,st never be s/own on a spirit of false/oodC b,t " /ac
s/own t/e- now as a parting gift for 8ila repa57
6aving seen -y g,r, as t/e B,dd/a in act,ality, " felt i--ec
s,rable Boy, and " t/o,g/t t/at " too -,st obtain t/ro,g/ conterc
plation -agic power s,c/ as /is5 8y g,r, said% 78y son, did uv
w
see: 3id yo, believe:7 And " replied% 7" saw, and " co,ld -
Ht
/elp b,t believeC and " t/o,g/t t/at " too -,st do likewi
Be
t/ro,g/ -y conte-plation57
6e said% 78y son, t/at is good5 And now yo, -ay go5 " /aC
e
s/own yo, t/at all events are ill,soryC so do yo, e9perience Iik
3
_
wise, ad/ering to t/e rocky wastes, t/e snowy ranges, and t/e so Bt
tary forests5 5 5 5 "n t/ese places -ake evocation yo,r foreino,c
ai-57
5 5 5 And wit/ tears flowing down /e said% 78y son, we tv
P
s/all not -eet again in t/is life5 " s/all not forget yo,C do nr
Ht
forget -e5 "f yo, do as " /ave said, s,rely we will -eet again
n
t/e celestial real-s57
#he (onstruction of Reality
1/is conceptEt/at t/e yogin<s i-agination can create not Vdx
none-pirical states of -ind b,t also none-pirical states of reali
Eis so startling to o,r own pres,ppositions t/at we -ig/t wfBB
e9a-ine briefly so-e of t/e c,lt,ral a9io-s ,pon w/ic/ it is baseBt
6ere " propose t/ree -odels to aid o,r ,nderstanding, based B
n
4estern concepts of sc/iFop/renia, s,rrealis-, and alc/e-y5
"t wad Fre,d w/o bro,g/t into t/e -ainstrea- of psyc/ologicc
t/o,g/t t/e idea of t/e reality of w/at p/ilosop/ers /ad long callr
d
t/e 7i-agination,7 a t/eory t/at do-inated p/ilosop/ical t/inkiig
,ntil abo,t 19*(, t/at t/e i-agination is a realiFing fac,lty, 7i-ag,
s
tending of t/e-selves to i-pose on ,s and presenting t/e-selves B
s
real7
11.
E7real7 insofar as t/ey /ave real effects ,pon t/e persoc
b,t not 7real7 as acting in t/e world5 1/e pres,-ption is alwa,
s
t/at reality as perceived is so-e/ow /ard or solidEa -etap/or f
Hr
7p,blic7Eand t/at t/e i-agination f,nctions only to prod,,
e
WOR2!.&
private i-ages5 71/e -entally ill,7 one a,t/or typically says, 7are
for t/e -ost part people w/o are living in t/e real- w/ere ideas /ave
t/e val,e of reality57
11(
#t,dies in psyc/edelic 7i-agination7 /ave
tended to affir- t/is pres,-ption even w/ile do,bting it%
11+
1/e percept,al c/anges were not c/anges in perception of t/e e9=
ternal world b,t rat/er c/anges in t/e ;,ality of internal i-agery5
.magery, /owever, is too -ild a word for t/e #s e9periences, as
it connotes so-et/ing less intense t/an perception of e9ternal
;,alities, less 7real,7 yet for t/e #s t/eir internal perceptions were
in no way less real or less vivid t/an t/eir ordinary sense'percep=
tions5 1/ey were also -,c/ -ore vivid and real t/an t/eir ,s,al
i-agery5 F,rt/er, t/e 7sensory7 ;,alities of t/e internal i-agery
were often more vivid t/an ordinary sense perceptions5
A sc/iFop/renic, it is felt, creates a reality, -,c/ as does t/e yogin,
b,t it is a personal reality of terror and e9cl,sion, ,ns/ared and
t/erefore i-aginary5 25 35 Laing reports /ow a patient na-ed
La-es evoked a -agical ,niverse%
11
6is 7self7, as it was only partially real'iFed even in and t/ro,g/
relations/ip wit/ ot/ers w/o s/ared /is views, beca-e -ore and
-ore ca,g/t ,p in, and itself a part of, t/e world of -agic5 1/e
obBects of p/antasy or i-agination obey -agical lawsC t/ey /ave
-agical relations/ips, not real relations/ips5 4/en t/e 7self7 be=
co-es -ore and -ore a participant in p/antasy relations/ips,
less and less a participant in real relations/ips, in doing so it loses
its own reality5 "t beco-es, like t/e obBects to w/ic/ it is related,
a -agical p/anto-5 >ne i-plication of t/is is t/at, for s,c/ a
7self,7 everyt/ing and anyt/ing beco-es possible, ,n;,alified,
as even every wis/ -,st be sooner or later, by reality, necessity,
t/e conditioned and finite5 "f t/is is not so, t/e 7self7 can be any=
one, be anyw/ere, and live at any ti-e5 4it/ La-es t/is was
co-ing to be t/e case5 7"n i-agination7 t/e conviction was grow=
ing and gat/ering of /aving p/antastic powers5
"n a very real sense, it is in t/is world of -agical o-nipotence and
private freedo- t/at a 1ibetan practitioner livesC /e is t/e -aster of
a divine reality created by /is own i-agination5 Even on t/is level,
/owever, w/ere psyc/ologist and yogin agree on t/e privacy of t/e
e9perience, t/ere is a difference5 1/e yogin goes fort/ to add a reality
to /is repertoire of awarenessC /e does not create one ,niverse in
frig/tened retreat fro- anot/er5 For t/e sc/iFop/renic, says Laing,
o-nipotence is based on i-potence, freedo- operates in a vac,,-,
and activity is wit/o,t life5
83
#!E (6+# OF #'R'
!(
Piece by piece " see-
to re'enter t/e world% " first begin
a s-all, fi9ed dot, " still can see t/at old
-yself, a darkbl,e t/,-btack
p,s/ed into t/e scenes,
a /ard little /ead protr,ding
fro- t/e pointillist<s b,FF and bloo-5 After
a ti-e t/e dot
begins to ooFe5 Certain /eats -elt
it5
$ow " was /,rriedly
bl,rring into ranges
of b,rnt red, b,rning green,
w/ole biograp/ies swa- ,p and
swallowed -e 5 5 5
1ill, wolfed al-ost to s/reds, "
learned to -ake -yself
,nappetiFing5 #caly as a dried b,lb
t/rown into a cellar
" ,sed -yself, let not/ing ,se -e 5 5 5 E
Adrienne 2ic/, %%
1/is poe- sets fort/ an e9perience t/at is a re-arkable parallel, as we
s/all see, to t/e Process of IenerationC as 1songk<apa said, t/e creation
of s,c/ a reality is 7nat,ral7 w/en one is 7s/aken wit/ wis/es, fears
and sorrows, worried by t/ieves and drea-s57 6ere again we see t/e
pri-ary i-portance of t/e rit,aliFation of -oral attit,des for t/e 1ibetan
conte-plative% t/e i-agination t/at evokes a ,niverse belongs to one
w/o is already a Bod/isattva, w/o /as awakened t/e t/o,g/t of
enlig/ten-ent for t/e benefit of all beings, and w/o creates /is -agical
reality fro- a real- t/at is not only e-pty and ,nlabelable b,t also
7wis/less57 1/e yogin conscio,sly bases /is -agical power ,pon /is
,nderstanding and /ence ,pon /is control of /i-self and /is realityC t/e
sc/iFop/renic<s power is based not on control b,t on c/aos%
11!
w/en t/e 7centre7 fails to /old Nwrites LaingO, neit/er self'
e9perience nor body'e9perience can retain identity, integrity,
co/esiveness, or vitality, and t/e individ,al beco-es precipitated into
a condition t/e end res,lt of w/ic/ we s,ggested co,ld best be
described as a state of 7c/aotic nonentity57
1/e yogin, indeed, ,ndergoes a tre-endo,s alteration in 7self'
e9perience7 and 7body'e9perience7C /e alters appearances to gain a
divine body and a divine ego, yet /e is always ,nder t/e /old of a
controlling 7centre57 B,t to t/e conte-platively ,nprepared, to
t/ose not i-pelled by t/e i-pet,s of avowed -oral p,rpose, t/e very
power of t/e -ind over reality is a naked /elplessness, as t/e body
disintegrates before t/e devo,ring i-agination%
1/e anc/ored -ind
screwed into -e by t/e
sky<s psyc/o'lascivio,s
t/r,st
is t/e one t/at i-agines all te-ptations all
desires all in/ibitions EAntonin Arta,d,
'rtaud le 9omo
118
"n s,c/ an altered state of awareness, perception beco-es non'
e-piricalC /ard reality softens and dissolves, to beco-e, in Adrienne
2ic/<s words, 7trenc/ant in -otion as an eel, solid as a cabbage'
/ead57 1o -any psyc/ologists, t/is is t/e res,lt of a conf,sion of
categories%
1)&
>ne of Byc/owski<s patients, w/en asked w/ere /er /,sband was,
answered t/at /e was on t/e wedding pict,re5 6ere t/e real- of
reality and t/e real- of representation are not kept apart5 1/e
facility of t/e sc/iFop/renic in separating t/e real-s of reality and
i-agination is notorio,sly i-paired5 Contrary to so'called nor-al
t/inking, w/ic/ /as to keep wit/in t/e sa-e real- or fra-e of
reference or ,niverse of disco,rse, t/e t/inking of t/e sc/iFop/renic is
s,bBect to little deter-ining infl,ence fro- t/e ,nitary field5
6ere t/e real-s of reality and i-agination are a9io-atically taken
as separate fields, and /ere t/e psyc/ologist and t/e yogin part
co-pany5 A 1ibetan finds it a strange a9io- to say t/at a p,blic
reality is necessarily -ore real t/an a private one, or even to pres,-e a
priori t/at t/ere is a bo,ndary between t/e two5 P,blic reality is as
a-enable to -agical control as private realityC t/e basis for
!+
#!E (1+# OF #'R '
WOR2!.& !
control is owners/ip, and t/e fo,ndation of owners/ip is ,nder=
standing% to know a t/ing is to possess it, and to possess it is to be able
to -anip,late it5 7E-ptiness7 is t/e -agic word t/at na-es t/e essence
of t/e ,niverseC again, as in -any -agical traditions, to na-e a t/ing
by its tr,e na-eEt/e secret essence of t/e t/ingEis to own it, and to
,nderstand /ow p,blic reality evolves fro- E-pti ness into awareness or
perception is to be free of its bonds of ordinary ca,sality, to be free, in
B,dd/ist ter-s, of 7being57 1/is p,blic reality is to t/e yogin
e9perientially and literally a nonreality w/erein all events are ill,soryC
it is B,st as tr,e and B,st as false as t/e reality /e /i-self can evoke
fro- E-ptiness, in t/e sa-e way as p,blic nonreality is evoked into
awareness by t/e action of kar-a5 As is said in t/e !eva-ra #anlra
N""5ii5.+'(1O%
4it/ t/e very portion of poison w/ic/ slays all ot/ers
/e w/o knows t/e essence of poison re-oves poison 5 5 5 5
4it/ t/e sa-e savage kar-a w/ic/ binds all ot/ers
/e w/o /as t/e 8eans is freed fro- t/e bonds of being5
1/e world is bo,nd by passion, and by passion it is freed%
renegade B,dd/ists do not know t/is reverse conte-plation5
"ndeed, t/e Cartesian d,alis- t/at is t/e psyc/ologists< -a9i- /as
not been ,nc/allenged even in t/e 4est% it was a disciple of Fre,d
na-ed Andre Breton w/o Gas #pinoFa to 3escartesH took t/e
i-agination fro- t/e real- of t/e totally s,bBective and began to break
once again t/e ontological bo,ndaries between t/e i-age and t/e obBect5
"n /is First 2urrealist 9anifesto
1"1
Breton wrote% 7Per/aps t/e
i-agination is on t/e verge of recovering its rig/ts5 "f t/e dept/s of o,r
-inds conceal strange forces capable of a,g-enting or con;,ering t/ose
on t/e s,rface, it is in o,r greatest interest to capt,re t/e-57 Five
years later, in t/e 2econd 2urrealist 9anifesto, /e again talked of t/e
i-agination, t/e 7vital and /ig/est fac,lty of t/e -ind,7 as t/e
ill,-inator and not t/e falsifier of reality, as t/e ,nveiler of /idden
Fones% 7"-agination alone,7 /e writes, 7-akes -e realiFe w/at can $e 4
4 57
1))
4e wo,ld give yo, kingdo-s vast and strange
w/ere t/e -ystery in flowers gives itself to t/ose w/o pl,ck it
t/ere are new fires of colors never seen
a t/o,sand -ysterio,s p/anto-s
w/ic/ we -,st say are real
EI,illa,-e Apollinaire, (alligrammesG
%
72eality, t/en,7 says Breton<s biograp/er Anna Balakian, 7in its
dyna-ic sense proceeding fro- an interior state, n,rt,red by w/at Wwe
call i-agination, and bro,g/t to an e9terior e9istence, 5 5 5 is w/at
Breton calls t/e < s,rreal,< in a sense t/at it /as no connection wit/ t/e
unreal4<
1"1
And t/,s, too, t/e i-age is no private ill,sion, b,t rat/er
-ay be 7real'iFed7 in t/e artistic obBect% 7t/e i-aginary,7 in Breton<s
definition, 7is w/at tends to beco-e real57
1)(
And Pa,l El,ard says%
1)+
7"-ages are, i-ages live, and everyt/ing beco-es i-age5 1/ey were
long -istaken for ill,sions beca,se t/ey were restricted, were -ade to
,ndergo t/e test of reality, an insensitive and dead reality57
1/,s to Breton, e9panding ,pon Fre,d and Bergson, t/e i-agination
is an o-nipotent power t/at, dwelling wit/in t/e -ental dept/s, -,st
be bro,g/t to t/e s,rface t/ro,g/ t/e drea-, t/ro,g/ free association,
t/ro,g/ a,to-atic writing, and t/ro,g/ -adness itselfC and t/e i-age,
once s,rfaced, is t/r,st into t/e reality wit/ all t/e s/ock and clas/ of
a drea- revelation5 2eality to t/e s,rrealist beco-es, in El,ard<s
words, 7alive, and perpet,ally -oving7C it beco-es 7none-pirical57
El,ard wrote in #he 2urrealist RevolutionC 71/e drea- alone entr,sts
to -an all /is rig/ts to freedo-5 1/anks to t/e drea-, t/e -eaning of
deat/ is no longer -ysterio,s, and t/e -eaning of life beco-es
,ni-portant57
1)
Breton<s friend 2obert 3esnos co,ld fall into a state of
drea-ing at t/e slig/test provocation and prod,ce a ric/ flow of verbal
i-ages for /is ad-iring colleag,es5 #alvador 3ali intentionally
c,ltivated /is sense of paranoia, crystalliFing 7t/e ,nbridled force of /is
-ind to contract an infinite n,-ber of free associations between
obBects, and t/ro,g/ t/e representation of t/ese /e was to s,ggest a
totally fl,id ,niverse s/aped according to t/e artist<s private
spec,lations57
1)!
"t t/rows a s/arp -etap/orical lig/t ,pon t/e world of t/e 1ibetan
yogin to say t/at /e lives in t/is totally fl,id s,rrealist ,niverse, t/at /is
vis,aliFation creates a s,rrealist i-aginary landscape proBected ,pon t/e
very fabric of realityC /is private real- of freedo- and power is
indeed an ec/o of Breton<s r/etorical ;,estion, 74/at if everyt/ing in
t/e Beyond is act,ally /ere, now, in t/e present, wit/ ,s:7
1)9
Ferdinand Al;,ie -ig/t well be describing t/e 1ibet ans% 71/ey ad-it,
t/en, -ore or less e9plicitly, t/e post,lates of t/is conception%
identity of sensation and i-age, proper e9istence of i-ages, power of
act,aliFation in/erent in t/e i-age57
1*&
#!E (1+# OF #'R' !9
1/is provocative s,rrealist -odel,
/owever, gives only a li-ited analog,e
for t/e total collapse of t/e bo,ndary
between t/e p,blic and private
,niverses5 4/at t/e s,rrealists call
t/eir 7-agic7 indeed increases t/e
repertoire of awareness, adding t/e
i-aginary to t/e obBective at t/e
sa-e ontological level5 B,t w/ere t/e
s,rrealist i-age is t/r,st ,pon a
reality already given in e9perience,
t/e 1ibetan yogin sees t/e co-plete
and absol,te interpenetration of t/e
two ,nitary fields5 6is i-age and /is
obBect are not s,peri-posed, b,t
rat/er are pri-ordially one, and t/is
is w/at -akes possible /is -agical
ability to -anip,late t/e ,niverse5
$evert/eless, it was in t/e 4estern
-agical tradition t/at t/e s,rrealists
fo,nd one of t/eir -ost fr,itf,l so,rces
of ideas5 1/e o-nipotence of t/e
controlled i-agination is a central
concept in bot/ -agic and alc/e-y,
w/ere t/e bo,ndaries bl,r even -ore
dra-atically, and 7t/e vis
imaginativa is nearly always present,
for it is t/e f,nda-ental, central force,
and t/e ot/ers are ,s,ally ,sed only as
aids to /eig/tening it or ways of
co--,nicating it57
1*1
Fro- t/is
tradition t/e concept of t/e vera
imaginatlo entered into t/e occ,lt
7,ndergro,nd,7 to s,rface occasionally
in s,c/ diverse persons as Aleister
Crowley G7t/e wickedest -an in
England7H, 4illia- B,tler Jeats, and
Andre Breton /i-self, w/o /ad read
t/e t/irteent/'cent,ry alc/e-ist
2ay-ond L,lle and was deeply
,nfl,enc'ed by Elip/as Levi, t/e 19t/'
cent,ry visionary and -ag,s of 7tran=
scendental -agic7%
1*)
A-ong t/e antino-ies, t/e -aBor one
t/at Levi attacks is t/e antit/esis
between spirit,al and -aterialC to /i-
it is -erely a -atter of degree of
opacity or of lig/tC 7#pirit,al and
corporeal are si-ply ter-s w/ic/
e9press t/e degrees of ,nity or
density in s,bstance57 8an /as in /i-
t/e power to transfor- t/e opa;,e into
t/e transl,centC Elip/as Levi defines
t/is power as imagination4 71o
i-agine is to see7 0Donner a voir will
reiterate t/e s,rrealistKH, and to see is to
crystalliFe, to render diaphane or
7transparent7C t/at is, i-agination is
not t/e creator of ill,sion, b,t t/e
ill,-inator of reality5 7"-agination, in
effect, is like t/e so,l<s eyeC t/erein
for-s are o,tlined and preservedC
t/ereby we be/old t/e reflections of
t/e invisible worldC it is t/e glass of
visions and t/e apparat,s of -agical
life57
Levi is /ere rendering in its typically
-aterialist ter-s a concept t/at /ad been
-olded by so-e of t/e -aBor fig,res of
t/e 2enaissance5 1o t/e -agician
Iiordano Br,no, writes Frances Jates,
7t/is -agically ani-ated i-agination is
t/e < sole gate to all internal
aff
ec
tio
ns
an
d
t/
e
lin
k
of
lin
ks
5<
Br
,n
o<s
la
ng
,a
ge
is
e9
cit
ed
an
d
ob
sc
,r
e
as
/e
e9po,nds t/is, to /i-, central
-ystery, t/e conditioning of t/e
i-agination in s,c/ a way as to draw
into t/e personality spirit,al and
de-onic forces w/ic/ will ,nlock its
inner powers57
1**
B,t t/is 7i-agination7 of t/e -ag,s
works o,twardly as well as inwardly,
and t/ese 7spirit,al and de-onic
forces7 are -oved beyond t/e
-agician<s -ind5 #endivogi,s, w/ose
alc/e-ical work is incl,ded in t/e
9usaeum hermelicum, writes%
1o ca,se t/ings /idden in t/e
s/adow to appear, and to take away
t/e s/adow fro- t/e-, t/is is
per-itted to t/e intelligent p/ilos=
op/er by Iod t/ro,g/ nat,re5 5 5 5
All t/ese t/ings /appen, and t/e
eyes of co--on -en do not see
t/e-, b,t t/e eyes of t/e -ind and of
t/e i-agination perceive t/e- wit/
tr,e and tr,est vision5
78atter,7 says ] I5 L,ng, 7is t/,s
for-ed by ill,sion, w/ic/ is
necessarily t/at of t/e alc/e-ist5 1/is
ill,sion -ig/t well be t/e vera
imaginatio possessed of <infor-ing<
power57
1*.
$ote t/at -atter is for-ed
by ill,sionEa -agical and creative
powerErat/er t/an by /all,cinationC
reality, in t/e alc/e-ical art, is
controlled by t/e tr,e i-agination5
8artin 2,land, in /is +e/icon
alchemiae, defines t/is imaginatio as
7t/e star in -an, t/e celestial or s,per'
celestial body,7 and L,ng again
co--ents% 71/is asto,nding definition
t/rows ;,ite a special lig/t on t/e
fantasy processes associated wit/ t/e
opus4 4e /ave to conceive of t/ese
processes not as t/e i--aterial
p/anto-s we readily take fantasy'
pict,res to be, b,t as so-et/ing
corporeal5 5 5 5 1/e imaginatio, or act of
i-agining, is t/,s a p/ysical activity t/at
can be fitted into t/e cycle of -aterial
c/anges, t/at brings t/ese abo,t57
1*(
Alkindi, a,t/or of t/e #heoria artis
magicae, e9plains t/ese -aterial effects
by s,pposing t/at t/e i-agination /as
7rays7 si-ilar to t/ose of t/e stars and
operating in t/e sa-e way ,pon reality,
to i-press on an e9ternal obBect an i-age
conceived in t/e i-agination, w/ere s,c/
i-ages /ave an 7act,al7 e9istence5 Pico
della 8iran'dola, in an indirect attack
,pon Ficino<s 7spirit,al -agic,7 denies
t/e e9istence of s,c/ raysC /e says t/e
only t/ings t/at can be proBected o,tside
a -an are t/e 7corporeal spirits,7 w/ic/
t/e so,l ,ses as instr,-ents5 B,t /e
never ;,estions t/eir power over
realityC if so-e strong desire leads to
t/ese spirits being e-itted, /e says, t/ey
-ay prod,ce an e9ternal effect% 75 5 5 5
anger -ay res,lt in fascination Nevil
eyeO and /ence a disease5 B,t t/ese
effects can be pro'
9&
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
91
d,ced only at a very s/ort distance and in s,itably receptive -aterial57
3aniel 4alker Gfro- w/ose e9cellent work " /ave borrowed t/is
disc,ssionH s,--ariFes Pico<s attack by saying% 7Fro- t/e weakness
of /is arg,-ents one can see t/at /is reBection of nat,ral -agic is based,
not on disbelief in its possibility, b,t on t/e feeling t/at it is so-e/ow
t/reatening to C/ristianity57
1*+
Corneli,s Agrippa, per/aps t/e greatest encyclopedist of 2enaissance
-agic, gives in /is De occulta philosophia -any instances of t/e -agic
power of t/e i-agination%
1*
>,r so,l ca,ses -,c/ t/ro,g/ fait/% a fir- confidence, an intent
vigilance, and a resol,te devotion , 5 5 lend strengt/ to t/e 4ork
w/ic/ we wo,ld acco-plis/5 4e -,st, t/erefore, for every work, for
eac/ application to any obBect, e9press a powerf,l desire, fle9 o,r
i-agination, and /ave t/e -ost confident tr,st and t/e fir-est
belief, for t/is contrib,tes i--ensely to s,ccess5
Agrippa ;,otes t/e 8,sli- p/ilosop/er Avicenna as believing t/at 7a
-an co,ld fell a ca-el, if /e b,t de-anded it wit/ /is i-agination7C
and 8arsilio FicinoEleader of t/e Florentine Acade-y, translator of
Plato, and one of t/e fo,nders of t/e 2enaissance -agical traditionE
e9pressed a si-ilar idea in /is #ractatus de viri-$us imaginationisC
7 5 5 5 t/ro,g/ t/e active i-agination a distant rider can be -ade to fall
fro- /is /orse and t,-ble into a well57
1*!
