in Southern Africa Energy baseline survey in Ga Maraba and Ga Mogano in the Northern Province (South Africa) FINAL REPORT JUNE 2001 PREPARE B! PA"MER E#E"$PME%N C$NS&"%'NG 'N ASS$C'A%'$N ('%) %)E NG(AABE AN B$C)&M ENERG! C$*$PERA%'#ES Executive Summary Biomass still amounts to nearly 80% of total energy demand in SADC countries. Most of this energy is used for household purposes (cooking !aking lighting heating" !ut a su!stantial amount goes into small#scale !usinesses like !rick firing fish smoking processing of agricultural products !eer !re$ing and restaurants. %n addition recent statistics suggest that !iomass energy use for Africa $ill ha&e dou!led !y the year '0'0. Main reasons for this are a high population increase lo$ incomes and a shortage of foreign currency. An energy !aseline study $as conducted in the northern (ro&ince of South Africa to pro&ide energy specific household data to assist in the planning and design of further actions on the dissemination of impro&ed sto&es. )he o!*ecti&e of the !aseline study $as to o!tain energy specific household data to assist in the planning and design of further actions on the dissemination of $oodsto&es and solar sto&es in the area. )he a&erage family si+e in !oth areas is , people. %n !oth areas in the ma*ority of the households men are considered to !e the heads of the households. )his $ould ha&e implications in the implementation of specific programmes $hen gender decision# making processes and po$er relationships regarding purchasing $ould need to !e considered. Both areas can !e considered fairly $ell off in terms of access to income sources although -a Mara!a seems to !e slightly less $ell off $ith more pensioners and less households $ith someone in employment. %n general !oth areas seem !etter off than rural areas in general $here unemployment is high and reliance on pensions and remittances &ery high. )he conclusion that -a Mogano is .richer/ or !etter off is !ased on the fact that more households ha&e someone formally employed in -a Mogano than in -a Mara!a (,'% &s. 00%" respecti&ely. Also more people farm and sell produce (120% &s 111%" and lastly only 13'% rely on pensions in -a Mogano in contract to 403% in -a Mara!a. 5ith regard to appliance o$nership a high le&el of o$nership of electrical appliances seems to indicate that the areas ha&e !een electrified for some time. %t further indicates the relati&e $ealth of households since appliances such as refrigerators are e6pensi&e and normally o$nership in rural areas is not that high. 7$nership of radio8s tele&isions as $ell as fridges is higher in -a Mara!a (identified as a poorer area" than in -a Mogano. )he use of $ood for cooking purposes in -a Mogano is higher in !oth summer and $inter than in -a Mara!a. 9lectricity use for cooking is high in -a Mara!a (0,,% in summer and 4,0% in $inter respecti&ely". %t $ould seem that $ood fuel inter&entions $ould !e more appropriate in -a Mogano due to the higher incidence of fuel $ood use for cooking purposes. )he use of $ood for cooking purposes in -a Mogano is higher in !oth summer and $inter than in -a Mara!a. 9lectricity use for cooking is high in -a Mara!a (0,,% in summer and 4,0% in $inter respecti&ely". %t $ould seem that $ood fuel inter&entions $ould !e more appropriate in -a Mogano due to the higher incidence of fuel $ood use for cooking purposes. %n -a Mara!a 04% of households !uy $ood ($hether they !uy $ood only or $ood and other fuels" at an a&erage cost of :1,8 per month. %n total households spend appro6imately :4;0 per month on energy. %n -a Mara!a 04% of households !uy $ood ($hether they !uy $ood only or $ood and other fuels" at an a&erage cost of :1,8 per month. %n total households spend appro6imately :4;0 per month on energy. )he most popular method of cooking in use is !oiling and that the method of cooking $ill !e suita!le for energy efficient $ood sto&es. %t can further !e concluded that enough cooking opportunities e6ist to *ustify the introduction of efficient sto&es i.e. households cook often (at least t$ice daily" as opposed to areas $here cooking may only take place once a day due to food scarcities energy shortages or la!our shortages (someone to actually do the cooking". <astly it is also clear that the type of food prepared (porridge &egeta!les meat" $ould !e suited to prepare on an energy efficient $ood sto&e. Conclusions therefore seem to indicate that !oth study areas are generally $ealthy $ith a high le&el of appliance o$nership. =o$e&er $ood fuel use especially for cooking purposes is still high and $ood fuel is considered to !e scarce in !oth areas. =ouseholds e6perience additional pro!lems associated $ith the use of $ood fuel as an energy source as $ell as pro!lems $ith the use of con&entional energy sources. )he com!ination of $ood fuel scarcity continued high le&els of $ood fuel use a$areness regarding pro!lems associated $ith $ood fuel use and an indication of the potential of disposa!le income to !e spent on appliances seems to indicate positi&e conditions for the implementation of an impro&ed sto&e programme. )a!le of Contents +,'N%R$&C%'$N,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,+ -,BAC.GR$&N/ PR$GRAMME 0$R B'$MASS ENERG! C$NSER#A%'$N 'N S$&%)ERN A0R'CA (PR$BEC),,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,+ 1,ME%)$$"$G!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,+ 2,%)E S%&! AREA 'N C$N%E3%,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,- 4,%)E 0'N'NGS 5 AN $#ER#'E(,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,2 5.1Socioeco!omic i!"ormatio!...................................................................................# 5.2A$$%ia!ce o&!er'(i$...............................................................................................) 5.*E!er+y U'e.............................................................................................................11 3.4.1 Daily fuels used per area.................................................................................11 %n -a Mogano more households !uy $ood than in -a Mara!a > ,,,% as opposed to 04%. )his is consistent $ith a significant higher le&el of $oodfuel use for cooking purposes in -a Mogano. =ouseholds spend more on paraffin in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano !oth areas spend a!out :,0 per month on coal $hile -a Mogano spends more on electricity than -a Mara!a. )his is strange since the le&el of electrical appliance o$nership is significantly higher in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano and also !ecause electricity is $idely used for cooking purposes in -a Mara!a. 7ne e6planation could !e that although a high le&el of electrical appliance o$nership is found it does not necessarily mean that all appliances are al$ays used. ?rom the a!o&ementioned ta!les it is also apparent that !oth areas spend similar amounts on $ood although $oodfuel use is lo$er in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano. ..................................................................................................................10 ?amilies in !oth these areas collect $ood in the natural &eldt !ut there is 10;% more $ood collection reported in -a Mogano than in -a Mara!a. Most of the families ha&e trees around their houses !ut it is mostly fruit and ornamental trees (not used for fire$ood".............................................................................................10 3.4.' Daily diets........................................................................................................10 3.4.4 (ro!lems associated $ith fuel use...................................................................1, 3.4.0A$areness of impro&ed sto&es.........................................................................'0 S'6E $0 P$%S,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,-- )his can !e compared to sto&es used e&ery day.......................................................'4 3.4.3 =ealth issues....................................................................................................'3 7, C$NC"&S'$NS AN REC$MMENA%'$NS,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,-7 B'B"'$GRAP)!,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,-8 9&ES%'$NNA'RE NR,/ AREA/ A%E/,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,1+ NAME $0 'N%ER#'E(ER,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,1+ NAME $0 RESP$NEN%,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,1+ -,)$&SE)$" C)ARAC%ER'S%'CS,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,1- Tota%.............................................................................................................................*2 Truc,...........................................................................................................................*2 *.E!er+y co!'ume- .y t(e (ou'e(o%-......................................................................