Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
12 December 2000
Protein–Energy
FOCAL POINT Malnutrition in
★ Weight loss, a common
presenting sign in adult alpacas
with protein–energy malnutrition,
Alpacas
can be caused by many diseases;
definitive diagnosis is difficult University of Saskatchewan
but can often be achieved by Saskatoon, Canada
thorough clinical examination, James L. Carmalt, MA, VetMB
laboratory tests, and feed
analysis.
ABSTRACT: Alpacas commonly present with clinical signs of weight loss and illthrift but often
have no other abnormalities on physical examination, making diagnosis difficult and frustrat-
KEY FACTS ing for veterinarians. Protein–energy malnutrition is a diagnosis of exclusion supported by ba-
sic protein–energy calculations, body condition scoring, and feed analysis. Although protein–
■ Regular weighing and body energy malnutrition has been described in domestic ruminants, this syndrome has not been
condition scoring by owners are studied in camelids.
integral components of a history
of weight loss or failure to gain
P
weight in alpacas. rotein–energy malnutrition (PEM) has been defined as insufficient provi-
sion of feed (quality and/or quantity) to ruminant livestock.1–3 This syn-
■ Failure to exhibit normal grazing drome has not been described in camelids, in which clinical signs differ
and browsing behavior are from those seen in domestic ruminants. In camelidae weight loss, illthrift and
common presenting signs of failure to exhibit normal grazing and/or browsing behavior are common present-
alpacas with weight loss and ing signs.
illthrift. The number of camelids seen by veterinary practitioners has been steadily in-
creasing. Most commercial camelid owners weigh and determine the body con-
■ Feed analysis and accurate dition score (BCS) of their animals on a regular basis and are thus aware of
knowledge of each ration changes in their animals’ weight, BCS, and demeanor; however, this is often un-
component enable veterinarians true for noncommercial camelid owners.
to calculate protein and energy The exact nutritional requirements of lamoids are unknown.4 The values pre-
intake in alpacas. sented in current literature are based on extrapolations from studies in sheep,4
goats,5,6 and cattle.7 The digestive system of lamoids—especially those on low-
■ Maximum third-compartment quality diets—is considered to be superior to that of other ruminants8; therefore,
capacity of 2% body weight dry the extrapolation of nutrient values may not be wholly accurate. Because both
matter is a significant limiting llamas and alpacas are lamoids, values presented for one are often assumed to be
factor in meeting protein–energy applicable to the other.
requirements during times of In the alpaca’s natural habitat (i.e., the South American Andes), the tempera-
nutritional stress. ture rarely falls below –10˚C.4 The average daily temperature in North America
and Canada during winter often falls below –15˚C and can be as low as –35˚C,
excluding wind chill. Published nutritional guidelines4,9 for camelids do not ac-
count for these extremes. Nutrition has a significant effect on fiber growth in al-
Compendium December 2000 Small Animal/Exotics
TABLE II
Diagnostic Differentials, Clinical Signs, and Additional Tests for Weight Loss in Adult Alpacasa
Condition Possible Clinical Signs Additional Tests
Gastrointestinal Decreased milk production, poor growth Fecal flotation, fecal microscopy
parasitism16,17 and/or feed conversion, diarrhea, dehydration,
emaciation
Dental problems18,19 Abnormal chewing/pain, quidding, partially Thorough buccal examination (sedation
chewed fibers in fecal pellets, mandibular may be needed), oblique radiographs of the
swellings or swellings over maxillary teeth roots, jaw,20 computed tomography and/or
odor or exudation from a nostril, apparent magnetic resonance imaging
sensitivity to cold water, visibly worn or
deformed teeth
Hypophosphatemia25 Poor growth, shifting lameness, angular limb Serum phosphate levels26,27
deformities/bony joint enlargement
Iron deficiency Poor growth, lethargy/diarrhea CBC, serum iron concentration,26–28 total