And again, Fabio Paolini
borrowed t/is Agrippan notion and e9plained it in 2enaissance
ter-inology% 7#o-e people assert t/at t/e feelings and conceptions of
o,r so,ls can by t/e force of o,r i-agination be rendered volatile and
corporeal 5 5 5 and will obey ,s in w/atever we want57
1*9
1/is concept of t/e o-nipotence of t/e i-agination occ,pies a
central place even in t/e writings of t/ose t/inkers w/o attacked t/e
entire -agical tradition5 1/o-as Erast,s gives a detailed ref,tation of
7t/e possibility of prod,cing transitive effects by t/e power of t/e
i-agination conveyed in e-issions of spirit57 Like Fre,d /e accepts t/e
reality of s,bBective effects, bot/ psyc/ological ones and t/e -ore
ordinary psyc/oso-atic ones5 B,t, as /e says, 7certainly no -an in /is
rig/t -ind will t/ink t/at an i-age fas/ioned in t/e spirit of -y
fantasy can go o,t of -y brain and get into t/e /ead of anot/er
-an57
1.&
Jet even so o,tspoken a critic as Francis Bacon believed in so-e
of t/e -agic of t/e i-agination, and /e s,ggested an e9peri-ent to
prove it, described by 3aniel 4alker as follows% 7"f, for e9a-ple, yo,
wis/ to c,re a sick gentle-an by fait/, first pick o,t
one of /is servants w/o is nat,rally very cred,lo,sC w/ile t/e gentle-an
is asleep, /and t/e servant so-e /ar-less concoction and tell /i- t/at
it will c,re /is -aster wit/in a certain space of ti-e5 1/e spirits of t/e
servant, -ade receptive by /is co-plete fait/ in yo,r -edical powers,
will be powerf,lly sta-ped wit/ t/e i-age of t/is f,t,re c,reC t/ey will
flow o,t and si-ilarly sta-p t/e spirits of /is -aster, also in a state of
receptivity beca,se /e is asleep5 1/,s t/e c,re will be effected57 1/is
s/ows clearly, 4alker concl,des, t/at Bacon still believed in at least
t/is ingredient of Ficinian -agic, t/e traditional doctrine of t/e -agical
power of t/e i-agination fortified by cred,lity5
1.1
1/e point to be noted in all t/ese arg,-ents is t/e -aterialist
pres,ppositions of t/e a,t/orsC w/et/er t/ey accept or reBect t/e
effectiveness of -agic, t/ey do not spirit,aliFe t/e ,niverse so -,c/ as
render t/e spirit corporeal5 1/e yogin s/ares wit/ t/e 2enaissance
-ag,s a self'conscio,s and literate tradition, a sense of syste- in
-etap/ysics, and a belief in -agic, b,t w/ere t/e -ag,s breaks t/e
bo,ndary between i-age and obBect by /ypostatiFing t/e i-age, t/e
yogin breaks t/e bo,ndary by dereifying t/e obBect, syste-ically
e-ptying every description of its reference to a real entity5 $agar'B,na
applies t/is process of -etap/ysical 7e-ptying7 to every concept of
7real e9istence7Eand /ence to every concept of 7real none9istence7
w/erever it is fo,ndC space, ti-e, -otion, ca,sality, persons, and events
can /ave e9istence neit/er predicated of t/e- nor denied t/e-5 1/,s
p,blic realityEt/e arising, abiding, and peris/ing of eventsEneit/er
e9ists nor none9ists% it is 7like an ill,sion, a drea-, a fairy city in t/e
sky57
1.)
Mas,band/,, b,ilding ,pon and in -any ways syste-atiFing
t/is tradition, says t/at t/e 7awareness7 of t/is p,blic reality is t/e
7constr,ction of a non'reality7% it neit/er e9ists in t/e way it see-s,
since it is only an appearance w/ere it see-s a fact, nor does it
none9ist, 7since it occ,rs at least as a p/antasy57 B,t t/en, contin,es
Mas,band/,, w/y not say t/at t/is nonreality si-ply does not e9ist:
Beca,se beings are bo,nd by itC if it were not real t/en 7t/ere co,ld
be neit/er bondage nor liberation, and we wo,ld fall into t/e error of
denying bot/ defile-ent and p,rity57
1.*
1/,s p,blic reality and t/e divine i-age, a -agical ill,sion and a
drea-, /ave no real e9istence, b,t t/ey all occ,r and /ave real
effects, and /ence /ave no real none9istence5 1/e 1ibetan yogin
takes t/is ontology as /is a9io-% t/e p,blic obBect and t/e conte-'
#!E (1+# OF #'R' WOR2!.
&
9*
plative i-age coalesce into an 7"nnate Union of appearance and
E-ptiness7 to w/ic/ predication is irrelevant5 Control of one real- is
control of t/e ot/erC t/e p/ysical events of t/e rit,al serve as a -agical
si-,lacr,- for t/e spirit,al pat/, and t/e private i-ages of t/e
conte-plation govern t/e appearances of t/e world5 1/e divine
reality and t/e p,blic nonreality interpenetrate at every point, and
bot/ -agic and salvation are -ade possible by t/e sa-e pre-ise%
71/ere is not t/e slig/test difference between t/is world and
nirvana,7 says $agarB,na5 71/e li-it of nirvana is t/e li-it of t/e
world% not t/e s,btlest so-et/ing is ever fo,nd between t/e-57
1..
#he (onstruction of 3onreality
1/e B,dd/ist p/ilosop/ers in "ndia /ad long -ade an a9io- of t/e
7softness7 of reality and given an ontological stat,s to t/e
o-nipotence of t/e i-agination% it devolved ,pon t/e- to e9plain not
w/y i-agery is private b,t rat/er w/y reality is p,blic5 8,c/ of
B,dd/ist 7ontological psyc/ology7 is an atte-pt to e9plain in /istorical
ter-s w/y we -ake a syste-ic episte-ological error in o,r
appre/ension of t/e world, w/y we attrib,te to it a solidity t/at in fact
it does not possess5 "n answering t/ese ;,estions, t/e p/ilosop/ers
planted -any of t/e seeds t/at wo,ld flower in t/e 1antric
-anip,lations of realityC t/ey asserted t/e possibility and provided a
-odel, b,t t/e 1antrics b,ilt a conte-plative tec/ni;,e ,pon t/e
str,ct,res of earlier -editation and gave it a new sy-bolic potency and
t/e -eans of -agic5 78ysticis- /as not t/e patience to wait for Iod<s
revelation,7 wrote Dierkegaard in /is Bo,rnalC if we s/o,ld ever be
forced to atte-pt a definition of 71antra,7 we wo,ld say t/at it is a
tec/ni;,e for -agically stor-ing t/e gates of B,dd/a/ood5
"n t/e broadest sense, -agic is t/e -anip,lation of a distant
obBect t/ro,g/ control of a si-,lacr,- t/at is in so-e way associated
wit/ it, w/et/er by na-e, rese-blance, or attrib,tion5 As Ant/ony
4allace says%
1.(
#i-,lation, t/en, is an al-ost ,niversally ,sed religio,s device5 "t
s,pposedly prod,ces an effect t/at wo,ld /ave been i-possible to
attain by applying energy directly to t/e obBect itself, since t/e obBect
-ay be distant in space or ti-e, inaccessible in a s,pernat,ral real-,
or ot/erwise inv,lnerable to nat,ral -anip,lation5
Per/aps t/e s/ortest e9pression of t/e -agical a9io- is fo,nd in t/e
celebrated 7E-erald 1able7 or #a$ula smaragdina ascribed to
6er-es or t/e Egyptian 1/ot/C earlier known versions of t/is e9=
pression of alc/e-ical dog-a are in Arabic, says 6ol-yard, and it /as
been well known since t/e early 8iddle Ages in a Latin rendering5 6ere
we read% 71r,e it is, wit/o,t false/ood, certain and -ost tr,e% t/at
w/ic/ is above is like to t/at w/ic/ is below, and t/at w/ic/ is
below is like to t/at w/ic/ is above, to acco-plis/ t/e -iracles of one
t/ing57
1.+
By -anip,lating events below, t/e -agician can control t/e
co,rse of events above5 Francis Jates tells of one rit,al based on t/is
a9io-%
1.
4e know t/at Ca-panella act,ally practised t/is -agic at 2o-e in
1+)! for Pope Urban M""" w/o was afraid of so-e eclipses w/ic/
/is ene-ies 5 5 5 /ad prop/esied wo,ld ca,se /is deat/5 Ca-panella
did -agic wit/ /i- to ward off t/e evil5 1/ey sealed a roo- against
t/e o,tside air, /,ng it wit/ w/ite clot/s, and b,rned certain /erbs
in it5 1wo la-ps 0luminariaD and five torc/es were lit,
representing t/e planets, and t/e signs of t/e Fodiac were i-itated
in so-e way 7for t/is is a p/ilosop/ical proced,re, not
s,perstitio,s as t/e v,lgar t/ink57 1/ere was Lovial and Menereal
-,sicC stones, plants, colo,rs belonging to t/e good planets were
,sed, and t/ey drank astrologically distilled li;,ors5
Ca-panella tells ,s t/at /is lig/ts i-itate t/e planets not only in t/eir
n,-ber b,t also in t/eir s,bstance, 7for bot/ of t/e- are fiery57
Again, 3aniel 4alker gives Ca-panella<s directions for dealing wit/
dangero,s co-ets% 7Jo, will not only si-,late, wit/in t/e roo-, t/e
/eavens, wit/ t/e planets and signs of t/e Fodiac, b,t yo, will also add
a si-,lacr,- of t/e co-et, -ade o,t of aerial, -edicated -aterial, so
t/at t/is will ,sef,lly s/ine for yo,57
1.!
1/is t/en is t/e -agical a9io- ,pon w/ic/ t/e 1antras are
fo,nded, a corollary of t/eir -etap/ysical a9io-5 1/e 7effigies7 and
t/e 7s,bstit,tes7 of t/e 1ibetan protective rit,als are -agical
si-,lacra, and t/e vivid appearance of t/e vis,aliFed i-age is a
si-,lacr,- for bot/ p,blic reality and for t/e deity /i-self% to
control t/e i-age is to control t/e obBect5 "n 1antric soteriology t/e
divine body is a si-,lacr,- for t/e cos-osC -ind, breat/, and se-en
are /o-ologiFed to one anot/er and to t/e forces t/at create and
destroy t/e ,niverse5 1/is is t/e reason for t/e lengt/y 7tables of
correspondences7 in t/e 1antric writings% B,st as a 4estern astrologer
-ediates t/e infl,ence of t/e planets t/ro,g/ -anip,lation of t/eir
corresponding colors, -inerals, and plants, t/e 1antric seeks in t/e
world and in /i-self as -any interconnections as /e can find,
9.
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.&
9(
and t/e yogin<s body is t/e -agical si-,lacr,- not only of t/e
deity /e /as beco-e b,t also of tr,t/, bliss, freedo-, creation, and
dissol,tion5 As t/e !eva-ra #antra says N"5i51)O%
Ireat knowledge abides in t/e body,
free of all constr,cts%
it is t/e pervader of all t/ings,
b,t t/o,g/ abiding in t/e body it is not born of t/e body5
1/e ai- of all conte-plative -anip,lation is t/e power to control
t/e -ind, t/e breat/, t/e ,niverse5 Power is t/e key, and t/e so,rce of
power is t/e deityC B,st as t/e yogin -ay ,se /is vivid vis,aliFation as
a si-,lacr,- for events, /e ,ses it as a si-,lacr,- for knowledge5
1o cieate and beco-e t/e deity is to 7own7 t/e deity in one<s person,
to be -aster even of t/e deity<s enlig/ten-ent5 And it is, finally, only
as a ra-ification of t/is divine powerEb,ilt ,p t/ro,g/ constant
conte-plative feedback, growing in eac/ conte-plative periodEt/at
t/e yogin is able to control t/e appearances of all /is realitiesC /e -,st
first be a god to act wit/ t/e power of a god, for only t/e deity /as t/e
,nderstanding of reality w/ic/ grants o-nipotence5
6ere too we see t/e central place of t/e -antra in 1antric practice%
7vis,aliFation and recitation7 for- an irred,cible ,nity of -agical
tec/ni;,e, for t/e -antra too is t/e divine power, crystalliFed into
its sonic i-age5 1antra is t/,s t/e 7;,ick pat/7 w/ereon control is
synony-o,s wit/ powerC to control t/e divine appearance, -antra,
and ego is to act wit/ t/e deity<s body, speec/, and -ind, and to
control t/e -ind and body is to own t/e world5
1/,s t/e evol,tion of reality is of great i-portance to t/e 1antric% /is
conte-plation will be its -agical reenact-ent, a si-,lacr,- for t/e
entire world of beingC /e will dwell in a real- w/ere t/e world is a
divine -ansion filled wit/ gods, w/ere effigies are persons, w/ere a
lot,s is a stage to enlig/ten-ent, w/ere a web of colored t/reads is a
gateway to paradise5 And t/e correspondences we see between t/e
p/ilosop/ical t/eory and t/e conte-plative evocation for- for t/e
yogin /i-self t/e -agical s,bstrat,- for t/is total interpenetra'tion of
t/e /,-an and t/e divine5
1/e -ost a,t/oritative description of t/e appearance of t/e
world fro- pri-ordial E-ptiness is fo,nd in a s/ort te9t called On
Distinguishing the E/tremes from the 9iddle,
1
G written by 8ai'treya
andXor Asanga and co--ented ,pon by Asanga<s /alf brot/er
Mas,band/,5 6ere, t/e process by w/ic/ t/e p/eno-enal world
evolves as perception or awareness fro- t/e seeds planted by
kar-a is called a$hutaparikalpaEliterally, t/e 7constr,ction of a
no
nreality7 or, less literally, t/e 7i-position of false constr,cts57 gy
t/is process t/e constr,cts of s,bBect and obBect are i-posed ,pon
E-ptiness, b,t t/e process is itself no -ore an entity t/an w/at it
prod,ces% it 7/as t/e c/aracteristic of bot/ e9isting and none9ist'
ing57 Asanga writes%
1/e constr,ction of a nonreality occ,rs%
d,ality is not fo,nd t/erein5 B,t
E-ptiness is fo,nd in it, and it is fo,nd in
E-ptiness5
1o constr,ct a nonreality, says Mas,band/,, is to constr,e awareness
as being bif,rcated into a s,bBect and an obBect, b,t, w/en freed
fro- t/is d,alis-, t/e sa-e nonreality is E-ptiness5 6e ;,otes
fro- Asanga<s work, 2tage of the odhisattvaC 74/en so-et/ing does
not e9ist so-eplace, one sees tr,ly t/at it is < e-pty< wit/ regard to itC
and w/en so-et/ing re-ains t/ere, one knows t/at it is really
t/ere57
1(&
74/en nonreality is e-ptied of s,bBect and obBect, w/at
re-ainsEw/at is 7really t/ere7Eis E-ptiness5 1/,s t/e -etap/ysical
a9io- of p,blic reality is reasserted% nonreality e9ists, since it occ,rs,
b,t it none9ists as a d,alityC everyt/ing is deter-ined to be neit/er one'
sidedly real nor one'sidedly ,nreal5 And t/is, says Asanga, is t/e
8iddle 4ay5
Iiven t/e ontological stat,s of nonreality, kar-ically i-pelled
awareness /ypostatiFes t/e appearance of d,ality and obsc,resE7de=
files7Et/e s,bstrat,- of E-ptiness5 "f t/e E-ptiness of events
were not defiled, says Mas,band/,, t/en all beings wo,ld be liberated
even wit/o,t effortC b,t if events were not E-ptyEif t/ere were no
7p,rity7Et/en any ,ndertaking for t/e sake of liberation wo,ld be
fr,itless, for we wo,ld all be bo,nd i-placably by t/e ca,sal c/ains
of nonreality5
1/,s awareness takes place, evolving psyc/ologically in eig/t
for-s, t/e first si9 of w/ic/ are G1'(H t/e five sense perceptions and G+H
-ental perceptionEt/e perception of -ental events s,c/ as drea-s
and -e-ories, and t/e fac,lty of discri-ination and attention wit/
regard to t/e sensory inp,t of t/e five senses5 1/ese -ay be
diagra-ed as follows%
ri
L
9+
#!E (1+# OF #'R' r
WOR2!.
&
9
'internal' 'e9ternal'
2ense
'sig/t
E/earing'
's-ell
' t as t eE
Eto,c/ tangibles
E-ind -ental events
G+H -ental perception'r
1o t/ese si9 are added GH t/e 7defiled -ind,7 t/e -ind as defiled by
t/e del,sion of self, t/at is, t/e false self wit/ w/ic/ we identify and
w/ic/ see-s to lie be/ind and appraise t/e processes of -ental
perceptionC and G!H t/e 7,nderlying awareness,7 t/e kar-ic contin,,-
t/at 7contains all seeds7 and fro- w/ic/ t/e seeds ripen into awareness
and beco-e perceptions in nonrealityC as is said in t/e +ankdvatara
2utra NQ5!1O%
All t/o,g/ts evolve fro- t/e 7,nderlying7 like
waves fro- t/e ocean% t/ey are all ca,sed by t/e
i-pressions of kar-a and are born in accord wit/
conditions5
1/,s t/e first seven awarenesses are called 7evol,tes,7 since t/ey
evolve fro- t/e 7,nderlying7 and f,nction only to receive t/e data it
s,pplies t/e-5 "t is of t/is ,nderlying awareness in t/e -ost general
senseEas t/e so,rce and totality of all percept,al e9perienceEt/at
Asanga says% 7Awareness arises in t/e appearance of e9ternal obBects,
living beings, selves, and sense'data57 1/,s it is not/ing b,t
awareness itself t/at appears e9ternally to be t/ings and persons, and
internally to be a self in receipt of sense'data5 B,t 7t/ese do not e9ist
wit/ reference to it% and beca,se t/ey non'e9ist it does not e9ist eit/er57
1/ese appearances are -ere proBections of d,ality ,pon defiled
E-ptiness% t/ey do not e9ist wit/ reference to t/eir s,pposed perception
beca,se t/ings and persons, w/ic/ appear to be 7o,t t/ere,7 are
not/ing b,t awareness itselfC t/ey are s,bBective, and t/e s,bBectEt/e
self and its sense'dataEis ill,sory5 7Beca,se its obBects do not e9ist,7
says Mas,band/,, 7t/e s,bBectEt/e awarenessEdoes not e9ist eit/er57
And so Asanga concl,des% 71/,s awareness is de-onstrated to be t/e
constr,ction of a nonreality57
"n t/e si-plest way, t/en, nonreality begins fro- an awareness
and evolves as follows%
e9ternal obBects
living beings
sell
sense data
1/is basic sc/e-e is e9panded ,pon in vario,s ways5 According to
Mas,band/,, t/is ,n;,alified awareness, in t/e constr,ction of its
nonreality, si-ply bif,rcates into obBects grasped Ge9ternal obBects and
living beingsH and t/e s,bBect w/o grasps t/e- Gself and sense'dataH5 6e
f,rt/er identifies e9ternal obBects as t/e si9 sense fields, and living
beings wit/ t/e five e9ternal sensesC t/e ter- 7self,7 /e says, refers to
t/e -ind Gbot/ as t/e internal sense and as defiledH, and 7sense'data7
refers to t/e si9 perceptions%
e9ternal obBectsE
living beings
awareness s
'-ind
'si9 perceptions
1/e table of percept,al events Gp5 9+H t/,s ,nfolds fro- awareness
itself, and fro- t/is single proBection of d,ality we can t/en assert t/at
Gwit/in t/e real- of nonrealityH a living being wit/ its self co-es in
contact wit/ an e9ternal obBect and t/e sense'data it s,pplies% t/at is,
e9ternally, t/at a living being Gt/e sensesH is in contact wit/ an
e9ternal obBect Gt/e sense fieldsH or, internally, t/at a self Gt/e -ind as
perceiver of sensory inp,t and as 7false self7H is receiving sense'data
GperceptionsH5
An alternative and p/ilosop/ically -ore co-ple9 sc/e-e is proposed
by t/e co--entator #t/ira-ati5 6ere it is not B,st an ,n;,alified
awareness t/at appears in nonreality, b,t rat/er all eig/t awarenesses
-anifest partic,lar classes of events in t/e world5 6ere, too, t/e defiled
-ind incl,des t/e fo,r defile-ents of reification of self, del,sion of
self, pride of self, and love of self Gor, so-eti-es, t/e si9 defile-ents
of l,st, /atred, pride, ignorance, reification, and do,btH5 #t/ira-ati
incorporates t/ese into /is sc/e-e of t/e appearances of awareness%
Field or o$-ect
'for-s 'so,nds
's-ells Etastes
Awareness
7G1H eye perception
1H ear perception
)H nose perception
*H -o,t/ perceptionE
I
'appears as
'si9 sense fields
'five senses
'
grasped
self
sense data'
Ill
9!
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
99
reification of self
del,sion of self
pride of self
love of self
"n t/is sc/e-e it is t/e ,nderlying awareness t/at appears e9ternally to be
t/ings and persons, or obBects graspedC b,t t/ese, again, /ave no real e9istence
apart fro- t/e fact of t/eir perception by t/e ot/er seven awarenesses t/at
appear internally to be a self and sense'data, t/e s,bBect w/o grasps t/e-5 1/is
t/eory leads to a certain lack of parsi-ony, for all fo,r appearances arise fro-
t/eir own seeds, w/ic/ are contained wit/in t/e ,nderlying awarenessC #t/ira-ati
-,st t/,s -ake at least a pedagogical distinction between two sorts of ,nderlying
awareness% on one level as one of t/e eig/t awarenesses, and on anot/er level as
incl,ding all eig/t wit/in itself5 A f,rt/er elaboration is fo,nd in anot/er te9t by
t/e sa-e a,t/or 8aitreya andXor Asanga, called 'dornment of the 2utras of the
)reat 6ehicle4 6ere we find t/e following verse NQ"5.&O%
1/e constr,ction of a nonreality
appears in t/ree kinds and again in t/ree kinds
c/aracteriFed as grasped and grasper 5 5 5
6ere appearances are e9panded to si9, as opposed to t/e fo,r of t/e first te9t5
1/is rat/er cas,al reference to 7t/ree kinds of grasped7 and 7t/ree kinds of
grasper7 is co--ented ,pon by bot/ Mas,band/, and #t/ira-ati, w/o give
slig/tly different ter-inologies for t/ese si9 appearances, wit/ Mas,band/,
again deriving t/e- fro- t/e pri-ary bif,rcation of a single awareness and
#t/ira-ati seeing t/e- as -anifestations of t/e eig/t%
2thiramati
6asu$andhu
gro,nd
obBect
bodyE
-indE
percept
constr,ct
All t/ese elaborations are si-ply -ore detailed
acco,nts of t/e sa-e process% t/e constr,ction of p,blic nonreality as
t/e d,alistic
appearance of awareness5 Bot/ portions of nonrealityEt/e e9ternal and t/e
internal, t/e 7sign7 and t/e 7seeing7Eare proBections ,pon a screen of defiled
E-ptiness5 "n perceiving nonreality, t/e sign portion is taken as t/e basis, and
t/e seeing portion is considered to be its e9pressionC and t/is relation is precisely
w/at is reversed in 1antric conte-plation5 1/e B,dd/ist 1antras in/erited
and developed t/is i-age of
eversal fro- t/e pree9isting and general yogic c,lt,sC in t/e "ndie vernac,lars of
t/eir -ystic songs, t/ese yogins called t/eir conte-plations u-ana 7going
against t/e c,rrent,7 or ulta 7regressive57
Cven today, in Bengal, t/e Ba,ls sing of t/e-selves%
1(1
1/e feeler of feeling, t/e lover of love, /is rites and
/is pat/ are reversedC w/o knows w/at /e will do
ne9t:
"n t/is yogic tradition, says 8ircea Eliade, conte-plation is a co-plete
reversal of /,-an be/aviorC t/e yogin s,bBects /i-self to petrified
i--obility, r/yt/-ic breat/ing and t/e stoppage of breat/, fi9ing of t/e flowing
-ind, t/e 7arrest7 and even t/e 7ret,rn7 of se-en% 7>n every level of /,-an
e9perience, /e does t/e opposite of w/at life de-ands t/at /e do57 1/is 7ret,rn,7
t/is 7regression7 i-plies destr,ction of t/e cos-os and /ence 7e-ergence fro-
ti-e,7 entrance into i--ortality5 And i--ortality, says Eliade, cannot be
gained e9cept by arresting -anifestation% 71/e sy-bolis- of t/e <opposite<
indicates bot/ t/e post'-orte- condition and t/e condition of divinity5 5 5 5
1/e <reversal< of nor-al be/avior sets t/e yogin o,tside of life57
1()
B,t /ere we see t/e B,dd/ist 1antric carrying /is in/erited sy-bolis- into
t/e world of events by t/e reality of /is conte-plative i-ageC /e reverses t/e
process by w/ic/ t/e world appears, and /e beco-es its -aster5 1/,s t/e yogin
begins /is evocation by reversing t/e entropy of kar-a and dissolving nonreality
back into E-ptinessC /e creates a new reality t/at /e possesses in its essence, and
over w/ic/ /e /as co-plete control5 1/e vivid appearance of t/e
conte-plation is a si-,lacr,- bot/ for t/e appearance of awareness in
nonreality and for t/e divine appearance in reality% /ere t/e seeing portion is
t/e basis, and t/e sign portion beco-es only its e9pression5 "n t/is new realityE
t/is world of t/e 7"nnate Union of appearance and E-ptiness7Et/e yogin is
-aster, and /e can control it as /e will5
e9ternal obBects
living beings
,nderlying awareness'
self sense'
data
defiled -ind'
si9 perceptions'
c-aterial world
e9ternal obBects 5
" si9 sense fields
living being si9 senses
,nderlyin
g
awareness
'grasped'
'defiled -ind
five perceptions
-ental perception
'self'
evol,te
awarenesses
I"
L?
