Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
=
@-A
respecti;e%(, 9here D is the "isp%ace*ent "ue to earth8uake groun" *otion an" $ is the
natura% perio". $he ;e%ocit( an" acce%eration "e,ine" b( 08s. @3A an" @-A are
appro:i*ations o, the true ;a%ues, an" there,ore, so*eti*es, the( are re,erre" to as
pseu"o<;e%ocit( an" pseu"o<acce%eration.
/i;en the response spectra, A7)Y) ca%cu%ates the responses o, the structure ,or
each *o"e as ,o%%o9s C2D=
i i i i
u D d B E B E =
@5A
9here B DE C B E N M u
T
i i
= @>A
E"B
i
is the *o"a% responses, "isp%ace*ent or acce%eration ,or the ith *o"e, D
i
is the
spectru* "isp%ace*ent or acce%eration ;a%ues @inputA an",E7B is an e:citation "irection
;ector. $he *o"a% responses are then co*bine" 9ith one o, the se;era% co*bination
*etho"s to obtain the tota% response o, the structure C2D.
$he stresses in the she%% e%e*ents are ca%cu%ate" 9ith the constituti;e re%ationship
bet9een stress an" strain, an" the strain is obtaine" ,ro* the no"a% "isp%ace*ents. $he
stresses at the top an" botto* o, the she%% are ca%cu%ate" separate%(. $he stresses in the
bea*s are obtaine" ,ro* the no"a% ,orces an" *o*ents 9hich are ca%cu%ate" ,ro* the
no"a% "isp%ace*ents C2D.
3
)pectru* ana%(sis "oes not gi;e the ti*e histor( response o, the structure an"
re"uces a "(na*ic ana%(sis to a series o, static ana%(ses C#D. For each *o"e, a static
ana%(sis is per,or*e" to ,in" the peak response an" the responses are then co*bine" to
obtain the tota% response. !t is, ho9e;er, sti%% a "(na*ic ana%(sis since the ;ibration
properties are use" C#D. )pectru* ana%(sis in;o%;es a coup%e o, appro:i*ations inc%u"ing
the re%ationships bet9een ;e%ocit( an" "isp%ace*ent, an" acce%eration an" "isp%ace*ent
as 9e%% as *o"e co*binations. !t re*ains a use,u% too% in structure "esign because o, its
si*p%icit( an" 9orse<case<scenario approach. As co*putation ti*e beco*es %ess o, a
,actor in F0 ana%(sis, *ore "etai%e" ti*e histor( ana%(sis *a( be pre,erre" o;er spectru*
ana%(sis.
#escription of the Buil!in"
$he structure stu"ie" in this project is the &erke%e( $o9n House %ocate" on 2++
Dana )treet, &erke%e(, Ca%i,ornia. !t 9as bui%t in .>3., an" is a nine<stor( rein,orce"
concrete bui%"ing as sho9n in Figure .. $he structure has a garage in the base*ent, a
s*a%% %ibrar(, a kitchen, an" a con;ersation corner on the .
st
,%oor, eight apart*ents each
on F%oors 2 through -, se;en apart*ents each on the 5
th
an" >
th
,%oors an" a penthouse an"
a *achine roo* on the roo, o, the bui%"ing.
$he base*ent o, the bui%"ing has a hori1onta% "i*ension o, .2- ,t 5> ,t 2 in.
an" a height o, 5 ,t # in. $he retaining 9a%%s o, the base*ent are 5 in. in thickness. 4n
the outer sur,ace o, the concrete 9a%%, there is a 9aterproo, *e*brane to pre;ent
un"ergroun" 9ater ,ro* seeping into the base*ent. A "ri;e9a( o, .'.+ ,eet runs ,ro*
the base*ent garage to the street outsi"e.
-
Figure .. $he &erke%e( $o9n House.
$he superstructure @,%oors . to >A has a hori1onta% "i*ension o, 5' ,t 3 in. 3> ,t
5 inches. $he outsi"e 9a%%s o, the superstructure are o,,set ,ro* the retaining 9a%%s o, the
base*ent b( a ;ariet( o, "istances e:cept at the southeastern corner 9here the 9ho%e
structure shares the sa*e shear 9a%% as sho9n in Figure 2. $he height o, the ,irst ,%oor is
.2 ,t - I in., the 2
n"
to the 5
th
,%oor is 5 ,t > I in., the >
th
,%oor is . ,t, an" the penthouse
an" the *achine roo* has a height o, > ,t .. in.