iron-binding capacity,28 bone marrow
aspirate
Copper deficiency29 Ataxia, anemia/immunosuppression, chronic Liver biopsy, hepatic copper concentration,
(primary or secondary) diarrhea (secondary), lameness, reduced growth serum copper26,27 concentration (the
rate, infertility and reduced milk production, accuracy of this method is questionable)
excessive shedding/stringy hair fibers,
depigmentation of haircoat
Selenium deficiency Chronic diarrhea, immunosuppression, repeated Dietary analysis, whole blood selenium
infection, poor libido/fertility/abortion, concentration26,30
weak/stillborn/lethargic crias, white muscle
disease, hyperthermia
Zinc deficiency Zinc-responsive dermatitis, zinc-responsive CBC, serum alkaline phosphatase, serum
parakeratosis, weight loss/anorexia, reduced zinc concentration,26,27 dietary analysis
fertility
Third-compartment Weight loss/anorexia, reduced fecal production, First-compartment fluid analysis (including
emptying defects32 abdominal distention chloride concentration), abdominal
radiography, exploratory laparotomy
Johne’s disease33,34 Poor growth/weight loss and/or diarrhea in Acid-fast stained fecal smear, fecal culture,
young animals >2 yr of age agar gel immunodiffusion test, necropsy
examination, impression smears of fresh
intestine, polymerase chain reaction testing
of mesenteric lymph nodes
Small Animal/Exotics Compendium December 2000
TABLE II (continued)
Condition Possible Clinical Signs Additional Tests
Juvenile Low-grade chronic problems, failure to respond CBC, blood smear, serum iron
immunodeficiency to treatments, repeated infections, depression, concentration, total iron-binding capacity,
syndrome35–37 (usually failure to gain weight, respiratory tract infection, transferrin saturation, bone marrow
detected in animals ocular infection, dermatitis/gingivitis, lameness, aspiration, serum biochemical analysis, fecal
6–18 mos of age) ataxia examination and urinalysis, bacterial culture
of infected focus, serum IgG concentration,
lymph node biopsy, paired sera (pre and 2
wk post), Clostridium perfringens C and D
vaccination
Protein–energy Weight loss; absence of anorexia, diarrhea, or Feed analysis and comparison of
malnutrition other significant clinical findings requirements with availability
Eperythrozoonosis39 Poor weight gain, chronic diarrhea and/or Complete physical examination, ELISA,
anemia stained blood smears, fecal examination
a Except for references 18, 25, and 33, these conditions have only been described in llamas but should be considered in all cases of
weight loss and illthrift in alpacas until further studies indicate otherwise.
CBC = complete blood count.
91.3% DM, 12.5% CP DM, and a DE of 2.74 Energy provided by grain = (0.13 kg DM ×
Mcal/kg DM. All calculations are performed on a DM 3.33 Mcal/kg DM) = 0.43 Mcal
basis. Therefore, 0.14 kg of oats is converted into 0.13 Protein provided by grain = (0.13 kg DM ×
kg DM (0.14 × 91.8% = 0.14 × 0.918). 10.7%) = 13.91 g
Total protein in ration = 133.75 g (hay) + 13.91 g and feed analysis in the absence of other disease, some
(grain) = 147.66 g owners are unwilling to accept a diagnosis of PEM, as-
Energy deficit = 5.42 Mcal – 3.36 Mcal = 2.06 Mcal suming that it indicates a degree of mistreatment on
Protein deficit = 168.02 g – 147.66 g = 20.36 g their behalf. In my experience, however, the benefits of
Maximum per-animal achievable DM intake of dietary management can generally be appreciated with-
hay – Intake needed to meet energy needs = in 5 to 7 days and supports the diagnosis.
1.07 kg DM – 1.81 kg DM = – 0.74 kg DM.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
This calculation indicates that the animals did not have
The author thanks Miss K. P. Rosel, Department of Tox-
adequate forestomach capacity to allow sufficient inges-
icology, and Dr. M. Smart, Large Animal Clinical Sci-
tion of hay to meet energy or protein requirements un-
ences, Western College of Veterinary Medicine, Universi-
der the stresses of advanced gestation and winter weath-
ty of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Canada, and Dr. J.
er. Weight loss and illthrift are obvious sequelae.
