In this exhibition Ebbe Stub Wittrup suspends the rules of reality in
an exploration of lifes enigmatic layers.
11 FEBRUARY - 1 APRIL 2012 ESSAY & INTERVIEW PLEASE JOIN US FOR THE PREVIEW 10 FEBRUARY, 5-8PM EBBE STUB WITTRUP ESSAY THE VOICE OF THINGS The Existence of the Possible By Anna Holm, Overgaden !"# %&'( )#*+(,-+. (",/0 1# 2*/ #34 5#6,#/2# ,' ("# %7'(#6,&+'8 Albert Einstein, 1930 The question of what is real has been debated throughout the entire history of humanity: Is it what our senses tell us, or is there a world beyond what we can immediately perceive? In this philosophical field, Ebbe Stub Wittrup explores lifes enigmatic layers by highlighting phenomena and material drawn from the periphery of culture. His work emphasizes the otherness of reality which, as the art historian Rune Gade has put it, runs like an esoteric undercurrent beneath the realistic subject matter. Since the late 1990s, Stub Wittrup has been extending his photographic prac- tice, in a movement from a neo- realistic snapshot aesthetics to a more conceptual sensibility with historical and literary dimensions. In the solo exhibition !"# 9&,2# &- !",/0', this movement finds expres- sion in a cross-media field in which fiction, mythology and theosophy are interwoven with optical and co- lour-psychological phenomena.
The front exhibition room on the ground floor of Overgaden lies in semi-darkness. A thick, white cur- tain conceals the windows facing the canal, and blocks the view of everyday life on Torvegade; a thea- trical gesture that signals that we are about to step into a world in which the usual concepts of reality are suspended. Here, the film instal- lation :*67 ;&'# < = >.*7 ,/ !"6## =2(' (2011) is presented, which like previous works by Ebbe Stub Wittrup is based on a specific place shrouded in myth. This time it is the rugged, storm-swept islands of the Hebrides, which both in local tales and in the world of fiction have been associated with mysterious disappearances, including those de- scribed by the Scottish writer J.M. Barrie in the play from which the in- stallation takes its name. The play, written in 1920, is partly set on the island of Harris, where the storys protagonist, Mary Rose, disappears into a timeless parallel world; first as a child, and later as an adult, where after several decades she re- turns without having aged, and with no recollection of what has tran- spired. On the basis of these sto- ries, the work, consisting of three black and white 16mm films, medi- tates on possible dimensions other than those we can see with the na- ked eye. In displaced film sequen- ces, gothic scenes of desolate land- scapes and abandoned houses fade into lingering images of the mouth of the legendary Fingals Cave. The cave opens up in the cliff like a por- tal to another world, and is reputed in Celtic mythology, and later in- theosophy, to possess supernatu- ral powers. From the third film strip, razor-sharp images of objects as- sociated with occult lore appear: An old book filled with closely packed, looping handwriting and a large, lu- minous crystal, which in an insis- tent materiality have a hyper-real appearance against the black back- ground. Fluctuating between pas- sive recording and the metaphori- cal, the films' levels of reality and fiction are woven into each other in a suggestive universe of intense suspense, which opens up the con- cept of reality in an ontological va- cillation between the perceived and the imagined.
In the work !"# ?/@,*/ ;&5# !6,2A (2011), the perspective shifts from the fantastic to the illusory. The trick is reputed to be one of the worlds oldest illusions, but in fact it can only be dated back to 1890, when it was first described by the journalist John Elbert Wilkie in the Chicago Tribune. Shortly afterwards the story was exposed in the same newspaper as pure fiction, but the trick had already taken hold in the public consciousness, and has since been performed in several places in India. The product of one mans imagination has thereby become a collective reality, which, like myth, in the perspective of the semioti- cian Roland Barthes, has forgot- ten its own historical genesis. In the work, which consists of a video and an object, Stub Wittrup does not address the tricks ideological and historical implications, but instead attempts to approach the myth as a formal figure. A rope rises up from the floor in the middle of the exhibi- tion space and floats in the air like a physical impossibility, which makes the trick both concrete and abstract by reducing it to a primordial form found in several cultures. The same oscillation between form and con- tent is present in the video work, in which the eye is drawn into the hypnotic compositions of ascending and descending ropes of varying sizes. The film is designed like a M- bius strip that continues indefinitely through a mirror image of the same recordings. In an unbroken move- ment, outside becomes inside, like a pictorialisation of the nature of the myth and the viewers encoun- ter with the artwork. The mean- ing arises in an intersubjective tape loop of physical and mental reality, slipping imperceptibly into itself like the outer and inner sides of the M- bius strip.