$he bui%"ing has t9o stairs an" t9o e%e;ators. )tair . is %ocate" in the stair9e%% o,
the center core, an" it runs ,ro* the base*ent to the roo, o, the bui%"ing. )tair 2 is
%ocate" on the ,ar 9est si"e o, the bui%"ing an" it runs ,ro* .
st
to >
th
,%oor. $he t9o
5
>
Figure 2. 2%an ;ie9 o, the structure.
e%e;ators are %ocate" in the e%e;ator 9e%% o, the center core ne:t to stair . as sho9n in
Figure 2. $he e%e;ator 9e%% has a hori1onta% "i*ension o, .2 ,t 3 in. . ,t .. in. an" the
hori1onta% "i*ension o, stair9e%% ,or stair 9e%% is .# ,t 5 in. > ,t. &oth e%e;ators run
,ro* the base*ent to the >
th
,%oor.
$he *ain supporting e%e*ents o, the bui%"ing are the ,oun"ation, center core,
co%u*ns, shear 9a%%s, an" ,%oor s%abs. $he ,oun"ation is rein,orce" concrete ra,t
,oun"ation an" its "epth ranges ,ro* ' ,t at the e"ge an" . ,t at the center core. $he
center core, 9hich houses the e%e;ators an" the stair9a(, is attache" to the ,oun"ation an"
is the *ain supporting e%e*ent, ,unctioning both as a co%u*n an" a shear 9a%%. $he core
is a%so *a"e o, rein,orce" concrete an" its "i*ensions can be ,oun" in $ab%e .. $he
bui%"ing has .2 rein,orce" concrete co%u*ns that run a%% the 9a( to the top o, the
structure. Jhen ;ie9ing ,ro* the east or the 9est si"e o, the bui%"ing, the co%u*ns ,or*
# ro9s perpen"icu%ar to the east 9a%%, an" the ro9s are space" at 25K2L or 25K'L 9ith each
other @Figure 2A. Co%u*n spacing ;aries ,ro* 22K5L to 2+K..L in the other "irection. $he
cross<sections o, the co%u*ns are sho9n in $ab%e 2. !n a""ition, there e:ist three
co%u*ns that support the roo, o, the base*ent on the 9est si"e. $he shear 9a%%s are
%ocate" at the ,our corners o, the bui%"ing as sho9n in Figure 2. $he shear 9a%%s on the
east en" o, the north 9a%% an" on the 9est en" o, south 9a%% are anchore" into the
,oun"ation an" the re*aining shear 9a%%s starts ,ro* the ,irst ,%oor. $he thickness o, the
shear 9a%%s is %iste" in $ab%e .. $he rest o, the outsi"e 9a%%s are architectura%
.
co*ponents. $he center core, co%u*ns an" ;ertica% 9a%%s are tie" together 9ith
rein,orce" concrete ,%oor s%abs an" the thickness o, the s%abs is > in.
$ab%e .. )hear Ja%% $hickness @in.A
)hear Ja%%s &ase*ent First )econ" $hir" Forth Fi,th )i:th )e;enth 0ighth 7inth
7orth @JestM0astA @M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A @3M.2A
0ast 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
)outh @JestM0astA @.2MA @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A @.2M3A
Jest 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
0%e;ator 7orth .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2
0%e;ator Jest 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
0%e;ator )outh .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2
0%e;ator 0astN)tair Jest 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
)tair )outh .' .' .' .2 .2 .2 . . 5 5
)tair 0ast 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5 5
)tair 7orth .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2
$ab%e 2. Cross<)ections o, the Co%u*ns @in.A
F%oor .A, 2A, #A 'A .&, 2&, #& '& .C 2C, #C, 'C
3th to >th .' : .' .' : .' .' : .' .' : .' .' : .' .' : .'
& to +th 2 : 2 .5 : .5 22 : 22 .5 : 22 .5 : .5 2 : 2
$he F0M *o"e% is base" on the a,ore*entione" structura% co*ponents.
