Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
INTRODUCTION
VIDEO INTRODUCTION
Click or scan the QR
code below to watch our
video introduction.
Welcome to the latest edition of Bloomberg Brief: Real Estate, which focuses
on recent transformations in commercial and residential real estate. This special issue features guest commentaries and exclusive interviews with leading
industry professionals analyzing the markets trends.
In this issue, Tim Ng, managing director and head of research at Clearbrook
Global Advisors, says commercial mortgage bond sales volume is undermined
by increased participation from overseas investors who dont need loans to
finance office building purchases. In some cases, the purchases are all-cash
deals and some of these investors end up leasing the land underneath their
buildings to insurers to help finance transactions.
Behind this growing interest from overseas buyers is the notion that U.S. real
estate still remains something of a safe haven, says Stuart Rothstein, COO
and partner of Apollo Global Managements global real estate group. International investors would like to park their capital in a hard asset in the U.S. rather
than their local currency, Rothstein says.
Meanwhile, the decline in residential lending is expected to spur title insurer
and appraisal company mergers, according to Brett Huff, a research analyst at
Stephens Inc. who tracks real estate information service companies.
The changes in the real estate sector are not relegated to financing residential and commercial property purchases. Shifts are also evident in building use.
Market professionals at CBRE Group found that how tenants work with their
office space is changing, and the move to convert office buildings to residential
properties likely will continue.
As veteran developer Bill Rudin puts it, conversion of obsolete office buildings
reinforces the trend of urbanization where workers and their families want to
be able to walk to work.
We also dig into the data in this issue and find that issuance of bonds backed
by commercial real estate has slowed. In the first three months of the year,
about $36 billion worth of securities pooling commercial real estate mortgages
were sold by Wall Street firms, down 9 percent from the first quarter of 2013.
At the same time, the amount of agency collateral resold into CMBS dropped
to $12.8 billion from $16.83 billion in the fourth quarter of 2013 and $13.78 billion a year ago. On the positive side, the foreclosure rate for all types of commercial property loans fell to 0.44 percent during the first three months of the
year, a low not seen since June 2009.
In the residential space, the first quarter saw a dramatic decline in applications for home loans. The industrys measure of loan applications in February
fell to a level not seen since 1995, even as mortgage rates remained low by
historic standards.
Refinancings a key source of profit for many lenders also dropped in
the first quarter. In March, 52.8 percent of all loan applications were related
to mortgage refinancings, down from 75 percent at the same time last year.
Some of the drop in residential home loan refinancings may be due to a decline in demand for loans that extract equity from homes cash-out refinancings that hit a peak in 2006.
We look forward to hearing your feedback on this special edition of Bloomberg
Brief. The next quarterly real estate market update will be published in the fall.
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
BY THE NUMBERS
$194 net loss
5.3 months
of new homes
in April 2014.
banks and mortgage subsidiaries of chartered banks in the fourth quarter of 2013.
4.19% rate
66
50
% of new U.S.
3.54% rate
155.00 MBA
Purchase Index
reading on
Feb. 21, 2014.
156.80 MBA
Purchase Index
4.5 months
of supply
of supply
of new homes
in May 2014.
3.29% mortgage
rate for a 15-year fixed rate
2.72% mortgage
rate for a 15-year fixed
reading on
Dec. 27, 1996.
$2.3 trillion
48.7 April 2013 reading of Architecture Billings Index.
A reading above 50 indicates an increase in billings.
$322 price
of framed lumber
(random lengths,
composite price)
per 1,000 board
feet on June 21,
2013.
Growth in home
equity in the
U.S. in 2013.
$6.5 billion
Amount of home
equity cashed out
via refinancings of
home loans in the
first quarter of 2014.
$84 billion
Amount of home
equity cashed out via
refinancings of home
loans in the second
quarter of 2006 a peak.
49
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
CONTENTS
DATA: MORTGAGE REFINANCINGS, CRE LEVERAGE
Fewer home owners refinanced their mortgage loans, CMBS issuance declined in the
first three months of the year and interestonly mortgages still played a big role in commercial real estate finance.