The optical illusion is given more concrete form in the work B.*'' C+)# (2011), which brings the view- ers own senses into play. On top of a completely transparent cube rests an identical cube of polarised glass that alters the frequency of the light and changes its phase, so that it changes character, depend- ing on the perspective. Seen from one location you see right through the grey box, while from another it closes up into a solid black form. In a particular position the work be- haves like a so-called Necker cube, in which the observer experiences a switch in the perception of what is seen. Suddenly the box is oriented differently. The side which was pre- viously in front is now at the back. On the immediate level, the work calls forth associations with the aesthetics of minimalism and its in- terest in the phenomenology of the artwork, but rather than empha- sizing the objects independence, Stub Wittrup challenges the con- cept of the object as a stable phe- nomenon. Like the other works, the cube shifts between outer and inner space, between transparency and opacity, whereby viewers in addi- tion to being made aware of their own role in the act of perception find that their faith in the seen is shaken. In this way, the work opens up a critique of the rational Western understanding of the world, linked as it is to an empirical tradition and the prioritisation of the sense of sight as a channel of objective in- formation. The subjective nature of sensory perception is further accentuated in the final series of works in the ex- hibition, which reflects upon colour phenomena as a bridge to the un- conscious. These works are based on the controversial personality test formulated by the Swiss psy- choanalyst Max Lscher in 1948, which was used to identify psycho- logical profiles on the basis of the test subject's colour preferences. As in !"# ?/@,*/ ;&5# !6,2AD the conceptual model has retreated into the background in a deliberate at- tempt to open up the viewers own interpretative space. In the work E C&.&+6#@ C*6@' (2011), the eight cards of the test are reproduced as a series of portraits, each of which represents a fictitious personality. In the absence of Lschers key to the test, the interpretation of the signs is left to the viewer, who ascribes meaning to them via her own associations and in the con- text of her own time. The same ap- plies to the work F,0"( C*6@' G.#/@4 ,/0 C&.&+6' (2011), which forms a contrast to Lschers simplifying classifica tion of the psyche. Slides of the eight colours of the test gradually blend into each other, adding countless new mixed shades to the colour spectrum, which, when projected onto the wall, opens up like a mental landscape that is constantly changing in depth and mood. As a phenomenon, colour is at once comprehensible and incom- prehensible. In objective terms col- ours do not exist, they are an illu- sion but nonetheless a reality. In the gap between the myths of culture and the sensing conscious- ness, the exhibition subtly weaves several parallel levels and modes of cognition together, to form an am- biguous picture of reality. Through the displaced view of myth towards Ebbe Stub Wittrup, !"#$ &'() * + ,-"$ ./ 01#)) +23(4 2011 Overgaden. Institute of Contemporary Art, Overgaden Neden Vandet 17, DK-1414 Copenhagen K, + 45 3257-7273, info@overgaden.org, www.overgaden.org. Tuesday-Sunday 1-5pm, Thursday 1-8pm Design: Annis CV Ebbe Stub Wittrup (b. 1973) graduated from The Academy of Fine Arts in Prague in 1999. He has had several solo exhibitions, recently at Nusser & Baumgart, Munich, 2011, and Martin Asbk Gallery, Copenhagen, 2010. His works have also been exhibited in a number of group shows, for instance at Kunsthallen Brandts, Odense, 2011; ParisCONCRET, 2011; Galleri Christina Wilson, Co- penhagen, 2010; Otto Zoo, Milan, 2009, and Arken, Ishj, 2007. In 2010, Ebbe Stub Wittrup was the recipient of The Danish Arts Councils 3-year grant. In 2011 he published the book >6#'+%#@ ;#*.,(7 at Hatje Cantz Verlag. Ebbe Stub Wittrup lives in Copenhagen. LECTURE Thursday 1 March at 5pm Overgaden invites you to a lecture on Goethes phenomenology by Henrik Botius, who is associate professor at Laboratory for Colour at The Royal Danish Aca- demy of Fine Arts. RADIO PLAY Thursday 15 March at 7pm Foley artist Helge Haahr and three actors will perform a radio play by author Gitte Broeng which is based on J.M. Barries play :*67 ;&'# from 1920. The performance will take place in the exhibition space and will create auditory clues to Ebbe Stub Wittrups film installation :*67 ;&'# < = >.*7 ,/ !"6## =2('8 UPCOMING EXHIBITIONS Friday 13 April 2012 Overgaden presents the exhibition !,/0#/ < H6&% ("# B6##2# B6&5#6' H&+/4 @*(,&/ by Jeuno JE Kim and Lasse Krog Mller. The last day of the exhibition is 3 June 2012. Concurrently, Overgaden has dedicated the top storey to a number of brief projects and longer events that under the title H,6'( H.