#escription of the $o!el
$he *o"e% is a three<"i*ensiona%, %inear, isotropic ,inite e%e*ent *o"e%. $he
"iscreti1ation o, "o*ain, geo*etr( o, the e%e*ents, *ateria% properties, boun"ar(
con"ition, %oa"s an" ana%(sis proce"ures are "escribe" be%o9.
Geometry and the FE Idealization
..
$he geo*etr( o, the *o"e% is obtaine" ,ro* the b%ueprint o, the bui%"ing an" ,ie%"
inspections. Detai%s o, the structure are gi;en in the pre;ious section, ODescription o, the
&ui%"ing.L $he origin o, the coor"inate s(ste* ,or the *o"e% is %ocate" at the southeast
corner o, the base*ent ,%oor. $he :, ( an" 1 a:es are in the J<0, )<7 an" ;ertica%
"irections, respecti;e%(. $he *o"e%, ,or the *ost part, is co*pose" o, the structura%
co*ponents o, the bui%"ing, na*e%(, the center core, the shear 9a%%s, the ,%oor s%abs an"
the ;ertica% co%u*ns, the "i*ensions o, 9hich can be ,oun" in Figure 2 an" $ab%es . an"
2. $he retaining 9a%%s aroun" the base*ent are a%so inc%u"e" in the *o"e%. $he
,oun"ation is not inc%u"e" in the *o"e%, but its beha;ior is re,%ecte" in the boun"ar(
con"itions. A%% the architectura% co*ponents inc%u"ing the *achine roo* at the roo, are
ignore" a%though a 2P *ass 9as a""e" to the *o"e% to account ,or those co*ponents
9hen the ana%(sis 9as con"ucte".
$9o t(pes o, e%e*ents, 9hich are "escribe" in the ne:t section, are use" in the
*o"e%= bea* e%e*ents an" she%% e%e*ents. $he .+ co%u*ns inc%u"ing the three ,or the
base*ent, are represente" 9ith bea* e%e*ents an" the rest o, the co*ponents are
"iscreti1e" 9ith she%% e%e*ents. $o *aintain a si1e<to<thickness ratio o, aroun" . ,or the
she%% e%e*ents, as suggeste" b( A7)Y), a genera% e"ge %ength o, > in. 9as use" ,or
*eshing the 9a%%s a%though e%e*ents 9ith other e"ge %engths 9ere a%so generate" because
o, the irregu%ar %ocations o, the structura% co*ponents. $he *ajorit( o, the she%% e%e*ents
are 8ua"ri%atera% 9ith a ,e9 triangu%ar ones to account ,or the irregu%arities o, the areas.
$he %engths o, the bea* e%e*ent are aroun" # in. A tota% o, #># bea* e%e*ents an"
2#' she%% e%e*ents 9ere generate" ,or the *o"e%. Figure # sho9s the *eshe" ,inite
e%e*ent *o"e%.
.2
Figure #. Finite 0%e*ent Abstract o, the &ui%"ing.
)o*e "i,,icu%ties 9ere encountere" 9hen generating the ,inite e%e*ent *esh. $he
"i,,icu%ties 9ere cause" b( the irregu%ar %ocations an" ;ar(ing "i*ensions o, the
structura% co*ponents an" b( the ,act that e%e*ents *ust be connecte" proper%(. For
e:a*p%e, a bea* e%e*ent can not pierce a she%% e%e*ent in the *i""%e geo*etrica%%( an"
it *ust *eet a she%% e%e*ents at a no"e. )i*i%ar%(, a no"e o, a she%% e%e*ent can not be
%ocate" in the *i""%e o, the e"ge o, another she%% e%e*ent. $he prob%e*s 9ere u%ti*ate%(
so%;e" b( re"ucing auto*atic *eshing an" increasing *anua% *eshing through the
creation o, *ore Ke(points an" *eshing the areas separate%(.
.#
Element Types
$he bea* e%e*ent use" in the *o"e% is &0AM' in A7)Y). &0AM' is a 2<no"e,
#<D, e%astic, unia:ia% e%e*ents 9ith tension, co*pression, torsion an" ben"ing
capabi%ities C2D. $he e%e*ent has si: "egrees o, ,ree"o* at each no"e, trans%ations in the
:, ( an" 1 "irections an" rotations about the :, ( an" 1 a:es. $he e%e*ent : a:is is
a%9a(s a%ong the a:is o, the bea* 9ith e%e*ent ( an" 1 a:es ,or*ing the cross<section
p%ane. 6e8uire" e%e*ent constants inc%u"e cross<section area, thickness in the ( an" 1
"irections @$KZ an" $KYA an" *o*ents o, inertia @!ZZ an" !YYA. $he re8uire"
*ateria% propert( inputs ,or the e%e*ent are YoungK *o"u%us @0QA an" "ensit( @D07)A.