'grasper'
Esense data
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
16E P2>CE## >F IE$E2A1">$
"t is into t/is real- of conte-plative reality t/at t/e yogin -ag=
ically -anifests t/e divine power% /e controls t/e ,nfolding of t/e
divine appearance in reality B,st as /e controls t/e appearances of
events in nonreality, by -anip,lating t/e -agical si-,lacr,- of /is
vis,aliFation5
Let ,s say t/at a great yogin wis/es to perfor- a -agical oper=
ation in p,blic nonreality, to s,bB,gate, for e9a-ple, an evil king
or a fierce and tro,bleso-e de-on5 6e -akes an effigy of wa9 and
7generates7 it as t/e person to be s,bB,gated% t/at is, /e dissolves
t/e obBect conte-platively into E-ptiness, and conte-platively re=
creates it as a vis,aliFed i-age5 "nto t/is effigy /e t/en s,--ons t/e
awareness of t/e victi-, in t/e for- of a s-all syllable A colored
brig/t red% /e t/reads a copper needle wit/ red t/read sp,n by a
yo,ng -aiden, and wit/ t/is /e draws forward t/e person to be
s,bB,gated, 7sewing7 t/e syllable into t/e wo-b of t/e effigyC and /e
7binds7 /i- t/erein, piercing it wit/ iron /ooks of lig/t and fettering it
wit/ a brilliant noose5 4/ile /e is vis,aliFing t/is /e recites t/e
-antra >8 DU2UDULLE 62l6 s,c/'and's,c/ a person MA#A8
DU2U 7#,bB,gate7 6>6 K ADA2#AJA 7#,-on7 62l6 #MA6AK
1/e practitioner takes t/e effigy at d,sk and tor-ents it over a
fire of k/adira wood, /olding it over t/e fla-es and letting it -elt
and trickle into t/e-, all t/e w/ile reciting t/e -antra5 1/en /e
takes t/e effigy and tra-ples it ,nderfootC no sooner does /e do so
t/an t/e victi- is s,bB,gated5
1(*
1/ere can be no do,bt abo,t t/e -agical nat,re and intent of t/is
operation, b,t w/at -akes it work is t/e vis,aliFation, w/ic/ creates
t/e -agical link not only between victi- and effigy b,t also between
effigy and yogin5 "t is one t/ing to play violent ga-es wit/ a wa9
doll and anot/er to possess t/e effigy, to control it absol,tely5 1o
s,bB,gate t/e effigy is to s,bB,gate t/e person, b,t s,c/ power of
-anip,lation belongs only to its tr,e owner5 1/ere are t/,s t/ree
basic steps in t/e conte-plative se;,ence% G1H 1/e effigy is gener=
ated as t/e victi-, 7known7 in essential E-ptiness and t/,s tr,ly
pliant to t/e yogin<s controlC t/e wa9 obBect beco-es b,t t/e e9=
pression of t/is conte-plative i-age, and its -anip,lation b,t t/e
bodily acting o,t of a conte-plative dra-a5 G)H "nto t/is receptacle
created for /i- is s,--oned t/e real victi-E/is awarenessE,sing
as si-,lacr,- t/e vis,aliFed syllableC /ere is forged t/e link wit/
WOR2!.&
1&1
p,blic nonreality, and t/e victi-, like t/e effigy, is converted fro-
inaccessible obBect to -alleable i-age5 G*H Finally t/ese i-agesEt/e
7real'iFation7 and t/e coalescence of t/e two obBectsEare bo,nd
into a ,nity, an i-ageXobBect to be -anip,lated in any way t/e
yogin -ay wis/C t/is ,nity of conte-plative 7appearance and
E-ptiness7 t/,s e9ists in two real-s si-,ltaneo,sly, to prod,ce its
effects in bif,rcated nonreality5
1/e rit,al Process of Ieneration si-ilarly takes t/e divine power
as obBect, to be controlled in and t/ro,g/ its vivid i-age, and to
sanctify t/is new reality wit/ its appearanceC it -anifests itself as
t/e blosso-ing of t/e seed syllable after t/e 7constr,ed and fab=
ricated7 ,niverse is dissolved into E-ptiness by t/e -antra, and it
,nfolds in fo,r stages%
1H 1/e divine power is given for- and s/ape as t/e sym$olic
$eing, t/e proBection ,pon t/e ,lti-ate fabric of reality of t/e
practitioner<s own vis,aliFationC t/is is, in t/e words of 1songk<apa
7t/e body of t/e deity adorned wit/ faces and /ands, w/ose real
nat,re is as an <appearance< of one<s own -ind, a -aking vivid of
one<s ordinary ego57
1(.
)H "t empoBers the senses of t/e vis,aliFed deity, radiating fort/
,pon it as t/e power of body, speec/, and -ind, crystalliFing as t/e
syllables >8 A6 6U8 on /ead, t/roat, and /eartC in -ore co-ple9
rit,als, t/is -ay incl,de any of t/e different sorts of 7body -anda'
la,7 t/e 7deep conte-plation of t/e s,btle deities7 w/ic/ fills t/e
body of t/e vis,aliFationEits senses, 7aggregates,7 organs, and
orificesEwit/ t/e entire divine /ost of t/e -andala, and -ay
f,rt/er 7p,t on ar-or7 of still -ore e-powering deities5
*H "nto t/e receptacle t/,s prepared for it, t/e divine power
descends in act,ality fro- its nat,ral abode of t/e 3/ar-a real-,
co-pelled by t/e vis,aliFation of its appearance and often greeted
wit/ offerings and praiseC t/is is t/e 7real7 deity, t/e knoBledge
$eing, w/o is dissolved into t/e sy-bolic being wit/ t/e fo,r /and
gest,res in fig,re 1. and t/e -antra LA6 6U8 BA8 6>6 to s,-=
-on, absorb, bind, and dissolve it t/erein% and at t/is very instant t/e
yogin casts off /is ordinary ego and grasps t/e ego of t/e god5 "f one
-akes t/e knowledge being enter in,7 says 1songk<apa, 7/is
e
yes and so
on are -i9ed inseparably wit/ t/e eyes and so on of t/e sy-bolic
being, down to t/eir very ato-s% and one s/o,ld fir-ly vis,aliFe t/eir
total e;,ality57
1((
1&&
L
1&)
#!E (1+# OF ?EOE
1&*
6>6K
Fig5 1.5 1/e -antras and t/e gest,res t/at G1H s,--on, G)H absorb,
G*H bind, and G.H dissolve t/e knowledge being5
.H 1/is power is finally 7sealed7 into a ,nitary si-,lacr,- by t/e
deity<s own rit,al initiation by t/e five fa-ilies of B,dd/as5 Again,
1songk<apa says% 7>nce t/e knowledge being /as been absorbed,
t/ere is t/e initiation5 5 5 5 6ere a strea- of water w/ose essence is t/e
t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent Gin -ost cases fro- a flask b,t occasionally
fro- wit/in a sk,ll'bowlH is said to be bestowed, and wit/ t/at water
of knowledge all defile-ents and propensities t/ereto are was/ed
away% t/erefore t/e initiatic li;,id takes its place ,pon t/e /ead,
and so <seals< t/e deity57
1(+
4e -ay see t/e str,ct,ral correspondences between t/e effigy
and t/e deity below%
divine power
knowledge being
binding
I
"n bot/ cases a 7receptacle7Ean i-age t/at t/e practitioner possesses
Eis prepared t/ro,g/ conte-plative generation fro- E-ptinessC into
t/is is -agically drawn t/e link wit/ t/e real- to be controlled, t/e
victi-<s awareness or t/e divine knowledge beingC and finally t/ese
are bo,nd or sealed into a ,nitary si-,lacr,-Et/e co-pleted effigy or
t/e yogin<s own bodyEw/ic/ -ay be -anip,lated toward any end5 1/e
effigy, we -ay note, re;,ires no e9tra step to prepare it for t/e
entrance of t/e victi-<s awareness, b,t t/e sy-bolic being 7-,st be
7e-powered7 before it is a fit vessel for t/e divinity, especially if t/e
practitioner is /i-self t/e sy-bolic being in self'generationC wit/o,t
t/e strengt/ening and ar-oring of t/e senses, t/e si-,ltaneo,s
casting away of ordinary ego and t/e infl,9 of divine power co,ld be
overw/el-ing5
$ow even an ordinary -an, driven to t/e e9tre-ities of desire,
-ig/t -old an effigy and -ake it work, -ig/t coerce events wit/ a
fort,ito,s vis,aliFation5 B,t t/e yogin 7fir-ly grasps t/e appearance
and ego of t/e deity,7 and t/is control g,arantees /is s,ccessC it is
t/e deity /i-self w/o -anip,lates t/e effigy and links it to t/e victi-5
A fallible -agic is available to everyoneC an ,nfailing -agic belongs
only to one w/o /as gone t/ro,g/ t/e prior rit,al service and /as
ac;,ired t/e power of t/e god5 And it is t/is sa-e process of
feedbackEt/is growing control and powerEw/ic/ allows t/e yogin
grad,ally to coerce t/e divine appearance itself wit/ ever greater
ass,rance, to be /i-self -ore of a god eac/ ti-e /e evokes t/e god5
"t is, after all, only t/is divine presence t/at sanctifies t/e yogin<s
conte-plative realityC we -,st disting,is/ t/e Process of Ieneration
Et/e evocation of t/e divine, at w/atever loc,sEfro- t/e si-ple
generation of t/e effigy as t/e victi-, or t/e -ere creation of vivid
appearance in l,st or /atred5 1/,s 1enpe nyi-a
1(
says t/at to
know appearances to be wit/o,t tr,t/ is t/e 7ill,sory
LA6K 6U8K
BA8K
ic world p,blic
'conte-plation '
sy-bolic
being
effigy awareness'
sealing
1
1&.
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
1&(
Process of Ieneration,7 t/eir -irac,lo,s arising as 7appearance and
E-ptiness7 is t/e 7profo,nd Process of Ieneration,7 and t/e body of
t/e deity wit/ /is consort is t/e 7e-anative Process of Ieneration57 "t
is t/e divine body t/at is t/e defining feat,re of t/e entire
tec/ni;,eC it is t/e ,ni;,e 7appearance and E-ptiness7 w/ic/ is
-anifested fro- t/e Bliss of -elting and w/ic/ arises fro- 7con=
str,ction and e9a-ination57
6e says, f,rt/er, t/at t/is Process of Ieneration /as fo,r special
properties t/at disting,is/ it fro- ot/er vis,aliFations% t/e special
property of its rit,al is its co-pleteness as a -eans of generation as
fo,nd in t/e 1antrasC t/e special property of its res,lt for t/e prac=
titioner is /is ability to p,t fort/ t/e strengt/ of t/e -antraC t/e
special property of its nat,re is its essence of E-ptiness and BlissC and
t/e special property of its f,nction is its co-pleteness in cleansing,
perfecting, and ripening5
"n ot/er words, t/is process is a special type of generation w/ose
-agical correspondences reverberate far beyond t/e li-ited ai-s of
t/e effigyC it creates a si-,lacr,- of divinity in t/e yogin<s own body,
w/ic/ speaks wit/ t/e divine power of t/e -antra, w/ic/ s/ares in
t/e Bliss of t/e 3/ar-a real-, w/ic/ controls in t/e very process of its
for-ation bot/ t/e stages on t/e pat/ to B,dd/a/ood and t/e ,lti-ate
events of p,blic nonreality% birt/, deat/, and t/e inter-ediate state of
t/e $ardo4 1/e body of t/e deity, t/e Bod/is'attva #tages, t/e i-pelling
processes of kar-aEall t/ese are -agically t/e sa-e, and to control
one is to /ave power over all5
1o -ake clear t/e fo,r steps of t/e rit,al se;,ence, " give an e9a-ple
of one of its briefest and si-plest for-s, part of a little daily rit,al for
4/ite ?@A@ written by t/e Ientle Lord Lodro t<aye, t/e Dongtrii
rinpoc/<e G1!1*'1!99H5 6ere we -ay see one of t/e advantages of
beginning fro- t/e rit,als of ?@A@, for in t/eir lack of elaboration t/ey
provide ,s wit/ a basic -odel for t/e -ore co-ple9 rit,als of t/e
-onastic c,lt%
1(*
1/e yoga of generation%
1H >8 #U$JA1A'L$A$A'MAL2A'#MAB6AMA18AD> <6A8 K
Fro- t/e so,nd of 6U8, innate prowess of E-ptiness, a
dia-ond circle of protection5 1/erein a crystal divine -ansion5
"n t/e -iddle a w/ite lot,s above a -oon5 Fro- ?SY a w/ite
,tpala flower -arked wit/ ?SY5
Lig/t radiates, serves t/e ai- of beings,
is gat/ered back, and transfor-s
into -yself t/e noble ?@A@, color of t/e -oon,
cal-, s-iling, sens,o,s, radiating five'colored lig/t 5 55
1H>n t/e t/ree places5of -y body >8 A6 6U85 By t/eir lig/t
1!Ht/e knowledge beingEMAL2A#A8ALA6 K
LA6 6U8 BA8 6>6 KEdissolves inseparably5
19HAgain lig/t radiates, inviting t/e five fa-ilies5
" pray t/e initiation deities initiate -eK
By t/is prayer t/e initiation deities say%
>8 #A2MA'1A16AIA1A'AB6"#EDA1A'#A8AJA'#2lJE
6U8K
7>8 1/e glory of t/e vow of initiation of all t/e 1at/agatas 6U8 K7
1/ey initiate -e, t/e water fills -y body, " a- adorned on -y
crest by A-itab/a, lord of t/e fa-ily5
1/is Process of Ieneration -ay take place at any loc,s% t/e
practitioner /i-self Gas /ereH, in front of /i-, or wit/in an obBect5 1/e
generations t/at take place in front are per/aps easiest to ,nderstand,
for t/e conte-plative events ,nfold before one like i-ages on a
-ovie screenC t/e closest analogy -ig/t be an abstract cine-a by
Lordan Belson5
1(9
1/e constant ,nfolding and -otion of i-ages, too,
-ake of vis,aliFation w/at can only be described as an aest/etic
e9perience, a ballet of lig/t and for- c/arged wit/ -eaning and power5
1/e self'generation is rat/er -ore diffic,lt to appre/end, as t/ere is
not Gor s/o,ld not beH anyone t/ere to watc/ itC t/e yogin /i-self
/as disappeared in E-ptiness, and t/e i-ages si-ply occ,r entirely
delocaliFed5 4e are ,sed to being at a partic,lar place, and we tend
to sit,ate o,rselves so-ew/ere in o,r /ead, be/ind o,r eyesC w/en
t/e yogin generates /i-self as t/e deity, /e is no longer t/ere5
B,t w/atever t/e loc,s, t/e vis,aliFation is t/e sa-e5 As t/e
practitioner recites t/e te9t above, t/ere appears a dance of lig/t, a
ballet of i-ages ,nfolding and -oving, w/ic/ is patterned as follows%
1H Fro- t/e 7real- of E-ptiness7 t/ere appears a circle of protection
and a divine -ansion, -ore or less elaborated according to t/e rit,al5 "n
t/e -idst t/ereof appears t/e syllable pSY w/ic/ transfor-s into a
lot,sC ,pon t/is is t/e syllable A w/ic/ transfor-s into a flat -oon
disk, laid down ,pon t/e lot,s to for- a 7t/rone57
#!E (1+# OF ?EPE
Above t/is appears t/e syllable ?SY w/ic/ transfor-s into
1ara<s em$lem, t/e lot,s flower, -arked again wit/ ?SY, t/e seed of
?@A@ w/ic/ will blosso- into t/e deity5 1/,s fro- t/e syllable
lig/t radiates fort/ in all directions, -aking offerings to t/e $oble
>nes and p,rifying t/e defile-ents of t/e entire world5 1/e lig/t
gat/ers back into t/e syllable, and at t/at instant t/e e-ble- and
seed transfor- into t/e perfected $ody of t/e goddess5
)&HUpon t/e top of 1ara<s /ead appears a w/ite >8, t/e power of
bodyC ,pon /er t/roat a red A6, t/e power of speec/C and
,pon
/er /eart a bl,e 6U8, t/e power of -ind5 Again, t/e
different rit
,als -ay elaborate ,pon t/is in vario,s ways, b,t finally
t/ere
appears a green ?SY in t/e center of /er /eart5
)1HFro- t/is syllable lig/t radiates fort/ and s,--ons t/e
know
ledge being fro- its nat,ral abodeC it appears in t/e sky wit/
MAL'
2A#A8ALA6 73ia-ond gat/eringK7 and dissolves into t/e
deity
wit/ LA6 6U8 BA8 6>6K
))HAgain lig/t radiates fort/ fro- t/e syllable ?SY in /er /eart,
inviting t/e five B,dd/as and t/eir retin,eC t/ey po,r fro-
t/eir
flasks a strea- of li;,id nectar ,pon /er /ead, filling "/er
entire
body, and t/e overflowing e9cess for-s on /er crown t/e%
7sealing7
fig,re of A-itab/a5
1/is basic sc/e-e -ay be e-bellis/ed and refined in vario,s
ways, e9tended wit/ incidental verses of offering, praises, and
prayer to t/e diverse deities w/o appear in t/e vis,aliFation5 B,t
t/e fo,r steps of t/e Process of Ieneration, /ere give- so s,c=
cinctly, are t/e f,nda-ental se;,ence of all evocations of t/e
divine, a pattern t/at is invariable, /owever -,c/ obsc,red by
detail or by co-pressionC as s,c/ t/ese steps /ave recerved -,c/
t/eoretical attention and /ave been organiFed and labeLed in va=
rio,s ways5
An early sc/e-atiFation of t/is process is fo,nd in t/e )uhyaF
sama-a #anlra, w/ere it is called t/e 7fo,r li-bs of approac/ and
evocation57 Later co--entators applied t/is ter-inology especially
to t/e Fat/er 1antras, and to t/e rit,als of t/e I,/yasa-aBa cycle
in partic,lar, occasionally disagreeing on partic,lars of correlationC
b,t wit/ so-e alternation fro- t/e idiosyncrasy of t/ese rit,als it
is often ,sed to sc/e-atiFe t/e Process of Ieneration w/eirever it is
fo,nd, and it is applied to t/e evocations of ?@A@ Gsee pp5 ..('..+H5
1/,s t/e
)uhyasa
ma-a
#antra
says%
1(9a
1&+
1&
"n all t/e 1antras of yoga
ever praised by yogins
t/e rit,al of approach is first,
near evocation is second,
evocation too is t/ird
and great evocation is fo,rt/5
glsew/ere t/e )uhyasama-a #anlra elaborates ,pon eac/ of t/ese
yfo,r li-bs,7 and we read%
1+&
1H 1o apply t/e -editation of approach
one s/o,ld conte-plate t/e /ig/est enlig/ten-ent5
Candraklrti, in /is co--entary #he .llumining +amp,
lsl
e9plains
t/is ter- as follows% 7Approac/% it is practiced by t/ose w/o desire
liberation, and so it is called an <approac/< t/ereto57 And1songk<a'
pa glosses t/is%
1+)
6ence 7approac/7 is t/e t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent taking E-pti=
ness as its conte-plative obBect% and since one fi9es one<s -ind
one'pointedly t/ereon, t/e verse calls it a 7-editation57 1/,s
7/ig/est enlig/ten-ent7 is t/e act,al enlig/ten-ent w/ic/ co-es
abo,t
t/ro,g/
e9a-in
ing t/e
-eanin
g of t/e
#>$J
A1A
-antra%
to
conte-
plate
t/is is
to
7appro
ac/57 5 5
5
7Appro
ac/7 is
t/,s
consid
ered
t/e
generation of t/e sy-bolic being5
$e9t is 7e-powering t/e senses7 of t/e vis,aliFed deity, and t/e
)uhyasama-a #antra says%
)H "n near evocation, t/e /ig/est attain-ent,
one e9a-ines t/e 3ia-ond #enses5
6ere t/e e-powered sy-bolic being, says Candraklrti, is t/e deity
called t/e 2it,al 8anifestation, t/e body now 7perfect7 in power%
and B,dd/aBnana says%
1+*
7$ear7 -eans 7close7% it -eans 7close to t/e Ireat 8anifesta=
tion,7 and refers to t/e first Nt/e sy-bolicO Lord, w/o is 7near7 to
t/e absol,te p,rity of t/e Ireat 8anifestation5
E-powering t/e sy-bolic being brings it near to t/e knowledge
being and prepares it for t/e entry of t/e real deity, t/e Ireat 8an'
gestation of t/e divine power in conte-plative reality5 1/,s
1songk<apa says%
1/e 7place7 to w/ic/ it is 7near7 is t/e co-pletely p,re divine
body, called t/e 7body of knowledge,7 t/e Ireat 8anifestation5
4/at is 7near7 t/ereto is t/e body of t/e first Lord5
1&!
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
r
WOR2!.
&
1&9
"n t/e verse, /e e9plains, 73ia-ond7 refers to t/e deities of t/e -andala, and
7#enses7 to t/e 7aggregates7 and places of t/e body w/ereon t/ey are arrayed% t/ese
are 7e9a-ined7 beca,se t/ey are placed on t/e vis,aliFed deity 7t/ro,g/ knowing
t/e ca,ses and effects of arraying t/e body -andala57
1/en t/e knowledge being is s,--oned, and t/e )uhyasama-a #antra says%
*H By conte-plating t/e Lord of t/e -antra
d,ring evocation /e is said to be i-pelled5
1/e knowledge being is 7i-pelled7 into t/e 2it,al 8anifestation of t/e e-powered
sy-bolic being% 7Evocation,7 says 1songk<apa, 7is t/e evocation of t/e body of t/e
Ireat 8anifestation57 6ere t/e 7t/ree gates7Et/e practitioner<s body, speec/, and
-indEbeco-e inpeparable fro- t/e 7t/ree 3ia-onds7Et/e 3ia-ond Body,
#peec/, and 8ind of t/e deityEand t/e yogin vows to practice as of 7one taste7
wit/ t/e god5
And finally t/e Ireat 8anifestation is 7sealed,7 and t/e )uhyasama-a #antra
says%
.H 4/en doing great evocation
t/e i-age is t/e Bearer of t/e MaBra in /is own -antraC and vis,aliFing t/e
Lord on one<s crown one will gain t/e 3ia-ond of Dnowledge5
1/e 73ia-ond of knowledge7 is t/e final 3ia-ond of total ,nityC it is, says
1sonk<apa, 7t/e practitioner possessed of yogaE<,nion< Ewit/ t/e deity57 1/e
great evocation, /e says, is sealing wit/ t/e lord of t/e fa-ily t/ro,g/ initiation%
7"f one conte-plates t/e Ireat 8anifestation, vis,aliFing t/at one is sealed wit/
t/e lord of t/e fa-ily, one will gain t/e -agical attain-ents57
16E #J8B>L"C BE"$I A$3 8AI"CAL C>22E#P>$3E$CE
1/,s t/e creation of t/e deity is no rando- series of syllables and flas/es of lig/t, b,t
rat/er a co/erent and -eaningf,l dra-a w/ose every ele-ent is s,bordinated to t/e
evocation of divine power in a for- bot/ -anip,lable and sy-bolically potent, even
in t/e very process of its conte-plative ,nfolding5 1/e variations ,pon t/is t/e-e
of power tend to center on t/e -alleable i-age of t/e sy-bolic being, on t/e details
of its evocation, and on t/e -agical correspondences in w/ic/ it participates5
"n t/e cycles of t/e Fat/er 1antras, t/e em$lem, t/e seed, and t/e perfected $ody of
t/e sy-bolic being are in t/e-selves often called t/e 7t/ree rites of 3ia-ond7 w/ic/
p,rify t/e practitioner<s body, speec/, and -ind5 As Lig-e c/<oc/i wangpo writes%
1+.
By vis,aliFing oneself as -anifest in t/e for- of t/e e-ble-, s,c/ as a five'
pointed vaBra, one<s -ind is cleansed into t/e 3ia-ond of 8ind5 By vis,aliFing
t/at sa-e e-ble- as -arked wit/ s,c/ syllables as 6U8, one<s speec/ is
perfected as t/e 3ia-ond of #peec/5 By t/e rite of t/e radiating and gat/ering in of
lig/t and G/aving served t/erewit/ t/e ai-s of oneself and ot/ersH its transfor-ation
into t/e divine body, vis,aliFed as co-plete wit/ all orna-ents and acco,tre-ents,
one<s body is ripened into t/e 3ia-ond of Body5
1/,s t/ese t/ree rites are a t/reefold table of correspondences, w/ic/ f,lfills w/at
1enpe nyi-a said was t/e special f,nction of t/e Process of Ieneration% to cleanse,
to perfect, and to ripen5 1/e rites are -agical si-,lacra for t/e pat/ of p,rification
w/ic/ leads to t/e t/reefold 3ia-ond of B,dd/a/ood5
1/ese 7rites7Ee-ble-, seed, and bodyEare seen too as si-,lacra for t/e processes
of birt/5 $ot only is t/e yogin literally born into /is new conte-plative reality after
7dying7 in E-ptiness, b,t also, by /is -astery of t/e Process of Ieneration, /e can
control /is t/reefold gestation and birt/ in t/e world, and /is t/reefold 7fr,ition7 as
a B,dd/a%
By t/e first rite, t/e frardo'awareness enters into t/e -ass of red and w/ite in
t/e wo-b5 By t/e second, t/e se-en, blood and -ind are -i9ed toget/er, and
t/e five states of gestation Gfoet,s and so onH are e9perienced5 By t/e t/ird, t/e
body assi-ilates t/e scattered ele-ents and is co-pleted, and it is born
o,tside5
4/en p,rified Nby t/e Process of IenerationO, at t/e ti-e of fr,ition t/ese
co-bine as t/e ca,sal conditions for t/e 1at/a'gata to arise in a Body of
1ransfor-ation to take ot/ers in /and, to dwell in t/e wo-bEt/e vaginaEof t/e
3ia-ond Lady, and to be born fort/ to s/ow /is deeds5
Again, in t/e cycles of t/e 8ot/er 1antras, t/e steps of creating and e-powering
t/e senses of t/e sy-bolic being are often gro,ped into a fo,rfold table of
correspondences and called t/e 7fo,r realiFations57 As it says in t/e !eva-ra #antra
N"5iii5)O%
First, Emptiness is t/e t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent,
second, t/e seed is arisen,
in t/e t/ird t/e $ody is perfected,
in t/e fo,rt/ t/e sylla$les are arrayed5
11&
#!E (1+# OF #'Rz
r
WOR2!.