PAGE 8
NEW REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT SETS
TONE FOR REAL ESTATE BANKING
William Cohan explains how changes imposed by regulators after the credit crisis will
alter how some Wall Street firms participate
in real estate investment banking.
PAGE 9-10
AGING BABY BOOMERS STICK BY
SINGLE-FAMILY NEST
Empty-nest boomers are lingering in their
single-family homes, contrary to popular
assumptions, writes Fannie Mae director
Patrick Simmons.
PAGE 11
DATA: COLLATERAL AND BOND SPREADS
The amount of agency debt resold into commercial mortgage backed bonds declined
in the first quarter and BBB-rated CMBS
spreads narrowed versus swaps.
PAGE 12
COMMERCIAL PROPERTY TENANTS MANAGE
TO DO MORE WITH LESS
The average square footage for each employee in a commercial space has decreased
and likely will continue to decline reflecting changes in the way that space is used
by employers, write CBRE Groups Georgia
Collins and Lenny Beaudoin.
PAGE 13-14
Newsletter Ted Merz
Executive Editor tmerz@bloomberg.net
212-617-2309
Real Estate Jennifer Prince
Data Editor jprince10@bloomberg.net
212-617-4589
Managing Jennifer Rossa
Editor jrossa@bloomberg.net
+1-212-617-8074
CMBS Analyst Tadvana Narayanan
tnarayanan1@bloomberg.net
212-617-3814
Real Estate Aleksandrs Rozens
Editor arozens@bloomberg.net
212-617-5211
Contributing Jeffrey Langbaum
Bloomberg jlangbaum1@bloomberg.net
Intelligence Analyst 609-279-4658
Reprints & Lori Husted
Permissions lori.husted@theygsgroup.com
717-505-9701
Contributing Deirdre Fretz
Bloomberg
dfretz@bloomberg.net
Editor 212-617-5166
To subscribe via the Bloomberg Terminal type BRIEF <GO> or on the web at www.bloombergbriefs.com.To contact the editors: arozens@bloomberg.net This newsletter and its
contents may not be forwarded or redistributed without the prior consent of Bloomberg. Please contact our reprints and permissions group listed above for more information.
2014 Bloomberg LP. All rights reserved.
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
VERBATIM
before them. All of those college degrees
will sooner or later pay dividends and they
will buy homes.
Were seeing
very slow improvement on the housing front with most
markets still trying
to move beyond
stall speed.
One of the fundamental changes occurring in the FHLBank System is membership composition. While the traditional
membership base has been contracting,
membership interest from insurance companies has been expanding. Advances
to insurance companies have increased
from one percent of advances in 2000 to
14 percent in 2013 and the number of insurance company members in the System
is now up to 290.
The credit
quality was the
best weve seen
since the mid1990s. There was
a premium for
being an early
mover since it
was a brand new
market.
Chris Hentemann
Source: Bloomberg/
Peter Foley
Chris Hentemann,
chief investment
officer at 400 Capital
Management LLC, speaking with Bloomberg
about a Freddie Mac bond in which private investors share the risk of home-loan defaults with the
mortgage-finance company (May 29, 2014)
Frank Nothaft
Source: Bloomberg/
Andrew Harrer
PEM
<GO>
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
Gateway
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
BLOOMBERG
BRIEF GROUP
SUBSCRIPtIOnS
Bloomberg newsletters
are now available for group
purchase at very affordable
rates. Share with your team,
firm or clients.
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
5,500
1.25
Multi-Family Starts
Millions (Annualized Pace)
5,000
4,500
4.7
4,000
4.5
3,500
0.75
3,000
2,500
4.3
4.1
2,000
0.5
3.7
1,500
0.25
2008
Source: Bloomberg
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
3.9
1,000
12/12
3/13
6/13
Source: Mortgage Bankers Association
3.5
9/13
12/13
3/14
Single-family starts declined in the first three months of the year from the
same period a year ago, while multi-family starts rose from first quarter
2013 levels. Some of the drop in starts was tied to inclement weather.
Partial IO
IO
Balloon
25
Fully Amort
100
All U.S.