4ther constant an" *ateria% input options are a%so a;ai%ab%e. $he e%e*ent stress is
ca%cu%ate" ,ro* no"a% ,orce an" *o*ents.
$he she%% e%e*ent use" in the *o"e% is )H0LL3# in A7)Y). )H0LL3# is a '<
no"e, #<D, e%astic she%% e%e*ent. $he e%e*ent has si: "egrees o, ,ree"o* at each no"e
si*i%ar to those o, a bea* e%e*ent. $he e%e*ent 1 a:is is a%9a(s perpen"icu%ar to she%%
sur,ace. 6e8uire" e%e*ent constants inc%u"e the thickness at each no"es @$K@!,A, $K@JA,
etc.A an" *ateria% properties inc%u"e YoungKs *o"u%us, 2oissonKs ratio an" "ensit( @0Q,
26QY an" D07)A. 4ther constants an" *ateria% properties can a%so be inputte"
"epen"ing on the app%ications. $he e%e*ent stress is ca%cu%ate" ,ro* the e%e*ent strain
an" the no"a% ,orces an" *o*ents are obtaine" ,ro* the e%e*ent stresses.
More "etai%s o, the e%e*ents can be ,oun" in A7)Y) usersK gui"e C2D.
Element Constants
.'
$9e%;e sets o, *ateria% constants 9ere use" in the *o"e%, si: ,or each t(pe o,
e%e*ents. $he nu*ber o, *ateria% constant sets *ain%( re,%ects the nu*ber o, e%e*ent
thickness in the *o"e%. $ab%es # an" ' %ist the e%e*ent constant sets ,or the bea* an"
she%% e%e*ents, respecti;e%(.
$ab%e #. 0%e*ent Constants ,or the &ea* 0%e*ents
)et R
A60A
@in.
2
A
!ZZ
@in.
'
A
!YY
@in.
'
A
$KZ
@in.A
$KY
@in.A
ADDMA)
@%b<sec
2
Nin.Nin.A
. #2' 5-'5 5-'5 .5 .5
2 #>3 .+>-2 .3>2 .5 22
# ' .#### .#### 2 2
' '5' .>+2. .>+2. 22 22
+ .>3 #2. #2. .' .'
3 .'' .-2' .-2' .2 .2
$ab%e '. 0%e*ent Constants ,or the )he%% 0%e*ents
)et R
$K
@in.A
ADM)SA
@%b<sec
2
Nin.Nin.
2
A
- 3
5 5
> > .'2
. .
.. .2
.2 .'
!n $ab%es # an" ', ADDMA) an" ADM)SA are the a""e" *ass per unit %ength ,or the
bea* e%e*ent an" a""e" *ass per unit area ,or the she%% e%e*ent, respecti;e%(, an" other
s(*bo%s are e:p%aine" pre;ious%(. Constant )et > is use" ,or the ,%oor s%abs an" a 2P
*ass 9as a""e" to the ,%oors to represent the *ass o, the ignore" ,eatures. For the she%%
e%e*ent, uni,or* thickness is app%ie" ,or each e%e*ent in the *o"e% an" there,ore, the
.+
thickness o, each no"e in a e%e*ent is the sa*e. $ab%e # an" ' re,%ect the thickness o, the
9a%% an" co%u*n "i*ensions %iste" in $ab%e . an" 2.
Material Properties
$hree sets o, *ateria% properties are use" in the *o"e%. $he nu*ber o, *ateria%
sets is base" on the t(pes o, concretes use" in the bui%"ing, as in"icate" on the b%ueprint,
an" the *o"e% abstraction. $here are t9o t(pes o, concretes 9ith a no*ina% strength o,
#-+ psi an" 2+ psi. $he structura% co*ponents 9ere constructe" 9ith #-+ concrete
an" the base*ent retaining 9a%% 9ith 2+ concrete. $he YoungKs *o"u%us is ca%cu%ate"
9ith the ,o%%o9ing ,or*u%a C'D=
T ..+
##9 0
c
f = @.A
9here 9 is the "ensit( in %bN,t
#
an"
T
c
f is the no*ina% strength o, the concrete in psi.