&
ill
And Lig-e c/oc/i wangpo glosses%
1/is sets fort/ t/e ter-inology of t/e fo,r realiFations5 7E-ptiness
is t/e t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent7% one possesses t/e inter-ediate state
between deat/ and rebirt/5 71/e seed is arisen7% t/e awareness of t/e
gandharva Nt/e being seeking rebirt/O takes its place in t/e -iddle of
t/e se-en and blood5 71/e body is perfected7% t/e body is grad,ally
prod,ced by t/e ten winds5 71/e syllables are arrayed7% /aving been
born, t/e senses discri-inate t/eir obBects5
1/ese t/ree' and fo,rfold tables of correspondences set fort/
patterns not of -ere sy-bolis- b,t of act,al -agical powersC t/e
Process of Ieneration is a reenact-ent and si-,lacr,- not only for
t/e -acrocos-ic creation of p,blic nonreality, b,t also for t/e
-icrocos-ic e9perience of deat/, t/e inter-ediate state of t/e
$ardo, and birt/ in t/e world5 >n one level t/e yogin is gaining
si-ple practice in dying into E-ptiness and being reborn in conte-=
plative reality, a re/earsal for t/e deat/ and rebirt/ /e will e9peri ence
w/en /is life is over, b,t on a deeper level t/is practice -eans -astery,
and t/is control -eans powerC /e 7owns7 t/ese processes, and t/ey are
set fort/ in t/ese co--entaries as t/e obBects of /is conte-plative
i-age, as t/e events over w/ic/ /e gains -agical control5
1/,s w/en t/ese states are cleansed by t/eir rit,al reenact-ent,
t/ey -ay be ripened into bliss and ,nderstanding, and perfected into
t/e knowledges and bodies of B,dd/a/oodC once t/e yogin /as beco-e
t/e deity, /e -ay ,se t/e se;,ence of /is own creation as a -agical
basis for -astering t/e deity<s enlig/ten-ent in t/e Process of
Perfection5
1+(
1o t/e 1ibetans a sy-bol is no abstract co,nter in an
intellect,al ga-e, b,t a key to -agical power5 Even t/e sy-bolic
potency of t/e recollection of p,rity is a re-inder of t/e power t/e
practitioner wields in t/e body of t/e god5
71o ta-e a r,tting elep/ant dr,nk on wine,7 says Lig-e c/<o' c/i
wangpo, 7one -ay ,se a plain elep/ant /ook or a fancy one7% t/e
Process of Ieneration -ay be -ore or less elaborated, and its -agical
correspondences -ore or less e9tended, to t/e li-its of n,-erical
analogy5 And even in t/e si-plest evocation of t/e goddess, t/ese
correspondences are i-plicit -otifs in t/e ballet of ,nfolding i-ages,
giving -eaning to t/e bare and ,nelaborated bones of t/e recitation5
per/aps t/e -ost i-portant of t/ese tables for t/e generation of t/e
sy-bolic being is not fo,nd in t/e rit,als of ?@A@ at all, being ,sed
only in t/e /ig/est rit,als of t/e -onastic c,lt, for t/e /ig/ patron
deities and t/e protecting 7Lord of knowledge57 6ere are w/at are
called t/e 7five realiFations,7 and o,r ,nderstanding of t/e Process of
Ieneration wo,ld be inco-plete wit/o,t so-e acco,nt of t/e-C t/e
-agical correspondences worked o,t by generations of sc/olars for
t/ese five realiFations reverberate even in t/e si-pler rit,als of ?@A@5
4e -,st re-e-ber, w/enever we talk of 1ibetan sc/olasticis-, t/at
t/e dry acco,nt book of correspondences is t/e res,lt of a basically
religio,s searc/, an atte-pt to e9tend t/e yogin<s power to its
,lti-ate bo,nds, and t/e yogin w/o generates t/e goddess brings to
t/e evocation all t/e -agical analogies of /is conte-plative career5
71/e five realiFations,7 says1songk<apa, 7are five awakenings% t/e
awakening G1H in #,c/ness, G)H in t/e -oon, G*H in t/e seed, G.H in t/e
e-ble-, and G(H in t/e perfected body57
1++
4e -ay look at an e9a-ple
of t/is -ode of generating t/e sy-bolic being as given in a rit,al of
I,/yasa-aBa%
1+
)*H>8 #U$JA1A'L$A$A'MAL2A'#MAB6AMA18AD> <6A8 K
).HAbove t/e central t/rone is a s,n disk arisen fro- 6U8, in t/e
-iddle of w/ic/ is a -oon disk arisen fro- >8C and above t/at
is a red eig/t'petaled lot,s arisen fro- A6, in w/ose center are
t/e t/ree syllables >8 A6 6U8, stacked one atop t/e ot/er5 All
t/ose -i9 toget/er and beco-e one co-plete and perfect -oon
diskC lig/t radiates fort/ t/erefro-, gat/ers toget/er t/e entire
ani-ate and inani-ate world, and dissolves back into t/e -oon5
>8 36A28A'36A1U'#MAB6AMA18AD> <6A8K 1/e ba
sis of all ani-ate and inani-ate events is not/ing b,t t/e -ind
riding ,pon t/e windsC t/at appears as a -oonC t/at is "K
)(HAbove t/e -oon is a w/ite >8, a red A6, and a bl,e 6U8,
spr,ng fro- t/e -oon like b,bbles appearing fro- water% lig/t
radiates fort/ t/erefro-, invites t/e -eas,reless five fa-ilies and
t/eir retin,e, and all dissolve back into t/e syllables5
)+H1/ey i--ediately transfor- into a w/ite five'pointed vaBra,
-arked in t/e -iddle wit/ >8 A6 6U8 MAL2A'#MAB6A'
MA18AD><6A8K
)H1/e vaBra and its syllables transfor- into t/e Lord5
11)
#!E (1+# OF
?EQE
WOR2!
.&
11*
>r again, in a rit,al of Cakrasa-vara%
1+!
)!H>8 #>$JA1A'L$A$A'MAL2A'#MAB6AMA18AD>
<6A8K
)9HAbove t/e central t/rone, co,nterclockwise, are t/e vowels,
twice% A A " " U & 2 2 L L E A" Z AU A8 A6, and clockwise t/e
consonants, twice% DA D6A IA I6A $A CA ][S LA L6A ft A
?S 16A 3A 36A $A ?S 16A 3A 36A $A PA P6A BA B6A
8A JA 2A LA MA #A #A #A 6A D#A JA 2A LA MA 3A 36A5
1/ese vowels and consonants transfor- into a 7kissing7 s,n and
-oon Nt/at is, a single disk t/at is /alf eac/O5
*&H"n t/e -iddle t/ereof is a 6U8 like ;,icksilver and an A like
ver-ilionC lig/t radiates fort/ t/erefro-, transfor-ing t/e world
of inani-ate obBects into a divine -ansion, and t/e world of ani
-ate beings into t/e /ost of deities of t/e -andala of Cakrasa-
varaC and it is gat/ered back in again5
*1H1/e syllables transfor- into a vaBra -arked wit/ 6U8 and a
c/opper -arked wit/ A5
*)HAll t/ose are -i9ed into one and transfor- into t/e Blessed
Cakrasa-vara 5 5 5 and t/e 8ot/er 3ia-ond Jogin Lady5
1/e evident differences in detail /ere derive fro- t/e conte-=
plative traditions of individ,al -asters and t/eir sc/ools of co--entary
,pon t/e basic te9tsC 1songk<apa in /is )reat 2tages of the 9antra
&ath devotes -,c/ space to a disc,ssion of t/ese rit,al variations on
t/e basic t/e-e5
1+9
B,t despite differences in detail, t/e two
generations are still str,ct,rally identicalC and t/e traditional
B,dd/ist love of t/e n,-ber ( can /ere lead to t/e -ost elaborate
correspondences, and /ence to t/e greatest disse-ination of -agical
power5 1/,s, for e9a-ple, t/e !eva-ra #anira correlates t/e five
realiFations wit/ t/e five knowledges of a B,dd/a N"5viii5 +'!O%
1/e moon is t/e 8irror'like Dnowledge
and t/e sun t/e Dnowledge of E;,alityC
t/e seed and t/e em$lem of t/e partic,lar deity
are said to be 3iscri-inative DnowledgeC
all of t/e- -erged into one are Active DnowledgeC
and t/e perfected $ody is t/e Dnowledge of P,rity5
1/e wise -an s/o,ld conte-plate t/ese five aspects
in t/e rit,al of w/ic/ we speak5
1/e rit,als of t/e /ig/ -onastic c,lt differ fro- t/ose of ?@A@ in
anot/er f,nda-ental way% t/e /ig/ patron deity w/o is t/e 7c/ief of
t/e -andala7Ecalled generically t/e 76er,ka7 of t/e rit,al, or its
7Bearer of t/e MaBra7E-ay be generated twice, in a causal for-
and in a resultant for-5 G"n t/e cycles of t/e Fat/er 1antras t/e
ca,sal deity is often called t/e 7MaBrasattva7 and t/e res,ltant deity
t/e 7Body of 1ransfor-ation75H 1/,s, in t/e evocation above, t/e
Cakrasa-vara prod,ced t/ro,g/ t/e five realiFations is t/e causal
!eruka, colored w/ite5 1/e generation contin,es%
>n a -oon at t/e tops of t/e /eads of bot/ Fat/er and 8ot/er is
>8, and on a s,n at t/eir t/roats and /earts are A6 and 6U85 At
t/e break of t/eir waists is #MA, on t/eir se9,al organs is A6, and
between t/eir t/ig/s is 6A5
"n t/e 7secret place7 of t/e Fat/er t/ere co-es fro- 6U8 a
w/ite vaBra, fro- BA8 a red ge- Nat its tipO, and t/e /ole is
blocked by a yellow P6A15 "n t/e 7place of space7 of t/e 8ot/er
t/ere co-es fro- A6 a red lot,s, fro- >8 its w/ite ant/ers, and
t/e /ole is blocked by a yellow P6A15
By t/e so,nd of t/e Bliss of t/e ,nion of t/e Fat/er and 8ot/er
and by t/e lig/t fro- t/eir /earts, t/ere are invited bot/ t/ose
w/ose acco-plis/-ent of deity is innate and t/ose beings w/o
/ad been cleansed into t/e -andala of Cakrasa-vara5 Entering into
,nion in t/e sky before -e, t/ey all -elt into Ireat Bliss and enter
t/ro,g/ -y -o,t/C descending t/e central c/annel, t/ey pass
t/ro,g/ t/e vaBra and ge-, and fall and -i9 into t/e ant/ers of t/e
8ot/er5 1/e Fat/er and 8ot/er dissolve into a ball of Bliss w/ic/
is as if in t/e for- of ;,icksilver5
"n so-e rit,al traditions
1&
t/e Ireat Bliss of t/e retin,e takes t/e for-
of a 7syllable of ftardo'awareness7Eeit/er 6U8 or >8 A6 6U8E
w/ic/, again, enters into t/e Fat/er and passes t/ro,g/ /is vaBra'penis
and into t/e lot,s'vagina of t/e 8ot/er, to be placed between two
syllables 6>6 before t/e deities dissolveC b,t in any event t/is 7-elted
deity7Et/is 7ball of Bliss7Eis 7aro,sed wit/ song7 to create t/e
resultant !eruka, colored bl,e%
All t/e B,dd/as of t/e ten directions aro,se Nt/e -elted deityO wit/
t/e song >8 8A6A#UD6A8 MAL2A#A11MA LA8 6U8 BA8
6>6 #U2A# 1MA8 32#JA 6>6 K 7>8 Ireat Bliss, MaBrasattva
LA6 6U8 BA8 6>6 K Jo, are t/e deity% beco-e visible 6>6 K7E
and instantaneo,sly it beco-es t/e Blessed Ilorio,s Cakrasa-vara,
/is body colored bl,e5
And t/en, after t/e res,ltant 6er,ka is generated, t/e retin,e of t/e
-andala is conte-platively created in t/e sa-e way%
11. #!E (1+# OF ?ERS4 11(
"n t/e 7secret place7 of t/e Fat/er t/ere co-es fro- 6U8% a
bl,e vaBra, fro- BA8 a red ge- Nat its tipO, and t/e /ole is blocked by
a yellow P6A15 "n t/e 7place of space7 of t/e 8ot/er t/ere co-es
fro- A6 a red lot,s, fro- >8 its bl,e ant/ers, and t/e /ole is
blocked by a yellow P6A15
By t/e so,nd of t/e Bliss of t/e ,nion of t/e Fat/er and 8ot/er and
by t/e lig/t fro- t/eir /earts, t/ere are invited all t/e 1at/a'gatas of
t/e ten directions5 Entering t/ro,g/ t/e B,nct,re of -y eyebrows,
t/ey arrive in -y /eart and -elt into l,stC descending t/e central
c/annel, t/ey pass t/ro,g/ t/e ge- and fall into t/e vagina of t/e
8ot/er, and t/ey ass,-e t/e roles of t/e deities w/o reside in t/e
residential -andala5
1/e retin,e of t/e -andala radiates o,t fro- t/e 8ot/er<s wo-b,
step by step, and t/ey take t/eir proper places in t/e divine -ansion5
1/is -ore elaborate generation of t/e sy-bolic being /as been worked
into -any of t/e classic sc/e-atiFations of t/e Process of Ieneration as
a w/ole5 1/,s we find t/at t/e cycles of Ja-antaka talk of 7fo,r
yogas7C as it is said in t/e #antra of the lack 2layer of DeathC
1I1
First t/e conte-plation is yoga,
second is further yoga,
t/ird is higher yoga,
and fo,rt/ is great yoga4
And t/e sa-e te9t elaborates ,pon t/ese fo,r%
1/e perfected MaBrasattva,
we -aintain, is yoga7
wit/ t/at as its ca,se, t/e divine body
is known as further yoga7
t/e co-plete perfection of all t/e retin,e
we /old to be higher yoga7
e-powering body, speec/, and -ind,
t/e eyes of t/e deity and so on,
absorbing t/e knowledge retin,e,
great offerings and praise,
is called great yoga4
1/,s, 1songk<apa glosses, yoga is t/e -editation of t/e 7MaBrasattva,7
t/e 7ca,sal Bearer of t/e MaBraEpossessing an essence of Dnowledge of
P,rityEevoked t/ro,g/ t/e five realiFations,7 and further yoga is t/e
yoga of t/e res,ltant Bearer of t/e MaBra5 !igher yoga is t/e 7perfection
of t/e retin,e% t/e Fat/er and 8ot/er enter into ,nion, t/e retin,e of
t/e deities generated in t/e lot,s radiate o,t and are arrayed eac/ in
/is own place57 And, finally, great yoga incl,des all
t/e re-aining acts of t/e rit,al% 7e-powering body, speec/ and -ind nd
so on, absorbing t/e knowledge being, sealing wit/ t/e initiation,
offerings and praise57 And /e adds%
1)
{11 t/e yogas w/ic/ are t/e fo,ndation of t/e Process of Ieneration
are s,bs,-ed ,nder t/ese fo,r yogas% t/e first two Gt/e evocation
of t/e c/ief Fat/er'8ot/erH are considered 7little yoga57 After t/at
t/e t/ird yoga Gadding t/e perfect evocation of t/e retin,e of
deitiesH is 7-iddle yoga57 And finally evoking oneself as of one
taste wit/ t/e knowledge being, e-powering one<s eyes and so on,
is 7great yoga57
"n t/e #antra of the Diamond &avilion
1
*
I%
t/e entire rit,al se;,ence of
t/e 6evaBra cycle is arranged ,nder 7si9 li-bs,7 beginning wit/ t/e
generation of t/e divine -ansion fro- B62U8, t/e seed of t/e
B,dd/a Mairocana, and incl,ding t/e f,rt/er acts of offering and
praise and t/e 7tasting of nectar7Et/e vis,aliFation of t/e -antra
7iss,ing fort/ wit/ lig/t fro- t/e 6U8 in one<s /eart, traversing t/e
vaBra pat/ t/ro,g/ t/e central c/annel, circling t/ro,g/ t/e <lot,s< of
t/e goddess and ,pward fro- -o,t/ to -o,t/57
1.
1/,s it says%
6aving -ade perfect t/e fo,ndation of B,dd/a/ood,
t/e s,bstance of t/e tr,t/ of t/e All'Beneficent,
/aving conte-plated t/e five aspects,
one s/o,ld do t/e -eans of evoking t/e s,pre-e deity,
likewise arraying t/e -andala,
offerings and praise, nectar, and so on%
if one conte-plates wit/ t/is se;,ence,
we /old it to be t/e yoga of 7si9 li-bs57
3,rBayacandra
1(
correlates t/ese si9 li-bs wit/ t/e si9 fa-ilies of
B,dd/a spoken of in t/e 8ot/er 1antras%
3oing 7dia-ond l,st7 and conte-plating
t/e separation of t/e divine -ansion of B,dd/a/ood,
initiation and t/e tasting of nectar,
offerings and praise% conte-plate t/e si9 li-bs5
4/at is t/is si9'li-bed yoga:
By it one ;,ickly gains t/e -agical attain-ents5
1/e palaceC B,dd/a Mairocana,
t/e initiationC Aksob/ya 1at/agata,
lasting nectarC A-itab/a,
praiseC glorio,s 2atnasa-b/ava,
offeringsC A-og/asidd/i<s perfect offering,
lustC MaBrasattva5
1/,s t/e first li-b is t/e vis,aliFation of t/e residential -andalaC as
"ndrabod/i says%
1
11+ #!E (1+# OF ?EQE
r
WOR2!.
&
11
Conte-plate t/e 7so,rce of all events,7 vis,aliFe t/e
B,dd/a placed t/erein5 5 5 5 1/e great Con;,eror Mairocana
is born fro- t/e syllable of t/e 3/ar-a real-C /e arrays
t/e B,dd/as in place5
1/e first li-b, says 1songk<apa, 7is t/e conte-plation of t/e divine
-ansion, t/e place of B,dd/a/ood, arisen fro- Mairocana% t/e reason for t/is
is t/at t/e body is t/e residence of t/e -ind% Mairocana, too, is t/e essence of
t/e <aggregate of for-< of t/e 1at/agatas, and so /e generates t/eir residential
divine -ansion57ye 1/e second li-b is t/e act,al generation of t/e deity, /ere
called 7dia-ond l,st57 1/e Diamond &avilion says%
>ne s/o,ld conte-plate t/e five aspects,
first vis,aliFing t/e person,
t/en radiating t/e circle of dakinls5
1/e gandharva enters
and fallsC t/ey -eltC t/inking of t/e-
t/e goddesses of t/e ;,arters aro,se it5
Aro,sed, t/ey draw in t/e retin,e%
on t/e eyes Lady 3el,sion and so on,
and t/e t/ree 3ia-onds arrayed in t/e t/ree places5
1/is t/en is 7dia-ond l,st7%
knowledge enters in act,ality5
1songk<apa glosses t/is as follows%
"n t/e second li-b one generates t/e ca,sal Fat/er'8ot/er Bearer of t/e
MaBra t/ro,g/ t/e five realiFations, e-powers t/e two 7secret places7 and
perfor-s t/e pride of l,st, prod,ces t/e goddesses of t/e retin,e and arrays
t/e- in place, aro,ses t/e -elted deity wit/ song, arises t/erefro-,
e-powers t/e eyes and so on and absorbs t/e knowledge being% t/ere is no
one w/o does not /old t/at all t/ese are incl,ded ,nder t/e li-b of 7l,st57
6ence all of t/eseEfro- conte-plating t/e five realiFations w/ic/
generate t/e deity w/o resides in t/e residence, t/ro,g/ t/e perfect generation
of t/e sy-bolic retin,e, e-powering and absorbing t/e knowledge beingEis
t/e perfor-ance of MaBrasattva, t/e pride of /is l,st, and t/e prod,ction of t/e
retin,e fro- oneself% t/is is t/e second li-b5
1/e reason for s,bs,-ing 7l,st7 ,nder MaBrasattva is beca,se /ere one
e-anates t/e deities of t/e retin,e fro- t/e 7t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent7 Nt/e
,nion of vaBra and lot,sO of t/e Fat/er and 8ot/er, and t/erefore t/e two
c/ief deities -,st perfor- 7l,st7% and t/at is /eld to be MaBrasattva5
fo,r re-aining li-bs are given by "ndrabod/i, one in eac/ of t/e
following lines%
1/e eig/t -antra goddesses initiate,
and one s/o,ld taste, the nectar7
t/e eig/t goddesses -ake offerings,
and one s/o,ld praise t/e conB,red retin,e5
And 1songk<apa again identifies eac/ li-b wit/ a B,dd/a5
#i-ilarly, t/e Diamond )arland #antra,
1II
part of t/e I,/yasa'-aBa cycle,
speaks of 7t/ree -editations7% /ere first preparations incl,des t/e preli-inary
acts and t/e co-plete generation of t/e Fat/er'8ot/er deity, t/e highest king
of the mandala is t/e deity as radiating t/e divine retin,e fro- wit/in t/e
wo-b of t/e 8ot/er, and t/e highest king of the ritual is t/e co-plete -andala
e-ployed in serving t/e ai-s of all beings5
1/ese t/ree -editations, again, are identified wit/ t/e t/ree bodies of
B,dd/a/ood% in t/e first preparations, says 1songk<apa, t/ere is t/e e-anation
of t/e divine to acco-plis/ first one<s own ai-, so t/is is considered t/e
Essential Body or 3/ar-a BodyC t/en t/e first bodies of 7for-7 arise to serve
t/e ai- of ot/ers t/ro,g/ t/e power of t/e Essential Body, so t/e /ig/est king
of t/e -andala is considered t/e Body of BlissC and t/en t/e divine /osts serve
t/e ai- of beings in t/e ten directions, eac/ one e-anating w/ile staying in /is
own place, so t/e /ig/est king of t/e rit,al is considered t/e Body of
1ransfor-ation5
"n t/e rit,als based on t/e Arya co--entatorial tradition of $agarB,na and
/is followers, /owever, t/e first preparations are e9panded to incl,de t/e
entire generation t/ro,g/ t/e absorption of t/e knowledge being, and t/e two
/ig/est kings are toget/er correlated wit/ t/e initiation of t/e deity5
Candraklrti<s .llumining +amp t/,s says t/at t/e great evocation spoken of in
t/e )uhya-sama-a #antra incl,des bot/ t/e /ig/est king of t/e -andala and t/e
/ig/est king of t/e rit,alC it is t/e 7great7 evocation beca,se t/ese two /ig/est
kings 7perfor- t/e actions of a B,dd/a7 and acco-plis/ t/e great ai- of ot/ers5
1/e first t/ree of t/e )uhyasama-as fo,r li-bs of approac/ and evocation,
t/en, are all incl,ded ,nder first preparations, and t/ey are 7s,bsidiaries of
acco-plis/ing one<s own ai-57
"n t/e co--entatorial tradition of B,dd/aBnana and /is Evocation 3amed
'll-$eneficent, on t/e ot/er /and, all fo,r of t/ese
11! #!E (1+# OF #
1 119
li-bs of approac/ and evocation are applied separately to t/e
Fat/er, t/e 8ot/er, and t/e /ig/est king of t/e -andala, w/ic/ are
t/en called t/e 7little,7 t/e 7-iddle,7 and t/e 7great7 for-s of t/e fo,r
li-bsC t/e rit,als of I,/yasa-aBa based on t/is sc/ool are in
conse;,ence so-eti-es e9traordinarily invol,ted and diffic,lt to
follow5
Ritual seTuence Four lim$s Four yogas #hree
meditations
#i9 lim$s
E-ptiness Approac/ First
preparations
Protective circle
3ivine -ansion Mairocana
1H #y-bolic being%
Ca,sal Bearer of
t/e MaBra
Joga
2es,ltant Bearer
of t/e MaBra
F,rt/er yoga
2adiation of t/e
2etin,e
6ig/er yoga 6ig/est king
of t/e -andala
MaBrasattva
l,st
)H E-powering t/e
senses
$ear
evocation
Ireat yoga 6ig/est king
of t/e rit,al
*H Dnowledge
being
Evocation
.H #caling Ireat
evocation
Aksob/ya
>fferings A-og/asidd/i
Praise 2atnasa-b/av
a
1asting nectar A-itab/a
2ecitation
E9cept for t/ese Grat/er i-portantH co-plications, t/e fo,r -aBor
classic sc/e-as of t/e Process of Ieneration -ay be easily seen in t/e
acco-panying table5 And 1songk<apa concl,des /is disc,ssion
o
f
t/ese syste-s by saying% 71/ese are t/e notewort/y classifications of
t/e Process of Ieneration% if one e9a-ines a rit,al wit/ t/ese as a basis,
one will know w/et/er t/e -ain points of t/is first Process are
co-plete or not57
1!
