TO OE FUND EXPENSES Thomson Reuters 2013. All Rights Reserved. This report is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute investment advice or an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security of any entity in any jurisdiction. No guarantee is made that the information in this report is accurate or complete and no warranties are made with regard to the results to be obtained from its use. In addition, Lipper will not be liable for any loss or damage resulting from information obtained from Lipper or any of its afliates. For immediate assistance, feel free to contact Lipper Client Services toll-free at 877.955.4773 or via email at LipperClientServices@thomsonreuters.com. For more information about Lipper, please visit our website at www.lipperweb.com. 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO OE FUND EXPENSES JUNE 2013 1 INTRODUCTION 1 For more information on Lipper classication/objective, please go to www.lipperweb.com Please note that the views expressed in this document are intended as nonconsultative and do not constitute legal advice. AUTHORED BY: PETER DE SOUSA BARROTE FIDUCIARY SERVICES SPECIALIST FIDUCIARY SERVICES, LIPPER peter.desousabarrote@thomsonreuters.com Each year, Lipper produces the Lipper Quick Guide to Fund Expenses. The report for open-end (OE) funds consists of a table displaying the asset-weighted average and average total expense ratios by load-type (front-end load/no-load, back-end load/level-load, and institutional), fund type (actively managed funds, indexed funds, exchange-traded funds, and funds of funds), and Lipper classication/ objective. 1 The table provides a quick reference to total expense ratios and enables the reader to compare them between different groupings. 2 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO OE FUND EXPENSES JUNE 2013 OVERALL Overall total expense ratios on average for actively and passively managed open- end funds have declined to 1.163%, a 0.7 basis points (bps) reduction from 2011 to 2012. While actively managed funds have, on average, a total expense ratio decrease of 0.9 bps, indexed funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) together have risen 2.1 bps. The average total expense ratio for ETFs increased from 0.571% to 0.636%. Both equity and xed income funds, within the actively managed fund grouping, have dropped their average total expense ratios by 1.3 bps and 0.2 bps, respectively. ALL GROUPS Two patterns concerning total expense ratios are consistent across Lipper classications/objectives and fund types. The rst demonstrates that asset- weighted average total expense ratios tend to be lower than average total expense ratios. While the average total expense ratio computes the simple average for a set of funds, the asset-weighted average assigns an asset weight based on the average net assets of a fund. Higher weights are assigned to the expenses of the larger funds. For each fund, the expense ratio is multiplied by this weight and, subsequently, its asset-weighted total is summed to obtain the asset-weighted average for a set of funds. For example, small-cap institutional funds have an average total expense ratio of 1.204%, compared to an asset-weighted average ratio of 0.944%. Based on the different calculation methods, the variation between these two averages stems from economies of scale. Typically, as a fund grows in asset size xed fund costs are able to be allocated across a larger asset base and greater operational efciencies may be achieved.
However, economies of scale do not continue indenitely; at a certain asset level economies of scale decrease at an increasing rate. At some point, large complexes may even experience scale diseconomies, whereby larger funds cost more to run. Weighting the expense ratio by the assets of the portfolio tends to equalize the discrepancy between small funds with higher expenses and larger funds, which can charge lower expenses.
The second nding concerns load-types. Institutional funds tend to have lower total expense ratios compared to front-end/no-load funds, while back-end/level- load funds typically have the highest average and asset-weighted average total expense ratios. For example, institutional long municipal debt funds average total FINDINGS METHODOLOGY The 2013 Lipper Quick Guide to OE Fund Expenses contains expense ratios for open-end funds with scal year ends in 2012 and at least six months of operating expense data. Because Lipper only reports on audited scal expense data derived from each funds annual report (publicly available two months after the scal year end for each fund), actual reported fund expenses may appear sluggish in reacting to market conditions. 3 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO OE FUND EXPENSES JUNE 2013 expense ratio is 0.592%, compared to 0.759% for front-end load/no-load funds. Back-end load/level-load long municipal debt funds average total expense ratio is higher still at 1.484%. The expense differences between funds of different load- types can be partly attributed to 12b-1 and non-12b-1 service fees incurred based on the method and type of distribution of the fund. Additionally, institutional funds may only be available to specic investors and, therefore, incur fewer advertising costs than their retail counterparts. FUND TYPESINDEX FUNDS AND EXCHANGE-TRADED FUNDS The table also displays several interesting ndings across fund types. Index funds and indexed exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are less expensive than actively managed open-end funds. For example, US diversied equity (USDE) institutional index funds and USDE ETFs have asset-weighted average total expense ratios of 0.176% and 0.195%, respectively, versus actively managed USDE institutional funds with expense ratios of 0.759%. The difference is mostly due to the operating structure of the funds. Index funds and indexed ETFs are designed to track an underlying index and index tracking is inherently less expensive than active management.