*# )ype of fuel@ energy source used.............................................................................40 /(at i' t(e "ue% or e!er+y 'ource u'e- "or...............................................................*# #.E!er+y 'u$$%y..........................................................................................................*0 5T(e ,itc(e! ute!'i%' a!- coo,i!+ $ro"i%e'..............................................................*1 )ime of cooking.......................................................................................................48 02o$i!+ &it( "ue%&oo- 'carcity................................................................................*) 1Im$rove- 'tove'........................................................................................................#0 3E!er+y a!- 4ea%t(...................................................................................................#1 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555 555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555555........#* (roB9C (age 1 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1. I!tro-uctio! (almer De&elopment Consulting $as contracted !y -)C to assist in the completion of a !aseline study in the -a Mara!a and -a Mogana districts of the Dorthern (ro&ince in South Africa. )he follo$ing report $ill pro&ide a general o&er&ie$ of the findings. 2. 6ac,+rou!-7 Pro+ramme "or 6ioma'' E!er+y 2o!'ervatio! i! Sout(er! A"rica 8Pro6E29 Biomass still amounts to nearly 80% of total energy demand in SADC countries. Most of this energy is used for household purposes (cooking !aking lighting heating" !ut a su!stantial amount goes into small#scale !usinesses like !rick firing fish smoking processing of agricultural products !eer !re$ing and restaurants. %n addition recent statistics suggest that !iomass energy use for Africa $ill ha&e dou!led !y the year '0'0. Main reasons for this are a high population increase lo$ incomes and a shortage of foreign currency. 7n the other side the a&aila!le !iomass resources ha&e !een significantly reduced due to a gro$ing population reEuiring more agricultural land and infrastructure de&elopment due to periodic droughts and in some countries due to years of ci&il conflict. Despite these facts energy in&estments in SADC countries ha&e !een concentrated on the modern energy sector and only less than '% of total energy !udgets are allocated to !iomass fuels. )hese $ere some of the reasons to start the (rogramme for Biomass 9nergy Conser&ation in Southern Africa. (roB9C is a supra#regional (rogramme $hich aims to enhance capacities and commitments of go&ernments and de&elopment institutions@organisations to plan and implement integrated !iomass energy conser&ation programmes. )hus it intends to contri!ute to the impro&ement of Euality of life for the poor rural and ur!an populations !y ena!ling them to fulfill their energy needs in a socially and en&ironmentally sustaina!le manner. (roB9C is a *oint programme !et$een SADC the 9uropean Commission (9C" and the -erman -o&ernment. Most of the financial support comes from the ?orestry Sector of the 9C. )he -erman Agency for )echnical Cooperation (-)C" is commissioned to implement (roB9C. -)C has a long and $orld#$ide e6perience in planning implementing and monitoring integrated household energy pro*ects and programmes. %n a first phase (1228#'001" (roB9C acti&ities are restricted to si6 SADC countriesA <esotho Mala$i Mo+am!iEue Dami!ia South Africa and Cim!a!$e *. :et(o-o%o+y )he o!*ecti&e of the !aseline study $as to o!tain energy specific household data to assist in the planning and design of further actions on the dissemination of $oodsto&es and solar sto&es in the area. %t $as also en&isaged that specific health related Euestions $ould !e included pertaining to =%F@A%DS as $ell as indoor air BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age ' 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB pollution. Due to strong resistance from the enumerators the health related Euestions $ere minimised. )he enumerators felt uncomforta!le asking =%F@A%DS related Euestions since they are not health $orkers and they feared that the community $ould !e offended. An alternati&e suggestion $as to contact the Departmetn of =ealth to o!tain the necessary information if a&aila!le. %t is recommended that (roB9C should liase $ith the Department of =ealth to formalise the reEuest for information and clearly state the purpose for $hich the information is reEuired. (DC8s responsi!ility $as to assist $ith Euestionnaire design training of field $orkers piloting and finalisation of the Euestionnaire. %n addition (DC also had to complete the data capturing and analysis originally meant to !e the responsi!ility of the enumerators. )he sur&ey $as conducted through a structured inter&ie$ and Euestionnaire. )he Euestionnaire is attached as Anne6 1. )he sur&ey areas $ere pre#selected !y (roB9C and households $ere randomly selected. %n total 1;3 inter&ie$s $ere conducted 8; in -a Mogano and 88 in -a Mara!a. Data capturing $as e6ecuted !y (DC utilising a specific designed data!ase in Access. )he full data!ase is a&aila!le for further analyses. (almer De&elopment Consulting pro&ided training to '0 enumerators during a training $orkshop held in (ieters!urg 4#8 May '001. )he training session included a piloting e6ercise to test and adapt the Euestionnaire. Dot all '0 enumerators attended the training and de!riefing session after completion of the pilot study. %n total 2 enumerators attended the training and 13 attended the de!riefing session. Do particular reasons $ere gi&en $hy the rest did not attend the training or de!riefing sessions. #. T(e 'tu-y area i! co!text )he Dorthern (ro&ince lies $ithin the great el!o$ of the <impopo :i&er and it shares !orders $ith Bots$ana Cim!a!$e and Mo+am!iEue. (ieters!urg is the capital city and lies strategically in the centre of the pro&ince. 7ther important Dorthern (ro&ince to$ns include the ma*or mining centres of (hala!or$a and )ha!a+im!i and )+aneen producer of tea forestry products and tropical fruits. A ne$ ma*or road route $ill !e the Maputo Corridor $hich $ill link the pro&ince directly $ith the Mo+am!iEue port creating de&elopment and trade opportunities particularly in the south#eastern part of the pro&ince. )he pro&ince8s link $ith Maputo has !een declared a Gmain8 corridor. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 4 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB %n the Dorthern (ro&ince more than fi&e million people li&e on a!out 1'4 210 kmH of land. )he main languages spoken are Sepedi (3';%" Iitsonga ('',%" )shi&enda (133%" and Afrikaans. Controlled hunting is often com!ined $ith cattle farming. Sunflo$ers cotton mai+e and peanuts are culti&ated in the 5arm!aths#Dylstroom area. Dylstroom is also kno$n for its ta!le grape crops. )ropical fruit such as !ananas litchis pineapples mangoes and pa$pa$s as $ell as a &ariety of nuts are gro$n in the )+aneen and <ouis )richardt areas. 96tensi&e tea and coffee plantations create many employment opportunities in the )+aneen area. Ce!ediela one of the largest citrus estates in the country is situated south of (ieters!urg. )he Dorthern (ro&ince has e6tensi&e forestry plantations in the <ouis )richardt and )+aneen districts. (lantations of hard $oods for furniture#manufacturing ha&e also !een esta!lished. Many of the rural people practise su!sistence agriculture. )he Dorthern (ro&ince is rich in minerals including copper as!estos coal iron ore platinum chrome diamonds phosphates and gold. )he pro&ince is a typical de&eloping area e6porting primary products and importing manufactured goods and ser&ices. )he Dational 9lectrification (D9<?" dta!ase recorded a total of 210 ;,2 houses in the Dorthern (ro&ince of $hich 114% $ere in ur!an areas. A mere 32% of these houses ha&e tap $ater in the house and ;'% ha&e full $ater!orne sanitation. )he Dational 9lectricity :egulator indicates that 43% of these houses ha&e access to electricity. 9skom8s Matim!a po$er station at 9llisras pro&ides the total electricity generating capacity of the pro&ince. )here are 1; licensed institutions that distri!ute electricity in the pro&ince. 9skom pro&ides electricity directly to 8;% of domestic users in the pro&ince. Ta.%e 17 Provi!cia% 2(aracteri'tic'. Source7 ;6SA< 1))3 I!