Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Ms.ElizabethM.Murphy
Secretary
SecuritiesandExchangeCommission
100FStreet,N.E.
Washington,DC205491090
Re:FileNo.EquityMarketStructure2013
DearMs.Murphy:
ThankyouforthechancetocommentontheSECsnewmarketstructureportal,andcongratulationstothe
SECforlaunchingsuchaninnovativewebsite.Notevenayearold,theportalalreadyhasvaluabledataand
analysesaboutourmarketsandisausefultoolforunderstandingatleastsomemarketdynamics.It'shard
tothinkofanotherregulatorthathasreachedouttothepublicinthisway.It'salsoastrikingcontrastwith
theSECofthepast,wherequantitativeanalyses,iftheyweredoneatall,wererarelyandonlyvery
reluctantlysharedwiththepublic,andthedataitselfkeptsecurelywithintheagency.
TheSEC'snewlylaunchedMIDAStoolisalsoagoodstepforward.ThetooltakesinSIPdatafeedsand
proprietaryexchangedatafeedsandmaintainsaconsolidateddatabaseofitall.SECanalystscanuse
thatdatatostudyaspectsofthemarketsdowntomicroseconds,brokenoutbystockandexchange.
MyinterestinthesefacilitieswaspiquedbysomerecentremarksfromChairWhiteaboutMIDAS.During
herrecentappearancebeforetheHouseFinancialServicesCommittee,shesaidshewasmakingcertain
thattheSECanditsexpertshadthedatatheyneededtofullyunderstandallofthemarketstructureissues
andthenrespondappropriatelyiftheresaneedtorespond."(Emphasishers.)Shethenhighlighted
MIDASasacoreinitiative,"TheknowledgebaseoftheCommissionhasbeenenhancedsignificantlyby
beingabletobringontheMIDAStechnology."
MyinterestsharpenedfurtherafewdayslaterwhenBloombergreportedthataseniorSECstaffmember
haddismissedcriticismtheagencywasbehindthetimes.Bloombergreportedthatatanindustry
conferenceinTexasthestafferpointedto"anewsurveillancesystem,knownasMidas,thatcollectsprice
datafromallU.S.exchangesandthathelpstheSECevaluatepracticessuchascolocation,inwhich
traderscuttradingtimesbyplacingcomputersinsideanexchange,andproprietaryfeeds,orstreamsof
datasen[t]toclientsfasterthantopublicsources."Bloombergparaphrasedtheofficial'sbewildermentat
criticismoftheSECbywriting,"Theagencycantbebothignorantofmarketbehaviorandhaveaccessto
suchexpansivedata"Bloombergthenquotedhimdirectly,"'Oneofthosestatementshastobewrong,'"
and"'Thosebothcantbetrueatthesametime.'"
ImwritingtobrieflycommentonthedatainMIDASandonsomeofthatdataslimitations,andtocomment
ontherisksofdrawingbroadconclusionsfromthatdatawithoutaccountingforthoselimitations.Itall
suggeststhat,atleastfornow,bothofthosestatementsaretrueatthesametime.
1
Data
TheportalnotesthatMIDASincludespostedordersfromtheexchanges,butit'simportanttobeprecise:
theexchangedatainMIDASincludesonlydisplayedandpostedorderdetail,andonlythatfromasubsetof
exchanges.
Whileordertypestatisticsfromalltheexchangesarentpubliclyavailable,someexchangesdopublish
thosestatistics.Oftheexchangesthatdo,somewherebetween50percentand65percentofallorderson
thoseexchangesarenotdisplayedorareatbestconditionallydisplayed.Ifanorderisntdisplayed,its
detailisntdistributedoverexchangedatafeeds.Ifitisntdistributedoverexchangedatafeeds,itisntin
MIDAS.Thatmissingdataperhapsasmuchashalftotwothirdsofallexchangeorderdetailisa
significantsourceoferrorunlessitiswellunderstoodandallitsimplicationsaredisclosed.
Thereareothersourcesoferror.Amongthem,NYSEdoesntdistributeorderleveldetailoveritsproprietary
feeds,soMIDASdoesntincludeorderdetailsforNYSEtrading,alossofabout12percentoftheoverall
equitiesmarket.ThisisamuchgreaterlossthanitsmarketshareimpliesbecauseNYSEistheprimary
marketforsomanyofthecountryslargestcompaniesandmostactivestocks.MIDASalsodoesnt
includedarkpoolandOTCmarketmakerdata,whichleavesoutperhapsanother40percentoftheoverall
equitiesmarketfromitsdatabases.
ExtrapolatingandthencombiningtheselimitationstounderstandwhatMIDASdatabasesincludeimplies
thatMIDAShasorderactivityforonlyabout25percentto40percentoftodayslitmarketsandonly15
percentto25percentoftheentireequitiesmarket.Thisisstillvaluableinformation,butitisfarfrom
completeinformation,andanyoneanalyzingMIDASdatashoulddoitcautiouslyandwithalotofdisclosure.