"n all t/ese dry and sc/olarly analyses we -ay yet see t/e /and of
-agical sy-bolis-5 1/e e-otional power of se9,al i-agery is /arnessed
to t/e -agic of identity, and we can perceive t/e direction t/e
correspondences will take% t/e processes of birt/ are /o-olo'giFed to
t/e creation of t/e deity and t/e ac/ieve-ent of B,dd/a'/ood5 1/e
body of t/e yogin contains all t/ese wit/in it, and it is in t/is /ig/ rit,al
of t/e -onastic c,ltEwit/ its preli-inary pattern of five realiFations
and its -anifold correspondencesEt/at we find t/e greatest
elaboration of -agical analogy5 1/ere are, indeed, any n,-ber of
variations ,pon t/e basic o,tline, especially in t/e generation of t/e
sy-bolic beingC a few sc/oolsEnotably t/e Arya tradition of
co--entary on t/e I,/yasa-aBa cycleEdepart so-eti-es radically
fro- o,r sc/e-e5 B,t all t/ese variations s/are t/e sa-e basic
str,ct,re and an essential core of -agical correspondences, w/ic/
1songk<apa analyFes after a lengt/y disc,ssion of individ,al differences
and w/ic/ /e correlates not only wit/ deat/, birt/, and $ardo b,t also
wit/ t/e individ,al events of t/e pat/ to B,dd/a'/ood5
"t -ig/t be well to review briefly t/e standard se;,ence of Bod/i'
sattva #tages over w/ic/ t/e Me/icle of t/e 8antra grants -agical
control, and w/ic/ re;,ire in t/e Me/icle of t/e Perfections t/ree
7incalc,lable eons7 to traverse%
19
**H>n t/e #tage of t/e 7Beginner7 t/e aspirant strives to ac
;,ire /is stocks of -erit and knowledge% t/is is e;,ivalent to
t/e
7Pat/ of Acc,-,lation57 1/is #tage e9tends fro- t/e
first
t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent t/ro,g/ t/e conte-plative growt/
of
fait/ and wisdo-, ,ntil t/e e9perience, of 7war-t/,7 t/e
first
signpost of s,ccess in -editation5
*.H>n t/e #tage of 7Practicing wit/ Conviction7 t/e Bod/isat'
tva c,ltivates t/e fo,r 7aids to penetration,7 beginning wit/
t/e
e9perience of 7war-t/,7 t/ro,g/ 7cli-a9,7 7acceptance,7
and
finally t/e 7/ig/est event in t/e world57 1/is is e;,ivalent to
t/e
7Pat/ of Preparation,7 w/ereon t/ese -editative
e9periences
#!E (1+# OF ki{{
overco-e and e9pel t/e antit/esis between s,bBect and obBect
and lead to nondiscri-inative knowledge5 1/en t/ere is t/e
-o-ent of 7i--ediate s,ccession7 w/ere t/e 7/ig/est event i
n
t/e world7 is transfor-ed into t/e s,pra-,ndane state of t/e
first of t/e ten basic stages of t/e Bod/isattva5
*(H1/is 7first stage,7 called 7t/e Boyf,l,7 is, like t/e re-aining
ones, associated wit/ t/e partic,lar Perfection t/at is
/eld to
c/aracteriFe it5 1/is is e;,ivalent to t/e 7Pat/ of Mision7
w/ere
t/e Bod/isattva for t/e first ti-e tr,ly 7sees7 t/e Fo,r
$oble
1r,t/s% /e sees s,ffering, its ca,se, its cessation, and t/e
pat/
to its cessation, and it is t/is pat/ t/at /e ne9t
proceeds to
develop5
*+H1/e re-aining basic stages are traversed in order5 "t /as taken
t/e Bod/isattva one incalc,lable eon to reac/ t/e first
stage and
it will take anot/er to reac/ beyond t/e sevent/C for
,pon t/e
eig/t/ stage /e is no longer liable to reversal since /e is
bo,nd, in
only one -ore eon, for B,dd/a/ood5 1/ese nine re-aining
basic
stages are t/,s e;,ivalent to t/e 7Pat/ of 3evelop-ent,7
w/ic/
c,l-inates in t/e 3ia-ond'like Conte-plation,
w/erein t/e
Bod/isattva f,lfills t/e Perfections of 8editation and
4isdo- and
destroys all t/e resid,es of defile-ent in t/e -o-ent
before /e
ac/ieves enlig/ten-ent5
*HFinally, in t/e -o-ent of 7instantaneo,s realiFation,7 t/e
Bod/isattva reac/es t/e #tage of a B,dd/a, t/e 7Pat/
beyond
Learning57
1/is Bod/isattva Pat/, and t/e -ost i-portant events ,pon it,
are o,tlined in t/e acco-panying table5
$ow s,ppose, says 1songk<apa, t/at so-eone acc,-,lates t/e
kar-a t/at is t/e ca,se of /is taking birt/ in a wo-b, and t/en dies
and reac/es t/e inter-ediate state of t/e $ardo4 As a $ardo-aBare-
ness /e enters into a -ot/er<s wo-b and stays t/ere ,ntil /e is born
o,tside, and t/en /e /i-self takes a wife and begets sons and
da,g/ters5 $ow s,ppose too t/at /e w/o /as done all t/ese t/ings
7-akes t/e- into religio,s obBects7 and conte-plates t/e Process
of Ieneration in accord wit/ /e-5
First /e will vis,aliFe t/e field of /osts and acc,-,late t/e stocks,
w/ic/ is like acc,-,lating t/e kar-a t/at ca,ses /i- to be born in
t/is world5 6ere t/e acts, s,c/ as t/e 7intentional7 and 7act,al7
t/o,g/ts of enlig/ten-ent, are in co--on wit/ t/e Me/icle of t/e
Perfections% and t/is -ay also be correlated wit/ t/e
Bod/isattva<s Pat/ of Acc,-,lation, as it says in
Ab/ayakarag,pta<s (lusters of #raditionC
1>=
Acc,-,lationE
Preparation
Mision
3evelop-entE
Beyond learning
1)&
UVO2!.&
1)1
1/,s it is% t/e Bod/isattva<s stage of acc,-,lation is like t/e
state of being in t/e world, beca,se /e acc,-,lates t/e stocks
co-pletely, in accordance wit/ t/e LawC b,t /ere /e acc,-,lates
o
nly t/e -erit of C/arity and so on, w/ereas before /e acc,-,lated
bot/ virt,e and evil5
(ontemplative events
Five aids to
liberation%
*!H Fait/
*9H #triving
.&H 8indf,lness
.1H Conte-plation
.)H 4isdo-
'Practicing wit/
conviction
.*H 4ar-t/
..H Cli-a9
.(H Acceptance
.+H 6ig/est event
in t/e world
"--ediate s,ccession
'G1H 1/e Boyf,l
|G)H 1/e stainless 'G*H
1/e ill,-ining 'G.H 1/e
fla-ing 'G(H 1/e /ard'to'
con;,er 'G+H 1/e face'to'
face |GH 1/e far'going '
G!H 1/e i--ovable 'G9H
1/e good'insig/t G1&H 1/e
clo,d of t/e Law
3ia-ond'like
conte-plation
"nstantaneo,s
realiFation
'B,dd/a
1
)
# WO2!.
1
)
$e9t, t/e
conte-plation of
E-ptiness is like deat/,
beca,se w/en one
decides t/at t/e
7aggregates7Et/e
fo,ndation of clinging
to 7"7 and 7-ine7Eare
essenceless, t/eir
7appearances7 are
n,llified, and it is like
giving ,p one<s worn'
o,t aggregates at t/e
-o-ent of deat/5 And
t/is too -ay be
correlated wit/ t/e
Bod/isattva<s Pat/ of
Preparation, as
Ab/ayakarag,pta says%
1/e stage of
7practicing wit/
conviction7 is like t/e
state w/ere t/e pat/ of
deat/ first beco-es
visible, beca,se it is
in/erently a
preparatory 7aid to
penetration57 After
t/is, at t/e end of t/e
preparatory state Glike
t/e after'deat/ $ardo
w/en one<s being in
t/e world is c,t offH,
one is in t/e state of
7i--ediate
s,ccession7 to t/e
7Boyf,l7 stage, as
nat,rally as one
instant passes on fro-
t/e dissol,tion of t/e
end of t/e preceding
one5
1/,s t/e 7/ig/est event
in t/e world,7 says
1songk<apa, beco-es
t/e 7i--ediate
s,ccession7 to t/e, first
of t/e ten Bod/isattva
stages, B,st as t/e $ardo
is preparatory to t/e state
of being in t/e wo-b5 As
it says in t/e ' dornment of
the 2utras of the
)reat6ehicleC
1
W
1
1/en
wit/o,
t
/indra
nce
one ;,ickly to,c/es
-editation5
$e9t t/e practitioner
vis,aliFes t/e generation
of t/e deity, w/ic/ is like
entering into t/e wo-b
fro- t/e $ardo and
growing t/erein as an
e-bryo5 1/is too -ay be
correlated wit/ t/e
Bod/isattva<s growt/
t/ro,g/ t/e ten stages, /is
Pat/s of Mision and
3evelop-ent, as
Ab/ayakarag,pta says%
After t/at, as t/e state
of being in t/e wo-b
follows ,pon t/e
dissol,tion of t/e
for- Gw/atever it
wasH w/ic/ one /ad in
t/e state of $ardo, t/e
state of t/e ten
Bod/isattva stages is
to be to,c/ed after t/e
dissol,tion of
7i--ediate
&erfectio
n
&at
h
'Fo,r aids
to'
penetration%
'C/arityE
'Mirt,e
Acceptance'
#trivingE
8editation'
4isdo-
8eans
2esolve
#trengt/
Dnowledge'
s,ccession,7 beca,se
N,p to t/is pointO
t/eBod/isattvas are still
possessed of
obsc,ration5
6ere, says 1songk<apa,
t/ere are two
possibilities% t/e
practitioner -ay 7enter
t/e wo-b7 eit/er wit/ or
w/ito,t 7-elting57 L,st
as a gandharva enters t/e
wo-b wi/to,t -elting,
t/e seed syllable t/at
radiates lig/t /as 7t/e
nat,re of t/e $ardo-
heing,< placed between
two orbs t/at are se-en
and blood, t/e latter 7like
a s,n arisen fro- -any
-ont/ly periods of
wo-en57 1/,s, w/ere a
te9t says t/at a s,n is
generated fro- t/e
consonants Gas in t/e
rit,al of Cakrasa-'vara,
aboveH, 7t/e intention is
to consider it a <red
-oon<7C t/e entry
between t/ese two
7-oons7 of t/e 7syllable
sy-boliFing $ar-do< is
like a $ardo-$eing
entering wit/in t/e
-i9ed se-en and blood
of its parents5
1/,s, too, t/e si9teen
vowels above t/e central
t/rone sy-boliFe t/e
7si9teen portions of
se-en w/ic/ are t/e
inner places of t/e
body7% t/ese are divided
into 8eans and
4isdo-, -aking t/irty'
two t/e n,-ber of t/e
bodily 7signs of
B,dd/a/ood7, and for
t/at reason t/e vowels
too are do,bled5
Ab/ayakarag,pta ;,otes
t/e following verses%
1/e syllable
A is at t/e
base of t/e
t/,-bs,
t/e syllable A
on t/e calves
of t/e legs,
t/e syllable "
on t/e two
t/ig/s,
t/e syllable "
on t/e secret
place,
t/e syllable U
on t/e base of
t/e navel,
t/e syllable &
on t/e belly,
t/e syllable 2
between t/e
breasts,
t/e syllable 2
on t/e /ands,
t/e syllable L
on t/e neck,
t/e syllable L
on t/e lips,
t/e syllable E
on t/e c/eeks,
t/e syllable
A" on t/e
eyes,
t/e syllable Z
on t/e nase of
t/e ears,
t/e syllable
AU on t/e
/eads,
t/e syllables
A8 and A6
on t/e crown5
Let t/e wise
-an
conte-plate
in t/is way%
/e will be
placed in t/e
w/iteness of
fort,ne
and t,rned
fro- t/e
blackness of
adversity5
1/ese are t/e si9teen
portions of se-en, t/e
t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent
wit/in t/e bodyC t/ey are
si-ilarly placed in t/e
#antra of the 'ppearance
of (akrasamvara,
1
W
"
and
2atnaraksita says in /is
co--entary t/ereon%
1!*
71/e left side5557
-eans t/at t/e
7w/iteness of
fort,ne7 is taken as
t/e left side of t/e
body, fro- t/e
t/,-bs to t/e /ead
Nt/e order of t/e verses
aboveO, and t/e
7blackness of
adversity7 enters in on
t/e rig/t side, fro-
t/e /ead to t/e
t/,-bs5
1/,s t/e si9teen
portions are divided into
t/irty'two, according to
t/eir position on t/e left
or rig/t side of t/e body,
and t/e two /alves of
t/e body are correlated
again wit/ 8eans and
4isdo-, as
2atnaraksita ;,otes t/e
!eva-ra #anlra
N"5viii5(&O%
1
/
e
B
l
e
s
s
e
d
>
n
e
i
s
t
/
e
f
o
r
-
o
f
s
e
-
e
n
,
a
n
d
t
/
e
L
,
s
t
f
,
l
L
a
d
y
i
s
t
/
e
B
l
i
s
s
t
/
e
r
e
o
f
5
1/en, again, t/ere are
t/irty'fo,r consonants
above t/e central t/rone,
fro- DA to D#AC and to
t/ese are added si9
-oreGJA 2A
1
)
#
W
O
1
LA MA 3A 36AH,
-aking forty, 7possessed
of -enstr,al blood57
1/ese are divided into
8eans and 4isdo-E
E-ptiness and Bliss E
-aking eig/ty, t/e
n,-ber of t/e bodily
7secondary signs of
B,dd/a/ood,7 and for
t/at reason t/e
consonants too are
do,bled5
>f co,rse, not all te9ts
do,ble t/e vowels and
t/e consonants, nor is
t/ere any strong
agree-ent ,pon w/ic/
prod,ces t/e -oon and
w/ic/ t/e 7second -oon7
or 7s,n57
1!.
B,t t/e basic
core of sy-bolis- is
clear% t/e syllable enters
between t/e se-en and
t/e blood, and t/e
practitioner enters t/e
wo-b5 1/en 7fro- t/e
appropriate seed between
t/e two -oons Gor t/e
-oon and t/e s,nH, one
conte-plates t/e
transfor-ation into t/e
e-ble- -arked wit/ t/e
seed57 "n -any of t/ese
rit,als t/is e-ble- is a
five'pronged vaBraC as t/e
(lusters of #raditions
e9plains in one place, its
five prongs are t/e feet,
/ands, and /ead of t/e
e-bryo, and in anot/er
place t/at its five prongs
are t/e five fingers and
toes on eac/ /and and
eac/ foot, and t/e five
sense'organs on t/e /ead%
7anyt/ing, in fact,7 says
1songk<apa, 7classified
into a gro,p of five57
6evaBra<s e-ble- -ay
be a sk,ll bowl, and t/at
of t/e 2ed #layer of
3eat/ a stick%
7accordingly we believe
t/at anyt/ing w/ic/ can
sy-boliFe t/e
develop-ent of t/e body
in t/e wo-b is
per-issible57
>n t/e ot/er /and, if
t/e deity 7-elts7 and is
7aro,sed wit/ song,7
t/en t/e ca,sal Bearer of
t/e MaBra perfected fro-
t/e five realiFations is
like t/e fat/er and
-ot/erC fro- t/e entry
of t/e $ardo-$eing ,p to
b,t not incl,ding t/e
perfection of t/e deity<s
body, everyt/ing is
correlated wit/ t/e state
of being in t/e wo-b5
1/,s t/e retin,e enters
into t/e ca,sal deity and
traverses t/e vaBra pat/C
Ab/ayakarag,pta
disting,is/es two
traditions of interpreta=
tion% one -aintains t/at
t/is descent t/ro,g/ t/e
penis into t/e wo-b
sy-boliFes t/e obsc,ring
wit/ greater degrees of
l,st in t/e $ardo as one
descends toward a
wo-bC t/e ot/er
-aintains t/at it serves to
sy-boliFe t/e l,st for t/e
Bliss t/at is t/e essence
of t/e 8eans and
4isdo-Et/e se-en and
bloodEw/ic/ co-e fro-
t/e f,t,re fat/er and
-ot/er5
Again, /ow does t/e
ftardo'being enter into t/e
ca,sal deity :
Ab/ayakarag,pta says%
For t/at sa-e reason
t/e Blessed >ne
e9po,nded
intentionally in t/e
1antras, teac/ing to
so-e deities t/at t/e
sentient being Et/e
gandharvaEenters
t/ro,g/ t/e 7golden
gate,7 to so-e t/at it
enters t/ro,g/ t/e
-o,t/, and to so-e
t/at it enters 7in
anot/er way57
1/,s t/e gandharva -ay
enter t/ro,g/ t/e top of
t/e /ead Gt/e 7golden
gate7 or t/e 7gate of
Mairocana7H or t/ro,g/
t/e -o,t/C or it -ay
enter 7in anot/er way,7
into t/e vagina of t/e
8ot/er5 1/ese are t/e
t/ree gates t/ro,g/
w/ic/ it enters, says
1songk<apa, and t/ese are
t/e ca,ses for its entering
t/ro,g/ t/e-% a
gandharva enters
t/ro,g/ t/e -o,t/ o,t of
a desire to 7s,ck t/e
/oney7 fro- one of its
parents< lips, and it
enters t/ro,g/ t/e gate
of Mairocana o,t of a
desire to stroke one of
its parents< /air5 "n bot/
instances it enters
t/ro,g/ t/e gate of t/e
fat/er if it /as l,st for a
-ale, and t/ro,g/ t/at of
t/e -ot/er if it /as l,st
for a fe-ale Galt/o,g/
so-e /old t/at in t/ese
cases it enters only
t/ro,g/ t/e -ot/erH5 And
t/e arg,-ent is t/e sa-e
for entering into t/e
vagina, eit/er directly or
t/ro,g/ t/e Fat/er<s
penis, for 7t/ere is no
one way it is done7C it
-ay enter t/e first
t/ro,g/ t/e 7lot,s7 of
t/e 8ot/er, or it -ay
enter into t/e Fat/er
and traverse t/e vaBra
pat/ into t/e wo-b5
4/en it enters t/e
wo-b, /owever, bot/
Fat/er and 8ot/er
7beco-e as if senseless
wit/ Bliss7C its entry is
t/e 7condition for Fat/er
and 8ot/er to -elt wit/
great l,st,7 and t/ey
re-ain in t/e for- of a
7drop57 1/en t/e -elted
deity is aro,sed wit/
song% if correlated wit/
t/e 7fr,ition,7 t/is is t/e
practitioner Gas B,dd/aH
being aro,sed to t/e ai-
of beings wit/ t/e Fo,r
"--eas,rables and
arising in a body of for-
for t/e sake of /is
followersC if correlated
wit/ t/e 7t/ings to be
p,rified,7 t/e fo,r
goddesses w/o aro,se
t/e deity wit/ song are
t/e fo,r ele-ents, so it is
e;,ivalent to t/e
;,ickened foet,s being
7/eld wit/ eart/,
a-assed wit/ water,
ripened wit/ fire, and
e9panded wit/ air57
"f t/e deity in t/e
partic,lar rit,al does
not -elt and is not
aro,sed wit/ song, t/en
t/e first fo,r
realiFations are
considered to be t/e
ca,sal deity, and t/e
fift/ t/e res,ltant deityC
w/en t/e deity does
-elt, all five
realiFations perfect t/e
ca,sal deity, and t/ere
t/e seed syllable
Gbetween t/e two orbsH is
not taken as t/e $ardo-
$eing4
1/,s, finally, t/e
practitioner perfects t/e
body of t/e c/ief Fat/er'
8ot/er, w/ic/ is like
being born o,t fro- t/e
wo-bC and t/e /ig/est
king of t/e -andalaE
bot/ t/e Fat/er and
8ot/er prod,cing t/e
-ale and fe-ale deities
of t/e retin,eEis like t/e
begetting of sons and
da,g/ters Gin t/e original
e9a-pleH5 As it says in
t/e (lusters of #raditionC
1)+
#!E (1+# OF #'R'4
1)
6aving grasped t/e perfected fr,it Nof /is kar-a } t/e bodyO, /e is born
t/at /e -ay e9perience all sense obBects, for /e e9periences t/e obBects of all
/is senses5 1/en t/e Body of 1ransfor-ation in t/e state of radiating t/e
deities is like t/e state of begetting sons, and so on5
1/is too -ay be correlated wit/ t/e Bod/isattva<s Pat/ beyond Learning, and
Ab/ayakarag,pta ;,otes t/e #antra of 9ystic 1nionC
19X
1/,s in t/e sense of being preparatory
t/e ten -ont/s are t/e ten stages%
t/ey bot/ fall ,nder t/e r,bric of ten stages of beings5
1/e p,rport, says 1songk<apa, is t/at fro- entering into t/e wo-b ,ntil being
born o,tside is correlated wit/ t/e ten Bod/isattva stagesC so t/ose
inter-ediate stages -,st be classified as t/e Pat/s of Mision and
3evelop-ent, and being born as t/e Pat/ beyond Learning5
1songk<apa concl,des t/is lengt/y analysis wit/ a s,--ary of its -ain
points, w/ic/ gives a concise res,-e of t/e -agical sy-bolis- o,tlined above%
1!(
"n t/e Process of Ieneration, it is necessary to recogniFe t/e 7t/ing to be
p,rified7 and t/e 7p,rifier7% t/e -et/od of t/is recognition is t/e
conte-plation of birt/, deat/ and $ardo B,st as t/ey are% so /ere we -,st
disc,ss in addition t/e act,al way in w/ic/ one 7takes birt/57
6ere, t/e one w/o takes birt/ is t/e conte-plating pratitioner5 "n w/at
sort of a body does /e take birt/ : 6e takes birt/ in t/e body of t/e c/ief
Fat/er'8ot/er, t/e res,ltant Bearer of t/e MaBra5 4/ere does /e take
birt/: Upon t/e central t/rone of t/e divine -ansion, in an act,al $ardo
arisen fro- a crossed vaBra5 By acc,-,lating w/at sort of kar-a does /e take
birt/ : By /is 7stocks7Evis,aliFing t/e special field, -aking /o-age and
offerings, awakening /is t/o,g/t of enlig/ten-ent, taking /is vows and so on5
$ow it is not proper t/at /e take t/e 7special body7 of t/e deity in t/at
-anner wit/o,t first abandoning /is ordinary 7aggregates,7 so /e takes it after
/aving n,llified /is 7ordinary appearance7 and 7ordinary ego7 wit/
E-ptiness5
B,t in t/e trackless interval between giving ,p /is for-er 7ordinary
aggregates7 ,ntil /e gains t/e later 7special body7 of t/e deity, /e is not born
in t/e divine body% so it is /ere Gafter conte-plating E-ptiness and before
perfecting t/e res,ltant Bearer of t/e MaBraH t/at /e -,st do t/e yogas of
7reposing in P,re #o,nd7 and so on Nt/at is, t/e conte-plation of t/e
7syllable
~ t/e ftardo'being7O5 6ere, #rlp/alavaBra was once asked% 74/at is t/e point
of dwelling in t/e five syllables Nt/e [Z[ ZY S[
t
iClM" 6>6 in t/e
8ot/er<s wo-bO: >ne s/o,ld take t/e divine body i--ediately after
conte-plating E-ptiness, to serve t/e ai- of beings% b,t /ere one does not
do so57 "n answer to t/is contention /e said t/at /is evocation was written as
an 7antidote to t/e t/ree states,7 so one -,st conte-plate oneself also as
e;,ivalent to a $ardo-$eing4
1/,s t/e ca,sal Fat/er'8ot/er Bearer of t/e MaBra enter into ,nion, after
being perfected fro- t/e five realiFations% and if one sees t/e- t/,s Gsince
one /as t/e aspect of a $ardo-$eingD, one enters into t/e wo-b of t/e 8ot/er5
1/is, too, is clearly stated by #rlp/alavaBra%
76e also enters into t/e glorio,s MaBrasattva w/o is enBoying Ireat Bliss,
seeing t/at all beings enter into /is -o,t/5 3esire arises t/at /e /i-self
-ig/t possess in act,ality t/ose wondro,s creat,res and sense'obBects, and t/is
infallibly res,lts% in t/is conte-plation of t/e 8ot/er as t/e < so,rce of all
events,< any being w/atever Gt/o,g/ possessed of t/e two obsc,rationsH -ay
attain to B,dd/a/ood by entering into /er5 6ence let /i- -ake /is -ind
fir- in t/is -anner% <Beca,se " s/o,ld attain to being All'Beneficent, let -e
enter into t/is very place<Eand in t/e for- of t/e <five syllables of t/e
$ardo-$eing* /e enters like a la-p into t/e secret lot,s of t/e 8ot/er57
6aving granted t/e necessity of doing as /e says, one -,st learn fro-
t/e co--entaries t/e e9act way in w/ic/ one enters5
1/en /e arises t/ro,g/ aro,sing t/e -elted deity wit/ song% we /ave already
e9plained t/at t/is is t/e occassion of perfectly attaining birt/5 "f one well
,nderstands t/e reasons for t/is 7aro,sing t/e -elted deity wit/ song,7
t/en one will knew t/at it is inad-issible t/at a B,dd/a co,ld wis/ to serve
t/e ai- of t/ose /e takes in /and only t/ro,g/ t/e 3/ar-a Body wit/o,t a
body of for-% it is i-possible to effect t/e ai-s of sentient beings in 7reality7
wit/o,t a body of for-, so for t/at reason a follower of t/e Ireat Melicle
-,st consider t/e part of 8eans to be t/e -ost i-portant5
And /aving taken birt/ in t/at -anner, w/at s/o,ld one do ne9t: 1/at is
s/own by w/at follows in t/e te9t% one perfectly generates t/e deities of t/e
7/ig/est king of t/e -andala7C and t/ose w/o /ave been generated are p,t to
t/eir vario,s e-ploy-ents, t/at t/ereby one -ay serve t/e ai-s of beings5
16E P2>CE## >F PE2FEC1">$
1/e Process of Ieneration is a se;,ence of conte-plative events t/at prod,ce
a divine bodyC bot/ t/e body and t/e events are si-,lacra for t/e -agical
control of a wide range of realities5 1/e e9'
1)!