-icator' Nort(er! Provi!ce (opulation 1223 (G000" 0 2402 (opulation gro$th 1280#23 (%" 4, Density 122; persons@km ' 0'0'4 ?unctional Jr!anisation le&el 1220 (%" 4'0 =uman De&elopment %nde6 1221 00;0 (ersonal %ncome per Capita 1220 (:" ' '88 Adult <iteracy :ate (1220" % ;04 (upil@teacher ratio 1223 4,, <ife e6pectancy 1220 ,'2 %nfant mortality rate 1220 332 =ospital !eds@1000 people 1223 41 <a!our force 1223 (G000" 1 112 Jnemployment rate 1223 (%" 010 Dominal --( 1220 (:m" 14 ;21' :eal --( 1220 (:m" 2 1'20 :eal --( gro$th 1280#20 (%" 3' :eal --( per Capita 1220 K 1 ;1' :eal --( per $orker 1220 (:" 1; 84, (ersonal %ncome@--( 1220 (%" 810 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 0 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 9nergy ser&ices are reEuired !y a &ariety of energy users $ho can !e grouped into the follo$ing three ma*or energy consumption sectorsA )he domestic sector i.e. households reEuiring energy for domestic needs such as cooking lighting $ater and space heating refrigeration recreation and mediaL )he ser&ice sector i.e. community facilities such as clinics $ater supply schools administration facilities community centers street lighting ser&ice centers churches police stations etc.L )he economic sector i.e. acti&ities such as farming (including su!sistence farming" trading manufacturing transport etc. -enerally energy use in rural areas need to !e seen in the conte6t of rural po&erty neglect and underde&elopment as these conditions ha&e largely determined current energy use patterns. At present domestic uses of energy account for most of the energy consumed in poor rural areas. 5. T(e Fi!-i!+' = a! overvie& 1 5.1 Socioeco!omic i!"ormatio! )he a&erage family si+e in !oth areas is , people. %n -a Mogano and -a Mara!a the smallest families consists only of one person. %n -a Mogano the largest family consists of 11 people and in -a Mara!a the largest family consists of 13 people. %n !oth areas in the ma*ority of the households men are considered to !e the heads of the households. %n -a Mogano in ; of the ,' male#headed households the male is not li&ing in the house and in 1 out of the ; the male does make decisions a!out appliances if it is more than :'00. %n -a Mara!a in only 1 of the 32 male#headed households the male is not li&ing in the house !ut it is uncertain $hether he makes any decisions ($ho makes decisions $asn8t reported in this response". %t can therefore !e concluded that the ma*ority of the reported male#headed households ha&e males present in the household as opposed to males $ho are a!sent (li&ing a$ay from the household" !ut still considered to !e the head of the household. )his $ould ha&e implications in the implementation of specific programmes $hen gender decision#making processes and po$er relationships regarding appliance purchasing $ould need to !e considered. %t may !e to the !enefit of the pro*ect if *oint decision#making is reEuired !efore an appliance such as an energy efficient sto&e can !e purchased if males are present > it could speed up the decision#making process and males can !e reached through demonstrations. Fi+ure 17 >e!-er7 4ea- o" t(e 4ou'e(o%- >a :o+a!o 1 Classification of households > Area 1 refers to -a Mogano and Area ' refers to -a Mara!a BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 3 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Fi+ure 27 >e!-er7 4ea- o" 4ou'e(o%- >a :ara.a 30% 70% F M Both areas ha&e a high pre&alence of male heads of households. )his could indicate more sta!le household incomes as male headed households are often considered to !e !etter off than female headed households. ?or e6ample $omen are more likely than men to !e poor > May et al (as Euoted in )hom 122;A3" found that 32% of $omen in rural areas are poor compared to 01% of men. )he phenomenon of female#headed households also indicates that $omen are at greater risk since ;3% of female#headed households are poor as compared to ,0% of male#headed households. Although female#headed households tend to !e poorer than male#headed households May et al found that $omen in certain categories of male#headed households are among the poorest of the population. %t can therefore not !e concluded that only female#headed households are poor !ut e&idence do seem to suggest that $omen tend to !e $orse off $hether in a female#headed or male#headed households. <astly May et al (as Euoted in )hom 122;A3" found that female#headed households ha&e less access to ser&ices than male#headed households# they are therefore not only poorer in terms of income !ut also in terms of access to ser&ices. Decision making responsi!ility is an important aspect to consider $hen inter&entions reEuiring purchases such as impro&ed sto&es are !eing considered. )his $ill indicate BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 26% 7% F M (roB9C (age , 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $hich groups should !e targeted for specific acti&ities such as demonstrations information dissemination and credit facilities. Decision making responsi!ility $ithin households regarding fuels and appliances in -a Mogano !elongs mainly to $omen sometimes to men and sometimes to !oth. A 3% &ariation occur $hen decisions a!out more e6pensi&e appliances ha&e to !e made and more men are then in&ol&ed in the process. %n -a Mogano it can ho$e&er !e concluded that $omen are the main decision#makers $hen it comes to the purchase of fuels and appliancesA Ta.%e 27 ;eci'io! ma,i!+ re'$o!'i.i%ity >a :o+a!o %n -a Mara!a there is a higher pre&alence of men in&ol&ed in decision making a!out energy as $ell as appliancesA BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 0% !0% 20% 30% 0% "0% 60% 70% #0% $0% !00% Energy A%%&iance '200 an( un(er A%%&iance ) '200 Ma&e Fema&e Both (roB9C (age ; 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e *7 ;eci'io! ma,i!+ re'$o!'i.i%ity7 >a :ara.a %t can therefore !e concluded that $omen seem to ha&e more decision making po$er in the area of -a Mogano e&en though there are less female heads of households in -a Mogano (',%" as opposed to 40% female headed households in -a Mara!a. 5hen taking formal employment in to consideration -a Mara!a seems less $ell off than -a Mogano. %n -a Mara!a only 004% of households ha&e someone li&ing in the house $ho is formally employed as opposed to ,'% of -a Mogano. %n -a Mara!a $here people are poorer and resources scarcer more men are in&ol&ed in decision making a!out the allocation of scarce resources is reEuired. )his is supported !y the fact that no distinguisha!le difference could !e o!ser&ed !et$een decisions o&er more e6pensi&e appliances in comparison to less e6pensi&e appliances again signalling that it doesn8t matter if an appliance is e6pensi&e or cheap !ut !ecause resources are limited a larger percentage of men participate in the decision# making process. )his is in contrast to -a Mogano $here a slight difference !et$een e6pensi&e and less e6pensi&e appliances can !e o!ser&ed > possi!ly a case of $here resources are not so scarce men are not so much in&ol&ed in making decisions a!out day to day e6penses !ut *oint decision#making is reEuired especially if the appliance is e6pensi&e. %n -a Mogano ,'% of the households ha&e someone li&ing in the house $ho is formally employed. 13'% li&e on a pension 120% farm and sell produce '8% ha&e temporary *o!s and 10% are self#employed. 43,% of the households in this area recei&e outside contri!utions $hether it is food money or groceries. %n -a Mara!a only 004% of the households ha&e someone li&ing in the house $ho is formally employed. 403% li&e on a pension 111% farm and sell produce and one person is a part time priest. ';4% of the households in this area recei&e outside contri!utions $hich include food money groceries and in one case clothing. (lease BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 0% !0% 20% 30% 0% "0% 60% 70% #0% $0% !00% Energy A%%&iance '200 an( un(er A%%&iance ) '200 Ma&e Fema&e Both (roB9C (age 8 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB note that total percentages $ill not add up to 100% since households ha&e more than one source of income i.e people $ho are formally employed also may recei&e outside contri!utions and farm and sell produce. ?rom the a!o&e it is clear that !oth areas can !e considered fairly $ell off in terms of access to income sources although -a Mara!a seems to !e slightly less $ell off $ith more pensioners and less households $ith someone in employment. %n general !oth areas seem !etter off than rural areas in general $here unemployment is high and reliance on pensions and remittances &ery high. )he conclusion that -a Mogano is .richer/ or !etter off is !ased on the fact that more households ha&e someone formally employed in -a Mogano than in -a Mara!a (,'% &s. 00%" respecti&ely. Also more people farm and sell produce (120% &s 111%" and lastly only 13'% rely on pensions in -a Mogano in contract to 403% in -a Mara!a. %n another attempt to understand household income the assets of households $ere in&estigated. )he assets o$ned !y a household $ere di&ided into 0 sectionsA implements appliances houses and farming. Fi+ure *7 >a :o+a!o Im$%eme!t O&!er'(i$ 0 !0 20 30 0 "0 60 70 #0 $0 !00 P & o u g h * o r s e C a r t + h e e & , a r r o - . r u c / . r a c t o r C a r 0 o n / e y C a r 1 2 e n ':;le:ent P e r c e n t a g e Again the conclusion that the area can !e considered fairly $ealthy is supported !y household o$nership of cars and trucks (al!eit lo$" and 4'% of households !eing in possession of li&estock and cattle (o6en". BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 2 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Fi+ure #7 >a :ara.a Im$%eme!t O&!er'(i$ 0 !0 20 30 0 "0 60 70 #0 $0 !00 P & o u g h * o r s e C a r t + h e e & , a r r o - . r u c / . r a c t o r C a r 0 o n / e y C a r 1 2 e n ':;le:ents P e r c e n t a g e )he earlier conclusion that -a Mara!a is less $ell off than -a Mogano is supported !y the implement o$nership figures in general lo$er than that of -a Mogano. )he ma*ority of houses in -a Mogano are !uilt of !rick (34" $hile traditional houses !uilt $ith a mi6ture of !rick +inc and mud can also !e found. 