ThoughinonesectionoftheportaltheSECdiscussesatleastoneofthesegapsinthedataNYSEorder
detailtheportalshoulddiscloseafullaccounting.Asubpopulationlikethisinevitablybreedsselection
biasandisfarfromChairWhitesgoalofmakingcertaintheSEChaswhatitneedsto"fullyunderstandall
ofthemarketstructureissues."
MIDAShasotherlimitations.Ofthedozensofdataelementsafirmcanputonanorderbeforesendingitto
anexchange,asaruleMIDASreceivesonlyfourofthemfromexchangedatafeedsstock,price,size,and
side.Andthen,ofthosefourdataelements,threeareclippedbeforetheyevergettoMIDAS.Ordersizeis
clippedtocontainonlythedisplayedsizeoftheorder.Thesameistruefororderprice.Theorder'ssideis
clippedtosimplebuyorsellanddoesn'tincludeanyshortsaleindicators.Ordersarealsonotmarkedwith
capacityindicators,likeprincipaloragency.Crucially,tradesandordersinMIDASdontincludeaccount
dataorotherparticipantidentifiers,meaningthere'snowaytoidentifywhoisdoingwhatinthemarkets,to
isolateafirm'strading,ortoidentifywhatfirmswereinvolvedinanyparticularmarketevent.Italsomeans
there'snowaytoconsolidatemarketactivityintoparticipantcategories,likeinstitutionalorproptrading,and
understandwhereandhowtheseparticipantsenterthemarket.Thesemattersareimportantenoughto
deepanalysisthattheSECsownrecentreviewofhighfrequencytradingresearch,availableontheportal,
deliberatelyexcludesstudiesthatdonthaveparticipantidentifiers.Itexcludesthosestudiesbecausethey
don'thavethe"tradingaccountdatathatcanbeusedtodistinguishdifferenttypesofmarketparticipants,"
makingitimpossibletosortoutwhoisdoingwhat.PresumablyresearchbasedonMIDASdatahasthe
samehandicap.
MIDAShasalmostnoinformationatallaboutordertypesandordermodifiers,otherthantheobviousfactit
containsonlydisplayedorders.Itdoesntincludeanyinformationaboutintermarketroutingbehavior,about
2
whatordersareroutedintoandoutofamarket,soMIDAScan'tgiveanyinsightintomarketwide
interactionsevenastheequitiesmarketbecomesmorefragmentedanddispersed.
Altogethertheseadduptoverysignificantlimitations,andtheyaregettingworse.Moretradingismigrating
tooffexchangevenues,andattheexchangesdisplayedorderusageisshrinkingfast.Lastyearone
exchange'sdisplayedordersdeclinedasaproportionofallordersbyalmost15percent.Atthatratethe
alreadysmallproportionoforderdataMIDASingestsnowwillbecutbyathirdbytheendof2016,andat
anextreme,andwithoutintervention,MIDASmightthenseeaslittleastenpercentorlessofalldetailed
orderdata.
TheexchangefeedsinMIDASsuitmanypurposes.Theycertainlydoagoodjobforthehighfrequency
firmsforwhichthesefeedswerefirstdesigned,especiallysincethetimeandsalesdatatheyincludecan
leakinformationaboutcertainhiddenorders.FormorethanadecadeHFTfirmshaveusedtheexchange
feedsinmanycleverwaystodominateexchangemarkets.Butashorttermalgorithmictradingdecisionis
differentfromapolicydecision,andpolicydecisionsshouldbebasedondatathatequipsregulatorstofully
understandtheirmarkets.MIDAScantanddoesnt,andevenlesssoasthemonthstickbyandmoreof
themarketgoesdark.Ifregulatorswilleverunderstandthemarkettheyneedtoseemorethanoneendof
it,howeverwelllit.WhileeveryonehopestheCATwilldothis,theCATisyearsaway.Inthemeantime,
regulatorsshouldbecompletelyupfrontabouttheirowndataslimitationsanddisclosewhatthose
limitationsmightmean.
Judgments
Datalimitationsaffectpolicyjudgments,andthatswhysomecommentsinarecentspeechbySEC
AssociateDirectorGreggBermanareworthexploring.Thoughhepointedouthespokeforhimselfandnot
fortheCommissionorforotherSECstaff,heisseniorstaffandhisspeechislikelyaninsightintopolicy
decisionsbrewingattheSEC,decisionsbasedonMIDASdata.
Mr.Bermanreportedthatwhile39percentofallordersfoundinMIDASwerecanceledwithinahalfsecond,
27percentofalltradeswereagainstordersthathadbeenrestingforahalfsecondorless.Drillingfurther
intothatdatahefoundthatwhile23percentofallorderswerecanceledwithin50ms,19percentofalltrades
wereagainstordersthathadbeenrestingfor50msorless.