90
All Non-U.S.
20
Issuance ($Billions)
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
15
10
5
10
0
2000
2002
* Transactions completed in Q1
2004
2006
2008
2010
2012
* 2014
Source: Bloomberg LP
Just over 50 percent of commercial mortgage debt resold into bonds was
in the form of interest-only or partial IO mortgages, continuing a trend
evident in 2013 when leverage approached pre-crisis levels.
1/13
3/13
Source: Bloomberg LP
5/13
7/13
9/13
11/13
1/14
3/14
Issuance of U.S. commercial mortgage bonds totaled just over $36 billion
in the first quarter of 2014, down slightly from the same period a year ago
when just over $40 billion of CMBS were sold.
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
GUEST EDITORIAL
WILLIAM COHAN
If the years leading up to the 2008 financial crisis were marked by the astounding failure of many Wall Street bankers,
traders and executives to perceive the
risks they were larding onto their balance
sheets especially when it came to real
estate related securities these days the
tables have turned diametrically.
Now, the focus of Wall Streets top executives seems to be on doing everything
possible to reduce risk.
Systemically, we are a much less risky
industry today, says one global head
of real estate finance with a Wall Street
banking firm, who declined to be named.
That doesnt mean people arent taking
risks but we are not in the business of taking risk. Our business is getting rid of it.
That difference between misunderstanding risk and hoarding it and attempting to be more astute about it and
offloading it will likely set the tone for
real estate banking on Wall Street for
years to come.
What that means precisely is, of course,
anyones guess and will continue to depend on the Federal Reserves monetary
policies, on how strictly Washington and
European regulators enforce the new
rules on proprietary trading and capital
requirements, the continued zeal by
investors for outsized returns, and the
markets demands for Wall Streets services, such as debt and equity underwriting, loan originations and merger advice.
But, in the short term, the heightened
focus on risk reduction will likely mean
that Wall Street will continue to be stingy
with credit, especially when a request
falls outside the narrow spectrum of what
qualifies as acceptable.
Regulatory changes
imposed after the
credit crisis of 2008
will alter how some
Wall Street firms
participate in real
estate investment
banking, writes
former senior
Wall Street M&A
investment banker
William Cohan.
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
GUEST EDITORIAL
(In 2012, the Lehman estate sold Archstone for around $6.5 billion to Equity
Residential, a company controlled by
legendary real estate investor Sam Zell,
and to Avalon Properties.)
These days, the regulators crawling
over the big Wall Street banks would
immediately question such a deal and
require that a large equity capital reserve be posted if it were to remain on
the balance sheet.
Not surprisingly, the slack in the
market for the riskiest tranches of real
estate financing is being picked up by
competitors subject to far less regulation than the big Wall Street banks. This
group includes a smattering of hedge
funds, as well as the Blackstone Group
now one of the largest owners of single-family homes in the country funds
affiliated with Starwood, the publicly
traded Ladder Capital and Rialto Capital
Management, a subsidiary of Lennar,
the home builder.
OXYMORON #4
transwestern.com
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
GUEST EDITORIAL
Popular perception holds that baby boomers have begun to change their housing
consumption as they exit their childrearing
years and approach retirement.
Multiple media accounts point to an
emerging trend of Boomers downsizing from suburban single-family homes
to urban multifamily residences as they
become empty nesters.
While baby boomers certainly are experiencing major life changes that could
have significant housing implications, one
key metric of boomer housing consumption the proportion of the population
residing in a detached single-family home
so far provides little support for the
downsizing narrative.
Given baby boomers vast numbers, even
small changes in their housing tendencies
could have significant market impacts.
The boomer generation comprises roughly
80 million individuals, and boomers residing
in detached single-family homes account for
more than one-quarter of the nations entire
occupied housing stock.
A frequently cited cause of boomer
downsizing is the departure of children
from the home. As the empty-nester
theory goes, once children leave home,
boomers have little need for the abundant
living space, quality schools, and other
amenities typically associated with suburban single-family residency.