7f the 8; households inter&ie$ed 34 $ere in&ol&ed in farming acti&itiesA 02 practised su!sistence farming $hile 0 households indicated that they are commercial farmers. %n -a Mara!a 0' houses are !uilt of !rick $hile '0 are a mi6ture !et$een !rick an +inc. More traditional mud houses are also found in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano. %n -a Mara!a ;0 households practice su!sistence farming $hile ' households are commercial farmers. 5.2 A$$%ia!ce o&!er'(i$ %n -a Mogano the ma*ority of households o$n a radio more than 03% o$n a tele&ision and appro6imately 40% o$n a refrigerator. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 10 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e #7 A$$%ia!ce o&!er'(i$7 >a :o+a!o 0 !0 20 30 0 "0 60 70 #0 $0 'a(io .3 Fri(ge A;;liance P e r c e n t a g e %n -a Mara!a more than ,;% of households o$n tele&isions and a &ery high percentage of more than ,'% of households o$n refrigerators. Ta.%e 57 A$$%ia!ce o&!er'(i$7 >a :ara.a 0 !0 20 30 0 "0 60 70 #0 $0 'a(io .3 Fri(ge A;;liance P e r c e n t a g e 5ith regard to appliance o$nership the high le&el of o$nership of electrical appliances seems to indicate that the areas ha&e !een electrified for some time. )his is indeed the caseA -a Mara!a has !een electrified for 8 years $hile -a Mogano has !een electrified for a!out ; years. %t further indicates the relati&e $ealth of households since appliances such as refrigerators are e6pensi&e and normally o$nership in rural areas is not that high. All appliances in !oth areas $ere !ought the ma*ority on credit. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 11 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB %nterestingly o$nership of radio8s tele&isions as $ell as fridges is higher in -a Mara!a (identified as a poorer area" than in -a Mogano. )his seems to indicate that the area may not !e as poor initially assumed. 5.* E!er+y U'e 5.*.1 ;ai%y "ue%' u'e- $er area Lighting ?rom the !reakdo$n of energy sources for lighting in the t$o areas it can !e seen that significant differences e6ist. %n -a Mara!a the most important fuel for lighting is electricity $hile in -a Mogano it is candles. 7nce more this refutes the conclusion that -a Mara!a is less $ell off than -a Mogano. Both areas ha&e !een electrified for some time 8 and ; years respecti&ely. Despite the long period of ha&ing access to electricity candles are still the ma*or energy source for lighting. A possi!le e6planation offered for the phenomenon !y one of the enumerators is that people prefer candles and they are reluctant to change. Fi+ure 57 Fue% u'e "or %i+(ti!+7 >a :o+a!o 60% 2% !"% !% Can(&es Paraffin E&ectricity 4enerator Do $ood is reported !eing used for lighting in this area. 7nly one household made use of a generator. Fi+ure 07 Fue% u'e %i+(ti!+7 >a :ara.a 3% "% #7% "% Can(&es Paraffin E&ectricity +oo( BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 1' 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Do generators are reported as !eing used for lighting. -a Mara!a displays energy consumption characteristics of a richer areaA a high le&el of electricity use for lighting although the use of $ood for lighting purposes is higher in -a Mogano ('0%" than in -a Mara!a (3%". Cooking )he use of $ood for cooking purposes in -a Mogano is higher in !oth summer and $inter than in -a Mara!a. 9lectricity use for cooking is high in -a Mara!a (0,,% in summer and 4,0% in $inter respecti&ely". %t $ould seem that $ood fuel inter&entions $ould !e more appropriate in -a Mogano due to the higher incidence of fuel $ood use for cooking purposes. Ta.%e 07 E!er+y 'ource' u'e- "or coo,i!+ 8>a :o+a!o9 >a :o+a!o /oo- Para""i! E%ectricity 2oa% >a' Summer ,2 102 113 '4 '4 /i!ter ;14 2' ,2 2' '4 %n summer '01% of the households use only $ood as fuel for cooking and in $inter '4% of the households use $ood e6clusi&ely. Ta.%e 17 E!er+y 'ource' u'e- "or coo,i!+ 8>a :ara.a9 >a :ara.a /oo- Para""i! E%ectricity 2oa% >a' Summer 40; '03 0,, '4 0 /i!ter 401 108 4,0 14, 0 %n summer '4% of the households use only $ood and no other fuel source for cooking and in $inter '03% of the households use $ood e6clusi&ely. -a Mogano has a lo$ le&el of <(- (liEuefied petroleum gas" use as opposed to no gas use in -a Mara!a. %t is possi!le that electricity use has displaced <(- for cooking purposes in -a Mara!a. Both areas use coal for cooking purposes and !oth areas display a higher le&el of coal use in $inter consistent $ith increased space heating reEuirements during the colder period. -a Mara!a displays a more &aried pattern of fuels used for cooking purposes consistent $ith a lo$er le&el of reliance on electricity for cooking purposes. As concluded earlier -a Mogano may !e more appropriate for the dissemination of energy efficient $oodsto&es due the reliance on $oodfuel for cooking purposes. =o$e&er energy efficient sto&es could also !e $elcomed in -a Mara!a $here monetary sa&ings may!e more important than direct $oodfuel sa&ings. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 14 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Monthly fuel expenses %n -a Mogano ,,,% of households !uy $ood ($hether they !uy $ood only or $ood and other fuels" at an a&erage cost of :1;3.00 per month. =ouseholds spend on a&erage :40 per month on paraffin and :,0 on coal. Ta.%e 07 :o!t(%y "ue% ex$e!'e' i! >a :o+a!o7 Fue% ? o" (ou'e(o%-' .uyi!+ -i""ere!t "ue%' Ex$e!'e' $er mo!t( (araffin ,;8 :40 (appro6imately" -as 113 :;4 (appro6imately" 9lectricity 148 :1,0 Coal 0, :,0 5ood ,2 :1;3 5ood and other fuels 328 Com!ination !et$een gas paraffin electricity and coal 113 %n -a Mara!a 04% of households !uy $ood ($hether they !uy $ood only or $ood and other fuels" at an a&erage cost of :1,8 per month. Ta.%e 17 :o!t(%y "ue% ex$e!'e' i! >a :ara.a7 Fue% ? o" (ou'e(o%-' .uyi!+ -i""ere!t "ue%' Ex$e!'e' $er mo!t( (araffin 30 :00 -as 03 :20 9lectricity ,24 :23 Coal 21 :,0 5ood 03 :1,8 5ood and other fuels 48, Com!ination !et$een gas paraffin electricity and coal 428 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 10 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB %n -a Mogano more households !uy $ood than in -a Mara!a > ,,,% as opposed to 04%. )his is consistent $ith a significant higher le&el of $oodfuel use for cooking purposes in -a Mogano. =ouseholds spend more on paraffin in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano !oth areas spend a!out :,0 per month on coal $hile -a Mogano spends more on electricity than -a Mara!a. )his is strange since the le&el of electrical appliance o$nership is significantly higher in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano and also !ecause electricity is $idely used for cooking purposes in -a Mara!a. 7ne e6planation could !e that although a high le&el of electrical appliance o$nership is found it does not necessarily mean that all appliances are al$ays used. ?rom the a!o&ementioned ta!les it is also apparent that !oth areas spend similar amounts on $ood although $oodfuel use is lo$er in -a Mara!a than in -a Mogano. ?amilies in !oth these areas collect $ood in the natural &eldt !ut there is 10;% more $ood collection reported in -a Mogano than in -a Mara!a. Most of the families ha&e trees around their houses !ut it is mostly fruit and ornamental trees (not used for fire$ood". 5.*.2 ;ai%y -iet' ?ood cooked for the morning meal is the follo$ingA -a MoganoA (orridge )ea meat morogo &egeta!les or porridge and relish (in order of importance" others also eaten !ut seldomA !read ca!!age potatoes and eggs -a Mara!aA )ea (orridge. 7ther dishes are also eaten !ut seldomA meat rice samp and cereal. ?ood cooked for the afternoon mealA -a MoganoA (orridge &egeta!les meat. 7thers dishes are also eaten !ut seldomA tea morrogo soup porridge and relish -a Mara!aA porridge tea eggs. 7thers dishes are also eaten !ut seldomA meat &egeta!les ca!!age and morogo. ?ood cooked for the e&ening mealA -a MoganoA (orridge meat porridge and relish &egeta!les. 7thers dishes are also eaten !ut seldomA Morogo tea ca!!age -a Mara!aA (orridge meat &egeta!les rice morogo. 