Forordersthatwerepricedatorbetterthantheinside,hefoundthatmorethanhalfofallorderswere
canceledwithinahalfsecondand25percentofalltradeswereagainstordersrestingforahalfsecondor
less.38percentofallorderswerecanceledwithin50ms,and19percentofalltradeswereagainstorders
restingfor50msorless.
Fromallthis,Mr.BermansaidhisanalysesonMIDASdatashowedthatthespeedofsystemsthattake
liquiditybyaccessingdisplayedquotesseemstobekeepingupwiththespeedatwhichthosequotescan
becanceled.Itisaverysignificantjudgmentandshowsplainaffectionforthecurrentstateofthings.
Whilethemarkethasalotofveryfastorders,italsohassometradesagainstthoseorders,whichhe
believessupportsthatjudgment.Butwithoutbetterdataitisnomorethanwishfulthinking.
Thefirstquestionweshouldaskabouttheseresultsiswhatitmeanswhennearly40percentofordersator
betterthantheBBOarecanceledwithin50ms.Atleastoverordinaryelectronicpathways,itsnotnearly
enoughtimeforaquotetomakearoundtripfromNewJersey,wherequotesarecreated,toanywherenear
thewestcoast,whereabout15percentofthecountrylivesandnearly20percentoftheeconomyis
3
produced.Itscertainlyfarlesstimethanhumanbeingsneedtoreacttoitnomatterwheretheyare.
Structurally,then,nearlyhalfofindividualBBOsaresomethingthatonlymachinescanhopetorespondto,
andthenonlyifthosemachinesaresomewhereeastofCalifornia.
Next,giventhelatenciesinroutingdatatotheSIP,andthenfromtheSIPoutward,wecanmakeanother
structuraljudgment,namely,anymachinehopingtorespondtoanyexchangequote,fastandslowalike,
needstohaveexchangeproprietaryfeeds.SIPdatajustisn'tfastenough.Evenamillisecondlostshipping
datatotheSIPorinprocessingdataattheSIPmeansmissingasignificantnumberofquotes,especiallyin
busymarkets.Theexcellentdatavisualizationtoolsontheportalimplythat15percentormoreofallorders
atorbetterthantheinsidearecanceledwithinamillisecond,atleastamonglargestocks.
Thefirstcertainjudgmentsofaristhataccessing[all]displayedquotesrequiresacolocatedsystemand
proprietaryfeeds.Whatdoesthatmean?Atcurrentprices,arackanddatafeedsatanyoneofthemajor
exchangesstartsomewherearound$10,000/month.It'sanextraordinaryamountofmoney,andabouttwice
whatitcosttoleaseaseatattheNYSEinearly2005,justbeforeNYSEannouncedplanstogopublicand
seatpricesjumped.
Becausesomuchquotingissofast,fullandcompetitiveaccesstodisplayedquotestodayatanyoneof
themajorexchangesnowmeansspending$100,000ayearormoretogetinthedoor,nearlytwiceas
muchasaseatonthenationslargestandmostprestigiousexchangecostlessthan10yearsago.Its
djvualloveragain,whereprivilegedinsidersseealltheflowandactonitasoutsidersnevercan.
Andsoitisn'tfarfetchedtocallthesekindsofmechanicsrigged,thoughatleastoneFINRAexecutive
preferscallingthem"firstclass." Theoldinsidersboughtorleasedseats,andthenewinsidersleaseracks
1
andbuydatafeeds.Forallthechangesofthelastdecade,westillsufferatwotieredmarketutterly
dominatedbyasmallclubofinsiders,excepttheentryfeesaremuchhigherthantheyusedtobewhile
regulationsmeanttoconstraintheclubhavebeenpassionatelydismantled.
It'stoobadMr.Bermandoesnttakehisthinkinginthisdirection,thoughthesequestionsmightbebeyond
hisroleorinclination.Insteadhesaysthatifasignificantnumberoftradesareagainstshortlivedordersits
evidencethemarketkeepsupwitheventhefastestquotes.