While not true in all cases, the impact of weighting total expense ratios by asset level generally produces signicant variations in numbers for index funds due to the economies of scale. Often, nonmanagement expenses, such as transfer agent and custodian, more heavily drive economies of scale. In the case of index funds, these nonmanagement expense components make up a signicant portion of the total expense ratio, as management fees are already at a minimum due to the passive management style of the funds. Therefore, weighting the expense ratio by assets impacts index funds total expense ratio more than actively managed funds. For example, when considering actively managed front-end load/no-load sector equity funds, the asset-weighted average represents about 68% of the average total expense ratio, compared to approximately 48% for front-end load/no-load sector index funds. FUNDS OF FUNDS The asset-weighted average and average total expense ratios for funds of funds are difcult to compare to non-funds of funds due to differing expense structures. The fund of funds total expense ratios (displayed in the last lines of the table) contain expenses known as underlying fund expenses or acquired fund fees and expenses (AFFE). Underlying fund expenses are incurred from a funds investments in its underlying funds. Comparing the total expense ratios for funds of funds and non-funds of funds entails comparing expenses containing different components. However, mixed-asset non-funds of funds do have similar average and asset-weighted average total expense ratios to lifestyle funds of funds and lifecycle funds of funds. This is most likely because they invest in a similar allocation mix of equity and xed income investments, despite the different expense components. 4 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO OE FUND EXPENSES JUNE 2013 ACTIVELY MANAGED FUNDS Average and asset-weighted average total expense ratios for actively managed funds vary by Lipper classication/objective. Equity funds are divided into ve groups: US diversied equity, balanced/mixed equity, other domestic equity, sector equity, and all world equity. These groups are further split into smaller sub-groups. Across load-types, other domestic equity, sector equity, and all world equity groups have the highest average and asset-weighted average total expense ratios. Within equity, the groupings are not consistently more expensive than one another; however, equity funds are more expensive than xed income funds. The asset-weighted average for front-end and no-load equity funds is 0.872%, while the asset-weighted average for front-end and no-load xed income funds is 0.474%. Fixed income funds are divided into three groups: taxable xed income, money market, and municipal debt. Across all three load-types, money market funds have the lowest average and asset-weighted average total expense ratios, ranging from 0.147% to 0.220%. The taxable xed income group has the highest average and asset-weighted average total expense ratios among the three groupings of funds. The 2013 Lipper Quick Guide to OE Fund Expenses shows that expense differences exist across load-types, fund types, and Lipper classications/objectives. Though the actual expense amounts for funds have changed from year-to-year, the general trends discussed in this paper have held true over parallel spans of time, indicating that while actual expenses have changed, the trends underlying them have not. CONCLUSION 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO OE FUND EXPENSES FRONT-END LOAD / NO-LOAD BACK-END LOAD / LEVEL-LOAD INSTITUTIONAL ALL 2012 Total Expense Ratios Asset-Weighted Average Average Asset-Weighted Average Average Asset-Weighted Average Average A C T I V E L Y