$he 2oissonKs ratio ,or concrete ranges ,ro* ..+ to .2+ C'D an" a ;a%ue o, .2 is chosen ,or
the *o"e%. $he "ensit( o, concrete ;aries ,ro* > to .++ %bN,t
#
an" a ;a%ue o, .+ 9as
se%ecte". !t *ust be pointe" out that in A7)Y), the "ensit( *ust be entere" as *ass per
unit ;o%u*e, not 9eight per unit ;o%u*e ,or *o"a% ana%(sis. 4ne can ;er( easi%( be
con,use" on this point, especia%%( ,or those 9ho are accusto*e" to static ana%(sis.
2erhaps, A7A)Y) shou%" consi"er a""ing a routine to per,or* a con;ersion ,ro*
9eightN;o%u*e to *assN;o%u*e so that the "ensit( can be entere" 9ith consistent unit ,or
both static an" "(na*ic ana%(ses. $he unit o, the "ensit( entere" in this *o"e% is %b<
sec
2
Nin.Nin.
#
.
!n the *o"e%, the e%e;ator "oors on each ,%oor 9ere ignore" to re"uce the
co*p%e:it( o, the *esh. $his o*ission 9as co*pensate" b( re"ucing the YoungKs
*o"u%us o, that si"e o, the 9a%% b( .N#.
.3
$he *ateria% properties are su**ari1e" in $ab%e +. !n the tab%e, Materia% )ets .,
2 an" # are ,or the structura% co*ponent, 9a%% o, the e%e;ator "oors an" the retaining
9a%%s, respecti;e%(.
$ab%e +. Materia% 2roperties
Materia% )et
0Q
@psiA
26QY
D07)
@%b<sec
2
Nin.Nin.
#
A
. #-.2+ .2 .22'55'
2 2'-+ .2 .22'55'
# ##.2 .2 .22'55'
Boundary Conditions and Applied Spectrum
$he boun"ar( con"itions ,or the ana%(sis are= aA a%% the no"es o, the she%% e%e*ents
at the ,oun"ation %e;e% are ,i:e", i.e., the "isp%ace*ents, trans%ationa% or rotationa%, 9ere
set to 1eroU an" bA ,or the bea* e%e*ents, the trans%ationa% "isp%ace*ents o, the no"es at
the ,oun"ation %e;e% 9ere set to 1ero, but rotations 9ere a%%o9e".
For the spectru* ana%(sis, the spectra ,or the 0% Centro earth8uake 9ith "a*ping
ratio o, 2P 9ere a"opte" in the ana%(sis. $he spectra are sho9n in Figure '. $he
spectru* ;a%ues 9ere entere" as a tab%e in A7)Y) as sho9n in $ab%e 3. A7)Y) takes
,re8uencies instea" o, perio"s 9hich ha;e a reciproca% re%ationship 9ith ,re8uencies.
$ab%e 3. 6esponse )pectru* ?a%ues Sse" in the Ana%(sis
Fre8uenc(
Disp%ace*ent
)pectru* @in.A
Acce%eration
)pectru* @gA
.
+
-.'- ..>.
..
+.>- .3.
2.
2.3- ..>
.-
Reponse Spectra
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
0 1 2 3
Period, sec
D
i
s
p
l
a
c
e
m
e
n
t
,
i
n
.
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
A
c
c
e
l
e
r
a
t
i
o
n
,
g
Displacement
Acceleration
Figure '. 6esponse spectra use" in the ana%(sis.C#D
Analysis Procedures and Options
$he ana%(sis proce"ure ,or the *o"a% ana%(sis is "escribe" in )ections #.' through
#.5 o, the A7)Y) )tructura% Ana%(sis /ui"e an" the proce"ure ,or a sing%e<point
response spectru* @)26)A ana%(sis is e:p%aine" in )ection 3.' o, the gui"e.