&&6 present aspects of contemporary art that are rarely of- fered space in the more established institutional contexts. Ebbe Stub Wittrup would like to thank Martin Asbk, Anders Sune Berg, Henrik Botius, Gitte Broeng, Jrgen Castenskiold, Claus Handberg Christensen, Jesper Fabricius, Ulrik Heltoft, Rikke Hvejsel, Kim Hgh, Helge Haahr, Thomas Ibsen, Mathias Lorentz, Basil McKinley, Jonas Raam, Carl Johan Sennels, Julie Quottrup Silbermann, Mia Bang Stenberg, David Stjernholm, The Dan- ish Art Workshops, and Overgaden. Translation: Billy OShea This exhibition folder can be downloaded from www.overgaden.org Overgaden is supported by The Danish Arts Councils Commitee for Visual Arts and The Obel Family Foundation the world and its phenomena, the works establish various modes of transformation and transgression that open up the possibility of pur- suing alternative paths into the material. Using a strict and formal technique, Ebbe Stub Wittrup mer- ges idea and materiality at the edge of language and logic, and points to what could have been, and which perhaps is, but which we have not yet called reality. Like this the world presents itself to us, not as a stable reality, but as a constant state of possibility that is constructed, takes shape and changes in the encoun- ter with a sensing subject. INTERVIEW Gerusch Meister By Claus Handberg Christensen Claus Handberg Christensen I&+6 1&6A' *6# &-(#/ )*'#@ &/ */ #3(#/4 ',J# 6#'#*62"8 K&1 @& 7&+ *556&*2" ("# %*(#6,*.L Ebbe Stub Wittrup Yes, thats right. Theres quite a lot of research involved in many of my works, and this forms the basis for some more intuitive processes that often end up creating connections. For exam- ple, part of the exhibition is based on the play :*67 ;&'# by J.M. Bar- rie. The play is about a woman who disappears several times on the is- land of Harris in the Hebrides; first for 21 days and then for 25 years, during which she has been in a pa- rallel world that is never further de- scribed in the play. What interested me about the play is that its about something that lies outside the sto- ry, which gives me an opportunity to reinvent the material. Later on I found out that the BBC had made a documentary about the island in which several people reportedly had the same experience as in the play. So I travelled to Harris to see if I could find anything to indicate how the phenomenon might have occurred. Three films resulted from that. One deals with the place where the play unfolds, and also involves a few lo- cations from the BBC documen- tary. The second film is based on Fingals Cave, located on the island of Staffa, also in the Hebrides. The cave consists of hexagonal basalt columns, and is a place that many people have studied, including Ru- dolf Steiner, who ascribed super- natural powers to it. In the third film we see a crystal from Mexico and a book on graphology, which establishes a link to another part of the exhibition, which is about some colour cards that were de- veloped for personality tests. The cards come with a book I had to buy several copies of it to get a set of identical cards. With one of the books, an extra book about grapho- logy happened to be included. It was from the 1920s, and contained analyses of the handwriting of vari- ous authors, reading it I discove- red that the only thing J.M. Barrie had ever written with his left hand was the play :*67 ;&'#. I became very interested in this, because it is said that if you write with your left hand you gain access to the brain hemisphere which is not based on reason, and this might shed some light on how the play came into ex- istence. So there are multiple links in and between the works, which include aspects of the same phenomena. I should emphasize that I have not taken any position on whether something is true or false. It is the mythical aspect alone that inter- ests me. CHC ?( '&+/@' .,A# * A,/@ &- 6*/@&% 6#'#*62"D ,/ 1",2" 7&+ '(+%).# &J#6 '&%# 2&//#2(,&/' *.&/0 ("# 1*7L ESW That is a very accurate de- scription of my way of working. I become fascinated by something and follow the pathways that lie buried in the material. Curiosity is the driving force. CHC ?/ 2&//#2(,&/ 1,(" ("# ?/@,*/ 6&5# (6,2A ("*( 7&+ +'#@ *' * '56,/04 )&*6@ -&6 (1& &- ("# 1&6A'D 7&+ "*J# (*.A#@ *)&+( */ +/@#6.7,/0 -,04 +6#8 M"*( @,@ 7&+ %#*/ )7 (",'L ESW Formally, a rope that rises up in the air is a figure that appears in several cultures as a kind of col- lective primordial form. As it is also the first figure I began to work with in connection with this exhibition, it represents a kind of doorway to my work. The film of the ropes shows various compositions that have a perspective within them and create an optical illusion. The ropes vary in size. Some of them are descend- ing, others ascending, depending on which way they are oriented. The film has no ending, it continues to mirror the same recordings. It is not a loop, but forms a Mbius strip a strip with a half-twist, so that it only has one side. If you run your finger along such a strip, you come from the inside to the outside in the same movement. It is at one and the same time quite concrete and entirely abstract like the myth. CHC :*/7 &- ("# 1&6A' @#*. 