M A N A G E D
F U N D S ALL ACTIVELY MANAGED FUNDS 0.718 1.117 1.097 1.779 0.479 0.912 ALL EQUITY 0.872 1.314 1.703 2.055 0.828 1.126 ALL US DIVERSIFIED EQUITY (USDE) 0.864 1.232 1.694 1.971 0.759 1.057 Large-Cap 0.759 1.110 1.570 1.880 0.686 0.955 Multi-Cap 0.912 1.256 1.869 1.975 0.745 1.023 Mid-Cap 1.005 1.269 1.791 2.009 0.896 1.102 Small-Cap 1.103 1.343 1.786 2.082 0.944 1.204 BALANCED/MIXED EQUITY 0.690 1.152 1.587 1.858 0.769 0.994 OTHER DOMESTIC EQUITY 0.968 1.593 1.726 2.165 0.968 1.301 Equity Income 0.832 1.164 1.645 1.886 0.759 0.997 Specialty Diversied 1.295 1.828 1.811 2.321 1.110 1.465 SECTOR EQUITY 0.911 1.342 1.942 2.144 0.872 1.168 ALL WORLD EQUITY 1.020 1.441 1.900 2.225 0.913 1.245 Global 1.010 1.367 1.815 2.132 0.907 1.215 International 0.949 1.363 1.866 2.166 0.847 1.167 Precious Metals 0.950 1.300 1.893 1.981 0.974 1.001 Other World Equity 1.294 1.623 2.180 2.408 1.059 1.418 ALL FIXED INCOME 0.474 0.730 0.702 1.323 0.284 0.553 ALL TAXABLE FIXED INCOME 0.646 0.890 1.521 1.619 0.542 0.763 ALL DOMESTIC TAXABLE FIXED INCOME 0.616 0.860 1.527 1.592 0.520 0.733 Short/Intermediate Taxable Fixed Income 0.547 0.751 1.435 1.441 0.472 0.642 Long Taxable Fixed Income 0.682 0.936 1.600 1.688 0.634 0.818 WORLD TAXABLE FIXED INCOME 0.937 1.062 1.482 1.780 0.695 0.923 ALL MONEY MARKET 0.212 0.193 0.220 0.198 0.147 0.171 Taxable Money Market 0.220 0.177 0.219 0.185 0.144 0.157 Tax Exempt Money Market 0.187 0.218 0.222 0.232 0.199 0.211 ALL MUNICIPAL DEBT 0.518 0.731 1.329 1.470 0.516 0.569 Short/Intermediate Municipal Debt 0.407 0.674 1.308 1.426 0.485 0.535 Long Municipal Debt 0.595 0.759 1.338 1.484 0.573 0.592 I N D E X E D
F U N D S ALL INDEXED FUNDSINCLUDES ETFs 0.163 0.894 1.579 1.989 0.262 0.595 ALL EQUITY 0.167 0.926 1.550 1.996 0.274 0.640 ALL US DIVERSIFIED EQUITY (USDE) 0.164 0.783 1.447 1.787 0.176 0.413 Large-Cap 0.276 0.846 1.794 1.985 0.179 0.364 Multi-Cap 0.125 0.890 1.274 1.708 0.131 0.473 Mid-Cap 0.204 0.569 1.445 1.703 0.168 0.426 Small-Cap 0.211 0.751 1.300 1.745 0.250 0.403 BALANCED/MIXED EQUITY 0.285 0.748 1.909 1.831 0.370 0.492 ALL OTHER DOMESTIC EQUITY 0.140 1.261 1.572 2.160 0.161 1.097 S&P 500 Index 0.123 0.464 1.090 1.289 0.081 0.411 SECTOR EQUITY 0.259 0.544 2.002 1.981 0.393 0.637 ALL WORLD EQUITY 0.212 0.814 1.930 1.881 0.414 0.586 ALL FIXED INCOME 0.147 0.625 1.795 1.904 0.207 0.349 ALL ETFs --- --- --- --- 0.306 0.636 ETFs - USDE --- --- --- --- 0.195 0.350 ETFs - Sector Equity --- --- --- --- 0.397 0.629 ETFs - World Equity --- --- --- --- 0.424 0.583 ETFs - Other Equity --- --- --- --- 0.220 1.301 ETFs - Fixed Income --- --- --- --- 0.268 0.381 ALL FUNDSACTIVE & INDEXED 0.651 1.102 1.100 1.791 0.417 0.859 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO OE FUND EXPENSES Thomson Reuters 2013. All Rights Reserved. This report is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute investment advice or an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security of any entity in any jurisdiction. No guarantee is made that the information in this report is accurate or complete and no warranties are made with regard to the results to be obtained from its use. In addition, Lipper will not be liable for any loss or damage resulting from information obtained from Lipper or any of its afliates. Please see www.lipperweb.com for further information regarding Lipper calculation methodologies and Lipper fund classications. For immediate assistance, feel free to contact Lipper Client Services toll-free at 877.955.4773 or via email at LipperClientServices@thomsonreuters.com. For institutional use only. Asset-weighted averages represent the