Indeed, boomers are becoming emptynesters in droves. Between 2006 and
2012, the proportion of leading-edge
boomer households consisting of a married couple with at least one child under
age 18 declined from 10 percent to just
3 percent, and the proportion for trailingedge boomers dropped from 35 percent to
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
Aleksandrs Rozens
45
European
40
Conduit
Agency
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
2012
2012
(Q1)
(Q2)
Source: Bloomberg LP
2012
(Q3)
2012
(Q4)
2013
(Q1)
2013
(Q2)
2013
(Q3)
2013
(Q4)
2014
(Q1)
Yield Premiums for Lower Rated CMBS Narrower Versus Year Ago
700
BBB-rated CMBS*
600
AAA-CMBS*
500
400
300
200
100
0
2012
(Q2)
2012
(Q3)
2012
(Q4)
2013
(Q1)
2013
(Q2)
2013
(Q3)
2013
(Q4)
2014
(Q1)
C
I
M
O
N
O
C
E
CHINA
>ECFC CN
>
>
S
T
S
FORECA
<GO>
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
GUEST EDITORIAL
45
40
220
35
210
30
25
200
190
180
20
15
10
170
1990 1993
Source: CBRE
$/Sq Ft
Demand for office space is always a leading topic for discussion in the commercial
real estate world. Recently, the conversation has focused on the basic premise that
changes in occupier preferences, such
as how much space companies provide
each of their employees, will reduce future
demand for office space.
But is it true that demand is decreasing?
The answer isnt a simple yes or no. It is
both a yes and a no.
Yes, we see occupiers planning more
efficient spaces to reduce their future
demand. In a survey last year by CoreNet
Global, a leading real estate association,
over 450 corporate real estate executives
indicated their average square footage per
worker had decreased from 225 to 150. We
think the reality on this score is slightly less
dramatic. From our own estimate of new
construction starts, on average, the new
space being delivered is 20 percent to 30
percent more efficient per employee than
the space being exited.
Is overall demand in the market decreasing as a result? Research from CBRE
Econometric Advisors (CBRE EA) suggests its not. In fact, their analysis shows a
clear upward trend in the average occupied
square footage per worker allocation over
the past 10 years. As of 2013, CBRE EA put
average allocation per worker at 215 square
feet, about 5 percent higher than it was a
decade ago.
Square Feet/Worker
0
1997
2001
2005
2008
2012
2016
2020
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
GUEST EDITORIAL...
We create
the space for success.
Explore now!
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
CAP RATES
Most Commercial Property Cap Rates Increased in Q1 2014
The weighted average cap rate for retail, office and hotel property loans resold into bonds rose in the first three months of 2014, while
the weighted average rate for multifamily properties fell, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The spread to U.S. Treasury rates
earned by lenders for all property types rose in the first quarter from the fourth quarter, though it was down from the same period a year
ago. Weighted average cap rates for hospitality property loans were at their highest in the first quarter since the fourth quarter of 2011.
Aleksandrs Rozens
Spread
Spread
6
5
4
3
2
6
5
4
3
1
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
Source: Bloomberg LP
1
2008
2009
Source: Bloomberg LP
2010
2011
2011
2012
2013
2014
The weighted average cap rate for retail mortgages resold into CMBS was
at 6.27 percent in the first quarter of 2014, up from 5.76 percent in the
fourth quarter of 2014 and up from 6.21 percent a year ago.
Multifamily cap rates ended the first quarter at 6.07 percent, down from
6.29 percent in the last three months of 2013. The spread to Treasuries
earned by lenders widened to 3.35 percent from 3.26 percent in Q1 2014.
12
Spread
10
10
6
4
2
0
2010
2011
Source: Bloomberg LP
Spread
6
4
2011
2012
2013
2014
Cap rates for hotel loans rose to 8.52 percent in the first three months
of 2014 from 7.35 percent in the fourth quarter of 2013. Cap rates for this
property type were as high as 10.34 percent in the third quarter of 2010.
0
2010
Source: Bloomberg LP
2011
2012
2013
2014
Cap rates for office property loans climbed to 6 percent in Q1 2014 from
5.82 percent in the last three months of 2013. The spread to Treasuries
earned by lenders rose to 3.28 percent from 2.79 percent in Q4 2013.