7thers dishes also eaten !ut seldomA tea !read fish soup 3,,% of households in -a Mogano eat their main meal in the e&ening 124% in the morning and ';;% in the afternoon. 83% of households in -a Mara!a ha&e their main meal in the e&ening 8% in the morning and 13% in the afternoon. Cooking Techniques BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 13 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB )he percentages $ere calculated !y di&iding !y 8; and 88 su!tracted !y the num!er of no responses in -a Mogano and -a Mara!a respecti&ely. %t does not take into account that some do not eat a specific meal or only made tea and did not mention it. Cooking techniEues used for the morning mealA -a MoganoA )he ma*ority !oil their food (;2%" and some steam (0%" or fry (0%" their food -a Mara!aA )he ma*ority !oil their food (3'%" and some fry (0%" their food. Cooking techniEues used for the afternoon mealA -a MoganoA )he ma*ority !oil their food (48%" and &ery little steam (,3%" fry (3'%" grill (4%" or !ake. -a Mara!aA )he ma*ority !oil their food ('8%" and 1'% fry their food some also steam and grill their food. Cooking techniEues used for the e&ening mealA -a MoganoA )his is the main meal and ,,% of food is !oiled 10% steamed 10% fried and some ste$ or !ake their food for this meal. -a Mara!aA )his is the main meal and 8;% of food is !oiled 43% fried and &ery little steam grill !ake or ste$ their food. Relationship between fuel used, food cooked and the cooking technique used Morning MealA -a MoganoA Fue%&oo- is !eing used ,13% of the time to prepare porridge (80% " $hich is !eing !oiled (20% of the time" as opposed to steaming follo$ed !y &egeta!les (0'3%" $hich is al$ays !oiled. )he ne6t most often used fuel is $ara""i! ('2'%"$hich is !eing used for porridge (,4'% of the time" and $hich is al$ays !oiled follo$ed !y tea (3',%" $hich is also al$ays !oiled. -a Mara!aA E%ectricity is !eing used 4,% of the time for tea (,11%" $hich is al$ays !oiled follo$ed !y porridge (';8%" $hich is also al$ays !oiled. )he ne6t most often used fuel is !oth "ue%&oo- or $ara""i! at 40% of the time. ?uel$ood is used for tea (,,;%" $hich is al$ays !oiled or porridge (',,%" $hich is also al$ays !oiled. (araffin is used for porridge (,0%" $hich is al$ays !oiled or tea (00%" $hich is also al$ays !oiled. Afternoon MealA -a MoganoA Fue%&oo- is !eing used ,,,% of the time for porridge (202%" $hich is al$ays !oiled follo$ed !y &egeta!les (30%" $hich is also al$ays !oiled". )he ne6t mostly used fuel is $ara""i! (13'%" $hich is !eing used for tea (,0%" $hich is al$ays !oiled or soup (00%" $hich is al$ays !oiled. -a Mara!aA Fue%&oo- a!- e%ectricity are !oth !eing used 444% of the time. ?uel$ood and electricity are used for porridge (303%" $hich is al$ays !oiled $hen fuel$ood is used and 844% !oiled as opposed to steaming in the case of electricity. )he ne6t most often used fuel is $ara""i! ('0'%" $hich BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 1, 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB is !eing used for &egeta!les (8;3%" $hich are !oiled (;10%" as opposed to steamed or porridge (30%" $hich is al$ays !oiled. 9&ening MealA -a MoganoA Fue%&oo- is !eing used ,04% of the time for porridge (88,%" $hich is !oiled (204%" opposed to steamed follo$ed !y &egeta!les (404%" $hich is !oiled (844%" opposed to ste$ed or fried. Fegeta!les are closely follo$ed !y meat (410%" $hich is !oiled (818%" opposed to ste$ed. )he ne6t most often used fuel is $ara""i! (12%" $hich is !eing used for porridge (202%" $hich is al$ays !oiled or &egeta!les (303%" $hich is also al$ays !oiled. -a Mara!aA E%ectricity is used 012% of the time for porridge (80,%" $hich is !eing al$ays !oiled or &egeta!les (482%" $hich is !eing !oiled (3;1%" opposed to fried. )he ne6t mostly used fuel is "ue%&oo- (480%" $hich is used for porridge (2;%" $hich is mostly !oiled or &egeta!les or meat !oth at ';4%. Fegeta!les are mostly !oiled some fried and meat is ,,;% fried opposed to ste$ed or !oiled. %t can therefore !e concluded that the o&er$helming cooking method in use is !oiling and that the method of cooking $ill !e suita!le for energy efficient $ood sto&es. %t can further !e concluded that enough cooking opportunities e6ist to *ustify the introduction of efficient sto&es i.e. households cook often (at least t$ice daily" as opposed to areas $here cooking may only take place once a day due to food scarcities energy shortages or la!our shortages (someone to actually do the cooking". <astly it is also clear that the type of food prepared (porridge &egeta!les meat" $ould !e suited to prepare on an energy efficient $ood sto&e. 5.*.* Pro.%em' a''ociate- &it( "ue% u'e )he responses in )a!le 8 represent the opinions of community mem!ers regarding the ad&antages and disad&antages of &arious fuels. A summary of ad&antages and disad&antages associated $ith the use of alternati&e fuels $hen fuel $ood is scarce is pro&ided !elo$A BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 1; 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e 37 A-va!ta+e' a!- -i'a-va!ta+e' o" a%ter!ative "ue%' "or .ot( area' Fue% A-va!ta+e ;i'a-va!ta+e E%ectricity Do smoke 96pensi&e 9asy to cook $ith (o$er failure Muick Dangerous to children Cheaper Con&enient 9fficient :eadily a&aila!le Sa&es time =ealthy Para""i! Done Done Sa&es time 96pensi&e 9asy to o!tain Smelling <ess e6pensi&e Slo$ Con&enient Smoke Can use if it rains Dot safe for children ?lama!le %tch eyes Cause headache >a' ?ast Difficult to o!tain Con&enient 96pensi&e Smokeless C7' is dangerous Sa&es time =ot 6ioma'' 8mea%y core@co&-u!+9 9asy to o!tain Burns Euickly ?ree 7nly a&aila!le after har&est =ot Smoke 9fficient Smelling Dot enough Short lifespan 2oa% 5arm house Smoke <ess e6pensi&e 96pensi&e Burns slo$ly Difficult to o!tain 9fficient Messy MultipurposeA iron !ake cook $arm house C7' is dangerous ?rom )a!le 8 it can !e seen that electricity is regarded as ha&ing more ad&antages as disad&antages. %t is regarded as clean (no smoke" Euick to use con&enient efficient and readily a&aila!le. (araffin is regarded as less e6pensi&e easier to o!tain and con&enient !ut $ith the disad&antages of !eing smelly causing itchy eyes headaches and not !eing safe for children. )he lo$ le&el of gas use could !e e6plained !y the responses that it is difficult to o!tain and e6pensi&e. Coal seems to !e popular !ecause it is a multi#purpose fuel !ecause you can iron !ake cook and $arm the house $ith it. %t is ho$e&er also difficult to o!tain messy and the C7 ' emissions can !e dangerous. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 18 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB %t is interesting to o!ser&e that communities seem fairly $ell informed a!out the associated dangers and dra$ !acks of the &arious fuels in use. )his can form an e6cellent !ase from $hich to raise further a$areness regarding health and safety issues associated $ith fuel use as $ell information dissemination regarding the use of fuel#efficient sto&es. Fi+ure 17 ? 4ou'e(o%-' i!-icati!+ t(at "ue% &oo- i' 'carce7 >a :o+a!o #"% !"% 5es 6o %n -a Mogano of the 83% of the households $ho feel that fuel $ood is scarce 40% think that fuel $ood $ill also !e scarce in the future $hile only 8% of those saying that fuel $ood is not scarce currently think that it $ill !e scarce in the future. %n -a Mogano people use paraffin and !uy $ood in order to cope $ith the fuel $ood scarcity although the use of gas and !iomass i.e. co$ dung are other alternati&es. %t is interesting to note that fuel $ood scarcity is associated more $ith difficulties in accessing fuel $ood i.e. to $alk '#4 hours to collect $ood e&ery second day. )o address this .scarcity/ people !uy $ood and therefore eliminate the need to $alk and collect $ood there!y eliminating the .scarcity/. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age 12 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e )7 Strate+ie' u'e- .y maAority 835?9 o" (ou'e(o%-' i! >a :o+a!o to co$e &it( "ue% &oo- 'carcity Strate+y Num.er o" re'$o!'e' Do nothing 4 N 8 no responses gi&en Jse electricity 3 Alternati&e fuels (response recei&ed" 1 Buy more $ood 2 (lant trees ' Jse gas 3 Jse coal 0 Jse paraffin 40 Jse !iomass (mealy cores co$ dung" , Collect $ood far 4 7ther (use $ood $hen necessary ne$ technologies cook less use green $ood" 0 DB. Some of the respondents ga&e more than one strategy to cope $ith fuel$ood scarcity. Alternati&e fuels is the response gi&en !y the respondents and could imply using any other fuel e6cept $ood. Because $ood is not so a&aila!le to collect !uying $ood is percei&ed !y the respondents as a $ay of coping $ith fuel$ood scarcity. Fi+ure 37 ? 4ou'e(o%-' i!-icati!+ "ue% &oo- i' 'carce7 >a :ara.a 6"% 3"% 5es 6o %n -a Mara!a '4% of the ,3% of the households $ho feel that fuel$ood is scarce currently think that it $ill also !e scarce in the future $hile '1% of those saying that fuel $ood is not scarce currently think that it $ill !e scarce in the future. Ta.