total expenses of each fund in the asset class weighted by the average net assets of each fund. More weight is assigned to the expenses of the larger funds. The asset-weighted average is intended to represent the expense ratio that is charged to the average dollar invested in the asset class. The simple average represents the average expenses of all funds in the asset class. Under this calculation, each fund is assigned equal weight and the value reects the average expense ratio that is charged by the average fund in the asset class. All funds that invest primarily in other investment companies (funds of funds) have been excluded from the data with the exception of the Lifecycle and Lifestyle funds. Total expense ratios for these funds include any estimated underlying fund expenses from each fund of funds most recent prospectus. FRONT-END LOAD / NO-LOAD BACK-END LOAD / LEVEL-LOAD INSTITUTIONAL ALL 2012 Total Expense Ratios (Including Underlying Fund Expenses) Asset-Weighted Average Average Asset-Weighted Average Average Asset-Weighted Average Average LIFECYCLE (TARGET DATE) FUNDS 0.525 0.991 1.114 1.660 0.721 0.912 Today 0.436 0.953 1.267 1.630 0.721 0.838 2010-2019 0.460 0.908 1.020 1.551 0.656 0.865 2020-2029 0.522 0.974 1.086 1.642 0.702 0.903 2030-2039 0.566 1.015 1.127 1.691 0.748 0.927 2040-2049 0.582 1.039 1.156 1.714 0.770 0.944 2050+ 0.571 1.031 1.162 1.726 0.789 0.956 LIFESTYLE (TARGET ALLOCATION) FUNDS 0.615 1.118 1.582 1.903 0.738 1.029 Conservative 0.515 1.094 1.868 1.903 0.798 1.045 Moderate 0.734 1.168 1.447 1.891 0.787 1.029 Growth 0.567 1.188 1.676 1.956 0.704 1.060 Retirement Income 0.545 0.838 1.840 1.603 0.755 0.726 MANAGEMENT TOTAL EXPENSES Asset-Weighted Average Average Asset-Weighted Average Average L E V E R A G E D ALL CE LEVERAGED FUNDS 1.054 1.026 1.224 1.290 ALL EQUITY 1.327 1.325 1.498 1.600 Domestic Equity 1.077 1.190 1.271 1.523 Other Domestic Equity 1.154 1.287 1.356 1.581 Sector Equity 1.440 1.357 1.588 1.581 World Equity 1.439 1.398 1.630 1.719 ALL FIXED INCOME 0.949 0.950 1.119 1.212 Taxable Fixed Income 1.026 1.043 1.213 1.350 Municipal Debt Fixed Income 0.857 0.875 1.004 1.103 World Fixed Income 1.121 1.145 1.332 1.449 ALL CE NON-LEVERAGED FUNDS 0.832 0.883 1.020 1.323 N O N - L E V E R A G E D ALL EQUITY 0.851 0.936 1.045 1.475 Domestic Equity 0.741 0.798 1.037 2.099 Other Domestic Equity 0.953 0.934 1.056 1.083 Sector Equity 0.574 0.897 0.755 1.223 World Equity 1.033 1.017 1.375 1.614 ALL FIXED INCOME 0.770 0.746 0.937 0.934 Taxable Fixed Income 0.744 0.732 0.933 0.952 Municipal Debt Fixed Income 0.574 0.585 0.684 0.715 World Fixed Income 0.880 0.946 1.022 1.103 ALL CE FUNDSLEVERAGED & NON-LEVERAGED 0.986 0.985 1.161 1.299 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO CE FUND EXPENSES Thomson Reuters 2013. All Rights Reserved. This report is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute investment advice or an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security of any entity in any jurisdiction. No guarantee is made that the information in this report is accurate or complete and no warranties are made with regard to the results to be obtained from its use. In addition, Lipper will not be liable for any loss or damage resulting from information obtained from Lipper or any of its afliates. Please see www.lipperweb.com for further information regarding Lipper calculation methodologies and Lipper fund classications. For immediate assistance, feel free to contact Lipper Client Services toll-free at 877.955.4773 or via email at LipperClientServices@thomsonreuters.com. For institutional use only. Asset-weighted averages represent the total expenses of each fund in the asset class