#!E (1+# OF #'R'
WOR2!.
&
1)9
tensive correspondences t/at set fort/ t/e -anip,lable i-ages and
t/eir obBects are fo,nd, as we /ave noted, only in t/e /ig/ rit,als of
t/e -onastic c,lt, w/ere t/e analogies are applied to basically
soteriological ends5 "ndeed, in -any rit,als w/ose intent is -agical
Ew/ose p,rpose is t/e control of aspects of p,blic nonreality rat/er
t/an divine ,nderstandingEt/e generation -ay be abbreviated even
to t/e point of being instantaneo,s5 As 1songk<apa says%
1!+
"f t/e practitioner /as no fit followers on any occasion, /e si-ply
dwells wit/ t/e Body of Ireat BlissC w/en t/ey co-e to /i-, /e
7appears7 to t/e- in a body of for-, so /e aro,ses t/e -elted
deity wit/ song t/at /e -ay act for t/eir benefitC and for t/e sake of
ot/ers /e does not 7-elt7 b,t dwells in t/e ravis/ing 7appearance7
of a body prod,ced instantaneo,sly5
"n rit,als of t/e soteriological type, /owever, t/ese correspondences
provide t/e yogin wit/ a range of -agical control over t/e -ost
i-portant events of /is -ortal and conte-plative life, and t/ese
analogies for- a backdrop of affect even in t/e si-plest evocation,
w/erever t/e yogin appears in t/e body of t/e god, to w/atever end5 A
diagra- of t/e preceding section will s/ow t/at t/ese powers of t/e
divine body fall into two -ain gro,ps%
#aking $irth )eneration
kar-a
stocks
Acc,-,lationEBeginner
8irror'like
E;,ality E
3iscri-inative
I A oi i VP
birt/EG(H Body Beyond LearningEB,dd/a
f P,rity
1/e left'/and col,-nE7taking birt/7Eis an elaboration of t/e
t/reefold 7birt/, deat/, and $ardo,< t/e 7t/ings to be p,rified7 by
t/e 7p,rifiers,7 t/e conte-plative events of t/e generation5 1/is is
t/e sa-e set of -agical powers we /ave seen before in t/e t/ree rites
and t/e fo,r realiFations, /ere e9panded to a fivefold table of
correspondencesC /ere too, w/en t/ese states /ave been
cleansed by t/e Process of Ieneration, t/ey -ay be ripened and
perfected into t/e #tages, t/e Pat/s, and t/e Dnowledges5 1/e
diagra- o-its -any of t/e -inor correspondences of t/e generation%
t/e do,bled vowels above t/e central t/rone, for e9a-ple, ripen into
t/e t/irty'two bodily signs of B,dd/a/ood, and t/e do,bled
consonants into t/e eig/ty secondary signs5 1/is play of -agically
potent sy-bolis- -ay be carried to t/e li-its of ingen,ity, restricted
only by t/e received lists of n,-erical analogies and t/e a,t/ority of
t/e great co--entatorial traditions5 All t/ese correspondencesEt/e
p,rification of events in t/e world and t/eir fr,ition in t/e divine
real-s of B,dd/a/oodEare based on t/e sa-e pre-ise% conte-plative
events are -agical si-,lacra for all ot/er events, and t/e yogin<s divine
body stands between two realities as t/e 7"nnate Union of
appearance and E-ptiness57 74e reBect t/e opinion,7 says
1songk<apa, 7t/at t/e <t/ings to be p,rified< and t/e <p,ri fier< are
connected only -etap/orically57
1!
1/is divine body, prod,ced by t/e Process of Ieneration and
containing in itself and in its own for-ation t/e -agical correspon=
dences t/at control bot/ B,dd/a/ood and t/e world, is called t/e
mantra $ody, for it is t/is body t/at e9ercises t/e power of divine
speec/5 B,t t/is body is yet i-p,reC t/o,g/ it appears and speaks as
t/e god it as yet does not possess t/e f,llness of divine ,nderstanding%
t/e -antra body -,st be p,rified into t/e knoBledge $ody by
i--ersion in t/e Clear Lig/t of E-ptiness5
1!a
1/e ;,estion is% 4/at does t/e yogin do wit/ /is divinity once /e
/as gained it: A deity generated only in frontEas in a rit,al of offering
E-ay be asked to depart wit/ t/e -antra 8U6 K once its 7/eart /as
been aro,sed7 wit/ t/e /o-age, offerings, and recitation of t/e
-antra for w/ic/ it was s,--oned5 1/e practitioner -ay take
e-power-ent fro- t/e deity before /i- by t/e 7process of gat/ering
in,7 vis,aliFing t/at t/e knowledge being separates and dissolves into
/is fore/ead wit/ ZY S[ 6U8C or /e -ay establis/ t/e deity in a
7basis7Ea painting or an i-ageEw/ic/ is t/ereby consecrated,
vis,aliFing t/at t/e knowledge being dissolves into it wit/
#UP2A1"#16A 7#tanding fir- K7 B,t t/o,g/ t/e deity in front
-ay be bot/ re;,ested and coerced by t/e vis,aliFation and recitation
to 7grant t/e -agical attain-ents,7 it is only in t/e divine body
t/at t/e practitioner wields t/e power of attaining t/e divine
enlig/ten-entC t/e opport,nities in self'genera Lion e9tend beyond t/e
-anifest e9ercise of power in t/e world, t/o,g/ t/is is
2tag
e
,noBledg
e
&at
h
deat/ G1H #,c/ness
parentsEG)H 8oon
e-bryoEG*H E-ble-
Practicing
EPreparationE
wit/ Conviction
$ardo-$eine,EG.H #eed "'1en staaes'
i3evelop-ent <
1*&
#!E (1+# OF WOR2!.
&
1*1
certainly a part of t/e basic intention G-any rit,als prescribe t/at t/e
knowledge being be asked to depart t/e yogin, w/o 7dwells steadfastly
wit/ t/e ego of t/e sy-bolic being7 to apply t/e power of t/e deity
,pon p,blic nonrealityH5 B,t in t/e -ost profo,nd of t/e /ig/ rit,als,
t/e self'generation ends wit/ t/e special vis,aliFations of t/e Process
of Perfection, t/e 7gat/ering in and arising7 t/at pl,nges t/e deity
into a divine E-ptiness and allows t/e now p,re knowledge body to
7leap fort/7 fro- t/e Clear Lig/t as t/e 7"nnate Union of t/e Clear
Lig/t and E-ptiness57
1/,s t/e answer to t/e ;,estion, 74/at does t/e yogin do wit/ /is
divinity:7 is si-ply t/is% /e does anyt/ing /e wis/es5 6e -ay control
t/e events of p,blic nonreality wit/ t/e power of t/e -antra, or as a
B,dd/a /e -ay i--erse /i-self in a B,dd/a<s E-ptiness, controlling
/is own appre/ension t/ro,g/ t/e si-,lacr,- of /is divine body5
1/,s t/e rit,al of Cakrasa-vara, w/ose Process of Ieneration we /ave
reviewed above, concl,des its section of self'generation wit/ t/e
following Process of Perfection%
1!!
1/e vowels and consonants, wit/ five'colored lig/t, radiate fort/
fro- -y rig/t nostril, bearing on t/eir tips t/e deities of t/e t/ree
circles of t/e -andalaC t/ey p,rify t/e triple world and -ake it
into t/eir own essenceC and t/e entire worldEnow t/e sa-e as
t/ose dakas and yoginls, innately divineEenters t/ro,g/ -y left
nostril and reac/es t/e level of -y navel5
1/en fro- t/e vowels and fro- t/e consonants appears a -oon of
w/ite and red radiance, and fro- t/ose dakas and yoginls " see a
w/ite and red 6U8C and t/at again beco-es t/e two'ar-ed
Blessed >ne, Fat/er and 8ot/er doing t/e sport of l,stC and by t/e
so,nd of t/eir e9perience of #pontaneo,s Bliss, t/e sy-bolic
-andala is aro,sed and satiated wit/ Ireat Bliss5
Fro- t/e cre-ation gro,nds inward, t/e entire -andala Nin=
cl,ding -yself in t/e centerO is gat/ered in d,e order into t/e
Fat/er and 8ot/er at -y navelC and t/ose two again dissolve
into lig/t and are retransfor-ed into t/e -oon and its 6U85 1/e
-oon dissolves into t/e 6U8, t/e U vowel into t/e 6A, t/at into t/e
/ead stroke, t/at into t/e crescent, t/at into t/e dot, and t/at
dissolves into P,re #o,nd5
1/e P,re #o,nd grows fainter and fainter, ,ntil finally " enter
into t/e inconceivability t/at is free of all obBectification5
1/is is t/e Process of Perfection in one of its si-plest for-s, and we
s/all see a very si-ilar conte-plation in t/e rit,al service of ?@A@
given in c/apter iii5 B,t t/e process is not yet finis/ed, for t/e
practitioner -,st still arise in t/e Body of "nnate Union, 7like a
fis/ le
a
P
-
# fro- water,7 t/at /e -ay serve t/e ai- of beings in a body
of for-5 1/is arising is instantaneo,s, and t/e practitioner dwells in
t/e knowledge body p,rified by its i--ersion in t/e Clear
Lig/t'
4e s/o,ld e-p/asiFe /ere t/e feedback -ec/anis- involved in
t/is conte-plation5 Bot/ processes begin wit/ t/e appre/ension of
E-ptiness, and t/is E-ptiness is always t/e sa-eC it is t/e appre=
/ension t/at differs5 "n t/e Process of Perfection, E-ptiness is
approac/ed by t/e practitioner as deity, and it is appre/ended 7as
it tr,ly is7 by a divine ,nderstanding5 1/e -agical powers of t/e
Process of Ieneration are /ere e9ercised in t/e coercion of
enlig/ten-ent itself% t/e tables of correspondences s/ow t/e practi=
tioner /is control of t/e #tages and t/e Pat/s, /is fr,ition in t/e
Process of Perfection5 1/e yogin -anip,lates t/e very steps of /is
divine generation as si-,lacra for /is ,lti-ate attain-ent% /e can
7gat/er in7 /is -antra body to t/e Clear Lig/t beca,se /e possesses it
in its essenceC /e can arise fro- t/e Clear Lig/t in /is knowledge body
beca,se of t/e -agical analogies /e controls5 1/,s t/e Process of
Perfection is possible only beca,se t/e practitioner is a deity, and a
deity for-ed t/ro,g/ a series of -agically potent conte-plative
eventsC t/,s t/e Process of Ieneration is a necessary prere;,isite for
t/is final appre/ension of t/e absol,te tr,t/5 7Jogins w/o desire
t/e Process of Perfection,7 one te9t typically says, 7-,st b,ild ,pon
t/e fo,ndation of t/e Process of Ieneration57
1!9
1/is feedback works t/ro,g/ a yogin<s entire conte-plative
career5 A beginner in solitary conte-plation, no -atter /ow precise
/is intellect,al training, sees E-ptiness as a sort of vag,e blackness,
called ,p to swallow /is ordinary awareness and labeled in accordance
wit/ t/e intellect,al categories of t/e -onastic college5 Fro- t/e real-
of t/is E-ptiness co-e t/e first /alting vis,aliFations of /i-self as t/e
deityC yet even t/ese s/adowy identifications wit/ t/e divine grant a
-agical control G/owever weakH w/ic/ brings /is final pl,nge wit/ into
Ireat E-ptiness a little closer to tr,e 7non'obBectifiability57 4it/ t/is
greater appre/ension /e begins again% eac/ ti-e /e is -ore of a
deity, and eac/ ti-e /is coercion of t/e divine ,nderstanding beco-es
-ore powerf,l5 6e -oves closer to /is 7nat,ral flow,7 w/erein /e sees
t/at an essence of Clear Lig/t is t/e basic nat,re of all eventsC /e sees
t/at /e /i-self, as t/e deity, is t/e "nnate Union of t/e Clear Lig/t
and E-ptiness5 And by t/e ti-e
1*)
#!E (1+# OF ?EY
1**
/e /as spent si9 -ont/s or a year in rit,al service, /is vis,aliFation
and ,nderstanding reinforce eac/ ot/er% /e is t/e deity beca,se /e
can create t/e deity, and /e can create t/e deity beca,se /e is t/e
deity5
1/is rapid increase of ,nderstandingEt/is ;,ick pat/ of B,dd/a'
/oodEis based ,pon /is -agical power, for it is only t/ro,g/ t/e si=
-,lacra of t/e Process of Ieneration t/at /e can -agically -anip,late
t/e fr,ition of t/e Process of PerfectionC o,t of t/is spiraling ability
co-es t/e power to control all realities, to apply /is vis,aliFation and
recitation ,pon t/e p,blic world, to own t/e ,niverse in /is body5
1/e process of Perfection is generally s,bs,-ed ,nder t/e two
/eadings, 7wit/ signs7 and 7signless57 As 1enpe nyi-a says, ;,oting
t/e Oral #eachings of the +ord of 2ecretsC 71o t,rn i-p,re appearances
into p,re appearances, and to conte-plate t/e- as t/e retin,e of
one<s -andala, is t/e Process of Ieneration5 B,t t/ese -,st be
,nderstood in t/e knowledge of Bliss and E-ptiness% /ence to
conte-plate t/e deep conte-plation <wit/ signs< Gt/e c/annels,
winds, and dropH and <signless< G#,c/nessH is t/e Process of
Perfection57
19&
1/e Process of Perfection Bith signs refers to t/e p/ysical yoga t/at
t/e B,dd/ist 1antras s/are wit/ -any 6ind, traditions, t/e control
of t/e 7winds7 wit/in t/e 7c/annels7 and t/e -anip,lation of t/e
7drop7 t/ro,g/ t/e central c/annel to 7pierce t/e vital centers7 of
t/e divine body5 1/e signless Process of Perfection is t/e 7gat/ering in7
of t/e body of t/e god and 7arising7 t/erewit/ fro- t/e Clear Lig/t of
E-ptiness5 As 1songk<apa says%
191
1/,s if one knows t/e -ain points of t/e tec/ni;,e of bringing
fort/ t/e c/annels, winds and drop, and is able to ,tiliFe t/e winds
and drop in t/e yoga w/ic/ pierces t/e vital centers, t/en one is
able to prod,ce t/e deep conte-plation of t/e fo,r Boys based
,pon reversing t/e evol,tion of one<s bodily ele-ents, and to
adorn t/at conte-plation wit/ t/e Ireat Bliss and Clear Lig/t,
i-posing ,pon it no -ental constr,cts5
B,t to do not/ing else is not t/e conte-plation% rat/er -,st one
base oneself on t/ose tec/ni;,es, and t/en -ove on to prod,ce t/e
entirely p,re view w/ic/ sets fort/ t/e -eaning of 7essenceless'
ness7, beca,seEin ot/er wordsEeven wit/ t/ose two sorts of con=
te-plation one is still ,nable to cross over fro- t/is world5 As it
says in t/e Discourse on the #hought of EnlightenmentC
18"
4/oever does not know E-ptiness
is no fit basis for freedo-%
del,ded, /e will be w/irled abo,t
in t/e si9 destinies, t/e prison of t/is world5
6ence one -,st enter into t/e /o,se of -editation and conte-=
plate t/e -eaning of 7essencelessness57
Fro- t/e general "ndian yogic c,lt,s t/e B,dd/ist 1antras in/erited
t/e notion t/at certain p/ysical -anip,lations of t/e body Gt/e
raising of t/e drop of se-en t/ro,g/ t/e central c/annel to t/e top of
t/e /ead, t/e aro,sing of /eat below t/e navel, and a w/ole co-ple9 of
si-ilar e9ercisesH prod,ce e9periences of bliss or Boy, w/ic/ are often
acco-panied by blaFing lig/ts and roaring so,nds, vis,al and sonic
enco,nters wit/ a divine state5 3asg,pta
19*
/as written e9tensively
,pon t/ese early tec/ni;,esC b,t t/e B,dd/ists, especially as t/e
1antras were incorporated into t/e sc/olarly fra-ework of t/e
,niversity c,rric,l,-, saw t/ese e9periences not as ends in t/e-selves
b,t rat/er as possible -agical si-,lacra wit/in t/e body for t/e
attain-ent of t/e rapt,re of enlig/ten-entC to t/e intellect,al
categories of E-ptiness t/ey added t/e e9periential di-ensions of
Ireat Bliss and Clear Lig/t, always warning Gas aboveH t/at bliss or
lig/t wit/o,t E-ptiness was si-ple sens,al ind,lgence5
1/ere /ave been atte-pts to correlate t/is yoga wit/ act,al p/ysi=
ology, or to interpret it sy-bolically, b,t we -,st bear in -ind t/at t/e
p/ysical events take place wit/in t/e body of t/e god, and t/e
sy-bolis- beco-es a set of -agical correspondences5 "f t/e signless
Process of Perfection coerces t/e divine ,nderstanding of E-ptiness,
t/en t/e Process of Perfection wit/ signs coerces t/e divine e9perience
of t/e Ireat Bliss, t/e divine vision of t/e Clear Lig/t, t/e divine
/earing of t/e 7,nstr,ck so,nd7 of E-ptiness5 And t/is coercion is
-ade t/ro,g/ t/e yogin<s -anip,lation of /is divine body, t/e
pri-ary si-,lacr,- for t/e e9perience, w/ic/ in t,rn beco-es t/e
si-ilacr,- for t/e attain-entC t/e divine e9perience is bro,g/t abo,t
t/ro,g/ possession of t/e divine body and t/e attain-ent of
E-ptiness is bro,g/t abo,t t/ro,g/ possession of t/e divine
e9perience5 All t/ese are based ,pon t/e Process of Ieneration,
w/ic/ provides t/e -agical sy-bolic potency of t/e -ani'p,lable divine
i-age, t/e pri-ary i-pet,s for t/e entire branc/ing tree of realiFation,
w/ose final fr,it is a divine body of "nnate Union, arisen fro-
E-ptiness and possessed of B,dd/a/ood%
1*.
#!E (1+# OF
1*(
(ontemplative Reality
i-age cobBect
Process of Ieneration Process of Perfection
wit/ signs G'signless
gat/ering in s arising
1/ese varied e9periences of bliss, lig/t, and so,nd t,-ble ,pon
t/e yogin as /e nears t/e goal, w/et/er t/ey are coerced by -ani=
p,lation or occ,r spontaneo,sly in conte-plation5 1/,s we find t/e
te9ts speaking of 7t/e e9perience of Lig/t and E-ptiness adorned
wit/ Bliss,7 and we read biograp/ical acco,nts s,c/ as t/e following%
19.
6e entered t/e gate Nof initiationO and began to conte-plate, and
/e gained possession of a body of for- w/ic/ was 7appearance and
E-ptiness57 6e was wit/o,t o,ter or inner, above or below, front or
rear, before or afterC /e was ,n-ade, ,nli-ited, ,ndividedC /e was
wit/o,t essence in appearance, wit/o,t bias in Lig/t, wit/o,t
defile-ent in BlissC /is glow was t/e Clear Lig/t, /is nat,re t/e
,nprod,ced, /is prowess -anifold5 And in t/is real- of ,ndefiled
Ireat Bliss /e saw t/e playEt/e residence and its residents, gods
and goddesses, dakas and dakinlsEt/e s,btle and self'spr,ng
,nderstanding, t/e -irac,lo,s knowledge5 All eventsEinner and
o,terEwere t/e appearance of /is -ind, occ,rring as t/e -anifold
prowess of /is ,nderstanding5
Fro- t/e -o-ent /e gained t/is appearance and E-ptiness /e
penetrated it as t/e Clear Lig/t, ,nconstr,ed, ,nfat/o-able,
e-pty of arising, abiding, and peris/ingC /e co-pre/ended t/e
nat,ral pace of /is ordinary knowledge as a gen,ine and innate
nat,re, and w/atever appeared as t/e play of t/e 3/ar-a Body,
Bliss, and E-ptiness, t/e pit/ of conditioned coprod,ction5 5 5 5
"n t/is state /e p,rified away s,bBect and obBect, and /e perfected
/is prowess of great knowledgeC as an attain-ent fro- t/is real- of
t/e Clear Lig/t of conte-plation, fro- t/en on /e knew t/at
w/atever occ,redEat t/e very -o-ent of its appearance Ewas
itself lig/t and itself clarity, ,nfat/o-able, ,nprod,ced, t/e nat,re
of Ireat Bliss, self'spr,ng, self'erected5
6e realiFed -any 7gateways to conte-plation7% t/e s/ining of
ge-s, t/e la-p of ge-s, t/e s/ining of t/e -oon, t/e la-p of t/e s,n,
t/e seeing of all t/ings5 1/ere appeared in /is -ind endless
insig/ts, visions, s,pernor-al powers, and signs of s,ccess, s,c/ t/at "
cannot write t/e- down, t/ey were so -any and so e9traordinary5
1/is cascade of conte-plative e9periences in t/e Process of Per=
fection is t/e e9periential 7given7 str,ct,red by t/e 1antric te9ts and
t/eir co--entators5 1/is process of refine-ent was bot/ an e9pansion
and a selection, for t/ere occ,red a typically B,dd/ist e9tension of
conte-plative tec/ni;,e to new areas and an e;,ally typical
sc/e-atiFation of t/e res,ltant options5 1/,s t/e sa-e conte-plative
tec/ni;,e -ay be ,sed to different ends% 7piercing t/e vital
centers7Et/e vis,aliFation of a 6U8 -oving wit/in t/e central
c/annel of t/e divine and 7/ollow7 bodyE-ig/t serve as t/e i-age
to t/e obBect of t/e 7-ystic /eat7 and t/e 7fo,r Boys,7 a grad,al
approac/ to t/e Ireat Bliss of E-ptiness, w/ere t/e 6U8 is
si-,lacr,- for t/e drop of se-en, itself /o-ologiFed to t/e t/o,g/t of
enlig/ten-ent5 B,t t/e 6U8 -ig/t also serve as si-,lacr,- for
awareness Gt/e yogin<s own or even t/at of anot/erH and its -otion
-agically control t/e transference of t/at awareness t/ro,g/ t/e gates
of deat/, to a different body, or directly to a P,re LandC or t/e
syllable -ig/t represent t/e practitioner<s life, and its vis,aliFed
i--obilityEcalled 7planting t/e -agic dagger of life in t/e /eart7E
grant freedo- fro- deat/% t/e sa-e vis,aliFation and -agical control,
b,t to radically opposite ends5
Again, we find different conte-plative e9ercises and analogies e-=
ployed for entering into E-ptiness% t/e divine body -ay be /o-o=
logiFed to t/e 7ill,sory7 bodies of t/e drea-, a -irror reflection, t/e
$ardo, to gain t/e 7"nnate Union of appearance and E-ptiness,7 and
t/ere are f,rt/er e-p/ases ,pon different types of 7"nnate Union,7 a
c/oice of t/e aspects of E-ptiness5 E-ptiness s/ines wit/ t/e Clear
Lig/t, and its e9perience is Ireat Bliss, and in t/e grad,al approac/ to
realiFation t/ere are different levels of appre/ension of E-ptiness, of
lig/t, and of BoyC t/e pat/ to enlig/ten-ent -ay follow t/e track of
any co-bination, as long as E-ptiness is t/ere5
1/,s Mir,pa
19(
arranges conte-plative e9perience in a se;,ence of
7views7 w/ic/ orders t/ese varied approac/es in a /ierarc/y of "nnate
UnionC /e speaks of 7appearance and E-ptiness7C 7Lig/t and
E-ptiness,7 7Bliss and E-ptiness,7 and t/e c,l-inating ,nion of
7,nderstanding and E-ptiness57 B,t t/ere is also t/e possibility of
c/oice a-ong t/ese pat/s to enlig/ten-ent, granting always t/at t/e
final e9perience incl,des t/e- all5 "t is c,rio,s, for e9a-ple, t/at
t/o,g/ B,dd/ists and 6ind,s agree on Bliss as an aspect of
#!E (1+# OF ?EP1
realiFation, B,dd/is- /as tended to e9cl,de t/e se;,ence of
sonic e9periences as an approac/ to t/e final goal, c/oosing to
e-p/asiFe t/e vis,al pat/% t/e early -ystic songs spoke e;,ally of
bot/ aspects of conte-plative e9perience, b,t t/e 6ind, 1antras
c/ose to treat of so,nd Gper/aps a /eritage of ort/odo9 8i-a-sa
p/ilosop/yH and t/e B,dd/ist of lig/t, alt/o,g/ t/ere is always an
in/erited overlapC b,t t/e 6ind,s tend to /ear t/e roaring of
enlig/ten-ent above its lig/t, and t/e B,dd/ists to see its lig/t
above its roar5
"ndeed, eac/ cycle of 1antric te9ts /as its own tec/ni;,e for
i--ersing t/e divine body into E-ptiness, varying in e-p/asis
,pon lig/t and Boy and analogical -editation5 1/e well'known
set of t/e 7si9 yogas of $aropa7 is essentially an ant/ology of t/ese
tec/ni;,es of t/e Process of Perfection, eac/ pres,-ing a prior
Process of Ieneration, and eac/ traced to its canonical so,rces and
-aBor co--entators5
19+
1/is 1antric notion of 7"nnate Union7 is a central concept de
serving -ore st,dy t/an is possible /ereC in c/apter iii " e9a-ine
its integration into rit,al and its f,nction in ac;,iring t/e divine
power5 4ay-an
19
/as given a detailed disc,ssion fro- t/e works
of 1songk<apa, based -ainly ,pon t/e )uhysama-a tradition, and
2,egg
19!