$he options use" in the *o"a% ana%(sis are sho9n in Figure + an" those ,or the
spectru* ana%(sis are in Figure 3. $he spectru* ana%(sis 9as con"ucte" ,or si: "i,,erent
%oa"ing cases= "isp%ace*ents in the e:citation "irections :, ( an" 1 an" acce%erations in
the e:citation "irections :, (, an" 1, respecti;e%(. Figure 3 sho9s on%( the case 9here the
spectru* ;a%ue is "isp%ace*ent an" the e:citation "irection is 1. 4ptions ,or other cases
are si*i%ar e:cept that the "isp%ace*ent *a( be rep%ace" b( acce%eration an" the ;a%ue ,or
)0DQ an" )0DY *a( take the ;a%ue o, one instea" o, 1ero 9here )0DQ, )0DY an"
)0DZ are i"enti,iers o, the e:citation "irection an" a ;a%ue o, one in"icates an e:citation
"irection.
.5
Figure +. Mo"a% ana%(sis options ,or the *o"e%.
.>
Figure 3. )pectru* ana%(sis options.
Results an! #iscussions
$he resu%ts obtaine" ,ro* the ana%(sis inc%u"e the natura% ,re8uencies an" *o"a%
shapes o, the bui%"ing, an" "isp%ace*ents, acce%erations an" stresses in"uce" b( seis*ic
%oa"ing.
Natural Freuencies and Modal Shapes o! the Buildin"
$9ent( natura% ,re8uencies an" ,i;e *o"a% shapes 9ere obtaine" ,ro* the *o"a%
ana%(sis. Fi;e o, the %o9est ,re8uencies are sho9n the $ab%e - an" correspon"ing *o"a%
shapes are sho9n in Figure - through ...
$he ,un"a*enta% perio" o, the bui%"ing is .5#+ sec. 9hich is co*parab%e 9ith the
esti*ate" ;a%ue o, .>' ,ro* the ,o%%o9ing e*pirica% ,or*u%a "e;e%ope" b( F0MA C+D
base" on actua% groun" shaking=
> .
.3 . H T
L
= @..A
9here
L
T an" H are the ,un"a*enta% perio" an" bui%"ing height, respecti;e%(. $his
sho9s that the *o"e% "e;e%ope" in this project is a rea%istic one.
2
$ab%e -. 7atura% Fre8uencies an" 2erio"s o, the &ui%"ing
Mo"e Fre8uenc( 2erio"
. ...>5 .5#+
2 ..53- .+#3
# 2..3> .'3.
' +..#. ..>+
+ +.253 ..5>
Figure -. $he ,irst *o"a% shape.
2.
Figure 5. $he secon" *o"a% shape.
Figure >. $he thir" *o"a% shape.
22
Figure .. $he ,ourth *o"a% shape.
Figure ... $he ,i,th *o"a% shape
2#
$he ,irst *o"e o, the bui%"ing is rotating about an a:is para%%e% to the :<a:is in the
0<J "irection an" the bui%"ing s9ings in the 7<) "irection @Figure -A. $he secon" an"
thir" *o"es are both t9isting, in c%ock9ise an" counter<c%ock9ise, respecti;e%( @Figure 5
an" >A. $he ,ourth *o"e is ben"ing in the 7<) "irection @Figure .A. $he %ast *o"e
sho9s se;ere ;ertica% *otion at the north9est part o, the bui%"ing an" so*e ben"ing
@Figure ..A.
#isplacement and Acceleration $esponses
)pectru* ana%(sis (ie%"e" a %ot o, in,or*ation. For each "isp%ace*ent e:citation,
there are eight "isp%ace*ent response ;a%ues at each no"e= trans%ationa% "isp%ace*ents in
the :, ( an" 1 "irection, rotations about the :, ( an" 1 a:is, an" tota% "isp%ace*ent an"
rotation. $he sa*e can be sai" about the acce%eration. $here,ore, a tota% o, '5
"isp%ace*ent an" acce%eration contour graphs can be generate". !n a""ition, ;ector
graphs can a%so be create". 4n%( the tota% "isp%ace*ent an" acce%eration graphs are
inc%u"e" in this section an" the rest can be ,oun" in the Appen"i:.