weighted by the average net assets of each fund. More weight is assigned to the expenses of the larger funds. The asset-weighted average is intended to represent the expense ratio that is charged to the average dollar invested in the asset class. The simple average represents the average expenses of all funds in the asset class. Under this calculation, each fund is assigned equal weight and the value reects the average expense ratio that is charged by the average fund in the asset class. All funds that invest primarily in other investment companies (funds of funds) have been excluded from the data with the exception of the Lifecycle and Lifestyle funds. Total expense ratios for these funds include any estimated underlying fund expenses from each fund of funds most recent prospectus. 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO FUND EXPENSES MANAGEMENT TOTAL EXPENSES Asset-Weighted Average Average Asset-Weighted Average Average A C T I V E L Y - M A N A G E D
F U N D S ALL VIP FUNDS 0.611 0.679 0.772 0.925 ALL EQUITY 0.666 0.735 0.836 0.994 ALL US DIVERSIFIED EQUITY (USDE) 0.641 0.719 0.802 0.958 Large-Cap 0.570 0.660 0.733 0.894 Multi-Cap 0.680 0.689 0.830 0.943 Mid-Cap 0.779 0.776 0.944 1.016 Small-Cap 0.815 0.827 0.974 1.058 BALANCED/MIXED EQUITY 0.634 0.655 0.811 0.939 OTHER DOMESTIC EQUITY 0.632 0.659 0.743 0.890 SECTOR EQUITY 0.781 0.765 0.997 1.087 ALL WORLD EQUITY 0.763 0.823 0.959 1.102 Global 0.704 0.792 0.882 1.046 International 0.745 0.787 0.942 1.069 Other World Equity 1.014 1.022 1.260 1.339 ALL FIXED INCOME 0.483 0.490 0.623 0.694 ALL TAXABLE FIXED INCOME 0.527 0.548 0.675 0.768 ALL DOMESTIC TAXABLE FIXED INCOME 0.520 0.530 0.662 0.754 Short/Intermediate Taxable Fixed Income 0.520 0.518 0.665 0.715 Long Taxable Fixed Income 0.520 0.538 0.659 0.777 WORLD TAXABLE FIXED INCOME 0.628 0.681 0.847 0.880 ALL MONEY MARKET 0.157 0.163 0.239 0.271 ALL VIP FUNDS 0.611 0.679 0.772 0.925 2013 LIPPERS QUICK GUIDE TO VIP FUND EXPENSES Thomson Reuters 2013. All Rights Reserved. This report is for informational purposes only, and does not constitute investment advice or an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to buy any security of any entity in any jurisdiction. No guarantee is made that the information in this report is accurate or complete and no warranties are made with regard to the results to be obtained from its use. In addition, Lipper will not be liable for any loss or damage resulting from information obtained from Lipper or any of its afliates. Please see www.lipperweb.com for further information regarding Lipper calculation methodologies and Lipper fund classications. For immediate assistance, feel free to contact Lipper Client Services toll-free at 877.955.4773 or via email at LipperClientServices@thomsonreuters.com. For institutional use only. Asset-weighted averages represent the total expenses of each fund in the asset class weighted by the average net assets of each fund. More weight is assigned to the expenses of the larger funds. The asset-weighted average is intended to represent the expense ratio that is charged to the average dollar invested in the asset class. The simple average represents the average expenses of all funds in the asset class. Under this calculation, each fund is assigned equal weight and the value reects the average expense ratio that is charged by the average fund in the asset class. All funds that invest primarily in other investment companies (funds of funds) have been excluded from the data with the exception of the Lifecycle and Lifestyle funds. Total expense ratios for these funds include any estimated underlying fund expenses from each fund of funds most recent prospectus.