gives a brilliant s,--ary of t/e Process of Perfection
according to t/e 7five steps7 of $agarB,na<s Arya tradition5
Per/aps t/e -ost i-portant point is t/e correlation of t/e Clear
Lig/t or of Ireat Bliss wit/ 7Co-plete E-ptiness7 as t/e c,l-ina=
tion of a series of realiFationsC b,t we -,st re-e-ber t/at t/e
series of fo,r lig/ts or Boys w/ic/ lead ,p to t/is final e9perience are
not different t/ings, b,t rat/er serve as 7-etap/ors7 for differing
levels of awareness of t/e one 7act,al7 Clear Lig/t or Ireat Bliss5
#i-ilarly, t/e different levels of realiFation of t/e one E-ptiness
are given different na-es to correspond to t/e different
appre/ensions of its radiance and rapt,reC we -ay tab,late t/e
series of realiFations as follows, as t/ey are correlated -agically
wit/ t/e bodies of B,dd/a/ood and wit/ t/e fo,r places of t/e
body of t/e god%
ELig/t Loy Body of $avel
1ransfor-ation
EAppearance 6ig/est Loy
3/ar-a
BodyE6eart
of lig/t
EC,l-ination Loy of
of lig/t Cessation
Co-plete E-ptiness Clear Lig/t "nnate LoyE
GIreat BlissH
1*
1/ere are bot/ orderings and c/oices a-ong t/e possibilities of
o-bination of t/ese e9periences, reading t/e diagra- eit/er /ori'
ontally or vertically, b,t /ere we briefly follow a single pat/ to en=
lig/ten-ent and e9a-ine t/e ,nfolding of t/e Clear Lig/t of E-pti=
ness5 As LoFang c/<oc/i nyi-a G1*)'1!&)H writes%
199
Alt/o,g/ t/e Clear Lig/t and E-ptiness are two, t/ey are not
separate% E-ptiness is t/e nat,re of -ind, and t/e Clear Lig/t
is fo,nd in t/e s/ifting interstices of t/e seeker of E-ptiness5
6ence w/en t/ere is t/e Clear Lig/t t/ere is E-ptiness, and fro-
t/e real- of E-ptiness t/e Clear Lig/t appears of itself5 1/e
Clear Lig/t and E-ptiness t/,s occ,rring are deter-ined to be
innately one% t/,s t/ey are in 7"nnate Union57 And t/,s arising
fro- t/e real- w/erein one e9periences only t/e absence of -ental
obBects, w/atever 7appears7 occ,rs as t/e play of t/e non'd,ality
of t/is world and nirvana5 #ince one e9periences t/is, one ,nder=
stands t/e entire ;,ality of t/e -ind w/ic/ is t/e "nnate Union
of Lig/t and E-ptiness, called 7t/e nat,re of t/e gen,ine -ind57
"solating t/e ele-ents fro- t/e c/art above, t/e grad,al
,nfolding of t/e lig/t of E-ptinessEt/e growing appre/ension of
t/e Clear Lig/tE-ay be diagra-ed alternatively, as s/own /ere5
Apperance as Clear Lig/t
E-ptiness
8etap/or
Clear
Lig/t
Beco-ing Clear Lig/t
Ireat E-ptiness
II C,l-ination
as Clear Lig/t
Co-plete E-ptiness
1/is se;,ence of develop-ent is, as 1songk<apa /as pointed
o,t, a 7reversal of evol,tion,7 and t/,s it -ay work toward t/e
creation of t/e world of appearances as well as toward its
dissol,tion5 1/e '$ridged .nstructions, an ant/ology of basic DaBii
teac/ings, contains a section on t/e Clear Lig/t written by
$gawang Fangpo, w/erein we find a specifically 1antric sc/e-e of
t/e evol,tion and devol,tion of d,alistic awareness w/ic/ parallels
t/e acco,nt of t/e constr,ction of nonreality e9a-ined above%
)&&
#o-eone w/o /as neit/er been instr,cted nor /as t/e -indf,l'
ness to recogniFe t/ings as t/ey really are insists ,pon taking
t/ings to be tr,e% t/,s t/e first of fo,r stages is t/at an event
appears as a real thing4
1*+
E-ptiness
8ore E-ptiness
'Body of BlissE1/roat
E"nnate Body 6ead Ireat E-ptiness'
"ncrease as Clear Lig/t
8ore E-ptiness
Act,al
Clear Lig/t
1*! #!E (1+# OF
1*9
6e t/en e9a-ines t/is t/ing, and /e decides t/at it is good
or
bad,
as appropriate% t/is second stage is t/at an event increases as a real
thing4
1/ro,g/ /is del,sionEnot knowing t/e obBect ne,trally to be
E-pty for-Eit beco-es, if good, an obBect of desire w/ic/ /e
-akes plans to get or, if bad, an obBect of aversion w/ic/ /e
-akes plans to avoid% t/is t/ird stage is t/at an event $ecomes a real
thing4
6is Boy at getting an obBect of desire and at no one else getting it
involves l,st and pride5 6is c/agrin at so-eone else getting it and at
not getting it /i-self involves /atred and envy5 "t i
s
t/ro,g/ /is
not knowing t/e obBect to be E-pty t/at /e tries to get w/at is
good and avoid w/at is badEt/at /e /as Boy or c/agrin at
w/et/er /e or so-eone else gets it or notEso all of t/ose involve
del,sion5 1/,s t/e five poisons are ever present in a single obBect of
desire, and it is t/e sa-e for /is avoiding or not avoiding an obBect of
aversion5 1/,s t/e five poisons are ever present in any obBect t/at
/e first takes to be a real t/ingC /ence /e is ever reborn in t/is worldC
/ence /e e9periences inter-inable s,fferingC /ence t/ere occ,r t/e
inter-ediate states between t/e birt/ and deat/ of appearances w/ic/
are inversions of t/e Clear Lig/t% t/is fo,rt/ stage is t/e way in w/ic/
an event culminates as a real thing4
1/ere is an inti-ate connection between t/e Clear Lig/t and t/ese
inter-ediate states w/ic/ are its inversions, for it is t/e Clear Lig/t
t/at s/ines t/ro,g/ t/e 7s/ifting interstices7 in t/e strea- of events,
any strea- of events, -acro' or -icrocos-ic, depending solely ,pon
t/e scope of t/e conte9t5 1/ere are t/,s inter-ediate states between
two -o-ents in t/e -ove-ent of a single t/o,g/t, and between t/e
dissol,tion and recreation of t/e cos-osC and, in a 7-edi,- conte9t,7
$gawang Fangpo -entions t/ree special $ardos Einter-ediate states
E7between t/e deat/ and birt/ of an event7% t/e 7drea- $ardo<
between sleeping and waking, t/e 7waking $ardo< between two
t/o,g/ts, and t/e <$ardo of dissol,tion into E-ptiness7 at t/e -o-ent
of deat/5 1/is last is also called t/e <$ardo of dying7 between deat/ and
t/e ill,sory body'awareness of t/e 7ill,sory $ardo< w/ic/ occ,rs in
t,rn between deat/ and t/e ne9t life5
4e -ay note /ere t/e level distinctions, t/e contin,o,s process of
s,bdivision5 #ince t/ere is an inter-ediate state between lives, an
earlier conception t/at served as t/e -odel for all t/e ot/er $ardos, t/ere
is an inter-ediate state between t/e -o-ent of act,al deat/ and t/e
first inter-ediate state, and so on Gso-eti-es t/e foet,s in t/e wo-b is
considered to be in a $ardo between t/at last inter-edi'
ate state and act,al birt/H5 1ibetan, not to -ention 4estern, t/eorists
/ave spent -,c/ ti-e and ingen,ity in t/e el,cidation, wit/ c/arts, of
t/ese states, b,t for o,r p,rposes t/e -ost i-portant t/ing to bear in
-ind is t/at all t/ese inter-ediate states are t/e s/ifting interstices
t/ro,g/ w/ic/ one can get a gli-pse of t/e Clear Lig/t5 Eac/ $ardo
reveals t/e E-ptiness t/at lies be/ind t/e appearance5
1/,s t/ere is a sort of nat,ral awareness of t/e Clear Lig/t
between two t/o,g/ts, especially in t/ose instants of great -ental
tension w/en t/ere is a break in t/e ot/erwise contin,o,s flow of
-ental events, -o-ents of great anger or rage or of se9,al orgas-, or
d,ring t/e c/ange of state fro- sleeping to waking, or in drea-less
sleepEt/ose fa-iliar ti-es w/en t/o,g/t slows down or stops for an
instant, and one gets a -isty gli-pse of t/e lig/t be/ind t/e t/o,g/t5
As 15 #5 Eliot writes%
)&1
>,r gaFe is s,b-arine, o,r eyes look ,pward
And see t/e lig/t t/at fract,res t/ro,g/ ,n;,iet water5
4e see t/e lig/t b,t see not w/ence it co-es5
A brig/ter and longer Clear Lig/t co-es w/en t/e ca,sal basis of t/e
p/ysical body is re-oved by deat/% t/is is t/e 7Clear Lig/t of deat/7
w/ic/ corresponds to t/e $ardo of dying5 1/is lig/t is so brig/t and
strong, /owever, t/at t/e average person flees it in panic rat/er
t/an recogniFing it for w/at it is5 1/e i-portant process of dying
/as been caref,lly analyFed, and t/e re-oval of t/e body begins wit/
t/e dissol,tion of its co-ponent ele-ents%
)&)
First, e9ternally, t/e dying -an vo-its ,ndigested food and
drinkC /is war-t/ di-inis/es, /is /ead bristles, and /e feels t/at /e
is falling downward5
1/en t/e five ele-ents dissolve into one anot/er in t/is -anner%
6is internal earth is fles/ and boneC t/e sign of its dissol,tion into
e9ternal eart/ is t/at /is body grows /eavy and falls to t/e gro,nd,
and t/e internal sign is t/at /e feels t/at t/e eart/ /as opened ,p
and /e is sinking into it5 Beca,se /is eart/ energy dissolves into
water, /e is ,nable to -aintain /is for-C /is bodily strengt/ slips
away and /is cognition grows clo,ded5
6is internal Bater is blood and p,s, and t/e sign of its dissol,tion
into e9ternal water is t/at /is saliva and -,c,s trickle and /is t/roat
and tong,e grow dry5 Beca,se /is water energy dissolves into fire, /is
bodily war-t/ slips away and /is cognition is so-eti-es clear and
so-eti-es darkened5
I
1.& #!E (1+# OF
WOR2!.
&
1.1
6is internal fire is war-t/, and t/e sign of its dissol,tion int
&
e9ternal fire is t/at /is eyes t,rn inward and /e does not recogniFe
people5 Beca,se /is fire energy dissolves into air, /is war-t/
contracts5
6is internal Bind is breat/C t/e sign of its dissol,tion into e9ternal
wind is t/at /is breat/ w/eeFes and /is li-bs ;,iver, and t/e
internal sign is t/at /is cognition is distorted, so /e t/inks /e sees
cows and so on, and /e /as ;,ick -irage'like flas/es5 All /is lice
leave /is body5
1/e dying -an t/en inverts t/e pattern by w/ic/ events originally
appeared to /i- as real t/ings, t/en increased as real t/ings, beca-e
real t/ings, and finally c,l-inated as real t/ingsEt/e very process by
w/ic/ /e was first cast into t/is world5 By inverting t/e process /e
approac/es nearer and nearer to t/e Clear Lig/t of 3eat/%
1/e blood /e obtained fro- /is -ot/er goes ,pward% t/is is
called t/e 7red pat/,7 and on t/is red pat/ /is appearances occ,r5 At
t/at ti-e, appearance dissolves into increase, and t/e forty -ental
constr,cts -ade fro- l,st are c,t off5
1/e se-en /e obtained fro- /is fat/er goes downward% t/is is
called t/e 7w/ite pat/,7 and on t/is w/ite pat/ /is appearances
occ,r5 At t/at ti-e, increase dissolves into $ecoming, and t/e
t/irty't/ree -ental constr,cts -ade fro- /atred are c,t off5
6is breat/ departs fart/er and fart/er away, and all t/e blood in /is
body gat/ers inside /is life c/annel, and t/e blood -i9es into a
single drop in t/e -iddle of /is /eart% t/is is called t/e 7black pat/,7
and on t/is black pat/ /e is stricken wit/ panic, /e feels as if /e
were falling into an abyss in t/e darkness5 At t/at ti-e, $ecoming
dissolves into culmination, and t/e seven -ental constr,cts -ade
fro- del,sion are c,t off5
Bot/ /is eyes open like a cow<s, roll ,pward, and beco-e glaFedC
e9ternal appearances beco-e to /i- like t/e setting of t/e s,n5 6is
fac,lties, -e-ory, and vision are c,t offC all appearances beco-e
gat/ered into blackness5 1/en /is breat/ departs /is body to t/e
lengt/ of a c,bitC internal appearances beco-e to /i- dark as nig/t5
1/en t/e blood in /is /eart for-s two dropsC /is /ead bows and
/is breat/ departs /is body to t/e lengt/ of an arrow5 1/en t/e
blood in /is /eart for-s t/ree dropsC /e sig/s and /is breat/
departs /is body to t/e lengt/ of a fat/o-5
Forgetting t/e black pat/, t/e breat/ is c,t off o,tsideC t/e red and
w/ite drops -eet toget/er in /is /eart, and t/en /is cognition swoons
into t/e real- of Bliss, /is awareness dissolves into t/e Clear Lig/t,
so t/at /e e9periences t/e "nnate Loy5 1/e perceptions in t/e center
of /is /eart dissolve into 2ealityC t/e -ot/er dissolves into t/e son5
1/e breat/ is c,t off insideC t/e 7-ind t/at rides ,pon t/e winds7
is placed in t/e central c/annel5
$ow at t/is point t/e basic Clear Lig/t appears to all beings, /,t
it is only so-e fewyogins possessed of ,nderstanding w/o can
no
w
7/ave t/e -ot/er -eet t/e son7EBoin t/is basic Clear Lig/t to t/e
7Clear Lig/t of t/e Pat/7 Nw/ic/ /e knows fro- /is conte-plations
d,ring lifeO and instantaneo,sly pass ,pward, to -anifest t/e
nonarising 3/ar-a Body and to serve t/e co,ntless ai-s of beings
wit/ a Body of Bliss and a Body of 1ransfor-ation5 1o -anifest
t/,s -irac,lo,sly t/e t/ree bodies is to be a B,dd/a5
"t is for t/is reason t/at t/ere is profit in gaining a /,-an body, and
it is very i-portant to e9perience t/erewit/ t/e co,nsels of t/e
profo,nd pat/5 1/e act,al Clear Lig/t arises to all beings, b,t
t/ey do not ,nderstand it, and t/ey flee fro- it in terror5
7"n t/e process of reBecting one<s ordinary aggregates to ac;,ire a
divine body,7 writes 1songk<apa, 7we /ave fo,nd t/at it is necessary to
conte-plate in accord wit/ birt/, deat/ and $ardo4 1/e /ig/est pat/s
of t/e Process of Perfection too are a practice ;,ite si-ilar to t/is% so
on t/e occasion of t/e latter Process as well one awakens in one<s
strea- an ,nderstanding of E-ptiness w/ic/ is like t/e process of
deat/, based on t/e strengt/ of t/e yoga of <c/annels, winds and
drop<% and to arise t/erefro- one -,st know t/e rit,al of generating a
deity < arisen as a body w/ic/ is in "nnate Union wit/ ill,sion5<7
)&*
And
t/,s $gawang Fangpo contin,es /is disco,rse on t/e Clear Lig/t, t/e
ontological insig/t granted by t/e -agical reenact-ent of t/e stages
of deat/%
1/ere are t/,s fo,r stages in t/e for-ation of appearances,
w/ic/ are inversions of t/e developing realiFation of t/e Clear
Lig/tC b,t no -atter /ow t/ey occ,rEin large or s-all conte9t,
persisting for longer or s/orter periods of ti-eEt/e practitioner
s/o,ld apply to t/e- t/e following instr,ctions, w/ic/ constit,te a
-et/od for e9periencing t/e Clear Lig/t alone5
L,st after t/ere is for-ed, in t/e first -o-ent, an appearance of a
-ale or a fe-ale, and so on, as an obBect of t/e si9 sense fac,lties
Gw/ic/ are t/e-selves ne,tral in ter-s of deciding w/et/er t/e obBect is
for- or E-ptiness, good or badH, /e knows t/at t/e event is
so-et/ing t/at is for-ed ,nceasingly fro- /is own innate -indC /e
s/o,ld re-e-ber to abandon any -ental constr,ct t/at i-poses
7reality7 ,pon it5 By /olding to t/is -indf,lness t/e appearance of
t/e percept,al obBect beco-es 7,ncontrived,7 wit/o,t t/e addition
of /is own constr,cts5 "t t/,s beco-es a 7deep conte-plation of
-indf,lness,7 7knowledge,7 t/e 3/ar-a Body, or t/e Clear Lig/tC at
t/is stage an event appears as the (lear +ight7 it is called t/e 7deep
conte-plation of E-ptiness57 By for-ing an appearance or t/o,g/t
as t/e Clear Lig/t, t/e practitioner does not take it to be or act as if
it were eit/er good
I
1.) #!E (1+# OF ?EQE WOR2!.
&
1.*
or badC at t/is stage an event increases as the (lear +ight7 it is
called t/e 7deep conte-plation of 8ore E-ptiness57
Beca,se /e is free of taking it to be good or bad, /e does not,
t/ro,g/ desire or aversion, try to get it or avoid itC at t/is stage an
event $ecomes the (lear +ight7 it is called t/e 7deep conte-plation of
Ireat E-ptiness57
By atte-pting neit/er to get it nor to avoid it, /e c,ts off t/e
/appy or -iserable feelings w/ic/ are t/e res,lt of /is getting it or
not getting it, avoiding it or not avoiding it, and w/ic/ are t/e
constr,cts of t/e five poisons5 6e t/,s c,ts off s,ffering and
dwells in t/e all'absorbingC at t/is stage an event culminates as the
(lear +ight7 it is called t/e 7deep conte-plation of Co-plete
E-ptiness57
1/is is t/e basic e9perience of t/e Clear Lig/t of ,nderstanding as
it is to be perfor-ed 7in t/e dayti-e7 Nt/at is, t/ro,g/ t/e waking
awareness, t/e waking $ardo7 t/e te9t later gives instr,ctions for its
e9perience 7in t/e nig/t7 Gt/e drea- $ardoD and 7at t/e -o-ent of
deat/7 Gt/e <$ardo of dissol,tion into E-ptiness7HO5 "n t/is -et/od,
B,st described, of entering into conte-plative co--,nion wit/ t/e
Clear Lig/t, t/e practitioner s/o,ld sit in t/e post,re 7precio,s
body of t/e deity7 like Mairocana, /is body ,n-oving, /is voice
,nspeaking, /is -ind constr,cting no 7reality,7 entering into
,ninterr,pted conte-plative co--,nion like a river falling
downward or t/e fla-e of a la-p b,rning ,pward5 B,t in fact even if
t/e e9perience were e9plained a t/o,sand ti-es, t/ere is not/ing else
for it b,t t/e ,nre-itting -indf,lness on w/at is to be
e9perienced5
B,t /aving t/,s e9perienced, a yogin w/ose fac,lties are of t/e
very best for-s even /is -ental constr,cts t/e-selves as -ind'
f,lness5 1/,s /e for-s t/e -indf,lness of 7recognition7% /e
gains t/e freedo- t/at occ,rs si-,ltaneo,sly wit/ appearance5 6e
w/o beco-es fir- t/erein is said to be 7in conte-plative ,nion
even afterward, even w/en /e is doing so-et/ing else7C /e is
called 7a B,dd/a in a single lifeti-e57 1/,s by /is -indf,lness of
recognition /e recogniFes eac/ appearance to be ne,tral E-pty for-C
as soon as it occ,rs /e is freed of it si-,ltaneo,sly, and t/e fo,r
stages of appearance do not occ,r5
1/,s, as it is said, 7Understanding t/e obBect to be appearance and
E-ptiness, wit/o,t tr,t/, t/e -ind beco-es Lig/t and E-ptiness,
wit/o,t grasping57
)&.
"t is, of co,rse, only t/e practitioner 7w/ose
fac,lties are of t/e very best7 w/o co,ld /ope to ac/ieve B,dd/a/ood in
/is lifeti-eC t/e -ain point in t/e 7conte-plative co--,nion wit/
t/e Clear Lig/t,7 " was infor-ed, is to gain t/e ability to recogniFe
and e-brace t/e Clear Lig/t of t/e -o-ent of deat/, w/en t/e
/indering presence of t/e p/ysical body /as been re-oved5
g,t /ere again, t/is re/earsal is a rit,al reenact-ent and /ence a
-agical si-,lacr,- for deat/% t/e control of t/e Clear Lig/t of t/e pat/
grants -agical access to t/e act,al Clear Lig/tC t/e son is t/e
si-,lacr,- for t/e -ot/er5 1/e Process of Perfection grants sy-bolic
power over deat/ and t/e lig/t t/at s/ines t/ro,g/ it, and /ence
control over enlig/ten-entC it is part of t/e conte-plative reality
w/erein all events beco-e sy-bols, all sy-bols beco-e i-ages, and all
i-ages beco-e one anot/er5
16E >FFE2"$I#
4e /ave now traveled so-e distance t/ro,g/ t/is startling real- of
conte-plative reality, and we /ave e9a-ined a few of t/e cor=
respondences t/at link toget/er in patterns of power and -agical
control5 B,t in t/e rit,als t/e-selves t/ere is an i-portant s,bsid'ary
,se of vis,aliFation w/ic/ we /ave not yet disc,ssed% t/e creation of
offerings Gor of goddesses w/o bear offeringsH w/ic/ are presented to
t/e deity5 1/e deity t/,s wors/iped -ay be in front of t/e
practitioner, or it -ay be t/e practitioner /i-self, -aking offerings to
t/e god /e /as beco-e5
6ere again, as in t/e generation of an effigy, all offerings Gin=
cl,ding t/e tor-as, w/ic/ are presented separatelyH are first dissolved
into E-ptiness and t/en conte-platively re'created as 7broad and
vast7C t/e offerings are bro,g/t ,nder t/e -agical control of t/e
yogin, w/o renders t/e- a 7perfect divine s,bstance7 fit for
presentation to t/e god5 Mario,s rit,als differ in t/e a-o,nt of t/is
preparation of t/e offerings, b,t t/ere are t/ree basic steps in t/e
process% G1H t/eir -aterial s,bstance is cleansed by t/e recitation of a
fierce -antra, often >8 A821A'DU$3AL" 6A$A 6A$A 6U8
P6A1C G)H t/ey are purified into E-ptiness wit/ t/e -antra >8
#MAB6AMA'#U336A6 #A2MA'36A28A6 #MAB6AMA'
#U336> <6A8, t/en vis,aliFed as born fro- t/eir seeds into
perfect divine s,bstance% and G*H t/ey are empoBered wit/ t/e -antra >8
A6 6U8 and t/e special /and gest,re called t/e 7flying bird57 1/is
process is so-eti-es called 7cleansing, increasing, and kindling7 t/e
offerings5
A wide variety of different offerings are vis,aliFed in t/e co,rse of
a rit,al, and /ere -ore t/an anyw/ere else we clearly see t/e rit,al
interplay of t/e standard triad of body, speec/, and -ind, for t/ese
conte-plative vis,aliFations are inevitably acco-panied by
L
1.)
#!E (1+# OF ?E OE
WOR2!.