%e 107 Strate+ie' u'e- .y maAority 805?9 o" (ou'e(o%-' i! >a :ara.a to co$e &it( "ue% &oo- 'carcity Strate+y Num.er o" re'$o!'e' BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '0 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Do nothing 11 N , no strategies gi&en Jse electricity 14 Alternati&e fuels 0 Buy more $ood 4 (lant trees 1 Jse gas 1 Jse coal 4 Jse paraffin 1' Jse !iomass (mealy cores co$ dung" 4 Collect $ood far 1 7ther (use $ood $hen necessary ne$ technologies cook less use green $ood" ; DB. Some of the respondents ga&e more than one strategy to cope $ith fuel $ood scarcity. Alternati&e fuels is the response gi&en !y the respondents and could imply using any other fuel e6cept $ood. Because $ood is not so a&aila!le to collect !uying $ood is percei&ed !y the respondents as a $ay of coping $ith fuel$ood scarcity. ?orm the responses in )a!le 2 and )a!le 10 it is clear that the most important strategy for people to cope $ith fuel $ood shortages is to make use of different fuels i.e. fuel s$itching. Multiple fuel use or the practice that utilises a range of fuels and appliances at the same time or interchangea!ly !ecause of their a&aila!ility and accessi!ility is the norm in most de&eloping households. )he use of multiple fuels or .fuel s$itching/ is mainly influenced !y sur&i&al concerns. Multiple fuel use is complicated !y the fact that appliances and fuels operate in systems. (oor households ha&e to spend limited income o&er a range of necessities of $hich energy is *ust one indicating specific household e6penditure priorities. %rregular and unrelia!le sources of income necessitate energy use strategies that can cope $ith &arying income patterns # $hen income allo$s more money can !e spent on paraffin for e6ample > $hen income is e6hausted poor households re&ert !ack to $ood. All energy sources are therefore considered in terms of their utility and afforda!ility. 5.*.# A&are!e'' o" im$rove- 'tove' %n -a Mogano a high le&el of a$areness a!out solar cookers $ere found as opposed to a lo$er le&el of a$areness regarding other impro&ed sto&es. )he reason for this may !e that a solar cooker demonstration $as conducted *ust !efore the field $ork $as completed and solar cookers may therefore still ha&e !een in the forefront of people8s mindsA BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '1 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e 117 A&are!e'' o" -i""ere!t im$rove- 'tove' 8>a :o+a!o9 Ty$e o" 'tove ? a&are!e'' So%ar coo,er' 04% Pro.ec 'tove' 0% Tur.o 0% :a%i 0% >e% '% 6raBier '% DBO (ro!ec sto&es refer to any sto&es associated $ith the pro*ect %n response to the Euestion $hat an ideal impro&ed sto&e should look like 20% of households in -a Mogano prefer a sto&e that is made of metal 1'% prefer clay and 1'% prefer cast iron. 7n a&erage households preferred that 4 pots could !e used on the sto&e. 7ther important characteristics that the households indicated the sto&es should ha&e $ere the follo$ingA !e a!le to !ake !e dura!le and strong ha&e an alarm and handles. 7n a&erage households $ill pay :08, for an impro&ed sto&e $ith some $ho $ant it for free and another $ho $ould pay as much as :;000. )hey e6pect to !uy the sto&es from (ro!ec solar cooker agents local shops supermarket or furniture stores. Fi+ure )7 I-ea% im$rove- 'tove7 >a :o+a!o 0 !0 20 30 0 "0 60 70 #0 $0 !00 M u s t B e P o r t a , & e M u s t + a r m * o u s e P r o v i ( e 7 i g h t P r e % a r e ( C o o / 1 u t s i ( e S % a c e C o o / 1 u t s i ( e P r e % a r e ( M o v e S t o v e Characteristics P e r c e n t a g e )his can !e compared to sto&es used e&ery dayA BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '' 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e 127 Stove' u'e- -ai%y i! >a :o+a!o Ty$e o" StoveC Ty$e o" Pot'D Num.er o" $ot' SiBe o" $ot' :or!i!+ A"ter!oo! Eve!i!+ :or!i!+ A"ter!oo! Eve!i!+ (araffin $ick stro&e Aluminium 1@' ' ' '@4 '@4 '@4 (rimus Aluminium 4#legged cast iron pot 7pen fire 4#legged cast iron pot Coal Aluminium =ot (late Aluminium 9lectrical Alumium -as Aluminium 4#legged cast iron pot P%n order of pots used most (responses such as saucepans aluminium hart stainless steel metal are all categori+ed under aluminium pots" Q%n order of sto&es used most %n -a Mara!a a$areness a!out impro&ed sto&es@solar cookers $as as follo$sA Ta.%e 1*7 A&are!e'' a.out -i""ere!t im$rove- 'tove' 8>a :ara.a9 Ty$e o" 'tove ? a&are!e'' So%ar coo,er' ,'3% Pro.ec 'tove' 0% Tur.o 1'3% :a%i 4;3% >e% 0% 6raBier 0% /oo-'tove 1,,% %n -a Mara!a ;0% of households prefer metal sto&es 02% prefer clay and 1'% prefer cast iron sto&es. 7n a&erage households prefer that the sto&e must !e a!le to use 0 pots. 7ther important characteristics that the households think the sto&es should ha&e is !e a!le to !ake dura!le ha&e handles and it should !e light. 7n a&erage the households $ill pay :'8' for an impro&ed sto&es $ith some $ho $ant it for free and one person $ill pay up to :1'00 for an impro&ed sto&e or solar cooker. )hey e6pect to !uy the sto&es from local shops (ieters!urg a factory supermarkets a dealer in Rohannes!urg the pension fund points or any$here. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '4 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Fi+ure 107 I-ea% im$rove- 'tove7 >a :ara.a 0 !0 20 30 0 "0 60 70 #0 $0 !00 M u s t B e P o r t a , & e M u s t + a r m * o u s e P r o v i ( e 7 i g h t P r e % a r e ( C o o / 1 u t s i ( e P r e % a r e ( M o v e S t o v e S % a c e C o o / 1 u t s i ( e Characteristics P e r c e n t a g e )his can !e compared to sto&es used e&ery day Ta.%e 1#7 Stove' u'e- -ai%y i! >a :ara.a Ty$e o" StoveC Ty$e o" Pot'D Num.er o" $ot' SiBe o" $ot' :or!i!+ A"ter!oo ! Eve!i!+ :or!i!+ A"ter!oo ! Eve!i!+ =ot (late Aluminium 9namel ' 1 ' '@4 ' 1@' 9lectrical Aluminium 9namel -lass Cast %ron (rimus Aluminium 9namel (araffin Aluminium 9namel 7pen fire 4#legged cast iron pot Cast %ron Aluminium 9namel Coal Aluminium 9namel -as Aluminium 9namel P%n order of pots used most (responses such as saucepans aluminium hart stainless steel metal are all categori+ed under aluminium pots" Q%n order of sto&es used most BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '0 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 5ith regard to risks associated $ith impro&ed sto&es the follo$ing summary can !e pro&idedA Ta.%e 157 Ri',' a''ociate- &it( im$rove- 'tove' 8>a :o+a!o97 Stove ri', re'$o!'e' ? o" re'$o!'e' Do response 2' Do risk 1;' )ampering 04; )heft 0;1 7ther ,2 Ta.%e 107 Ri',' a''ociate- &it( im$rove- 'tove' 8>a :ara.a9 Stove ri', re'$o!'e' ? o" re'$o!'e' Do response 10'% Do risk 401 )ampering '03 )heft 033 7ther 40 ?rom )a!le 13 and )a!le 1, the potential of theft emerges as the !iggest potential percei&ed risk associated $ith impro&ed sto&es. )he risk could !e addressed during demonstrations and a$areness raising programmes !y informing people on safe storage tips as $ell as highlighting the point that often people are at home $hen cooking takes place and therefore the risk can !e minimised. (ro!lems associated $ith the use of other sto&es $ere reported as follo$sA Ta.%e 117 Pro.%em' a''ociate- &it( ot(er 'tove' 8>a :o+a!o97 Stove Pro.%em' 9lectricity )oo e6pensi&e po$er failure consume more energy (araffin Smell e6pensi&e smoke flames -as 96pensi&e Coal Scarce colouring of chimneys and !ricks consumes too much $ood 7pen fire Smoke ?lame sto&e Dangerous can !urn BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '3 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB Ta.%e 137 Pro.%em' a''ociate- &it( ot(er 'tove' 8>a :o+a!o9 Stove Pro.%em' 9lectricity Maintenance e6pensi&e electricity e6pensi&e hotplate e6pand and not dura!le po$er failure cracks (araffin 96pensi&e smell smoke itch eyes old sto&e e6pand flames -as C7 ' emissions gas leaks dangerous 7pen fire Smoke itch eyes $ood sometimes $et $ood far $ood scarce !urn children smoke damage eyes smell messy ash Coal 96pensi&e smoke rust )a!les 13 and 1, a!o&e pro&ide &alua!le information that can !e used in the information dissemination campaign. %t is clear that smoke and related health pro!lems are ma*or issues. )he health !enefits of the impro&ed sto&es should therefore !e highlighted. 5.*.5 4ea%t( i''ue' %n -a Mogano 010% of the households did not respond to the health related Euestions. 7f those $ho did respond ;03% said that smoke in the house is a pro!lem. )his is mainly !ecause smoke makes the eyes itch red and painful and further causes headaches and is inhaled (colds and flu8s are also reported". 03% of the responses indicated that smoke causes illness under $hich eye pro!lems and flu are the most reported (others include headache coughing and !ronchitis". 43% of the responses indicated that smoke is a pro!lem and causes illness. %n -a Mara!a 401% of the households did not respond to the health related Euestions. 