Butwhoisitkeepingup?Aretheyinstitutionaltradersorproptraders,orevenretail,orordersfromother
markets,oramixofallthese,andinwhatproportions?WecantsaybecauseMIDAScanttellus.What
ifthequickesttradesareinitiatedalmostexclusivelybycolocatedpropfirms?Whatifthequickesttrades
areinitiatedalmostexclusivelybythesamesmallhandfulofpropfirms?Whatifthefastestorderscome
fromthesamesmallhandfuloffirms?Whatifcolocatedpropfirmsarenearlyalwaysfirstinpricequeues,
squeezingoutthepublic?Oftheorderscanceledwithinamillisecond,doanyofthosefirmssoontradeat
thatprice,andwhatistheirordertotraderatio,orisitallquotespam?Whowasontheothersideofthose
trades?Whatifaggressivetradesbypropfirmssomehowneatlypredictsubsequentpriceaction,and
includetheirmostprofitabletrades?Howfrequentlydomarketmakingfirms,armedtotheteethwithan
arsenalofregulatoryprivilegesnooneelsehas,turnaggressive,andwhatistheeffectonpriceswhenthey
do?Whatothertradingstrategiesdomarketmakingfirmsdeploy,anddotheyusetheirprivileges
privilegesintendedonlytohelpthemprovideliquiditytoinvestorswhentheydeploythem?Howfrequently
domarketmakerssellshortaggressively?Howfrequentlydotheyturnandrun,coweringbehindminimum
quotingstandards?Howmuchinventorywillamarketmakerholdbeforeaggressivelyliquidatingit,risking
1
Seehttp://wealthmanagement.com/blog/highfrequencytradingbuyingfirstclasssaysfinraenforcementchief.
4
thekindof"hotpotato"tradingthatslammedpricesintheflashcrash?Whatportionofdisplayedliquidity
comesfromthesamefirmsscatteredacrosstheexchanges?Whenafirmtradesononeexchange,doesit
cancelorrepriceitsquotesonothers?Doesitthentradeaggressivelyonotherexchanges,andinwhat
direction?Doesitevensellshortaggressivelyonotherexchanges?Andisanyofthisbehaviordifferent
dependingontheexchange,orwhenmarketsarevolatile?
Knowingatleastsomeofthisisessentialbeforemakinganynormativejudgments.Andasconsequential
asanswerstothesequestionswillbe,whatifmanyofthosefasttradesarejustcoincidences?
Foranexampleofthat,wecanlooktoMrs.BettyJohansseninRedLake,Minnesotaassheentersan
ordertobuy100sharesofMMM.Ifherarthritisisn'tactingupittakesherlessthanaminutetologintoher
brokerswebsite,setupamarketablelimitorder,andclicksend.Itmighttakeanotherhalfsecondorsofor
herordertomakeitswayfromhercomputerthroughherbrokerssystemsandonitswaytoanexchange
(letspretenditactuallydoesmakeittoanexchange).
NomatterhowlongittookMrs.JohanssentoentertheorderandfortheordertomakeitswaytoNew
Jersey,thatorderisgoingtotradeagainsttheinsidemarket.Sincealmost40percentofallordersatthe
insiderestfornomorethan50ms,Mrs.Johnanssensorderhasasignificantchanceoftradingwitha
shortlivedordercompletelybyaccident.Anotherwaytoputthisisthatofcoursealotofshortlivedorders
tradeifenoughofthemareattheinside,becausetheinsideiswhereorderstrade.Withoutfirststudying
whoisbehindthem,nooneshouldthinkthesekindsofrandomcollisionsarepurposefulandthenturna
coincidenceintoapolicyjudgment.You'llhitsomethingifyouthrowpebblesintoafan,butthatdoesn't
meanyouaimedatwhatyouhit.
Theimportantquestionisntwhetherfleetingordersattheinsideorevendeepinthebookaretradeable.In
anyautomatedsystemtheyaretradeable,bothonpurposeandbyaccident.Theimportantquestionsare
whatportionofexchangeliquiditytheyprovide,whatcoststheyimposeonotherinvestors,whoorwhatcan
tradewiththemonpurpose,andwhatthatkindofaccesscosts.OncetheSECanswersthosequestions
wecanframenewquestionsandperhapsbegintomakenormativejudgments.Nomatterhowmuchwe
mightwantitto,fornowMIDAScanthelp.
Inlightofallthis,it'sprematuretocallMIDASa"surveillancesystem,"atleastasthattermisusedin
industry.Unlessthere'smoretoMIDASthanwe'vebeentold,it'salsoprematuretosayMIDAShelpsthe
SECkeeppacewithorstayaheadofitscritics,orhelpstheagencyfullyunderstandmarketstructure
issues.Thedatatoachievethosegoalsresidesinsideexchangeaudittrails,oratFINRA,ormightbe
collectedsomedaybytheCAT,butit'snotyetinMIDAS.
It'sacommonfailingtobelieveanexcitingnewtoolwillfitwhatevercomesalong.MIDASisagreatstep
forwardbutthere'smuchfurthertogo.FornowtheSECshouldthinkverybroadlyaboutwhatquestionsit
needstoanswerandnotstraintoanswerthemhastilywithatoolthatisn'tsuitedforit.Doingusnogood
atall,thatwillonlynurturemorecynicismabouttheindustryatatimeweneedtonurturegoodwill.
Sincerely,
R.T.Leuchtkafer