1,(" %7("' */@ ,@#*'L ESW Yes, and how ideas can be- come reality. As I briefly mention- ed earlier, there is a giant crys- tal in one of the :*67 ;&'# films. Its there for two reasons: First of all because it has the same shape as the hexagonal basalt columns in Fingals Cave, and thereby pro- vides a complementary response to them, and secondly because it comes from a cave in Mexico which was described by Buddhists and sci- ence fiction writers before it was even discovered. The cave was first discovered in 2000, but the idea of it goes far back in time. So its hard to say which came first, the idea or the cave. CHC = 56,%&6@,*. -,0+6# .+6A,/0 ,/ &+6 '+)2&/'2,&+'D 1"#6# ,( '",/#' ("6&+0" */@ 26#*(#' ,@#*'L ESW There may well be something underlying, somewhere or other, that forms the idea, yes. That is also why the exhibition is called !"# 9&,2# &- !",/0', which is a title I borrowed from a book by the writ- er Francis Ponge. Its about how things project meaning in them- selves, they possess a kind of lan- guage. There is a phenomenon called synaesthesia, which is a clini- cal term for sensory disturbances. Some people hear a note when they see a colour, or taste something when they hear a note. You might also call it translations from an- other language a language which is beyond our logic. I am fascinated by what you can produce in such translations. CHC ?/ 7&+6 1&6AD 7&+ #.+2,@*(# %#/(*. ,%*0#' */@ 5'72"&.&0,4 2*. '5*2#' ("*( *6# *)'(6*2(D )+( ("# 1&6A' ("#%'#.J#' *6# -&6%*..7 '(6,2(8 ?' (",' (#2"/,N+# @#.,)#6*(#L ESW Very much so. Take the works with the coloured cards, for exam- ple. I used them because the col- ours illustrate psychological states, but they are also interesting in that they already exist in language in a concrete form, as for example when we colloquially say Its all in the cards or The whole house of cards came tumbling down. These linguistic constructs are useful be- cause they create an entrance and a form that ensures that things do not coalesce entirely and end up as pure acid. Another feature of the cards is that, as I said, they are used in personality testing, which is to say, to describe someone. The theory that eight differently colou- red cards can reflect your persona- lity is of course somewhat ques- tionable, but the idea itself is bril- liant. Whether it works or not is completely irrelevant to me. At any rate, I photographed the cards in the same way that you would pho- tograph a human being. I used an 8 x 10 inch camera, which is a classic format that many portrait photo- graphers use, because it creates the most objective view of a per- son. The lighting is also quite clas- sic. Technically, it has been done by the book, as a way of pursuing an idea all the way. CHC ? #35#6,#/2# ,( *' ("&+0" ("#6# ,' * '5*2# &+(',@# &- ("# '5*2# ,/ ("# #3",),(,&/O' 1&6A' < */ ,..+'&67 '5*2# ("*( 7&+ 5&,/( &+( ("6&+0" 2&/26#(# &)P#2(' */@ 5"#/&%#/*8 ESW The exhibition is a bit like the play. The play has a dialogue and a cast of characters, which is all very concrete, but its really all about the space that lies outside the story, and which we never ac- tually see in the play itself. It is merely suggested. During the ex- hibition, a radio play will be per- formed in which three actors read an adapted excerpt from the play while sitting in chairs wearing their own clothes. The session involves a so-called geruschmeister or Foley artist, which is to say, a sound tech- nician who creates sound effects on the spot. He might for example use coconuts to imitate the sound of horse hooves, or potato flour to create the sound of someone walk- ing through snow, and in this way an illusory space is created through the sounds. I think it will be a kind of foundation course in illusions. In all humility. CHC M"#/ 7&+ (*.A *)&+( '+)P#24 (,J# 5#62#5(,&/ J#6'+' &)P#2(,J# 6#4 *.,(7D ,' ,( * 56#4.,/0+,'(,2 '(*(# ("*( 7&+ *,% -&6L ESW Its all about the unfinished. That which contrasts with a system, or whatever you might call it. If you take for example a building which for some reason was never built, whether for economic or political reasons, then there is only the idea of the building. It is in a way inde- pendent of time, as it has not been fixed in space. The point is that it has not become part of a system. Only the mythological aspect re- mains, and so it can be reinvented. CHC K&1 ,%5&6(*/( *6# ("#'# #/,04 %*'L ESW I dont feel that I have to read all kinds of books and obtain some comprehensive knowledge of the field. The important thing for me is the unfinished. So yes, in that re- spect the enigmas are important. They create a space with many pos- sible stories and understandings, which you should preferably sense when you are confronted with the works. I hope that the sum of the works creates the sensation of a third space a space that must be sensed. Claus Handberg Christensen is a writer who lives in Copenhagen. Ebbe Stub Wittrup, 5-"(( 678), 2011