Vaughn, Division of Veterinary and Biomedical Sciences,
The grain portion accounts for 10.8% of the diet,
Murdoch University, Murdoch, Western Australia, for
leaving 89.2% as forage. Dietary crude fiber (CF) must
their help in the preparation of this manuscript.
not be reduced below 25%14 because CF has a signifi-
cant effect on saliva production and, combined with
first-compartment bicarbonate-secreting glands, first- REFERENCES
compartment pH. Camelids differ from any other ru- 1. Oetzel GR, Berger LL: Protein-energy malnutrition in do-
minant-type animals because of the bicarbonate-secret- mestic ruminants. Part I. Predisposing factors and patho-
physiology. Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet 7(11):S672–S679,
ing glands of their first compartment. The 25% CF 1985.
equates to approximately 40% forage in the total diet 2. Oetzel GR, Berger LL: Protein-energy malnutrition in do-
but is heavily dependent on forage quality. mestic ruminants. Part II. Diagnosis, treatment, and preven-
The diet of camelids may need to be supplemented tion. Compend Cont Educ Pract Vet 8(1):S 16–S 21, 1986.
with corn,14 canola, flax, or cotton seed to increase the 3. Oetzel GR: Protein-energy malnutrition in ruminants. Vet
Clin North Am Food Anim Pract 4(2):317–329, 1988.
energy density of the ration during nutritional stress. 4. Fowler ME: Feeding and nutrition, in Medicine and Surgery
An alternative method is to invest in more expensive of South American Camelids, ed 2. Ames, Iowa State Univer-
commercial pellet or textured feeds, such as mixtures of sity Press, 1998, pp 12–48.
grain, protein supplements, vitamins, and minerals 5. Prieto C, Aguilera JF, Lara L, et al: Protein and energy re-
bound together to increase the protein–energy density quirements for maintenance of indigenous Granadina goats.
Br J Nutr 63(2):155–163, 1990.
of the ration. 6. Sengar OP: Indian research on protein and energy require-
ments of goats. J Dairy Sci 63(10):1655–1670, 1980.
CONCLUSION 7. Christinson IG, Cymbuluk NF, Nicolson HG: Feed intake
Literature published in the United States4,14 indicates of growing bulls in severe winters. Can J Anim Sci 70:441–
that camelids are prone to overcondition when re- 450, 1990.
8. Dulphy JP, Martin-Rosswet W, Jouany JP: Forage intake
moved from their typical environment. Nutritional and digestibility compared in different herbivores species.
guidelines for camelids are available in the scientific Product Anim Paris 8(4):293–307, 1995.
and lay press as well as on the Internet; most of these 9. Carmean BR, Johnson KA, Johnson DE, Johnson LW:
guidelines, however, are extrapolated from ruminant Maintenance energy requirement of llamas. Am J Vet Res
data. Based on these guidelines, owners resist feeding 53(1):1696–1698, 1992.
10. Russel AJF, Redden HL: The effect of nutrition on fibre
their camelids more than 0.14 kg (0.3 lb) of grain daily growth in the alpaca. Anim Sci 64:509–512, 1997.
because they believe that feeding more will induce 11. Newman SA, Paterson DJ: Effect of level of nutrition and
third-compartment ulceration. Although no evidence season on fibre growth length in alpacas. Proc NZ Soc Anim
supports this belief, the role of diet in the development Prod 54:147–150, 1994.
of third-compartment ulceration is indirectly supported 12. Lean IJ: Nutrition of dairy cattle. Proc Univ Sydney Post-
Grad Found Vet Sci :363, 1987.
by the fact that llamas and alpacas in South America 13. San Martin F, Bryant FC: Nutrition of domesticated South
have both low-grain consumption and a low incidence American llamas and camelids. Small Ruminant Res 2:191–
of gastric ulceration.31 216, 1989.
Protein and energy needs of alpacas vary according to 14. Johnson LW: Llama nutrition. Vet Clin North Am Food
the specific conditions on the individual farms or Anim Pract 10(2):187–201, 1994.
15. Vaughan JL, Costa ND: Nutrition of the alpaca. Town
ranches. Calculating the correct dietary needs is integral Country Farmer 15:53–60, 1998.
to the complete diagnostic workup of an individual or 16. Cheney JM, Allen GT: Parasitism in llamas. Vet Clin North
herd problem. Despite the irrefutable evidence of BCS Am Food Anim Pract 5(1):217–221, 1989.
17. Rickard LG: Parasites. Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract tices, region of United States, reproductive stage and health
10(2):239–245, 1994. of offspring. J Anim Sci 73(2):337–344, 1995.