7f those $ho responded 23% said that smoke in the house is a pro!lem. )he reasons gi&en are mainly !ecause smoke makes the eyes itch red or painful the smoke smells and causes coughing (other reasons reported are causes headaches and flu". ;8% of the responses indicated that smoke causes illness under $hich headaches and eye pro!lems are the most reported (others include coughing !lindness and flu". ;'% of the responses indicated that smoke is a pro!lem and it causes illness. Again the high le&el of pro!lems associated $ith smoke could !e used to the !enefit of impro&ed sto&es during the information dissemination stage. %t also illustrates that households are a$are of the negati&e side effects of dirty and unhealthy fuels and that they percei&e it as a pro!lem. %mpro&ed cook sto&es should therefore not only !e offered as an ans$er to fuel $ood shortages !ut also as an ans$er to health related pro!lems associated $ith the use of other fuels. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age ', 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0. 2o!c%u'io!' a!- Recomme!-atio!' Conclusions and recommendations can !e formulated regarding the follo$ing issuesA Socio-economic issues Both areas seem to !e in some$hat !etter off than rural areas in general in South AfricaL Both areas ha&e a high pre&alence of male headed householdsL Decision making responsi!ility is fairly mi6ed !et$een men and $omen indicating a dissemination approach taking strong cognisance of gender issuesL Sources of income in !oth areas are mi6ed and seem to !e more sta!le than in rural areas in general > a smaller dependence on pensions for e6ample is noted in !oth areasL =igh le&els of formal employment $ere found (,'% and 004% respecti&ely"L Both areas are supported !y outside contri!utions ((43,% and ';4% respecti&ely"L =ouseholds in !oth areas reported o$nership of cars and trucks as $ell as li&estock and cattle supporting the conclusion that !oth areas are fairly !etter off than rural areas in general in South Africa. ?rom the a!o&ementioned conclusions it can !e recommended that impro&ed sto&es should !e introduced in !oth areas since !oth areas seem to !e in a position to a!sor! ne$ technology or inter&entions. )his is opposed to some rural areas $here households $ere found to !e so poor that they could not a!sor! additional appliances or inter&entions e&en $hen the inter&entions $ere aimed at impro&ing their situation. )his lead to the conclusion that households need to !e at a threshold le&el of sur&i&al those !elo$ the threshold le&el $ill !e una!le to respond to inter&entions and it could e&en impo&erish them further and place a drain on their already scarce resources. ?or e6ample $hen solar cookers are introduced into a household the impact $ould !e limited $hen the household is so poor that they can not afford to !uy food to cook. %t can further !e recommended that !oth males and females should !e targeted during a demonstration or a$areness#raising programme since there is s high le&el of males present in !oth areas as $ell as a high percentage of male#headed households. ?urther it $as clear that $omen and men take decisions a!out fuels and appliances especially e6pensi&e appliances. Both should therefore !e targeted to recei&e information regarding impro&ed sto&es. ppliance owne!ship Fery high le&els of o$nership of e6pensi&e electrical appliances $ere found possi!ly indicating adeEuate disposa!le income to purchase appliances as $ell as the desire to o$n appliances. )his is a positi&e indicator for the programme since it could indicate that ne$ appliances such as impro&ed sto&es could !e $ell accepted and integrated into the householdL =igh le&els of o$nership of other cooking appliances $ere also found such as coal sto&es paraffin sto&es and gas sto&esL BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '; 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB )he high incidence of radio o$nership should !e considered $hen designing an a$areness programmeL A high le&el of a$areness $as found regarding the negati&e effects of sto&es using fuels such as paraffin $ood and coal especially health pro!lems such as smoke itchy eyes colds and fluL A &ery high le&el of a$areness regarding solar cookers $ere foundL =ouseholds displayed their $illingness o purchase an impro&ed sto&e and they $ere $illing to pay :08, and :'8' on a&erage per area. ?rom the a!o&e it can !e concluded that households are $illing to purchase and use appliances and that impro&ed sto&es $ould !e purchased. %t is recommended that impro&ed sto&es !e marketed as an additional cooking option i.e. e6tending the range of cooking appliances already in use !y the household and therefore e6panding choice. %t is further recommended that the high le&el of a$areness regarding solar cookers should !e e6panded to also include other impro&ed sto&es. )he !est $ay to achie&e this $ould !e through e6tensi&e demonstrations of all impro&ed sto&e types. "uel use Significant differences regarding the use of fuels for lighting purposes $ere recorded > one area uses mostly candles $hile the other area uses mostly electricityL 5ood is used in !oth areas !ut it is used more e6tensi&ely in -a MoganoL 5ood is !oth collected and !oughtL Both areas e6perienced fuel $ood as !eing scarceL -a Mogano spends more on electricity per month than -a Mogano although -a Mogano used less electricity for cooking and lighting purposes and o$ned fe$er electrical appliances. Do adeEuate e6planation could !e found for this. Boiling is the most often used method of cookingL 9lectricity is regarded as a con&enient fuel to useL 7ther fuels are associated $ith health and safety risksL =ouseholds cope $ith fuel $ood shortages !y s$itching to other more a&aila!le and afforda!le fuels such as paraffinL %t is recommended that impro&ed sto&es !e disseminated $ith the message that it can also address health issues and not only fuel $ood scarcity. )he high le&el of a$areness of health pro!lems associated $ith fuel use can form an e6cellent !asis for further $ork and the dissemination of impro&ed $ood sto&es. Conclusions therefore seem to indicate that !oth study areas are generally $ealthy $ith a high le&el of appliance o$nership. =o$e&er $ood fuel use especially for cooking purposes is still high and $ood fuel is considered to !e scarce in !oth areas. =ouseholds e6perience additional pro!lems associated $ith the use of $ood fuel as an energy source as $ell as pro!lems $ith the use of con&entional energy sources. )he BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting (roB9C (age '8 9nergy Baseline Sur&eyA -a Mara!a and -a Mogano BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB com!ination of $ood fuel scarcity continued high le&els of $ood fuel use a$areness regarding pro!lems associated $ith $ood fuel use and an indication of the potential of disposa!le income to !e spent on appliances seems to indicate positi&e conditions for the implementation of an impro&ed sto&e programme. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 6i.%io+ra$(y 1. De&elopment Bank of Southern Africa. 1228. %nfrastructureA a foundation for de&elopment. De&elopment :eport 1228. '. May R. 1224. :ural 9nergy Consumption in Datal@S$aCulu. Department of Minerals and 9nergyA (retoria. 4. )hom C. 122;. :ural 9nergy Jse. 9nergy for De&elopment :esearch CentreA Cape )o$n. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting '2 ANNEX 1 Questionnaire BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 40 )$&SE)$" ENERG! S&R#E! P'E%ERSB&RG REG'$N Pro+ramme "or 6ioma'' E!er+y 2o!'ervatio! 8Pro.ec9 Eue'tio!!aire !r.7 Area7 ;ate7 >a :o+a!o >a:ara.a I!tervie&er I!'tructio!'7 >oo- -ay 'ir@ma-am. :y !ame i' FFFF.. 8'tate your !ame9< I re$re'e!t Pro.ec. /e &ou%- %i,e to a''i't you i! -etermi!i!+ &(at t(e "ue% u'e i' o" (ou'e(o%-' i! t(e Pieter'.ur+ re+io! to im$rove t(e u'e o" "ue%. T(i' i!"ormatio! &i%% .e treate- &it( t(e 'tricte't co!"i-e!ce a!- u'e- "or re'earc( $ur$o'e' o!%y. :ay I a', you a "e& Gue'tio!'H 1. -eneral informationA Dame of inter&ie$er Dame of respondent Address of respondent -ender of respondent Male ?emale (osition in household (grandparent parent child" 1.1 %s there anyone li&ing in your house $ho is formally employedT Ues ( " Do ( " 1.' %f no $hat other source of income do you ha&e (farming selling produce etc."T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 41 2. 4ou'e(o%- c(aracteri'tic' '.1 5ould you tell us a!out the si+e and mem!ership of your family li&ing in your houseT :em.er Num.er A-u%t' Men 5omen 2(i%-re! (under 18" Boys -irls Tota% '.' %s there any!ody else not li&ing in the house currently !ut $ho also contri!utes to the house (contri!ute money food etc." Ues ( " Do ( " '.'.1 5ho is the person(s" (gender and relationship to the respondent"T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB '.'.' 