ECONOMIC
WORKBENCH:
HAVE OUR DATA MAKE YOUR POINT
ECWB
<GO>
12
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
LOAN ORIGINATOR
CURRENT
BALANCE ($BN)
DELINQUENT
BALANCE ($M)
TOTAL
NUMBER
OF LOANS
NUMBER OF
DELINQUENT
LOANS
NUMBER OF LOANS
WITH BORROWERS
IN BANKRUPTCY
PERCENTAGE
OF LOANS
DELINQUENT
15.04
2,358.48
5,159
204
15
3.95%
Column Financial
24.57
2,756.11
6,437
203
3.15%
Wachovia Bank NA
40.98
5,777.23
3,504
189
5.39%
11.91
2,365.37
2,378
150
6.31%
57.46
2,687.57
4,982
140
2.81%
Bank of America, NA
37.15
2,233.01
4,274
118
2.76%
Lehman Brothers
18.87
1,364.37
4,032
110
2.73%
Greenwich Capital
15.58
2,138.88
1,863
101
5.42%
CRF
8.67
1,035.81
1,297
91
7.02%
10
CIBC
10.19
1,134.26
1,861
83
4.46%
11
19.06
1,055.58
1,867
71
3.80%
12
28.97
1,983.72
1,931
68
3.52%
13
PNC
11.57
740.74
1,881
65
3.46%
14
UBS AG
21.51
1,369.09
2,459
65
2.64%
15
CGM
11.38
1,171.84
1,077
64
5.94%
16
7.47
713.61
2888
62
2.15%
17
38.43
478.82
6,001
61
1.02%
18
Goldman Sachs
28.66
1,313.90
1,690
60
3.55%
19
2.34
304.98
966
50
5.18%
20
1.14
51.45
2,573
46
1.79%
21
14.40
1,002.40
2,401
39
1.62%
22
Barclays
8.87
630.49
844
34
4.03%
23
Morgan Stanley
11.65
240.36
2197
31
1.41%
24
2.50
252.61
937
30
3.20%
25
NCCI
4.80
354.10
963
30
3.12%
Source: Bloomberg LP
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
Premium
Turnkey Space
212.594.2700 I slgreen.com
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
Age: 48
Education: Bachelor of Science from Pennsylvania State University and
Masters of Business Administration from the Stanford University Graduate
School of Business
Professional Background: Co-Managing Partner of Four Corners Properties;
Director of KKR Financial Advisors, LLC; Executive Vice President of Related
Capital Company; Chief Financial Officer of Spieker Properties
Family: Married with two sons
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
Q&A...
<HELP>
Front page | Previous page | Next page
07.24.14 www.bloombergbriefs.com
Foreclosures of commercial property mortgages resold into securities fell to a nearly five-year low in March.
The rate of commercial mortgage debt foreclosures involving all
property types was 0.44 percent in March, the lowest since June
2009 when it was at 0.42 percent.
Foreclosures of commercial mortgage debt peaked in July 2011 at
1.92 percent.
The 30-day delinquency rate of commercial mortgage debt involving all property types was 0.28 percent in March. Thats up from
Februarys 0.27 percent.
Commercial mortgage debt delinquent 60 days was at a rate of
0.18 percent in March, up from Februarys 0.16 percent; this was the
third consecutive month of increases in the rate of 60-day commercial mortgage debt delinquencies.
Sixty-day delinquency rates were as high as 0.72 percent in
April 2010.
Ninety-day delinquencies of commercial mortgage debt rose to
1.1 percent in March from 1.01 percent in February. In June 2010,
90-day delinquencies were as high as 4.06 percent.
30 Day
60 Day
90 Day-plus
Foreclosure
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
3/2012
9/2012
Source: Bloomberg LP
3/2013
9/2013
3/2014
Aleksandrs Rozens
Contact:
Annie Gustavson
agustavson@bloomberg.net
+1 212-617-0544
Hillary Conley
hconley@bloomberg.net
+1 212-617-3003