18. Long P: Llama herd health. Vet Clin North Am Food Anim 31. Smith BB, Pearson EG, Timm KI: Third compartment ul-
Pract 5(1):229–230, 1989. cers in the llama. Vet Clin North Am Food Anim Pract 10(2):
19. Fowler ME: Health care of the geriatric llama/alpaca. Vet 319–330, 1994.
Clin North Am Food Anim Pract 10(2):392–395, 1994. 32. Belknap EB: Medical problems of llamas. Vet Clin North
20. O’Brien RT: Intraoral dental radiography: Experimental Am Food Anim Pract 10(2):294–295.
study and clinical use in two horses and a llama. Vet Radiol 33. Ridge SE, Harkin JT, Badman RT, et al: Johne’s disease in
Ultrasound 37(6):412–416, 1996. alpacas (Lama pacos) in Australia. Aust Vet J 72(4):150–153,
21. Smith BB, Reed PJ, Pearson EG, et al: Erythrocyte dyscrasia, 1995.
anemia, and hypothyroidism in chronically underweight lla- 34. Belknap EB, Getzy DM, Johnson LW: Mycobacterium
mas. JAVMA 198(1):81–88, 1991. paratuberculosis infection in two llamas. JAVMA 204(11):
22. Smith BB, Pearson EG, Leon J: Evaluation of normal tri- 1805–1808, 1994.
iodothyronine and tetraiodothyronine concentrations in lla- 35. Hutchison JM, Garry FB, Johnson LW, et al: Immunodefi-
mas (Lama glama). Am J Vet Res 50(8):1215–1219, 1989. ciency syndrome associated with wasting and opportunistic
23. McLaughlin BG, Evans CN, Colton RL: Serum triiodothy- infection in juvenile llamas: 12 cases (1988–1990). JAVMA
ronine and thyroxine concentrations in neonatal llamas. J 201(7):1070–1076, 1992.
Vet Diagn Invest 5(2):208–211, 1993. 36. Hutchison JM, Garry FB: Ill thrift and juvenile llama im-
24. Smith BB, Watrous BJ, Pearson EG: Llama medical prob- munodeficiency syndrome. Vet Clin North Am Food Anim
lems, in Kaneps AJ, Crisman RO, Long PO, et al (eds): Pract 10(2):331–343, 1994.
Management of Medical and Surgical Problems in Llamas 37. Hutchison JM, Garry FB, Belknapp EB, et al: Prospective
[monograph]. Ann Conv Am Vet Med Assoc, Portland, OR, characterization of the clinicopathologic and immunologic
July 19th, 1988. features of an immunodeficiency syndrome affecting juvenile
25. Van Saun RJ, Smith BB, Watrous BJ: Evaluation of vitamin llamas. Vet Immunol Immunopathol 49(3):209–227, 1995.
D status of llamas and alpacas with hypophosphatemic rick- 38. Fowler ME: Feeding and nutrition, in Medicine and Surgery
ets. JAVMA 209(6):1128–1133, 1996. of South American Camelids, ed 1. Ames, Iowa State Univer-
26. Smith BB, Van Saun RJ, Reed PJ, et al: Blood mineral and sity Press, 1989, p 21.
vitamin E concentrations in llamas. Am J Vet Res 59(8): 39. Reagan WJ, Garry FB, Thrall MA, et al: The clinicopatho-
1063–1070, 1998. logic, light, and scanning electron microscopic features of
27. Bechert US, Smith BB: Serum macro and micro element eperythrozoonosis in four naturally infected llamas. Vet
concentrations in the llama. Vet Clin Nutr 3(4):119–127, Pathol 27(6):426–431, 1990.
1996.
28. Weiser MG, Fettman MJ, Van Houten D, et al: Characteri-
zation of erthrocytic indices and serum iron values in healthy About the Author
llamas. Am J Vet Res 53(10):1776–1779, 1992.
Dr. Carmalt is affiliated with the Department of Large
29. Andrews AH, Cox A: Suspected nutritional deficiency caus-
ing anemia in llamas (Lama glama). Vet Rec 140(6):153– Animal Clinical Sciences, Western College of Veteri-
154, 1997. nary Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon,
30. Herdt TH: Blood serum concentrations of selenium in fe- Canada.
male llamas (Lama glama) in relationship to feeding prac-