Figure .2 through .' sho9 the tota% "isp%ace*ent contours 9hen the e:citation is
in the :, ( an" 1 "irections, respecti;e%(, an" Figure .+ through .- are the contour *aps
,or the acce%eration. $hese ,igures in"icate that 9hen the e:citation is in the : or (
"irection, the *a:i*u* "isp%ace*ents an" acce%erations occur at the top %e;e% o, the
bui%"ing. Jhen the e:citation is in the 1 "irection, *a:i*u* ;a%ues occur in the
north9est part o, the bui%"ing 9here the north9est shear 9a%% is %ocate" at the so,test
spot ,or the entire bui%"ing @Figure .' an" .-A. $he ,act that the "istribution patterns o,
the "isp%ace*ents an" acce%erations are si*i%ar can be e:p%aine" b( 08s. - through >.
2'
Figure .2. $ota% "isp%ace*ent in"uce" b( e:citation in the :<"irection.
Figure .#. $ota% "isp%ace*ent in"uce" b( e:citation in the (<"irection.
2+
Figure .'. $ota% "isp%ace*ent "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
Figure .+. $ota% acce%eration "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
23
Figure .3. $ota% acce%eration "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
Figure .-. $ota% acce%eration "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
2-
$he resu%ts suggest that the top an" the north9est part o, the bui%"ings are the *ost
sensiti;e areas ,or the 9ire%ess sensors to pick up *o;e*ents.
Stress #istri%utions
)i*i%ar to "isp%ace*ents an" acce%erations, a %ot o, "ata 9ere generate" ,ro* the
spectru* ana%(sis about ,orces an" stresses. 4n%( the ,irst principa% stress contours are
sho9n here. Figures .5 through 2 are the ,irst principa% stress "istributions "ue to
e:citations in the :, (, an" 1 "irection, respecti;e%(. Figures .5 an" .> in"icate that the
*a:i*u* stress concentrations occurs at the botto*s o, the shear 9a%%s an" center core
as 9e%% as the areas o, the ,irst ,%oor s%ab 9here the north9est an" southeast shear 9a%%s
sit on. $he *a:i*u* stresses in"uce" b( e:citation in the 1<"irection concentrate in the
north9est part o, the bui%"ing @Figure 2A, 9hich is consistent 9ith the "isp%ace*ent
"istribution.
Figure .5. Ma:i*u* principa% stress "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
25
Figure .>. Ma:i*u* principa% stress "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
Figure 2. Ma:i*u* principa% stress "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
2>
$he *a:i*u* stresses range ,ro* .2.# psi to .>+.' psi 9hich ,ar e:cee" ..+ ti*es the
no*ina% strength ;a%ue o, the concrete, +32+ psi, in"icating that the bui%"ing cou%" be
"a*age" b( an earth8uake o, 0% Centro *agnitu"e.
)o*e suggestions on retro,itting can be *a"e base" on the ana%(sis. First, the
south9est an" northeast shear 9a%%s an" the center core, 9hich are a%% connecte" to the
,oun"ation, *a( nee" rein,orce*ent at the botto* ,ro* the ,oun"ation %e;e% to the ,irst
,%oor. )econ", co%u*ns shou%" be bui%t un"erneath the north9est an" southeast shear
9a%%s in the base*ent to sti,,en those corners.
Conclusions an! Recommen!ations
A #<D ,inite e%e*ent *o"e% 9as bui%t an" ana%(1e" in the stu"(. $he *o"e% is
base" on the actua% "i*ensions ,ro* the b%ueprint an" inc%u"es a%% structura% co*ponents
an" the retaining 9a%%. $he *ateria% properties o, the *o"e% are those reco**en"e" b(
AC!. Mo"a% an" spectru* ana%(ses 9ere per,or*e" 9ith the F0 package, A7)Y). $he
,un"a*enta% ,re8uenc( obtaine" ,ro* the *o"a% ana%(sis co*pares 9e%% 9ith the
e*pirica% ;a%ue. Disp%ace*ent, acce%eration an" stress "istributions are generate" ,ro*
spectru* ana%(sis 9ith the 0% Centro response spectru*. !t is suggeste" ,ro* the
ana%(ses that the *ost sensiti;e areas ,or the acce%erate *eters to pick up structura%
*otions are the top %e;e% an" the north9est part o, the bui%"ing. $he ana%(ses a%so
suggest that *ost o, the retro,itting spots are %ocate" in the base*ent area an" the
north9est portion o, the bui%"ing.