5hat does the person(s" contri!ute (food soap money"T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB '.4 5ho is the head of the householdT (name gender" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB '.0 5hich of the follo$ing does the respondent ha&eT (inter&ie$er to see for themsel&es (lough =orse Cart 5heel !arro$ )ruck )ractor Car Donkey@=orse car 76en :adio )F ?ridge Brick house (type" cement mud face !rick Cinc house )raditional house BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 4' Commercial farming Su!sistence farming BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 44 *. E!er+y co!'ume- .y t(e (ou'e(o%- 4.1 5hat type of fuel do you use the most for cooking lighting space heating@cooling and $ater heatingT Ty$e o" "ue%@ e!er+y 'ource u'e- /(at i' t(e "ue% or e!er+y 'ource u'e- "or Summer 5inter Most used 7ther fuels Most used 7ther fuels Cooking <ighting Space heating Space cooling 5ater heating 4.' 5hat else do you use energy for (traditional feasts appliances entertainment"T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 40 4.4 5hat cleaning or other appliances ()F fridge radio" do you ha&e $hich uses fuel@energyT ($ood gas paraffin electricity coal" 4.4.1 Appliance 1 ' 4 0 3 , ; 4.4.' =o$ much did the appliance costT 4.4.4 5here did you !uy the applianceT(tpe store 4.4.0 =o$ did you pay for the applianceT 4.4.3 )ype of fuel@energy used !y appliance 4.4., Amount of fuel@ energy (k5 !undle of $ood litres@!ottle of paraffin etc." used per $eek 4.4.; =o$ many times a day $eek or month do you use the applianceT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 43 #. E!er+y 'u$$%y 0.1 =o$ much fuel do you !uy (gas paraffin or electricity" for ho$ long does it lastT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0.' %s $ood collected for any other use than fuel$oodT Ues ( " Do ( " %f yes 0.4 ?or $hat other purposes (other than cooking space#heating@cooling lighting $ater heating" is $ood collectedT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0.0 =o$ much of the $ood collected is used for fuel$oodT Fery little ( " =alf of it ( " Most of the $ood ( " 0.3 5hat $ould !est descri!e the appearance of fuel$ood collected (tick off" Summer 5inter <ogs (more than 40cm diameter" )$igs (shorter than 00 cm" Seed pods :oots Bark of trees )ree stumps (part of tree left after has !een chopped" -reen !ranches of li&e trees Dead !ranches of li&e trees 7ther 0., =o$ often does someone collect fuel$ood for your house in summer and in $inter and in $hat EuantitiesT SummerBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 5interBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0.; 5ho collects the $oodT ( " Adult ( " Child 0.8 5here do you collect $ood ($oodlot natural &eldt" T =o$ far is itT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 4, 0.2 =o$ long does it take to collect the $oodT ( " =alf hour ( " =our ( " =our and a half ( " )$o hours ( " More than t$o hours 0.10 Do you e&er !uy $oodT Ues ( " Do ( " %f yes ho$ much do you !uy (head load truck load !akkie load $heel!arro$ load" at $hat price ho$ often (inter&ie$er to standardise ans$er in days per $eek"T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0.11 5here do you !uy $oodT (type of store". =o$ far is the sourceT Descri!e BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 5 T(e ,itc(e! ute!'i%' a!- coo,i!+ $ro"i%e' 3.1 5hat cooking method do you use for most of your food (frying !oiling steaming"T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3.' 5hat type of sto&e(s" do you ha&e or do you use open fireT %f more than one $hich is used the mostTBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3.4 ?or ho$ long ha&e you had the mostly used sto&eT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3.0 =o$ did you get the sto&e(s"T Stove 4o& -i- you +et itH 3.3 =o$ much did you pay for the sto&e(s"T Stove Payme!t met(o- BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 4; 3., 5hat pro!lems ha&e you e6perienced $ith your sto&e(s"T Stove@O$e! "ire Pro.%em' 3.; Are you satisfied $ith your most used sto&e@open fireT Ues ( " Do ( " 5hyT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3.8 5hen do you cook your main mealT Morning ( " Afternoon ( " 9&ening ( " 3.2 =o$ many times do you cook per dayT BBBBBBBBBBBBBB 3.10 =o$ many times do you cook per $eekT BBBBBBBBBBBB 3.11 Time o" coo,i!+ Morning Afternoon 9&ening )ype of sto&e@ open fire =o$ many pots used at time of cooking 5hat si+es are the pots (litres no." )ype of food usually cooked )ype of fuel used 5hat techniEue is used (!oiling frying !aking grilling"T =o$ long does the cooking take (appro6imate"T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 48 3.1' 5hat type of pots do you use for the sto&e(s" (material"T Stove Ty$e o" $ot' 0 2o$i!+ &it( "ue%&oo- 'carcity ,.1 Do you find that fuel$ood is scarceT Ues ( " Do ( " %f no continue $ith ,.4 ,.' %f yes $hat do you do (strategies" to cope $ith the fuel$ood scarcityT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ,.4 Do you plant trees for fuel$oodT ( " Ues ( " Do 5hat type of treesTBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ,.0 Do you plant trees for any other purposes (shading etc"T ( " Ues ( " Do 5hat type of treesT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ,.3 5hat other fuels do you use to cope $ith the scarcityT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ,., 5hat are the ad&antages and disad&antages of the alternati&e fuelsT A%ter!ative "ue% A-va!ta+e' ;i'a-va!ta+e' BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 42 ,.; %f no do you think fuel$ood might !ecome scarce in the futureT Ues ( " Do ( " (Do not ans$er ,.; and ,.8 if the respondent replied yes at ,.1" ,.8 5hat $ould you do if fuel$ood !ecome scarce in futureT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ,.2 Do you kno$ of any specific cooking techniEues ($ays" that you could apply to sa&e fuel$oodT ( " Ues ( " Do %f yes $hat techniEuesT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 1 Im$rove- 'tove' ;.1 5ho makes decisions a!out !uying fuel@energy sourcesT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.' 5ho makes the decision to !uy ne$ cooking appliances ($hat is the person8s position in the household" $hen :'00 or underTBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB $hen a!o&e :'00BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.4 %f it is possi!le to ha&e a sto&e that can sa&e on fuel$ood $hat must it look like and $hat must it !e a!le to doT ;.4.1 =o$ many pots must it !e a!le to useT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.4.' 5hat material should it !e made of (clay metal"TBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.4.4 Must you !e a!le to carry it aroundT Ues ( " Do ( " ;.4.0 Must it $arm your houseT Ues ( " Do ( " BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 00 ;.4.3 Must it !e a!le to pro&ide lightT Ues ( " Do ( " ;.4., 5ould you !e prepared to cook outsideT Ues ( " Do ( " ;.4.; 5hat $ould the risk !e to lea&e the cooker outside during the dayT )ampering ( " )heft ( " 7ther ( " Do risk ( " ;.4.8 5hat other characteristics should an impro&ed sto&e ha&eT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.0 Are you a$are of any impro&ed sto&es or solar cookers in your &illage or district if so $hich onesT ( " Ues ( " Do BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.3 =o$ much are you prepared to pay for an impro&ed cook sto&eT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;., 5here do you e6pect to !uy an impro&ed sto&eT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ;.; 5ould there !e enough space to cook outsideT Ues ( " Do( " ;.8 5ould you !e prepared to mo&e the cooker sometimes during the cooking processT Ues ( " Do ( " 3 E!er+y a!- 4ea%t( 8.1 5hat are the common diseases or ailments attacking people in your &illage or districtT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 01 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 0' 8.' %s smoke in the kitchen a pro!lemT Ues ( " Do ( " %f yes or $hyT BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 8.4 Do people !ecome ill !ecause of smoke in the kitchenT ( " Ues ( " Do Descri!e their symptoms. BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBB 8.0 Do you attempt to reduce smokeT ( " Ues Do %f yes ho$T BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 8.3 =a&e the people in your house had any illnesses in the last si6 monthsT ( " Ues ( " Do %f yes descri!e the symptoms BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 8., Did you ha&e to use more energy to care for ill people at homeT (any special meals cook more often put on more lights more !oiling of $ater" BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB (almer De&elopment Consulting 04
Assessment of Collective Bargaining and Industrial Conflictmanagement in Nigerian Universities A Study of Federaluniversity of Technology, (Fut) Minna PDF