&
1.*
or badC at t/is stage an event increases as the (lear +ight7 it i
s
called t/e 7deep conte-plation of 8ore E-ptiness57
Beca,se /e is free of taking it to be good or bad, /e does not,
t/ro,g/ desire or aversion, try to get it or avoid itC at t/is stage an
event $ecomes the (lear +ight7 it is called t/e 7deep conte-plation of
Ireat E-ptiness57
By atte-pting neit/er to get it nor to avoid it, /e c,ts off t/e
/appy or -iserable feelings w/ic/ are t/e res,lt of /is getting it or
not getting it, avoiding it or not avoiding it, and w/ic/ are t/e
constr,cts of t/e five poisons5 6e t/,s c,ts off s,ffering and
dwells in t/e all'absorbingC at t/is stage an event culminates as the
(lear +ight7 it is called t/e 7deep conte-plation of Co-plete
E-ptiness57
1/is is t/e basic e9perience of t/e Clear Lig/t of ,nderstanding as
it is to be perfor-ed 7in t/e dayti-e7 Nt/at is, t/ro,g/ t/e waking
awareness, t/e waking $ardo7 t/e te9t later gives instr,ctions for its
e9perience 7in t/e nig/t7 Gt/e drea- $ardoD and 7at t/e -o-ent of
deat/7 Gt/e <$ardo of dissol,tion into E-ptiness7HO5 "n t/is -et/od,
B,st described, of entering into conte-plative co--,nion wit/ t/e
Clear Lig/t, t/e practitioner s/o,ld sit in t/e post,re 7precio,s
body of t/e deity7 like Mairocana, /is body ,n-oving, /is voice
,nspeaking, /is -ind constr,cting no 7reality,7 entering into
,ninterr,pted conte-plative co--,nion like a river falling
downward or t/e fla-e of a la-p b,rning ,pward5 B,t in fact even if
t/e e9perience were e9plained a t/o,sand ti-es, t/ere is not/ing else
for it b,t t/e ,nre-itting -indf,lness on w/at is to be
e9perienced5
B,t /aving t/,s e9perienced, a yogin w/ose fac,lties are of t/e
very best for-s even /is -ental constr,cts t/e-selves as -ind'
f,lness5 1/,s /e for-s t/e -indf,lness of 7recognition7% /e
gains t/e freedo- t/at occ,rs si-,ltaneo,sly wit/ appearance5 6e
w/o beco-es fir- t/erein is said to be 7in conte-plative ,nion
even afterward, even w/en /e is doing so-et/ing else7C /e is
called 7a B,dd/a in a single lifeti-e57 1/,s by /is -indf,lness of
recognition /e recogniFes eac/ appearance to be ne,tral E-pty for-C
as soon as it occ,rs /e is freed of it si-,ltaneo,sly, and t/e fo,r
stages of appearance do not occ,r5
1/,s, as it is said, 7Understanding t/e obBect to be appearance and
E-ptiness, wit/o,t tr,t/, t/e -ind beco-es Lig/t and E-ptiness,
wit/o,t grasping57
)&.
"t is, of co,rse, only t/e practitioner 7w/ose
fac,lties are of t/e very best7 w/o co,ld /ope to ac/ieve B,dd/a/ood in
/is lifeti-eC t/e -ain point in t/e 7conte-plative co--,nion wit/
t/e Clear Lig/t,7 " was infor-ed, is to gain t/e ability to recogniFe
and e-brace t/e Clear Lig/t of t/e -o-ent of deat/, w/en t/e
/indering presence of t/e p/ysical body /as been re-oved5
g,t /ere again, t/is re/earsal is a rit,al reenact-ent and /ence a
-agical si-,lacr,- for deat/% t/e control of t/e Clear Lig/t of t/e pat/
grants -agical access to t/e act,al Clear Lig/tC t/e son is t/e
si-,lacr,- for t/e -ot/er5 1/e Process of Perfection grants sy-bolic
power over deat/ and t/e lig/t t/at s/ines t/ro,g/ it, and /ence
control over enlig/ten-entC it is part of t/e conte-plative reality
w/erein all events beco-e sy-bols, all sy-bols beco-e i-ages, and all
i-ages beco-e one anot/er5
16E >FFE2"$I#
4e /ave now traveled so-e distance t/ro,g/ t/is startling real- of
conte-plative reality, and we /ave e9a-ined a few of t/e cor=
respondences t/at link toget/er in patterns of power and -agical
control5 B,t in t/e rit,als t/e-selves t/ere is an i-portant s,bsid'ary
,se of vis,aliFation w/ic/ we /ave not yet disc,ssed% t/e creation of
offerings Gor of goddesses w/o bear offeringsH w/ic/ are presented to
t/e deity5 1/e deity t/,s wors/iped -ay be in front of t/e
practitioner, or it -ay be t/e practitioner /i-self, -aking offerings to
t/e god /e /as beco-e5
6ere again, as in t/e generation of an effigy, all offerings Gin=
cl,ding t/e tor-as, w/ic/ are presented separatelyH are first dissolved
into E-ptiness and t/en conte-platively re'created as 7broad and
vast7C t/e offerings are bro,g/t ,nder t/e -agical control of t/e
yogin, w/o renders t/e- a 7perfect divine s,bstance7 fit for
presentation to t/e god5 Mario,s rit,als differ in t/e a-o,nt of t/is
preparation of t/e offerings, b,t t/ere are t/ree basic steps in t/e
process% G1H t/eir -aterial s,bstance is cleansed by t/e recitation of 1
fierce -antra, often >8 A821A'DU$3AL" 6A$A 6A$A iU8
P6A1C G)H t/ey are purified into E-ptiness wit/ t/e -antra *8
#MAB6AMA'#U336A6 #A2MA'36A28A6 #MAB6AMA'
#U336> <6A85 t/en vis,aliFed as born fro- t/eir seeds into
perfect divine s,bstance% and G*H t/ey are empoBered wit/ t/e -antra >8
A6 6U8 and t/e special /and gest,re called t/e 7flying bird57 1/is
process is so-eti-es called 7cleansing, increasing, and kindling7 t/e
offerings5
A wide variety of different offerings are vis,aliFed in t/e co,rse
ab a rit,al, and /ere -ore t/an anyw/ere else we clearly see t/e rit,al
interplay of t/e standard triad of body, speec/, and -ind, for t/ese
conte-plative vis,aliFations are inevitably acco-panied by
1..
#!E (1+# OF 1.(
t/e recitation of special -antras and t/e perfor-ance of /and ge
s
t,res5
9antras especially /ave attracted sc/olarly attention, and Ionda
)&(
/as written an e9cellent article on t/e-5 As 8alinowsky says of spells
in general, -antras are 7a -ode of action and an e9pression of /,-an
will 5 5 5 a translation of t/e ,rge of /,-an desire into words57
)&+
B,t
-antras are -ore t/an t/is% t/ey are, as we /ave seen, t/e very speec/ of
t/e god5 As 2osen writes%
)&
6owever, t/e effectiveness of c,rses and blessings, s,c/ as t/ose of
Balaa-, does not depend -erely on verbal -agic, on t/e belief t/at
t/e words ,ttered are forces let loose in t/e world for evil or good5
Belief in t/e effectiveness of s,c/ ,tterances is so-et/ing -,c/
-ore co-ple95 1/ey are regarded as efficacio,s not only beca,se
t/ey are words of power, b,t beca,se t/ey are /eld liter ally to effect
w/at t/ey signify, beca,se t/ey are e-bodied activity5 "n s/ort, as
3orot/y E--et /as s,ggested, s,c/ verbal acts are in a way
7perfor-ative ,tternaces,7 in w/ic/ saying is doing5
1/,s, for e9a-ple, a vis,aliFation for s,bB,gation is acco-panied by
a -antra s,c/ as >8 DU2UDULLE s,c/'and's,c/ a person MA#A8
A$AJA 62"6 #MA6A K 7>8 D,r,k,lla, lead s,c/'and's,c/ a person
into -y power 62l6 #MA6AK7 >r t/e -antra for t/e dissol,tion
of oneself or of an obBect into E-ptiness is, as we /ave seen, >8
#MAB6AMA'#U336A6 #A2MA'36A28A6 #MAB6AMA'
#U336> < 6A8 K 7>8 P,re of essence are all events, p,re of essence
a- "K7 >ne of t/e -ost widely ,sed of t/ese -antras of in-unction is
t/e 1&&'syllable -antra of MaBrasattva, w/ic/ t/e practitioner recites
d,ring t/e preli-inary practices of /is solitary conte-plation, or in t/e
co,rse of a rit,al itself Geit/er at t/e very beginning or before praying
to t/e deityH, to p,rify all /is past sins%
>8 MAL2A#A11MA #A8AJA8 A$UPALAJA MAL2A#A11MA
1ME$>PA1"#16A 3236> 8E B6AMA #U1>#J> 8E B6AMA
A$U2AD1> 8E B6AMA #UP>#J> 8E B6AMA #A2MA'
#"336"8 8E P2AJACC6A #A2MA'DA28A'#UCA 8E
C"11A8 #2EJA6 DU2U 6U8K 6A 6A 6A 6A 6>6K
B6AIAMA$ #A2MA'1A16AIA1A'MAL2A 8A 8E 8U$
K
CA
MAL2"'B6AMA 8A6A#A8AJA#A11MA A6 K
7>8 MaBrasattva, g,ard -y vows K MaBrasattva, let t/e- be fir- K Be
steadfast for -e, be satisfied, be favorable, be no,ris/ed for -e K
Irant -e all t/e -agical attain-entsK "ndicator of all kar-a%
-ake glorio,s -y -ind 6U8 K 6A 6A 6A 6A 6>6 K Blessed
>ne, dia-ond of all t/e 1at/agatas% do not forsake -e, -ake -e
dia-ond 1 Ireat being of t/e vow A6 K7
general, t/e translation into Englis/ of s,c/ an inB,nctive -antra ed
in 1ibetan rit,al is ;,ite s,fficient to s/ow /ow it is being ,sed, t/o,g/
its stereotyped for-,lation in sonoro,s #anskrit is psyc/ologically
-ore effective5 #o-eti-es, of co,rse, t/e inB,nction is not ;,ite
clear on t/e s,rface, as in t/e following -antra%
&1i $A8> B6AIAMA1E PU#PA'DE1U 2ALAJA 1A16A'
IA1AJA A26A1E #A8JAD#A8BU336AJA 1A3JA16A
PU#PE PU#PE 8A6APU#PE PU#P>3B6AME PU#PA'#A8'
B6AME PU#PAMADl2$E #MA6AK
7>8 6o-age to t/e Blessed >ne, Ding of t/e Flowery Banner,
1at/agata, 4ort/y >ne, f,lly enlig/tenedK 1/at is% Flowers,
flowers, great flowersK Irowing of flowers, birt/ of flowers,
strewing of flowers #MA6A K7
By t/e power of t/is -antra, t/e te9ts tell ,s, 7as -any flowers as
t/ere -ay be, t/eir offering co,nts for ten -illion ti-es as -any7C
t/e i-plied inB,nction is t/,s -ade e9plicit5
B,t even t/e ,ntranslatable portions of t/e -antrasEw/at are
/ere called -antra particlesEfill well'defined rit,al slots and t/,s
f,nction -orp/e-ically in t/e -agical ,tterance% >8 A6 6U8
represent body, speec/, and -ind, and are ,sed to e-power vis,al iFed
obBects and deitiesC P6A1 is ,sed as an ele-ent of power in fierce
-antrasC 12" is ,sed to e-body or -anifest so-et/ing i--aterial
into a -aterial obBect, s,c/ as an effigy or tor-aC LA6 is ,sed to
s,--on, and 8U6 to dis-iss5
#o-e of t/ese -antra particles serve as seeds for t/e conte-plative
generation of an obBect or deity% B62U8 is t/e seed vis,al iFed in t/e
creation of a divine -ansion or any dwelling for t/e godC t/e fo,r
se-ivowels JA8 2A8 LA8 MA8 are t/e seeds of wind, fire, eart/,
and waterC >8 6U8 12A8 62l6 A6 collectively represent t/e five
fa-ilies of B,dd/a5 #o-eti-es t/e derivation of t/ese seeds is
relatively transparent% pSY is t/e seed t/at is vis,aliFed as
transfor-ing into a lot,s Ga PAd-aH, B,st as ?SY is t/e seed of
1Ara or IA8 of IAnapati5
>ne f,rt/er f,nctional category of -antra -,st be disting,is/ed
fro- bot/ inB,nction and particle% t/ese are stereotyped doctrinal or
ot/er formulas Geven /y-ns of praise, or t/e #anskrit alp/abetH ,sed
for partic,lar p,rposes in t/e rit,al and so-eti-es totally
disassociated fro- t/eir -eaning5 "ncl,ded are 1ara<s basic -antra,
/er praises ,sed for protection, t/e vowels and consonants recited
#!E (1+# OF
1.+
for t/e e-power-ent of speec/5 1/,s, for e9a-ple, t/e fa-o,s
verse called t/e 7/eart of conditioned coprod,ction7 reads as follov
s
5
JE 36A28A 6E1U'P2AB6AMA 6E1U$ 1E#A8 1A16A
IA1> A6A X 1E#A8 CA J> $"2>36> EMA8 MA3" 8A'
6A#2A8A$A6 X<
4/atever events arise fro- a ca,se, t/e
1at/agata /as told t/e ca,se t/ereofC and
t/e great ascetic also /as ta,g/t t/eir
cessation as well5
1/is for-,la is ,sed, as a -antra, for consecration, -aking fir- a
deity generated wit/in an obBect, or fi9ing a rit,al act5 #i-ilarly,
t/e following ano-olo,s -antra is ,sed in t/e offering of tor-as%
>8 A'DA2> 8UD6A8 #A2MA'36A28A$A8 A3J'A$U1'
PA$$A1MA1K
7>8 1/e syllable A is first, beca,se of t/e pri-ordial nonarising
of all eventsK7
1/e vis,aliFation of t/e offerings is also acco-panied by rit,al
hand gestures, as indeed are -ost of t/e i-portant acts of t/e cere=
-ony5 For so-e reason t/ese gest,res /ave not received t/e sc/olarly
attention t/at /as been lavis/ed ,pon t/e -antras, or else t/ey
/ave been conf,sed wit/ t/e iconograp/ic gest,res t/at serve to
identify paintings and i-ages5 4e -ay disting,is/ two f,nctional
categories of rit,al /and gest,res5 1/e first, co-paratively few,
are stereotyped gestures of reverence, t/reat, welco-e, or farewell%
t/e practitioner -ay Boin /is pal-s in reverence, /old o,t /is e9=
tended pal-s in a typically 1ibetan gest,re of good'bye, or cross
/is ar-s over /is c/est to indicate t/e absorption of t/e deity
wit/in /i-5 1/e second category incl,des t/e rit,al /and gest,res
t/at acco-pany t/e presentation of offerings, and t/ese are e9=
plicitly intended as mimetic representations of t/e obBects being
offeredEsi-,lacra t/at control t/e trans-ission of wors/ip to t/e
god, B,st as t/e -antras of offering enBoin its acceptance and re=
sponse5
A wide variety of offerings are vis,aliFed in t/e rit,als and t/,s
dispatc/ed to t/e deity wit/ so,nd and gest,reC t/ese are generally
s,bs,-ed ,nder t/e /eadings of 7o,ter offerings,7 7inner offerings,7
and 7secret offerings,7 to w/ic/ is added in so-e rit,als an 7offering
of t/e 1r,t/57
#!E (1+# OF ?EQE
1/e outer offerings are all t/ose t/ings of t/e e9ternal worldEani=
-ate and inani-ateEw/ic/ are proper to t/e reception of a royal or
divine g,est5 1/e -ost basic of t/ese, w/ose acco-panying gest,res
are ill,strated in fig,re 1(, are t/e tBo Baters and t/e five gifts,
listed as follows wit/ t/eir #anskrit na-es as given in t/eir -an=
tras%
.HA2I6A8 7oblation7 or 7water for t/e face7
.!HPA3JA8 7water for t/e feet7
.9HPU#PE 7flowers7
(&H36UPE 7incense7
(1HAL>DE 7la-ps7
()HIA$36E 7perf,-e7
(*H$A"ME3JE 7food7
1/ese offerings are represented ,pon t/e altar by seven bowls filled
wit/ water and grainC and to t/ese seven is added
!H #AB3A 7-,sic,7
w/ic/ is not set o,t on t/e altar, since it is s,pposed to be o--i'
present in t/e asse-bly /all5 6ere t/e -i-etic intention of t/e
gest,res is not so apparent as it is in so-e of t/e ot/er sets of offer=
ingsC b,t note /ow gest,re ( represents t/e la-ps being offered,
wit/ t/e t/,-bs raised in i-itation of a wick rising fro- a pool of
b,tter, or /ow gest,re ! represents beating ti-e to -,sic5
4e -ay re-ark t/at t/e -antras t/at acco-pany t/ese offer=
ings -ay appear to a #anskritist to /ave ,ndergone so-e rat/er
biFarre defor-ations5 B,t -any of t/ese -ay be acco,nted for as
reg,lar early Prakritic analogical assi-ilations Ge5g5, dative sing,lar
2ALAJA for 2ALftEH or as -ore or less well'attested B,dd/ist
6ybrid for-s Ge5g5, vocative sing,lar IU2U for IU2>, present
i-perative D6A6" for D6A3A 7eatK7H5 1/e two waters are
clearly acc,sative obBects of t/e i-perative P2A1lCC6A 7acceptK7
b,t t/e five giftsEoften offered as a separate se;,enceEwo,ld
see- to be fe-inine sing,lar vocatives Ge5g5, PU#PE 7& Lady of
t/e flowersK7H addressed to t/e goddesses w/o e-anate fro- t/e
practitioner and -ake offerings to t/e deity, stereotyped in t/e
-antra even w/en s,c/ e-anation is not given in t/e rit,al te9t5
#AB3A see-s, ano-alo,sly, to be a -asc,line vocative sing,lar,
parallel per/aps to -antras of t/e for- >8 #UMA2$A'CAD2A
P2A1lCC6A 7>8 Iolden w/eel% accept itK7
WOR2!.&
1/e standard pattern of presentation for all t/ese offerings is t/e
recitation Gor t/e c/anting, ,sing any one of a n,-ber of standard
-elodies t/at fit t/e -eterH of a dedicatory verse and t/en of t/e
#anskrit -antra, acco-panied by t/e appropriate gest,re5 >ften
eac/ gest,re is preceded d,ring t/e co,rse of t/e verse by a series of
prefatory /and -otions, w/ic/ are i-possible for -e to drawC if t/e
offerings are being -ade in abbreviated for-, wit/ t/e recitation of
t/e -antra alone, t/e practitioner -akes /is gest,res flow into eac/
ot/er, per/aps also snapping /is fingers after eac/ gest,re, like t/e
s,pple and flowing -ove-ents of a -an,al dance5 All t/ese -ove=
-ents vary fro- sect to sect, even fro- -onastery to -onastery,
B,t everyw/ere, w/en properly perfor-ed, t/ey add a f,rt/er
aest/etic di-ension to t/e so,nds of t/e asse-bly /all, and provide
t/e individ,al practitioner wit/ a controlled set of bodily -otions
to acco-pany t/e ballet of /is vis,aliFation5
For e9a-ple, t/e verses and -antras for t/e offering of t/e two
waters and t/e five gifts -ig/t be recited or s,ng as follows, eac/
wit/ t/e appropriate gest,re%
)&!
1H Lord, it is good t/at yo, /ave co-e /ere,
giving ,s t/e opport,nity for -eritC
and w/en yo, /ave accepted o,r oblation
we pray yo, re-ain /ere5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A P2AMA2A'#A1DA2A'8A'
6A#A1DA2A'8A6A'A2I6A8 P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6AK
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% accept t/is e9cellent, respectf,l,
-ost respectf,l, and great oblation 6U8 #MA6A K7
)H L,st as t/e B,dd/a, as soon as /e was born,
was bat/ed by all t/e gods,
we pray yo, likewise bat/e yo,r body
wit/ t/is p,re divine water5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A 8A6A'PA3JA8 P2A1lC=
C6A 6U8 #MA6AK
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% accept t/is great water for yo,r
feet 6U8 #MA6AK7
1/is second verse, by t/e way, is a standard one, ,sed also in 7bat/=
ing t/e deity7 and in bestowing initiation ,pon a disciple5 And /ere,
too, as in -any ot/er rit,als, t/ere co-es a brief pa,se between t/e
waters and t/e gifts to offer t/e deity a seat%
1.!
1.9
#!E (1+# OF
>,t of love for ,s and for all beings, wit/ t/e
strengt/ of a -agic -anifestation, re-ain
/ere, Blessed >nes, we pray yo,, for as long as
we -ake offering5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A PA38ADA8ALAJA#
1MA8K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% a lot,s seat for yo, K7
$e9t are offered t/e gifts, and in t/is standard series t/e verses and
-antras beco-e rat/er -ore reg,lariFed%
*H Lot,s flowers, bl,e and w/ite,
and red% all sorts of flowers,
all well'colored, well'for-ed, sweet's-elling,
we offer ,p to t/e -ost precio,s of incarnations5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A PU#PE PULA'8EI6A'
#A8U32A'#P6A2A$A'#A8AJE 6U8 K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% flowers% t/e gat/ering swelling
ocean of clo,ds of offerings 6U8 K
.H Aloewood and pine,
t/e sweetest savors of all t/e real-s%
all t/e -ost e9cellent incense of t/e world,
we offer ,p to t/e -ost precio,s of incarnations5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A 36UPE PULA'8EI6A'
#A8U32A'#P6A2A$A'#A8AJE 6U8K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% incense% t/e gat/ering swelling
ocean of clo,ds of offerings 6U8K7
(H B,tter la-ps wit/ /earts of oil,
la-ps of ba-boo and twigs of fr,it trees% all
t/at ill,-inates t/e darkness of t/e world, we
offer ,p to t/e -ost precio,s of incarnations5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A AL>DE PULA'8EI6A'#A'
8U32A'#P6A2A$A'#A8AJE 6U8 K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% la-ps% t/e gat/ering swelling
ocean of clo,ds of offerings 6U8 1
+H Ca-p/or, sandalwood, and saffron%
t/e sweetest's-elling of perf,-es, a Boy to to,c/,
bot/ nat,ral and -i9ed,
we offer ,p to t/e -ost precio,s of incarnations5
1(1
&8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A IA$36E PULA'8EI6A'
#A8U32A'#P6A2A$A'#A8AJE 6U8K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% perf,-es% t/e gat/ering swelling
ocean of clo,ds of offerings 6U87
H Cooked rice and ot/er p,re foods,
prepared wit/ all t/e co,ntless varieties of cooking,
-i9ed foods, all of t/e -ost e9cellent flavor, we
offer ,p to t/e -ost e9cellent of incarnations5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A $A"ME3JE PULA'8EI6A'
#A8U32A'#P6A2A$A'#A8AJE 6U8K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% food% t/e gat/ering swelling ocean
of clo,ds of offerings 6U8K7
!H Ireat dr,-s, conc/ s/ells, clay dr,-s, kettledr,-s,
cy-bals, and tabors, /osts of -,sic% all t/e -ost
-elodio,s so,nds of t/e world, we offer ,p to t/e
-ost e9cellent of incarnations5
>8 IU2U'#A2MA'1A16AIA1A #AB3A PULA'8EI6A'
#A8U32A'#P6A2A$A'#A8AJE 6U8K
7>8 I,r, and all 1at/agatas% -,sic% t/e gat/ering swelling
ocean of clo,ds of offerings 6U8K7
Even -ore pictorial t/an t/ese are so-e of t/e rit,al /and gest,res
t/at acco-pany several of t/e ot/er types of o,ter offerings5 Fig=
,re 1+, for e9a-ple, ill,strates t/e gest,res t/at acco-pany t/e
seven precious gems of sovereignty4
(.HCAD2A'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s w/eel7
((H6A#1"'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s elep/ant7
(+HA#MA'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s /orse7
(H8A$"'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s ge-7
(!H#12l'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s ;,een7
(9HPU2U#A'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s -inister7
+&HD6A3IA'2A1$A 7t/e precio,s general7 or 7sword7
1o t/is list is added
+1HUPA2A1$A 7t/e s,bsidiary precio,s t/ings,7
w/ose gest,re is ,sed also to represent t/e offering called t/e 7space'
vast treas,ry57 >ne of t/e rit,als by Pe-a karpo, for e9a-ple,
contains t/e following verses and -antras for t/e presentation of
t/ese offerings%
)&9
1(&
WOR2!.& 1(*
I
n 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s w/eelC we offer it, self'created
fro- divine gold, its ro,nd nave radiating a t/o,sand spokes to its -ost e9cellent
ri-, granting victory over all t/e -ost noble5
>8 CAD2A'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6AK
)H 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s elep/antC
we offer t/e si9't,sked w/ite elep/ant, t/e color of t/e -oon,
w/o ;,ickly circles t/e ocean'girt eart/,
t/e divine circ,-ference t/ro,g/ t/e pat/ of t/e sky5
>8 6A#1"'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6AK
*H 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s /orseC
we offer it, its color delig/tf,l as a peacock<s t/roat,
adorned wit/ gold, swift as t/o,g/t,
circling t/e eart/ and ret,rning wit/in t/e -orning5
>8 A#MA'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6AK
.H 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s ge-C
we offer t/e green'blaFing t,r;,oise,
s,rpassing t/e brilliance of t/e s,n,
its eig/t portions of p,rity f,lfilling all wis/es5
>8 8A$"'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6AK
(H 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s ;,eenC
we offer /er, as bea,tif,l as an i--ortal -aiden,
delig/ting body and -ind wit/ /er -ost e9cellent to,c/,
bestowing t/e perf,-e of /er skill, knowledge, and elo;,ence5
>8 #12"'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6AK
+H 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s -inisterC
we offer /i-, /is -ind like a dagger, wise and pr,dent,
g,iding to all desires wit/ /is /idden store of s,btlety,
w/ose words -,st be /eeded, /aving t/e eyes of a god5
>8 PU2U#A'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6A K
H 4e vis,aliFe all of space filled wit/ t/e precio,s generalC
we offer /i-, a /ero wit/ t/e strengt/ of a godC
destroying t/e ene-y, instantly acco-plis/ing
all t/e ai-s t/at -ove t/e -ind of a c/a-pion5
>8 D6A3IA'2A1$A P2A1lCC6A 6U8 #MA6A K
-