A%though the stu"( (ie%"s reasonab%e an" use,u% in,or*ation, it is sti%% %i*ite" in a
coup%e o, aspects. First o, a%%, the spectru* ana%(sis has its inheritant prob%e* o, too
#
*an( appro:i*ations as *entione" in the theoretica% "iscussions. Another %i*itation is
that the *o"a% ana%(sis "i" not inc%u"e "a*ping though it 9as ,actore" into the spectru*
ana%(sis. !n a""ition, the stu"( 9as constraine" b( ti*e an" resources.
)o*e o, the reco**en"ations ,or ,urther stu"( inc%u"e= .A con"ucting a*bient
;ibration tests to "eter*ine the natura% ,re8uencies o, the bui%"ing an" co*pare the*
9ith the F0 resu%tsU 2A consi"ering "a*ping e,,ect in *o"a% ana%(sisU an" #A per,or*
ti*e<histor( ana%(ses such as har*onic or transient stu"ies.
Acknowle!"ements
$he authors 9ou%" %ike to ackno9%e"ge the support o, 7)F, D40 an" 0;ergreen
?a%%e( Co%%ege through the Fa)$ progra*. Cre"its are a%so "ue to Dr. Caro% Corra"i o,
L&7L ,or A7)Y) suggestions an" Mr. Ja(ne La9 ,or his he%p in the structura%
engineering area.
References
.. Meiro;itch, L., 0%e*ents o, ?ibration Ana%(sis, Mc/ra9<Hi%%, 7e9 York,
.>53
2. A7)Y), !nc., Docu*entation 3.., 22
#. Chopra, A. K., D(na*ics o, )tructures<$heor( an" App%ications to
0arth8uake engineering, 2rentice Ha%%, 7e9 Jerse(, .>>+
'. AC!, AC! Manua% o, Concrete 2ractice, 2art ., Far*ington Hi%%s, M!, 2.
+. F0MA, 70H62 6eco**en"ations ,or )eis*ic 6egu%ations ,or 7e9
&ui%"ings an" 4ther )tructures, 2art 2, 2 0"ition V Co**entar(,
Jashington D. C., 2.
3. ?entura, C. 0. an" Hor(na, $., OMeasure" an" Ca%cu%ate" Mo"a%
Characteristics o, the Heritage Court $o9er in ?ancou;er, &. C.,L
#.
2rocee"ings o, !MAC<Q?!!!= A Con,erence on )tructura% D(na*ics, )an
Antonio, $Q, 2, pp. .-<.-'
-. Horta, J. an" Castano, ?. M., O)hi,t o, 7atura% Fre8uencies in &ui%"ings
Da*age" b( 0arth8uakes,L 2rocee"ings o, !MAC<Q?!!!= A Con,erence on
)tructura% D(na*ics, )an Antonio, $Q, 2, pp. .'.2<.'.+
#2
A%%EN#&' A!!itional Results from the $o!el
Figure A<.. Acce%eration in the :<"irection "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
Figure A<2. Acce%eration in the (<"irection "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
##
Figure A<#. Acce%eration in the 1<"irection "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
Figure A<'. Acce%eration in the :<"irection "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
#'
Figure A<+. Acce%eration in the (<"irection "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
Figure A<3. Acce%eration in the 1<"irection "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
#+
Figure A<-. ?ector p%ot o, the tota% acce%eration "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
Figure A<5. Acce%eration in the :<"irection "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
#3
Figure A<>. Acce%eration in the (<"irection "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
Figure A<.. Acce%eration in the 1<"irection "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
#-
Figure A<... ?ector p%ot o, the tota% acce%eration "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
A<.2. Disp%ace*ent in the :<"irection "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
#5
A<.#. Disp%ace*ent in the (<"irection "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
A<.'. Disp%ace*ent in the 1<"irection "ue to e:citation in the :<"irection.
#>
A<.+. Disp%ace*ent in the :<"irection "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
A<.3. Disp%ace*ent in the (<"irection "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
'
A<.-. Disp%ace*ent in the 1<"irection "ue to e:citation in the (<"irection.
A<.5. Disp%ace*ent in the :<"irection "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
'.
A<.>. Disp%ace*ent in the (<"irection "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
A<2. Disp%ace*ent in the 1<"irection "ue to e:citation in the 1<"irection.
'2
'#